NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-SEFSC-645
PROCEEDINGS OF THE THIRTY-THIRD
ANNUAL SYMPOSIUM ON SEA TURTLE
BIOLOGY AND CONSERVATION
5 to 8 February, 2013
Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Compiled by:
Tony Tucker, Lisa Belskis, Aliki Panagopoulou, ALan Rees, Mike Frick,
Kris Williams, Robin LeRoux, and Kelly Stewart
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
National Marine Fisheries Service
Southeast Fisheries Science Center
75 Virginia Beach Drive
Miami, Florida 33149
May 2013
NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-SEFSC-645
PROCEEDINGS OF THE THIRTY-THIRD
ANNUAL SYMPOSIUM ON SEA TURTLE
BIOLOGY AND CONSERVATION
5 to 8 February, 2013
Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Compiled by:
Tony Tucker, Lisa Belskis, Aliki Panagopoulou, ALan Rees, Mike Frick,
Kris Williams, Robin LeRoux, and Kelly Stewart
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Dr. Rebecca Blank, Acting Secretary
NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION
Dr. Kathryn D. Sullivan, Acting Under Secretary for Oceans and
Atmosphere
NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE
Samuel D. Rauch III, Acting Assistant Administrator for Fisheries
May 2013
This Technical Memorandum is used for documentation and timely
communication of preliminary results, interim reports, or similar special-purpose
information. Although the memoranda are not subject to complete formal review,
editorial control or detailed editing, they are expected to reflect sound professional
work.
February 2013, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
NOTICE
The NOAA Fisheries Service (NMFS) does not approve, recommend or endorse any
proprietary product or material mentioned in this publication. No references shall be
made to NMFS, or to this publication furnished by NMFS, in any advertising or sales
promotion which would indicate or imply that NMFS approves, recommends or
endorses any proprietary product or material herein or which has as its purpose any
intent to cause directly or indirectly the advertised product to be use or purchased
because of NMFS promotion.
For bibliographic purposes, this document should be cited as follows:
Tucker, T., Belskis, L., Panagopoulou, A., Rees, A., Frick, M., Williams, K., LeRoux,
R., and Stewart, K. compilers. 2013. Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual
Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation. NOAA Technical
Memorandum NOAA NMFS-SEFSC-645: 263 p.
Technical Editor:
Lisa Belskis
Copies of this report can be obtained from:
NOAA Fisheries Service
Southeast Fisheries Science Center
75 Virginia Beach Drive
Miami, FL 33149
PDF version available at http://www.sefsc.noaa.gov/species/turtles/techmemos.htm
or
National Technical Information Service
5301 Shawnee Rd
Alexandria, VA 22312
(703) 605-6050, (888)584-8332
http://www.ntis.gov/numbers/htm
ii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
PRESIDENT’S REPORT (abridged*)
33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
“Connections”
2-8 February 2013, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Raymond R. Carthy, President, ISTS
The 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation was held on February 2-8, 2013
in Baltimore, Maryland, USA. Baltimore is within the National Capital Region which is a hub for
important scientific research, policy and decision-making by the nation's government and many leading
conservation organizations. The pioneering 1st World Conference on Sea Turtle Conservation was held
in Washington, D.C., 26-30 November 1979, and having this year’s meeting in the National Capital
Region just over 33 years later provided an inspirational link through time and location.
“Connections“ was the theme for the Baltimore Symposium, and our focus for the meeting was to
explore the biological and ecological linkages that sea turtles share with their environments, while also
examining and celebrating the connections that they impose on us as we try to learn about and conserve
them. The theme was evident in the attendance, the program, the special sessions and activities, and the
partnerships that made the meeting a success. There were 1016 registrants, representing 67 countries,
and an additional 130 local students and educators attended particular sessions. The program included
7 regional meetings, 5 workshops, 4 special sessions, and a Video Night. There were 144 oral
presentations and 248 posters- an additional 53 talks were given during a three-day Terrapin, Tortoise
and Freshwater Turtle Meeting preceding the main Symposium. Forty-three Vendors and Exhibitors,
including many that were new to the event, contributed to an engaging venue. The National Aquarium
in Baltimore was a key partner in hosting the Symposium, providing volunteer personnel and access to
their facilities, and the Virginia Aquarium and Marine Science Center were strong partners in our
education efforts.
The Symposium was held at the Baltimore Marriott Waterfront in Baltimore’s Inner Harbor. The venue
provided ample meeting and lodging space for the participants. The convenient facilities and the very
accommodating staff were conducive to both intellectual and social interactions.
Educational Outreach: Positive local impact has become a strong tradition in hosting ISTS Symposia.
In Baltimore we enjoyed proximity to Washington, D.C. and increased participation by government
agencies and NGOs, but the primary outreach effort was a multi-faceted educational program. In
cooperation with the Virginia Aquarium and Marine Science Center and the National Aquarium, a
Teachers and Educators Workshop was held on February 2nd. Twenty-five local teachers and five
Symposium participants learned techniques and received materials that will aid them in incorporating
marine science, sea turtles, and the Chesapeake Bay into their curricula. Local schools (St. Demetrius
Bilingual Day School, Poolesville H.S., South River High School, Furman Templeton Prep, Dr. Rayner
Browne Academy, and Friends Meeting School) participated in a “Threats to Sea Turtles” Art Contest
sponsored by ISTS, and the winning artwork was displayed at the Symposium. The opening session on
Tuesday was followed by an early highlight- the “Sea Turtles Revealed” plenary was attended by 80
students and teachers from Baltimore middle and high schools ( St. Demetrius Bilingual Day School,
Dr. Rayner Browne Academy, Western High School, and Augusta Fells Savage Institute of Visual
iii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Arts). The students engaged a panel of renowned sea turtle biologists and conservationists with a
question and answer session where the panel was surprised to find themselves not only answering the
usual “how big “ and “how old” queries, but pondering some of the same difficult ecological questions
that drive their own work. The students and teachers that attended the Symposium's morning session
had lunch with various biologists, graduate students and others in the sea turtle community as an
opportunity for more personal "connections" between participants and students. Their lunch was
followed by a trip to the National Aquarium. The “Sea Turtles Revealed” session and the “Sea Turtle
Success Story” sessions on Tuesday afternoon were made available as a live webcast to 250 web
sharepoints that were provided to schools, colleges, and universities.
ISTS Awards 2013: The 2013 ISTS Awards Committee was chaired by Sally Murphy and the
members were Kimberley Maison, Stephen Dunbar, Jim Spotila, Dean Bagley, Ana Barragan, Ray
Carthy, and Roldan Valverde. The Committee did an excellent job and presented this year’s meeting
with an incredible group of awardees. The ISTS Lifetime Achievement Award was presented to Jack
Woody for a career dedicated to sea turtle conservation, including establishment of the sea turtle
program in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, focusing attention on critical sea turtle conservation
issues in Mexico and Central America, garnering international protection for Kemp’s and olive ridley
turtles, and advocacy for TEDs. Hoyt Peckham received the ISTS Champions Award for his tireless
work in tackling difficult and pressing conservation issues for North Pacific loggerhead sea turtles, and
communicating effectively with stakeholders at all levels. There were two recipients of the Ed Drane
Award for Volunteerism. Betsy Brabson was recognized as an outstanding volunteer Project Leader for
the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources and for her role as a catalyst in protecting nesting
beaches against invasive flora and fauna. Daniela Freggi was honored for her pioneering volunteer
work in sea turtle veterinary care in Italy and as a dedicated promoter of national and international
cooperation and skill exchange in the Mediterranean. The ISTS President’s Award was presented to
Marydele Donnelly for over twenty-five years of profound involvement in global sea turtle
conservation efforts, including successful support of the TED requirement for U.S. shrimpers, the
InterAmerican Convention for the Protection and Conservation of Sea Turtles, and the U.S. Marine
Turtle Conservation Act.
Archie Carr Student Awards: There were 50 oral presentations and 89 poster presentations submitted
by students for consideration in the Archie Carr Awards. The winner for Best Biology Poster was
Vanessa Bezy and Runners Up were Deasy Lontoh, Tomoko Hamabata, and Jake Lasala.Best
Conservation Poster went to Nicole Reintsma. The Best Biology Oral was won by J. Roger Brothers.
Nicole Mazouchova won the Best Biology Field-based Oral and Justin Perrault was Runner Up. The
Conservation Oral winner was Elizabeth Bevan, and Francesc Domenech and Monette Schwoerer
received Runners Up honors in Conservation Field-based Oral and Conservation Experimental Oral
respectively.
(* The full text of the 2013 President’s Report can be found in the Marine Turtle Newsletter.)
iv
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
COMMITTEES, CHAIRS, AND KEY ORGANIZERS
Symposium Coordinator
Internet Communications Coordinator
Baltimore Symposium Registrar
Public Relations
Fundraising
Nominations Committee
Donna Broadbent
Michael Coyne
Rick Herren
Wallace J. Nichols
Elena Finkbeiner, Ingrid Yañez
Andres Estrades, Frank Paladino, Mario
Mota, Mariana Fuentes, Marydele Donnelly
Kelly Stewart, Michael Jensen, Kristen Hart
Dubose Griffin, Katy Garland
Sarah Milton, Brian Stacy, Heather Harris,
Mike James, Kim Reich, Larry Wood,
Catherine McClellan, Cynthis Lagueux,
Stephen Dunbar, SaraMaxwell, Angela
Formia, Rhema Bjorkland, Sheila Miller,
Becca Lewison, Andy Coleman, Kartick
Shanker, Meg Lamont, Erik Martin, Jason
Van deMerwe, J Nichols, Joanna Alfaro,
Mariana Fuentes, George Shillinger, Donna
Shaver, Suzanne Livingstone, David
Waayers, Andrea Phillott, Brian Shamblin,
Nancy FitzSimons, Bill Kendall, Mike Frick,
Hoyt Peckham, Lekelia Jenkins, Blair
Witherington
Alexander Gaos
Angela Formia (Africa), Karen Eckert
(Caribbean, English), Emma Harriosn
(Mexico, Central America and Spanish
Speaking Caribbean), Aliki Panagopoulou
(Europe), Alan Rees (Middle East),
Alejandro Fallabrino (South America),
Kartik Shanker (South Asia), Nicolas Pilcher
(Southeast Asia/Pacific), Kelly Stewardt
(USA and Canada)
Jane Provancha, Barbara Schroeder
Matthew Godfrey, Andrea Phillott
Marc Girondot, Jen Keller, Manjula Tiwari,
Craig Harms, Yakup Kaska, Erin Seney,
Mike James, Dave Owens, Jesus Tomas,
Amanda Williard, Catherine McClellan,
Emma Harrison, Cynthia Lageux, Cathi
Campbell, Ana Barragan, Kate Mansfield,
Paolo Casale, Sheryan Epperly, Mark Dodd.
Sally Murphy, Stephen Dunbar, Kim
Maison, Dean Bagley, Jim Spotila
Cathi Campbell
Janet Hochella
Jennifer Homcy, Marina Zucchini
Emma Harrison
Hannah Vander Zanden, Joe Pfaller
Itzel Sifuentes, Annelisse Ibarra
Tony Tucker, Lisa Belskis, Aliki
Panagopoulou, Alan Rees, Mike Frick, Kris
Williams, Robin LeRoux, Kelly Stewart
Kelly Stewart, Michael Jensen
Program Chairs
Program Committee Coordinators
Program Committee
Travel Grant Committee Chair
Travel Regional Chairs
Poster Session Chairs
Student Judge Committee
Student Judges
ISTS Awards Committee
Video Chair
Exhibitor/Vendor Chair
Auction Co-Chairs
Activity Coordinator
Volunteer Co-chairs
Student Committee
Proceedings Coordinators
Printed Program
v
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Africa Regional Meeting
Manjula Tiwari, Jacques Fretey, Angela
Formia
Indian Ocean & Southeast Asia Regional Meeting
RETOMALA (Latin American Meeting)
Lalith Ekanayake, Nadia Swidan
Juan Manuel Rodriguez, Nineve Espinosa,
Rocio Alvarez
Karen Eckert
Paolo Casale
Irene Kinan Kelly
Chuck Schaffer
Tomo Eguchi
Elizabeth Whitman, Junichi Okuyama
Daniela Freggi, Leigh Clayton
Amy Hapeman
Elena Mustakova-Possardt
Brian Hutchinson
WIDECAST (Caribbean) Regional Meeting
Mediterranean Regional Meeting
Pacific Island Meeting
Terrapin, Tortoise & Freshwater Turtle Meeting
Statistics & Data Analysis Workshop
Dive Behavior Workshop
Sea Turtle Medicine Workshop
NMFS Permit Workshop
Cultivating Resilience: Processes and Skills Workshop
IUCN Marine Turtle Specialist Group
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
President
President-Elect
Past President
Treasurer
Secretary
Ray Carthy
Roldan Valverde
Ana Barragán
Terry Meyer
Manjula Tiwari
BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND THEIR END OF TERM
Didiher Chacon
Scott Eckert
Jack Frazier
Mark Hamann
Cynthia Lagueux
Roldan Valverde
Paolo Casale
Aliki Panagopoulou
George Balasz
Alejandro Fallabrino
2013
2013
2014
2014
2015
2015
2016
2016
2017
2017
Kartik Shanker (past president 2010)
Jeff Seminoff (past president 2011)
Ana Baragan (past president 2012)
2013
2014
2015
vi
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
SPONSORS AND CONTRIBUTORS
The International Sea Turtle Society gratefully acknowledges the generous financial support from the
following organizations and individuals:
Platinum Sponsors
NOAA –National Marine Fisheries Service
Marine Turtle Conservation Act-U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Gold Sponsors
Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management Council
Silver Sponsors
Anonymous
Disney’s Animals, Science & Environment
Ecoteach
International Seafood Sustainability Foundation
Maryland Dept. Natural Resources
Patagonia
Sea Turtle Conservancy/Florida License Plate
Sirtrack
The Ocean Foundation
The Shared Earth Foundation
Vaughan W. Brown Charitable Trust
Virginia Aquarium
Wildlife Computers
World Wildlife Fund
Bronze Sponsors
CLS America
Defenders of Wildlife
Ecological Associates, Inc
Marydele Donnelly
Society for Conservation Biology
Telonics
Inconel Sponsors
Desert Star Systems
East Coast Biologists, Inc
Janet Hochella
Karen Frutchey
Kiki Jenkins
Nancy FitzSimmons
Seaturtle.org
Tampa Bay Green Consortium
Turtle Time, Inc.
Vendors
Anna Maria Island Turtle Watch
Ayotzintili AC
Bangladesh Enviroment and Development Society
Bioko Biodiversity Protection Program
Canadian Sea Turtle Network
Center for Biological Diversity
CLS America, Inc
CRC Press/ Taylor& Francis LLC
CTL
Desert Star Systems LLC
Eco Maniac Company
Inwater Research Group
Johns Hopkins University Press
Karumbe
Loggerhead Instruments
Nature Conservation Egypt
Pentair Aquatic Eco-Systems
Sea Turtle Conservancy
vii
Sea Turtle Foundation
Sea Turtle Restoration Project
Sea Turtles 911
Sirtrack
Society for Conservation Biology
SWOT
Tampa Bay Green Consortium
Tecolutla Turtle Preservation Society
Telonics
Texas Sea Grant
The Ocean Foundation
Turtlely Inspired
Turtles in Clay
Wildlife Computers
Wildlife Rescue & Conservation Association
World Society for the Protection of animals
WWF
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
STUDENT AWARDS
There were 139 student presentations in the Archie Carr Prize Competition - 50 oral presentations and 89 posters.
Award amounts: Winners = US $300 each, Runners-up = US $150 each. Grand total for all student awards = US
$2400.
ORAL PRESENTATIONS
Winner- Biology Experimental: J. Roger Brothers, UNC-Chapel Hill, USA.
A mathematical model consistent with geomagnetic imprinting hypothesis of natal homing.
Winner- Biology Field-Based: Nicole Mazouchova, Temple University, USA.
Effects of granular incline angle on the locomotion of loggerhead sea turtle hatchlings in the field.
Runner Up- Biology Field-Based: Justin Perrault, Florida Atlantic University, USA.
Bioaccumulation and biomagnification of mercury and selenium in leatherback sea turtles: a cause for concern in
this species.
Winner- Conservation: Elizabeth Bevan, University of Alabama-Birmingham, USA.
Implications of hatchling sex ratios and survival in the recovery program for the endangered Kemp’s ridley sea
turtle.
Runner Up- Conservation Field-based: Francesc Domenech, University of Valencia, Spain.
Incidental catch of the loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta) by bottom trawling in the Valencian community.
Runner Up- Conservation Experimental: Monette Schwoerer, University of Central Florida, USA.
Shading in situ marine turtle nests: a potential practice to mitigate nest temperatures in response to climate change.
POSTER PRESENTATIONS
Winner- Biology: Vanessa Bezy, College of Charleston, USA.
Preliminary results: olive ridley sea turtle embryo mortality as a function of the nest microbial community at
Ostional, Costa Rica.
Runner Up- Biology: Deasy Lontoh, Mos Landing Marine Laboratories, USA.
Variation in remigration interval is linked to the foraging destination of Western Pacific leatherback turtles.
Runner Up- Biology: Tomoko Hamabata, Kyoto University, Japan.
Genetic structure of green turtles nesting in Northwestern Pacific Ocean.
Runner Up- Biology: Jake Lasala, Georgia Southern Univeristy, USA.
New microsatellite DNA analyses may confound current population models for loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta
caretta).
Winner- Conservation: Nicole Reintsma, Florida Atlantic University, USA.
Assessing a potential lighting problem for loggerhead hatchlings near the brightest lighthouse in the world: Arena
assays at Hillsboro Beach, Florida, USA
viii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
ISTS AWARDS 2013
Chair- Sally Murphy
Members: Kimberly Maison, Stephen Dunbar, Jim Spotila, Dean Bagley, Ana Barragan, Ray Carthy, and Roldan
Valverde.
President’s Award
Marydele Donnelly
Ed Drane Award for Volunteerism
Betsy Brabson
Daniela Freggi
Life Time Achievement Award
Jack Woody
Champions Award
Hoyt Peckham
PLENARY AND SPECIAL SESSIONS
SEA TURTLES REVEALED: MARVELS, MYSTERIES, AND NEWS YOU CAN USE
Chair- Blair Witherington-Florida Fish and Wildlife Research Institute
Panel Members: Bryan Wallace-Oceanic Society, Jeanette Wyneken- Florida Atlantic University, David
Godfrey- Sea Turtle Conservancy, Kiki Jenkins-University of Washington, Pam Plotkin- Texas Sea Grant, Thane
Wibbels- University of Alabama-Birmingham, Baltimore middle and high schools.
SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION SUCCESS STORIES
Chairs- Hoyt Peckham- Center for Ocean Solutions and SmartFish, Lekelia Jenkins-University of Washington
Moderator- Juliet Eilperin- Washington Post
Invited Speakers:
THE SUCCESS OF THE US MARINE TURTLE CONSERVTION ACT AND ITS UNCERTAIN FUTURE
Marydele Donnelly, Sea Turtle Conservancy
CONSERVING SEA TURTLES BY LAND AND BY SEA IN PERU
Joanna Alfaro, ProDelphinus and University of Exeter
BUILDING SUSTAINABLE TED PROGRAMS WORLDWIDE
Marlene Menard, US Department of State/Office of Marine Conservation
THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND THE UGLY: CONSERVING SEA TURTLES IN NICARAGUA
Jose Urteaga, Fauna and Flora International
THE DECLINE AND RISE OF A SEA TURTLE: HOW KEMP’S RIDLEYS ARE RECOVERING IN THE
GULF OF MEXICO
Larry Crowder, Center for Ocean Solutions
BRAZIL’S SEA TURTLES ARE NOW WORTH MORE ALIVE: TAMAR’S SOCIAL PRODUCTION CHAIN
Neca Marcovaldi, Projecto TAMAR
ix
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
UNDERSTANDING RESILIENCE: CORE CONNECTIONS THAT SUSTAIN
Speaker- Elena Mustakova-Possardt Spoke as special session and workshop
SATELLITE TELEMETRY (PRESENTATIONS ARCHIVED ON SEATURTLE.ORG)
Chairs: Brian Stacy and Kristen Hart
ECOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS OF BIOTELEMETRY DRAG IN MARINE TURTLES
T. Todd Jones, NMFS
OVERVIEW OF TAG TECHNOLOGIES: A MANUFACTURER’S PERSPECTIVE
Thomas Gray, Desert Star
TAG SELECTON AND TECHNIQUES FOR SATELLITE TRACKING SMALL HARD-SHELLED SEA
TURTLES
Kate Mansfield, Florida Atlantic University and Erin Seney, Erin Seney Consulting
TAG SELECTION AND TECHNIQUES FOR SATELLITE TRACKING LARGE HARD-SHELL SEA TURTLES
Kristen Hart, USGS
USE OF SATELLITE TELEMETRY TO DETERMINE SEA TURTLE MORTALITY
Yonat Swimmer, NMFS
AN UPDATE ON LEATHERBACK TURTLE SATELLITE TRACKING TECHNIQUES
Sabrina Fossette, NMFS
x
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
VIDEO PRESENTATIONS
Les Amis de la Nature (Friends of Nature), Epidosde 2: Mayumba
Aimee Sanders, Gabon Sea Turtle Partnership & Wildlife Conservation Society
3M Project
Anfani Msoili, Association for the Social-Economic Development of Itsamia
Europa: 40 Years of Scientific Adventure
Jerôme Bourjea, Alefa Production and Kélonia
Ulithi Marine Turtle Project
Jennifer Cruce & JR Rulmal, Ulithi Marine Turtle Program & Oceanic Society
Tracking the Nicaraguan Eastern Pacific Hawksbills
Jose Urteaga, Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative & Flora & Fauna International
Moochula- Giving Hawksbill Sea Turtles Hope
Barry Erdeljon & Sarah Gulick, Marymount University
A Non-Invasive Approach to Documenting Human Interactions with Nesting Sea Turtles
Ray Mojica & David Godfrey, Barrier Island Ecosystem Center & Sea Turtle Conservancy
Verde Salaje
Veronica de los Llanos & Belen Orsin, CNAC, Morocota Films & Xenon Films
Our Dreams Don’t Age
Neca Marcovaldi, Projecto TAMAR
Karumbé, Tortugas Marinas del Uruguay
Daniel Gonzalez-Paredes, Karumbé
Los Amigos De Las Tortugas (Turtle’s Friends)
Augustin Balestini, Programa Regional de Investigatción y Conservación de Tortugas Marinas de Argentina &
Reserva Natural Bahia Blanca,Bahía Falsa, Bahía Verde
xi
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page #
iii
PRESIDENT’S REPORT
v
COMMITTEES, CHAIRS, AND KEY ORGANIZERS
vi
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AND BOARD OF DIRECTORS
vii
SPONSORS AND CONTRIBUTORS
viii
STUDENT AWARDS
ix
ISTS AWARDS 2013
ix
PLENARY AND SPECIAL SESSIONS
xi
VIDEO PRESENTATIONS
Abstract titles marked with an * at the end of the title denote an Oral Presentation.
Anatomy, Physiology, Health
1.
STEROIDOGENIC EXPRESSION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS DURING THE GONADAL
DIFFERENTIATION IN THE GREEN SEA TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS AL-HADD, OMAN
Issa S. Al-Amri, I.Y. Mahmoud, B. Al-Farsi, S.N. Al-Bahry, B. Al-Sumri, M.A. Al-Kindi, and S.K. AlMusharafi
1.
HEAVY METALS DETECTION BY X-RAY MICROANALYSIS IN FRESHLY LAID EGGS OF THE
GREEN TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, AT RAS AL-HADD, OMAN
Salma K. Al-Musharafi, Saif N. Al-Bahry, Ibrahim Y. Mahmoud, Issa S. Al Amri, and Abdulaziz A.
Al-Kindi
2.
THE IDENTIFICATION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS IN THE EMBRYONIC MALE USING
HISTOLOGICAL AND IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL TECHNIQUES IN THE GREEN TURTLE,
CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS AL-HADD, OMAN
Abdulaziz Y. Alkindi, I.S. Al-Amri, I.Y. Mahmoud, S.N. Al-Bahry, S. Al-Yaqoobi, and B. Al-Sumri
2.
PRELIMINARY RESULTS: OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE EMBRYO MORTALITY AS A FUNCTION
OF THE NEST MICROBIAL COMMUNITY AT OSTIONAL, COSTA RICA
Vanessa S. Bézy, Roldán A. Valverde, and Craig J. Plante
3.
THE MICRONUCLEUS TEST: A RELIABLE TOOL FOR HEALTH SCREENING OF GREEN
TURTLES
Virginia Borrat, Silvia Villar, Gustavo Martinez Souza, and Alejandro Fallabrino
4.
THE EFFECTS OF TRACKING DEVICES ON ATLANTIC GREEN (CHELONIA MYDAS) SEA
TURTLE DIVE BEHAVIOR IN RELATION TO CARAPACE SENSITIVITY*
Ashley Chambers, Suzie Marlow, Nina Nahvi, Jeffrey George, and Christopher Devlin
xii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
5.
CLINICAL CONDITION IN OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) IN
GUASAVE, SINALOA, MEXICO
Paula Aguilar Claussell, Alan Zavala Norzagaray, Catherine E. Hart, César Paul Ley Quiñonez, and
Alonso Aguirre
5.
NOVEL MICROBIAL POPULATIONS RECOVERED FROM FAILED LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
NESTS (CARETTA CARETTA) ON JEKYLL ISLAND, GA
K. S. Craven, M. Walker, M. Lamb, S.L. Schwartz, C. Weed, and J. Brofft Bailey
6.
BENEFITS OF A COMPLETE X-RAY EVALUATION TO ASCERTAIN THE POSITION AND
ORIENTATION OF FISHING HOOKS IN INTRACOELOMATIC ESOPHAGUS TISSUES OF
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA)
Antonio Di Bello, Carmela Valastro, Daniela Freggi, Olimpia R. Lai, Giuseppe Crescenzo, and Delia
Franchini
7.
EPIBIONTS OF NESTING FEMALE OLIVE RIDLEYS, LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA, IN PLAYON DE
MISMALOYA, JALISCO, MÉXICO
Ildefonso Enciso, Julia Cisneros, Fredy C. Gastelum, and Francisco J. Jacobo
7.
PERCEPTION OF DIMETHYL SULFIDE (DMS) BY LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES: A POSSIBLE
CUE FOR LOCATING FORAGING AREAS
Courtney S. Endres and Kenneth J. Lohmann
8.
THE GENTLE TREATMENT OF SEA TURTLE LESIONS BY HYPERMIX, A NEW BOTANICAL
PRODUCT FROM ITALY
Daniela Freggi and Antonio di Bello
8.
FIBROPAPILLOMAS IN GREEN TURTLES ALONG THE COAST OF THE CONGO-BRAZZAVILLE.
SEVEN YEARS OF OBSERVATIONS GIVE AN INSIGHT INTO A RISING ISSUE IN CENTRAL
AFRICA
Alexandre Girard, Hélène NDembé, and Nathalie Bréheret
9.
SERUM BIOCHEMISTRY PROFILE FOR NESTING HAWKSBILLS (ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA)
IN RIO GRANDE DO NORTE, BRAZIL*
Daphne Wrobel Goldberg, Santiago Alonso Tobar Leitão, Armando José Barsante Santos, Gustave
Gilles Lopez, Jayme da Cunha Bastos, and Vera Lúcia Freire da Cunha Bastos
10.
PRELIMINARY STUDY OF ORGANIC AND INORGANIC POLLUTANTS IN MARINE TURTLES
FROM MAURITANIA (WEST AFRICA)
Feitoumatt Lematt Hama, Christelle Dyc, and Jacques Fretey
10.
SEDATION AND ANESTHESIA OF HATCHLING LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES
Craig A. Harms, Wendy Dow Piniak, Scott A. Eckert, and Elizabeth M. Stringer
11.
VALIDATION OF ULTRASONOGRAPHY AS A NONINVASIVE DIAGNOSTIC TOOL TO MEASURE
SUBCUTANEOUS FAT DEPTH IN LEATHERBACK TURTLES
Heather Harris, Scott Benson, Michael James, Kelly Martin, Brian Stacy, Charles Innis, Julie Cavin,
Pierre-Yves Daoust, Paul Rist, Thierry Work, George Balazs, and Jeffrey Seminoff
xiii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
12.
SURGERY, REHABILITATION AND RELEASE OF A JUVENILE HAWKSBILL RESCUED FROM A
LONGLINE IN THE BAHIA DE JALTEMBA, NAYARIT, MEXICO
Catherine E. Hart, Alan A. Zavala-Norzagaray, Cesar P. Ley-Quñonez, Paula Aguilar-Claussell, and
Alonso A. Aguirre
13.
A PRELIMINARY SCREENING OF PERSISTENT ORGANIC POLLUTANT CONCENTRATIONS IN
HAWAIIAN GREEN TURTLE PLASMA IN RELATION TO FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS
Jennifer M. Keller, George H. Balazs, Brenda A. Jensen, Frances Nilsen, Marc R. Rice, and Thierry
M. Work
14.
IS POLYCYTHEMIA AN ADAPTATION TO HIGH CO2 INCUBATION CONCENTRATIONS BY
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE EMBRYOS?
Robyn E. Lee and Mario J. Mota
15.
EMBRYONIC GONADAL DIFFERENTIATION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS IN THE GREEN
TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS AL-HADD, OMAN.
Ibrahim Y. Mahmoud, M. Alawi, M.W. Yaish, and S.N. Al-Bahry
15.
SCALING OF BITE PERFORMANCE WITH HEAD AND CARAPACE MORPHOMETRICS IN GREEN
SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS)
Christopher D. Marshall, John Wang, Axa Rocha, Carlos Godinez, Shara Fisler, Tomoko Narazaki,
and Katsufumi Sato
16.
USE OF HYPERBARIC OXYGEN THERAPY TO TREAT OSTEOMYELITIS IN A LOGGERHEAD
SEA TURTLE
Nancy S. Mettee
17.
ANATOMICAL STUDY OF HEART MORPHOGENESIS OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) ON THE COAST OF OAXACA*
Eleazar A. Mijangos, Hortensia M. Rosales, Estela R. Hernandez, and Isbel S. Del Angel
18.
SEA TURTLE DERMAL SCUTE VARIATIONS FROM RESCUED INDIVIDUALS IN THE GULF OF
VENEZUELA
Beatriz Morán, Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido
18.
PRELIMINARY EVALUATION OF MINIMALLY INVASIVE SEXING TECHNIQUES FOR INWATER STUDIES OF LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES
April Nason, Thane Wibbels, Heather Harris, and Michael James
19.
FLOW CYTOMETRY OF MYCOBIOTA ISOLATED FROM NESTS, EGGS, AND STILLBIRTHS OF
THE SEA TURTLE ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA (LINNAEUS, 1766)
Milena S. C. Neves, Mariana O. Castro, Carina C. M. Moura, João Loreiro, Luciana G. Oliveira, and
Anabela Marisa Azul
20.
FLIPPER BEATING MODULATION OF GREEN TURTLES IN WATER AND ON LAND:
IMPLICATIONS FOR AQUATIC ADAPTATION AND LOCOMOTOR TRADE-OFF
Hideaki Nishizawa, Junichi Okuyama, Tohya Yasuda, Nobuaki Arai, and Masato Kobayashi
xiv
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
20.
PAIN MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES IN SEA TURTLES AND PHARMACOKINETICS OF
TRAMADOL AND O-DESMETHYLTRAMADOL IN LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA
CARETTA)
Terry M. Norton, Kurt K. Sladky, Sherry Cox, Steven Nelson, Michelle Kaylor, Amy Hupp, and
Rachel Thomas
21.
SEA TURTLE HEALTH, VETERINARY CARE, AND REHABILITATION WORKSHOP IN COSTA
RICA
Terry M. Norton, Nancy Mettee, Brian Stacy, Noha Abou-Madi, Alexia Maizel, and Oscar Brene
Arias
22.
FACTORS AFFECTING SURVIVORSHIP IN REHABILITATING SEA TURTLES WITH
FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS
Annie Page-Karjian, Terry Norton, Maya Groner, and Nicole L. Gottdenker
22.
BIOACCUMULATION AND BIOMAGNIFICATION OF MERCURY AND SELENIUM IN
LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA): A CAUSE FOR CONCERN IN THIS
SPECIES?*
Justin R. Perrault
23.
GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) RECEIVED AT CENTRO DE RECUPERAҪÃO DE
ANIMAIS MARINHOS (CRAM/FURG) IN 2011
Roberta Petitet, Pedro Bruno, Laís Guterres, Andrea Adornes, Lauro Barcellos, and Rodolfo Pinho da
Silva Filho
24.
AGE AND GROWTH OF GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN SOUTHERN BRAZIL
Roberta Petitet, Paul G. Kinas, Eduardo R. Secchi, and Larisa Avens
25.
BACTERIAL FLORA IDENTIFIED FROM LEATHERBACK TURTLE (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA)
EGG SHELLS AND NEST SAND AT GRANDE RIVIERE BEACH, TRINIDAD.
Ayanna Carla N. Phillips, Neville Stewart, Johanna Coutou, Stacy Rajh, Antonio Watson, Adam Jehu,
Hamish Asmath, Francis Dziva, Ridley Holder, and Raymond Carthy
26.
IMMUNOSUPPRESSION EVALUATION OF CHELONIA MYDAS (TESTUDINES, CHELONIIDAE)
CAUGHT IN BRAZIL
Silmara Rossi, Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento, Nicolle G. T. de Queiroz Hazarbassanov, Elmer A.
Genoy-Puerto, Denise Kinoshita, and Eliana R. Matushima
27.
A PROPOSAL TO OBJECTIVELY CLASSIFY FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS SEVERITY IN SEA
TURTLES CONSIDERING NUMBER AND SIZE OF TUMORS
Silmara Rossi, Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento, Ralph E. T. Vanstreels, Robson G. dos Santos, and
Eliana R. Matushima
28.
IMMUNOTOXIC EFFECTS OF SELECTED PCBS UPON IN VITRO EXPOSURE IN JUVENILE
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES, CARETTA CARETTA
Estelle Rousselet, Milton Levin, Erika Gebhard-Cote, Benjamin M. Higgins, Sylvain De Guise, and
Celine A.J. Godard-Codding
xv
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
29.
BODY CONDITION INDEX OF CHELONIA MYDAS (TESTUDINES, CHELONIIDAE) WITH AND
WITHOUT FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS ALONG THE COAST OF BRAZIL
Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento, Silmara Rossi, Ralph E. T. Vanstreels, Robson G. dos Santos, Juliana
Marigo, Carolina P. Bertozzi, and Eliana R. Matushima
30.
PROLAPSE AND EXPULSION OF OVIDUCT IN OLIVE RIDLEY LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA,
DIFFERENT BEACH IN SINALOA, MEXICO.
Fernando Enciso Saracho, José Barrón, Marco A. Barraza Ortega, Ingmar Sosa Cornejo, Iván de
Jesús Guardado-González, and Luz María Rincón
30.
EVIDENCE FOR NUTRITIONAL PROMOTION OF SEA TURTLE TUMORS
Nicole Sarto and Kyle Van Houtan
30.
PLASMA CONCENTRATION OF VITELLOGENIN IN THE LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE (CARETTA
CARETTA): FROM THE NESTING BEACH TO IN WATER STUDIES
Kimberly Smelker, Lauren Smith, and Roldán Valverde
31.
DETERMINATION OF HEMATOLOGICAL AND BIOCHEMICAL VALUES IN A WILD
POPULATION OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN NORTHERN PERU
Tania Suarez-Yana, Jeffrey C. Mangel, David Montes I., Renato Zuñiga, and Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto
32.
COMPARISON OF BEHAVIORAL RESPONSE TO COLD WATER BETWEEN GREEN AND
LOGGERHEAD TURTLE JUVENILES
Runa Tabata, Ayana Wada, Junichi Okuyama, Yuka Obe, Kana Nakajima, Nobuaki Arai, and
Masato Kobayashi
32.
ESTABLISHING A GLOBAL DNA BARCODE AND MOLECULAR PHYLOGENY FOR MARINE
LEECHES (OZOBRANCHUS SPP.) FROM SEA TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC AND PACIFIC OCEAN
BASINS*
Triet M. Truong, Philip Lavretsky, Jeffrey L. Peters, and Audrey E. McGowin
33.
NEW RECORDS OF MARINE LEECHES HIRUDINIDA:OZOBRANCHIDAE
IN TAIWAN*
Cheng T. Tseng and I. J. Cheng
34.
TAIL GROWTH IN HAWKSBILL TURTLES MATURING AT MONA AND MONITO ISLANDS,
PUERTO RICO
Robert P. van Dam and Carlos E. Diez
34.
THE EVOLUTION OF LEATHERBACK (DERMOCHELYID) TURTLES
Roger C. Wood, James L. Knight, David Cicimuri, and Albert Sanders
OF SEA TURTLES
Conservation, Management and Policy
35.
QARAPARA - SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN CHILE
Rocío E. Álvarez, Marcela A. Mella, Cristián E. Squella, Kharla I. Skamiotis, and Tatiana P. Vuskovic
35.
NESTING BEACH AND BYCATCH MONITORING EFFORT IN SIERRA LEONE
Edward Aruna, Augustine Sesay, Ibrahim Bah, Francis J. Tucker, Aiah P. Koroma, and Ibrahim
Boima
xvi
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
36.
HALTING INDONESIAN SEA TURTLE DECLINES: EXPANDING AND IMPROVING
EFFECTIVENESS OF PROTECTED AREAS FOR TURTLE NESTING SITES
Irawan Asaad, Cherryta Yunia, Wen Wen, and Sangeeta Mangubhai
36.
THE XUNLIAO GUANGDONG PROVINCE EXPERIENCE: RELEASING SEA TURTLES FOR
RESTOCKING AND CONSERVATION AWARENESS IN CHINA
George Balazs, Ka-yan Ng, He-Xiang Gu, and Feiyan Zhang
37.
AN UPDATE ON THE STATUS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN VIEQUES AND AN
EXAMPLE IN CO-MANAGEMENT OF THE SPECIES BETWEEN GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS
Mike Barandian, Mitsuka Bermudez, Francheska Ruiz, and Erick Bermudez
38.
COMMUNITY-BASED CONSERVATION OF MARINE TURTLES ON TETEPARE ISLAND,
SOLOMON ISLANDS
Allan Bero, Hobete Aku, John Read, Katherine Moseby, Gillian Goby, Eleanor Sterling, and Michael
Esbach
38.
U.S. NAVY ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE AND CONSERVATION EFFORTS FOR SEA
TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC AND GULF OF MEXICO
Danielle M. Buonantony, Richard. J. Nissen, David T. MacDuffee, Keith A. Jenkins, Anurag Kumar,
and Andrew DiMatteo
39.
NESTING OF LEATHERBACKS AT COSTA RICA NORTH CARIBBEAN COAST
Didiher Chacón-Chaverri, Didiher A. Chacón-Vargas, Luis Fonseca-Lopez, and Vanessa Lizano
39.
COMMUNITY BASED SEA TURTLE CONSERVANCY IN SOUTHEASTERN PUERTO RICO:
PROYECTO ATMAR A STORY OF SUCCESS.
Luis A. Crespo, Carlos E. Diez, and ATMAR volunteeers
40.
THE PROTECTION OF SEA TURTLE IN NEW CALEDONIA
M. Jean louis D'Auzon, Théa Jacob, M. Dominique Lafage, and Laurence Bachet
40.
SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN UNITED ARAB EMIRATES: STATUS OF IMPLEMENTATION
OF IOSEA MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
Himansu S. Das and Maitha A. Al Hameli
41.
MAKING CONNECTIONS: THE INTER-AMERICAN CONVENTION FOR THE PROTECTION AND
CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES (IAC)
Belinda M. Dick and Veronica C. Chamorro
42.
CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES IN PUERTO RICO: FROM SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH TO
COMMUNITY-BASED MANAGEMENT.
Carlos E. Diez, Raimundo Espinoza, Luis Crespo, and Suki Bermudez
43.
INTERAGENCY COLLABORATIONS IN MARYLAND 1990-2012: NATIONAL PARK SERVICE AND
MARYLAND DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Cindy Driscoll, Tami Pearl, Jamie Testa, Allison Turner, Brenda Kibler, and Jack Kumer
xvii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
43.
INFLUENCE OF TIDAL CURRENTS ON OFFSHORE MIGRATION AND SURVIVAL OF SEA
TURTLE HATCHLINGS RELEASED FROM THE GULF OF FONSECA, HONDURAS
Noemi Duran and Stephen G. Dunbar
44.
ON EFFECTIVE PARTNERSHIPS THROUGH SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION
Michael Esbach
45.
A DECISION FRAMEWORK FOR PRIORITIZING MULTIPLE MANAGEMENT ACTIONS
Mariana MMPB Fuentes, Bob Pressey, Piero Visconti, and Helene Marsh
45.
DEVELOPMENT OF A SUSTAINABLE ECO-TOURISM SYSTEM AT BLUFF BEACH, BOCAS DEL
TORO PROVINCE, PANAMA.
Emma Harrison, Drew Hart, and Cristina Ordoñez Espinosa
46.
HABITAT-USE OF BREEDING GREEN TURTLES, CHELONIA MYDAS, TAGGED IN DRY
TORTUGAS NATIONAL PARK, USA: MAKING USE OF LOCAL AND REGIONAL MPAS
Kristen M. Hart, David G. Zawada, Ikuko Fujisaki, and Barbara H. Lidz
47.
CURRENT STATUS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN SRI LANKA
Thushan Kapurusinghe
47.
BYCATCH AND CUMULATIVE IMPACTS IN U.S. FISHERIES: WHERE ARE THEY NOW?
Amanda J. Keledjian, Beth Lowell, and Casey Youngflesh
48.
MANAGEMENT TOOLS TO PROTECT THE CALIFORNIA CURRENT LARGE MARINE
ECOSYSTEM: ARE THEY ENOUGH TO SAVE LEATHERBACK AND LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES?
Catherine Kilduff, Miyoko Sakashita, and Jaclyn Lopez
49.
ENHANCEMENT OF THE MARINE TURTLES LAND HABITAT QUALITY – GUADELOUPE
ARCHIPELAGO INSHORE PLANNING
François Korysko, Eric Delcroix, Sandra Pédurthe, Sophie Bédel, Guilhem Santelli, Stéphane Guyot,
Didier Lambert, and Marion Diard
50.
WWF'S MARINE TURTLE CONSERVATION PROGRAMME
Aimée Leslie, Diego F. Amorocho, Paolo Casale, Creusa Hitipeuw, Mamadou Diallo, Marina
Antonopoulo, and Marianne Fish
51.
CONSERVATION EFFORTS TO PROTECT SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN THE MALDIVES
Liraz Levy, Alban Viaud, Patrik Svensson, and Thomas Le Berre
52.
IDENTIFYING IMPACTS OF MONGOOSE PREDATION ON GREEN AND HAWKSBILL SEA
TURTLES AND PROTECTING NESTS AT SANDY POINT NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE, ST.
CROIX, USVI
Claudia D. Lombard, Jennifer Valiulis, Jerry Hairston, and Amy Mackay
52.
THE CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT STRATEGY FOR SEA TURTLES IN KENYA:
CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES
Douglas Maina
xviii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
53.
PROJETO TAMAR: MATCHING THREATS AND CONSERVATION PRIORITIES FOR SEA
TURTLES IN BRAZIL
Maria A. Marcovaldi, João C. Thomé, Augusto C. C. Dias da Silva, Gilberto Sales, Bruno Giffoni,
Berenice M. Gomes, Cecília Baptistotte, Eduardo Lima, Juçara Wanderlinde, Armando J. B. Santos,
Alexsandro S. dos Santos, Milagros L. Mendilaharsu, and Gustave G. López
54.
SEA TURTLE SEX RATIO ESTIMATOR
Maria S. Martins and Guilherme R. Barbosa
54.
EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF SEA TURTLE LIGHTING LEGISLATION IN FLORIDA
Jame McCray, Rachel Bruce, Thomas Ankersen, Susan Jacobson, and Raymond Carthy
55.
CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN NIGERIA
Adegbile O. Mojisola, B. B. Solarin, D.A. Adeogun, A.A. Ajulo, D.A. Bolaji, and R.O. Orimogunje
55.
BOHOL RESCUE UNIT FOR MARINE WILDLIFE: A VITAL COMPONENT OF SEA TURTLE
CONSERVATION IN BOHOL, PHILIPPINES
Kristina A. Pahang, Alessandro Ponzo, and Joshua N. Silberg
56.
δ13C AND δ15N BULK TISSUE STABLE ISOTOPE PATTERNS OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLES
(LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) IN THE EASTERN PACIFIC OCEAN
Lindsey E. Peavey, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, Robert L. Pitman, and Steven D. Gaines
56.
VANUA-TAI TURTLE MONITORS A STORY OF SUCCESSFUL TURTLE CONSERVATION IN
VANUATU
George Petro
57.
ASSESSING A POTENTIAL LIGHTING PROBLEM FOR LOGGERHEAD HATCHLINGS NEAR THE
BRIGHTEST LIGHTHOUSE IN THE WORLD: ARENA ASSAYS AT HILLSBORO BEACH, FLORIDA,
USA
Nicole Reintsma, Morgan Young, and Mike Salmon
58.
THE CASE OF THE GREEN TURTLE: AN UNCENSORED HISTORY OF A CONSERVATION ICON
Alison Rieser
59.
THE SEA TURTLE NEST LOCATOR PROGRAM: USING ADVANCED GIS & GPS TECHNOLOGY
TO BALANCE BEACH MANAGEMENT DEMANDS WITH ECOCONSERVATION EFFORTS
David N. Rubin
59.
ARE HAWAIIAN GREEN SEA TURTLES IMPERILED OR RECOVERED?
Miyoko Sakashita and Jaclyn Lopez
60.
CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT INTENSIVE SPORADIC NESTING HABITATS OF ANDHRA PRADESH COAST,
BAY OF BENGAL, INDIA
Raja Sekhar, P.S
60.
ASSESSING THE INFLUENCE OF NEST RELOCATION ON SEA TURTLES IN NORTH CAROLINA,
SOUTH CAROLINA AND GEORGIA
Michael Shaughnessy, Matthew H. Godfrey, Brian Shamblin, Mark Dodd, DuBose B. Griffin, and
Michael Coyne
xix
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
61.
WINNING SEA TURTLE PROTECTION THROUGH LEGISLATION IN CALIFORNIA AND BEYOND
Teri Shore and Todd Steiner
61.
A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF BEST PRACTICES IN PROTECTED SPECIES ADVISORY
GROUPS, AS THEY PERTAIN TO NORTH CAROLINA’S SEA TURTLE ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Ainsley F. Smith and Michelle B. Nowlin
62.
STATUS OF SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN PALOH, WEST KALIMANTAN, INDONESIA, WITH
SPECIAL NOTES ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF LOCAL PARTICIPATION IN PROTECTING
TURTLE NESTS
Dwi Suprapti, I.B.Windia Adnyana, and Creusa Hitipeuw
62.
THE USE OF RECREATIONAL DIVERS FOR IN-WATER SEA TURTLE MONITORING IN
MOZAMBIQUE
Jessica L. Williams, Mark Hamann, and Simon J. Pierce
63.
SEA LEVEL RISE, SPECIES SURVIVAL, AND PRESERVATION OF UPLAND HABITAT
Shaye Wolf and Jaclyn Lopez
Education, Outreach and Advocacy
64.
GTTM-GV: 15 YEARS OF EFFORT TOWARDS SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN VENEZUELA
Hector Barrios-Garrido, Jordano Palmar, Francisco Rodriguez, Tibisay Rodriguez, Martin Oquendo,
Maria J. Petit-Rodriguez, Graciela Pulido-Petit, Beatriz Moran, Efrain Moreno, Daniela RojasCañizales, Laura Carruyo-Rincon, Karledys Garcia, Dana Padron, Luis Valero-Barrios, Brirelys
Conde, Ninive Espinoza-Rodriguez, Lisandro Moran, Natalie Wildermann, and Maria G. MontielVillalobos
65.
COMMUNITY INITIATIVE OF NON-CONSUMPTIVE USE OF SEA TURTLES AS A RESULT OF
LONG TERM CONSERVATION PROGRAM IN BRAZIL
José Henrique Becker, Bruno Giffoni, Fernando Siqueira Alvarenga, Edson Leopoldo dos Santos,
Flávia Cysne Suárez Navarro, Jaime Navarro Barbosa, Patrícia Ortiz, and Berenice Maria Gomes
Gallo
66.
SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION: TRANSFORMATION INTO K-12 EDUCATION: HYBRID POGILTM
METHODOLOGY IN A PLACE-BASED GEOSCIENCE PROGRAM
Gale A. Bishop, R. Kelly Vance, Kathryn M. Ortiz, Veronica Greco, and Brian K. Meyer
66.
SEA TURTLE REHABILITATION AND MEDICINE COURSE: A UNIQUE HANDS ON CLINICAL
EDUCATION FOR VETERINARY STUDENTS
Heather Broadhurst, Craig A. Harms, and Jean Beasley
67.
INTERGRATING SEA TURTLE RESEARCH INTO INFORMAL EDUCATION
Karen P. Burns, Rachel Reisbeck, Katie Vaughan, Alexis Rabon, and Elisabeth Boys
68.
BAHARI KARUNA - CONNECTING PEOPLE THROUGH SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN WEST
AFRICA.
Neil Davis, John Flynn, Juliana Baker, and Kostas Papafitsoros
xx
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
68.
EXPERIENCING SCIENCE TO CULTIVATE THE DESIRE FOR CONSERVATION AT HOME AND
ABROAD
Tera C. Dornfeld, Gabriela S. Blanco, Julianne Koval, Pamela T. Plotkin, Richard D. Reina, Vincent
S. Saba, Bibi Santidrián Tomillo, Lesley Stokes, Jen Swiggs, Bryan P. Wallace, James R. Spotila, and
Frank V. Paladino
69.
A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL APPROACH TO EDUCATION AT A SEA TURTLE NESTING BEACH IN
PLAYA GRANDE, COSTA RICA
Tera C. Dornfeld, Kristin M. Reed, and Frank V. Paladino
70.
CONNECTING JAQUÉ, PANAMÁ TO THE WORLD OF CONSERVATION
Mary Duncan, Ana Maria V. Leon, Richard Boren, Iver Valencia, and Jose A. Cordoba
71.
TOUR DE TURTLES – USING RESEARCH TO INCREASE AWARENESS ABOUT SEA TURTLES
ONLINE
Daniel R. Evans, Rocio Johnson, and David Godfrey
71.
COMMUNITY AWARENESS & CAPACITY BUILDING IN SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN SRI
LANKA
Thushan Kapurusinghe
72.
THE SUCCESSFUL STORY OF LOS CALIFORNIOS VERDES
Luciana Klinge and Cristian Jimenez
73.
SEA TURTLES AND TRASH: AN UNFORTUNATE BUT PREVENTABLE RELATIONSHIP
Nicholas J. Mallos and Allison Schutes
73.
UTILIZING NATIONAL SERVICE PROGRAMS IN CONSERVATION
Jeannie M. Martin
74.
CROSSING SPACE AND TIME WITH SEA TURTLES: AN EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT TO RAISE
AWARENESS FOR THE CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES AND ECOSYSTEM BASEDMANAGEMENT
Gustavo Martinez-Souza
75.
NEW STRATEGIES OF ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION AND AWARENESS FOR A GOOD
CONSERVATION OF THE SEA TURTLES ALONG THE COASTLINE OF MUADA, DEMOCRATIC
REPUBLIC OF CONGO
Samuel Mbungu
75.
SEA TURTLE FORENSIC FIELD INVESTIGATION WORKSHOP
Nancy Mettee, David Gulko, Patrica Rameriz, Angelique Brantwaith, and Karen Eckert
76.
INCREASING CAPACITY FOR SEA TURTLE RESEARCH AND MANAGEMENT IN THE IOSEA
REGION
Andrea D. Phillott and Ruvani N. Nagoda-Gamage
76.
ENDANGERED PACIFIC LEATHERBACKS DOCUMENTED THROUGH COLLABORATIVE
CITIZEN SCIENCE – THE LEATHERBACK WATCH PROGRAM
Christopher A. Pincetich and Kari K. Gehrke
xxi
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
77.
MARINE DEBRIS ACTION TEAMS WORKING TO CREATE PLASTIC-FREE SEA TURTLE
HABITAT
Christopher A. Pincetich, Marc Ward, Katherine C. Santos, and Randall Arauz
78.
OUTREACH AND EDUCATION PROGRAM TO LOCAL COMMUNITIES: AN ESSENTIAL TOOL
FOR SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION
Graciela DC. Pulido, Efrain C. Moreno, Laura Carruyo-Rincon, Jordano Palmar, Francisco
Rodriguez, Dana P. Padron, Ninive E. Espinoza, Natalie E. Wildermann, and Hector Barrios-Garrido
79.
THE GEORGIA SEA TURTLE CENTER MARINE DEBRIS CITIZEN SCIENCE AND EDUCATION
PROGRAM
Caitlin Sampson and Jeannie M. Martin
80.
EIGHT YEARS OF OUTREACH IN COASTAL GABON: FEELING THE SEA TURTLE LOVE
Aimée T. Sanders, Angela Formia, Fiona Maisels, Francois Boussamba, Gil A. Mounguengui, Solange
Ngouessono, Brice D. K. Mabert, and Richard Parnell
81.
CITSCI.ORG: CYBERINFRASTRUCTURE SUPPORT FOR GRASSROOTS CONSERVATION,
CITIZEN SCIENCE, AND COMMUNITY-BASED TERRESTRIAL, FRESHWATER, AND MARINE
TURTLE MONITORING
Russell Scarpino, Gregory Newman, and James Buehler
81.
THE BELIZE TURTLE WATCH PROGRAM – IS CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTING OUR SEA
TURTLES?
Linda Searle and Melanie Day
82.
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION AND SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION ACTIVITIES IN COASTAL
GUJARAT, INDIA
Shwetal Shah and Dinesh Goswami
83.
RAISING SEA TURTLE AND DUGONG CONSERVATION AWARENESS IN WESTERN
PROVINCES, PAPUA NEW GUINEA
Julie Traweek and Rachel Groom
84.
HAWKSBILL CUP: ADDING NON-ECONOMIC VALUES TO SAVE A SPECIES IN EL SALVADOR
AND NICARAGUA
José Urteaga, Michael Liles, Ingrid Yañez, Perla Torres, Ana Henriquez, Gena Abarca, Eduardo
Altamirano, David Melero, Carlos Rivas, Cleide Cea, Victor Medina, and Alexander Gaos
Fisheries and Threats
85.
HOW MUCH IS IT? ASSESSMENT OF SEA TURTLE SUB PRODUCTS ILLEGAL TRADE ON THE
PACIFIC COAST OF NICARAGUA
Gena Abarca, José Urteaga, Isabel Sirias, Liza González, Carlos Mejía, Pedrarias Dávila, Alma
Chávez, Edwin Caballero, María Galeano, Ruth Aguirre, Istvan Sepulveda, and Azucena Baltodano
85.
OVERCOMING THE LOGISTICAL CHALLENGES OF IMPLEMENTING OBSERVER PROGRAMS
IN SMALL-SCALE FISHERIES
Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto, Jeffrey C. Mangel, Natalia Ortiz, Elizabeth Campbell, and Brendan Godley
xxii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
86.
COMPARISON OF CIRCLE HOOK AND J-HOOK PERFORMANCE IN SEA TURTLE REDUCTION
RATES IN ARTISANAL LONGLINE FLEETS IN FOUR COUNTRIES OF THE EASTERN PACIFIC
OCEAN
Sandra Andraka, Maite Pons, Liliana Rendón, Lucas Pacheco, Alvaro Segura, Samuel Amorós,
Michael Valqui, María L. Parga, Takahisa Mituhasi, Nick Vogel, and Martin Hall
87.
ADULT GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN OGASAWARA, JAPAN: A STUDY OF ANIMALS
LIVING WITH INGESTED MARINE DEBRIS
Ayaka Asada and Hiroyuki Suganuma
88.
LEATHERBACK TURTLE MOVEMENTS AND BEHAVIOR IN THE PACIFIC OCEAN: ITS
APPLICATION IN PREDICTING INTERACTIONS WITH FISHERIES
Helen Bailey, Scott R. Benson, George L. Shillinger, Steven J. Bograd, Peter H. Dutton, Scott A.
Eckert, Stephen J. Morreale, Frank V. Paladino, Tomoharu Eguchi, David G. Foley, Barbara A.
Block, Rotney Piedra, Creusa Hitipeuw, Ricardo F. Tapilatu, John H. Roe, Evan Howell, and James
R. Spotila
89.
GHOST NETS: A NEW HAZARD TO SEA TURTLES IN THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
Hector Barrios-Garrido, Maria Jose Petit-Rodriguez, Efrain Moreno, and Natalie Wildermann
90.
THE SPATIAL OVERLAP BETWEEN NESTING LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES (DERMOCHELYS
CORIACEA) AND NEARSHORE FISHERIES: BYCATCH IN THE TRINIDAD DRIFT GILLNET
FISHERIES
Rhema Bjorkland
90.
RISK ASSESSMENT OF HEAVY METALS IN THE OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT OSTIONAL BEACH, COSTA RICA
Lucrezia C. Bonzi, Annalisa Zaccaroni, and Laura Sofia Brenes Chaves
91.
THE UTILIZATION OF A HATCHERY TO MINIMIZE SEA TURTLE IMPACTS DURING A SEA
DEFENSE PROJECT IN ADA FOAH, GHANA.
Audrey Bourgois and Phil Allman
92.
APPLYING LANDSCAPE MODELING APPROACHES TO PREDICT GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA
MYDAS) MOVEMENT PATTERNS IN THE NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC
Wan-Hwa Cheng, John F. Weishampel, I-Jiunn Cheng, and Katsufumi Sato
92.
EU PURSE SEINE FISHERY INTERACTION WITH MARINE TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC AND
INDIAN OCEANS: A 15 YEAR ANALYSIS
Sandra Clermont, Pierre Chavance, Alicia Delgado, Hilario Murua, Jon Ruiz, Stéphane Ciccione, and
Jérôme Bourjea
93.
SUMMER OF THE KEMP'S RIDLEY: THE IMMS RESPONSE TO HIGH NUMBERS OF INCIDENTAL
CAPTURES AT MISSISSIPPI FISHING PIERS
Andrew Coleman, Delphine Shannon, Heidi Zurawka, Wendy Hatchett, Jamie Klaus, Billie Stevens,
Tim Hoffland, and Moby Solangi
94.
HEAVY METAL ANALYSIS OF MARINE LEECHES (OZOBRANCHUS SPP.) TO ASSESS EXPOSURE
IN SEA TURTLES
Kyle A. Danielson, Jacqueline M. Roth, Triet M. Truong, and Audrey E. McGowin
xxiii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
94.
INCIDENTAL BY-CATCH OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) BY BOTTOM
TRAWLING IN EASTERN SPAIN
Francesc Domenech, Sebastian Bitón, Manuel Merchán, Gabriela Vélez-Rubio, Ohiana Revuelta, and
Jesús Tomás
95.
ESTIMATES OF SEA TURTLES BYCATCH IN ARTISANAL FISHING IN SOUTHERN BRAZIL
Camila Domit, Liana Rosa, and Maurício de C. Robert
96.
ALARMING POACHING OF SATELLITE TRACKED INDIVIDUALS RAISES REGIONAL
CONSERVATION CONCERNS FOR GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE WESTERN
INDIAN OCEAN.
Stella Dubernet, Mayeul Dalleau, Stéphane Ciccione, Rose Machaku, Lindsey West, Bertin
Rakotonirina, and Jérôme Bourjea
97.
SEA TURTLE INTERACTIONS AT THE BRUNSWICK STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, SOUTHPORT,
NORTH CAROLINA
Sarah A. Finn
97.
TRASHING TURTLES: QUANTIFYING GARBAGE ON THREE SEA TURTLE NESTING BEACHES
IN COSTA RICA
Kari Gehrke, Emily Kuzmick, Lauren Piorkowski, Katherine Comer Santos, Chris Pincetich, Catalina
Gonzalez, Manuel Sanchez, Lotti Adams, Emma Harrison, Randall Arauz, and Beth Whitman
98.
INTERACTIONS BETWEEN SEA TURTLES AND FISHERIES IN BRAZIL. AN OVERVIEW WITHIN
THE SCOPE OF PROJETO TAMAR MONITORING AREA (1990 – 2012)
Bruno B. Giffoni, Maria Ângela Marcovaldi, Gilberto Sales, João C. A. Thomé, Augusto C. C. Dias da
Silva, Guy Marcovaldi, Berenice M. G. Gallo, Eduardo H. S. M. Lima, Eron P. Lima, Cláudio Bellini,
Juçara Wanderlinde, Gustave Lopez, Armando J. B. Santos, Milagros López-Mendilaharsu, and
Alexsandro Santos
99.
SEA TURTLE CELL CULTURES AS TOOLS FOR INVESTIGATING TOXICANT EXPOSURE AND
EFFECTS.
Céline A.J. Godard-Codding, Sarah Webb, Sandy Wiggins, Benjamin M. Higgins, and Joseph P.
Flanagan
100.
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTION OF LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES IN THE RIO DE
LA PLATA: INSIGHTS FROM STRANDING AND FISHERIES DATA
Daniel Gonzalez-Paredes, Cecilia Lezama, Andres Estrades, Milagros Lopez-Mendilaharsu, Gabriela
Veléz-Rubio, and Alejandro Fallabrino
101.
INCIDENTAL CATCH OF MARINE TURTLES IN BOTTOM TRAWLING IN SOUTHEASTERN
BRAZIL
Suzana M. Guimarães, Juan Pablo Quimbayo, and Cassiano Monteiro-Neto
102.
PREDICTING THE EFFECTS OF SEA LEVEL RISE ON THREE SEA TURTLE NESTING BEACHES
IN COSTA RICA
Lizette Guzman-Zaragoza, Alyssa Giffin, Kristen Zemaitis, Katherine Comer Santos, Catalina
Gonzalez, Manuel Sanchez, Lotti Adams, Emma Harrison, Randall Arauz, Mariana MPB Fuentes,
Marianne Fish, Beth Whitman, and Rebecca Lewison
xxiv
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
103.
DEAD SEA TURTLES FROM DRINI BAY, ALBANIA DURING 2002-2012
Idriz Haxhiu and Vilma Piroli
103.
SEA TURTLE TRADE IN INDONESIA: CURRENT MAGNITUDE AND NEW MODE OF OPERATION
Creusa Hitipeuw, I.B. Windia Adnyana, Dwi Suprapti, and Rusli Andar
104.
BYCATCH INTENSITY OF SEA TURTLES IN THE MARINE WATERS OF BANGLADESH
Mohammad Z. Islam
104.
GREEN TURTLE INTERACTIONS WITH COASTAL GILLNET FISHERY OF THE RIO DE LA
PLATA ESTUARY, URUGUAY
Cecilia Lezama, Florencia Rivas, Natalia Viera, Alejandro Fallabrino, and Andrés Estrades
105.
LOGGERHEADS AND MEDITERRANEAN MONK SEALS: TWO FLAGSHIP SPECIES CLASH IN
ZAKYNTHOS
Dimitris Margaritoulis and Smaro Touliatou
106.
IMPORTANCE OF THE ISLAND OF MAIO (CAPE VERDE) FOR CURRENT AND FUTURE
LOGGERHEAD CONSERVATION IN THE EASTERN ATLANTIC
Samir Martins, Fernando Soares, Eusa Ribeiro, Elena Abella, Franziska Koenen, and Adolfo Marco
107.
ANALYSIS OF SEA TURTLE SPECIMENS ON THE COAST OF KANTO AREA, JAPAN
Shinji Matsuoka, Yuto Aoki, Ai Sakabe, Hiroyuki Suganuma, and Mai Takase
107.
DEVELOPMENT AND TESTING OF A TOW TIME DATA LOGGER TO MONITOR AND ENFORCE
TOW TIME RESTRICTIONS IN TRAWL FISHERIES
Eric Matzen and Henry O. Milliken
108.
PELAGIC PREDATOR DISTRIBUTIONS AND ANTHROPOGENIC IMPACTS: IMPLICATIONS FOR
EFFECTIVE SPATIAL MANAGEMENT IN THE CALIFORNIA CURRENT
Sara M. Maxwell, Elliott L. Hazen, Steven J. Bograd, Benjamin S. Halpern, Barry Nickel, Greg Breed,
Nicole M. Teutschel, Barbara Block, Scott Benson, Peter Dutton, Helen Bailey, Michelle A. Kappes,
Michael J. Weise, Bruce Mate, Scott A. Shaffer, Jason Hassrick, William Henry, Carey Kuhn, Ladd
Irvine, Brigitte McDonald, Patrick Robinson, Samantha Simmons, and Daniel P. Costa
109.
MORTALITY AND BYCATCH OF SEA TURTLES ASSOCIATED WITH ANTHROPOGENIC
FACTORS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF PERNAMBUCO STATE, BRAZIL
Carina C. de M. Moura, Milena S. C. Neves, Arthur P. Barbosa, Thyara N. Simões, Vivian C. S.
Neves, Arley C. Barbosa, and Geraldo J. B. Moura
109.
LEATHERBACK AND GILLNET INTERACTIONS OFF PERU, HIGHLIGHTING IN COASTAL
BYCATCH
Evelyn Paredes and Javier Quiñones
110.
BYCATCH MASS MORTALITY OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES AT NW MEXICO
S. Hoyt Peckham, David Maldonado, Jesse Senko, and Aarón Esliman
111.
FIRST REPORT OF PLASTIC ITEMS IN STOMACH AND INTESTINAL CONTENTS OF GREEN
TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
María José Petit Rodríguez, Natalie Wildermann, Flor Vera, Andrés Pineda, and Héctor BarriosGarrido
xxv
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
111.
SEA TURTLE BYCATCH IN ARTISANAL FISHERIES IN PARANÁ, SOUTHERN BRAZIL
Liana Rosa, Camila Domit, Maurício de C. Robert, and Maria Camila Rosso-Londoño
112.
MONITORING OF ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES IN JUVENILE CHELONIA MYDAS
(TESTUDINES, CHELONIIDAE) CAUGHT IN BRAZILIAN SOUTHEASTERN COAST
Angélica María Sánchez-Sarmiento, Silmara Rossi, Franz Zirena Vilca, Ralph Eric Thijl Vanstreels,
Robson Guimarães dos Santos, Juliana Marigo, Carolina Pacheco Bertozzi, Valdemar Luiz Tornisielo,
and Eliana Reiko Matushima
113.
USING EARTH SYSTEM AND GLOBAL CLIMATE MODELS TO ASSESS THE POTENTIAL
IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON SEA TURTLES
Vincent S. Saba
114.
IS THE SW MEDITERRANEAN SEA A TRAP FOR NORTH ATLANTIC LOGGERHEAD TURTLES?
Ricardo Sagarminaga, Yonat Swimmer, Mariluz Parga, Ana Tejedor, and Amanda Southwood
114.
CONNECTING THE DOTS: THE HIDDEN COSTS OF PLASTIC POLLUTION TO MARINE TURTLES
Dee Sagawe and Jesse Senko
115.
ARE TURTLES EATING MORE DEBRIS? A GLOBAL ANALYSIS SINCE 1900
Qamar Schuyler, Britta Denise Hardesty, Chris Wilcox, and Kathy Townsend
115.
SHADING IN SITU MARINE TURTLE NESTS: A POTENTIAL PRACTICE TO MITIGATE NEST
TEMPERATURES IN RESPONSE TO CLIMATE CHANGE
Monette Virginia Schwoerer, Betsy Von Holle, and John C. Stiner
116.
CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT INTENSIVE SPORADIC NESTING HABITATS OF ANDHRA COAST, BAY OF
BENGAL, INDIA
P. S. Raja Sekhar
116.
EFFECTS OF LED ILLUMINATED GILLNETS ON BYCATCH OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES IN
COASTAL MESH NET FISHERIES AT BAJA CALIFORNIA SUR, MEXICO
Jesse Senko, John Wang, Jesus Lucero-Romero, David Maldonado Diaz, Daniel Aguilar-Ramirez,
Antonio Figueroa, and S. Hoyt Peckham
117.
SYNOPSIS OF THREATS TO SEA TURTLES IN THE GULF OF GUINEA: CONSERVATION
IMPLICATIONS OF ILLEGAL, UNREPORTED AND UNREGULATED (IUU) FISHING
Boluwaji Solarin, O. Adeogun, D. A. Bolaji, C O. M. Adegbile, A. A. Ajulo, R. O. Akinnigbagbe, and
O. S. Fakayode
118.
OVERVIEW OF SOUTHEAST FISHERIES SCIENCE CENTER FISHERY OBSERVER PROGRAMS
AND BYCATCH ANALYSIS
Lesley W. Stokes, Paul M. Richards, and Sheryan P. Epperly
118.
SEA TURTLE RESEARCH, RESCUE AND REHABILITATION CENTRE (DEKAMER), DALYAN,
MUGLA-TURKEY; RESULTS OF THE FIRST FOUR YEARS
Meryem Tekin, Barbaros Şahin, Erdi Can, Cigdem Fak, Mucahit Secme, Çisem Sezgin, Eyup Baskale,
and Yakup Kaska
xxvi
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
119.
MORTALITY AND SERIOUS INJURY DETERMINATIONS FOR SEA TURTLES IN THE NMFS
NORTHEAST REGION, 2006-2010
Carrie M. Upite, Kimberly T. Murray, Brian A. Stacy, Sara E. Weeks, and C. Rogers Williams
119.
UNUSUAL COLD-STUNNING EVENT OF GREEN TURTLES IN URUGUAY
Gabriela M Vélez-Rubio, Andrés Estrades, Virginia Ferrando, and Jesús Tomás
120.
INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECTS OF SEA LEVEL RISE ON SEA TURTLE NESTING
DISTRIBUTIONS WITHIN THE SOUTH ATLANTIC BIGHT
Betsy Von Holle, John Weishampel, Jennifer Irish, Scott Hagen, Monette Auman, Annette Spivy,
Mark Dodd, Matthew Godfrey, DuBose Griffin, Anne Meylan, Llewelyn Ehrhart, and John Stiner
121.
UV ILLUMINATION OF GILLNETS REDUCES SEA TURTLE AND ELASMOBRANCH BYCATCH
John H. Wang, Shara Fisler, Joel Barkan, and Yonat Swimmer
121.
FEEDING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD (CARETTA CARETTA) AND LEATHERBACK
(DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA) SEA TURTLES: A MODEL TO UNDERSTAND BYCATCH
Natasha Warraich and Jeanette Wyneken
122.
IN VITRO TOXICITY OF PERFLUORINATED COMPOUNDS IN LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
(CARETTA CARETTA) PRIMARY SKIN CELL CULTURES
Sarah Webb, Benjamin M. Higgins, Joseph P. Flanagan, and Céline A.J. Godard-Codding
123.
REDUCING ENTRAPMENT OF MARINE TURTLES IN WASTE FISHING GEAR AROUND THE
COASTAL WATERS OF BONAIRE, DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Sue Willis and Mabel Nava
124.
FIRST RECORD OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) IN SINALOA, GULF OF
CALIFORNIA, MEXICO
Alan Zavala-Norzagaray, Catherine E. Hart, Adrian Canizalez-Roman, Paula Aguilar-Claussell,
César Paul Ley-Quiñonez, and Alonso Aguirre
In-Water Biology
125.
A FAIR “EGGS” CHANGE: COMPARING STABLE ISOTOPE RATIOS OF FRESH-LAID VS.
ADDLED EGGS*
Ciro M. Amato, Fernanda B. Gusmão, Ryan M. Chabot, Simona A. Ceriani, and Llewellyn M.
Ehrhart
125.
DEPTH AND WATER TEMPERATURE PREFERENCES OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE DURING
INTER-NESTING PERIOD ON DALYAN-IZTUZU BEACHES, TURKEY
Eyup Baskale, Yusuf Katılmıs, Mücahit Seçme, Çisem Sezgin, and Yakup Kaska
126.
CHARACTERIZATION AND SATELLITE TRACKS OF THE MIGRATORY ROUTES OF TWO
HEAD-STARTED HAWKSBILL TURTLES 13 FROM SANTA MARTA, COLOMBIA*
Jorge E. Bernal-Gutiérrez, Guiomar A. Jauregui, and Carmen L. Noriega
127.
SEASONAL VARIABILITY OF MIGRATING CORRIDORS AND FORAGING AREAS OF ADULTS
GREEN TURTLES REVEALED BY SATELLITE TRACKING AT THE REGIONAL SCALE
Jérôme Bourjea, Mayeul Dalleau, and Stéphane Ciccione
xxvii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
127.
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTIONS OF SEA TURTLES WITHIN THE FLORIDA
CURRENT AND SURROUNDING WATERS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR OCEANIC ENERGY
DEVELOPMENT
Caitlin M. Bovery and Jeanette Wyneken
128.
A PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE SPATIAL DYNAMICS OF IMMATURE GREEN TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS) WITHIN A FORAGING GROUND ON THE ATLANTIC COAST OF
ELEUTHERA, THE BAHAMAS
Annabelle M. Brooks, Marie E. Tarnowski, Alan B. Bolten, and Karen A. Bjorndal
129.
POWER ANALYSIS USING PROGRAM SOFTWARE MONITOR GREATLY INFORMS
EFFECTIVENESS OF MONITORING MARINE TURTLES IN NERITIC HABITATS
Lucie S. Brown, Annabelle Brooks, Dave Hodgson, Marie Tarnowski, and Brendan J. Godley
129.
TOP-DOWN CONTROL IN A RELATIVELY PRISTINE SEAGRASS ECOSYSTEM
Derek Burkholder, Michael Heithaus, James Fourqurean, Aaron Wirsing, and Larry Dill
130.
ROTTEN LUCK: USING NON-VIABLE LOGGERHEAD EGGS TO INFER FEEDING GROUNDS
ALONG FLORIDA’S EAST COAST*
Simona A. Ceriani, James D. Roth, John F. Weishampel, Daniel R. Evans, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
131.
WHAT’S THE SKINNY? TESTING WHETHER SHOULDER AND REAR FLIPPER SKIN PROVIDE
THE SAME ISOTOPIC INFORMATION
Simona A. Ceriani, Ryan M. Chabot, Fernanda B. Gusmão, Ciro M. Amato, and Llewellyn M.
Ehrhart
131.
GOLFO DULCE TROPICAL FJORD A SPECIAL SITE FOR GREEN AND HAWKSBILL FEEDING
GROUND
Didiher Chacón-Chaverri, Didiher A. Chacón-Vargas, and David Rojas-Morales
132.
PLASTICITY OF THE DIVING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES IN DIFFERENT
HABITATS
I-Jiunn Cheng and Wan-hwa Cheng
132.
LONG-TERM MARINE TURTLE POPULATION AND FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS TRENDS IN THE
INDIAN RIVER LAGOON SYSTEM, FLORIDA
Kendra Cope, William Redfoot, Dean Bagley, and Llewellyn Ehrhart
133.
CATCHING MALE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) NEAR ISLA DE AVES, VENEZUELA
Marco G. Cruz, Javier Medina, Verónica de los Llanos, Robert P. van Dam, Margarita Lampo, Jesús
Mavárez, and Kathryn Rodríguez-Clark
134.
TRANS-EQUATORIAL MOVEMENTS OF LATE JUVENILE INDIVIDUALS CHALLENGE THE
UNDERSTANDING OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE (CARETTA CARETTA) LIFE HISTORY IN THE
INDIAN OCEAN*
Mayeul Dalleau, Stéphane Ciccione, Marie Lauret-Stepler, and Jérôme Bourjea
135.
TRACKING NESTING HAWKSBILLS “CHEL” AND “GINGER” FROM THE BAY ISLANDS,
HONDURAS
Lindsey E. Damazo and Stephen G. Dunbar
xxviii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
135.
DIET ANALYSIS OF STRANDED LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES IN VIRGINIA, 2011
Shannon J. Davis, Kristen M. Phillips, Erin E. Seney, and Susan G. Barco
136.
THE U.S. NAVY MARINE SPECIES DENSITY DATABASE: CURRENT STATUS AND
IMPROVEMENTS OF IN-WATER DENSITY ESTIMATES OF MARINE TURTLES AND MAMMALS
Andrew DiMatteo, Anurag Kumar, Bryan Wallace, and Patrick Halpin
137.
DO HATCHLING SWIMMING PATTERNS MATTER WHEN IT COMES TO PREDATION?*
Noemi Duran and Stephen G. Dunbar
138.
PREVALENCE OF OCEANIC FORAGERS AMONG ADULT FEMALE LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES CARETTA CARETTA NESTING IN CAPE VERDE (NORTHWESTERN AFRICA)
Elena Eder, Alba Ceballos, Samir Martins, Héctor Pérez-García, Isabel Marín, Adolfo Marco, and
Luis Cardona
139.
DO GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) NESTING IN PRINCIPE ISLAND, WEST AFRICA,
EXHIBIT SIMILAR ISOTOPIC NICHES?
Rogerio L. Ferreira, Filipe R. Ceia, Jaime A. Ramos, Teresa C. Borges, and Alan B. Bolten
139.
TROPHIC ECOLOGY OF CHELONIA MYDAS (LINNAEUS, 1758) IN SOUTH COAST OF BRAZIL:
SEASONAL AND INTER-ANNUAL VARIATION OF THE DIET.
Luciana R. Gama, Liana Rosa, and Camila Domit
140.
POSSIBLE HYBRIDIZATION BETWEEN EAST PACIFIC GREEN AND OLIVE RIDLEY SEA
TURTLES IN NORTH WEST MEXICO
Catherine E. Hart, Alan A. Zavala-Norzagaray, Cesar P. Ley-Quiñonez, Alonso A. Aguirre, Paula
Aguilar-Claussell, and F. Alberto Abreu
141.
HABITAT-USE OF BREEDING HAWKSBILL TURTLES ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA TAGGED AT
BUCK ISLAND REEF NATIONAL MONUMENT, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS
Kristen M. Hart, Zandy Hillis-Starr, Autumn R. Sartain, Michael S. Cherkiss, Clayton Pollock, and
Ian Lundgren
141.
INTEGRATION OF GUT CONTENT AND STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSIS TO INVESTIGATE
ONTOGENETIC SHIFTS IN DIET AND HABITAT BY JUVENILE GREEN SEA TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS) ALONG THE TEXAS COAST*
Lyndsey N. Howell, Kimberly J. Reich, Donna J. Shaver, and Andre M. Landry, Jr.
142.
POST-NESTING MOVEMENTS AND FORAGING GROUND UTILIZATION BY UPPER TEXAS
COAST NESTERS
Christi L. Hughes and Andre M. Landry, Jr.
143.
FIRST REPORT OF CHANGES IN δ13C AND δ15N VALUES IN SCUTE FROM AN ADULT KEMP’S
RIDLEY TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS KEMPII) FOLLOWING A DIET SHIFT
Claire E. Iseton and Kimberly J. Reich
143.
NEW INSIGHTS FOR SEA TURTLE DISTRIBUTION IN COASTAL WATERS OF JAPAN INFERRED
FROM FISHERMEN SURVEYS
Takashi Ishihara, Naoki Kamezaki, Yoshimasa Matsuzawa, and Asuka Ishizaki
xxix
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
144.
DETERMINATION OF SEA TURTLE MIGRATION PATHWAY BY SATELLITE MONITORING
SYSTEMS IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN COAST OF TURKEY
Yakup Kaska, Eyup Başkale, Yusuf Katılmıss, Meryem Tekin, Çiğdem Fak, Mücahit Seçme, Çisem
Sezgin, Fulvio Mafucci, Sandra Hochscheid, and Flegra Bentivegna
145.
LONG-DISTANCE TRAVEL DURING INTER-NESTING: UNIQUE AND DEVIANT MOVEMENTS OF
LOGGERHEAD NESTERS IN THE NORTHER GULF OF MEXICO
Margaret M. Lamont, Kristen M. Hart, Ikuko Fujisaki, Autumn R. Sartain, Brail Stephens, Jackie
Isaacs, and Dianne Ingram
146.
VARIATION IN REMIGRATION INTERVAL IS LINKED TO FORAGING DESTINATION OF
WESTERN PACIFIC LEATHERBACK TURTLES
Deasy N. Lontoh, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, Ricardo F. Tapilatu, James T. Harvey, and Scott R. Benson
147.
FIRST SATELLITE TRACKS OF NEONATE GREEN (CHELONIA MYDAS) TURTLES USING A NEW
TAG ATTACHMENT METHOD
Kate L. Mansfield and Jeanette Wyneken
148.
IDENTIFYING IMPORTANT FEEDING AGGREGATIONS OF GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA
MYDAS): THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
María G. Montiel-Villalobos, Héctor A. Barrios-Garrido, Rodrigo Lazo, and Kathryn M. RodríguezClark
148.
AN APPLICATION OF VIDEO ANALYSIS TO THE COGNITIVE STUDY: THE RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN LOOKING-AROUND BEHAVIOR OF GREEN TURTLES AND THEIR HABITAT
ENVIRONMENT
Kana Nakajima, Junichi Okuyama, Kenta Matsui, Kazuaki Kondo, Takahiro Koizumi, Yuichi
Nakamura, Ayana Wada, Nobuaki Arai, and Shiro Kagawa
149.
COMPLEX HABITAT USE BY HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN LAC BAY, BONAIRE, DUTCH
CARIBBEAN - PRELIMINARY RESULTS
Mabel Nava and Robert van Dam
150.
FEEDING ECOLOGY OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) STRANDED ALONG
THE PORTUGUESE SOUTHERN COAST – ALGARVE
Lídia Nicolau, Ana Marçalo, Catarina Eira, and José Vingada
150.
AN ENERGY STRATEGY OF FEMALE GREEN TURTLES DURING INTER-NESTING PERIOD IN
ISHIGAKI ISLANDS, JAPAN
Yuka Obe, Junichi Okuyama, Hideaki Nishizawa, Tohya Yasuda, Masato Kobayashi, and Nobuaki
Arai
151.
FIRST SATELLITE TRACK OF A HEAD-STARTED HAWKSBILL (FOUR YEARS OLD) IN THE
COLOMBIAN CARIBBEAN
Karen A. Pabón-Aldana, Carmen L. Noriega-Hoyos, and Guiomar A. Jaúregui
151.
IDENTIFYING BEHAVIORAL STATES IN LOGGERHEAD TURTLES USING SATELLITE
TELEMETRY DATA
Samir H. Patel, Aliki Panagopoulou, Helen Bailey, Stephen J. Morreale, Frank V. Paladino, Dimitris
Margaritoulis, and James R. Spotila
xxx
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
152.
POST-NESTING BEHAVIOR OF LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA NESTING IN CAMP LA GLORIA,
JALISCO, MEXICO
Theodora Pinou, Robert DiGiovanni, Ildefonso E. Padilla, Jacobo Francisco, Carlos Barrera, and
Antonio T. Robles
153.
SEA TURTLE STUDY IN ALBANIA DURING 2011
Vilma Piroli and Idriz Haxhiu
153.
DISTRIBUTION AND RELATIVE ABUNDANCE OF SEA TURTLES IN BUCK ISLAND REEF
NATIONAL MONUMENT, ST. CROIX, US. VIRGIN ISLANDS
Clayton Pollock, Paul Jobsis, Kristen M. Hart, and Zandy Hillis-Starr
154.
USING MULTIPLE METHODS TO LINK THE LOGGERHEAD FORAGING POPULATION IN
AMVRAKIKOS GULF, GREECE, TO SOURCE NESTING POPULATIONS IN THE
MEDITERRANEAN
ALan F. Rees, Annette C. Broderick, Carlos Carreras, Dimitris Margaritouliis, and Brendan J.
Godley
155.
FACTORS AFFECTING NEST AND IN-WATER SURVIVAL OF HAWKSBILL HATCHLING SEA
TURTLES AT JUMBY BAY, ANTIGUA, WEST INDIES*
Megan Reising, Michael Salmon, Seth Stapleton, and Seth Stapleton
156.
TROPHIC BEHAVIOR DIVERSIFICATION OF GREEN TURTLES FROM MEXICAN PACIFIC IN
RELATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
Juan M. Rguez-Baron, Jorge M. López-Calderón, Rafael Riosmena-Rodríguez, and Jeffrey A.
Seminoff
156.
USE OF NON-OCEAN HABITAT BY SEA TURTLES AS FORAGING OR RESTING GROUNDS
Todd A. Rimkus, Samantha Grimmer, and Melany Su
157.
OASTAL OR PELAGIC: UPDATING THE LEATHERBACK PARADIGM
Nathan J. Robinson, Ronel Nel, Stephen J. Morreale, and Frank V. Paladino
158.
DIET, FOOD AVAILABILITY AND SELECTIVITY OF CHELONIA MYDAS JUVENILES AT
GORGONA NATIONAL PARK, COLOMBIAN PACIFIC*
Laura Sampson, Alan Giraldo, and Diego Amorocho
158.
TROPHIC ECOLOGY OF KEMP’S RIDLEY TURTLES IN THE CHARLOTTE HARBOR ESTUARY,
FLORIDA
Jeffrey R. Schmid, Anton D. Tucker, Bradley D. MacDonald, and Jeffrey A. Seminoff
159.
CALETA CHASCOS IN NORTHERN CHILE: RESEARCH AND CONSERVATION IN THE MOST
AUSTRAL FORAGING SITE FOR BLACK TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS AGASSIZII)
Cristián E. Squella, Marcela A. Mella, Carlos Canales, and Rocío E. Álvarez
160.
ECOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF DIFFERENCES IN ABUNDANCE OF JUVENILE GREEN
TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ON NEARSHORE REEFS IN SOUTHEAST FLORIDA
Melanie Stadler, Charles Roberts, and Michael Salmon
160.
SUMMARIZING IN-WATER SEA TURTLE RESEARCH IN ST. JOSEPH BAY, FLORIDA
Brail S. Stephens, Caitlin E. Hackett, Margaret M. Lamont, and Raymond R. Carthy
xxxi
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
161.
MIGRATIONS OF POST NESTING AND MOVEMENTS OF JUVENILE HAWKSBILL TURTLES
(ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) OF AMERICAN SAMOA
Alden P. Tagarino and Katerine Schletz Saili
162.
STABLE NITROGEN ISOTOPES IN THALASSIA TESTUDINUM ON THE FEEDING GROUNDS OF
GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN AKUMAL, QUINTANA ROO, MEXICO
Ana L. Talavera, Alberto Sánchez, Concepción Ortiz, Sergio Aguíñiga, and Eduardo Balart
162.
INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL DIET VARIATION IN A GENERALIST POPULATION? FORAGING
ECOLOGY OF GREEN TURTLES IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA BASED ON TURTLE-BORNE VIDEO
AND STABLE ISOTOPES
Jordan A. Thomson, Derek A. Burkholder, and Michael R. Heithaus
163.
TRACKING HABITAT USE AND LIFE HISTORY PATTERNS OF EAST PACIFIC GREEN TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS) USING STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSIS WITH SKELETOCHRONOLOGY*
Cali Turner Tomaszewicz, Carolyn Kurle, Hoyt Peckham, Larisa Avens, Lisa Goshe, Victor de la
Toba, Juan M. Rguez-Baron, Brad MacDonald, and Jeffrey Seminoff
164.
GREEN TURTLES: CREATURES OF HABIT*
Hannah B. Vander Zanden, Karen A. Bjorndal, and Alan B. Bolten
164.
WINTER DIETS OF IMMATURE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ON A NORTHERN
FEEDING GROUND: INTEGRATING STOMACH CONTENTS AND STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSES
Natalie C. Williams, Karen A. Bjorndal, Margaret M. Lamont, and Raymond R. Carthy
165.
DOES A TROPICAL STORM AFFECT THE INTERNESTING BEHAVIOR OF A LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLE?
Maria Wilson, Anton D. Tucker, and David A. Mann
165.
OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION OF THE BARNACLE STEPHANOLEPAS MURICATA
FISHER,1886, ON SEA TURTLES IN THE GOLFO DULCE, PACIFIC, COSTA RICA
Nadège Zaghdoudi-Allan
Nesting Biology
166.
EVALUATION OF HAWKSBILL TURTLE STATUS ALONG THE DARIEN GAP-CHOCÓ REGION
OF PACIFIC PANAMA AND COLOMBIA
Diego F. Amorocho, Alexander Tobón López, M. Alejandra Jaramillo, Marino E. Abrego, and
Alexander R. Gaos
166.
CHARACTERIZING THE INTER-NESTING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES (CARETTA
CARETTA) AT KYPARISSIA BAY, GREECE
Thomas F. Backof, Thomas F. Backof, Stephen J. Morreale, Thomas Riggall, and Frank V. Paladino
167.
MARINE TURTLE NESTING AT THE ARCHIE CARR NWR: ARE LOGGERHEADS MAKING A
COMEBACK?
Dean A. Bagley, William E. Redfoot, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
xxxii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
168.
LONG-TERM MONITORING AND CONSERVATION OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE NESTS ON
DALYAN BEACH, TURKEY: RESULTS OF THE RECENT CONSERVATION AFFORDS
Eyup Başkale, Yusuf Katılmıs, Mücahit Seçme, Çisem Sezgin, and Yakup Kaska
168.
EXAMINING HERITABILITY IN NEST-SITE SELECTION FOR LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
(CARETTA CARETTA) USING ADVANCED GENETIC AND SPATIAL TECHNIQUES
Bonnie E. Berry, Brian M. Shamblin, Mark G. Dodd, Kristina L. Williams, Joseph B. Pfaller, Gale A.
Bishop, and Campbell J. Nairn
169.
IMPLICATIONS OF HATCHLING SEX RATIOS AND SURVIVAL IN THE RECOVERY PROGRAM
FOR THE ENDANGERED KEMP’S RIDLEY SEA TURTLE
Elizabeth Bevan, Amy Bonka, Tony Torres, Diana J. Lira-R, Thane Wibbels, Marco Antonio-P,
Hector J. Martinez-O, Jaime Pena-V, Patrick M. Burchfield, Earl Possardt, and Barbara Schroeder
170.
AIR-DAM ENTRAPMENT OF EMERGING LOGGERHEAD HATCHLINGS, ST. CATHERINES
ISLAND, GEORGIA: A CASE OF OBSTRUCTED EMERGENCE
Gale A. Bishop, Kenneth F. Clark, Edward J. Davis, Doris Davis, Martha L. Schriver, and R. Kelly
Vance
171.
EFFECTS OF HABITAT VARIABILITY ON ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA INCUBATION
TEMPERATURES: A PILOT STUDY ON LONG ISLAND, ANTIGUA
Charlie Braman, Jonathan Pahlas, and Seth Stapleton
171.
FIFTEEN YEARS OF RESEARCH ON GREEN TURTLES AT GUANAHACABIBES PENINSULA: A
RETROSPECTIVE OF COMMUNITY BASED TURTLE CONSERVATION AND RESEARCH IN
WESTERN CUBA
Fernando Bretos Trelles, Julia Azanza Ricardo, and Anton D. Tucker
172.
PRELIMINARY RESULTS FROM AKAZUL’S SEA TURTLE TAGGING PROGRAM, LA BARRONA,
GUATEMALA
Rachel Brittain, Sarah Lucas, and Scott Handy
173.
A MATHEMATICAL MODEL CONSISTENT WITH THE GEOMAGNETIC IMPRINTING
HYPOTHESIS OF NATAL HOMING
J. Roger Brothers and Kenneth J. Lohmann
173.
MODELING INTRAGUILD PREDATION AND PREDATOR FACILITATION ON SHARED PREY
Joshua Castro
174.
GREEN TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITIES ON ZABARGAD ISLAND, A MAJOR ROOKERY IN THE
SOUTHERN EGYPTIAN RED SEA
Islam El Sadek, Agnese Mancini, Mahmoud Hanafy, and Marc Girondot
175.
VEGETATION AND SUBSTRATE CHARACTERIZATION AT ENSENADA MALIMANSIPA,
CASTILLETES: KEY BEACHES FOR NESTING ACTIVITY AT GULF OF VENEZUELA
Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez, Efrain Moreno, Lisandro Morán, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido
176.
ACOUSTIC COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HATCHLINGS OF DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA
Camila R. Ferrara, Richard C. Vogt, Martha Harfush, Renata Souza Lima, Ernesto Albavera, and
Alejandro Lopez
xxxiii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
176.
A LABORATORY EVALUATION OF HATCHLING LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE (CARETTA
CARETTA) PERFORMANCE IN RESPONSE TO CONTROLLED INCUBATION TEMPERATURES
Leah Fisher, David Owens, and Matthew Godfrey
177.
PRELIMINARY DATA ON THE OLIVE RIDLEY TAGGING PROGRAM AT NANCITE BEACH,
COSTA RICA
Luis G. Fonseca, Wilberth N. Villachica, Eduardo R. Matarrita, Yeudy Argüello, Carlos M. Orrego,
Wagner Quirós, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, and Roldán A. Valverde
178.
STUDYING BEACH NOURISHMENT TEMPLATES AND MARINE TURTLE NESTING CUES TO
LEARN HOW TO ENGINEER MORE “TURTLE FRIENDLY” BEACHES
Allison W. Hays and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
179.
TO RELOCATE OR NOT
Ş. Karakaya, Z. Ün, C. Yılmaz, A. Oruç, and O. Türkozan
179.
POSSIBLE EFFECT OF RELOCATION ON SEX RATIO OF HATCHLINGS: SPATIAL AND
TEMPORAL DIFFERENCES IN NEST TEMPERATURES AND SEX OF HATCHLINGS AND
EMBRYOS OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES ON DALAMAN AND DALYAN BEACHES, TURKEY
Yakup Kaska, Eyup Baskale, Yusuf Katilmis, Fikret Sari, Cigdem Fak, Mucahit Secme, and Cisem
Sezgin
180.
DECLINE OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE NESTS ON FETHIYE BEACH, TURKEY
Yusuf Katılmıs, Eyup Başkale, Fatih Polat, Musa Azmaz, and Yakup Kaska
180.
INVERTEBRATE INFESTATION IN LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE NESTS ON DALYAN BEACH,
TURKEY
Yusuf Katılmıs, Eyup Başkale, İlker Kara, Mücahit Seçme, Çisem Sezgin, and Yakup Kaska
181.
EXTENSIVE MARINE TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITY REVEALED ON REMOTE BEACHES OF
ANTIGUA & BARBUDA, WEST INDIES
Kathryn Levasseur, Dominic Tilley, Seth Stapleton, and Mykl C. Fuller
181.
RUNNING INTO THE FIRE: LOGGERHEAD NESTING DENSITY SHIFTS INTO AREAS OF
INCREASED EROSION OVER A 20-YEAR PERIOD*
Chris A. Long, Joshua S. Reece, John F. Weishampel, Allison W. Hays, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
182.
BAMBOO BAY, MALAKULA ISLAND,VANUATU, AN IMPORTANT NESTING BEACH FOR
WESTERN PACIFIC GREEN (CHELONIA MIDAS) AND HAWKSBILL TURTLES (ERETMOCHELYS
IMBRICATA).
Kenneth T. MacKay and George Petro
183.
THE STATUS AND NESTING ECOLOGY OF SEA TURTLES IN KENYA
Rose Machaku and Boaz Kaunda-Arara
183.
EMERGENCE PATTERN OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE (CARETTA CARETTA) HATCHLINGS FROM
IZTUZU BEACH, DALYAN, TURKEY
Joanne C. Makin, Yakup Kaska, and James Reynolds
xxxiv
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
183.
DO SEA TURTLES PREFER WHITE SAND BEACHES? IMPLICATIONS OF THE RESPONSE OF
ENDANGERED POPULATIONS TO GLOBAL WARMING
Adolfo Marco, Samir Martins, María Martins, and Elena Abella
184.
CONNECTING RECORD LEVELS OF LOGGERHEAD NESTING IN KYPARISSIA BAY, GREECE,
TO LONG-TERM NEST PROTECTION
Dimitris Margaritoulis, ALan F. Rees, and Thomas E. Riggall
185.
EFFECTS OF GRANULAR INCLINE ANGLE ON THE LOCOMOTION OF LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLE HATCHLINGS (CARETTA CARETTA) IN THE FIELD
Nicole Mazouchova and Daniel I. Goldman
186.
SPATIO-TEMPORAL VARIABILITY IN REPRODUCTIVE SUCCESS OF THE HAWKSBILL TURTLE
(ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) IN JARDINES DE LA REINA, CUBA
Yosvani Medina Cruz, Félix G. Moncada Gavilán, and Gonzalo Nodarse Andreu
186.
EVIDENCE OF SEA TURTLES NESTING IN LAGOS, SOUTHWESTERN NIGERIA
Adegbile O. Mojisola, B.B. Solarin, A.B. Williams, K.I. Oshisanya,, F.C. Olakolu, and H.O.
Omogoriola
187.
EFFECT OF CLOSED SEASONS ON NESTING POPULATIONS OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA
MYDAS) AND LOGGERHEADS (CARETTA CARETTA) AT GUANAL BEACH, ISLA DE LA
JUVENTUD, CUBA
Félix G. Moncada Gavilán, Dana Tizol, Gonzalo Nodarse Andreau, and Yosvani Medina Cruz
187.
SEASONALITY OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) REPRODUCTION AT ALDABRA ATOLL,
SEYCHELLES
Jeanne A. Mortimer
188.
LEATHERBACKS, COMMUNITIES, AND COASTAL CHANGE IN GRANDE RIVIERE, TRINIDAD
Kevin Muhammad, Len Peters, Nicholas Alexander, Marcia Barker, and David Silverthorn
188.
ASPECTS OF REPRODUCTIVE ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA (LINNAEUS, 1766), FROM THE
SOUTH COAST OF PERNAMBUCO, BRAZIL
Vivian C. S. Neves, Milena S. C. Neves, Elisângela S. Guimarães, and Simone F. Teixeira
189.
FATE AND EMERGENCE SUCCESS OF HAWKSBILL (ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) NESTS IN
THE COMARCA NGÖBE-BUGLÉ AND BOCAS DEL TORO PROVINCE, PANAMA
Cristina Ordoñez, Peter Meylan, Anne Meylan, and Emma Harrison
190.
IMPACTS OF WRACK DEPOSITION ON ST. CATHERINES ISLAND, GA
Kathryn M. Ortiz, R. Kelly Vance, and Gale A. Bishop
190.
IMPACTS OF A DECLINING BEACH PROFILE ON HAWKSBILL TURTLE NESTING SUCCESS
AND SITE CHOICE
Jonathan M. Pahlas, Charles A. Braman, and Seth P. Stapleton
191.
TIDAL AND BEACH CONFIGURATION INFLUENCES ON THE LANDING OF MARINE TURTLES
ON THEIR NESTING BEACH
Christina Péron, Damien Chevallier, and Antoine Gardel
xxxv
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
192.
TOUCHING BASE – THE STATUS OF MARINE TURTLE NESTING AT THE PATRICK AIR FORCE
INSTALLATION, FLORIDA (USA)
Steffan M. Pierre, Andrew T. Sterner, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
193.
CONTINUED DECLINE OF NESTING LEATHERBACK TURTLES AT CULEBRA ISLAND, PUERTO
RICO
Cristian Ramírez-Gallego, Carlos E. Diez, Karla Barrientos-Muñoz, Abby White, and Ana M. Roman
193.
PROFILES OF PROTECTED AREA NESTING BEACHES AT PUMPKIN HILL AND CUERO Y
SALADO WILDLIFE REFUGE, HONDURAS
Robyn E. Reeve, Dustin S. Baumbach, Lindsey E. Damazo, Stephen G. Dunbar, Amy L. Tan, Ariana
Cunningham, Angela Randazzo, and Lidia Salinas
194.
TEMPORAL VARIATION OF INCUBATION TEMPERATURE OF GREEN TURTLE NESTS IN THE
SOUTHWESTERN CUBAN ARCHIPELAGO
Julia A. Ricardo, José L. G. Muro, Fernando Bretos Trelles, and Adrián G. Abraham
195.
EFFECTS OF INCREASED CONSTRUCTION ON THE DISTRIBUTION OF LOGGERHEAD NESTS
IN SOUTHERN KYPARISSIA BAY, GREECE
Thomas E. Riggall, ALan F. Rees, and Dimitris Margaritoulis
196.
ESTIMATION OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) HATCHING RATES OF
CHACOCENTE AND LA FLOR BEACHES, NICARAGUA DURING THE 2009 AND 2011 NESTING
SEASONS
Heydi Salazar, Perla Torres, Lidiceth Jarquin, Danelia Benavides, Roldán Vaverde, Jose Urteaga,
Luis Fonseca, Domingo Cuendis, Carol Cabrera, Nancy Barahona, Marcial Chávez, Nelson Guevara,
Wilber Alegría, Jefer Cruz, and Faustino Obando
197.
CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES IN PLAYA CEUTA, ELOTA, SINALOA, MEXICO: 2012-2013
SEASON
Fernando E. Saracho, Marco A. B. Ortega, Ingmar S. Cornejo, Jesús I. Guardado-González, Juan L.
C. González., Zuleica B. Gonzalez Camacho, and Saúl Rubio
197.
EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT LIGHT INTENSITIES ON HATCHLING LEATHERBACK (DEMOCHELYS
CORICEA) SEA TURTLES
Alyssa Scarfo, Eric Koepfler, Taylor Dacal, Destinee Green, Taylor LaChance, and Molly Wainscott
198.
SPATIAL ANALYSIS OF SEA TURTLE NESTING FREQUENCY ON TWO BARRIER ISLANDS IN
NORTH CAROLINA
Marc B. Sciance and Joanne Halls
198.
MARINE TURTLES NESTS IN DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENTS IMPACTED IN THE NATURAL
RESERVES OF MONA AND CULEBRA ISLANDS, PUERTO RICO
Krystina R. Scott and Carlos E. Diez
199.
NESTING ECOLOGY AND REPRODUCTIVE SUCCESS OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) SEA TURTLE AT GODAVARI RIVER MOUTH NESTING BEACHES, ANDHRA COAST,
BAY OF BENGAL, INDIA
P. S. Raja Sekhar
xxxvi
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
200.
EFFECTS OF INUNDATION ON HATCH SUCCESS OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE (CARETTA
CARETTA) NESTS*
Katherine R. Shaw and Dave Addison
201.
DARKER BEACHES, BRIGHTER FUTURE: REDUCING THE IMPACTS OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING
ON SEA TURTLE NESTING BEACHES
Karen Shudes and David Godfrey
201.
EVALUATION OF SEX RATIOS OF THE OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT AN ARRIBADA NESTING BEACH IN MEXICO: SECOND YEAR FOLLOW-UP
Itzel Sifuentes-Romero, Annelisse Bárcenas-Ibarra, Rosina Varela-Valenzuela, Martha HarfushMeléndez, and Alejandra García-Gasca
202.
OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) EMBRYO DEVELOPMENT AS A
FUNCTION OF BEACH ZONES AND AN ASSESSMENT OF A METHODOLOGY TO DETERMINE
EMBRYO DEVELOPMENT
Sarah R. Steele, Ariana O. McCarthy, and Roldán A. Valverde
203.
BEACH AND NEST TEMPERATURES, AND ESTIMATES OF LEATHERBACK HATCHLING SEX
RATIOS AT BIRD’S HEAD PENINSULA, PAPUA, INDONESIA
Ricardo F. Tapilatu, Thane Wibbels, and Manjula Tiwari
204.
REPRODUCTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF GREEN TURTLES, CHELONIA MYDAS, IN
TORTUGUERO, COSTA RICA
Luis Valero-Barrios, Emma Harrison, Nínive Espinoza, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido
204.
ON-GOING RECOVERY OF THE HAWKSBILL TURTLE POPULATION BREEDING AT MONA
ISLAND, PUERTO RICO
Robert P. van Dam, Carlos E. Diez, Karla G. Barrientos Muñoz, and Cristian Ramirez Gallego
205.
ACOUSTIC COMMUNICATION DURING LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA ARRIBADA
Richard C. Vogt, Camila R. Ferrara, Martha Harfush, Renata Sousa-Lima, and Ernesto Albavera
205.
GREEN TURTLES NESTING ON ARUBA 2001-2012
Edith van der Wal, Sietske van der Wal, and Richard van der Wal
206.
GREEN TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITY AT JUANI ISLAND, TANZANIA, DURING THE 2012 PEAK
NESTING SEASON
Lindsey West, Boniventure Mchomvu, and Omari Abdallah
207.
GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) NESTING ON AKYATAN BEACH: RESULTS OF SIX YEARS
SURVEY
C. Yılmaz, A. Oruc, and O. Türkozan
207.
HATCHING AND EMERGENCE SUCCESS OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE
GALAPAGOS ISLANDS*
Patricia M. Zárate, Karen A. Bjorndal, Macarena Parra, Peter H. Dutton, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, and
Alan B. Bolten
xxxvii
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
Other
208.
ARCHELON VOLUNTEERS: AN ARMY OF HOPE
Theodoros Benos-Palmer, Theoni Karkoulia, Aliki Panagopoulou, Anna Kremezi-Margaritoulis, and
Dimitris Margaritoulis
209.
THE PROTECTOR – GHI - SIMS PARTNERSHIP: A MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH; SAVING
TURTLES, HELPING PEOPLE
S.G. Dunbar, S.S. Dunbar, C. Chapman, S. Vodhanel, S. Plafker, C.A. Church, V.L. Leggitt, J.
Zumwalt, E. Rosspencer, L. Bayardo, M. Friedman, L. Huey, R.L. Parker, G. Delgado, R. Cruzado, L.
Salinas, and N. Zelaya
210.
GRASSROOTS VOLUNTEERING OFFERS GREATER OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE CONSERVATION
IMPACT FOR SEA TURTLES IN CHINA
Laura Gross and Frederick Yeh
210.
VOLUNTEER PROGRAMS OF THE GEORGIA SEA TURTLE CENTER
Jeannie Miller Martin and Caitlin Sampson
211.
DISMANTLING OLD WALLS AND BUILDING NEW BRIDGES: SEA TURTLE ADVOCACY IN THE
COMMONWEALTH OF THE NORTHERN MARIANA ISLANDS, WESTERN PACIFIC
Tammy Mae Summers, Jessy Hapdei, Joseph Ruak, Eileen Escudero, Dimitri Varmazis, and Arielle
Buyum
212.
900 HOURS ON NESTING BEACHES: PROTECTOR VOLUNTEER EFFORTS IN HONDURAS
Amy L. Tan, S. Dunbar, D. Baumbach, A. Cunningham, L. E. Damazo, R. E. Reeve, K. Lindsay, and
L. Salinas
212.
COMMUNITY-BASED SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN NORTH QUEENSLAND
Julie Traweek
Population Biology and Monitoring
213.
ASSESSMENT OF SEX RATIO AND REPRODUCTIVE STATUS OF A FORAGING GREEN TURTLE
POPULATION IN SAN DIEGO BAY, CALIFORNIA
Camryn D. Allen, Michelle N. Robbins, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, Dave W. Owens, Nick M. Kellar, and
Peter H. Dutton
214.
AN EFFECTIVE AND SAFE TECHNIQUE TO PIT TAG HATCHLING GREEN TURTLES CAPTIVE
BRED AT SEA LIFE PARK HAWAII
George H. Balazs, Robert Morris, and Jeffrey Pawloski
214.
GLOBAL PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF HAWKSBILL TURTLES, ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA BASED
ON MTDNA
Karla G. Barrientos Munoz and Cristian. Ramirez Gallego
215.
THRESHOLD TO MATURITY IN GREEN TURTLES: INTERACTIONS OF AGE, SIZE AND
GROWTH
Karen A. Bjorndal, Joe Parsons, Walter Mustin, and Alan B. Bolten
xxxviii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
215.
PREDICTING THE IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING ON SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN
VIETNAM
Cuong The Chu and The Duc Nguyen
216.
MICROSATELLITE ANALYSES SHOW RESTRICTED MALE-MEDIATED GENE FLOW BETWEEN
MEDITERRANEAN ROOKERIES FOR LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
Marcel Clusa, Carles Carreras, Marta Pascual, Andreas Demetropoulos, Dimitris Margaritoulis, Alan
F. Rees, Abdulmaula A. Hamza, Mona Khalil, Monica Aureggi, Yaniv Levy, Ogüz Türkozan, Alex
Aguilar, and Luis Cardona
217.
PREDICTED SEX RATIO OF IMMATURE KEMP’S RIDLEYS INCIDENTALLY CAPTURED AT
MISSISSIPPI FISHING PIERS
Andrew Coleman, Thane Wibbels, Delphine Shannon, Heidi Zurawka, Wendy Hatchett, Elizabeth
Bevan, Tim Hoffland, and Moby Solangi
217.
GENETIC CHARACTERIZATION OF OLIVE RIDLEY AGGREGATIONS OFF THE MEXICAN
CENTRAL PACIFIC COAST- PRELIMINARY RESULTS
Rodolfo Martín del Campo, Christian Ortega, Sonia Quijano, and Alberto Abreu
218.
MULTIPLE PATERNITY OF THE GREEN TURTLE POPULATION AT KOSGODA TURTLE
ROOKERY, SRI LANKA ASSESSED USING MICROSATELLITE* MARKERS
E.M. Lalith Ekanayake, P. Samaraweera, K.B. Ranawana, Thushan Kapurusinghe, M.M. Saman,
A.M.D.S. Rathnakumara, and R.S. Rajakaruna
219.
MORTALITY RATES OF KEMP'S RIDLEY SEA TURTLES IN THE NERITIC WATERS OF THE
UNITED STATES
Sheryan P. Epperly, Selina S. Heppell, Paul M. Richards, Marco Antonio Castro Martínez, Blanca
Monica Zapata Najera, Adriana Laura Sarti Martínez, Luis Jaime Peña, and Donna J. Shaver
219.
CLIMATE CHANGE POTENTIAL EFFECTS OVER SEA TURTLE POPULATION ON FORAGING
GROUNDS: VENEZUELAN GULF, A CASE STUDY
Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez and Héctor Barrios-Garrido
220.
EXPLORING SOUTHERN WATERS: THE PRESENCE OF HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN URUGUAY
Andres Estrades, Gabriela Velez-Rubio, Maria Noel Caraccio, and Alejandro Fallabrino
221.
USING CUSTOM-DESIGNED CAPTURE ARRAYS AND NEXT-GENERATION SEQUENCING FOR
SNP DISCOVERY IN LEATHERBACKS (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA)
Amy Frey, Suzanne Roden, and Peter H. Dutton
221.
CONSERVATION OF SANDY BEACHES: HOW ANTHROPOGENIC AND NATURAL FACTORS
IMPACT SEA TURTLE NESTING ON A REGIONAL SCALE
Ikuko Fujisaki and Meg Lamont
222.
POPULATION TRENDS AND SURVIVORSHIP OF NESTING GREEN SEA TURTLES ON ISLA DE
AVES, VENEZUELA
Marco García Cruz, Margarita Lampo, Claudia Peñaloza, Genaro Sole, and Kathryn RodríguezClark
xxxix
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
223.
GENETIC STOCK STRUCTURE OF HAWKSBILL NESTING POPULATIONS IN THE EASTERN
PACIFIC
Alexander R. Gaos, Rebecca L. Lewison, Michael Liles, Andres Baquero, José Urteaga, Perla Torres,
Aarón Esliman, Ingrid L. Yañez, Amy Frey, Erin LaCasella, and Peter H. Dutton
224.
LAGUNA MADRE RECRUITING CLASS OF 2012
Anthony J. Gillis, Jeff George, and Luis Jaime Pena
224.
BAYESIAN FRAMEWORK TO INTEGRATE TRADITIONAL ECOLOGICAL KNOWLEDGE INTO
ECOLOGICAL MODELING: A CASE STUDY WITH SEASONALITY OF MARINE TURTLES IN
FRENCH GUIANA
Marc Girondot
225.
ADVANCES IN SEA TURTLE PHOTO-IDENTIFICATION. A CASE-STUDY CARRIED OUT AT THE
MARINE BIOLOGICAL RESERVE OF ARVOREDO, BRAZIL
Bruno T. Gonçalves and Nuno S. Loureiro
225.
HISTORICAL AND SEASONAL TRENDS IN GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) CAPTURED
AT SOUTH HUTCHINSON ISLAND, FLORIDA, USA
Jeffrey R. Guertin, Dave R. Clark, Cody R. Mott, Steve Weege, Ryan C. Welsh, Michael J. Bresette,
Jonathan C. Gorham, and Vince Munne
226.
PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF OLIVE RIDLEY TURTLES
Anelise Torres Hahn, Eugenia Naro-Maciel, Michael Jensen, Brian Bowen, Jaqueline Comin de
Castilhos, Alberto Abreu-Grobois, Nancy FitzSimmons, Col Limpus, Scott Whiting, Benoit de Thoisy,
and Sandro L. Bonatto
227.
GENETIC STRUCTURE OF GREEN TURTLES NESTING IN THE NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC
OCEAN*
Tomoko Hamabata, Naoki Kamezaki, , , and Tsutomu Hikida
228.
THE “HUNT” METHOD FOR ASSESSING RELATIVE ABUNDANCE OF SEA TURTLES IN
SHALLOW COASTAL WATERS
Richard Herren, Blair Witherington, Dave Clark, and Cody Mott
229.
ORIGIN OF IMMATURE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) AT TWO FORAGING GROUNDS
IN SABAH, MALAYSIA
Michael P. Jensen, Nancy N. FitzSimmons, and Nicolas Pilcher
229.
GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) GENETIC COMPOSITION AT A FEEDING GROUND AND
ROOKERIES IN THE WEST ATLANTIC: CONNECTIONS BETWEEN POPULATIONS
Juliana C. Jordao, Ana C. V. Bondioli, Benoit de Thoisy, and Lurdes F. Almeida-Toledo
230.
ESTIMATING ABUNDANCE AND CLUTCH FREQUENCY FROM TAGGING DATA ON NESTING
BEACHES: HOW MUCH EFFORT IS ENOUGH?
William L. Kendall and Wendy Lanier
230.
ESTIMATING DEMOGRAPHIC PARAMETERS OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES NESTING IN THE
NORTHERN GULF OF MEXICO
Margaret M. Lamont, Ikuko Fujisaki, and Raymond R. Carthy
xl
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
231.
NEW MICROSATELLITE DNA ANALYSES MAY CONFOUND CURRENT POPULATION MODELS
FOR LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA)
Jake Lasala, Scott Harrison, Mike Frick, Kristina L. Williams, and David C. Rostal
232.
GENETIC ANALYSIS OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE HATCHLINGS FROM THE ALABAMA
COAST
Jenny E. Layton, Jessica Delo, Miranda Goins, Rivvi Kukkamalla, and Thane Wibbels
233.
PHOTO-ID AND SNORKELING TRANSECTS: COMPARING TWO METHODS TO ESTIMATE
GREEN TURTLE ABUNDANCE IN A MAJOR FEEDING GROUND IN THE SOUTHERN EGYPTIAN
RED SEA
Agnese Mancini, Islam El-Sadek, Mahmoud Hanafy, and Bénédicte Madon
234.
BODY SIZE MINIATURIZATION OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES NESTING ON MINABE-SENRI
BEACH, JAPAN
Yoshimasa Matsuzawa and Kiyoshi Goto
234.
PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF ATLANTIC GREEN TURTLES: INSIGHTS FROM MULTIPLE GENETIC
MARKERS
Eugenia Naro-Maciel, Brendan Reid, S. Elizabeth Alter, George Amato, Karen A. Bjorndal, Alan B.
Bolten, Meredith Martin, Campbell J. Nairn, Brian Shamblin, and Oscar Pineda-Catalan
235.
COMBINED GENETIC ANALYSIS AND DISPERSAL MODELLING REVEAL DIVERSE NATAL
ORIGINS OF GREEN TURTLES FORAGING AT THE PALMYRA ATOLL NATIONAL WILDLIFE
REFUGE, CENTRAL PACIFIC
Eugenia Naro-Maciel, Stephen J. Gaughran, Nathan F. Putman, George Amato, Felicity Arengo, Erin
Betley, Peter H. Dutton, and Eleanor Sterling
235.
INTEGRATING DETECTABILITY AND ABUNDANCE IN ASSESSMENTS OF SEA TURTLE
POPULATION TRENDS
Joseph B. Pfaller, Karen A. Bjorndal, Milani Chaloupka, Kristina L. Williams, Michael G. Frick, and
Alan B. Bolten
236.
DEVELOPING QUANTITATIVE TOOLS TO EVALUATE RECOVERY IN GREEN SEA TURTLES,
CHELONIA MYDAS: A RESEARCH PROSPECTUS*
Susan E. Piacenza, George H. Balazs, Stacy Hargrove, Paul M. Richards, and Selina S. Heppell
237.
MIGRATION OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) BETWEEN NESTING AND FEEDING
GROUNDS ACROSS THE CORAL SEA
Tyffen C. Read, Colin J. Limpus, Laurent Wantiez, and Jonathan Werry
237.
GENDER IN A MIXED STOCK GENETIC ANALYSIS OF SUBADULT LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES
Mark A. Roberts, Michael D. Arendt, David W. Owens, and Joseph M. Quattro
238.
GENETIC SIGNATURE OF POPULATION BOTTLENECKS IN THE OLIVE RIDLEY TURTLE
(LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) AFTER COMMERCIAL EXPLOITATION IN MEXICO:
IMPLICATIONS FOR CONSERVATION
Clara J. Rodríguez-Zárate, Axayacatl Rocha-Olivares, and Luciano B. Beheregaray
xli
February 2013 Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Page #
238.
PREDICTED SEX RATIOS OF JUVENILE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ALONG THE
EAST COAST OF FLORIDA, USA
Cheryl Sanchez, Thane Wibbels, Llewellyn Ehrhart, and Michael Bresette
239.
ANNUAL SURVIVAL OF JUVENILE LOGGERHEADS IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC OCEAN
Christopher R. Sasso and Sheryan P. Epperly
239.
CATCH RATES, SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION, AND DEMOGRAPHICS FOR KEMP’S RIDLEY SEA
TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS KEMPII) CAPTURED IN NEARSHORE COASTAL WATERS BETWEEN
WINYAH BAY, SC AND ST. AUGUSTINE, FL (2000-2012)
Jeffrey A. Schwenter, Michael D. Arendt, Albert L. Segars, J. David Whitaker, Lindsey Parker, David
W. Owens, Joseph M. Quattro, and Mark A. Roberts
240.
DEMOGRAPHIC ISOLATION AND COLONIZATION OF SOUTHERN GREATER CARIBBEAN
GREEN TURTLE ROOKERIES WITH AN EMPHASIS ON FEMALES NESTING ON BUCK ISLAND,
UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Brian M. Shamblin, Ian Lundgren, Zandy M. Hillis-Starr, Karen A. Bjorndal, Alan B. Bolten,
Eugenia Naro-Maciel, and Campbell J. Nairn
241.
CLUTCH FREQUENCY AND NUMBER OF NESTING LOGGERHEADS (CARETTA CARETTA) AT
THE ARCHIE CARR NATIONAL WILDLIFE SANCTUARY DURING THE 2010, 2011 AND 2012
SEASONS*
Andrew T. Sterner, Llewellyn M. Ehrhart, William L. Kendall, and Dean A. Bagley
242.
VARIATIONS IN THE OPERATIONAL SEX RATIO FOR BREEDING LEATHERBACK TURTLES
(DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA) OVER THREE NESTING SEASONS AT ST. CROIX, USVI.
Kelly R. Stewart and Peter H. Dutton
243.
ESTIMATES OF LOGGERHEAD CLUTCH FREQUENCY AT MASIRAH, OMAN DERIVED FROM
SATELLITE TRACKING
Anton D. Tucker, Robert Baldwin, Andrew Willson, Ali Al Kiyumi, Barbara Schroeder, Earl
Possardt, and Blair Witherington
244.
IS THE MAJOR FLORIDA LOGGERHEAD ROOKERY IN THE GULF OF MEXICO EXPERIENCING
DECADAL POPULATION OSCILLATIONS?
Anton D. Tucker, Kristen Mazzarrella, Sarah Hirsch, Kathy Klingensmith, Wilma Katz, Zoe Bass,
Carol Leonard, Jerris Foote, George Tatge, Jim Grimes, Howard Berna, Matthew Osterhoudt, Kim
Heuberger, Kenya Leonard, Chance Steed, and Jennifer Rogers
245.
EVIDENCE OF RECOVERY OF THE ARRIBADA OLIVE RIDLEY POPULATION AT NANCITE
BEACH, COSTA RICA
Roldán A. Valverde, Luis G. Fonseca, Carlos M. Orrego, and Wagner Quirós
246.
MIXED STOCK ANALYSIS OF LEATHERBACK TURTLES FEEDING IN BRAZIL: RECORDS OVER
FOUR YEARS
Sarah Vargas, Érica Molfetti, Sibelle Torres Vilaça, Danielle Monteiro, Sérgio C. Estima, Luciano
Soares e Soares, Antônio P. Almeida, Benoit de Thoisy, Eugenia Naro-Maciel, and Fabrício R. Santos
247.
INDIVIDUAL IDENTIFICATION OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) USING THE
PARIETAL AND INTERPARIETAL SCALE PATTERN
Amanda W. Vidal, Suzana M. Guimarães, and Cassiano Monteiro-Neto
xlii
Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation
Page #
Social, Economic and Cultural Studies
247.
FROM SEA TURTLES TO REEFS: COMMUNITY-BASED MARINE CONSERVATION AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH THE COMMUNITY OF FALALOP, ULITHI ATOLL,
FEDERATED STATES OF MICRONESIA
Nicole L. Crane, Jennifer A Cruce, and John Rulmal
248.
STUDYING SEA TURTLE VOLUNTEERS IN NORTH CAROLINA, USA
Matthew H. Godfrey, Lisa M. Campbell, and Nicholas Mallos
249.
PERCEPTION OF FISHING COMMUNITIES ON SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN THREE
NATURAL PROTECTED AREAS SINALOA, MEXICO
Zuleika B. González Camacho, Ingmar Sosa-Cornejo, Jorge Guillermo Sanchez-Zazueta, Fernando
Enciso-Saracho, Marco A. Barraza-Ortega, and Jesus Ivan Guardado-González
249.
PERCEPTIONS, PARTICIPATION AND POACHING: IDENTIFYING THE DRIVERS BEHIND
ILLEGAL SEA TURTLE USE IN COMMUNITIES ADJACENT TO CAHUITA NATIONAL PARK,
COSTA RICA
Katharine A. Hart
250.
U.S. SHRIMP INDUSTRY ADOPTION OF TURTLE EXCLUDER DEVICES (TED)—OVER A
DECADE LATER: CASE STUDIES FROM TED RESEARCH IN GULF OF MEXICO AND U.S. SOUTH
ATLANTIC
Troy W. Hartley and Michel A. Nalovic
251.
KNOWLEDGE OF BEACHGOERS TO THE PRESENCE OF AND THREATS TO SEA TURTLES IN
THE GULF OF MEXICO; RESULTS OF A SURVEY OF VISITORS TO GALVESTON ISLAND,
TEXAS
Sarah E. Horn and Kimberly J. Reich
251.
CONNECTING INTERNATIONAL CONSERVATION PRIORITIES WITH HUMAN WELFARE IN
LOW-INCOME REGIONS: HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN EL SALVADOR
Michael J. Liles, Markus J. Peterson, Yvonna S. Lincoln, Ana V. Henriquez, Jeffrey A. Seminoff,
Alexander R. Gaos, and Tarla R. Peterson
252.
CAMINHO MARINHO EXPEDITION: CONNECTING RESEARCH AND COMMUNITY IN A WAY
WHICH CONSERVES THE SEA TURTLES WITH AN ECOSYSTEM-BASED APPROACH
Gustavo Martinez-Souza, Jefferson Bortolotto, Karine Steigleder, Pedro Renato Gonçalves Filho, and
Paul Gerard Kinas
253.
PRODUCTIVE WORKSHOPS IN COMMUNITIES ASSOCIATED TO SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION
PROJECTS IN THE MEXICAN PACIFIC
Lourdes L. Parra-Lopez and Pablo A. Trujillo-Susunaga
254.
MARINE CHELONIAN ILLUSTRATION: PART VIII – THE RISE AND FALL OF TURTLE SOUP
Rick Schaffer and Chuck Schaffer
255.
Author Index
xliii
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Anatomy, Physiology, Health
STEROIDOGENIC EXPRESSION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS DURING THE
GONADAL DIFFERENTIATION IN THE GREEN SEA TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS ALHADD, OMAN
Issa S. Al-Amri1, I.Y. Mahmoud1, B. Al-Farsi2, S.N. Al-Bahry2, B. Al-Sumri3, M.A. Al-Kindi4, and
S.K. Al-Musharafi5
1
Department of Biological Sciences and Chemistry, University of Nizwa, Nizwa, Oman
Department of Biology, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
3
Department of Histopathology, Sultan Qaboos University Hospital, Muscat, Oman
4
Department of Pathology, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
5
Sur College of Applied Sciences, Sur, Oman
2
Steroidogenesis and progesterone receptors have not been studied in the green turtle. A total of 150 eggs
from green turtles, Chelonia mydas, were collected at random following oviposition from different nests at
Ras Al-Hadd Reserve during June 2010. The eggs were placed in an incubator set at 30oC. Under this high
temperature all hatchlings were females. Eight to ten eggs were examined every 48h for determination of
embryonic differentiation. Prior to day 20, the gonads were undifferentiated. However, between day 20-30
which is called the thermosensitive period (TSP), the undifferentiated gonads developed to primary ovarian
organ. Using immunohistochemistry technique, the progesterone receptors (PRs) were strongly expressed
during this period and throughout the incubation period which is also indicative of steroidogenic activities
such as the appearance of the ulturastructural steroidogenic features. The PRs remained strongly expressed
for the rest of the incubation period. However, prior to day 20, the PRs expressed weakly which indicates
the lack of gonadal differentiation. The appearance of the ovarian follicles in the ovarian stroma is a clear
indication that steroidogenic activity is already in process during the TSP. Results from this study are in
agreement with the detection of progesterone receptors using immunoblotting technique in both female and
male embryos.
HEAVY METALS DETECTION BY X-RAY MICROANALYSIS IN FRESHLY LAID EGGS OF
THE GREEN TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, AT RAS AL-HADD, OMAN
Salma K. Al-Musharafi1, Saif N. Al-Bahry2, Ibrahim Y. Mahmoud3, Issa S. Al Amri3, and Abdulaziz
A. Al-Kindi3
1
Sur College of Applied Sciences, Sur, College of applied Science, Sur, Oman
Department of Biology, College of Science, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
3
Department of Biological Science and Chemistry, University of Nizwa, Oman
2
Freshly laid eggs from the green turtle (Chelonia mydas) were collected at random from different nests
immediately after oviposition at Ras Al-Hadd reserve. Eggshell of the green turtle is made up of three
major porous layers, the loose calcareous layer, the compact middle layer with multistrata and the fibrous
innershell membrane. The layers from each eggshell sample were analyzed separately for the detection of
heavy metal using Oxford energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDS). The heavy metal spectrum xmicroanalysis as well as other elements spectrum of elemental was analyzed. Al, S, Si were the dominant.
The heavy metal percentage weight revealed that S, Si and P were the dominant. The presence of these
heavy metals may have detrimental effect on the health of the embryo during the incubation period.
1
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
THE IDENTIFICATION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS IN THE EMBRYONIC MALE
USING HISTOLOGICAL AND IMMUNOHISTOCHEMICAL TECHNIQUES IN THE GREEN
TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS AL-HADD, OMAN
Abdulaziz Y. Alkindi1, I.S. Al-Amri1, I.Y. Mahmoud1, S.N. Al-Bahry2, S. Al-Yaqoobi2, and B. AlSumri3
1
Department of Biological Sciences and Chemistry, University of Nizwa, Oman
Department of Biology, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
3
Department of Histopathology, Sultan Qaboos University Hospital, Muscat, Oman
2
Immediately after oviposition, 150 eggs were collected at random from different nests of the green turtle,
Chelonia mydas, during June 2011 and were placed in the incubator set at constant temperature (26oC) to
develop embryonic males only. Between day 20 – 30 of incubation, which is known as the thermosensitive
period (TSP), the embryos were examined histologically for the presence of gonadal differentiation. A total
of 8-10 eggs were examined every 48h for the condition of the embryonic differentiation. As a result, all
the embryos examined after day 20 showed gonadal differentiation which consequently differentiated into
testicular tissues. In addition, it was confirmed that the testicular tissues were steroidogentically active
using the immunohistochemistry technique for the presence of progesterone receptors, which strongly
expressed throughout the thermosensitive period. Prior to day 20 the progesterone receptors were weakly
expressed without any steroidogenic activity. In summary, the testicular tissue followed the same pattern of
development as ovarian tissue, even though the incubation period was longer in males (60 days) compare to
females (50 days). The seminefrous tubules of the medulla were fully developed after day 20 in connection
with the strong progesterone receptor expression and the presence of ultrastructural steroidogenic features.
These conditions remained for the rest of the incubation period. Results from this study are in agreement
with the detection of progesterone receptor using immunoblotting technique in both female and male
embryos.
PRELIMINARY RESULTS: OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE EMBRYO MORTALITY AS A
FUNCTION OF THE NEST MICROBIAL COMMUNITY AT OSTIONAL, COSTA RICA
Vanessa S. Bézy1, Roldán A. Valverde2, and Craig J. Plante3
1
Graduate Program in Marine Biology, College of Charleston, Charleston, SC
Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, Louisiana, USA
3
College of Charleston, Charleston, SC
2
The olive ridley sea turtle population at Ostional, Costa Rica exhibits mass nesting events (arribadas)
estimated at up to 500,000 nesting females over a period of only seven days. Despite the large population
of nesting females, concern remains that the low hatching success (8%) at this beach is not enough to
sustain the population long-term. Several studies have suggested that embryo mortality is associated with
the high microbial load resulting from the decomposition of eggs broken by overlapped nesting due to the
high nest densities characteristic of arribada events. Thus, a legalized community-based egg harvest
program is aimed at reducing the number of nests destroyed while providing the funds to support local
infrastructure and family income. However, no previous research has directly quantified microbial
abundance and the associated direct and/or indirect effects on hatching success in situ. This study aims to
determine the impact of microbial abundance on hatching success by monitoring natural nests and applying
experimental treatments to reduce the microbial load of the sand into which nests are relocated. Preliminary
2
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
results show no significant differences in nest temperature or oxygen content across experimental
treatments, yet a marked increase in hatching success was observed in sand treated with a bleach (NaOCl)
solution. Natural nest observations revealed a significant spatial variation in hatching success in association
with significant differences in the organic matter content, temperature, and pO2 of the nest environment.
The mean pO2 of nests in the high nest density area was also significantly lower in the 1st and 2nd half of
incubation (15.43 kPa, p=0.001; 12.27 kPa, p=0.003; respectively), whereas nest temperatures were the
highest and exceeded the lethal limit (35ºC). The oxygen levels and hatch rates observed in natural nests
are drastically lower than those previously observed when isolating nest density alone as a factor affecting
hatch rates. These preliminary results suggest that microbial abundance and other factors associated with
nest destruction at such high nest densities are likely responsible for the low hatching rates observed at
Ostional. Another field season is planned for 2013 and the molecular analysis to quantify the microbial
abundance in nest sand is on-going. Ultimately, treatments that successfully increase hatching success
could be applied as a management technique to improve hatching success at arribada beaches and in
hatcheries experiencing microbial infestations. This study will help identify a relationship between hatching
success and the microbial community of the sand while ensuring the sustainability of the egg harvest as a
conservation strategy. Acknowledgements: Funds to support field research for this study were provided by:
National Geographic Young Explorers Grant (C220-12), USFWS Marine Turtle Conservation Act (962000-G037), and College of Charleston Graduate Research Awards. Funds to support this presentation were
provided by the College of Charleston Graduate School and Graduate Student Association, International
Sea Turtle Society, International Sea Turtle Symposium, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National
Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack,
Telonics and CLS America.
THE MICRONUCLEUS TEST: A RELIABLE TOOL FOR HEALTH SCREENING OF GREEN
TURTLES
Virginia Borrat1, Silvia Villar2, Gustavo Martinez Souza3, and Alejandro Fallabrino4
1
Karumbé & Laboratorio de Microscopía Electrónica de Barrido, Facultad de Ciencias & Sección Genética,
Uruguay
2
Laboratorio de Microscopía Electrónica de Barrido, Facultad de Ciencias & Sección Genética, Uruguay
3
Karumbé & Programa de Pós-Graduação em Oceanografia Biológica, Universidade Federal do Rio
Grande & FURG, Laboratório de Estatística Ambiental, Uruguay
4
Karumbé, Montevideo, Uruguay
The green turtle (Chelonia mydas) is catalogued ¨Endangered¨ in the UICN red list. Uruguay is an
important area of feeding and development of juveniles, which are mainly concentrated in Cerro Verde and
La Coronilla (Dept. de Rocha). Sixty animals were analyzed, the samples were collected at different sites:
Pesquero and Cerro Verde, located in a sandy beach affected by a freshwater discharge (Andreoni Canal)
derived from man-made canals built for agricultural activities. These discharges have been documented as
strong modifiers of sandy beaches, affecting nutrient regimes, habitat features and the resident biota. It has
been observed that individuals sampled at mentioned sites remain for at least one season there. To analyze
the genetic health of the species, we used the micronucleus (MN) test in peripheral blood, following the
rules of the CHEA (Uruguay). The presence of micronuclei at cellular levels indicate a DNA loss, and
proof of micronucleated erythrocytes in peripheral blood provides clear and definitive results, with the
possibility of working in vivo, and requires only a drop of blood. Additionally, a sediment screening for
chemical elements were done for Pesquero, Cerro Verde and the discharge channel, through energy
dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) with a Thermo Scientific probe coupled to a Jeol 5900 LV SEM. The results
indicate the presence of thallium in the channel and Pesquero, which coincides with higher frequencies of
MN, i.e. greater genetic damage. Thallium has been used for decades as a rodenticide (pesticide; organic
metalloid). Currently, its use is prohibited in several countries in Latin America and it was declared a toxic
element by ATSDR (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry of the United States). However, at
3
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
present some substances which are used as fertilizers and soil improvers for agricultural have been
developed and contain thallium, copper, manganese, silicon, nickel, tin, barium and molybdenum (several
such elements are also considered toxic in high concentrations). They are used mainly in potato, sorghum
and rice. The pesticides are often used for the same crop simultaneously, creating an additive genotoxic
effect. It may also occur synergism: the combined effect of two or more chemicals is greater than the sum
of the effects of each separately, or the enhancer; which occurs when an agrochemical does not have
genotoxic effect but in combination with another compound is much more toxic (even genotoxic). The
results show that when the distance is greater from the discharge channel, there is a decrease in the
frequency of micronucleated cells and total MN. Also, individuals kept in captivity for rehabilitation, have
shown a dramatic decrease in the frequency of MN in blood.
THE EFFECTS OF TRACKING DEVICES ON ATLANTIC GREEN (CHELONIA MYDAS) SEA
TURTLE DIVE BEHAVIOR IN RELATION TO CARAPACE SENSITIVITY*
Ashley Chambers, Suzie Marlow, Nina Nahvi, Jeffrey George, and Christopher Devlin
Sea Turtle Inc., South Padre Island, TX USA.
Tracking devices have become increasingly important for insight into aquatic species behavior. The main
behavioral patterns of these species are challenging to study because the behaviors occur while the species
are submerged and out of view. Sea turtle dive behavior has been well investigated in the wild using
tracking devices such as data loggers, satellite-linked transmitters, and animal-borne video. ‘Instrumented’
turtles are studied for the purpose of extrapolating behavior to untagged individuals; therefore, it is crucial
to consider the degree to which results are biased by the effects of tracking device attachment. We
monitored the behavior of a captive Atlantic green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) for 60 days using a
specifically designed ethogram. A neutrally buoyant mock tracking device was constructed of PVC and
small weights. The device was attached to the subject’s carapace via neoprene and epoxy. Observations
occurred before and after mock tracking device attachment to assess behavioral changes due to presence of
the device. Interaction with the current line, which provides outflow of the tank’s filtration system, and
interaction with a PVC enrichment structure were both deemed as behaviors associated with carapace
irritation relief. Three behaviors changed significantly after device attachment: amount of time spent
swimming increased and interaction with the current line and PVC increased as well. The alteration in
behavioral activity may indicate that a tracking device attached to a wild turtle can skew dive data as a
result of behavior changing due to carapace irritation; however, the small sample size and the duration of
this study must be considered as they can both significantly impact results. This project is of considerable
interest to the scientific community in regards to the potential of tracking devices affecting behavior of sea
turtles. Acknowledgments: We would like to thank the following institutions for their continuous support as
well as financial contributions: Sea Turtle Inc. and its staff, volunteers, and interns; Eckerd College; and the
International Sea Turtle Symposium and its chairs as well as the travel grants committee. Additionally,
none of this would have been possible without the five other wonderful, hardworking interns who donated
their time and energy: Lauren Miller, Anthony Gillis, Sharon Lee, Sarah Nevison, and Alexis Bergman.
4
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CLINICAL CONDITION IN OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) IN
GUASAVE, SINALOA, MEXICO
Paula Aguilar Claussell1, Alan Zavala Norzagaray1, Catherine E. Hart2, César Paul Ley Quiñonez3,
and Alonso Aguirre4
1
CIIDIR-IPN, Unidad Sinaloa, Juan de Dios Bátiz Paredes No. 250, Col. San Joachín, C.P. 81101,
Guasave, Sinaloa, México.
2
Red Tortuguera A.C., Tepic, Nayarit, México. Doctorado en Ciencias en Biosistemática, Ecología y
Manejo de Recursos Naturales y Agrícolas (BEMARENA), Centro Universitario de la Costa, Universidad
de Guadalajara, Puerto Vallarta, Jalisco, México.
3
Doctorado Regional en Biotecnología, Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa, Culiacán, Sinaloa, México.
4
Smithsonian-Mason School of Conservation, Front RoyalDepartment of Environmental Science and
Policy, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, USA.
During 2011-2012 ten cases were submitted to the CIIDIR-IPN Sinaloa for rehabilitation. These turtles
were found stranded on nearby beaches with strong signs of disease. All of the turtles were olive ridleys
(Lepidochelys olivacea) and displayed the same clinical condition with few differences - including severe
emaciation and dehydration, low reactivity and no signs of traumatic lesions. One of them presented
carapace lesions with transparent and inodorous fluid. They didn´t respond to any treatment and finally
died. At necropsy they also shared common lesions and evidence of chronic renal infection and subequent
damage. Clinical tests were done in order to determine the cause but we still have not identified the source
of the infection. It’s very important for us to know if any similar conditions have been submitted to another
rehabilitation centers and if they could determine the causes, particularly because olive ridleys are dying
fast and in terrible conditions without a precise identified pathogen, pollutant or toxin that causes this kind
of damage.
NOVEL MICROBIAL POPULATIONS RECOVERED FROM FAILED LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLE NESTS (CARETTA CARETTA) ON JEKYLL ISLAND, GA
K. S. Craven, M. Walker, M. Lamb, S.L. Schwartz, C. Weed, and J. Brofft Bailey
Armstrong Atlantic State University, Savannah, GA, USA
The composition and diversity of microbial populations present in loggerhead sea turtle nests is part of an
ongoing investigation of egg failure. Unhatched eggs are often characterized by the presence of black,
yellow or red areas on the shell or inside the eggs assumed to be associated with bacterial or fungal
invasion of the nest. Loggerhead nests in Georgia have averaged 66% nest success. It is consistent, yet,
lower than the estimated 80% for sea turtle populations worldwide. The goals of this project were to
substantiate anecdotal reports of microbes in sea turtle nests using molecular techniques, investigate and
compare microbial populations in nests found in Georgia and elsewhere, and assess the potential role of
opportunistic pathogens in egg failure. In 2010, unhatched loggerhead eggs were collected from six nests
that had completed incubation on the North, Central and Southern regions of Jekyll Island. Fluid was
collected aseptically and used to extract both DNA and RNA. Thirty eight DNA samples were screened by
PCR using fungal-specific primers (ITS5F and ITS4Rev) that amplify the internal transcribed spacer (ITS)
region. Of the 11 samples of DNA cloned and sequenced, five different genera were detected. However,
77% of the samples had 99-100% identity with Fusarium solani, a microbe suspected of causing embryonic
5
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
mortality in sea turtle nests in the Pacific and Mediterranean. Thirty bacterial groups were detected based
on 395 16S rRNA sequences analyzed. Nine groups were recovered from multiple nests and seven of these
groups were ≥ 99% identical to known or suspected pathogens - including members of Vibrio,
Enterobacter, Pseudomonas, Stenotrophomonas, Hahella, Achromobacter and Klebsiella. The detection of
Hahella chejuensis is of interest since it produces a prodigiosin (red pigment) which inhibits the growth of
certain cell types and has immunosuppressive activity. Forty DNA samples were screened using PCR
primers specific to H. chejuensis, and PCR products were produced from all eggs containing a pink-red
biofilm or fluid. The use of molecular identification and species specific primers and probes have revealed
the first known accounts of Fusarium infection and the presence of Hahella in sea turtle nests in the
southeastern US.
BENEFITS OF A COMPLETE X-RAY EVALUATION TO ASCERTAIN THE POSITION AND
ORIENTATION OF FISHING HOOKS IN INTRACOELOMATIC ESOPHAGUS TISSUES OF
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA)
Antonio Di Bello1, Carmela Valastro1, Daniela Freggi2, Olimpia R. Lai1, Giuseppe Crescenzo1, and
Delia Franchini1
1
2
Department of Veterinary Medicine, Bari University, Valenzano, Italy
WWF Sea Turtle Rescue Centre, Lampedusa (Ag), Italy
Radiographic studies are among the most important diagnostic procedures in the clinical evaluation of sea
turtles. The anatomical structures for which it is possible to obtain an optimal assessment by radiographic
examination are respiratory tract, digestive tract, skeleton, carapace, and plastron. The fundamental and
indispensable projections for a proper radiographic estimation of the body are dorsoventral view, vertical
beam, horizontal beam, lateral view, and craniocaudal view. Radiographs in the dorsal-ventral projection
usually allow achieving the detection of fishhooks in the various sections of the digestive tract. In fact,
hooks are poorly detectable in other projections due to the intense radiopacity determined by the
superimposition of other anatomical structures, and to the inability to set the radiographic cassette in strict
contact with the body of the animal. On the contrary, when the hooks are stacked in the esophagus wall,
especially in the intracoelomatic tract, images in the dorsoventral beam do not allow to ascertain if the tip
or the hook barbs are dangerously close to airways (trachea and bronchi) or great vessels (brachycephalic
trunk). Without this information, the surgeon risks to cause irreparable injuries during the removal of the
hook. On the other hand, a complete radiographic study in two orthogonal projections is invaluable to
correctly assess position and orientation of the hook to properly schedule the surgery. The present study
included 21 loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) referred to the Department of Veterinary Medicine of
Bari University (Italy), which showed drifting longlines hooks located in the caudal cervical or
intracoelomatic esophagus subsequently to a first radiographic evaluation in dorsoventral beam. The other
radiographic projections were obtained in horizontal beam lateral view, with turtles set on a radiolucent
support (plastic box) with the surface of the radiographic cassette adherent to the lateral margin of the
bridge. In order to reduce the overlap of soft tissues of the pectoral girdle, the front flippers were forward
stretched below the neck, and temporarily wrapped together with self-adhesive elastic bandage. X-ray
images were obtained with a digital acquisition system, which allowed improving contrast and brightness
of images by graphic processing. The opportunity to evaluate different radiograms obtained in two
orthogonal projections has allowed to precisely locate the position of hook, shank and bend with respect to
the horizontal midsagittal plane of the animal, the orientation of the tip (cranially, caudally or laterally), and
above all the closeness to vital anatomical structures. These significant assessments have allowed choosing
the most appropriate surgical approaches, and to avoid dangerous intraoperative maneuvers during removal
of hooks.
6
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EPIBIONTS OF NESTING FEMALE OLIVE RIDLEYS, LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA, IN
PLAYON DE MISMALOYA, JALISCO, MÉXICO
Ildefonso Enciso1, Julia Cisneros1, Fredy C. Gastelum1, and Francisco J. Jacobo2
1
Universidad de Guadalajara. Centro Universitario de Ciencias Biológicas y Agropecuarias. Departamento
de Ecología.
2
Universidad de Guadalajara. Centro Universitario de Ciencias Biológicas y Agropecuarias. Departamento
de Ciencias Ambientales.
The presence of epibionts on marine turtles has been used for different purposes, such as biogeographic
indicators, migration routes and movements of pelagic life stages. With the goal to know the richness and
species distribution of epibionts, specimens were collected from 163 female L. olivacea from a total of 178
turtles observed nesting in the Playon de Mismaloya, Jalisco, representing 91.5% of the total sample. The
study period was in 2004, 2006 and 2007 during the months of July to December. The epibionts were
collected directly from the soft parts (neck and flippers) and the hard parts (carapace) of the turtle, and were
preserved in 70% alcohol. The total of epibionts collected was 2,567, corresponding to 10 species, the most
abundant was the ruby-eyed amphipod, Podocerus chelonophilus.
PERCEPTION OF DIMETHYL SULFIDE (DMS) BY LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES: A
POSSIBLE CUE FOR LOCATING FORAGING AREAS
Courtney S. Endres and Kenneth J. Lohmann
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
During their long-distance migrations, sea turtles of several species feed on jellyfish and other invertebrates
that are particularly abundant in ocean regions characterized by high productivity. An ability to distinguish
productive oceanic regions from other areas, and to concentrate foraging activities in locations where prey
density is highest, might therefore be adaptive. The volatile compound dimethyl sulfide (DMS) is released
by phytoplankton and accumulates in the air above productive ocean areas such as upwelling and frontal
zones. In principle, DMS might therefore serve as an indicator of a good foraging area for turtles. To
determine whether turtles perceive DMS, juvenile loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) were placed into a
water-filled arena in which DMS and other odorants could be introduced to air above the water surface.
Turtles exposed to air that had passed over a cup containing 10 nM DMS spent more time at the surface
with their noses out of the water than did control turtles exposed to air that had passed over a cup
containing distilled water. Odors that do not occur in the sea (cinnamon, jasmine, and lemon) did not elicit
increased surface time, implying that the response to DMS is unlikely to reflect a generalized response to
any novel odor. The results demonstrate for the first time that sea turtles can detect DMS, an ability that
might enable turtles to identify favorable foraging areas.
7
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
THE GENTLE TREATMENT OF SEA TURTLE LESIONS BY HYPERMIX, A NEW
BOTANICAL PRODUCT FROM ITALY
Daniela Freggi1 and Antonio di Bello2
1
2
Lampedusa Sea Turtle Rescue Centre, WWF, Italy
Bari University, Dept. of Veterinary Medicine, Italy
We tested a new botanical medicine produced in Italy on 10 sea turtle lesions - monitoring the wound
healing, and comparing the results with previous procedures. Turtle lesions have healed in a shorter time
and with the use of fewer antibiotics.
FIBROPAPILLOMAS IN GREEN TURTLES ALONG THE COAST OF THE CONGOBRAZZAVILLE. SEVEN YEARS OF OBSERVATIONS GIVE AN INSIGHT INTO A RISING
ISSUE IN CENTRAL AFRICA
Alexandre Girard1, Hélène NDembé2, and Nathalie Bréheret2
1
2
Rénatura France, Paris, France
Rénatura Congo, Pointe Noire, Congo
The first observation of tumors consistent with fibropapillomas in Congo occurred in Nov 2005 on a
juvenile green turtle incidentally captured in traditional fishing nets in the Loango bay. Existence of
cutaneous fibropapillomas (FP) in sea turtles was known as early as 1938. Since then it has emerged, from
the 1980’s as a significant worldwide epizootic, mainly in Green turtles. The main and best known
epizootic took place in Hawaii. A long-term follow up of the cancer has also been implemented in Florida.
The disease has been described all around the world: in the Caribbean, Brazil, Atlantic coast of Costa Rica,
California, Pacific Coast of Mexico, Australia and India. The report of the disease on the west coast of
Africa (Eastern Atlantic) is more recent. The disease was diagnosed and histologically characterized in
green sea turtles at Corisco bay, in the Gulf of Guinea, on the border between Equatorial Guinea and Gabon.
Data collected over seven years (1998 – 2006) on the green turtle population of Corisco Bay reveal a 17%
prevalence of probable fibropapillomatosis in captured turtles. It was then observed in Mayumba National
Park in the South of Gabon just north to the Congo coast. In 2009 the disease was also described in green
turtles in Principe Island. From 2005 to 2012 in Congo, the Renatura NGO has implemented a programme
designed to release turtles incidentally caught in traditional fishing nets. The Sea Turtle Release
Programme allowed for more than 10,000 observations of green turtles to be made. Observation took place
mainly at The “Pointe Indienne” and in the Loango Bay which is an important feeding ground for green
turtles and hawksbill turtles located 40km north to Pointe Noire. The study of the recapture events shows
that the FP frequency in green turtles rises from 2005 to reach 15% on 2009. It decreases afterward and it is
around 8% in 2012. Thanks to a generalized linear model, we studied the factors that influence the
occurrence and gravity of FP such as the month of observation (seasonality), the year of observation (trend),
curved carapace lengths and maturity status of individuals, the presence of concomitant lesions or parasites,
previous Monel tagging and time since tagging, number of observation on the capture site and time spent
since the first observation on the capture site. The influence of FP on growth was also assessed in
comparing the growth curve in healthy turtles and affected turtles.
8
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SERUM BIOCHEMISTRY PROFILE FOR NESTING HAWKSBILLS (ERETMOCHELYS
IMBRICATA) IN RIO GRANDE DO NORTE, BRAZIL*
Daphne Wrobel Goldberg1,2, Santiago Alonso Tobar Leitão1, Armando José Barsante Santos3,
Gustave Gilles Lopez4, Jayme da Cunha Bastos1, and Vera Lúcia Freire da Cunha Bastos1
1
Departamento de Bioquímica, Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Av. 28 de setembro, 87 Fds, 4º
Andar, Vila Isabel, Rio de janeiro, RJ, CEP: 20551-030, Brazil.
2
Fundação Pro-Tamar, Caixa Postal 5098, Florianópolis, SC, 88040-970, Florianópolis, Santa Catarina,
Brazil.
3
Fundação Pro-Tamar, Caixa Postal 50, Fernando de Noronha, PE, 53990-000 Brazil.
4
Fundação Pró-Tamar, Caixa Postal 2219, Rio Vermelho, Salvador, BA, 41950-970, Brazil.
Forty one nesting females of Eretmochelys imbricata were sampled from Barreira do Inferno and Pipa,
located in the State of Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil, from January to March 2011 and from January to
March 2012 respectively. Blood samples (10 ml) were withdrawn from the dorsal cervical sinus into tubes
without anticoagulant. The triglycerides (1033 mg/dl ± 202) and cholesterol concentrations (287 mg/dl ±
42) were significantly higher than in literature. Both are likely to be raised in nesting females due to
vitellogenesis. The average values for total protein were 5.45 g/dl ± 0.63 and 2.11g/dl ± 0.43 for albumin.
Serum protein levels are often elevated during the reproductive season due to vitellogenesis, which requires
increased protein synthesis. Additionally, elevated albumin may be associated with increased demand for
egg production. On the other hand, urea values (20.6 mg/dl ± 4.2) were slightly lower than those reported
for adult individuals of Caretta caretta, Chelonia mydas, Eretmochelys imbricata and Lepidochelys kempii,
outside reproductive period. Mean uric acid values (0.95 mg/dl ± 0.17) were slightly higher than those
reported for nesting leatherbacks. Even higher values were found in juvenile green turtles (1.5 mg/dl ± 0.6)
probably because young C. mydas are primarily carnivores and according to literature, carnivorous reptiles
have higher uric acid blood levels. Moreover, uric acid levels are expected to be higher in foraging sea
turtles, as the animals feed daily. The mean calcium (11.6 mg/dl ± 0.25) and phosphorus (11.3 mg/dl ± 1.4)
values were similar to those reported for reproductively active leatherbacks. Both minerals are likely to be
elevated in nesting sea turtles due to vitellogenesis and egg production. The mean sodium (139.6 mEq/l ±
3.5), and potassium levels (5.09 mEq/l ± 0.76) were also similar to reports for nesting sea turtles. The
average values for Alanine aminotransferase (ALT) reported here fall within the range found for nesting
leatherbacks and loggerheads. The Aspartate aminotransferase (AST) activity (55.4 U/l ± 17.1) was low
when compared to other studies. Although little is known about the tissue distribution of AST in sea turtles,
AST concentrations are not considered to be organ-specific in reptiles. Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity
(15.9 U/l ± 3.7) was similar to that suggested for adult sea turtles. Furthermore, ALP is associated with
increased osteoblastic activity. Thus, it is probable that animals in development stage show higher
enzymatic levels, since osteoblasts are responsible for bone matrix synthesis. The serum Gamma-glutamyl
transferase (GGT) activity (10.8 U/l ± 2.4) was similar to literature, although GGT is not a parameter
frequently used to evaluate sea turtles health conditions, since it is normally low. Biochemical intervals
reported here represent normal parameters for nesting hawksbills. However, there is still little published
information regarding hawksbills biochemical profiles and further studies are urgently required. To our
knowledge, this is the first study to report on biochemical reference intervals for nesting hawksbills in the
southeastern Atlantic Ocean.
9
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PRELIMINARY STUDY OF ORGANIC AND INORGANIC POLLUTANTS IN MARINE
TURTLES FROM MAURITANIA (WEST AFRICA)
Feitoumatt Lematt Hama1, Christelle Dyc2, and Jacques Fretey3
1
Faculté des Sciences, Université Abdel Malek Essaadi, BP 2121, Tétouan, Maroc
Laboratory of Oceanology, University of Liège B6c, Allée de la Chimie, 4000 Liège (Sart-Tilman),
Belgium
3
Chélonée, Centre de conservation des tortues marines, Mas du Ringué, 46260 Beauregard, France
2
Mauritania is an arid country of West Africa bordered by an almost straight 754 km-lengh beach along its
Atlantic seashore. The entire coastline is scarcely inhabited by humans except for a few villages and
fisherman’s camps, as for the two larger urban zone: Nouakchott (the capital) and Nouadhibou) of which
the population is estimated close to one million inhabitants. Sporadic and scattered Chelonia mydas and
Caretta caretta nests have been observed along the border between Senegal and the Baie du Lévrier.
Between Nouakchott and Nouadhibou, the National Park of Banc d’Arguin is of particular and important
conservation concern since its classification by IUCN as one of the main feeding areas of Chelonia mydas
in the world. The important fishery activities in the Mauritanian waters pose a significant threat to
immature and adult marine turtles which are trapped in artisanal and industrial fishing nets. As a
consequence, a lot of individuals become stranded along the coast. Incidentally, the poor facilities setting
up for treating the urban wastes (e.g. domestic, agricultural and industrial wastes), especially in Nouakchott
and Nouadhibou, and offshore waste produced by oil platforms contribute to increase the existing marine
pollution. By June 2012, 62 dead stranded marine turtles were observed on a stretch of coastline of about
200 km and, included 59 greens (51 immature and 8 adult individuals), 2 loggerheads and 1 leatherback
turtle. Ten fresh turtles were necropsied and tissues were collected (i.e. pectoral muscles, liver, kidneys and
fat) as well as the stomach content. Samples were kept frozen (-20°C) in Nouakchott until analysis for
organic and inorganic pollutants (Laboratory of Oceanology, ULg, Belgium), by one of us. The aim of the
present study is to determine the pollutant pattern of marine turtles inhabiting the Mauritanian coasts, both
on their nesting and feeding ground. Furthermore, opportunities for discussion should be given for both
marine turtle and environmental conservation guidelines.
SEDATION AND ANESTHESIA OF HATCHLING LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES
Craig A. Harms1, Wendy Dow Piniak2, Scott A. Eckert3, and Elizabeth M. Stringer4
1
College of Veterinary Medicine and Center for Marine Sciences and Technology, North Carolina State
University, Morehead City, North Carolina, USA
2
Duke University Marine Laboratory, Beaufort, North Carolina, USA, and Wider Caribbean Sea Turtle
Conservation Network, Ballwin, Missouri, USA
3
Wider Caribbean Sea Turtle Conservation Network, Ballwin, Missouri, USA, and Principia College,
Elsah, Illinois, USA
4
Denver Zoo, Denver, Colorado, USA
Sedation or anesthesia of hatchling leatherback sea turtles was employed to acquire auditory evoked
potential (AEP) measurements in air and in water to assess their hearing sensitivity in relation to potential
consequences from anthropogenic noise. Although hatchling hard-shelled sea turtles are amenable to light
physical restraint for AEP measurements, leatherback hatchlings proved refractory to physical restraint
alone, with myogenic artifact masking AEP signals. To reduce artifacts caused by muscle movement, we
10
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
sedated hatchlings with midazolam 2 or 3 mg/kg IV for in-air (n = 7) or in-water (n = 11) AEP
measurements, and anesthetized hatchlings (n = 5) with ketamine 6 mg/kg and dexmedetomidine 30 µg/kg
IV reversed with atipamezole 300 µg/kg half IM and half IV for in-air AEP measurements. Midazolamsedated turtles were also physically restrained with a light elastic wrap. For in-water AEP measurements,
sedated turtles were submerged 14 cm and brought to the surface every 45 – 60 seconds, or whenever they
showed intention signs for breathing, and not submerged again until they took a breath. Underwater tests
did not exceed 60 min. Time to effect, time to full recovery, heart rates, respiratory rates, post-procedure
venous blood gasses (pH, pCO2, pO2, HCO3-, lactate), number of movements disturbing AEP
measurements (in-air only), and subjective quality of release were recorded. Heart rate and blood gases
were measured from an additional six hatchlings after nest emergence to compare with sedated and
anesthetized turtles. Both sedation with midazolam and anesthesia with ketamine-dexmedetomidine were
successful for allowing AEP measurements in hatchling leatherback sea turtles. Disruptive movements
were less frequent with anesthesia than with sedation in the in-air group. Post-procedure temperaturecorrected venous blood pH, pCO2, pO2, and HCO3- did not differ among groups, although for the
midazolam-sedated in-water group, pCO2 trended lower and pO2 varied most widely, and in the ketaminedexmedetomidine anesthetized group there was one turtle considered clinically acidotic (temperaturecorrected pH = 7.117). Venous blood lactate was greater for hatchlings recently emerged from the nest than
for turtles sedated with midazolam in air, with the other two groups falling intermediate between but not
differing significantly from the high and low lactate groups. All releases of hatchlings to the ocean were
scored as good, except for one fair on one poor release out of 11 in the midazolam-sedated in-water group.
Use of midazolam for sedating red-eared sliders (Trachemys scripta elegans) and snapping turtles
(Chelydra serpentaria) has previously been described, but reports in sea turtles are lacking. Full anesthesia
for in-water AEP measurements, as has been reported for larger juvenile green turtles, was not pursued for
leatherback hatchlings because the small glottis and trachea posed physical limitations on protecting the
airway adequately with an endotracheal tube while submerged. Sedation allowed the turtle to protect its
airway voluntarily while limiting flipper movement. Midazolam or ketamine-dexmedetomidine (and
reversal with atipamezole) would be useful for other procedures requiring minor or major restraint in
leatherback sea turtle hatchlings and other sea turtles, although variable susceptibilities may require dosage
adjustments.
VALIDATION OF ULTRASONOGRAPHY AS A NONINVASIVE DIAGNOSTIC TOOL TO
MEASURE SUBCUTANEOUS FAT DEPTH IN LEATHERBACK TURTLES
Heather Harris1, Scott Benson2, Michael James3, Kelly Martin4, Brian Stacy5, Charles Innis6, Julie
Cavin6, Pierre-Yves Daoust7, Paul Rist7, Thierry Work8, George Balazs9, and Jeffrey Seminoff10
1
NOAA Southwest Fisheries Science Center (contract veterinarian), Morro Bay, California, USA
NOAA Southwest Fisheries Science Center, Moss Landing, California, USA
3
Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
4
Loggerhead Marinelife Center, Juno Beach, Florida, USA
5
NOAA/University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
6
New England Aquarium, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
7
Atlantic Veterinary College, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, Canada
8
USGS National Wildlife Health Center, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
9
NOAA Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
10
NOAA Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, California, USA
2
Leatherback turtles undergo substantial cyclical changes in body condition between foraging and nesting
grounds caused by periods of intensive foraging followed by prolonged fasting during migration and
reproduction. These anatomical changes are characterized by alterations in body mass and morphometric
measurements, prominence of dorsal carapacial ridges, and thickness at the base of the head and
appendages. Ultrasonography has been used to measure subcutaneous fat depth to quantify body condition
11
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
in a variety of domestic and wild animal species, but has not been reported for use in any sea turtle species.
To assess the efficacy of this technique for leatherback turtles, a total of 21 turtles were sampled, including
foraging adults from central California (n = 4), Massachusetts (n = 1), and Nova Scotia (n = 5); nesting
adult females from Florida (n = 8); and immature turtles from the Pacific Islands region (n = 3). Ultrasound
images were obtained from four anatomical sites: dorsal shoulder, dorsal neck, lateral neck, and hind end.
Ultrasound sites were chosen based upon previously identified regions of fat deposition, accessibility of the
site for turtles on a nesting beach and on a capture boat, and ability of the ultrasound signal to penetrate the
tissue. A SonositeVet 180 Plus portable ultrasound machine with curvilinear transducer was used to
determine tissue boundaries of the epidermis, dermis, subcutaneous fat, and muscle. The thickness of each
tissue layer was recorded with the machine’s internal calipers. Rigid landmarks were used as reference
points and multiple measurements were obtained from the same site to facilitate comparison within and
between individuals. The dorsal shoulder region was identified as the best site for differentiation of tissues
and appeared to be less affected by position or movement of the body as compared with the neck and hind
end. Imaging through the carapace was not possible due to the tight matrix of dermal ossicles which
reflected the ultrasound signal. Ultrasound measurements of subcutaneous fat depth were validated and
confirmed histologically in a subset of turtles by directly measuring the fat layer at necropsy in dead turtles
(n = 8) and with surgical fat biopsy of live turtles (n = 2). Potential issues causing variability with this
method include operator-applied pressure of the transducer, position of the front flipper in flexion or
extension, gelatinous consistency of the fat reducing accuracy of direct measurements, and degree of tissue
autolysis and freeze-thaw artifact in dead animals. Ultrasound can be used to rapidly assess body condition
during nesting and in-water capture operations without requiring manual restraint or disrupting normal
nesting behavior. Quantitative assessment of body condition may provide valuable data that can be used in
conjunction with other health parameters to facilitate global health comparisons between increasing and
declining leatherback turtle populations, and may have applications for other sea turtle species.
SURGERY, REHABILITATION AND RELEASE OF A JUVENILE HAWKSBILL RESCUED
FROM A LONGLINE IN THE BAHIA DE JALTEMBA, NAYARIT, MEXICO
Catherine E. Hart1, Alan A. Zavala-Norzagaray2, Cesar P. Ley-Quñonez3, Paula Aguilar-Claussell2,
and Alonso A. Aguirre4
1
Doctorado en Ciencias en Biosistemática, Ecología y Manejo de Recursos Naturales y Agrícolas
(BEMARENA), Centro Universitario de la Costa, Universidad de Guadalajara, Puerto Vallarta, Jalisco,
Mexico.
2
CIIDIR-IPN, Unidad Sinaloa, Juan de Dios Bátiz Paredes No. 250, Col. San Joachin, C.P. 81101,
Guasave, Sinaloa, México.
3
Doctorado Regional en Biotecnología, Universidad Autonoma de Sinaloa, Culiacan, Sinaloa, Mexico.
4
Smithsonian-Mason School of Conservation , Front Royal, Virginia, USA.
We report the treatment, surgery and satellite tracked release of a juvenile East Pacific hawksbill turtle
(Eretmochelys imbricata) that was given to our research group after being cut from a longline by divers in
the Bahia de Jaltemba, Nayarit, Mexico. The turtle was transported to the wildlife department of the
CIIDIR-IPN in Sinaloa for treatment. Radiography was used to gather information on the position and size
of the hook. The hook measuring 3cm was found lodged in the esophagus. The removal of the hook was
complicated due to its relatively large size compared to that of the turtle (SCL: 40cm; SCW: 31cm; 5 kgs).
The hook was successfully removed by making an 5mm incision through the tissue on the neck through
which the point of the hook was cut allowing the subsequent removal of the shank through the mouth. After
38days to recuperate at the research center we returned the turtle named “Jaltemba” to the bay where she
had been caught. Jaltemba is the first sea turtle to be satellite tracked in the state of Nayarit which resulted
in the turtles release being attended by hundreds of people from the community, press (local and national)
and government officials raising awareness of sea turtle bycatch and EP hawksbill turtles in the Mexican
Pacific.
12
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
A PRELIMINARY SCREENING OF PERSISTENT ORGANIC POLLUTANT
CONCENTRATIONS IN HAWAIIAN GREEN TURTLE PLASMA IN RELATION TO
FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS
Jennifer M. Keller1, George H. Balazs2, Brenda A. Jensen3, Frances Nilsen3, Marc R. Rice4, and
Thierry M. Work5
1
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Charleston, South Carolina, USA
NOAA, Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
3
Hawaii Pacific University, Kaneohe, Hawaii, USA
4
Hawaii Preparatory Academy, Kamuela, Hawaii, USA
5
USGS, National Wildlife Health Center, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
2
Fibropapillomatosis (FP) prevalence in green turtles (Chelonia mydas) has varied through time and space in
Hawaii but appears to be declining island-wide for unknown reasons. Because of this variation and
immunosuppressive qualities of contaminants, scientists have hypothesized that pollutants may contribute
to this disease. To address this, in 2011, we screened 12 Hawaiian green turtle plasma samples for
concentrations of 164 persistent organic pollutants (POPs). Four groups of turtles were examined: freeranging turtles from Kiholo Bay (0% FP), Kailua Bay (low to moderate FP 0-10%), and Kapoho Bay
(higher FP >10%) and severely tumored stranded turtles that required euthanasia. Samples were archived
by the Biological and Environmental Monitoring and Archival of Sea Turtle Tissues (BEMAST) project at
the National Institute of Standards and Technology Marine Environmental Specimen Bank. Three samples
from each group were selected for POP screening. Only seven of 84 polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs 99,
118, 138, 153+132, and 180+193), one of 19 organochlorine pesticides, one of 36 brominated flame
retardants, three of 16 hydroxylated/methoxylated polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) or polybrominated
diphenylethers (PBDEs), and two of nine halogenated phenols were detected with all other compounds
below the limit of detection. Medians (n = 12) were 66.7 pg/g total PCBs, 2.63 pg/g 4,4’-DDE, 14.6 pg/g
PBDE 99, 8.05 pg/g 4OH-PCB 187, 275 pg/g 6OH-PBDE 47, 127 pg/g 6OH-PBDE 99, 352 pg/g 2,4,6tribromophenol, and 149 pg/g pentachlorophenol. For comparison, PCB levels in Hawaiian turtles are
approximately one order of magnitude lower than green turtles examined elsewhere and two orders of
magnitude lower than loggerhead turtles from the southeastern U.S. coast. The presence of hydroxylated
and phenolic compounds is a novel discovery for sea turtles. These compounds originate from liver
metabolism of parent pollutants (e.g., OH-PCBs) or are naturally synthesized by marine organisms like
algae or sponges (e.g., OH-PBDEs and 2,4,6-tribromophenol). Their presence at concentrations higher than
total PCBs leads to interesting questions about their origins and toxicity, particularly because hydroxylated
PCBs/PBDEs can be more toxic than the parent contaminant. Significant differences were detected among
the four groups for total PCBs (p = 0.0102; stranded>Kiholo>Kailua>Kapoho). Stranded turtles also had
the highest concentrations of 4,4’-DDE and PBDE 99 probably because of weight loss resulting in a release
of POPs from fat stores thus elevating the blood concentrations. Even though POPs probably did not play a
role in the genesis of tumors, the higher circulating levels after weight loss could exacerbate their poor
health status. Significant differences were also detected for 6OH-PBDE 99 (p = 0.0037), in which Kiholo,
the FP-free site, was the only site with detectable concentrations. Kiholo turtles also had the highest
concentrations of 6OH-PBDE 47, and Kailua turtles had the highest levels of 4OH-PCB 187, 2,4,6tribromophenol, and pentachlorophenol. These findings provide some of the first baseline data for POP
exposure in Hawaiian sea turtles and suggest that these 164 POPs are not contributors of FP. Future
analysis of additional samples is expected to provide more statistical power to better answer this question.
13
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IS POLYCYTHEMIA AN ADAPTATION TO HIGH CO2 INCUBATION CONCENTRATIONS BY
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE EMBRYOS?
Robyn E. Lee1 and Mario J. Mota2
1
2
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
National University, La Jolla, California, USA
Loggerhead sea turtles lay their eggs approximately 30-45 cm deep and clutch incubation is dependent on
several intrinsic factors such as sand quality, temperature, moisture and compaction. Beach erosion has led
to beach restoration projects that create anthropogenic shorelines that may or may not be conducive to egg
incubation. Previous research has shown that nourished beaches with high sand compaction restrict the
diffusion of oxygen and carbon dioxide gases between the egg clutch and beach surface. Depending on
individual sand properties and nest location along the planform, high sand compaction can increase
embryonic mortality. However, in some situations, embryonic development proceeds and hatchlings
emerge successfully. This paradox leads to questioning if polycythemia could be an adaptation used by
loggerhead embryos to survive higher carbon dioxide (and lower oxygen) concentrations during incubation.
The experimental design consisted of two incubator conditions of high and low sand compaction. Each
incubator had 40 randomized eggs and each treatment had four replicates, plus in situ control nests.
Concentrations of carbon dioxide and oxygen were measured continuously throughout incubation. After
emergence, hatchlings were weighed, measured (straight carapace length, straight carapace width, body
depth), and a sample of 10 hatchlings/incubator had blood drawn from the dorsal cervical sinus. Blood was
used to make smears that were stained with Wright’s solution. Erythrocytes (rbc) were counted using a
light microscope under oil immersion and averaged for each experimental treatment. Data show that
clutches incubated in higher sand compaction had restricted gas diffusion rates and its embryos were
exposed to higher concentrations of carbon dioxide and lower oxygen. Conversely, clutches in lower sand
compaction had opposite gas concentrations and were similar to in situ nests. Hatchlings from high carbon
dioxide nests had higher RBC counts when compared to those from the opposite incubation treatment.
However, these values were not statistically significant so we cannot state that polycythemia is a survival
adaption used by sea turtle embryos under similar incubation conditions. Another possible explanation for
the high hatching success of some clutches exposed to high carbon dioxide and low oxygen is the effect
that carbon dioxide can have on the oxygen affinity of hemoglobin. As the amount of blood carbon dioxide
increases, more H+ are formed and blood pH decreases. This changes the percentage of oxygen saturation
of hemoglobin (Bohr Effect), causing it to deliver more oxygen to tissues. It appears that loggerhead sea
turtle embryos evolved different physiological adaptations to incubation conditions of high carbon dioxide
and low oxygen concentrations, such as those created when beach sand compaction is very high. Whether
through polycythemia, the Bohr Effect, or both, sea turtle embryos can develop under these compromised
incubation conditions. However, physiological constraints exist which limit the ability to adapt to these
incubation environments. Besides lowering the hatching success, high incubation concentrations of carbon
dioxide also lower hatchling physical characteristics and vigor, which decrease survivorship. Therefore, we
recommend that when designing a beach restoration project, that sand compaction be a key factor to
determine the successful incubation of sea turtle clutches.
14
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EMBRYONIC GONADAL DIFFERENTIATION OF PROGESTERONE RECEPTORS IN THE
GREEN TURTLE, CHELONIA MYDAS, RAS AL-HADD, OMAN.
Ibrahim Y. Mahmoud1, M. Alawi2, M.W. Yaish2, and S.N. Al-Bahry2
1
2
Department of Biological Sciences and Chemistry, University of Nizwa, Oman
Department of Biology, College of Science, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
Steroidogenesis and the expression of the progesterone receptor (PR) is not well established during the
embryogenesis in the sea turtles. A total of 170 freshly laid green turtle (Chelonia mydas) eggs were
collected at random during June 2010 at Ras Al-Hadd Reserve, from different nests immediately after
oviposition. Shortly after, the eggs were placed in an incubator set at 30oC to produce 100% females. Eight
to ten eggs were dissected every 48h and the embryos were immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen. Prior to
day 20, the gonads were undifferentiated but became differentiated between day 20-30 which is known as
the thermosensitive period (TSP). The undifferentiated gonads gave rise to primary ovarian organ. To
detect progesterone receptors, soluble proteins were extracted and the concentrations were determined
using nanodrop. Then the proteins were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis (SDSPAGE) and were detected by commassie blue staining technique. Progesterone receptors were then
specifically detected using western immunoblotting technique. Rabbit polyclonal to PR was used as a
primary antibody and alkaline phosphatase conjugated mouse IgG was used as a secondary antibody.
Progesterone receptors were present during the TSP which is an indicative of steroidogenesis. However,
these receptors were not present prior to day 20. These progesterone receptors remained stable for the rest
of the incubation period. The initiation of gonadal differentiation occurred almost 1/3 of the incubation
period. Results from this study are in agreement with the immunohistological studies of progesterone
receptor expression in both female and male embryos.
SCALING OF BITE PERFORMANCE WITH HEAD AND CARAPACE MORPHOMETRICS IN
GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS)
Christopher D. Marshall1, John Wang2, Axa Rocha3, Carlos Godinez4, Shara Fisler5, Tomoko
Narazaki6, and Katsufumi Sato7
1
Texas A&M University, Galveston, TX, USA
Joint Institute of Marine and Atmospheric Research, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI, USA
3
Centro de Investigación Científica y de Educación Superior de Ensenda, Ensenada, MX
4
Comisíon Nacional de Áreas Naturales Protegida, MX
5
Ocean Discovery Institute, San Diego, CA, USA
6
International Coastal Research Center, Atmosphere and Ocean Research Institute, The University of
Tokyo, Kashiwa, Chiba Prefecture, Japan
7
International Coastal Research Center, Atmosphere and Ocean Research Institute, The University of
Tokyo, Kashiwa, Japan
2
Traditionally, adult green sea turtles (Chelonia mydas) are characterized as predominately herbivorous.
However, data from the pacific demonstrates that green turtles consume a more varied and omnivorous diet
comprised of sea grasses, algae, and animal matter. For example, green turtles off the Baja Coast of Mexico
occasionally target red crabs. Also, there is evidence that green turtles in this region consume more animal
matter in deeper water and more plant matter in shallower water. The ability to mix diets from a variety of
habitats should be reflected in adaptations of the feeding apparatus. Recent data in loggerhead turtles
15
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
(Caretta caretta) demonstrate that bite force is correlated with head morphometrics and that the ontogeny
of bite force has implications for foraging ecology. Therefore, the objective of this study was to correlate
bite force data with head and carapace morphometrics from adult green sea turtles. We predicted that
maximum bite force in green sea turtles would be less in magnitude than loggerheads, but still forceful
enough to break vegetation, which is a tough material. In light of the omnivorous diet of some green turtles,
a high bite force would also be advantageous for consuming animal matter. In addition, we predicted that
bite force would be positively correlated with head width since an increase in the cross-sectional area of the
adductor mandibulae (as reflected by head width) should increase bite force. Therefore, mass, straight
carapace length, straight carapace with, greatest head width, height, and length, were collected along with
bite force from free-ranging green sea turtles (N=73) from Punta Abreojos, Baja California Sur, Mexico
and from several adult green sea turtles from Otsuchi, Japan. Subjects ranged from 13.6 to 147 kg, with a
mean straight carapace length and width of 56.6 cm (S.D. ±12.5) and 45.2 ±7.6, respectively. A bite force
apparatus that incorporated a piezoelectric force transducer, with bite plates customized for sea turtles, was
used to collect bite force data at the rostral most tips of the jaws from subjects. The maximum bite force
measured was 303 N. Mean HW, HH, and HL were 8.9 cm (± 1.8), 9.0 (± 2.0), and 11.2 (±2.7),
respectively. A stepwise regression demonstrated that head width was the best predictor of bite force (P <
0.01; R2 = 0.61). Although the maximum bite force for green turtles was lower than that reported for
loggerheads, bite forces were relatively forceful compared to other marine durophagous vertebrates. In
addition, during bite force measurements, propalineal movement of the lower jaw was routinely observed.
This suggests that the maximum bite force may be slightly underestimated. This movement also suggests
that some degree of oral processing occurs during feeding events. The magnitude of bite force and
propalineal motion of the lower jaw of green turtles is likely an adaptation for cropping tough plant and
algal material, but bite forces generated are also in the range required to crush several crab and mollusk
species at small size classes.
USE OF HYPERBARIC OXYGEN THERAPY TO TREAT OSTEOMYELITIS IN A
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
Nancy S. Mettee
Wider Caribbean Sea Turtle Conservation Network (WIDECAST), Juno Beach, FL USA
Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy (HBOT) involves inhaling 100% oxygen while under increased atmospheric
pressure. This fully saturates the hemoglobin in the red blood cell, and allows for hyperoxygenation of the
blood by further dissolving oxygen into plasma. The first use of HBOT was in 1600s, when a British
clergyman built a structure he called a domicilium and used hand bellows to pressurize the air inside. Its
use today has multiple physiological effects which have proven beneficial for a remarkable variety of
diseases. The objective of HBOT is hyperoxygenation, which is effective in the treatment of:
decompression sickness, carbon monoxide toxicity, retinal artery occlusion, crush injury/compartment
syndrome, compromised grafts, blood loss anemia, soft tissue infection, refractory osteomyelitis, and more.
Some of the important benefits include: vasoconstriction, reduction of edema, promotion of angiogenesis,
stimulation of fibroblasts, increase of collagen synthesis, increased oxidative killing by leukocytes, and
clostridial toxin inhibition. Treatment involves placing the patient in a chamber and increasing pressure to
2-4 atmospheres depending on overall condition and reason for use. Pressure is increased with addition of
100% oxygen and maintained for approximately one hour. Treatment frequency can be daily for several
months. In this case, HBOT was employed as treatment of refractory osteomyelitis. HBOT has many
beneficial effects specific for osteomyelitis as it will reduce the presence of anerobic bacteria and make
systemic antibiotics more effective. Furthermore, as oxygen tension in the infected bone is elevated above
normal levels, oxygen dependent polymorphonuclear cell function will increase. Finally, HBOT promotes
osteoclast function, as resorption of necrotic bone is also oxygen dependent. An adult female loggerhead
was presented in the fall of 2010 with both front flippers partially amputated by apparent shark bite. There
was a deep laceration on the ventral side of the right flipper which penetrated the carpal joint. The left front
16
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
flipper was missing 60% of its distal tip. Over the subsequent year, wounds were cultured multiple times
and treated with appropriate systemic antibiotics for extended courses (60-90 days). Wounds were also
deeply debrided twice under anesthesia: once with silverlon drains placed to facilitate exudate leaving the
wound, and a second time with antibiotic impregnated beads placed into the wound bed to elute antibiotic
directly into the wound. Despite the variety of techniques and extended treatment intervals, when treatment
was discontinued, within 6 weeks the patient would become inactive, anorexic, and show a marked increase
in the WBC. Active osteomyelitis was visible radiographically as an increase in bone lysis in the affected
areas. HBOT therapy was initiated as an alternative therapy. The treatment sessions involved 1 hour “dives”
to 2.5 atmospheres of pressure for one hour 3 days a week for a total of 18 dives. Concurrent use of
appropriate systemic antibiotic was also used for its synergistic effect. The turtle was held in captivity for 1
year after treatment and showed none of the clinical or radiographic changes previously seen. The turtle
was tagged and released and her progress can be monitored by satellite tag.
ANATOMICAL STUDY OF HEART MORPHOGENESIS OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) ON THE COAST OF OAXACA*
Eleazar A. Mijangos1, Hortensia M. Rosales2, Estela R. Hernandez1, and Isbel S. Del Angel1
1
2
Escuela de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Universidad Autónoma “Benito Juárez” de Oaxaca, México
Laboratorio de Embriología, Escuela Nacional de Ciencias Biológicas, IPN, México, D.F.
Sea turtles are endangered, which is why research on embryos of these species is limited; obtaining
permission to collect samples is difficult. Because of this the study aimed to examine morphological
changes of the heart in embryos during development until hatching. Embryos were studied from 240 eggs,
which were collected from two olive ridley nests on the beach of Palmarito, in the municipality of Bajos de
Chila, San Pedro Mixtepec, Oaxaca, Mexico, under permit number SGPA/DGVS/01731 / 08 dated April 1
2008. The collected eggs were incubated in the sand protected by a corral on the beach. The first specimen
was taken on the 2nd day of incubation, and collection continued daily with sampling until day 45 of
incubation. The samples were injected with 10% formol for fixation and were preserved in the same
solution in plastic bags, labeled with the date and the day of incubation. Subsequently embryos were
obtained by cutting the shell of the egg and baring the yolk, where the organisms were extracted and fixed
in jars with 10% formol for 24 hours. After this fixing time, we proceeded to wash the embryos with tap
water for 12 hours and continued the processing in toto using the "Green Light" technique. This begins with
the embryos in the light green solution, then excess dye is removed by washing them in alcohol at 85°,
followed by dehydration through changes of one hour at 96° alcohol, absolute alcohol followed and the
mixture in absolute alcohol - salicylate, the transparentation was performed with salicylate - xilol mixture
and finally the embryo is mounted with synthetic resin and observed under a microscope to obtain the
results. It was noted that embryos on the 3rd day of incubation showed secondary encephalic vesicles,
cephalic flexure, were developing eyes and the heart was forming by the heart straight tube having a series
of expansions corresponding to arterial trunk, arterial bulb, primitive ventricle atrium and venous sinus, in
addition 7 to 9 pairs of somites. As the incubation days advanced until the 12th day, the following changes
were observed in the heart: the development of the cardiac loop corresponding to the first curvature called
bulboventricular asa, then the curvature took the form of an "S"; that ensures that the atria that are still
developing are positioned dorsal to the ventricle. We conclude that the morphological changes that occur
until the 12th day include a heart with well-formed structures, and from then until 45 days, the heart only
undergoes changes in its structural size (atria and ventricle) with the right atrium predominating in size
with respect to the left atrium.
17
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLE DERMAL SCUTE VARIATIONS FROM RESCUED INDIVIDUALS IN THE
GULF OF VENEZUELA
Beatriz Morán1, Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez1, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido1,2
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela. Maracaibo – Venezuela. Laboratorio de
Ecología General. FEC. Universidad del Zulia. Maracaibo – Venezuela.
2
IUCN SCC Marine Turtle Specialists Group (IUCN SCC-MTSG). Centro de Modelado Científico.
Universidad del Zulia (CMC).
Species from the Cheloniidae family: Chelonia mydas, Caretta caretta, Eretmochelys imbricata,
Lepidochelys olivacea, Lepidochelys kempii and Natator depressus, presents as a distinctive feature the
presence of an osseous carapace covered with skin and scutes. In the Gulf of Venezuela (GV) four of the
six species belonging to this family are present; this area is a well-known foraging location for Caribbean
populations of marine reptiles. The number and arrangement of these scutes or scales are specific to each
species, the presence of supernumerary dermal shields or scales could lead to confusion at the moment of
correctly identify these species. This variation has been associated with altered dermal environmental
conditions during embryonic development. Based on the review of sea turtles individuals rescued and
included in the database of the Workgroup on Marine Turtles in the Gulf of Venezuela (GTTM-GV, by its
Spanish Acronym) a total of 19 individuals with presence of supernumerary scales were analyzed; 89% of
individuals belonged to the species Chelonia mydas and 11% of the species Caretta caretta. Several
variations in dermal shields agreements of both species’ carapace were observed, with a range from one to
four "extra" scales or scutes. This phenomenon (called "Dovetail Syndrome") does not affect the survival of
the individuals; it is known to be an anomaly related with either a genetic or embryogenesis condition and a
poorly understood phenomenon. All records and photographs of sea turtle individuals may have different
uses in sea turtle populations’ management and conservation programs. In foraging areas, such as the Gulf
of Venezuela, this data can complement the morphometric and meristic database with a standardized photoidentification of individuals; such identification might be used in areas of illegal consumption and trade of
carapace and other products for a better control for these unlawful acts with endangered species.
PRELIMINARY EVALUATION OF MINIMALLY INVASIVE SEXING TECHNIQUES FOR INWATER STUDIES OF LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES
April Nason1, Thane Wibbels2, Heather Harris3, and Michael James4
1
Department of Biology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS CANADA B3L 2T2
Department of Biology, University of Alabama, Birmingham, AL, USA 35294-1170
3
NOAA-SWFSC (contract), Marine Turtle Ecology and Assessment Program, Morro Bay, California,
USA
4
Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Bedford Institute of Oceanography, Dartmouth, NS CANADA B2Y 4A2
2
Sea turtles do not contain heteromorphic sex chromosomes, precluding the use of genetic methods to
confirm sex of individuals. Common alternative techniques used to confirm sex include laparoscopy, gonad
histology and ultrasound of the inguinal region to view the reproductive organs. These techniques are not
practical for in-water studies of leatherback sea turtles that depend on humane and short handling protocols.
For large sub-adult and adult leatherbacks, tail length is a secondary sexual characteristic that can
accurately identify sex. However, unless phallus eversion occurs during handling or tag recapture data can
link individuals to nesting beaches, sex cannot be confirmed with absolute certainty. We explored the use
18
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of three techniques for identifying sex of leatherbacks live-captured off of Nova Scotia, Canada: ultrasound
of the tail to view the phallus, digital palpation of the phallus through the cloacal opening, and blood
sampling followed by testosterone radioimmunoassay (RIA) to analyze sex hormone levels. Digital
palpation was performed on two live adult male turtles and tail ultrasounds were performed on three live
adult turtles (two females and 1 male) and one stranded, dead adult turtle. For the latter, ultrasound was
promising as the phallus was identifiable using a 7.4cm field depth, especially when the phallus was
manipulated. Ultrasound on the live adult male turtle was inconclusive, possibly due to boat and animal
movement. Digital palpation of the phallus through the cloacal opening was unsuccessful in the two live
male turtles. Using 600pg/mL as the cutoff value between males and females, we found that testosterone
levels of 22 of 26 turtles agreed with their sex assignment based on tail length. The sexes of 9 of the 22
individuals were confirmed based on tag recapture data or phallus eversion. Three of four turtles for which
testosterone levels were discrepant with sex assignment based on tail length were visually determined to be
males with testosterone levels more typical of females. This may have been resulted from stress-induced
increases in cortisol, which can decrease testosterone levels.
FLOW CYTOMETRY OF MYCOBIOTA ISOLATED FROM NESTS, EGGS, AND
STILLBIRTHS OF THE SEA TURTLE ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA (LINNAEUS, 1766)
Milena S. C. Neves1, Mariana O. Castro2, Carina C. M. Moura3, João Loreiro2, Luciana G. Oliveira4,
and Anabela Marisa Azul2
1
University of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal
3
University Federal Rural of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
4
Agronomic Institute of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
2
The hawksbill sea turtle, Eretmochelys imbricata, was a subject of trade due to the collection of its eggs,
consumption of the female’s meat, and fishing activities in coastal areas. Besides human impacts,
pathogens have also led to high rates of mortality, especially fungi that can kill embryos and cause
cutaneous mycosis. Flow cytometry, a highly robust and fast technique, has become widely used in the last
couple of decades to estimate the genome size of living organisms, including fungi. This can be very useful
for biosystematics purposes. This study used this technique to quantify the genome size of fungal species
isolated from soil, stillbirths and hawksbill turtle eggs, and then to evaluate the usefulness of this character
to complement previous morphological identification of fungal species. Nuclear suspensions were obtained
after chopping the fungal tissue in 1 mL of lysis buffer, subsequent filtering of the solution through a 80
µM nylon filter and staining with propidium iodide. The stained samples were then analysed in the flow
cytometer and data was acquired in the form of histograms. Using this method, the genome sizes of
Fusarium solani, Aspergillus terreus, and A. niger were estimated as 1C=95 Mbp, 35 Mbp and 40 Mbp.
Consistent estimates among different replicates aided in the complementary identification of the fungal
species. Using this method, the genome size of Fusarium solani, Aspergillus terreus and A. niger was
estimated as 1C = 95 Mbp, 35 Mbp and 40 Mbp. The detection of Fusarium solani is particularly important
as this species is known to be the cause of mortality in embryos of some species of sea turtles. Further
studies related to the size of the fungal genome, its possible variations, and other inferences on gene
mutations in differentiation of species or subspecies are necessary to investigate their pathogenicity and
strengthen studies on the ecology and conservation of sea turtles.
19
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FLIPPER BEATING MODULATION OF GREEN TURTLES IN WATER AND ON LAND:
IMPLICATIONS FOR AQUATIC ADAPTATION AND LOCOMOTOR TRADE-OFF
Hideaki Nishizawa1, Junichi Okuyama2, Tohya Yasuda3, Nobuaki Arai1, and Masato Kobayashi4
1
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Kyoto, Japan
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Kyoto, Japan Present address: NOAA, La Jolla, CA, USA
3
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Kyoto, Japan Present address: Seikai National Fisheries Research Institute,
Fisheries Research Agency, Nagasaki, Nagasaki, Japan
4
Seikai National Fisheries Research Institute, Fisheries Research Agency, Ishigaki, Okinawa, Japan
2
Sea turtles spend most of their lives in marine habitats, but they require a terrestrial environment for
oviposition. In both conditions, they use limbs for thrust production and modulating the stroke for
efficiency or higher thrust is important in their biomechanical strategy. We attached animal-borne
W1000L-3MPD3GT data loggers on green turtles during inter-nesting periods and recorded the surging
acceleration and swimming speed. We report how green turtles modulate flipper beating during travel in
the inter-nesting period and whether the stroke cycle is different between in-water and on-land. Firstly, we
assessed the relationship between swimming speed, stroke frequency, and amplitude of surging
acceleration representing stroke amplitude for varying swim speed. For varying speed, stroke frequency ×
amplitude of surging acceleration had more explanatory power than stroke frequency or amplitude of
acceleration. Therefore, flipper-beating of sea turtle during continuous swimming is indicated to be
modulated by both of stroke frequency and thrust per stroke that may enable sea turtles to adopt flexible
swimming strategy depending on the situation. Assuming that the amplitude of acceleration is proportional
to the stroke amplitude, the relationship observed in this study indicated that Strouhal number slightly but
significantly decreases as swim speed increases. Secondly, stroke frequency was compared between during
swimming in water and crawling on land. The results showed that stroke frequency during terrestrial
crawling is significantly higher than that during swimming. It contrasts to previous studies of animals
performing drag-based swimming. Because green turtles are thought to be lift-based swimmers that
produce thrust mainly by dorsoventral excursion, anteroposterior excursion that is thought to be important
for drag-based swimming and terrestrial crawling may be restricted. Small anteroposterior excursion
resulting in short stride length may be complemented by higher stroke frequency during crawling. We
thank the Symposium Travel Fund and donors for assistance.
PAIN MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES IN SEA TURTLES AND PHARMACOKINETICS OF
TRAMADOL AND O-DESMETHYLTRAMADOL IN LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA
CARETTA)
Terry M. Norton1, Kurt K. Sladky2, Sherry Cox3, Steven Nelson1, Michelle Kaylor1, Amy Hupp1, and
Rachel Thomas1
1
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island Authority, Jekyll Island, GA USA
Department of Surgical Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
USA
3
Department of Biomedical and Diagnostic Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of
Tennessee, Knoxville, TN USA
2
Trauma is the most common reason for sea turtles to be presented to the Georgia Sea Turtle Center for
rehabilitation. Boat strike injuries account for over 20 percent of our caseload and these injuries are likely
20
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
to be extremely painful. During the past few years, our understanding of reptile pain and its reduction
through analgesic (pain management) drugs has become clearer, although many of these drugs cause
respiratory depression in reptiles as they do in mammals. Tramadol hydrochloride is a centrally-acting
synthetic analgesic drug which is used for moderate to moderately-severe pain in a variety of species.
Tramadol is a very weak μ-opioid (morphine-like drug) receptor agonist, induces serotonin release, and
inhibits the reuptake of norepinephrine. Tramadol is converted to O-desmethyltramadol, a significantly
more potent μ-opioid agonist. The opioid agonistic effect of tramadol and its major metabolite(s) is almost
exclusively mediated by such μ-opioid receptors. This further distinguishes tramadol from opioids in
general (including morphine), which do not possess tramadol's degree of receptor subtype selectivity and
which are much stronger opiate-receptor agonists. A recent study in red eared sliders showed that orally
administered tramadol provided analgesia in red-eared slider turtles, and the pain relieving effects appeared
to last for 4-5 days following a single oral dose. In addition, tramadol caused minimal respiratory
depression in the same turtles. The objective of this study was to determine the pharmacokinetics of two
orally administered doses of tramadol (5 and 10 mg/kg) and its major metabolite (O-desmethyltramadol) in
loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta). After oral administration, the half-life of tramadol administered at
5 mg/kg and 10 mg/kg was 20.35 and 22.67 hours, whereas the half-life of M1 was 10.23 and 11.26 hours,
respectively. The maximum concentration (Cmax) for tramadol after oral administration at 5 mg/kg and 10
mg/kg was 373 and 719 ng/mL, whereas that of M1 was 655 and 1376 ng/mL, respectively. We were able
to determine that tramadol, administered orally to loggerhead sea turtles at both dosages provided
measurable plasma concentrations of tramadol and O-desmethyltramadol for several days with no adverse
effects. Plasma concentrations of tramadol and O-desmethyltramadol remained ≥ 100 ng/ml for at least 48
hours and perhaps as long as 96 hours when tramadol was administered at 10 mg/kg. Based on therapeutic
levels that are achieved in humans, a dose of 10 mg/kg every 48 hrs should produce similar levels but
further studies are needed to confirm this information including multi-dose and pharmacodynamic studies.
SEA TURTLE HEALTH, VETERINARY CARE, AND REHABILITATION WORKSHOP IN
COSTA RICA
Terry M. Norton1, Nancy Mettee2, Brian Stacy3, Noha Abou-Madi4, Alexia Maizel5, and Oscar Brene
Arias5
1
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA
WIDECAST Veterinarian and Private Practice, Hobe Sound, Florida, USA
3
University of Florida College of Veterinary Medicine, National Oceanographic and Atmospheric
Administration (NOAA), Gainesville, Florida, USA
4
Cornell University School of Veterinary Medicine, Ithaca, New York, USA
5
Reserva Playa Tortuga, Ojochal, Costa Rica
2
Sea turtles are global citizens whose status is imperiled worldwide. As nations struggle to conserve this
priceless natural resource by developing their own methods for conservation, it should be remembered that
rehabilitation is a powerful tool. While the number of animals returned to the sea is often inconsequential,
the number of people that can be influenced by the effort can be enormous.The positive effect of a
successful rehabilitation and public release back to the wild can ripple thru the community and inspire
people from many backgrounds.Sea turtles are effective ambassadors for ocean conservation worldwide.
Education programs using animals undergoing rehabilitation can highlight local threats to sea turtles. When
witnessed, this can develop an appreciation and even sympathy for the species which can have far reaching
effects. Sea turtle rehabilitation allows for "saving turtles, one person at a time". Sea turtle rehabilitation in
the United States attracts hundreds of thousands of visitors who are local and many more tourists from
other regions and countries. Many countries already have veterinarians that are willing to help but simply
lack the knowledge and the coordination with local biologists and wildlife rehabilitators to successfully
hold animals in captivity during convalescence. Due to endangered species law it is not practical or legal to
move animals across borders so it becomes vital that each nation have its own network for a successful
21
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
rehabilitation program. The purpose of the sea turtle medicine and surgery workshop is to provide the
special training to these people. It is a 5 day intensive lecture and wet lab designed to expose veterinarians,
veterinary students, biologists, and rehabilitation specialists to the unique aspects of sea turtle health care. It
is taught by four veterinarians with extensive experience in facility development, husbandry, pathology,
and wildlife medicine.
FACTORS AFFECTING SURVIVORSHIP IN REHABILITATING SEA TURTLES WITH
FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS
Annie Page-Karjian1, Terry Norton2, Maya Groner3, and Nicole L. Gottdenker1
1
University of Georgia, College of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Pathology, Athens, GA USA
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, GA USA
3
University of Prince Edward Island, Centre for Veterinary Epidemiological Research, Charlottetown, PE
Canada
2
Fibropapillomatosis (FP), a neoplastic disease of sea turtles with a likely primary herpesviral etiology, is
characterized by cutaneous, conjunctival, and occasionally visceral growths. We characterized the
occurrence, clinical presentation, case progression, and outcome of rehabilitating sea turtles with FP (n =
18) at the Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, GA (GSTC). We also evaluated case data from a group
of non-FP turtles in rehabilitation (control group, n = 18). During 2009-2012, FP was present in ~5% of
rehabilitating sea turtles at the GSTC, including green (Chelonia mydas) and Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys
kempii) turtles. The majority of the FP+ turtles were juvenile (94.4%), female (87.5%), green (94.4%) sea
turtles. Highest FP prevalence was in the 25–29.9 cm and 40–44.9 cm SCL size classes (22.2% each).
Floating was significantly more likely to be observed in FP+ turtles than in non-FP turtles. Average time in
rehabilitation was 251 days (± SE 18.94) for FP+ turtles, and 127 days (± SE 62.59) for non-FP turtles.
Time to FP onset ranged from demonstration of FP lesions at the time of submission (0 weeks) to 40 weeks.
Of the FP+ cases, 61.1% were released following rehabilitation; 22.2% were euthanized due to FP; 11.1%
died in captivity; and 5.6% kept in permanent captivity. FP+ turtles had significantly greater odds of being
euthanized than non-FP turtles. This study summarizes multifactorial aspects of FP cases in rehabilitation,
suggests important parameters to evaluate in prospective FP cases, and provides potential predictors for
possible case outcomes.
BIOACCUMULATION AND BIOMAGNIFICATION OF MERCURY AND SELENIUM IN
LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA): A CAUSE FOR CONCERN IN
THIS SPECIES?*
Justin R. Perrault
Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Leatherback sea turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) make long-distance migrations between foraging areas and
breeding areas. Within foraging areas, leatherbacks consume vast amounts of prey that can expose them to
high concentrations of environmental toxicants. Increased concentrations of contaminants may have
detrimental impacts on health, reproduction and survival. Specifically, I chose to analyze mercury, a
toxicant with no known biological function, and selenium, a necessary nutrient that is known to detoxify
mercury, yet can be toxic at elevated concentrations. To quantify bioaccumulation and biomagnification of
22
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
mercury and selenium in the leatherback food chain, I collected and analyzed water and prey samples from
areas where leatherbacks feed and liver samples from stranded leatherbacks of all life stage classes
(hatchlings, juveniles, subadults, adults). Lastly, one food sample and multiple liver samples from postmortem lab-reared leatherback post-hatchlings were collected. All samples were analyzed for total mercury
and selenium compounds by spectrometric methods. I found that both of these trace elements tended to
biomagnify up the food chain: water samples had the lowest concentrations of mercury and selenium, while
liver samples from the adult life stage class had the highest concentrations of these elements. Analyses of
captive-raised individuals, which fed on a manufactured diet that used tuna as a protein source, showed
bioaccumulation of mercury. Individuals that were captive for longer had much higher concentrations of
mercury in their livers than those individuals that died in quarantine (i.e., before feeding began) indicating
biomagnification and bioaccumulation can start early in life and primarily occurs from food intake;
however, absorption of the yolk sac may cause a slight increase in bodily mercury levels at this early life
stage. Liver samples of stranded juvenile leatherbacks had significantly lower concentrations of both
mercury and selenium in comparison to the adult life stage class. In leatherbacks, mercury and selenium
concentrations in the liver of adult individuals were much lower than marine mammal species, but are often
similar to or higher than fishes, birds, and other marine turtles. One interesting observation found is that
concentrations of both mercury and selenium in the liver of the stranded leatherback adults were greater
than or equal to levels known to affect health of some bird species and were above tolerance limits
established for human food consumption set by a variety of environmental and public health agencies. This
observation is important in areas where turtle meat is consumed by human populations. Such levels suggest
that scavengers and predators upon leatherbacks are also at risk unless they have physiological mechanisms
to detoxify ingested mercury. Anthropogenic deposition of trace elements and toxicants into the
environment is of concern because bodily concentrations of both mercury and selenium increase as
leatherbacks age. Because these organisms are long-lived, toxicant loads may increase to physiologically
harmful levels in these imperiled species and to their consumers.
GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) RECEIVED AT CENTRO DE RECUPERAҪãO
DE ANIMAIS MARINHOS (CRAM/FURG) IN 2011
Roberta Petitet1, Pedro Bruno2, Laís Guterres3, Andrea Adornes2, Lauro Barcellos2, and Rodolfo
Pinho da Silva Filho2
1
Centro de Recuperação de Animais Marinhos, CRAM-FURG; Programa de Pós-graduação da
Oceanografia Biológica, Instituto de Oceanografia, Universidade Federal de Rio Grande – FURG, Rio
Grande, Brazil
2
Centro de Recuperação de Animais Marinhos, CRAM-FURG, Rio Grande, Brazil
3
Laboratório de Tartarugas e Mamíferos Marinhos, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande (FURG), Rio
Grande-RS, Brazil
Although the Centro de Recuperacao de Animais Marinhos (CRAM-FURG) receives a number of green
sea turtles exhibiting different types of injuries each year, numbers were unusually high during 2011, with
92 green turtles being admitted for treatment. These turtles ranged from 28.5 to 62.0 cm curved carapace
length (CCL) (mean = 38.0 ± 4.96 cm CCL) and injuries were classified as: 1) heavy epibiont load, 2)
debris ingestion, and 3) fishery interaction. The purpose of the current study was to assess potential
relationships between injury type and stranding date. Of the total 92 green sea turtles received, 56 had
debris in their gastrointestinal tract, 21 exhibited heavy epibiont loads, 9 displayed evidence of fishery
interaction, and for the remaining 9 turtle’s cause of stranding could not be determined. In addition, three of
the individuals exhibited two types of injuries. Two ingress peaks were observed, one during April/May
and the other in October/November. Turtles received during the first peak were cachectic and severely
dehydrated, while those during the second peak displayed good body condition and only moderate
dehydration. We propose that the first peak results from consumption of debris that accumulates in great
quantities near the beaches of Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil, from tourist use of the area during summer
23
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
months (December to March). Because early juvenile green turtles may not yet have fully transitioned to an
herbivorous diet, if food resources are limited in these areas then the turtles might adopt a mixed,
omnivorous feeding strategy that could lead to consumption of debris. Treatment for debris ingestion was
intensive hydration, antibiotic therapy, and regular feeding; however only two (5%) of individuals
displaying this type of injury had good response to the treatment and were released. Green turtles received
during the second ingress peak appeared to represent those turtles that stayed in inshore waters during the
winter (July to September) and possibly entered a lethargic, dormant state due to low water temperatures
(~10° C) and food availability, which in turn allowed extensive epibiont colonization of the turtles’
carapaces. This behavior may be comparable to the dormancy observed for Gulf of California green sea
turtles, which have been observed to decrease activity and partially bury themselves in the substrate at
temperatures below 15° C. Treatment for the second group first involved hydration as well as regular
feeding and 14 (70%) of the individuals responded well, beginning to eat on their own, and were
subsequently released. No ingress pattern was evident for the 9 turtles exhibiting signs of fishery
interaction, as they were received throughout the year, and 5 of these turtles were rehabilitated and released.
Acknowledgements: We acknowledge the following organizations for the travel grants, International Sea
Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach,
Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America
AGE AND GROWTH OF GREEN SEA TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN SOUTHERN
BRAZIL
Roberta Petitet1, Paul G. Kinas2, Eduardo R. Secchi3, and Larisa Avens4
1
Programa de Pós-graduação em Oceanografia Biológica, Instituto de Oceanografia, Universidade Federal
do Rio Grande (FURG); Centro de Recuperação de Animais Marinhos – CRAM-FURG, Rio Grande-RS,
Brazil
2
Laboratório de Estatística Ambiental, Instituto de Matemática, Estatística e Física, Universidade Federal
do Rio Grande (FURG), Rio Grande-RS, Brazil
3
Laboratório de Tartarugas e Mamíferos Marinhos, Instituto de Oceanografia, Universidade Federal do Rio
Grande (FURG), Rio Grande-RS, Brazil
4
NOAA Fisheries, Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Center for Coastal Fisheries and Habitat Research,
Beaufort, NC, USA
Sea turtles of the species Chelonia mydas use the Brazilian coast for development and reproduction, with
the major nesting beaches located in Trinidade Island (ES State), Atol da Rocas (RN State) and Fernando
de Noronha (PE State). The majority of studies on green turtles in Brazil involve adult females on nesting
beaches and information about juveniles during their pelagic and neritic stages is fragmentary. In the
current study, age was estimated for 55 green sea turtles through skeletochronoogical analysis of humerus
bones. All turtles in the study stranded dead on Cassino Beach in Rio Grande do Sul state in southern
Brazil and curved carapace lengths (CCL) ranged from 28.0 to 49.0 cm (mean = 38.3 cm ±4.98 SD). As
annual growth mark deposition has been validated for green sea turtles, the number of lines of arrested
growth (LAGs) was taken as the age estimated for those samples that retained the annulus (i.e. diffuse LAG
denoting the end of the first year). For larger turtles whose humeri exhibited resorption, or destruction of
early growth marks, a correction factor was applied to estimate the number of lost LAGs. This correction
factor was based on two models, the first denoted “naïve” made no distinction between inter- and intraindividual variability and the second denoted “hierarchical”, took this distinction into account. The
hierarchical model fit the data set best, probably because these reptiles experience stochastic conditions
throughout their lives, so that some individuals may grow more than others. Ages estimated for the sample
ranged from 3 to 12 years. Schnute’s growth model was fit to age-at-CCL data and was used because of its
versatility in shape and lack of a requirement for data from the entire size range (i.e. hatchlings to adults
near asymptotic size). As the sample only included juveniles and growth was generally linear, a linear
model also fit the data quite well and both this and the Schnute model had similar DIC (Deviance
24
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Information Criteria) values. The “Body Proportional Hypothesis” (BPH) was incorporated into the
calculation of growth rates through conversion of sequential growth mark measures to estimates of CCL.
Growth rates averaged 2.46 cm CCL ± 0.59 SD year-1 and ranged from 1.31 to 3.58 cm CCL year-1 and
were similar to results from other skeletochronological analyses of Atlantic green turtles, but lower than
those estimated through mark-recapture. Humeri from 43 of the green turtles retained an annulus, allowing
back-calculation of size at age 1 and it averaged 22.97 cm CCL ± 5.3 SD and ranged from 11.92 to 34.97
cm CCL. It is likely that the turtles retaining the annulus were new recruits and, as a result, their ages
should approximate pelagic stage duration. Ages for these turtles ranged from 1 to 7 years, similar to
estimates from North Atlantic green turtle populations, as assessed through skeletochronological data and
stable isotope analysis. The results of the current study provide the first age and growth data for juvenile
green sea turtles in the south Atlantic. Acknowledgements: We acknowledge the following organizations
for the travel grants, International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine
Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and
CLS America.
BACTERIAL FLORA IDENTIFIED FROM LEATHERBACK TURTLE (DERMOCHELYS
CORIACEA) EGG SHELLS AND NEST SAND AT GRANDE RIVIERE BEACH, TRINIDAD.
Ayanna Carla N. Phillips1, Neville Stewart1, Johanna Coutou1, Stacy Rajh1, Antonio Watson1, Adam
Jehu2, Hamish Asmath2, Francis Dziva1, Ridley Holder1, and Raymond Carthy3
1
The University of the West Indies, School of Veterinary Medicine, St. Augustine Campus, Trinidad and
Tobago
2
Institute of Marine Affairs, Hilltop Lane, Chaguaramas, Trinidad and Tobago
3
University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
Grande Riviere beach, on the island of Trinidad, supports the country’s largest nesting population of
leatherback turtles, Dermochelys coriacea. It is estimated that up to 5000 turtles come ashore to nest on the
970m stretch of beach annually. Throughout the nesting season which spans from March to August, nests
are naturally disturbed by newly nesting females, resulting in egg breakage and loss of some egg viability.
This environment provides ideal conditions for the growth and proliferation of microbes. Dramatic changes
in the course of the Grande Riviere river also significantly affect this nesting site, by periodically washing
away large areas of sand and the nests therein. Tidal activity quickly replenishes the void area with ‘new’
sand throughout the season, thus potentially altering microbial load in the affected zone. This study sought
to identify the range of bacterial flora present in beach sand and egg shells on the nesting beach, with
emphasis being placed on bacteria that may pose a threat to animal health, including turtle hatchling health,
as well as those of public health significance. It further sought to determine the extent to which the bacterial
load and bacterial species on the beach changed throughout the season. Three sample sets were taken
during the 2011-2012 nesting season, representing the early, peak and late season. Each sample set
consisted of 40 sand samples collected across the entire beach, in addition to swabs of any egg shells that
were adjacent to the sand sample site. Samples were cultured on a variety of nutrient agars and selective
media, standard biochemical tests were used to identify organisms to the genus level and heterotrophic
plate counts were performed to quantify the bacterial load of each sample. Pseudomonads have been found
to predominate. We discuss the pathogenic bacteria identified, the nesting areas with the highest bacterial
load and the potential threats posed to visitors and hatchling health. Further studies will seek to document
the fungal pathogens that may pose a threat on this heavily nested, highly traversed beach.
25
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IMMUNOSUPPRESSION EVALUATION OF CHELONIA MYDAS (TESTUDINES,
CHELONIIDAE) CAUGHT IN BRAZIL
Silmara Rossi1, Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento2, Nicolle G. T. de Queiroz Hazarbassanov3, Elmer A.
Genoy-Puerto2, Denise Kinoshita3, and Eliana R. Matushima2
1
Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz e Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura,
Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil
2
Laboratório de Patologia Comparada de Animais Selvagens, Departamento de Patologia, Faculdade de
Medicina Veterinária e Zootecnia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
3
Laboratório de Farmacologia e Toxicologia, Departamento de Patologia, Faculdade de Medicina
Veterinária e Zootecnia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
The green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) feeds and nests along the Brazilian coast. Fibropapillomatosis (FP),
a disease characterized by skin tumors, is a growing threat to this species, having a multifactorial and
complex etiology (Chelonid Fibropapilloma-associated Herpesvirus, genetic and environmental factors
including organochlorine compounds and heavy metals). This study assessed leukocyte activity
(phagocytosis and oxidative burst) from non-affected turtles (control group) and affected turtles (FP group)
by flow cytometry, and correlated these results with hematological data. The evaluation of leucocyte
activity is extremely necessary because turtles affected by FP are immunosuppressed. Specimens of C.
mydas were randomly caught or rescued on beaches in Ubatuba/SP and São Sebastião/SP (Brazil). After
capture, debilitated green sea turtles remained at TAMAR-ICMBio Rehabilitation Center in Ubatuba/SP.
Blood samples were taken and biometric data (curved carapace length, curved carapace width and body
mass) were recorded from 58 juveniles specimens (23 without tumors and 35 with tumors) in accordance to
protocols of TAMAR-ICMBio. Frequency and distribution of tumors by anatomical region were also
recorded. Leucocytes were obtained using Percoll Amersham Biosciences® and the stimuli applied were
Phorbol Miristate-Acetate for oxidative burst and Zymosan A (Saccharomyces cerevisiae Bio Particles®,
Alexa Fluor® 594 conjugate) for phagocytosis. Tumor number per animal ranged from 1 to 59, with the
anterior limbs being the most affected region. Animals with FP were larger in size (42.18 cm ± 8.42) than
turtles without FP (39.26 cm ± 12.34). The values of hematological parameters (from 43 turtles) were
similar (p≥0.05) for both affected (n=24) and non-affected (n=19) turtles. Additionally, hematological
results were also compared with reference values from non-affected juvenile green sea turtles caught in
Fernando de Noronha/PE, Brazil, revealing that the turtles from this study had lower values for Hematocrit,
Hemoglobin, Mean Cell Volume (MCV), Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin (MCH), Mean Corpuscular
Hemoglobin Concentration (MCHC) and Eosinophils (Eos), but higher values for total Leucocytes,
Heterophils (Het), Monocytes (Mon) and Lymphocytes (Lym). The results of flow cytometry included
samples from 22 specimens (8 non-affected and 14 affected turtles). Three cell populations, isolated first by
Percoll Amersham Biosciences®, were observed: Lym, Mon and Granulocytes (Gran). Phagocytosis and
oxidative burst analyses (geometric mean of fluorescence intensity) included two populations (Mon and
Gran). Phagocytosis and oxidative burst from turtles with and without tumors did not differ (p≥0.05).
However, there was a significant difference (p≤0.05) between control group and stimulus group for
Phagocytosis. The pathogenesis of FP is still unclear, so elucidating some parameters linked to diseases
related to pollution are relevant in studying ecosystem imbalances and are important for new directions in
sea turtle conservation issues. Acknowledgements: Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São
Paulo (FAPESP): 2010/01781-8 and 2011/04565-7; Projeto TAMAR-ICMBio.
26
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
A PROPOSAL TO OBJECTIVELY CLASSIFY FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS SEVERITY IN SEA
TURTLES CONSIDERING NUMBER AND SIZE OF TUMORS
Silmara Rossi1, Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento2, Ralph E. T. Vanstreels2, Robson G. dos Santos3,
and Eliana R. Matushima2
1
Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz e Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura,
Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil
2
Laboratório de Patologia Comparada de Animais Selvagens, Departamento de Patologia, Faculdade de
Medicina Veterinária e Zootecnia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
3
Departamento de Oceanografia e Ecologia, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, ES, Brazil
Fibropapillomatosis (FP) is a disease that affects sea turtles, especially green turtles, Chelonia mydas.
Researchers attribute complex etiology involving genetic and environmental factors, as well as the
Chelonid Fibropapilloma-associated Herpesvirus. Specimens of C. mydas were caught in different feeding
areas along the Brazilian coast: Ubatuba-SP (n=63), Vitória-ES (n=23) and Almofala-CE (n=4). Biometric
data was collected in accordance to protocols of TAMAR-ICMBio-Brazil, and the number and distribution
of the tumors per anatomic region (anterior and posterior flippers, including adjacent skin; cervical region;
plastron; eyes; inguinal region and tail; carapace and horny scales of head) were recorded. Tumors were
measured and classified for each individual according to their diameter based on Work & Balazs: A ( <1
cm), B (1 cm ≤ tumor ≤ 4 cm), C (4 cm < tumor ≤ 10 cm) and D (> 10 cm). A total of 3,035
fibropapillomas were counted, ranging from 1 to 129 (34.49 ± 27.69) per turtle and were classified as: FPA
(43.14% of tumors), FPB (50.55%), FPC (5.98%) and FPD (0.33%). Tumors were distributed in greater
quantities on the anterior and posterior flippers (respectively 44.12% and 29.36%), cervical region
(11.51%), plastron (4.97%), near the eyes (4.16%), inguinal region and tail (3.22%), carapace (1.79%) and
head (0.88%). Based on this data, we developed a system to objectively classify the severity of
fibropapillomatosis based on the quantity of the tumors in each size category. The number of tumors in
each size category was then used to calculate a novel fibropapillomatosis index (FPI) for each individual:
FPI = (1×FPA)+(2×FPB)+(4×FPC)+(8×FPD), where FPx is the number of tumors of the x size category
that were counted on that individual. The resulting fibropapillomatosis index may be used to classify the
degree of this disease of that individual as “mild” (FPI<50), “moderate” (50≤FPI<100) or “severe”
(FPI≥100). Through this index, individuals with the same number of tumors may be classified very
differently. For example, consider two hypothetical individuals with 40 tumors: individual A has 10 tumors
smaller than 1 cm, 25 tumors from 1 to 4 cm, 4 tumors from 4 to 10 cm, and one tumor larger than 10 cm;
individual B has 37 tumors smaller than 1 cm, 2 tumors from 1 to 4 cm, and one tumor from 4 to 10 cm. As
a result, individual “A” will have a fibropapillomatosis index of 84 and will be classified as “moderate”,
whereas individual “B” will have an index of 45 and will be classified as “mild”. This fibropapillomatosis
index will be applied to green turtles caught along the Brazilian coast to correlate the severity of
fibropapillomatosis with other health and environmental variables in order to develop a better
understanding of the regional manifestations of the disease and its implications for the conservation of this
species. Acknowledgements: Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP):
2009/53956-9, 2010/01781-8, 2011/04565-7; Projeto Tamar-ICMBio.
27
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IMMUNOTOXIC EFFECTS OF SELECTED PCBS UPON IN VITRO EXPOSURE IN JUVENILE
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES, CARETTA CARETTA
Estelle Rousselet1, Milton Levin2,3, Erika Gebhard-Cote2, Benjamin M. Higgins4, Sylvain De Guise2,
and Céline A.J. Godard-Codding5
1
VetAgroSup-Campus Vétérinaire de Lyon, Lyon, France
Department of Pathobiology and Veterinary Science, University of Connecticut, Storrs, USA
3
Center for Environmental Sciences and Engineering, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, USA
4
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service, Southeast
Fisheries Science Center, Galveston, USA
5
Department of Environmental Toxicology, The Institute of Environmental and Human Health, Texas
Tech University, Lubbock, USA
2
The loggerhead sea turtle, Caretta caretta, is considered endangered by the IUCN and is currently
protected under the Endangered Species Act. Sea turtles face numerous environmental challenges including
exposure to anthropogenic chemical pollutants such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Although banned
in the 1970s in the United States, they still persist in the environment and are documented to exert
immunotoxicity in a wide range of species. This is of particular concern as modulation of the immune
system may lead to an increase of disease’s susceptibility. A battery of in vitro immune assays, previously
optimized in loggerhead sea turtles, was used to quantify the direct effects of selected PCBs at increasing
concentrations (0.5, 1, 2.5, 5, 10, 15 and 20 ppm) on peripheral blood leukocytes. The effects of PCB 105
and 138 on innate immunity were assessed (eosinophils phagocytosis and natural killer (NK) cell activity).
The activity of NK cell after exposure to PCB 169 was also determined. Acquired immunity was tested by
incubating lymphocytes with PCB 105, 153 or 180 for 96 h while phytohaemagglutinin (PHA)-induced T
lymphocyte proliferation was measured. Blood samples from healthy juvenile captive loggerhead sea
turtles were collected from the cervical sinus under the appropriate permits. The results show that: (1)
peripheral blood mononuclear cell viability was > 90% after 96h of exposure of either coplanar PCBs (105,
123, 169) and non-coplanar congeners (138, 153, 180) at all tested concentrations; (2) PCB 105 and 138
significantly increase phagocytosis at 10 and 15 ppm (p<0.002, n=4, PCB 105) and 15 ppm (p<0.04, n=4,
PCB 138) compared to unexposed eosinophils; (3) PCB 169 did not modulate NK cell activity, while PCBs
138 and 105 significantly decreased NK cell activity at 15 ppm (p=0.007, n=3) and 20 ppm (p=0.008, n=3),
respectively, compared to unexposed control; and (4) PCB 180 significantly decreased T lymphocyte
proliferation at 10, 15 and 20 ppm (p<0.001, n=3). None of the other PCBs tested (105 and 153) modulated
T lymphocyte proliferation, however, data obtained with these two congeners had insufficient statistical
power to determine significant differences if they existed. In conclusion, this is the first study reporting the
toxic effects of two PCBs (105 and 138) on sea turtle innate immunity such as phagocytosis and NK cell
activity. Any modulation of immune functions may increase the likelihood of infection, which may impact
the survival of individuals. This research will help establish relationships between chemicals measured in
loggerhead sea turtles and the integrity of defense mechanisms as indicators of disease susceptibility to
pathogens and consequently guide veterinarians and wildlife rehabilitators in caring for and treating
afflicted animals. Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank the supporting personnel at the
NOAA Fisheries Service Galveston Sea Turtle Facility. Funding and logistic support for this project was
provided by the Rotary Foundation. I would like to thank the Sea Turtle Symposium for making trip to the
33th Sea Turtle Symposium possible through a student grant travel.
28
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
BODY CONDITION INDEX OF CHELONIA MYDAS (TESTUDINES, CHELONIIDAE) WITH
AND WITHOUT FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS ALONG THE COAST OF BRAZIL
Angélica M. Sánchez-Sarmiento1, Silmara Rossi2, Ralph E. T. Vanstreels1, Robson G. dos Santos3,
Juliana Marigo1,4, Carolina P. Bertozzi4, and Eliana R. Matushima1
1
Laboratório de Patologia Comparada de Animais Selvagens, Departamento de Patologia, Faculdade de
Medicina Veterinária e Zootecnia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
2
Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz e Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura,
Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil
3
Departamento de Oceanografia e Ecologia, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, ES, Brazil
4
Projeto Biopesca, Praia Grande, SP, Brazil
Fibropapillomatosis (FP) is an important conservation threat to green turtles, Chelonia mydas, due to its
widespread and complex character. Its etiology is not yet entirely understood and its impacts on sea turtle
populations is a priority for conservation efforts. The body condition index (BCI) can be used for routine
green sea turtle health evaluations. This study used BCI to evaluate and compare the condition of C. mydas
specimens with (n=94) and without fibropapillomas (n=127) in relation to capture location, gender and
capture method in Brazilian waters. Biometric data (curved carapace length-CCL, curved carapace widthCCW and body mass-BM) were recorded. Straight carapace length (SCL) was extrapolated (SCL=(CCL2.2464)/1.0363) and then Body Condition Index was calculated (BCI=BM/SCL3). BCI had a normal
distribution (KS=0.053 P=0.140), and a General Linear Model with Tukey’s post-hoc test was used to
compare BCI in relation to capture location (Ceará, Espírito Santo, Rio de Janeiro, Santa Catarina, São
Paulo), gender (female, male, not determined), capture method (incidental netting, floating, stranded,
others) and fibropapillomatosis (absent, present). Animals captured through incidental netting were further
compared to the fishery type (fishing hooks, floating siege, corral, trawl nets, gillnets, driftnet, cast net, not
determined). BCI was not significantly different among genders (F=1.83, P=0.163) or whether they had
fibropapillomatosis or not (F=0.01, P=0.919). However this may result from the fact that there was great
variation in the number and distribution of tumors, and therefore the impacts on body condition may vary
largely among individuals with the disease. There was a significant difference in relation to capture
location (F=2.89, P=0.023), however the Tukey post-hoc comparison failed to identify it (all P>0.05). BCI
differed in relation to capture method (F=11.05, P<0.001): turtles captured though incidental netting (1.50
± 0.19) had a higher BCI than those found floating (1.29 ± 0.33), stranded (1.30 ± 0.23) or captured by
other methods (1.41 ± 0.26). Among the animals captured through incidental netting, BCI was different
depending on the fishery type (F=3.22, P=0.002), with a higher BCI for animals captured by fishing hooks
(1.86 ± 0.08; n=2) than in those captured by cast nets (1.42 ± 0.10; n=17). These groups did not differ from
others, nor did any other groups differ from one another. Further studies are currently under development to
correlate BCI with FP severity and tumor distribution, as well as with levels of persistent organic pollutants
such as organochlorine pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls in tissues samples of C. mydas caught
along the Brazilian coast to clarify their role in the etiology of fibropapillomatosis. Acknowledgements:
Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP): 2011/04565-7 and 2010/01781-8;
Projeto TAMAR-ICMBio and the International Sea Turtle Symposium and sponsors.
29
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PROLAPSE AND EXPULSION OF OVIDUCT IN OLIVE RIDLEY LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA,
DIFFERENT BEACH IN SINALOA, MEXICO.
Fernando Enciso Saracho1, José Barrón2, Marco A. Barraza Ortega1, Ingmar Sosa Cornejo1, Jesús
Ivan Guardado-González3, and Luz María Rincón1
1
Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa
Acuario Mazatlán
3
Ayuntamiento de Elota, Sinaloa, México
2
Four cases are reported and documented on prolapse and expulsion of oviduct in olive ridley (Lepidochelys
olivacea) during nesting on beaches as Caimanero, Rosario, Sinaloa (1989), Stone Island, Mazatlan,
Sinaloa (1997); Playa Brujas, Mazatlan, Sinaloa (2003) and Playa Ceuta, Elota, Sinaloa (2011), which
according veterinarians consulted due to deficiencies in calcium, they also lay eggs before prolapsing
shelled or shell very weak.
EVIDENCE FOR NUTRITIONAL PROMOTION OF SEA TURTLE TUMORS
Nicole Sarto1 and Kyle Van Houtan2
1
2
Stanford University, Stanford, California, USA
NOAA Fisheries, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
Around the Hawaiian Islands, green sea turtles are often afflicted with fibropapilloma, a potentially
debilitating, tumor-forming disease associated with herpes virus. While the disease itself is not uncommon,
the continuous expression of large tumors leading to animal mortality is cause for concern. Recent spatial
analysis work has shown that disease rates are highest in watersheds where human land use impacts are
greatest. The proposed mechanism for this correlation posits that nitrogen-rich runoff enters the neritic
environment and is taken up by invasive algae, which are then eaten by foraging turtles. The algae store the
excess nitrogen as arginine, which is an amino acid essential to herpes growth. Using stable isotope
analysis, we are comparing the dietary composition of tumored and tumor-free turtles during their prerecruitment and post-recruitment life stages. In tumored turtles, we expect to see evidence that they are
eating algae that have been enriched with N15 post-recruitment. This would provide additional evidence for
the mechanistic role of diet in promoting this disease.
PLASMA CONCENTRATION OF VITELLOGENIN IN THE LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
(CARETTA CARETTA): FROM THE NESTING BEACH TO IN WATER STUDIES
Kimberly Smelker, Lauren Smith, and Roldán Valverde
Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, Louisiana, USA
The loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) is a keystone species found throughout the temperate waters of
the world’s oceans. Four of the 9 distinct population segments (DPS) are listed by the IUCN as endangered,
30
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
including the Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS. This population is made up of mostly juveniles and immature
adults but also includes many females that nest along the U.S. east coast. Research on the reproductive
physiology of sea turtles has clarified the distinct seasonal cycles in hormone production during
reproduction. Several physiological processes, such as vitellogenesis, are under hormonal control during
the reproductive cycle in females. As a precursor protein for yolk production in oviparous vertebrates, liver
production of vitellogenin (vtg) is induced by estrogen typically only in reproductively active females;
however, both males and females carry the vtg gene. Both progesterone (P4) and testosterone (T) are
inhibitors of vitellogenin production; therefore rising concentration of these hormones is thought to cease
vitellogenesis at the end of the ovulatory phase. The multi-hormonal control of vitellogenesis and the
biologically healthy concentration of vtg in sea turtles are not fully understood. To date, concentrations of
vtg in wild populations of loggerhead sea turtles during reproductive and non-reproductive periods has not
been described. This study describes the circulating concentration of vtg in nesting (n = 193) and nonnesting loggerhead females (n = 44) from the Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS, and also reports
concentrations of vtg in males (n = 111), juveniles and non reproductive females (n = 250) of the same DPS.
Blood samples were collected from turtles caught off the coast of South Carolina in 2008 and 2009, and
from nesting females in 2008 at Hutchinson Island, Florida. All samples were analyzed using Enzymelinked Immunosorbent Assays specific for Caretta caretta vtg. The detection limit of the assay used to
analyze the South Carolina samples was estimated at 3.5 µg/ml, and the detection limit of the assay used to
analyze the Florida samples was estimated at 0.5 µg/ml. Vitellogenin concentration in turtles captured at
South Carolina ranged from undetectable to 16 µg/ml, with a mean detection of 6.0 µg/ml ± 1.3 µg/ml. A
single female yielded a vtg concentration of 146 µg/ml, and was not included in the mean. In nesting
Florida turtles, vtg concentration fluctuated between 1.3 mg/ml and 96 mg/ml, with a mean of 18 mg/ml ±
1.6 mg/ml. There was a significant difference between vtg concentration in reproductive females versus
males and non-reproductive females. Vtg concentration was correlated with month in both nesting turtles
and turtles captured off shore. Vtg concentration was not correlated with size, or whether or not an emerged
female oviposited. These results indicate that low concentrations of vtg can be detected in males and nonreproductive females, and that vitellogenesis is complete before the end of the nesting season in
reproductive females. This assay is useful in determining variations in vitellogenin concentration during the
reproductive cycle and can also be used to identify exposure to xenoestrogens at ecologically meaningful
concentrations in juveniles, males, and non-reproductive females.
DETERMINATION OF HEMATOLOGICAL AND BIOCHEMICAL VALUES IN A WILD
POPULATION OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN NORTHERN PERU
Tania Suarez-Yana1, Jeffrey C. Mangel2, David Montes I.1, Renato Zuñiga3, and Joanna AlfaroShigueto2
1
Pro Delphinus, Lima, Peru; Cayetano Heredia University, Lima, Peru
Pro Delphinus, Lima, Peru; University of Exeter, Cornwall, UK
3
Cayetano Heredia University, Lima, Peru
2
The green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) is the most common sea turtle in Peru. The species is considered
endangered by the IUCN as a result of anthropogenic threats including fisheries bycatch and threats at
nesting beaches. Due to their migratory behavior, green turtles are an important bioindicator of the coastal
marine environment, both locally and globally. In addition, variability in hematological and biochemical
values may occur because of geographic area, diet, season, age, etc., which help define the variance in each
population. In this study, we analyzed 32 clinically healthy individuals that were incidentally captured in
artisanal fisheries from Sechura Bay, Peru. The average hematological and biochemical values found were:
erythrocytes 0.52 ± 0.18 x 106/µL, hematocrit 33 ± 5 %, mean corpuscular volume 720.62 ± 288.76 fL,
leukocytes 15.25 ± 5.73 x 10³/µL, heterophils 9.66 ± 4.43 x 10³/µL, lymphocytes 3.58 ± 1.61 x 10³/µL,
eosinophils 0.55 ± 1.41 x 10³/µL, monocytes 1.47 ± 0.91 x 10³/µL, normal thrombocytes, alkaline
phosphatase 38.04 ± 14.85 UI/L, alanine aminotransferase 32.38 ± 42.89 UI/L, aspartate aminotransferase
31
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
191.17 ± 64.63 UI/L, urea 64.31 ± 37.84 mg/dL, creatinine 0.25 ± 0.28 mg/dL, glucose 148 ± 52 md/dL,
total protein 4.2 ± 0.7 g/dL, albumin 2.2 ± 0.6 g/dL, globulin 2.1 ± 0.4 g/dL and A/G ratio 1.1 ± 0.6 g/dL.
There was no correlation of body size with any of the blood parameters measured. The values of
erythrocytes, hematocrit and mean corpuscular volume are within the reference values from other Pacific
Ocean regions. While there are similarities with blood chemistry values reported here with those from other
healthy green sea turtle populations, urea, total protein, albumin and globulin values are higher probably
due to an omnivorous diet rich in proteins and carbohydrates. Post-capture stress may have affected glucose
and heterophils values.
COMPARISON OF BEHAVIORAL RESPONSE TO COLD WATER BETWEEN GREEN AND
LOGGERHEAD TURTLE JUVENILES
Runa Tabata1, Ayana Wada1, Junichi Okuyama1, Yuka Obe1, Kana Nakajima1, Nobuaki Arai1, and
Masato Kobayashi2
1
Kyoto university, Kyoto, Japan
Yaeyama station, Research Center for Subtropical Fisheries Seikai National Fisheries Research Institute,
Fisheries Research Agency, Ishigaki, Japan
2
Generally, loggerhead turtles nest at the temperate zones, but green turtles nest at the subtropical and
tropical zones. Thus loggerhead turtle juveniles are assumed to have a tolerance for colder water, and they
are triggered escape reaction at lower temperature than green turtle juveniles. Comparing the behavioral
response to cold water between loggerhead and green turtle juveniles, may enable us to get a key of the
difference in distribution among two species. We conducted a tank experiment to reveal the behavioral
response of green and loggerhead turtle juveniles to water temperature. In this study, we used 8 green and 8
loggerhead turtle juveniles captured at Ishigaki island, Japan (24oN, 124oE) and then bred for about 1
month at Yaeyama station, Research Center for Subtropical Fisheries Seikai National Fisheries Research
Institute, Fisheries Research Agency, Japan. In the first experiment, to compare the activity level in the
different water temperature of loggerhead and green turtle juveniles, the juveniles were settled in the
experimental tank which could change the water temperature voluntarily by a thermo-regulator. Then, we
monitored the number of their stroking and their swimming performance for 30 minutes at different
temperatures (15, 20, 25 and 28 oC). In the second experiment, to reveal their behavioral response to the
water at different temperature, we flowed different waters in temperature from one side and another of the
tank, then monitored which temperature they preferred. As a result of this study, both green and loggerhead
turtle juveniles escaped from the waters at low temperature, but loggerhead turtle juveniles demonstrated a
greater tolerance for lower temperature than green turtles. Our results indicate that loggerhead juveniles are
able to disperse in wider range than green turtle juveniles.
ESTABLISHING A GLOBAL DNA BARCODE AND MOLECULAR PHYLOGENY FOR
MARINE LEECHES (OZOBRANCHUS SPP.) FROM SEA TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC AND
PACIFIC OCEAN BASINS*
Triet M. Truong, Philip Lavretsky, Jeffrey L. Peters, and Audrey E. McGowin
Wright State University, Dayton, OH, USA
The possible role of Ozobranchus spp. in sea turtle fibropapillomatosis (FP) disease etiology has not been
fully explored, yet these ectoparasites have been shown to contain high concentrations of the
32
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
fibropapilloma-associated turtle herpesvirus virus thought to cause FP. Only two O. spp. (Ozobranchus
branchiatus and Ozobranchus margoi) are known to be associated with sea turtles. O. branchiatus has
historically had a species-specific relationship with host Chelonia mydas yet host divergence has recently
been recorded. Likewise, FP was first reported in C. mydas but has since been documented to a lesser
degree on all other species of sea turtles. Assessment of their potential role in FP etiology requires accurate
species identification. Morphological identification of O. spp. can be difficult or impossible due to their
small size and various life stages including larval and cocoon. DNA barcoding using mitochondrial
cytochrome c oxidase I (COI) gene was employed to identify both O. branchiatus and O. margoi at all
stages of development that were collected from turtles in the Pacific and Atlantic ocean basins. Collection
sites included Barbados (five O. spp. samples from Eretmochelys imbricata), Florida (43 from Chelonia
mydas and 13 from Caretta caretta), Hawaii (34 from C. mydas), Hong Kong (two from C. mydas), Brazil
(ten from C. mydas), and Mexico (two from Lepidochelys olivacea). O. branchiatus was found in both
ocean basins, while O. margoi was only found in the Atlantic Ocean. All Pacific turtle hosts were green
turtles (C. mydas) with the exception of olive ridley turtles (L. olivacea) from Western Mexico. The COI
marker has proven successful at meeting all the requirements for a DNA barcode. Diagnostic sites at COI
successfully identify not only the species of marine turtle leech but also determine from which ocean basin
the specimen originated. Furthermore, pooled samples yielded identical genetic information as unpooled
samples from the same locations. Although COI is conserved for O. margoi in the Atlantic, at least four
COI haplotypes for O. branchiatus exist in each ocean basin. Phylogenetic analysis of O. spp. at other
genes (18S rDNA, 28S rDNA, and histone H3) may establish whether Atlantic and Pacific Ocean turtles
are infested with cryptic species of O. branchiatus. Preliminary data indicates 28S rDNA to be
uninformative because it was conserved in all O. branchiatus samples from Florida and Hawaii. On the
other hand, O. branchiatus specimens from Hawaii and Florida revealed two fixed sites for 18S rDNA.
New primers were developed to sequence histone H3, revealing gene duplication for O. branchiatus and
possibly three for O. margoi. Acknowledgments: Special thanks to the WSU WISGC for funding much of
the research and to the International Sea Turtle Symposium for providing a travel award to attend the 33rd
Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation. Support for the grant has been made
available through generous donations by the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy,
Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, and CLS America.
TWO NEW RECORDS OF MARINE LEECHES
TURTLES IN TAIWAN*
HIRUDINIDA:OZOBRANCHIDAE OF SEA
Cheng T. Tseng and I. J. Cheng
National Taiwan Ocean University, Keelung, Taiwan
Marine turtle leeches (Ozobranchus spp.) are ectoparasites of sea turtles. They can cause such symptoms as
anemia, large-scale thinning of the dermal layer and general deterioration in the health of sea turtles. Only
two species were identified on turtles examined from Taiwan: Ozobranchus branchiatus, only found on the
green turtle (Chelonia mydas), with 7 external gills on each side of its abdomen and Ozobranchus margoi,
found on the loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta), with 5 external gills on each side of its abdomen. From
July 2009 until July 2011 in eastern Taiwan’s Don-Ou village, the infection rate of O. branchiatus and O.
margoi were 8.5% (2/23) and 37.5% (3/8), respectively. We report the first records of both leech species in
Taiwan. We observed an extreme case of infection, with approximately 400 O. margoi on a single
loggerhead turtle taken as by-catch in the local pound net fishery on December 14, 2009. The infection
caused cloacal swelling and localized carapace depression.
33
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TAIL GROWTH IN HAWKSBILL TURTLES MATURING AT MONA AND MONITO ISLANDS,
PUERTO RICO
Robert P. van Dam1 and Carlos E. Diez2
1
2
Chelonia Inc., San Juan, Puerto Rico
Programa de Especies Protegidas, Departamento de Recursos Naturales, San Juan, Puerto Rico
Mona and Monito Islands harbor a large aggregation of immature and adult hawksbill turtles that use a
variety of habitats for foraging and breeding. Since 1992 we have performed annual in-water surveys of
hawksbills along the nearshore waters of both islands, an effort that includes turtle capture for tagging,
measurement and sampling. Here we report on 1,177 plastron to tail-tip measurements taken over a 21 yr
period for 665 individual hawksbill turtles. Measured turtles ranged in size from 20.00 to 91.80 cm straight
carapace length (SCL). Hawksbill tail lengths scale linearly with SCL for both sexes from 20.00 cm until a
median 64.00 cm SCL, beyond which tail lengths bifurcate by gender and indicating the onset of maturity.
Hawksbills can exhibit long tails (extending well beyond the carapace) and other secondary male
characteristic from 50.10 cm SCL. Tail growth trajectories for nine maturing male turtles yielded mean
peak tail growth rates of 3.50 cm/yr (range 1.60-4.80 cm/yr). Based on these tail growth rates, males can be
expected to take on average 6.90 yr after reaching 64.00 cm SCL to become fully mature.
THE EVOLUTION OF LEATHERBACK (DERMOCHELYID) TURTLES
Roger C. Wood1, James L. Knight2, David Cicimuri2, and Albert Sanders3
1
The Wetlands Institute, Stone Harbor, NJ, USA
South Carolina State Museum, Columbia, SC, USA
3
The Charleston Museum, Charleston, SC, USA
2
Recent discoveries of relatively well-preserved fossil shells (in Egypt, Peru, California, Maryland, and
especially South Carolina) have permitted reassessment of the evolutionary history of leatherback
(Dermochelyid) turtles. A review of the entire fossil record of Dermochelyids allows the formulation of a
phylogenetic hypothesis for this extremely divergent family of turtles. In the past, there has been a
tendency to refer most Dermochelid fossils to one extinct genus, Psephophorus, the implication being that
some form of Psephophorus eventually evolved during the Teriary into the living genus Dermochelys.
However, cladistic analysis clearly indicates that Dermochelyid evolution has been considerably more
complex. The earliest known fossil leatherbacks in the Cretaceous had a shell morphology rather similar to
other types of contemporaneous marine turtles. Over time several distinct leatherback lineages evolved, all
but one of which became extinct. As many as three different types of Dermochelyids coexisted at various
times during the Tertiary. One of these is represented by forms having a smooth, unridged carapace, as well
as, apparently, a fully ossified plastron. There are other leatherback lineages typified by varying numbers of
anteroposterior carapacial ridges and distinctive ridge morphologies. It is now clear that most taxa
previously referred to Psephophorus are not assignable to that genus, and Psephophorus is definitely not
ancestral to Dermochelys. Features of Dermochelyid shell evolution include: 1) a progressive decrease in
shell thickness; 2) a concomitant decrease in the size of individual ossicles (and therefore an overall
increase in the number of ossicles forming the carapace); 3) wide variation in the number of anteroposterior
ridges on the carapaces of different taxa (from zero to seven or more); 4) variation in the cross-sectional
structure of the anteroposterior ridges; 5) the development of undulting crests along the length of the
ridges; and 5) an increase in the number of ossicles between adjacent ridges.
34
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Conservation, Management and Policy
QARAPARA - SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN CHILE
Rocío E. Álvarez, Marcela A. Mella, Cristián E. Squella, Kharla I. Skamiotis, and Tatiana P.
Vuskovic
Qarapara Sea Turtles Chile, Chile
The migration routes and foraging habitats of four of the five species of sea turtles that inhabit the Eastern
South Pacific are found along the coast of Chile. These four species include Caretta caretta, Chelonia
mydas, Dermochelys coriacea and Lepidochelys olivacea. Important research studies and conservation
efforts in different parts of the country are conducted by universities and government institutions. However,
even though some foraging sites have been identified and are monitored systematically, there is a gap in the
integration of the information collected throughout the country. Qarapara Tortugas Marinas Chile was
formed in 2012 by young professionals from different disciplines (veterinary medicine, marine biology,
ecotourism, agriculture, etc.) with knowledge in various areas related to these species and the support of
experts in the field of sea turtles. It's mission is to promote, coordinate and develop research that
contributes to the knowledge and conservation of sea turtle populations and their habitats in Chile, and
integrate the development of associated human communities and form networks throughout the country.
The scope of the work incorporates advice on rescue and rehabilitation activities, environmental education
and research. The first studies in Bahía Salado, a foraging site for the black turtle (C. mydas agassizii)
located in the north of the country which is the southernmost congregation site of this species in the Eastern
South Pacific, have just begun. Furthermore, in order to gain experience and build a cooperating network,
we have conducted a series of outreach activities and participated in scientific workshops in Chile and
abroad. Likewise, our NGO has the support of private organizations and experts in various fields concerned
with the protection of marine ecosystems and their biodiversity.
NESTING BEACH AND BYCATCH MONITORING EFFORT IN SIERRA LEONE
Edward Aruna1, Augustine Sesay1,2, Ibrahim Bah1,2, Francis J. Tucker1,2, Aiah P. Koroma3, and
Ibrahim Boima1,2
1
Reptile and Amphibian Program - Sierra Leone, Freetown, Sierra Leone
MTCP-SL, Marine Turtle Program- Sierra Leone
3
Conservation Society of Sierra Leone (Rtd), Sierra Leone
2
The Marine Turtle Program - Sierra Leone (MTCP-SL) began as a student research project in the late 1990s
and has turned into a full sea turtle conservation program in Sierra Leone. The project actually started in
2001 after five of the world's seven species of sea turtles were identified in Sierra Leone. Threats imposed
on the five marine turtle species and their nesting beaches were documented during a national survey that
was funded by the USFWS in 2006. However, the species of sea turtles that nested in Sierra Leone still
needed to be identified. In order to identify and protect the nesting sea turtles, MTCP-SL, with support
from USFWS and in collaboration with the Conservation Society of Sierra Leone, the Wildlife
Conservation Branch (WCB) of the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Food Security (MAFFS) and the
Ministry of Fisheries and Marine Resources (MFMR), set up taskforce groups along selected coastal
35
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
communities based upon the result of the national survey. Responsibilities of the taskforce group included
bycatch and beach monitoring, while MTCP and the collaborating organizations listed above embarked on
education and sensitization campaigns. Results of these efforts include the release of captured turtles,
burying of dead turtles and identification of marine turtle species that nest on beaches in most communities.
So far, MTCP-SL has documented all five species nesting on beaches in Sierra Leone, and in over three
years, has identified over 600 turtles and released over 15,000 hatchlings. With the presence of MTCP, the
government has now afforded much protection for sea turtles in Sierra Leone. This is demonstrated by the
inclusion of marine turtles into both wildlife and fisheries acts as protected species.
HALTING INDONESIAN SEA TURTLE DECLINES: EXPANDING AND IMPROVING
EFFECTIVENESS OF PROTECTED AREAS FOR TURTLE NESTING SITES
Irawan Asaad1,2, Cherryta Yunia1, Wen Wen3, and Sangeeta Mangubhai3
1
Directorate General of Forest Protection and Nature Conservation, Ministry of Forestry, Indonesia.
Contact address : Forestry Centre, Manggala Wanabakti Building Block VII, 7th Floor, Gatot Subroto
Street, Jakarta (10470), Indonesia.
3
The Nature Conservancy, Indonesia - Marine Program, Bali, Indonesia
2
Sea turtle species in Indonesia are experiencing declining population trends. Direct catches for personal
consumption or for sale at national and global markets, uncontrolled coastal development, pollution,
disease and climate change are all contributing to turtle declines. A gap analysis, which is a method to
identify important ecosystems and habitats while investigating the representation of ecosystems that have
not been included in the system of conservation area networks, was conducted in order to analyze the status
of sea turtle conservation. There have been at least 95 major nesting beaches documented in Indonesia,
many of which are regionally significant. Of these, 95 nesting areas 53 (56%) lack protection status.
Halting turtle declines will require two key actions: 1) establishing conservation areas that protect currently
unprotected turtle nesting beaches, and 2) increasing the effectiveness of management efforts at existing
protected beaches. To accomplish this requires investment in programs focusing on community
empowerment, public awareness, enforcement, inter-governmental collaboration and scientific studies;
these will all be important factors in ensuring the long-term survival of these species.
THE XUNLIAO GUANGDONG PROVINCE EXPERIENCE: RELEASING SEA TURTLES FOR
RESTOCKING AND CONSERVATION AWARENESS IN CHINA
George Balazs1, Ka-yan Ng2, He-Xiang Gu3, and Feiyan Zhang3
1
NOAA Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, Hawaii USA
City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR P. R. China
3
Huidong Gangkou Sea Turtle National Nature Reserve, P. R. China
2
There is widespread global and historic multi-cultural interest in releasing or returning sea turtles to the sea
for restocking efforts, conservation awareness, government-sponsored activities, and even for religious
purposes. Sources of these turtles have included hatchlings from artificial hatcheries, captive rearing
projects, captive breeding, fishery by-catch, and turtle rehabilitation facilities. Often the turtles are released
in considerable numbers with advance publicity attracting many adult and child spectators filled with
excitement and interest. The mass release of sea turtles for restocking and conservation awareness in
36
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Mainland China occurs periodically but not predictably as to date and location. Very little information in
English has been reported outside of China about internal turtle release events. These activities usually
include the release of other marine life such as fish, shrimp, and crabs obtained from aquaculture facilities.
On June 6, 2012 the authors were honored to participate in the release of 134 turtles and an array of other
marine life at Xunliao, Oceania Point Resort, in Guangdong Province, People's Republic of China. The
event marked the government's seasonal closure prohibiting the use of certain fishing gear in the South
China Sea, including Guangdong Province. Thirty-four of the turtles released were from fishery by-catch
turned in to the authorities by fishermen. These turtles ranged up to 99 cm carapace length and included 33
green turtles and one loggerhead all obtained from the coastal waters of Guangdong Province, such as Daya
Bay. In addition, 100 others were captive-reared green turtles estimated to be 45cm carapace length. All
turtles appeared to be healthy, active, and in excellent body condition. This presentation explores and
photographically illustrates some of the unique aspects of China's spectacular sea turtle release
phenomenon, as witnessed at Xunliao. Ideas are set forth for the possibility of enhanced conservation study
involving both cultural and biological science perspectives. The People's Republic of China has vigorous
and growing sea turtle conservation and research programs that deserve praise and partnership to improve
the status of regional stocks.
AN UPDATE ON THE STATUS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN VIEQUES AND AN
EXAMPLE IN CO-MANAGEMENT OF THE SPECIES BETWEEN GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
AND COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS
Mike Barandian1, Mitsuka Bermudez2, Francheska Ruiz1, and Erick Bermudez1
1
2
USFWS-Vieques NWR, Viegues, Puerto Rico, USA.
TICATOVE, Inc. & USFWS- Vieques NWR, Viegues, Puerto Rico, USA.
There is an informational void on the status of sea turtles in Vieques and the role that this island plays in
the overall conservation of these endangered species in Puerto Rico, to this date. Therefore we will be
presenting information on the sea turtle monitoring program that has been taking place in Vieques (both on
and off the Vieques National Wildlife Refuge) since the U.S. Navy left the island and transferred the
property to the Municipality of Vieques, the Puerto Rico Conservation Trust and the Department of the
Interior. This data and work will be contrasted with the previous sea turtle management work done by the
U.S. Navy. The presentation will highlight the cooperation and co-management of sea turtle conservation
between Government Agencies (the PR-DNER and the USFWS) and local community groups in Vieques
(TICATOVE, Sea Grant at UPR in Humacao, the Vieques Historical and Conservation Trust). The
programs continues to go through growing pains and improvements; yet we believe that it is proving itself
to be successful and may be useful to other municipalities in Puerto Rico or even other regions that could
benefit from this type of cooperative sea turtle conservation efforts between well trained community based
conservation organizations and Government agencies.
37
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
COMMUNITY-BASED CONSERVATION OF MARINE TURTLES ON TETEPARE ISLAND,
SOLOMON ISLANDS
Allan Bero1, Hobete Aku1, John Read2, Katherine Moseby2, Gillian Goby1, Eleanor Sterling3, and
Michael Esbach3
1
Tetepare Descendants' Association, Munda, Solomon Islands
Ecological Horizons, Adelaide, Australia
3
Center for Biodiversity and Conservation, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY, USA
2
Tetepare Island, the largest uninhabited island in the South Pacific, is an icon of Solomon Islands
biodiversity and conservation management. In response to destructive logging threats, displaced
landowners formed the Tetepare Descendants' Association (TDA) with the core objective of conserving
natural resources for the use of future generations. TDA’s flagship conservation program is focused on
monitoring and conserving marine turtles, particularly greens (Chelonia mydas), hawksbills (Eretmochelys
imbricata), and leatherbacks (Dermochelys coriacea), in both their foraging and nesting environments.
Through this monitoring, TDA seeks to gain a better understanding of the demographic characteristics,
distribution, and population status of globally endangered sea turtles around Tetepare. By strengthening and
expanding existing community-based monitoring programs, this project also seeks to empower local
communities to manage their resources, laying the foundation for long-term marine turtle conservation. In
addition, by linking this community-based effort to nearby islands, this project is able to catalyze
partnerships that can cope with local economic and social challenges to sea turtle conservation. Results
from this study will improve our overall understanding of sea turtles in the greater Pacific region, and
contribute to the development of an effective management plan to protect sea turtles and their ecosystems
around the island.
U.S. NAVY ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE AND CONSERVATION EFFORTS FOR SEA
TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC AND GULF OF MEXICO
Danielle M. Buonantony1, Richard. J. Nissen2, David T. MacDuffee2, Keith A. Jenkins3, Anurag
Kumar4, and Andrew DiMatteo4
1
Chief of Naval Operations, Washington, D.C., USA
U.S. Fleet Forces Command, Norfolk, VA, USA
3
U.S. Navy Marine Mammal Program San Diego, CA, USA
4
Naval Facilities Engineering Command Atlantic, Norfolk, VA, USA
2
Environmental stewardship is an integral part of the Navy’s mission. It protects and preserves the
capabilities of training areas, ensures operational flexibility, and sustains the resources and public support
needed to carry out the Navy’s mission. The Navy is responsible for compliance with a suite of
environmental and natural resources laws and regulations that apply to the marine environment, and in
particular, to sea turtles. To comply with these mandates, the Navy works closely with regulatory agencies
and must be able to properly evaluate the impacts of at-sea training activities on protected species. In order
to institute efforts to minimize these impacts there must be: 1) the best available data on the density and
distribution of the species in question; 2) the criteria necessary to assess impacts; and 3) the creation of the
practical mitigation measures. To meet these objectives, the Navy developed the Navy Marine Species
Density Database (NMSDD) which documents density estimates for all sea turtle populations where the
Navy primarily trains in the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico. The Navy also established an initial set of
38
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
quantitative criteria for assessing acoustic impact to sea turtles from sonar and explosives. These data are
utilized in regulatory compliance documents to support quantitative modeling and qualitative assessments
of the potential impacts of a variety of Navy stressors on sea turtles and their habitats, including but not
limited to the use of sonar, explosives, and military expended materials. Additionally, the Navy employs
mitigation measures both at-sea and on Navy installations to minimize the impacts of Navy activities on sea
turtles and to promote conservation of their populations. Some of these measures include monitoring sea
turtle nests on Navy beaches during the nesting season, having trained lookouts to observe mitigation zones
during at-sea training activities to minimize potential effects to sea turtles, and conducting or funding sea
turtle research to reduce knowledge gaps. The Navy continues to be a leader in environmental stewardship
and utilize the best technology and techniques to improve our compliance and conservation efforts with
respect to sea turtle populations. However, deficiencies in the amount or quality of data available, as well
as access to research, can significantly limit the Navy’s ability to assess and mitigate impacts. As a result,
the Navy plans to improve partnerships with international, federal, state, and local agencies; public and
private organizations; and academic institutions by engaging stakeholders to maximize our effectiveness in
addressing environmental issues.
NESTING OF LEATHERBACKS AT COSTA RICA NORTH CARIBBEAN COAST
Didiher Chacón-Chaverri1, Didiher A. Chacón-Vargas1, Luis Fonseca-Lopez1, and Vanessa Lizano2
1
2
WIDECAST, Costa Rica
Ecopareadero, Limón, Costa Rica
The project was developed in the north Caribbean coast of Costa Rica, particularly on Pacuare and Moín
Beaches. The objective was the protection and monitoring of sea turtle nesting on these locations. These
places have very strong and particular threats over the nests, nesting females and habitat. The poaching of
eggs, the hunting specifically over green and hawksbill and the impact of ocean erosion, expressed as loss
of sand, excess of organic matter deposited on beach and coastal floods were the most important impacts
over the nesting critical habitats. Both places show a nesting over 2000 nests of leatherback, green and
hawksbill turtles. Monitoring and conservation patrols, hatcheries, alternative livelihoods and
environmental education were some of the activities developed to reduce the impacts and increase the
number of hatchlings getting the water.
COMMUNITY BASED SEA TURTLE CONSERVANCY IN SOUTHEASTERN PUERTO RICO:
PROYECTO ATMAR A STORY OF SUCCESS.
Luis A. Crespo1, Carlos E. Diez2, and ATMAR volunteeers1
1
2
Proyecto ATMAR, Maunabo, Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico Department of Natural Resources, San Juan, Puerto Rico
Since 2001 and through the ATMAR Project, community volunteers in the coastal town of Maunabo
southeast of the island of Puerto Rico have worked to assist in the conservation of sea turtles. This project
is a story of success in community-based turtle conservation. Organized and run by community volunteers
who are committed to stop the poaching of nests and turtles, ATMAR Project is the oldest of its kind in
Puerto Rico and has become a model for other coastal communities on the island. It has worked
continuously for 12 years and has helped other communities to get organized and to work for the same
purpose. More than 65 volunteers have been involved with the project, and several thousand people have
39
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
been impacted. Volunteer work includes conducting nests surveys, night patrols, tagging turtles and
hatchling work. All field data obtained through their work is part of the National Sea Turtle Project of
Puerto Rico. Volunteers also serve as guides to those who are interested in learning about sea turtles. A
very important part of their work is educational - visiting schools, churches, communities and universities
to inform others about the project and its work. Volunteers also utilize newspaper, television, radio, and
internet outlets (www.tortugasmaunabo.com) to publish information about the project and the importance
of conservation. As a result of the project, nest poaching decreased significantly (6% in the early years).
During the past three years the poaching of nests and turtles has been 0 %. In addition, leatherback nests
have increased from 53 to 199 per season and hawksbill nests increased from 15 to 129 per season.
Proyecto ATMAR thanks our sponsors: Puerto Rico Department of Natural and Environmental Resources,
Regional Newspaper LA ESQUINA, Cooperativa Mauna-Coop and Sea Grant-University of Puerto Rico at
Humacao Campus.
THE PROTECTION OF SEA TURTLE IN NEW CALEDONIA
M. Jean Louis D'Auzon1, Théa Jacob2, M. Dominique Lafage3, and Laurence Bachet4
1
ASNNC, Nouméa, New Caledonia
WWF, Nouméa, New Caledonia
3
BWARA TORTUES MARINES, Bourail, New Caledonia
4
DENV, Nouméa, South Province, New Caledonia
2
Here we present the history of sea turtle occurrence and protection in New Caledonia. The “Bwara Tortues
Marines” association was created by Emmanuel Hernu and Dominique Lafage in July 2006 to protect "La
Roche Percee" Beach, which is the first nesting beach for Caretta caretta in New Caledonia. There are
numerous threats to nesting sea turtles, including stray dogs, fires and lights of the campers and residents,
cars on the beach and egg poachers. Cages were constructed to protect the nests from dogs. Four-hour
patrols were conducted every evening (8:30 pm) and morning (5:00 am) on the beaches of “ La Roche
Percee” (1.8 kilometers) and “Baie des Tortues” (.3 km). We have education programs to raise awareness
of the locals but behavior modification is difficult and we do not hesitate to lodge complaints to the
authorities against the offenders. We also have a school program to educate young people about sea turtle
conservation. We work with two South Pacific scientists, George Balasz of Hawaii and Colin Limpus of
Australia, to create a database for turtles and their nests. We created a nursery for trees resistant to sea
spray to reforest the coast. We also worked with the authorities to create current fisheries legislation.
Harvesting and/or selling sea turtles and their eggs is now forbidden, as well as the disturbance of nesting
sea turtles by humans or dogs. Melanesians have the right to harvest turtles for food only for important
ceremonies and have to request permission from the authorities.
SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN UNITED ARAB EMIRATES: STATUS OF
IMPLEMENTATION OF IOSEA MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
Himansu S. Das and Maitha A. Al Hameli
Environment Agency Abu Dhabi, UAE
Two species of sea turtles, the hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata) and green (Chelonia mydas),
predominantly occur in the waters of the Emirate of Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates (UAE). Both
40
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
species extensively use UAE waters for foraging and one species, the hawksbill, nests on the sandy beaches
of at least 18 offshore islands. UAE is a signatory to the UNEP-CMS Memorandum of Understanding
(MoU) on the conservation and management of marine turtles and their habitats of the Indian Ocean and
South-East Asia (IOSEA) since 2007. The “Conservation and Management Plan” (CMP) appended to the
MoU lists 6 objectives and 24 programmes (actions) to be considered by signatory states for
implementation. UAE has been undertaking at least 60% of the actions listed in the CMP. Investigation of
causes of sea turtle mortality reveals that 46% of sea turtles die from drowning in illegal or abandoned
fishing nets followed by 25% from vessel strike. Seasonal aerial surveys indicate that at least 67.4% of sea
turtles (both green and hawksbill) occur within the MPAs during 2011compared to 62% in winter 2004 and
64.8% in winter 2009. This trend of gradual increase of foraging turtles within the protected areas may be
the result of protection of foraging areas of green as well as hawksbill sea turtles within the MPAs. All
nesting beaches in the UAE are protected by Federal Law no 23 (1999) and are being monitored
continuously since 2000. Inter-annual nesting variability ranges from 155 to 242 nests in the emirate of
Abu Dhabi and 142 to 261 nests in the emirate of Sharjah. Data on nesting processes and patterns are being
collected and analysed. As part of the objective under rehabilitation of sea turtle habitats, UAE has
regulations in place to rehabilitate sea turtle habitats impacted by human activities by implementing
appropriate mitigation measures. As part of the study to understand sea turtle ecology of the region, UAE
has been involved in a regional program of satellite tagging to study post nesting migration of the nesting
species in order to review and revise conservation initiatives taken up by the Range States within the Gulf.
Meetings with stakeholders, training to teachers, field tours for students, beach cleaning involving general
public are part of the public awareness program that has yielded significant results as evidenced by reports
of dead and stranded turtles by various stakeholders and increased number of requests by schools for
teachers training and field trips for students. The paper presents the status of implementation of IOSEA
MoU in the UAE and analyses the methods followed and results achieved.
MAKING CONNECTIONS: THE INTER-AMERICAN CONVENTION FOR THE PROTECTION
AND CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES (IAC)
Belinda M. Dick and Veronica C. Chamorro
Inter-American Convention for the Protection and Conservation of Sea Turtles (IAC), Washington D.C.,
USA
Without a doubt, sea turtles connect us. As ambassadors of the oceans they bring people and countries
together. The Inter-American Convention for the Protection and Conservation of Sea Turtles (IAC) is
becoming a leader in this initiative by connecting decision makers, scientists and NGOs in order to make
the best possible management decisions for the future of this species. In 2001, the IAC was established to
encourage international cooperation to protect and conserve sea turtles in the Americas. The IAC is quite
unique in being the only legally binding treaty for sea turtle conservation and protection in the Western
Hemisphere. Its objective is to promote the protection, conservation and recovery of the populations of sea
turtles and those habitats on which they depend by using the best available scientific information and taking
into consideration the environmental, socioeconomic and cultural characteristics of the parties. Although
the Conference of the Parties is the highest entity of the Convention, it has two subsidiary bodies, the
Consultative Committee of Experts (CCE) and the Scientific Committee (SC), to which each country
nominates a specialist in diverse topics relating to sea turtles. The CCE has an additional nine members,
three from each of the following sectors: non-governmental organizations, private sector and scientific
community. These committees, as well as the participation of official IAC observers, provide the IAC with
a balanced, transparent approach to address current challenges facing sea turtles. In order to strengthen its
ability to effect change, the IAC supports efforts to harmonize national legislation throughout the region by
providing countries with guidelines to prepare national sea turtle action plans and thus provide a more
effective management. The IAC promotes cooperation among its party countries and non-party countries
through a series of agreements, resolutions and memorandums of understanding to help create policies and
41
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
programs that safeguard sea turtles and their habitats. For example, under these agreements and resolutions,
IAC Parties have taken actions such as the creation of protected areas specifically for sea turtles and
prohibiting certain types of fisheries. In order for the IAC to follow-up on compliance with the mandates of
the Convention, IAC Parties submit annual reports highlighting their activities in favor of sea turtle
protection and conservation, especially regarding the leatherback and hawksbill turtles, their efforts to
mitigate fisheries interactions with sea turtles and adaptation to climate change. Just a decade after its
existence, it is important to recognize and applaud the efforts and achievements carried out by its current 15
member countries in implementing the objectives of the Convention. The IAC is a testament to the
extraordinary regional efforts taken to preserve these ancient animals, and inspires all of us to continue this
good work by addressing the many challenges that sea turtles still face.
CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES IN PUERTO RICO: FROM SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH TO
COMMUNITY-BASED MANAGEMENT.
Carlos E. Diez1, Raimundo Espinoza2, Luis Crespo3, and Suki Bermudez4
1
Department of Natural and Environmental Resources of Puerto Rico, San Juan, Puerto Rico
The Nature Conservancy, San Juan, Puerto Rico
3
ATMAR, Maunabo, Puerto Rico
4
TICATOVE, Vieques
2
During the early 1990s until the 2010s, sea turtle projects in Puerto Rico focused on basic research
conducted by university and government agencies. These studies were related to status surveys, genetics,
fibropapillomatosis assessments, migration patterns, sex ratios, population trends and dynamics, amongst
other specialized studies such as diving behavior and diet selection. These studies contributed greatly in the
elaboration of management and recovery plans for sea turtle species that occur in Puerto Rico (hawksbill
turtles, green turtles and leatherbacks). However, many of the recommendations that these studies yielded
were not implemented. During 2010, the Department of Natural and Environmental Resources of Puerto
Rico (DNER) started to deputize management and conservation strategies through local community-based
groups (most of them incorporated as “non-profit” organizations). A total of eight groups are authorized to
conduct such tasks. These groups are: ATMAR (Maunabo-Yabucoa), Vida Marina (Isabela), Yo Amo El
Tinglar (Hatillo, Arecibo, Barceloneta), ATIPUR (San Juan), Chelonia (Dorado and Culebra), TICATOVE
(Vieques), Coalición del Corredor Ecológico del Noreste (Luquillo-Fajardo) and Playas pal Pueblo (Isla
Verde). The groups are responsible for collecting statistical data (nests counts and hatchling production).
Also, they are authorized to conduct management actions such as beach clean-ups, habitat restoration,
stranding/rehabilitation of injured animals, assist hatchlings and adult females during disorientation events,
preventive vigilance against poachers, control of exotic predators, outreach and proposed designations for
protected areas. All these activities are in close coordination and collaboration with the DNER. The
following presentation illustrates the significant contributions of combining both strategies (scientific
research and community-based management).
42
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
INTERAGENCY COLLABORATIONS IN MARYLAND 1990-2012: NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
AND MARYLAND DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Cindy Driscoll1, Tami Pearl2, Jamie Testa1, Allison Turner2, Brenda Kibler1, and Jack Kumer2
1
2
MD DNR Fish and Wildlife Health Program, Oxford, MD, USA
National Park Service, Berlin, MD USA
The Maryland Department of Natural Resources (MD DNR) formed the Sea Turtle Stranding Program in
the Fall of 1990. MD DNR is responsible for all dead-stranded sea turtles in Maryland waters as well as
nesting sea turtles. Our geographic response area includes 3,800 miles of Maryland coastline in the
Chesapeake Bay and on the Atlantic Ocean. Assateague Island is a 37-mile (60 km) long barrier island
located off the eastern coast of the Delmarva Peninsula. The northern two-thirds of the island is in
Maryland while the southern third is in Virginia. The MD DNR has partnered with the National Park
Service at Assateague Island National Seashore in an effort to document species occurrence, causes of
strandings and nesting activities, as well as to promote sea turtle conservation. This presentation
summarizes 22 years of collaborative conservation in Maryland. The majority of stranded sea turtles are
found along the coast of the Atlantic Ocean and this presentation will focus on the species found along
AINS shores. Four species of sea turtles have been found in Maryland: loggerhead (Caretta caretta), green
(Chelonia mydas), leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea), and Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys kempii). The
loggerhead is the most commonly stranded sea turtle. Loggerhead strandings increased in 1998, 2001 and
2002, and leatherbacks stranded in large numbers along the mid-Atlantic coast in 2004. Data collection
parameters include date, species, location, carcass size, body decomposition index, evidence of human
interaction, and gross necropsy findings. Little is published about sea turtles in Maryland, yet there is a
need to provide this information when conservation measures are proposed. Two loggerhead nesting events
have been fully documented in the 22 years of our partnership: one in 1999 and one in 2012. False crawls
are rarely reported, but have been noted. A nesting protocol is currently being developed with other
partners to help protect nesting beaches and document nesting attempts. We hope to gain a better
understanding of threats to sea turtles in our state through a thorough examination of nesting in the midAtlantic with a comparison to stranding records. Acknowledgements: The authors wish to thank all past
and current rangers and natural resource biologists in sea turtle conservation in MD, including federal and
state staff the Assateague Island National Seashore.
INFLUENCE OF TIDAL CURRENTS ON OFFSHORE MIGRATION AND SURVIVAL OF SEA
TURTLE HATCHLINGS RELEASED FROM THE GULF OF FONSECA, HONDURAS
Noemi Duran1 and Stephen G. Dunbar1,2
1
Marine Research Group, Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma
Linda, California, USA. Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research, Inc.
(ProTECTOR), Colton, California, USA.
2
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research (ProTECTOR) Honduras,
Tegucigalpa, Honduras.
Punta Raton is the main olive ridley nesting beach on the Pacific coast of Honduras. As part of a
conservation project established by the Honduran Government, more than 200,000 hatchlings have been
released since 1975, yet until 2011, no studies had been performed on their fate, and there were no data
available on survival or mortality rates. Because Punta Raton is located in the eastern end of the Gulf of
43
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Fonseca, a shallow inlet of the Pacific Ocean, released hatchlings must swim more than 30 km towards the
West before reaching the open sea. In 2011, we carried out a study on aquatic predation during hatchling
offshore migration. Although no predation events were observed, we did observe tidal currents strongly
affecting hatchling movement. From September to November 2012, we followed 14 hatchlings for up to 12
hours, releasing them at different times respective to high tide and tracking their movements until the next
high tide. We released half of the hatchlings from the local hatchery and the other half from the main
nesting beach in the area, 2 km South of the hatchery. We plotted our data in a GIS and observed that the
hatchlings released from the hatchery moved Southwest during the outgoing tide but were pulled Northeast,
in the opposite direction to the mouth of the Gulf, during incoming tidal movements. One hatchling was
carried several miles up into one of the local estuaries. Hatchlings released from the nesting beach were
also pulled back towards the coast during incoming tides, but their trajectories were more variable. To
assess the influence of tidal currents in the absence of hatchling movement, we did two trials (one from
each releasing point) with dead hatchlings. Their trajectories followed the same patterns as live hatchlings.
These results suggest that hatchlings released from Punta Raton become entrapped in the tidal cycle,
delaying their exit from the Gulf and extending their vulnerability to predation, entanglement in nets, and
beach strandings. The possibility exists that these hatchlings are staying in the estuaries and using them as
early juvenile feeding grounds, although this seems unlikely since there are currently no reports of neonates
or juvenile Olive ridleys seen in the area. Further research is needed to assess if hatchlings from Punta
Raton are eventually able to leave the Gulf, the temporal scale of this exodus, and what routes they may be
utilizing. Conclusions from this and subsequent studies will also have important applications to assessing
and enhancing the effectiveness of the sea turtle conservation efforts currently implemented by the
Honduran Government. This research has been funded by ProTECTOR, the Boyd Lyon Sea Turtle Fund
and a Sigma Xi grant from Loma Linda University. I appreciate the Travel Award granted by the
International Sea Turtle Symposium to attend the 2013 meeting, supported by generous donations from the
International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service,
Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics
and CLS America.
ON EFFECTIVE PARTNERSHIPS THROUGH SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION
Michael Esbach
Center for Biodiversity and Conservation, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY, USA
Across the world’s oceans and coastlines, the territories of indigenous peoples often overlap with critical
sea turtle habitats. Consequently, the fate of these ancient mariners lies heavily in the hands of indigenous
or local communities, placing community-level partnerships at the heart of sea turtle conservation efforts.
This idea is not new; conservation organizations have been partnering with communities for decades.
However, with a focus on awareness and scientific monitoring activities, many of these partnerships have
been unable to link community action to direct conservation efforts and have failed to engender a long-term
commitment to sea turtle conservation. In order to be successful, these partnerships can no longer be
consultative or passive, but need to accept the diverse perspectives of local communities and focus on
enabling community decision-making capacity and fostering opportunities for community-level
engagement in sea turtle conservation. Sea turtles represent an excellent opportunity to achieve this type of
partnership due to their ability to attract international investment, focus capacity-building objectives,
increase community-level engagement, and ultimately provide a platform for indigenous voices. Overall,
this type of participatory engagement can improve the long-term conservation of sea turtles in changing
social, political, and ecological contexts. To illustrate this point, I provide a case study that identifies the
challenges and impacts of a partnership between the Tetepare Descendants’ Association (TDA) from the
Solomon Islands and the Center for Biodiversity and Conservation at the American Museum of Natural
History. With increased investment, we are strengthening TDA’s flagship conservation program focused on
monitoring sea turtles, which provides us with a clear capacity building agenda and also empowers this
communities’ agency to steward their customary resources.
44
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
A DECISION FRAMEWORK FOR PRIORITIZING MULTIPLE MANAGEMENT ACTIONS
Mariana MMPB Fuentes1, Bob Pressey1, Piero Visconti2, and Helene Marsh3
1
ARC COE, James Cook University, Australia
Sapienza Università di Roma
3
SEES, James Cook University, Australia
2
Conservation funds are grossly inadequate to address the plight of marine turtles. Government and
conservation organizations faced with the task of conserving marine turtles desperately need simple
strategies for allocating limited resources. The whole array of management actions necessary to stop
decline and support recovery of marine turtles is usually described in their recovery plans, which aim to
maximize the long term survival. Although recovery plans often provide a planned and logistical
framework for policy makers to coordinate their work, the majority do not provide any support to help
prioritize resources across identified management actions, and when they do, there is no transparency of
how these priorities were determined. However, where conservation targets and management actions are
diverse, within a species or population, the frameworks that set these priorities are vital. Here we present a
novel framework which explicitly prioritizes actions necessary to minimize the impacts of several threats
across the geographic range of the flatback turtle population in the Gulf of Carpentaria and Torres Strait
(GOC/TS). This framework includes a budget constraint and maximizes the expected improvement in
species persistence, resulting from a set of selected management actions that accounts for the likelihood of
the action being successfully applied and accepted by local communities. This structured approach can be
applied to guide prioritization of other species in similar contexts.
DEVELOPMENT OF A SUSTAINABLE ECO-TOURISM SYSTEM AT BLUFF BEACH, BOCAS
DEL TORO PROVINCE, PANAMA.
Emma Harrison1, Drew Hart2, and Cristina Ordoñez Espinosa2
1
2
Sea Turtle Conservancy, San Jose, Costa Rica
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Bocas del Toro, Panama
Bluff Beach, located on Isla Colón, in Bocas del Toro Province, on the Caribbean coast of Panama,
supports nesting populations of leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) and hawksbill (Eretmochelys
imbricata) sea turtles. Unfortunately, various anthropogenic threats have been identified in recent years,
including the illegal take of nests and females, and degradation of the nesting habitat through sand
extraction and inappropriate use of the beach during the filming of reality television programs. The local
indigenous community acknowledged the potential negative impacts of such threats on these critically
endangered species, and in 2010 established a grassroots conservation organization; the Bocas Hawksbill
Association (Asociación Natural Bocas Carey - ANABOCA). Members of ANABOCA have been working
with Sea Turtle Conservancy (STC) staff to conduct a regular monitoring and conservation program along
4.8 km of beach since 2010; results indicate that 250 – 300 leatherback, and 100 – 150 hawksbill nests are
laid each season. Due to its proximity to Bocas Town, and relative ease of access, Bluff Beach is subject to
considerable tourist activity, especially tours to observe nesting turtles at night. To date, however, such
tours have been conducted in an ad hoc and uncontrolled manner, with no formalized training of guides, no
regulation of the number of tourists permitted on the beach, and no established regulations or best practices.
These problems arise primarily from the fact that while designated as a Municipal Reserve, Bluff Beach is
not included in the official list of protected areas of the National Environmental Authority (Autoridad
45
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Nacional del Ambiente – ANAM); thus there is no law enforcement or protection, no restriction of access,
and no control on the use of the natural resources in the Reserve. During 2012, under its contract with the
USAID Regional Program for the Management of Aquatic Resources and Economic Alternatives, STC has
collaborated with ANABOCA and other regional stakeholder groups to form an Advisory Group for Bluff
Beach Municipal Reserve, with the goals of: a) establishing a turtle tourism program for the Reserve that
ensures economic benefit for the local community while simultaneously minimizing the impacts of tourism
on turtles and the nesting habitat; b) working with the municipality to encourage them to establish the
Reserve as an ANAM protected area, and thus ensure its adequate protection; and c) establishing a
management plan for the Reserve, which will ultimately subsume the turtle tourism administrative program
and ensure its long-term viability. The Advisory Group has also assisted ANABOCA in obtaining legal
incorporation and developing a business structure, and has provided scientifically-informed training for
guides and beach monitors. Results from a series of meetings and workshops conducted throughout 2012
will be presented, to demonstrate the development of the Advisory Group and the steps taken to establish a
sustainable turtle tourism program at Bluff Beach. Conclusions and recommendations will be provided, as
will an analysis of some problems encountered to date, and the solutions devised to address them. There
will also be a summary of the proposed next phase in this ongoing process.
HABITAT-USE OF BREEDING GREEN TURTLES, CHELONIA MYDAS, TAGGED IN DRY
TORTUGAS NATIONAL PARK, USA: MAKING USE OF LOCAL AND REGIONAL MPAS
Kristen M. Hart1, David G. Zawada2, Ikuko Fujisaki3, and Barbara H. Lidz2
1
United States Geological Survey, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Davie, Florida, USA
United States Geological Survey, St. Petersburg Coastal and Marine Science Center, St. Petersburg,
Florida, USA
3
University of Florida, Department of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation/Ft. Lauderdale Research and
Education Center, Davie, Florida, USA
2
Use of existing marine protected areas (MPAs) by far-ranging marine turtles can be determined using
satellite telemetry. Because of a lack of information on MPA use by marine turtles in the Gulf of Mexico,
we used satellite transmitters in 2010 and 2011 to track movements of 11 adult female breeding green
turtles (Chelonia mydas) tagged in Dry Tortugas National Park (DRTO), in the Gulf of Mexico, south
Florida, USA. Turtles nested every 9 to 18 days and consistently used a common core-area within the
DRTO boundary, determined using individual 50% kernel-density estimates (KDEs). We mapped the area
in DRTO where individual turtle 50% KDEs overlapped using the USGS Along-Track Reef-Imaging
System, and determined the diversity and distribution of various benthic-cover types within the mapped
area. We also tracked turtles post-nesting as they transited to foraging sites 5 to 282 km away from tagging
beaches; these sites were located both within DRTO and in the surrounding area of the Florida Keys and
Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS), a regional MPA. Year-round residency of 9/11
individuals (82%) both within DRTO and in the FKNMS represents novel non-migratory behavior which
offers an opportunity for conservation of this imperiled species at both local and regional scales. These data
comprise the first satellite-tracking results on adult nesting green turtles at this remote study site.
Additional tracking could reveal whether the distinct inter-nesting and foraging sites delineated here will be
repeatedly used in the future by these and other breeding green turtles.
46
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CURRENT STATUS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN SRI LANKA
Thushan Kapurusinghe
Turtle Conservation Project, 11, Perera Mawatha, Madakumbura, Panadura, Sri Lanka
Five species of sea turtles nest in Sri Lanka: green (Chelonia mydas), leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea),
olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea), loggerhead (Caretta caretta) and hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata)
turtles. Coastal communities of Sri Lanka depend on surrounding natural resources for their survival. In
addition, development activities are taking place in many coastal areas of the island. As a result, very
important coastal habitats (i.e. coral reefs, sea grass beds, mangroves) and coastal fauna (i.e. marine turtles)
are under serious threat of extinction. After the eradication of terrorism from the island, the government
now plans to extend development to the northeastern coast, which includes large scale tourism projects.
Domestic travel and tourism have increased after the war, resulting in coastal habitat degradation such as
damage to the coral reefs on the Pigeon Islands and Bar Reef of the Kalpitiya Peninsula. Large mangrove
areas have been cleared in Kalpitiya area to construct luxury hotels, disturbing the Puttlam lagoon system
where sea turtles and dolphins are found. Sea turtle hatcheries are still illegally operated in Sri Lanka and
the Department of Wildlife Conservation has failed to regulate these hatcheries. There is a great political
influence to keep the illegal turtle hatcheries in operation. Although the nesting turtles are protected in
National Parks (NP) such as Yala NP, Kumana NP and Wilpattu NP, natural predators account for nearly
100% egg predation in these areas. Sea turtle by-catch seems to be the biggest threat for survival in their
marine habitat. Thousands of turtles become entangled in fishing nets and drown each year. TCP has
recorded several fishhook entanglements associated with long-line fisheries but further research is needed
to fully understand this problem. The new harbor which is being constructed in Hambanthota is posing a
serious threat to sea turtles in the Ussangoda-Godawaya and Rekawa sea turtle sanctuaries. Additionally,
there is a proposal to remove beach sand from the Ussangoda-Godawaya Sanctuary. The planting of
introduced beach pines (Casuarina) along the beaches of Ussangoda-Godawaya sanctuary disturbs the sand
dune formation process and shows negative impacts on nesting activities of critically endangered
leatherback turtles. Sea turtles that nest in Kosgoda beach forage in Hikkaduwa Marine Sanctuary and these
turtles are being used as tourist attractions as children ride them and locals feed them. Although there is a
wildlife office located in Hikkaduwa Marine Sanctuary, they fail to prevent these illegal activities. Also,
both Kosgoda and Rekawa beaches are currently becoming narrower each year, limiting suitable nesting
habitat for sea turtles.
BYCATCH AND CUMULATIVE IMPACTS IN U.S. FISHERIES: WHERE ARE THEY NOW?
Amanda J. Keledjian, Beth Lowell, and Casey Youngflesh
Oceana, Washington, DC, USA
Fishing-related injury and mortality is one of the primary threats impeding the recovery of threatened and
endangered sea turtle populations in U.S. waters. Studies have estimated that up to 346,500 sea turtle
interactions occurred in U.S. fisheries each year throughout the 1990s, with over twenty percent of those
likely causing mortality. Many measures have since been implemented to minimize these harmful impacts,
but are they helping? We assess U.S. fisheries identified as having high levels of turtle bycatch over the last
two decades and provide an update on progress in three areas: accounting for cumulative impacts, reducing
bycatch, and refining bycatch estimates through improved observer coverage. This evaluation reveals the
cumulative number of takes authorized in U.S. fisheries and shows that even where improvements have
47
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
been made, many gaps still exist in comprehensively minimizing the harmful impacts of fisheries. No
improvements have been made by the National Marine Fisheries Service to account for cumulative
incidental takes across fisheries that operate in the same region and interact with the same populations of
turtles. Accounting for these significant cumulative impacts when authorizing additional incidental takes of
loggerheads and other sea turtle species is required under the Endangered Species Act and should be a
future priority. Although estimated bycatch has declined in a number of fisheries, we question the validity
of these estimates based on poor compliance with conservation measures, particularly in southeast Atlantic
shrimp trawls. Likewise, observer coverage has improved in only a few of the fisheries, with coverage
actually declining since the early 2000s in several cases, leaving insufficient data to accurately estimate
bycatch. Oceana combats these shortcomings by promoting measures that will ensure adequate
management, monitoring, and enforcement. In the coming years, it will be important for the National
Marine Fisheries Service to develop a cost-effective system to effectively document cumulative impacts,
elucidate the sub-lethal impacts of fisheries interactions, and enforce existing conservation regulations.
This analysis highlights the importance of advocacy and litigation in ensuring that fishing activities are not
threatening the recovery or future existence of sea turtle populations within U.S. waters.
MANAGEMENT TOOLS TO PROTECT THE CALIFORNIA CURRENT LARGE MARINE
ECOSYSTEM: ARE THEY ENOUGH TO SAVE LEATHERBACK AND LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES?
Catherine Kilduff1, Miyoko Sakashita1, and Jaclyn Lopez2
1
2
Center for Biological Diversity, San Francisco, CA, USA
Center for Biological Diversity, St. Petersburg, FL, USA
As highly migratory species, sea turtles depend on safe passage through open oceans to successfully feed
and reproduce. Recent tagging data of Pacific leatherback and loggerhead sea turtles and other large marine
vertebrates has shed light on ocean migrations and the importance of the California Current large marine
ecosystem in attracting and retaining these animals. These data prompt the question of how to protect the
open water habitat of loggerhead and leatherback sea turtles. We compared and contrasted the recent
scientific papers on sea turtle concentrations and environmental parameters used to predict these
concentrations with available U.S. management measures. To protect and recover endangered leatherback
and loggerhead populations in the North Pacific Ocean, the U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service
(“Fisheries Service”) must designate critical habitat, defined by the Endangered Species Act as specific
geographic areas essential for conservation and that may require special management and protection. In
January 2012, the Fisheries Service identified leatherback critical habitat based on the density of prey items,
specifically gelatinous zooplankton, but declined to recognize migratory pathways as part of the critical
habitat. The Fisheries Service uplisted North Pacific Ocean loggerhead sea turtles from threatened to
endangered in September 2011, triggering their statutory requirement to designate critical habitat no later
than a year after designation. Critical habitat protection provides a greater chance of recovery of
endangered species. Species with critical habitat protected under the Endangered Species Act are twice as
likely to be recovering as those without. In the case of Pacific leatherback, the current implementation of
critical habitat protection is inadequate. Since designation of Pacific leatherback critical habitat, a scientific
study suggested that the time leatherback sea turtles spend searching for food may be hindering population
recovery, which underscores the need to protect sea turtle prey. Therefore the designation of prey density as
the primary element of critical habitat is a positive step. The Fisheries Service identified activities that may
affect leatherback critical habitat, but these are largely coastal threats, including coastal water pollution, oil
spill response, power plants, desalination plants, and tidal and wave energy projects. This suggests we need
to explore more ways to protect open water habitat within the 200-mile U.S. exclusive economic zone. The
Fisheries Service must designate North Pacific Ocean loggerhead critical habitat in the near future. This
provides a second chance to examine what parameters compose habitat for highly migratory species in the
California Current large marine ecosystem and how to define this habitat to ensure conservation and
recovery of sea turtles.
48
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ENHANCEMENT OF THE MARINE TURTLES LAND HABITAT QUALITY – GUADELOUPE
ARCHIPELAGO INSHORE PLANNING
François Korysko1, Eric Delcroix2, Sandra Pédurthe1, Sophie Bédel3, Guilhem Santelli3, Stéphane
Guyot4, Didier Lambert4, and Marion Diard5
1
Office National des Forêts - Direction régionale de Guadeloupe, Basse-Terre, Guadeloupe, France
Office National de la Chasse et de la Faune Sauvage, Lamentin, Guadeloupe, France
3
Non-profit organization
4
Conservatoire du Littoral - Antenne Guadeloupe, Basse-Terre, Guadeloupe, France
5
Non-profit organization Association Ti-Té, La Désirade, Guadeloupe, France
2
Three different species of marine turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata, Chelonia mydas, Dermochelys coriacea)
lay eggs on the Guadeloupe archipelago beaches from April to November and are protected by a National
Recovery Plan. Those same beaches are often the scenes of many human activities which may lead to
serious damages on marine turtles land habitat and on reproduction: large vegetation deterioration (quantity
and quality), sand compression made by vehicles, inappropriate lighting of the beaches, which can put the
turtles under pressure during the egg-laying season. The French Forest Service (ONF), The Fish and
Wildlife Service (ONCFS) and the Coastal Region Institute (CDL) in Guadeloupe, together with the
Marine Turtle Protection Network, are setting up an inshore management plan which is both taking into
account the human presence on the beaches and the protection of marine turtle laying sites. Inshore
management recommendations come from the following study : "The terrestrial habitat of sea turtles. Study
on its relation to coastal development and ecological recovery in the French West Indies", made by the
ONF and the Marine Turtle Protection Network in 2006.The main actions (that can be already done,
currently tested or planned) are : - the setting of regeneration enclosures, to reconstitute the natural coastal
plant cover - the creation of wooden fences, to avoid turtle road crossing. - Traffic control, car park or
artificial lighting management are also being analyzed. - Members of the Marine Turtle Protection Network
continue to actively watch the beaches to prevent any threat. - During the next 2 years, a thorough artificial
light disturbance analyze will be planned. - Vehicles traffic on beaches or cutting down of coastal
vegetation are illegal actions that will be more often controlled and prosecuted by the police. In addition to
that, a communication campaign was launched in 2011 to celebrate the 20th anniversary of the legalization
of turtle protection. A communication and technical guide was offered to local governments, to inshore
managers and to all the coastal operators in Guadeloupe throughout meetings and seminars. This
methodology guide fits more to territorial and practical needs and sums up the study recommendations.
Moreover, an ombudsman will be hired to help local governments. Information signs are placed on beaches
and communication actions are organized by the Marine Turtle Protection Network. The first results are
very positive: the plant cover is growing on supervised beaches and technical progress is made. From now
on, nesting sites are included in national and regional land management plans and political programs.
49
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
WWF'S MARINE TURTLE CONSERVATION PROGRAMME
Aimée Leslie1, Diego F. Amorocho2, Paolo Casale3, Creusa Hitipeuw4, Mamadou Diallo5, Marina
Antonopoulo6, and Marianne Fish7
1
WWF International, Gland, Switzerland
WWF Latin America and the Caribbean, Cali, Colombia
3
WWF Italy/Univ. of Rome, Rome, Italy
4
WWF Indonesia, Jakarta, Indonesia
5
WWF West Africa Marine Ecoregion, Dakar, Senegal
6
EWS/WWF United Arab Emirates, Dubai, UAE
7
WWF Canada, Vancouver, Canada
2
WWF has been working on marine turtle conservation for over 50 years, since its inception in 1961. As
threats to these fascinating and unique species increase, the next 10 years of conservation work will be
critical to ensure they continue to inhabit our seas and visit our beaches. Marine turtles are arguably the
most “global” of WWF’s species priorities, present in almost all the marine and coastal priority places
listed in the GPF, and in all of the world’s oceans. They cross thousands of kilometres of ocean and rely on
a wide range of very different coastal and marine ecosystems at different times during their life cycle. As a
consequence, marine turtle conservation requires a comprehensive approach to protection of many
important marine habitats, and to mitigation of key threats within those habitats. Marine turtles are thus a
symbol of key global threats to coastal and marine biodiversity and the importance of a marine
conservation agenda in most parts of the world. Therefore WWF has launched the Global Marine Turtle
Strategy (2012-2020). This strategy outlines WWF’s priorities for marine turtle conservation, taking into
account their conservation status and needs, and WWF’s role and niche. This strategy includes site-based
interventions, both on nesting beaches and in-water habitats (such as inter-nesting areas, foraging grounds
and migratory routes), as well as broader regional and international policy interventions. It focuses
specifically on five of the seven marine turtle species, but broad international, intergovernmental policy
interventions intended for these five species will most likely also benefit the other two species (Kemp’s
ridley and flatback turtles). The breadth and variety of WWF marine turtle projects reflect an evolving
conservation scenario – emerging from an initial focus on interventions on nesting beaches aimed at
protecting female turtles and their eggs. While these programmes remain an essential part of the overall
strategy, WWF’s efforts have expanded to: reduce bycatch in fisheries; support and advocate international
and intergovernmental policies to provide meaningful protection; generate community participation in
conservation; and address climate change. Research and management, capacity building, public education
and outreach have been key components of this work. Partnerships are vital to WWF’s conservation
practice, and we value our relationships with governments, industry and other non-governmental
organizations (NGOs). The purpose of this presentation is to give an overview of what WWF, in
collaboration with many external partners, has determined are key intervention points where we will be
focusing in the coming years. We would like to share some examples to receive feedback and determine
synergies with the global marine turtle conservation community, because we need to build on each other’s
efforts to have the biggest impact where it’s most needed. We’re running out of time and we need to do this
together. Help us help you help turtles.
50
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CONSERVATION EFFORTS TO PROTECT SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN THE
MALDIVES
Liraz Levy1, Alban Viaud1, Patrik Svensson2, and Thomas Le Berre2
1
2
Seamarc Pvt. Ltd. Four Seasons Resort, Kuda Huraa, North Male Atoll, Maldives
Seamarc Pvt. Ltd. Honey Dew, Izzuddeen Magu, Male’, Maldives
Five of the seven species of sea turtles can be found in the Maldives, the hawksbill (Eretmochelys
imbricata) and green (Chelonia mydas) turtles being the most common. Sea turtles face many threats in the
Indian Ocean: entanglement in ghost fishing nets and long lines, ingestion of marine debris and direct
capture for their shells, meat and eggs. In 1995, the Maldives Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture banned
the hunting and killing of sea turtles, as well as the importation and sale of turtles and turtle products. Even
though these actions have been implemented, sea turtle populations are still struggling to recover. The
Maldivian Sea Turtle Conservation Program was initiated by Seamarc Pvt. Ltd marine biologists to protect
sea turtles through conservation and research. Since 2011 we have been visiting local islands and hosting
school children to raise awareness of the importance of protecting turtles and their nests. As a result, we
have created a network of islanders that assist us in safeguarding turtle nests from poaching. To date, we
have protected nine nests and released more than 500 hatchlings. Nest location, depth, width and number of
undeveloped eggs are also recorded. Since hatchling survival rate in the wild is very low, we have
established a Head Start Program at Kuda Huraa Marine Centre. A few hatchlings from each protected nest
are brought to the rearing facilities, where they stay until they reach 30cm straight carapace length
(approximately 18 months) before being released. At this stage, their size protects them from the majority
of predators, increasing their chances of survival to maturity. Body weight, straight carapace length and
width and ID pictures are regularly recorded for each individual throughout their stay. Prior to their release,
a few individuals will be equipped with satellite trackers that record position, water temperature and dive
time. This information is of great scientific value since there is a significant lack of data regarding
migration patterns and preferred foraging grounds of juvenile sea turtles in Maldives and greater Indian
Ocean. Other important conservation projects include a rehabilitation program which was initiated in
March 2010 at Landaa Giraavaru Marine Centre. The Centre rescues ill and injured individuals and nurses
them back to health. To date, we have released 15 turtles back into the wild. We are also trying to estimate
the wild Maldivian sea turtle population. Since 2010, we have been conducting a photo identification
monitoring survey with marine biologists across the Maldives as part of a first national inventory. We now
have a database of more than 200 individuals. The date, location, size and sex are also recorded. We aim to
develop a nation-wide protection network with both local and resort islands in order to maintain a healthy
population of sea turtles in the Maldives through such research and conservation efforts.
51
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IDENTIFYING IMPACTS OF MONGOOSE PREDATION ON GREEN AND HAWKSBILL SEA
TURTLES AND PROTECTING NESTS AT SANDY POINT NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE,
ST. CROIX, USVI
Claudia D. Lombard1, Jennifer Valiulis2, Jerry Hairston3, and Amy Mackay2
1
US Fish and Wildlife Service, Christiansted, USVI
Geographic Consulting, Frederiksted, USVI
3
US Department of Agriculture Wildlife Services, Frederiksted USVI
2
Sandy Point National Wildlife Refuge (SPNWR) provides critical nesting habitat for three species of sea
turtle. Although widely known for the long-term saturation tagging and nest management activities
conducted on leatherbacks, SPNWR also supports large numbers of nesting greens and hawksbills which
have been monitored primarily through daytime track surveys. The introduced small Asian mongoose
(Herpestes javanicus) is a known predator of sea turtle nests. In an effort to curtail predation, intermittent
trapping and removal of mongoose has occurred at SPNWR since 1995. Trapping efforts were minimally
successful because of staffing and funding limitations. During the 2011 season, a more concerted effort was
made to document mongoose predation. Nests were monitored throughout incubation for signs of
depredation. Thirty five known hawksbill nests and 56 green nests were depredated. This constitutes 52%
of all confirmed hawksbill nests or 29% of all potential nests, and 35% of all confirmed green nests or 24%
of all potential nests. Mongoose predation on SPNWR was found to be a significant threat to green and
hawksbill sea turtles. Consequently, predator control was determined to be the most important management
activity for the 2012 season. Conibear® traps were deployed along the vegetation line of a section of the
nesting beach with high nesting densities. Trapping efforts effectively controlled mongoose and decreased
nest predation rates.
THE CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT STRATEGY FOR SEA TURTLES IN KENYA:
CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES
Douglas Maina
Kenya Sea Turtle Conservation & Management Trust (KESCOM), Mombasa, Kenya
The Government of Kenya has shown its commitment to sea turtle conservation through adapting
legislations such as the Wildlife Conservation and Management Act, the Fisheries Act, and the
Environment Management and Coordination Act, among others. Internationally, Kenya is a signatory to the
Convention on Migratory Species as well as the Indian Ocean South East Asia Memorandum of
Understanding on the conservation of sea turtles and their habitats. However, while marine turtle
conservation is provided for within these laws, the legislation is inadequate in scope, strength and penalties.
Effective management and recovery of Kenya’s sea turtle populations can therefore only be achieved
through implementation of a national strategy that links into regional and international initiatives to protect
nesting beaches and critical foraging habitats from degradation, eliminate illegal harvesting and trade in sea
turtles and their products, mitigate fisheries impacts, and enhance collaborative participation of local
communities and other stakeholders in conservation. The Kenya Wildlife Service through its Biodiversity
Research and Monitoring division’s team convened a meeting in November 2007 for representatives of all
key stakeholders in Sea Turtle conservation. The Kenya National Sea Turtle Taskforce was formed and
later endorsed by the Kenya Wildlife Service Board of Trustees. This taskforce was given the responsibility
52
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
to develop a national sea turtle conservation and management strategy which would provide a coordinated
framework for the conservation of sea turtles in Kenya. The national sea turtle conservation and
management strategy went through several developmental stages and was finally endorsed at another
Stakeholders’ Workshop held in 2009. Subsequently, the Kenya Sea Turtle Conservation Trust led
awareness activities on this policy before its formal launch in 2010. The strategy is consistent with
programmes including the formation of the Kenya Sea Turtle Conservation and Management Trust
(KESCOM) and is guided by FAO-ecosystems based management and similar instruments. It is aligned
with regional initiatives such as the Indian Ocean South East Asia Turtle MOU, the Marine Turtle
Conservation Strategy and Action Plan for the WIO, Marine Turtle Task Force (MTTF), IOSEA/Nairobi
Convention partnership, The Marine Turtle Specialist Group (MTSG), South Western Indian Ocean
Fisheries Commission and the National Oceans and Fisheries Policy. Thus, it contributes towards the
realization of Kenya’s Vision 2030 and the new constitution, which both emphasize stakeholder
participation in conservation. The main tools utilized include advocacy, communication, education, public
awareness, targeted research and monitoring and threat mitigation. Ultimately, the wider participation of
the local communities and other stakeholders, including scientists, government and non-governmental
institutions, is to be realized. It builds on ongoing efforts and initiates changes that will add value to sea
turtle conservation efforts. The strategy’s overall goal is to reduce and mitigate threats, reverse declining
sea turtle populations and enhance ecological, social and cultural benefits. This presentation highlights the
framework for sea turtle conservation in Kenya as guided by this management strategy, while outlining the
challenges and successes in its implementation.
PROJETO TAMAR: MATCHING THREATS AND CONSERVATION PRIORITIES FOR SEA
TURTLES IN BRAZIL
Maria A. Marcovaldi1, João C. Thomé2, Augusto C. C. Dias da Silva2, Gilberto Sales2, Bruno Giffoni1,
Berenice M. Gomes1, Cecília Baptistotte2, Eduardo Lima1, Juçara Wanderlinde1, Armando J. B. 1,
Alexsandro S. dos Santos1, Milagros L. Mendilaharsu1, and Gustave G. López1
1
2
Fundação Pró-TAMAR. Postal 2219, Rio Vermelho, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil
Projeto TAMAR/ICMBio. Caixa Postal 2219, Rio Vermelho, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil
Marine turtles are circumglobally distributed, inhabit nearly all oceans, occupy unique ecological niches
and are subject to different risks and threats. Therefore, several studies have acknowledged and identified
global sea turtle research and conservation priorities to address essential actions for their protection.
Considering the nearly continental dimensions of the Brazilian coast (8000 km) and the distribution of the
sea turtle species throughout its length, it is essential to assess and orient conservation actions. Given that
conservation resources are limited and conservation targets are diverse, it is important to concentrate efforts
and prioritize actions for the recovery of the populations of the five species of sea turtles that occur in
Brazil. Over 30 years of data collected by TAMAR/ICMBio through regular monitoring and research has
made it possible to identify threats to each species of sea turtle and highlight important gaps in available
information. A series of workshops were held with TAMAR’s technical team and experienced researchers
were invited. We categorized known threats to sea turtles and prioritized recovery actions. Threats were
identified and classified for each of the different life stages and ecosystems inhabited by the sea turtles. We
considered six life stages to facilitate the construction of the matrix: egg, hatchling, juvenile neritic,
juvenile oceanic, adult neritic and adult oceanic. As threats varied depending on the ecosystem inhabited by
the turtles, we incorporated beach and “in water” environments into the matrix. We assigned magnitudes to
threats (e.g. low, medium and high impact) based on the best available information (e.g. published data,
TAMAR database) and expert opinion to establish relative parameters. This work represents an
experimental exercise to assist us in our current actions and to address future issues.
53
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLE SEX RATIO ESTIMATOR
Maria S. Martins1 and Guilherme R. Barbosa2
1
2
Rua Almeida e Sousa, Lisboa, Portugal
Avenida Conde D. Henrique, Braga, Portugal
The conservation status of most marine species, including sea turtles, is difficult to assess. Nonetheless,
there is an international consensus on the need to protect sea turtles, since all seven species are threatened
to a certain degree and all are included on the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s (IUCN) red
list. Incidental capture, alteration and loss of habitat, direct take, and marine pollution are, among others,
the main threats these animals face. Climate change may also represent new cause for concern. In the case
of animals with temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), including sea turtles, small changes in the
incubation conditions can be sufficient in provoking important changes in the sex ratio of hatchlings. Air
temperature has been increasing globally for the past few decades and the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change estimates an average world increase of about 3ºC before the end of the century. As global
temperature is on the rise, the number of females produced in natural nests is expected to increase, leading
to a female-skewed population of adult sea turtles, or possibly a complete feminization of the species in the
future. In general, females are expected to breed less frequently than males, which allows an adult sex ratio
higher than 50% female to be sufficient to produce an operative ratio of 1:1 during the breeding season.
However, the dynamics of future adult populations can be threatened as the percentage of female hatchlings
rises, increasing their vulnerability to extinction. The Sea Turtle Sex Ratio Estimator (STSRE) is a new tool
that allows users to easily estimate hatchling sea turtle sex ratios (Primary Sex Ratio, SR) produced in nests
from various beaches. Based on sand or incubation temperatures, this tool calculates the average
temperature of the nest during the middle third of the incubation period (thermosensitive period) and
estimates SR taking into account 3 sex determination variables: pivotal temperature, transitional range of
temperatures and embryonic thermal tolerance. STSRE will allow users from all over the world to easily
calculate SR values for specific work (Individual Use), and also help to build (and continuously complete
and update) a global database of theoretical sea turtle SRs (Global Use). Ultimately, this will help scientists
evaluate the vulnerabilities and tendencies found in sea turtle populations. Thus, the main objective of the
STSRE is to help prioritize conservation areas with relation to climate change impacts, particularly global
warming. I would like to thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek,
Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for the Travel Grant that
have helped fund my travel costs for the 33rd ISTS in Baltimore, USA.
EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF SEA TURTLE LIGHTING LEGISLATION IN
FLORIDA
Jame McCray1, Rachel Bruce2, Thomas Ankersen2, Susan Jacobson1, and Raymond Carthy1
1
2
University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
UF Levin College of Law, Gainesville, Florida, USA
Artificial lighting negatively impacts sea turtle populations. It discourages females from nesting and
interferes with the ocean-finding abilities of hatchlings. This is a particularly salient issue in Florida, which
hosts 90% of the sea turtle nesting in the United States and is projected to have nearly 15 million people
living in its coastal counties by 2050. To reduce the impact of artificial light on sea turtles and their nesting
54
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
habitats, 84 local governments in Florida have passed beach lighting ordinances, most of them based on the
Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) model lighting ordinance for sea turtle protection (FL
Admin Code Rule 62B-55). This study employs a content analysis methodology to evaluate both biological
relevance, and strength of law for the State’s model lighting ordinance (62B-55), newly promulgated draft
best management practices, and the local government lighting ordinances currently in place. This study also
uses GIS technology to understand how the strength of law relates to the nesting densities throughout the
state.
CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS OF SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN NIGERIA
Adegbile O. Mojisola, B. B. Solarin, D.A. Adeogun, A.A. Ajulo, D.A. Bolaji, and R.O. Orimogunje
Nigerian Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research, Victoria-Island, Lagos, Nigeria
Sea turtles are part of Nigeria’s cultural and natural heritage, as five species have been documented feeding
offshore and nesting on beaches. According to historical information, they have been a part of the fisheries
for centuries. Although they are non-target species, their incidental capture in fisheries has aided their
exploitation for ages. However, nesting females and their eggs have been the targets of coastal dwellers for
centuries. Within the last three decades, fishermen began to value the incidentally captured sea turtles due
to the decline in fisheries and the need to keep body and soul together. Surveys conducted in coastal
communities since 2008 revealed that green (Chelonia mydas) and olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea)
turtles are the most commonly captured turtles. A single nesting green turtle has been reported to Nigerian
Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research (NIOMR). Investigations into the prospects and
challenges of sea turtle conservation in Nigeria indicate that educating coastal communities about the status
of the sea turtles is necessary for sea turtle conservation. The establishment of conservation programs, not
just for sea turtles alone but for marine species and habitats at large, is of paramount importance. There are
many challenges to sea turtle conservation, including poverty, low indigenous conservation in coastal
communities, coastal development, lack of marine conservation programs for coastal communities, nonenforcement of existing fisheries laws, inadequate scientific and historical data and lack of marine reserves.
There are many opportunities for sea turtle conservation in Nigeria provided that coastal dwellers are
educated and trained for a conservation program guided by accurate scientific data and information. These
efforts will aid sea turtle research and conservation in Nigeria.
BOHOL RESCUE UNIT FOR MARINE WILDLIFE: A VITAL COMPONENT OF SEA TURTLE
CONSERVATION IN BOHOL, PHILIPPINES
Kristina A. Pahang, Alessandro Ponzo, and Joshua N. Silberg
Physalus NGO, Jagna, Bohol, Philippines
The Province of Bohol, part of the Sulu-Sulawesi Marine Ecoregion in the Central Visayan region of the
Philippines, provides ideal sea turtle habitats across all life history stages. There are four species of sea
turtles found in the surrounding waters of Bohol Island: green (Chelonia mydas), hawksbill (Eretmochelys
imbricata), olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea), and leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea). These species
are listed by the IUCN as Endangered, Critically Endangered, Vulnerable, and Critically Endangered,
respectively. Despite existing laws, sea turtles are still caught for local consumption of meat and eggs are
still poached. Other threats include solid waste pollution, habitat destruction from unregulated tourism
55
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
development, fishery interactions and the exponential growth of the local human population. The existence
of threats to all sea turtle life stages highlights the urgency of conservation efforts. Unfortunately, no data
are available about sea turtles in the region. This report attempts to start filling these gaps by presenting
stranding data as an indicator of the presence and distribution of sea turtles in Bohol. The local stranding
network, named the Bohol Rescue Unit for Marine Wildlife (BRUMW) and the non-profit organization
Physalus responded to and recorded sea turtle strandings in the province. From June 2011 to September
2012, fifteen sea turtle strandings were documented. Hawksbill turtles were the most commonly stranded
species (8), followed by green (5), leatherback (1), and olive ridley (1). The leatherback turtle stranding in
May 2012 was only the second record of the species from the area and the olive ridley turtle currently in
rehabilitation represents the first record of this species in Bohol. Of the fifteen stranded turtles, nine were of
unknown sex (mostly juveniles). Six of the eleven live strandings were immediately released. Three turtles
were rehabilitated and successfully released back to the sea and one arrived in critical condition and did not
survive the first twelve hours of therapy. In addition, beach patrols and targeted interviews have identified
and protected more than fifteen nests in the municipality of Anda, where a 20-year old illegal headstarting
facility has been demolished and all the hatchlings released. Starting in 2010, an intensive information,
education, and communication (IEC) campaign led by Physalus comprehensively trained municipal
response units, provincial BRUMW members and local veterinarians to respond to strandings. This
complimented Physalus’ IEC program which presented lectures about turtles and marine ecosystems to
more than 10,000 students from schools along the south coast of Bohol. This is just a small first step toward
the protection and conservation of sea turtles in the province. IEC is a key tool for conservation and will be
supported by more rigorous data collection on the distribution of these species. The stranding data will be
used to identify, quantify and manage threats that are bringing these species to the brink of extinction.
δ13C AND δ15N BULK TISSUE STABLE ISOTOPE PATTERNS OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA
TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) IN THE EASTERN PACIFIC OCEAN
Lindsey E. Peavey1, Jeffrey A. Seminoff2, Robert L. Pitman2, and Steven D. Gaines1
1
Bren School of Environmental Science & Management, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA,
USA
2
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, CA, USA
Olive ridley sea turtles (Lepidochelys olivacea) come to shore annually to nest in the eastern Pacific Ocean,
but otherwise spend all of their time in the open ocean. Individuals have the ability to travel great distances,
however actual habitual movement patterns (niche width, distinct foraging regions, etc.) are largely
unknown. To advance our understanding of open ocean sea turtle foraging ecology, we analyzed the δ13C
and δ15N stable isotope values of bulk epidermis samples from 200 olive ridley sea turtles (Lepidochelys
olivacea) that were hand-captured in 2006 in three eastern tropical Pacific Ocean sub-regions: (1) Gulf of
California (GOA; n=29); (2) North Equatorial Current (NEC; n=33); and (3) Eastern Pacific Warm Pool
(n=138). We compared our findings to results from the analysis of 45 samples collected in 2003 from the
same region by Hess et al. in 2007. We found no significant difference in δ13C and δ15N between size
classes for all samples. We observed a significant difference in δ13C values between the GOC and the two
more southern sub-regions, but not between the two southern sub-regions themselves. We found δ15N to
enrich as latitude increased, with a significant difference between the values in the GOC and the two
southern sub-regions, but not between the two southern sub-regions themselves. Here, we spatially
contextualize observed isotopic patterns in olive ridleys oceanographically across the eastern Pacific Ocean,
which is a dynamic region that supports diverse ecosystems and foodwebs. We have identified potential
reasons for observed nitrogen isotopic patterns related to spatial variation in nutrient supply across the
region due to changes in thermocline depth, iron deficiency, and/or oxygen depletion. The most interesting
difference between our investigation and the prior study is that we found that both δ13C and δ15N values
decreased as distance from shore increased in the NEC region. Since δ13C values reflect the carbon source
for photosynthesis, this is an expected result because cell boundaries of plants in pelagic regions are thicker,
56
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
which results in resistance to diffusion and subsequent assimilation of 13C, as diffusion is a rate-limiting
step in photosynthesis. This analysis is part of a larger research study aiming to develop a biochemical
roadmap to open ocean sea turtle foraging on the seascape scale intended to provide useful open ocean
foraging ecology information to marine resource managers.
VANUA-TAI TURTLE MONITORS A STORY OF SUCCESSFUL TURTLE CONSERVATION IN
VANUATU
George Petro
Wan Smolbag Theatre, Port Vila, VANUATU
The Republic of Vanuatu is a chain of 83 islands in the South Pacific lying between 13°S-20°S Latitude
and 170°E- 166°E Longitude. Vanuatu is home to three of the six marine turtle species in the Indo-Pacific
region, namely the green turtle, the hawksbill turtle and the critically endangered leatherback turtle. Turtle
meat and eggs are a delicacy to the indigenous people of Vanuatu similar to the situation in other Pacific
Islands. Recent archeological evidence suggests a three thousand year history of consumption of marine
turtles. Currently on some former nesting grounds there is no longer nesting probably due to a long history
of turtle egg harvesting. Sea turtle conservation in Vanuatu was first introduced to local communities in
1995 when a local non-government organization, Wan Smolbag Theatre (WSB) implemented a sea turtle
awareness campaign using a play on the plight of marine turtles that was performed in local villages on the
main Island of Efate. After the performance a discussion was held with villagers searching for solutions,
out of this came the suggestion for the village to nominate a knowledgeable fisherman as a turtle monitor.
This was the beginning of WSB’s sea turtle conservation and monitoring program with the establishment of
village turtle monitors and a network, the Vanua-Tai Resource Monitors Network who now number over
500 and are spread throughout Vanuatu. The monitors initially focused on conservation and sustainable use
of marine turtles but have proved invaluable documenting marine turtle occurrence and nesting beaches,
tagging turtles and carrying out research. A 2005 survey suggested that the Vanua-Tai network in only 5
villages had conserved over 1200 marine turtles, extrapolated over the whole of Vanuatu this would
amount to over 10,000 turtles conserved. The network has subsequently expanded to involvement in
broader marine resource issues including coral reef monitoring and other marine resource conservation.
Some of the significant achievements have been the identification and subsequent monitoring of important
leatherback, green and hawksbill nesting beaches, the negotiation with tribal elders to reduce the take of
large adult turtles for a traditional ceremony from 300 to 50 turtles, the development of turtle related
ecotourism activities including sponsoring by tourists and cruise ship visitors of tagged and released turtles,
and a village based turtle nesting beach watching activity.
ASSESSING A POTENTIAL LIGHTING PROBLEM FOR LOGGERHEAD HATCHLINGS
NEAR THE BRIGHTEST LIGHTHOUSE IN THE WORLD: ARENA ASSAYS AT HILLSBORO
BEACH, FLORIDA, USA
Nicole Reintsma, Morgan Young, and Mike Salmon
Biology Dept., Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Florida’s East Coast is home to 90 percent of all loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) nests in the U.S. It
is also home to most of the 19 million people in Florida. This concentrated human population affects the
57
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
turtles in many ways. The impacts of artificial lighting are major concerns, well known to both nesting
beach managers as well as coastal residents. Consequently, many Florida municipalities and counties have
adopted lighting ordinances. These are especially important in urbanized portions of southeastern Florida
where some nesting beaches are exposed to many sources of artificial lighting. An advocacy group known
as Sea Turtle Oversite Protection, Inc. (STOP) operates in one such urbanized setting (Broward County,
Florida). Volunteers patrol beaches and document locations where lighting problems are severe. This is
especially the case in the southern portions of the county where, in 2011, between 24-48% of the hatchlings
emerging from nests in those locations were disoriented. STOP volunteers rescued 36,398 hatchlings from
those sites and released them on dark beaches where they could successfully locate the sea. However, the
northern portion of Broward County (Hillsboro Beach) is relatively dark and backed by private residences.
Nesting densities are the highest in the County and only 6% of the hatchlings are disoriented. There is an
inlet at the south end of the beach which is marked by a tall (41 m high) lighthouse maintained by the U.S.
Coast Guard (USCG). Its 1000 w light is sufficiently bright to be visible 54 km out to sea. Its beam rotates
rapidly above the beach, once every 20 s. STOP claimed that this light threatened marine turtles by
repelling females from the nesting beach, and by attracting hatchlings toward the light and away from the
ocean. They pressured the USCG to modify the light or to turn it off. The USCG sought opinions from
experts at the National Marine Fisheries Service (which has authority over coastal waters). The NMFS
concluded that nesting activity was unaffected. The USCG also sought opinions from the U. S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (which has authority over the nesting beach). The USFWS concluded that there was not
sufficient data to determine whether hatchlings were attracted to the lighthouse. That conclusion was
unsatisfactory both to STOP and to the USCG. To resolve the problem, we did experiments to measure how
loggerhead hatchlings oriented after simulated nest emergences. Hatchlings scheduled to emerge that
evening were collected in the afternoon from nearby nests, and released that night in the center of a 4 m
diameter circle (arena) drawn in the sand at Hillsboro Beach. Their orientation angle as they exited the
circle was measured at three locations (100 m, 330 m, and 915 m north of the lighthouse) under each of two
conditions (lighthouse light on; lighthouse light off). All of the hatchlings crawled with great accuracy
toward the ocean. These data provided the evidence required to resolve the issue and allow the parties to
concentrate on other ways to promote sea turtle recovery.
THE CASE OF THE GREEN TURTLE: AN UNCENSORED HISTORY OF A CONSERVATION
ICON
Alison Rieser
University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
When the first generation of conservation scientists determined that the green sea turtle was threatened with
extinction, they helped transform this heavily hunted species from a food source into a conservation icon.
With its impressive migrations and homing abilities, the green turtle, like the giant panda, became a symbol
of humanity’s commitment to preserve life on Earth, especially the relics of the original order. But the
‘founding fathers’ of sea turtle biology disagreed on how best to preserve the object of their studies. Would
farming the green turtle as livestock help to feed human populations or trigger a new era of unsustainable
demand for a fashionable luxury food? As a question of values and human behavior, biology had no answer,
and so it fell to the courts to decide. Now, as the green turtle recovers from centuries of overexploitation, a
new generation of turtle biologists grapples with the ‘sustainable use’ conundrum, reprising the debate that
so bedeviled their intellectual forebearers.
58
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
THE SEA TURTLE NEST LOCATOR PROGRAM: USING ADVANCED GIS & GPS
TECHNOLOGY TO BALANCE BEACH MANAGEMENT DEMANDS WITH
ECOCONSERVATION EFFORTS
David N. Rubin
City of Fort Lauderdale, Parks & Recreation Department, Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA
Many cities face the challenge of balancing the need to protect a tourist economy with the need to protect
endangered ecosystems. Innovations in GIS have allowed for the integration of advanced technology and
ecoconservation. In the past 4 years, the City of Fort Lauderdale, in partnership with Broward County, has
developed a program model focused on balancing the efficacy of mechanical beach cleaning with the
objective to protect sea turtle nests. The Sea Turtle Nest Locator Program utilizes a Trimble GeoExplorer
sub-meter GPS, ArcGIS Mobile, and ArcGIS Desktop to collect and analyze data used to identify and reestablish sea turtle nests in the event of natural or man-made disturbance. The program has resulted in
improved efficiency in mechanical beach cleaning and increased ecopreservation of sea turtle nests. Due to
its success, the program model has been adopted by other beach cleaning services within Broward County
and is being implemented in several municipalities. This presentation will explain the program model, give
examples of how the model has been put into use on Fort Lauderdale Beach and describe the use of ArcGIS
Mobile and ArcGIS Desktop as tools in providing GIS services within beach management programs.
ARE HAWAIIAN GREEN SEA TURTLES IMPERILED OR RECOVERED?
Miyoko Sakashita1 and Jaclyn Lopez2
1
2
Center for Biological Diversity, San Francisco, CA, USA
Center for Biological Diversity, St. Petersburg, FL, USA
The United States is conducting a status review of green sea turtles to determine whether they should still
be protected under the Endangered Species Act. The prospect of removing protections comes in response to
a petition to remove the Hawaiian population of green sea turtles from the list of threatened and endangered
species, and the move is highly controversial. This presentation will discuss the recovery criteria and
examine the present classification of the green sea turtle. It will also identify the ongoing threats to the
survival of Hawaii’s green sea turtles, including sea level rise, climate change, plastic pollution, disease,
and fisheries bycatch. Legal protections have been instrumental in bringing green sea turtles back from the
brink of extinction, and this demonstrates the success of the Endangered Species Act. The goal of the law is
to recover imperiled species so that the protections of the law are no longer necessary. While population
increases for the Hawaiian population of green sea turtles are encouraging, there are many factors and
management challenges that weigh against removing protections.
59
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT INTENSIVE SPORADIC NESTING HABITATS OF ANDHRA PRADESH
COAST, BAY OF BENGAL, INDIA
Raja Sekhar, P.S
Dept. of Environmental Sciences, Andhra University, Visakhapatnam -530 003, A.P., India
The Andhra Pradesh coast is situated on East Coast of India between 11°24”- 19°54” N latitudes and 80°
02”- 86°46” E longitudes. This part of coastline abutting Bay of Bengal has diversified shore environments
of main land beaches, salt water lagoons, backwater swamps and sand spits of Krishna and Godavari River
mouths,. The breeding population of olive ridleys (Lepidochelys olivacea) is migrating during winter
months (December to March) from Indian Ocean to the Orissa mass nesting sites (Gahirmatha &
Rushikulya) they utilize the beaches of Andhra Coast for their sporadic nesting on remote main land
beaches and riverine sandy spits & sand bars. Intensity of sporadic nesting activity and nesting density of
the olive ridley were found to be varied from river mouth sand spits (>30 nests /km) to the main land
beaches (<4 nests /km. Predation of eggs and hatchlings was very high at river mouth beaches due to
jackals (Vulpes vulpes), foxes (Vulpes bengalensis), mongoose (Herpestes edwardsi) and shore crabs
(Ocypoda sp.). As part of conservation and management of olive ridley sea turtle a total of 3000 Olive
ridley nests were relocated at sand spits of Krishna, Godavari and Vamsadhara river mouths and protected
naturally (in situ) until hatching of eggs. The newly emerged hatchlings (2000 nos) were reared in captive
conditions up to six days old and released them in to marine waters. Besides, sea turtle awareness programs
were organized at major fishing harbors for implementation of Turtle Excluder Devices (TEDs) to reduce
the incidental catches of breeding population due to shrimp trawl nets. The vulnerable nesting sites of olive
ridleys were regularly monitored to protect freshly laid nests, eggs and hatchlings from natural predation
and beach erosion along the sporadic nesting sites of Andhra Pradesh coast, Bay of Bengal, India.
ASSESSING THE INFLUENCE OF NEST RELOCATION ON SEA TURTLES IN NORTH
CAROLINA, SOUTH CAROLINA AND GEORGIA
Michael Shaughnessy1, Matthew H. Godfrey2, Brian Shamblin3, Mark Dodd4, DuBose B. Griffin5,
and Michael Coyne6
1
Duke University, Durham, NC
NC Wildlife Resources Commission, Beaufort, NC
3
NOAA-NMFS SWFSC, La Jolla, CA
4
GA Department of Natural Resources, St. Simons, GA
5
SC DNR Marine Turtle Program, Charleston, SC
6
SEATURTLE.ORG, Durham, NC
2
Nest relocation is generally considered a successful tool in sea turtle conservation. It is commonly used by
many sea turtle projects in many countries, and often high hatching success in relocated nests has been
interpreted as being beneficial for populations overall. However, there has been debate about potential
negative effects of nest relocation, such as the possibility that relocated eggs may experience unnatural nest
incubation conditions. It has also been suggested that nest relocation may artificially select for poor nesting
behavior and possibly result in reduced overall fitness of sea turtle populations. As a way to test for the
artificial selection hypothesis, we investigated nest relocation data of >11,000 loggerhead sea turtle nests
laid in Georgia, South Carolina and North Carolina during the 2010 and 2011 nesting seasons. Nearly all
60
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
known nests laid (>95%) were linked to individual females, through a DNA fingerprinting project. As a
result, we were able to assess if relocation of nests was randomly distributed across nests of individual
turtles, or if nests of some females were relocated more often than others. This study is the first of its kind,
with a large sample size distributed across a wide region. The results from our research will be informative
in the ongoing discussion about the possible impacts of nest relocation on sea turtle populations.
WINNING SEA TURTLE PROTECTION THROUGH LEGISLATION IN CALIFORNIA AND
BEYOND
Teri Shore and Todd Steiner
Turtle Island Restoration Network, California, USA
Passing several state bills and resolutions supporting sea turtle conservation through the California state
legislature and key marine management agencies over the past five years has proven an effective tool for
increasing protections for endangered Pacific leatherbacks and raising the profile of the marine species
among public officials, policymakers and the public. Turtle Island Restoration Network (TIRN) will
explain the history, legislative language and campaign that resulted in successful passage of such bills,
including a 2012 bill signed into law that designates the Pacific leatherback as an official state symbol of
California. TIRN will also show how we've leveraged legislation and resolutions in other policy arenas including the ISTS - and how such an approach can be modeled by others to enhance protections for and
build constituencies for support of sea turtle conservation in the U.S. and internationally.
A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF BEST PRACTICES IN PROTECTED SPECIES ADVISORY
GROUPS, AS THEY PERTAIN TO NORTH CAROLINA’S SEA TURTLE ADVISORY
COMMITTEE
Ainsley F. Smith1 and Michelle B. Nowlin2
1
Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University; Duke Environmental Law and Policy Clinic,
Durham, North Carolina, USA
2
Duke University Law School, Duke Environmental Law and Policy Clinic, Durham, North Carolina, USA
In accordance with a 2010 Settlement Agreement between NC Division of Marine Fisheries, NC Marine
Fisheries Council and the Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center, the NC Sea Turtle
Advisory Committee (STAC) was formalized. The committee consists of 12 members appointed by the
MFC Chairman and the Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center. The role of the STAC
includes: the review of monthly observer reports and fishing effort data, the review of weekly stranding
reports, assisting with fishermen education on sea turtle biology, and advising on take-reduction measures
such as gear modification or seasonal restrictions. The STAC also reviews and provides comment on all
Incidental Take Permit provisions and take calculations prior to formal application to NMFS. After several
years in their current capacity, members of the STAC expressed interest in expanding their work from NC
gill net fisheries, which were the target of the Settlement Agreement, to advising on other state-managed
fisheries that impact sea turtles. In an effort to maximize the STAC’s effectiveness and clarify goals, other
protected species advisory groups and marine mammal take reduction teams were examined, to determine
best management practices and effective strategies. The size and composition of each advisory committee
was examined, as well as the committee’s mission, goals, and funding, if applicable. A close look is also
61
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
taken at each group’s major initiatives and any documents produced in their advising capacity. Based on
informal interviews and anecdotes, best practices are compiled and presented. Many thanks to the ISTS,
Nicholas School of the Environment and Duke Environmental Law and Policy Clinic for their generous
support of this project and presentation.
STATUS OF SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN PALOH, WEST KALIMANTAN, INDONESIA,
WITH SPECIAL NOTES ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF LOCAL PARTICIPATION IN
PROTECTING TURTLE NESTS
Dwi Suprapti1, I.B.Windia Adnyana2, and Creusa Hitipeuw1
1
2
WWF, Indonesia
Udayana University, Indonesia
Paloh beach, which is located within the District of Sambas in the Province of West Kalimantan, Indonesia,
is one of the major nesting beaches for sea turtles in Indonesia. Green (Chelonia mydas) and hawksbill
(Eretmochelys imbricata) turtles have been documented nesting on this 63 km long beach. For decades, sea
turtle eggs in this region were exploited either by the local government who sold them through auctions to
private entities, or by local people who took all of the eggs. In early 2009, WWF Indonesia initiated a
campaign to obtain local support to promote effective law enforcement. Ex-egg poachers were transformed
into monitoring and surveillance workers which resulted in a significant reduction in egg poaching
activities. A total of 8,540 turtle nests were documented between June 2009 – August 2012. Based on the
track width of the nesting females or on egg diameter and weight, it was estimated that the nests were
composed of 98.33% green turtle nests and 1.70% hawksbill turtle nests. Regardless of species, overall
proportion of poached nests during 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 were found to be 99.62%, 95.01%, 25.64% and
21.42%, respectively. Significant reduction in poaching during the period of 2011 and 2012 compared to
2009 and 2010 indicates the necessity and effectiveness of involving local community in conducting
monitoring and surveillance of nesting turtles in this particular area. Monitoring results indicated that peak
nesting in Paloh occurs from June-August. Nesting abundance seemed to be concentrated on a segment of
beach named Sebubus (89.41%) compared to the neighboring beach segment called Temajuk (10.59%).
Considering the limitation of the resources, these results can be used as guidelines to focus the temporal
and spatial scope of work during the peak periods.
THE USE OF RECREATIONAL DIVERS FOR IN-WATER SEA TURTLE MONITORING IN
MOZAMBIQUE
Jessica L. Williams1,2, Mark Hamann1, and Simon J. Pierce2
1
2
James Cook University, Townsville, Australia
Marine Megafauna Foundation, Tofo, Mozambique
Five sea turtle species, all of which are globally threatened, are found within southern Mozambican waters.
Illegal capture of foraging turtles by spear-fishers, nest raiding and coastal habitat modification are known
to affect local sea turtle populations. Such is the case in many developing countries, where conservation
initiatives have been hampered by the lack of capacity, lack of data and resource constraints for monitoring
activities. Low monitoring capacity is a common issue, particularly within developing countries, and a
potential solution is to enlist the help of the recreational diving community. Between 2008 and 2011 there
62
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
have been at least two projects in which recreational divers collected data on turtles and other marine
megafauna in Mozambique. This study assessed the suitability of using volunteer divers to collect baseline
data of sea turtle populations. The two datasets were consecutively collected for 37 months: one was a
routine logbook of all marine megafauna sightings and the second was a dedicated turtle survey. A total of
317 sightings of loggerhead (Caretta caretta), green (Chelonia mydas) and hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys
imbricata) were reported over 918 dives. Our analysis found that a large proportion of the sightings
reported by the volunteer participants could not be conclusively assigned to species, and while estimates of
turtle sizes were recorded, 13% exceeded biological limits and were clearly erroneous. While the dedicated
survey protocol allowed for more detailed behavioural data collection, the independent logbook record was
more useful for analysis of sighting trends because we could also get absence data (i.e. dives with no turtle
sightings). Overall, useful data on foraging sea turtle species composition, size and distribution were
obtained, which was a first for Mozambique. In addition, we used the data to develop a more robust
protocol for a specialist in-water citizen science program. We advocate for the development of clear
questions or objectives around which the monitoring program is developed, collection of effort data, and
refinement of methodology, particularly through the incorporation of photographic verification of species
identification. These changes can improve the ability of ‘citizen scientist’ programmes for in-water sea
turtle monitoring to be a cost-effective and practical means to gather baseline data and to enhance the longterm sustainability of monitoring programmes.
SEA LEVEL RISE, SPECIES SURVIVAL, AND PRESERVATION OF UPLAND HABITAT
Shaye Wolf1 and Jaclyn Lopez2
1
2
Center for Biological Diversity, San Francisco, CA, USA
Center for Biological Diversity, St. Petersburg, FL, USA
Florida’s coastal ecosystems and species face rising sea levels and increasing storm surge. It is critical to
proactively map, protect, and manage upland habitats to enable adaptive habitat shifts by coastal species.
The U.S. Endangered Species Act can help accomplish these objectives by protecting upland habitat for
species to ensure they are able to move inland as their habitats are inundated. Mean global sea level is
projected to rise by 1 to 2 meters this century, and intensifying storms and storm surge will exacerbate the
effects of sea level rise. The Florida coast faces a significant threat of inundation, and many coastal species
will likely suffer extensive habitat loss. Sandy beaches that are narrow, lack extensive dune systems, or are
backed by armoring are vulnerable to disappearing entirely. Coastal species may be limited in their ability
to move landward as coastal habitat has already been lost and degraded due to development and dense
human populations along the coast. In Florida, population density in coastal counties is three times greater
than in inland counties – thus coastal species are at risk of being trapped between rising sea levels and
human development. Moreover, undeveloped areas that might be suitable for species’ landward migration
are likely to be claimed by development as human populations also retreat landward. Our nation’s foremost
biodiversity protection law, the Endangered Species Act, provides a powerful but under-utilized tool for
proactively protecting habitat in response to climate change through the designation of “critical habitat.”
Under the Act, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, must
designate areas essential to the survival and recovery of a species as “critical habitat.” These areas receive
protection from all federal agency actions that are likely to “destroy or adversely modify” them and critical
habitat designation provides safeguards against development and other potentially destructive activities. In
a climate change context, the Act allows the Services to designate critical habitat outside of a species’
current range if those areas are needed for its conservation. The loggerhead sea turtle is widely distributed
within its range, and makes some of the longest journeys of any sea turtle species. Originally listed as
threatened range-wide, the Services recently divided the species into nine District Population Segments,
and are now required to designate critical habitat. Loggerhead sea turtles nest on beaches from Texas to
Virginia, and face significant loss of nesting habitat due to sea level rise. However, about 90% of U.S.
loggerhead nesting occurs in Florida counties, mainly in Brevard, Indian River, St. Lucie, Martin, Palm
63
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Beach, Broward, and Sarasota counties. A critical habitat designation for the Northwest Atlantic Distinct
Population Segment that includes upland habitat that will become necessary for sea turtles will help ensure
their survival and recovery under rising sea levels.
Education, Outreach and Advocacy
GTTM-GV: 15 YEARS OF EFFORT TOWARDS SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN
VENEZUELA
Hector Barrios-Garrido1,2,3,4, Jordano Palmar1, Francisco Rodriguez1, Tibisay Rodriguez1, Martin
Oquendo1, Maria J. Petit-Rodriguez1,2, Graciela Pulido-Petit1,2, Beatriz Moran1,2, Efrain Moreno1,5,
Daniela Rojas-Cañizales1,2, Laura Carruyo-Rincon1, Karledys Garcia1, Dana Padron1,2, Luis ValeroBarrios1,2, Brirelys Conde1,6, Ninive Espinoza-Rodriguez1, Lisandro Moran1,7, Natalie
Wildermann1,2,3, and Maria G. Montiel-Villalobos1,8
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela (GTTM-GV)
Laboratorio de Ecologia General, Departamento de Biologia, La Universidad del Zulia (LUZ),
3
Centro de Modelado Cientifico (CMC-LUZ)
4
MTSG-IUCN
5
Universidad Rafael Belloso Chacin (URBE)
6
Facultad de Ciencias Veterinarias (FCV), La Universidad del Zulia (LUZ)
7
Laboratorio de Sistematica de Invertebrados Acuaticos (LASIA-LUZ)
8
Centro de Ecologia, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Cientificas (IVIC)
2
Management plans of endangered species worldwide have centered their guidelines based on the interinstitutional cooperation between countries and ecoregions. All proposed initiatives for sea turtle (ST)
conservation have developed their work proposals based on networks that allow a fluent exchange of
information and an effective extent to the protagonists of the conservation projects, which are the
inhabitants of the coastal communities near sea turtle's habitats. This has been the key for the integration of
fishing and indigenous (Wayuu) communities and the members of the "Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas
Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela" (GTTM-GV) during the last 15 years. The Gulf of Venezuela constitutes
an important zone where conservation efforts for endangered species such as sea turtles need to be
developed due to the combination of the complex sociocultural and environmental issues. It is a frontier
zone between Colombia and Venezuela, with problems such as illegal drug and oil trade, critical economic
situations and illegal immigrants. However, it also contains important ecological elements such as the
presence of the five sea turtle species that inhabit the southern Caribbean, and ideal ecosystems for the
development of sea turtles. This complex reality was one of the greatest challenges for the creation and
growth of GTTM-GV as an NGO. After 15 years, many projects have been developed successfully under
the three basic worklines: Intercultural Bilingual Environmental Education (Spanish-Wayuunaikii),
Investigation-Action, and Networking (interinstitutional efforts). The GTTM-GV is recognized as a
regional and national example of environmental efforts for community based conservation, achieving the
integration of Wayuu and Añu indigenous communities. Additionally, there is an increasing number of
volunteers and professional members in several academical areas (Biology, Social Communication,
Education, Public Relations, Veterinary Medicine, Graphic Design and Engineering), as well as the
development of workshops and courses directed towards students, fishermen, children and housewives, and
finally the creation of a Biological Station in Zapara Island. For 15 years, the GTTM-GV has been
successful in leading academic and community projects in the regions, training students in international
internships, actively participating in workshops with governmental entities, and is constantly assuming new
commitments promoting the conservation of sea turtles and their habitats in Venezuela.
64
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
COMMUNITY INITIATIVE OF NON-CONSUMPTIVE USE OF SEA TURTLES AS A RESULT
OF LONG TERM CONSERVATION PROGRAM IN BRAZIL
José Henrique Becker1, Bruno Giffoni1, Fernando Siqueira Alvarenga1, Edson Leopoldo dos Santos2,
Flávia Cysne Suárez Navarro2, Jaime Navarro Barbosa2, Patrícia Ortiz3, and Berenice Maria Gomes
Gallo1
1
Fundação Pró-TAMAR. Rua Antônio Athanazio da Silva, 273, Jardim Paula Nobre, Ubatuba – SP. Brazil.
11680-000.
2
² AICAS. Praia do Engenho s/nº, Almada, Ubatuba – SP. Brazil. 11680-000
3
Taubaté University. Rua Machado de Assis, Itaguá, Ubatuba – SP, Brazil. 11680-000
Since 1990 TAMAR develops scientific research, environmental education and social inclusion activities to
protect sea turtles in Ubatuba, north shore of São Paulo state, Brazil. As a result, more than 10,000 juvenile
sea turtles, which were caught incidentally at artisanal fishing, were released to the ocean with the
fishermen volunteering partnership. Among them, 643 sea turtles (636 Chelonia mydas and 7 Eretmochelys
imbricata) were captured by artisanal fishermen from Almada Beach. Since 1992, besides continuous
development of research and educational activities in Almada, TAMAR has supported local events, helped
in the implantation of mussel cultivation and promoted annual meetings with the fishermen to present the
results of the sea turtle conservation program, also to clarify questions and issues about environmental
legislation. In 2011/2012, a research about the touristic potential of Almada Beach, with the goal to plan
and structure the activity in the area was conducted by AICÁS. This NGO, constituted of local people,
develops educational activities with the community and tourists to protect the historical and environmental
patrimony. In the AICÁS research, from a list of seventeen options of traditional touristic activities, the
residents pointed out the observation of sea turtles as the second most significant one, only behind hiking in
the rainforest. The proposal is to take groups of five people in small boats to watch turtles in 4 defined
locations according to local fishermen knowledge, where turtles usually gather to feed. TAMAR Project
was invited by the community to take part of a workshop to teach the local residents about the biology and
conservation of sea turtles, relating it to their own performance as tourist guides. In this commitment,
TAMAR also promoted dialogues about the ordering of the activity, the supporting capacity, the quality of
the services offered and safety. This was also an opportunity to recommend how to live peacefully with the
sea turtles, with the lowest impact possible for the turtles and its environment. Eight residents were trained
and 4 boats’ owners became interested in this activity. Just a few participants of this initiative are older than
thirty five years and most of them are young people who have been involved in the TAMAR activities,
since their adolescence. These people were raised in an environment where protecting turtles is important
and where tourists’ interest and affection for its observation represents a great business opportunity. This
report suggests that the long term continuity developing education and inclusion actions in the community
is the basis to build values and environmental consciousness, in a context where new initiatives and
behavior can come from new generations.
65
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION: TRANSFORMATION INTO K-12 EDUCATION: HYBRID
POGILTM METHODOLOGY IN A PLACE-BASED GEOSCIENCE PROGRAM
Gale A. Bishop1, R. Kelly Vance2, Kathryn M. Ortiz3, Veronica Greco3, and Brian K. Meyer3,4
1
GeoTrec LLC; St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, Fayette, IA, USA
Georgia Southern University; St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, Statesboro, GA, USA
3
St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, St. Catherines Island, GA, USA
4
Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA, USA
2
The St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program (SCISTP) was founded in 1990 and has been funded
continuously for 22 years through a consortium of partners led by Georgia’s Improving Teacher Quality
Program (GaITQ). The SCISTP combines “Conservation, Research, and Education” into an integrated,
interdisciplinary, holistic program, featuring a total-immersion, procedure-optimized, process-oriented,
guided inquiry learning (POGIL) educational component. The layered procedures of sea turtle conservation
provide an excellent mechanism for modeling introduction of a hybrid POGIL methodology into K-12
curricula. The conservation procedures have been summarized and integrated onto a new map of the
beaches of St. Catherines Island, gridded to GaDNR standards, to guide the layered learning in a field
environment. A formal POGIL exercise piloted in 2012 rapidly taught new knowledge and new pedagogy
to 16 K-12 teacher-interns. Over the years we have taught place-based sea turtle conservation, aspects of
geology, ecology, oceanography, biology, archaeology, hydrology, history, and pedagogy, to 307 interns.
Two hundred seventy three of these have been K-12 teachers from Georgia who, because of the
compounding effect of multiple cohorts of students in their classrooms, have impacted approximately
373,858 K-12 students. During this process we have conserved 2,796 sea turtle nests that put 165,974 sea
turtle hatchlings into the Atlantic Ocean, and have shared our science and experiences through numerous
talks, publications, and websites. The SCISTP provides a robust model of how observational science and
conservation can be transformed to maximize their impact in the public arena, especially in K-12 education,
leading, we believe, to enhanced environmental stewardship and an enhanced appreciation for science. We
intend to continue this project with shared operating support and exportation of our robust model to
enhance science and science education around the world. This will be done through our website
(www.scistp.org), through formal association with the POGIL Project (http://pogil.org/), and publication of
a new book “Two Thousand Sunrises; Ten Thousand Surprises” (Draft II, ~ 425 p., single-spaced with
illustrations), extending place-based POGIL learning through life-long learning processes in science and
science education using the nesting ecology of charismatic sea turtles as a science education and wildlife
conservation vehicle.
SEA TURTLE REHABILITATION AND MEDICINE COURSE: A UNIQUE HANDS ON
CLINICAL EDUCATION FOR VETERINARY STUDENTS
Heather Broadhurst1, Craig A. Harms1, and Jean Beasley2
1
North Carolina State University, College of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Clinical Sciences,
Center for Marine Sciences and Technology, Morehead City, NC, USA
2
Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center, Surf City, NC, USA
The North Carolina State University College of Veterinary Medicine (NCSU-CVM) was established in
1979 and has a reputation for its dedication to teaching, research, community outreach, and providing
unique student learning opportunities. This is exemplified by the Sea Turtle Rehabilitation and Medicine
66
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Course that was created in 2005. A relationship between the NCSU-CVM and Jean Beasley, the founder of
the Karen Beasley Sea Turtle Rescue and Rehabilitation Center (KBSTRRC), was formed in the late
1990’s as the demand increased for consistent specialized care for injured sea turtles along coastal North
Carolina. Faculty members from NCSU-CVM have been the primary veterinary caregivers for sea turtles at
the KBSTRRC since its opening in 1997. Combining the mission of the NCSU-CVM to provide excellence
in educating and training veterinarians and a mission of the KBSTRRC to provide an experiential learning
site for students, the sea turtle rehabilitation and medicine course was born. The course is attended by
fourth year veterinary students for two weeks, spending the majority of their time at the KBSTRRC in
Topsail Beach, NC. The students engage in extensive hands-on practical and clinical experience with
threatened and endangered sea turtles. Skills acquired during this time include sea turtle husbandry and
rehabilitation techniques, diagnostic sample collection and interpretation, physical examination and safe
animal handling, medication delivery, wound treatment, and necropsy protocols. Another aspect of this
course is the social experience provided by interacting with people from all walks of life including
volunteers, natural resource managers and biologists, working together for the conservation of these high
profile species. Forty-seven students have completed the course since its inception. A number of these
former students are pursuing zoological medicine careers in both public and private practice involving
protected species, rehabilitation, wildlife, aquatic, zoo and exotic companion animals. While participating
in the course, students have also been directly involved with sample collection and processing for research
that has resulted in publications contributing to sea turtle health management. This distinctive course
provides valuable experience applicable to many veterinary career paths, with a particular appreciation of
the challenges and rewards of working with flagship protected species like sea turtles.
INTERGRATING SEA TURTLE RESEARCH INTO INFORMAL EDUCATION
Karen P. Burns, Rachel Reisbeck, Katie Vaughan, Alexis Rabon, and Elisabeth Boys
Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center, Virginia Beach, VA, USA
Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center educators worked with aquarium research staff to develop
educator curriculum materials on sea turtle research and conservation. Sea Turtle Science & Stewardship
workshops are being conducted for educators representing approximately 40 informal science centers in
Virginia and Maryland. The workshops will provide informal educators with instructional kits, highlight
programs and activities appropriate for family audiences, and explore how our facilities can best engage the
public in sea turtle conservation issues and foster sea turtle stewardship. These workshops are designed to
assist informal educators in developing programs for their institutions regarding sea turtles in general and
research, threats and conservation efforts in Chesapeake Bay and other waters of Virginia and Maryland.
Sea Turtle Action Kits have been developed for distribution to schools, scout troops, 4-H Clubs, and other
youth organizations in Virginia and Maryland. These kits will provide props, materials, and activities that
demonstrate the danger marine debris poses to sea turtles and contain the basics needed to create a display
on the subject, such as directions for constructing a “Trash Talking Turtle” and posters about
biodegradation of debris and how to properly dispose of balloons and trash. The kits will promote
stewardship by encouraging youth groups to create action plans for setting up displays at school fairs, Earth
Day events, and local parks that educate the public on how individuals can make a difference. Workshops
and trainings are facilitated by both education staff and research staff for a greater impact on the
participants. Through the Sea Turtle Science & Stewardship workshops, aquariums and informal science
centers will have the resources to strengthen their programming about sea turtles. Workshop attendees are
asked to track the number of sea turtle programs and program participants and to collect evaluation
information. Through the Sea Turtle Action Kits, youth groups will have the resources to help increase
awareness about the impact of marine debris on sea turtles and to share ideas for reducing the threat.
Groups that receive the kits will report on their activities and provide estimates of the number of people
they reach. The goal of all of these educational outreach components is to empower residents of Virginia
and Maryland to take actions that reduce human impact on loggerheads and other sea turtle species that
67
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
visit our waters. All materials will be continually updated to incorporate new research as we generate
results.
BAHARI KARUNA - CONNECTING PEOPLE THROUGH SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN
WEST AFRICA.
Neil Davis, John Flynn, Juliana Baker, and Kostas Papafitsoros
Wildseas, Bahari Karuna, Eikwe, Ghana
A small team of WILDSEAS staff began working closely with existing turtle groups and fishermen in
remote areas of Western Ghana in 2011/2012. The goal was to establish the first volunteer project of its
kind in the region. After meeting in January 2012 we secured the support of many local communities and
received land for a marine conservation and education centre in the village of Eikwe. After many setbacks,
the project BAHARI KARUNA (meaning ocean compassion) was founded in October, 2012. The project
works closely with local fishermen to ensure that sea turtles that have been accidentally captured are safely
released, and also to facilitate data collection on any shark landings. Additionally, we also run a successful
school education program. Approximately 10 local people are employed full time and many fishing boats
have agreed to join us in this pilot project. The results are presented along with future goals.
EXPERIENCING SCIENCE TO CULTIVATE THE DESIRE FOR CONSERVATION AT HOME
AND ABROAD
Tera C. Dornfeld1, Gabriela S. Blanco2, Julianne Koval3, Pamela T. Plotkin4, Richard D. Reina5,
Vincent S. Saba6, Bibi Santidrián Tomillo1, Lesley Stokes7, Jen Swiggs3, Bryan P. Wallace8, James R.
Spotila2, and Frank V. Paladino3
1
The Leatherback Trust, San Jose, Costa Rica
Drexel University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
3
Indiana University-Purdue University, Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA
4
Sea Grant Texas, College Station, Texas, USA
5
Monash University, Victoria, Australia
6
NOAA, Princeton, New Jersey, USA
7
NOAA Fisheries, Miami, Florida, USA
8
The Ocean Society, Ross, California, USA
2
For the past 24 years, our research team has conducted studies on the population dynamics, behavior, and
physiology of the leatherback turtles nesting at Playa Grande, Playa Ventanas, and Playa Langosta on the
Pacific Coast of Costa Rica. Our research was an instrumental component of the effort to turn these
beaches into the Las Baulas National Marine Park. Furthermore, these 24 years of meticulous data
collection have allowed us to amass one of the most detailed sea turtle databases in existence. This
comprehensive database owes its existence to the tremendous volunteer force that accompanies us to the
beach each night. During the leatherback turtle nesting season, which runs October – March, we are
assisted by 50+ Earthwatch volunteers as well as school groups from around the world. Volunteers walk
with biologists on the beach each morning and night helping to tag and identify turtles, record nest
locations, measure turtles, count turtle eggs as they are laid to understand fecundity, take internal nest
temperatures to predict hatchling sex ratios, and excavate nests to calculate hatching success. Volunteers
68
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
also help with maintenance and protection of our beach hatchery, a safe place to relocate nests laid in
perilous locations. We receive new volunteers every 10 days, however, we receive more than just ablebodied workers. By providing an opportunity for volunteers to experience sea turtles and a research team
that is dedicated to conservation we are able to pass on knowledge about sea turtles, the threats they face,
and conservation strategies. When volunteers who are already passionate about turtles have the opportunity
to experience sea turtles and conservation in action their resolve to protect turtles strengthens. This resolve
extends beyond their time at the project to when they return home. In this way we are providing not just
field training but spreading the message of conservation around the world. At the time of writing this
abstract we are midway through the nesting season. We have had the privilege of working with many
volunteers so far and are looking forward to many more in 2013. To date we have encountered 22 different
leatherback turtle females. Encouragingly, our first turtle of the season was first tagged in 1994-95, fitted
with a satellite tag in 2007, and has been seen nesting during five previous seasons. With the help of our
volunteers we look forward to protecting more nesting females and their clutches during the 2012-13
nesting season. We wish to thank the generous contribution of The International Sea Turtle Symposium,
The International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries
Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack,
Telonics, and CLS America for funding the travel grant that made possible the participation in this year’s
symposium. We also wish to thank the Earthwatch Neville Shulman Award for helping fund our
participation in this symposium.
A MULTI-DIMENSIONAL APPROACH TO EDUCATION AT A SEA TURTLE NESTING
BEACH IN PLAYA GRANDE, COSTA RICA
Tera C. Dornfeld1, Kristin M. Reed1, and Frank V. Paladino2
1
2
The Leatherback Trust, San Jose, Costa Rica
Indiana University-Purdue University, Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA
The Leatherback Trust began helping to collect biological data and protect nesting beaches for leatherback
sea turtles at Playa Grande, Costa Rica in the late 1980s. We witnessed a dramatic decline and now the
population could be stabilized, albeit at lower numbers. We believe the way forward is to pair research and
protection of the remaining sea turtles and their habitat with community involvement. By providing
residents with information about sea turtles and the anthropogenic threats facing them, as well as
conservation strategies, we can mitigate one of the main threats to sea turtles: the negative effects of coastal
development. These negative effects include an increase in plastic pollution, invasive species, and
beachfront lighting, as well as a loss of beachfront vegetation. Without conservation information and
strategies, we face two key problems: 1) residents are underutilized as partners in conservation and 2) some
residents are, actively or unknowingly, working against conservation. To begin to partner with residents we
first developed a survey to gauge their receptivity to educational programming as well as their perceived
value of sea turtles. Of the 97 residents surveyed, 41/42 respondents strongly agreed or agreed with the
statement ‘I would like to learn about sea turtles’ and 88% (37/42) answered that they would volunteer their
time to help protect sea turtles. Many (88%; 37/42 respondents) strongly agreed or agreed with the
statement ‘Educating people in Playa Grande about sea turtles will benefit sea turtles’. Finally, 64% (27/42
respondents) believed they benefited from having sea turtles in Playa Grande. We are now organizing many
different types of activities to learn which best facilitate community participation as well as education
focused on the conservation of sea turtles and their habitat. Each month we aim to focus activities on a
central theme; each theme is one of the main threats to sea turtles and how we can work together to
mitigate that threat. With these themed activities we strive to engage different cohorts within the local
population. We have hosted events including family hikes, a Kid’s Club, beach clean-ups, and lectures. By
capitalizing on the desire of local people to get involved in conservation we believe this program is
beneficial, as it will provide eager residents with the information, opportunities, and strategies to connect
with and conserve sea turtles. We wish to thank the generous contribution of The International Sea Turtle
69
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Symposium, The International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine
Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek,
Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America for funding the travel grant that made possible the participation in this
year’s symposium. We also wish to thank the Earthwatch Neville Shulman Grant for providing funding to
facilitate our participation in this symposium.
CONNECTING JAQUÉ, PANAMÁ TO THE WORLD OF CONSERVATION
Mary Duncan1, Ana Maria V. Leon1, Richard Boren2, Iver Valencia1, and Jose A. Cordoba1
1
2
Grupo Protector de la Tortuga Marina de Jaque, Darien, Panama
Grupo Protector de la Tortuga Marina de Jaque, Tucson, AZ, USA
Ana Maria Vasquez Leon, Artist and Educator, left Colombia in 1998 due to the violence in the region.
When she arrived in Jaque, Panama, she realized that sea turtle nests were being poached. She created a
hatchery in Jaque which was modelled after a hatchery in Choco, Colombia that she had previously visited.
The hatchery only had room for 20 nests, but at least some nests would not be poached. Soon Iver Valencia
and other villagers joined this effort and were able to enlarge the hatchery after receiving funding through
the Colegio de la Tierra, private donors and the sale of local sea turtle crafts. This group became the Grupo
Protector de la Tortuga Marina de Jaque, coordinated by Iver Valencia. Soon the group was educating and
involving students who helped collect nests and release hatchlings, recruit local volunteers and create an
Annual Sea Turtle Festival. Biologists also visited the project throughout the season. Almost all nesting
turtles here are solitary Lepidochelys olivacea nesters, however, we do see an occasional Chelonia mydas
and in 2000, a Dermochelys coriacea. There have been a few stranded turtles that the group has helped,
including a few Eretmochelys imbricata which do not nest in Jaque. This group has seen great
improvements this year! By the end of this season there were 179 nests in the hatchery. These nests were
collected by our volunteers and locals that receive $0.07 per egg to encourage conservation rather than
consumption or sale of the turtle eggs. This is a very remote village in the Darien Gap and the locals eat all
animals that they can find, so it is really exciting that we are now getting the community to connect with
the turtles and conservation. This is not a tourist area so conservation has to be encouraged for conservation
itself. Less than 50 nests were poached this year. Even the police are involved as they made their own turtle
conservation banner and t-shirts for volunteers that say Grupo Protector de la Tortuga Marina de Jaqué. A
group of community artists created a sea turtle mural in the airport and there are sea turtle posters all
around town. This year we also had a biologist, Mary Duncan, who worked on the project to standardize
and enforce procedures on the beach and in the hatchery, make the hatchery more efficient, create better
data collection methods and to spread information and excitement for conservation. There are very few
resources in Jaqué (2000 dollars per season or less) and we are trying to continue our conservation efforts
and would love to have better connections with all of you! Acknowledgements: Thank you to the
International Sea Turtle Symposium, International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of
Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America for all your help in getting our group to the
Symposium!
70
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TOUR DE TURTLES – USING RESEARCH TO INCREASE AWARENESS ABOUT SEA
TURTLES ONLINE
Daniel R. Evans, Rocio Johnson, and David Godfrey
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Gainesville, Florida, USA
The Tour de Turtles Migration Marathon is a popular educational program that is increasing public
awareness and support for the conservation of sea turtles and their habitats. Started in 2008, Tour de Turtles
is a fun, educational journey through the science, research and geography of sea turtle migration using
satellite telemetry. Created by the Sea Turtle Conservancy, this 3-month-long online program follows the
migration of sea turtles from their nesting beaches to unknown foraging grounds. Tour de Turtles utilizes
satellite telemetry data from migration studies in Florida, conducted in partnership with the University of
Central Florida, and from STC’s research programs in Central America and the Caribbean. After departing
from some of the most important nesting sites in the Western Hemisphere, individual sea turtles are tracked
and their locations and distances traveled are uploaded to interactive maps on the Tour de Turtles website,
www.tourdeturtles.org. The turtles are competing with the goal of being the first to swim the furthest
distance during the marathon. Tour de Turtles also includes a secondary competition, the Causes Challenge,
to raise awareness about threats to sea turtle survival. Audiences, particularly educators and students, are
invited to learn more about each turtle competitor and their Cause with the goal of promoting positive
actions on behalf of sea turtles. Each year Tour de Turtles generates considerable public interest in sea
turtles and, during just a three month period, inspires more than 30,000 visitors to log onto the Tour de
Turtles website. In addition to reaching the general public and media outlets, the program provides
educational resources to teachers across the United States, with hundreds of new educators signing up each
year. Tour de Turtles includes a full suite of activities focusing on the biology and habitats of sea turtles.
Teachers have free access to educational materials, quizzes and lesson plans that easily incorporate
environmental education into classroom activities and lessons. The ultimate goal of Tour de Turtles is to
raise awareness about the different species of sea turtles and the various threats to their survival. With an
estimated one out of 1,000 hatchlings reaching adulthood, conservation must focus on combating humancaused threats. Using information gained through Tour de Turtles, the public will be better equipped to take
action and reduce threats to the sea turtles.
COMMUNITY AWARENESS & CAPACITY BUILDING IN SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN
SRI LANKA
Thushan Kapurusinghe
Turtle Conservation Project, Madakumbura, Panadura, Sri Lanka
Five species of sea turtles nest in Sri Lanka. They include the green turtle (Chelonia mydas), leatherback
turtle (Dermochelys coriacea), olive ridley turtle (Lepidochelys olivacea), loggerhead turtle (Caretta
caretta) and the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata). Coastal communities of Sri Lanka depend on
surrounding natural resources for their survival. In addition, development activities are taking place in
many coastal areas of the island. As a result, very important coastal habitats and coastal fauna such as the
coral reefs, sea grass beds, mangroves, marine turtles and other coastal vegetation are under serious threat
of extinction. Creating awareness could play a vital role in conservation and management of sea turtles.
The Turtle Conservation Project's (TCP) community awareness and capacity development programmes
included conducting training workshop, field training, vocational training, school lectures, exhibitions, film
71
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
shows etc. TCP’s community capacity development programme has turned the turtle egg poachers into nest
protectors. Thirty-two former egg poachers have been employed as nest protectors in Kosgoda and Rekawa
villages. With the assistance of Sri Lanka Tourist Board (SLTB) TCP trained local villagers and licensed
them as eco tour guides. In addition, TCP has formed small community groups or Community Based
Organizations (CBOs) such as the Community Batik Group, Community Sewing Group, Community
Ornamental Fish Breeding Group, Community Coir Group and Turtle Nest Protector Groups in Kosgoda
and Rekawa villages in order to implement various community livelihood development projects. By
developing the capacities of CBOs it facilitated the TCP to implement various community projects.
Through the education and awareness projects in these villages, TCP was able to change some of the
negative attitudes of the local fishermen on marine and coastal resources that led them to over exploit the
resources. In addition, TCP has also implemented community skills development programs such as primary
school programs, computer classes, free English language classes, sewing training and disaster
preparedness training etc. Children’s clubs were established in order to involve children in the coastal ecosystem conservation and management process, providing them with necessary awareness through various
educational programs. The target groups of TCP’s awareness and capacity development programs included
local fishermen, school children, general public, wildlife officers, NAVY and Police officers, tour operators
and academics etc.
THE SUCCESSFUL STORY OF LOS CALIFORNIOS VERDES
Luciana Klinge1 and Cristian Jimenez2
1
2
Ecology Project International
Club de Ecología Los Californios Verdes, Mexico
“Los Californios Verdes” is a youth Ecology Club initiated by students from different high schools in La
Paz, Mexico and Ecology Project International (EPI). Their general goal is to be agents of positive change
and to generate opportunities to have contact with projects pro nature within the community of La Paz,
Baja California Sur, Mexico. The passion for nature conservation of five young paseños was the seed of
this now 30 member Ecology Club with more than 490 volunteers in La Paz in just 8 months. Los
Californios Verdes co-lead two projects under the mentorship of an EPI staff person. The first project is a
sea turtle conservation project, in collaboration with ASUPMATOMA and ProFaunaBaja. This project is
their most popular. They study olive ridley sea turtles during a two-night beach patrol program that
includes nest patrols, egg relocation and hatchery studies. The second project is the beach water quality
monitoring project in collaboration with The La Paz Waterkeepers organization. Also, in September of
2012 they launched their Beach Cleaning project “Limpia Baja California Sur!” which is the first project
they fundraised for and have organized by themselves. With this project they won the Amigos por el
Mundo fellowship from Disney, which is a huge step for the young community of La Paz. This presentation
is intended to show the history of the journey of los Californios Verdes, their challenges and
accomplishments, and how a small group of young students with a big passion and enthusiasm has stolen
the hearts of the people of Baja California Sur and how this is helping sow seeds of environmental
stewardship in the minds of kids, teenagers and adults.
72
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLES AND TRASH: AN UNFORTUNATE BUT PREVENTABLE RELATIONSHIP
Nicholas J. Mallos and Allison Schutes
Ocean Conservancy, Washington, DC, USA
Marine debris is a ubiquitous threat to marine organisms and ocean ecosystems, and has been documented
to affect more than 267 marine species. However, plastic debris is consistently noted as the entangling or
ingested debris. Sea turtles demonstrate an affinity for plastic debris in the marine environment, likely
confusing it for natural prey items. Debris is also an impediment for sea turtles on beaches, where
hatchlings can become severely entangled in fishing gear or entrapped in food containers. With all 7
species of sea turtles listed on the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), minimizing the
threat of marine debris to sea turtle survival is imperative. This threat is not new however, and Ocean
Conservancy has been engaged in the issue for more than a quarter century through the International
Coastal Cleanup. Since 1986, citizen scientists around the world have come out on a single day to rid
beaches, waterways, and the ocean of trash. Over the past 26 years, more than nine million (9,361,453)
volunteers have removed almost 154 million (153,790,918) pounds of debris from 312,000 miles of
coastline in 153 countries and locations. Volunteers record items of debris they collect on a standardized
data form and document entangled animals such as sea turtles—more than 4,400 entangled animals have
been encountered. These debris data have been cited in seminal publications and have lead to increased
awareness by stakeholders including product manufacturers, consumers and government officials. Data
were also critical in informing marine debris legislation. The simplicity of marine debris monitoring
protocols lends them well to be incorporated into the thousands of existing volunteer conservation projects
carried out on beaches around the world. Of these projects, volunteer sea turtle monitoring programs are
some of the most extensive globally, and are conducive for simultaneous marine debris monitoring. Sea
turtle volunteers perform an array of data collection services that directly aid sea turtle conservation,
including beach patrols to check for signs of nesting activity, marking new nests, and calculating hatch
success rate. Volunteers who engage in these activities typically monitor the same strand of beach or
coastline for three to four months, from first crawl to final hatch. Incorporating cleanup and data collection
protocols into these transects will generate a robust data set that can be used to evaluate potential
interactions between nesting mothers and sea turtle hatchlings and marine debris. Furthermore, these data
will enrich the existing open-access data set of the International Coastal Cleanup, expanding our
understanding of debris proliferation worldwide. Sea turtle volunteers are highly motivated and committed
and believe strongly in the conservation work they perform; and many volunteers already remove trash
while monitoring beaches for sea turtle activity. In a climate where resources for marine conservation are
limited, integrating standardized debris monitoring protocols into volunteer sea turtle programs seems a
logical and necessary action for sea turtle conservation and overall ocean health.
UTILIZING NATIONAL SERVICE PROGRAMS IN CONSERVATION
Jeannie M. Martin
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA
Looking for a unique way to engage students and community members in conservation? Need additional
support for conservation programs but have limited funding? Combining National Service with
Conservation may be the answer. The Georgia Sea Turtle Center (GSTC) is a hospital for ill and injured sea
turtles located on Jekyll Island, Georgia. The center is open to the general public with an interactive Exhibit
73
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Gallery and Rehabilitation Pavilion with viewable turtle patients. The center also focuses on environmental
education and research in the fields of ecology and wildlife health. The AmeriCorps GSTC program is a
nationally recognized national service program currently in its fourth year. During the first year of Service,
it was recognized as one of the 52 Most Innovative AmeriCorps programs in the country and has continued
to gain recognition since. During the first three years, the AmeriCorps GSTC program has trained 46 young
professionals with 11 current participants and 6 additional members starting in the spring for the 2013 turtle
nesting season. These members have donated more than 93,000 hours to sea turtle conservation efforts.
This poster highlights the collaboration between the GSTC and the AmeriCorps program, and includes the
AmeriCorps history, how the program began at the GSTC, and how this innovative collaboration promotes
national service, member development, and conservation initiatives. Techniques for program development
and how to apply for funding are also covered.
CROSSING SPACE AND TIME WITH SEA TURTLES: AN EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT TO
RAISE AWARENESS FOR THE CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES AND ECOSYSTEM
BASED-MANAGEMENT
Gustavo Martinez-Souza
Karumbé, Montevideo, Uruguay, Projeto Caminho Marinho and Oceanografia Biológica, Universidade
Federal do Rio Grande, Rio Grande, RS, Brasil
“Crossing Space and Time with Sea Turtles” is an educational project based on the concept of emotional
diversity, designed in the form of a board game. Up to four teams (4-30 children) can explore the ocean
while learning about the historic and current states of sea turtles. All aspects are incorporated into a fun and
exciting educational activity, including the turtle's environment, connections to local ecology, economics
and culture. Teams choose game pieces from two category options: (1) sea turtle species (green, loggerhead,
hawksbill, leatherback or olive ridley turtles), or (2) great travelers (Cabeza de Vaca, Sacawgawea, Charles
Darwin or Jacques Cousteau). Cabeza de Vaca was selected to represent a traveller game piece because he
was the first governor of River Plate Province after living in North America as an exile from Europe;
Sacawgawea travelled across America to the Pacific Ocean; Charles Darwin travelled across the oceans,
assessing biodiversity and exploring the connectedness of organisms, and Jacques Cousteau was vital to
oceanic exploration and the documentation of marine life, as the inventor of the SCUBA aqualung. All
historical figures chosen as game pieces represent a major societal connection to their work with nature. At
each space in the game, the player or team can choose 3 cards, referring to 3 light wavelengths (ultraviolet,
infrared, and visible light), each with a unique movement dynamic for the game pieces. In ultraviolet light,
different real life situations are presented (narrative style) in which players either advance or retreat based
on the information given, referring to more than 30 different papers. In infrared light, the players answer
questions about geography, history, general biology, sea turtle biology, or environmental education
(citizenship ecology, methods of improving sustainability and minimizing carbon footprints). Based on the
accuracy of their response, players either advance or retreat. In the case of the pilot, questions reference
concepts referred to during previous festivals (and the continued environmental education program of
Karumbé in La Coronilla, Uruguay) as a method to assess the amount of information successfully
assimilated by children. In visible light, movement forward or backward is determined by the outcome of
the players participation in short games, incorporating different learning styles and methods. The different
dynamics applied in the visible light dimension were discussed and tested in the last four sea turtle festivals.
The distinctive characteristic of this game is that the applied concept of travel across oceans is rooted in the
historic and contemporary information, consolidated from more than 30 publications. It also enhances
participants’ awareness of being Citizens of the Oceans, while creating a focused, local and potentially lowcost global educational product.
74
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
NEW STRATEGIES OF ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION AND AWARENESS FOR A GOOD
CONSERVATION OF THE SEA TURTLES ALONG THE COASTLINE OF MUADA,
DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO
Samuel Mbungu
ACODES, Muanda, Democratic Republic of Congo
Sea turtle conservation along the Muanda coastline began during the nesting season of 2006-2007. To date,
several objectives have been initiated, including identifying nesting sites and seasonality, training guards to
assure surveillance of the nesting beaches, conducting night patrols and track surveys, identifying and
keeping under surveillance the artisanal fishing ports, and raising awareness in coastal communities
through meetings and other media events. During the 2011-2012 nesting season, we adopted a new
methodological approach. Environmental education activities preceded night patrols and port and market
surveys. We have integrated the authorities along the coastline of Muanda in order to increase their level of
implication in sea turtles conservation efforts. An ambitious awareness and education campaign was led
along with the monitoring. We reached a large number of local people, belonging to very diverse groups:
120 community leaders, 6,405 students, 116 teachers from 10 schools located along the coast of Muanda
and 124 militaries and policemen from the Banana naval base and the Company of NSIAMFUMU. We also
have distributed 500 leaflets and 60 posters to raise local awareness, and local radio and television stations
generously offered us one TV and two radio broadcastings per month. Sensitizing is an essential
component of the efforts required to ensure the effectiveness of sea turtle conservation in Muanda. Our
financial resources did not allow us to do more, but we were very motivated by the desire to communicate
and educate the local communities on the sea turtle threats and the importance of protection.
SEA TURTLE FORENSIC FIELD INVESTIGATION WORKSHOP
Nancy Mettee1, David Gulko2, Patrica Rameriz3, Angelique Brantwaith3, and Karen Eckert1
1
Wider Caribbean Sea Turtle Conservation Network
CRCSI, 91-1020 Kai Loli St., Ewa Beach, HI, USA
3
CRCSI Instructor
2
Regardless of region, most coastal sea turtle habitats around the world are under various levels of impact
from illegal fishing, vessel groundings, destructive fishing, physical damage, coastal pollution and runoff,
overfishing, illegal international trade, overlapping (and often conflicting) use by various user groups,
bleaching, chemical effects and endocrine disruption, alien species-associated phase shifts, and nutrientassociated phase shifts. Few areas have trained field investigators and well-developed natural resource
programs to properly assess and handle the wide variety of anthropogenic events occurring; in most cases,
such short term human impact events often overwhelm the capabilities of resource managers to maximize
prosecution, mitigation, negotiation, mediation, or litigation success. This takes on even greater
significance relative to the illegal take of sea turtles and illegal trafficking in sea turtle products. While
investigation systems and resource management strategies vary from country to country and island to island,
successful field forensic strategies related to sea turtle anthropogenic events are relatively limited and, until
now, unstandardized at the most basic levels. Recently, groups of recognized experts within the United
States (The Coral Disease and Health Consortium’s Forensics Workshop Committee) and the international
community (the International Coral Reef Initiative (ICRI) Committee on Coral Reef Enforcement and
Natural Resource Investigation) have proposed initiating projects to create such standards for coral reef
75
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
investigations. The Coral Reef CSI Field Training Program has in turn adapted these standards towards
investigations of sea turtle take and habitat damage. This project makes use of investigative and rapid
ecological assessment techniques, marine evidence collection methods and handling, in-water enforcement
techniques, and education of both the public and decision-makers, and will enhance both resource
protection and management capabilities. Examples of this approach for coral reefs are available from the
successful pilot Coral Reef CSI workshop held in Cozumel in late 2006 and the fourteen previously funded
workshops held in the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, Malaysia, Indonesia, Trinidad & Tobago, Belize,
South Africa, Barbados, the Maldives, French Polynesia, Guam, Honduras, Thailand (Field Marine
Enforcement Investigation), Guadaloupe (Field Contaminant Assays) and the recent pilot workshop on Sea
Turtle Field Forenics held in Merida, Mexico. To date, the Coral Reef CSI Field Training Program remains
the only internationally recognized course which trains natural resource managers and marine enforcement
officers in standardized techniques and protocols to investigate and collect underwater evidence associated
with human-induced injuries and crimes to protected marine natural resources. The pilot workshop on Sea
Turtle Field Forensics was a successful 60 hour course taught in 2012. This program is available for use in
other countries with budget and specifics of deliverables available upon request.
INCREASING CAPACITY FOR SEA TURTLE RESEARCH AND MANAGEMENT IN THE
IOSEA REGION
Andrea D. Phillott and Ruvani N. Nagoda-Gamage
Asian University for Women, Chittagong, Bangladesh
Access to scientific literature is often a challenge for researchers in developing countries due to the high
cost of Western scientific journals, low bandwidth connections, and frequent publication solely in English.
To identify ways of overcoming these limitations, we conducted an on-line survey for readers of the Indian
Ocean Turtle Newsletter in the IOSEA region. Responses indicated that access to literature problems were
improved by the Sea Turtles of India and IOSEA Marine Turtle on-line bibliographies and libraries.
However, the majority of free, on-line scientific papers are written in English, which can potentially restrict
knowledge and understanding about standard research methods, and global research and conservation
priorities. Our survey results indicated that translation of papers from English to first languages would be
the second-best strategy to improve access to relevant scientific literature. To increase the regional
awareness and understanding of important publications on sea turtle biology and conservation in the
IOSEA region, we translated publications addressing global priorities, topics of regional interest and
standard research methods into Bangla, Burmese, Cambodian, Hindi, Malayalam, Sinhala, Tamil, Urdu and
Vietnamese. Papers were printed in each language, and hard copies and pdf’s can be obtained from the
senior author.
ENDANGERED PACIFIC LEATHERBACKS DOCUMENTED THROUGH COLLABORATIVE
CITIZEN SCIENCE – THE LEATHERBACK WATCH PROGRAM
Christopher A. Pincetich and Kari K. Gehrke
Sea Turtle Restoration Project, Forest Knolls, California, USA
Endangered Pacific leatherback sea turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) migrate across the Pacific to forage on
abundant jellyfish in and around 41,914 square miles of federally protected critical habitat offshore of
76
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
California, Oregon and Washington (USA). The Leatherback Watch Program is a collaborative citizen
science project sponsored by the Sea Turtle Restoration Project that works to record and communicate
sightings of leatherback sea turtles off the west coast of North America. The information obtained is then
used for education, research, and conservation purposes. The objective is to build a database of
opportunistic sighting with date, time, name of observer, exact GPS coordinates, a photograph or video as
evidence of the sighting, weather and behavior details from each sighting included. The Leatherback Watch
Program was organized and launched during the summer of 2010 and recorded one sighting in the
Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary from a marine biologist, who also shared a spectacular collection
of photographs from the sighting. During 2011 the program compiled 23 sightings from California to
British Columbia, Canada through outreach to approximately 150 program participants that receive our
monthly emails, phone calls and connect through the program Facebook page. The first sighting in 2011
was recorded June 29 offshore of Point Sur; sightings peaked offshore of Moss Landing in August, and the
frequency of opportunistic sightings increased with increased program participants. A grading system was
established to rank sightings; “A” grade contained photos, GPS coordinates, date, time, and came from an
experienced observer while “D” grade was an observation reported without photos or GPS coordinates by
an inexperienced observer. The first reported sighting of a leatherback in 2012 occurred offshore of Central
California June 7, but due to a lack of photos, GPS coordinates, and the report coming from recreational
sailors and not experienced marine naturalists, it was given a low grade. From July 9 to Jul 28, 2012 a total
of 17 sightings were reported by experienced observers and accompanied by photographs and GPS
coordinates. The current total of opportunistic sightings in 2012 is at 26 as of October 1. The Leatherback
Watch Program contact list has served as a useful outreach tool for on-water researchers and for advocacy
to gain support from businesses for AB 1776, the bill sponsored by the Sea Turtle Restoration Project bill
that successfully established the Pacific Leatherback sea turtle as the official marine reptile of California
and October 15 as Pacific Leatherback Conservation Day. The 2011-2012 observations represent a
significant contribution to the limited information currently available describing the habitat use and
behavior of the critically endangered Western Pacific population of leatherbacks. Sea Turtle Restoration
Project's outreach and education programs have found many Californians are not aware that leatherbacks
exist in the state’s coastal waters and rely on critical feeding habitat offshore of the state. The photos and
videos obtained from leatherback sightings are invaluable components of the growing public awareness of
this amazing sea turtle.
MARINE DEBRIS ACTION TEAMS WORKING TO CREATE PLASTIC-FREE SEA TURTLE
HABITAT
Christopher A. Pincetich1, Marc Ward2, Katherine C. Santos3, and Randall Arauz4
1
Sea Turtle Restoration Project, Forest Knolls, CA, USA
Sea Turtles Forever, Seaside, OR, USA
3
The Science Exchange, San Diego, CA, USA
4
PRETOMA, Costa Rica
2
Marine Debris Action Teams are volunteer groups that conduct scientific assessments of marine debris
density on shorelines, remove the debris, and spread awareness of the harmful impacts of plastic pollution
to sea turtles. Endangered sea turtles are jeopardized by marine debris in both marine and beach habitats
when they become entangled or ingest it. During the past three years of work building collaborative
partnerships with volunteers, scientists, and students, the Marine Debris Action Team's work has increased
its focus on developing a model project that can be implemented at sea turtle nesting beach conservation
projects around the world. The current Marine Debris Action Team's effort working to create plastic-free
sea turtle habitat in Costa Rica builds on a successful pilot project partnering with the local conservation
group PRETOMA and the Science Exchange Sea Turtle Internship Program based in San Diego, CA, USA.
Student interns work on nesting beach patrols during the evenings and early mornings as a top priority, then
spend the remainder of the working day collecting debris density data, performing beach cleanups, and
77
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
working to engage the local community and online followers in the importance of this work to sea turtle
and ocean health. One intern performed over 240 debris density surveys in three months at Playa Caletas,
Costa Rica, cataloged over 6,000 debris items, found a significant pattern of high debris density in nesting
and hatchling emergence habitat, and published the results in Marine Turtle Newsletter. During the summer
of 2012, interns collected debris density data at beaches on both Pacific and Caribbean coast nesting
beaches in Costa Rica and found a significantly greater density of debris along the Caribbean.
Collaborative efforts with Sea Turtles Forever at nesting beaches near Lagartillo Reef, Guanacaste, Costa
Rica resulted in the recording and removal of over 14,000 debris items in 2010-2011 and increased to over
17,000 debris items during 2012. Marine Debris Action Teams efforts on beaches inshore from Pacific
leatherback sea turtle critical habitat in Oregon and Washington have resulted in partnerships between
federal, state, and local organizations. Macro and micro-debris density surveys performed in Oregon by Sea
Turtles Forever use college student volunteers and receive support from local city government officials.
Debris density assessments led by Sea Turtle Restoration Project in California have cataloged and removed
over 10,000 debris items from 10 sites monitored over 20 months. Marine Debris Action Teams in
California have led scientific trainings for members of the Surfrider Foundation, 5 Gyres, YMCA and
collaborate with NOAA teams preparing for debris from the 2011 Japan tsunami. Plans in 2013 include the
release of a Project Manual to transform any sea turtle field station into an action and awareness center for
community education and action to create plastic-free sea turtle habitat, establishing permanent signage to
educate the public of the harmful effects of plastic pollution to sea turtles at PRETOMA field stations, and
increasing project partners around the world.
OUTREACH AND EDUCATION PROGRAM TO LOCAL COMMUNITIES: AN ESSENTIAL
TOOL FOR SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION
Graciela D.C. Pulido1, Efrain C. Moreno1, Laura Carruyo-Rincon1, Jordano Palmar1, Francisco
Rodriguez1, Dana P. Padron1, Ninive E. Espinoza1, Natalie E. Wildermann2, and Hector BarriosGarrido2
1
Grupo de Trabajo de Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela, Maracaibo, Zulia, Venezuela
Centro de Modelado Científico (CMC), Grupo de Trabajo de Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela,
Maracaibo, Zulia, Venezuela
2
Empirical knowledge in local communities that interact with sea turtles is a fundamental element in their
customs, and also represents a valuable resource for research and studies conducted by the Sea Turtle
Workgroup of the Gulf of Venezuela (GTTM–GV). This cultural information, linked with scientific data
obtained throughout 15 years of sea turtle conservation, has allowed us to better understand the current
status of sea turtles that feed in the Gulf of Venezuela (GV). This information stimulates our passion for
conservation, opening our senses to the mosaic of life-threatening impacts to these animals in our country
(i.e. by-catch, illegal trade of products and by-products, ship collisions, plastic and water contaminants and
ghost nets, among others). Thus, the GTTM-GV under its conservation objectives (research, education and
extension) will study and mitigate these impacts and create awareness among urban and rural communities
inhabiting GV coasts. We conducted educational and training activities through an outreach program in
three different target communities: (1) Indigenous inhabitants and fishermen, (2) university students and
faculty, and (3) urban citizens, granting social and ecological awareness and promoting a possible change
in their current lifestyles which might decrease negative consequences to sea turtle populations in the
region. The tools used for each target community were determined by evaluating surveys, tests, graphic
design strategies, and the degree of literacy in each locality. Coastal communities (rural) in the GV are
comprised mostly of illiterate indigenous people, primarily artisanal fishermen. Therefore, informal
workshops in these communities during a sea turtle’s rescue and/or release, and semi-structured interviews
supported by images and other graphic materials, have resulted in the integration and empowerment of at
least one community leader from each locality to sea turtle conservation activities executed by the NGO.
Within the university community, photography exhibitions, forums and documentary films faciltated the
78
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
integration of young researchers with the NGO, presenting conservation and research opportunities with
these reptiles or their habitats. Finally, at the third community level (urban), we implemented a series of
structured talks and school tours for small groups to observe sea turtles in rehabilitation centers, and we
displayed thematic bazaars and itinerant photographic exhibitions at several cultural facilities such as hotels,
shopping centers and museums, among others, to educate larger groups. Our outreach efforts are
fundamental to the development and implementation of the sea turtle conservation program. Each year a
greater number of fishermen and Indigenous people are trained and committed to sea turtle conservation.
New research opportunities along with financial support are growing. This helps us work towards one
simple goal: to make a difference in the world and connect all of those involved: fishing communities,
researchers, students and the general public.
THE GEORGIA SEA TURTLE CENTER MARINE DEBRIS CITIZEN SCIENCE AND
EDUCATION PROGRAM
Caitlin Sampson and Jeannie M. Martin
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA
The Georgia Sea Turtle Center (GSTC), located on Jekyll Island, Georgia, rehabilitates ill and injured sea
turtles along with other native wildlife. The Center is open to the general public with an interactive Exhibit
Gallery and Rehabilitation Pavilion with viewable turtle patients. The Center also focuses on environmental
education and research in the fields of ecology and wildlife health. The GSTC has developed a grant
funded program to address the issue of Marine Debris on Jekyll Island and the Georgia Coast in
collaboration with the Southeast Atlantic Marine Debris Initiative (SEA-MDI). The GSTC’s Marine Debris
Initiative consists of citizen science and educational components. The Garbage in the Water program is
presented to 3rd grade classrooms in Glynn County, GA, in the hopes of educating the next generation
about the fight against marine debris while encouraging them to make decisions that benefit our
environment. The second component of the grant involved the creation of a citizen science program using
the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration(NOAA)/SEA-MDI Marine Debris Tracker App. A
Marine Debris Docent volunteer position was created to give active and episodic volunteers at the GSTC an
app-based citizen science opportunity. Using the NOAA/SEA-MDI Marine Debris Tracker App, the GSTC
volunteers perform beach cleanups and plot the locations and types of marine debris found in and around
the coast. In addition to the benefit of having less marine debris, involving community members allows
them to take greater pride in their coastal environment, gain experience with science and technology and
show the importance of keeping our beaches clean. Previously there were no formal opportunities for onetime or short term volunteers at the GSTC, thus the Marine Debris Docent position is allowing more people
to become involved in our Center and to work with us towards our goals of research, rehabilitation and
education. To date, we have discovered that debris is concentrated in multiple kilometers of our beach and
is comprised of over 80% plastic. Each of the remaining categories (cloth, fishing gear, glass, lumber, metal,
rubber and other) individually constitutes 3% or less of our total plotted marine debris. The plastic category
can be further broken down to reveal that 48% of the total plastics is cigarettes while 25% is plastic
fragments. This data is being used to develop varied beach clean-up focus areas, to improve the Garbage in
the Water educational program, and the interpretation of the marine debris exhibits within our Educational
Gallery.
79
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EIGHT YEARS OF OUTREACH IN COASTAL GABON: FEELING THE SEA TURTLE LOVE
Aimée T. Sanders1, Angela Formia2, Fiona Maisels2, Francois Boussamba3, Gil A. Mounguengui4,
Solange Ngouessono5, Brice D. K. Mabert6, and Richard Parnell2
1
Gabon Sea Turtle Partnership, Libreville, Gabon
Wildlife Conservation Society, NY, USA
3
Aventures Sans Frontières, Libreville, Gabon
4
IBONGA-ACPE, Gamba, Gabon
5
Agence Nationale des Parcs Nationaux, Libreville, Gabon
6
Centre National des Données et de l’Information Océanographiques, Libreville, Gabon
2
Gabon hosts the largest leatherback population in the world, and the highest nesting density in Africa of
this critically endangered species. However, Gabon's leatherbacks and other sea turtle species (green,
hawksbill and olive ridley turtles) face threats, including commercial fisheries, poaching of adults and eggs,
and habitat disturbance and degradation (i.e. pollution, development, erosion, lighting, debris and logs on
the beaches). The Gabon Sea Turtle Partnership has been conducting community outreach and education in
Gabon since 2005. We have organized a national campaign to raise awareness of sea turtle conservation,
focusing on our coastal field sites and on Libreville, Gabon's capital. We will present an overview of the
last eight years of our efforts as an example of a successful and dynamic outreach program in Coastal
Equatorial Africa, with the hope that it will inspire similar efforts worldwide. Our goal is to raise awareness
among people of all demographics, including those that live near the national parks and those that live in
cities, where one doesn’t have many opportunities to discover the rich biodiversity of Gabon. If the
conservation of sea turtles is to succeed in Gabon, it is essential for the Gabonese people to have a sense of
stewardship toward their natural heritage and of responsibility toward its preservation for future generations.
Each year, we run a large number of seminars, presentations, and informal discussions with members of
coastal communities and school children. We produce and distribute educational materials. We have been
working extensively with children using role-playing techniques, enacting scenes and threats from the life
history of sea turtles in the schools and villages near sea turtle habitats. We also hold costume-making
workshops to teach local educators how to create durable, low-cost costumes for use in dramatic role-play.
Our activities and initiatives have frequently been presented in the national media through interviews,
documentaries, TV programs and newspaper articles. Sea turtle publicity videos are frequently shown on
giant flat-panel screens overlooking Libreville's busiest road, and a series of turtle murals publicize
conservation in the smaller towns. We have also produced a website and number of Partnership films in
order to broadcast our activities as widely as possible. The Partnership’s flagship outreach event is Turtle
Day, which is celebrated each year at the end of the nesting season in April and May. From its humble
roots at a single elementary school in Mayumba, a small town in southern Gabon, Turtle Day has grown
into a national event with over 2,000 participants at ten coastal sites, with large Gabonese corporations
seeking to sponsor our festivals. The fact that sponsorships such as these are being offered attests to the
success of our efforts. Even more encouraging is that after eight years, former elementary school students
who participated in the first Turtle Day are volunteering at the events, and are seeking jobs in conservation
and ecotourism as they begin to enter the workforce.
80
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CITSCI.ORG: CYBERINFRASTRUCTURE SUPPORT FOR GRASSROOTS CONSERVATION,
CITIZEN SCIENCE, AND COMMUNITY-BASED TERRESTRIAL, FRESHWATER, AND
MARINE TURTLE MONITORING
Russell Scarpino1, Gregory Newman1, and James Buehler2
1
2
Natural Resource Ecology Laboratory, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, USA
Gainesville, FL, USA
Citizen science and community-based turtle monitoring conservation programs are increasing in number
and breadth, generating volumes of scientific data. Many programs are ill-equipped to effectively manage
these data. We built a free, open-source, cyberinfrastructure support system for citizen science programs
(www.citsci.org) to support the full spectrum of program management and data management needs. The
system affords program coordinators the opportunity to create their own projects, manage project members,
build their own data entry sheets, streamline data entry, visualize data on maps, automate custom analyses,
and receive feedback. The majority of programs are grassroots efforts with conservation biology-oriented
goals and objectives. Thus far, CitSci.org has engaged 34 programs resulting in some 7,000+ natural
resource observations, and is perfectly suited to accommodate Testudine species project data. Here, we
discuss the unique opportunities afforded by CitSci.org to support the needs of community-based terrestrial,
freshwater, and marine turtle monitoring.
THE BELIZE TURTLE WATCH PROGRAM – IS CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTING OUR SEA
TURTLES?
Linda Searle and Melanie Day
ECOMAR, Belize City, Belize
The Belize Turtle Watch Program was launched in 2011 to determine if climate change is impacting sea
turtles. In order to measure these impacts, the Annual Sea Turtle Census was launched which aimed to
collect baseline data on the number of sea turtles nesting on our beaches, foraging in our waters, and the
number of sea turtles that are stranded along our coast. At the end of each year data and reports are
summarized so that changes, and impacts, over time can be measured. Diverse stakeholder groups living
along the coast including biologists working with marine protected area managers, coastal property owners,
marine guides, and the general public are invited to participate in the Belize Turtle Watch Program.
Biologists participated in a 3 day training workshop and took part in the first Annual In-water Sea Turtle
Survey. Biologists also learned new protocol prepared by SandWatch which measures changes in the beach
profile within their MPAs that can be useful to monitor impacts of climate change. Other stakeholder
groups were reached through the production and distribution of educational materials including a minidocumentary informing volunteers about the program, posters, stickers, calendars, and radio
announcements. Questionnaires were also used to measure stakeholder participation. Other programs
launched in conjunction with the Belize Turtle Watch Program include the Adopt A Beach and Adopt A
Reef programs which encouraged stakeholders to become actively involved in monitoring for sea turtle
activity. Results from the first Annual Sea Turtle Census indicate that hawksbill sea turtles are the most
abundant in Belize. New reports on sea turtle nesting locations were received and an increase in the
reporting of stranded sea turtles was also recorded. Preliminary results indicate that in some locations sea
turtles in Belize are already impacted by climate change. Acknowledgments: There are numerous persons
and organizations that must be acknowledged including partners of the Belize Turtle Watch Program: the
81
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Belize Fisheries Department, World Wildlife Fund, Protected Areas Conservation Trust, Gulf & Caribbean
Fisheries Institute, Caribbean Protected Areas Managers, United Nations Environment Program, Caribbean
Environment Program, the Wider Caribbean Sea Turtle Conservation Network, and other members of the
Belize Sea Turtle Conservation Network including the Belize Audubon Society, Oceanic Society, Southern
Environmental Association, Toledo Institute for Development and the Environment, University of Belize
Environmental Research Institute and Wildlife Conservation Society. The primary author is grateful for the
travel grant awarded through generous donations by the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle
Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America. Special recognition of
the stakeholders in Belize that monitor sea turtle activity must also be made and includes the biologists that
spend hours in the field and share the results of their surveys; the coastal residents for volunteering with the
Belize Turtle Watch Program by monitoring their beaches and coastal waters for sea turtles; and the general
public for their interest in learning more about the great ocean migrators, the extraordinarily humble sea
turtle.
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION AND SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION ACTIVITIES IN
COASTAL GUJARAT, INDIA
Shwetal Shah1 and Dinesh Goswami2
1
2
Environmental Expert & Ex-Chief Ministers Fellow, Government of Gujarat, India
Environmental Conservation Activist & Founder, Prakruti Nature Club, Kodinar, Gujarat, INDIA
Gujarat is one of the fastest developing states in India, comprising 6% of the total geographic area and 5%
of the country's population. Gujarat has the longest shoreline of any Indian state (1,600 km), and therefore
the highest interface with the marine environment. Olive ridley, green and leatherback sea turtles are found
in Gujarat amongst various other marine fauna, and green and olive ridley sea turtles also nest on sandy
beaches along the coast. Due to rapid industrialization, many natural sea turtle habitats are vanishing and
require special attention for their conservation. There has been an effort by NGOs and local activists to
conserve sea turtles, which has had positive results in Gujarat. Here we highlight how the IEC (Information,
Education and Communication) activities have impacted the conservation efforts by local communities.
The primary methods of the IEC include: (1) AV (Audio-video) communications, (2) publications and (3)
mass addresses to women and children. There are more than 10 voluntary organizations involved in IEC
activities for the conservation of sea turtles and other marine fauna. Additional coordinated efforts are
required by the conservation practitioners and communities to improve the preservation of natural habitats
and sea turtles in Gujarat. Acknowledgements: We acknowledge the support of International Sea Turtle
Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA), Ecoteach,
Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and our parent
organisation Prakruti Nature Club (INDIA).
82
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
RAISING SEA TURTLE AND DUGONG CONSERVATION AWARENESS IN WESTERN
PROVINCES, PAPUA NEW GUINEA
Julie Traweek1 and Rachel Groom2
1
2
Sea Turtle Foundation, Townsville, Queensland, Australia
GHD, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
Sea turtles and dugongs worldwide are close to extinction due to an array of human impacts such as overfishing, coastal development, marine debris and unsustainable hunting. People living in thirteen Western
Province communities of Papua New Guinea have recognised that current take levels are unsustainable. Sea
Turtle Foundation, in partnership with several organisations (listed below) and at the request of the
communities themselves, created a Sea Turtle and Dugong Awareness program that complements other
work taking place in the Torres Strait, around Cape York and in other countries in the region. The first
phase of the program entailed a workshop with elders of each of the participating communities; this gave
everyone a chance to have a voice in the direction and scope of the program and ensured that traditional
knowledge was included in the written resources and helped form the foundation of the program delivered
in the communities. The final program content explored sea turtle and dugong biology, historical
knowledge, environmental values, and sustainable practices. Resource packs distributed as part of the
program included community participant workbooks, leader manuals, posters, stickers, hats, t-shirts, etc., as
well as waterproof cards with rules that can be taken on boats. Resources were developed in consultation
with community leaders including elders and teachers. The program was delivered to thirteen communities
by a local, well-known conservation leader and STF staff, mainly by boat, and included twenty schools as
well as general community visits. In addition, digital cameras were given to each community to record
what was important in their community, with the understanding that the memory cards would be returned to
STF (the cameras and new memory cards were left in the communities). The response to the awareness
program has been very positive. Community members reported learning new information, particularly
about sea turtle biology and life history characteristics, and are applying this new knowledge in their
interactions with turtles and dugongs (i.e., taking smaller turtles rather than the largest ones). The photos
returned from the villages are extremely good, and were used to create a calendar, the proceeds of which
will go back into the awareness program. A gallery show of the photos is also planned, to increase
awareness of the Western Provinces and the linkages between our turtle populations and the collective
efforts to protect them in our region. This program is a joint effort between Sea Turtle Foundation, Marine
and Tropical Sciences Research Facility, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Torres Strait Regional
Authority, Department of Environment and Conservation PNG, and James Cook University.
83
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
HAWKSBILL CUP: ADDING NON-ECONOMIC VALUES TO SAVE A SPECIES IN EL
SALVADOR AND NICARAGUA
José Urteaga1, Michael Liles2, Ingrid Yañez3, Perla Torres1, Ana Henriquez2, Gena Abarca1,
Eduardo Altamirano1, David Melero1,3, Carlos Rivas4, Cleide Cea4, Victor Medina5, and Alexander
Gaos3
1
Fauna & Flora International Nicaragua-FFI
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative, San Salvador, El Salvador
3
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative - ICAPO
4
GrönComunicación, San Salvador, El Salvador
5
Ekofilm, Nicaragua
2
Sea turtle eggs in low-income regions are often viewed by local residents as an economic resource, and
conservation initiatives must offer a higher economic incentive for protection than would be received from
other uses. This is particularly true for hawksbill eggs in El Salvador and Nicaragua, as conservation
legislation formed by top-down, non-participatory measures has failed to protect hawksbill nests in both
countries. However, the purchase of hawksbill nests for protection is financially unsustainable and does
little to promote a local conservation ethic. To add non-economic value to hawksbill eggs, we initiated the
Hawksbill Regional Cup in 2012, a friendly competition which emulated the Soccer World Cup such that
the hawksbill nesting season represented the “final match” between the two most important nesting sites
(i.e., El Salvador and Nicaragua) in the eastern Pacific Ocean. The goals were to determine which “team”
could score more “hawksbill conservation goals” (e.g., most nests protected, most hatchlings released) and
to examine how the Hawksbill Regional Cup has affected the values that local participants place on
hawksbills and associated conservation actions at both sites. We analyzed the results of a standardized
survey that was conducted with a total of 30 local participants in each country to better understand the
motives that determine their level of participation in hawksbill conservation. We discuss how the Hawksbill
Regional Cup has enhanced stakeholder interest and participation in nest protection activities, facilitated
information-exchange and experience-sharing among egg collectors, and shifted local discourse on
hawksbill conservation from purely economic terms.
84
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Fisheries and Threats
HOW MUCH IS IT? ASSESSMENT OF SEA TURTLE SUB PRODUCTS ILLEGAL TRADE ON
THE PACIFIC COAST OF NICARAGUA
Gena Abarca1, José Urteaga1, Isabel Sirias1, Liza González2, Carlos Mejía3, Pedrarias Dávila4, Alma
Chávez5, Edwin Caballero6, María Galeano7, Ruth Aguirre8, Istvan Sepulveda9, and Azucena
Baltodano10
1
Fauna & Flora Internacional, Nicaragua
Paso Pacifico, Nicaragua
3
Ministerio del Ambiente y Recursos Naturales, Nicaragua
4
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de Nicaragua- León, Nicaragua
5
Hermanamiento Wisconsin-Santa Teresa, Nicaragua
6
Fundación Luchadores Integrados al Desarrollo de la Región, Nicaragua
7
Alianza para las Áreas Silvestre, Nicaragua
8
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de Nicaragua- Managua, Nicaragua
9
Asociación de Municipios Integrados por la Cuenca y Territorios de la Laguna de Apoyo de Nicaragua
10
Corporacion Municipal de Mercados de Managua, Nicaragua
2
Nicaragua hosts important habitats for five sea turtle species. Two of the most important threats to these
species have been poaching of eggs and hunting to extract hawksbill shells. Direct take of turtles and eggs
are especially driven by financial incentives to coastal communities provided by urban populations where
these products are demanded. For more than forty years Governmental and nongovernmental organizations
have been developing actions to protect sea turtles. These efforts have been strengthened during the last 10
years. Today the trade of sea turtle eggs and hawksbill shell are banned and violation to this regulation face
penalties of two to four years of prison. Even though the existence of these efforts and legislation, illegal
trade of sea turtle sub products is widely widespread and still occurs openly in the cities of Nicaragua. The
objective of this study was to quantify the volume of sea turtle sub products being sold in cities of the
pacific coast of Nicaragua as well as understand the drivers for sellers and consumers. We analyze the
results of 2,224 semi structured surveys performed in eight cities of the Pacific coast of Nicaragua. We
conclude that major efforts must be implemented in cities in order to reduce the demand and therefore the
extraction of sea turtle sub products, providing key elements to be considered on the development of a
strategy to pursue this goal.
OVERCOMING THE LOGISTICAL CHALLENGES OF IMPLEMENTING OBSERVER
PROGRAMS IN SMALL-SCALE FISHERIES
Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto1, Jeffrey C. Mangel1, Natalia Ortiz2, Elizabeth Campbell2, and Brendan
Godley3
1
University of Exeter, UK/ ProDelphinus, Peru
ProDelphinus, Peru
3
University of Exeter, UK
2
Onboard observers are identified as the most accurate way to assess bycatch and mortality in fisheries
operations. However, the implementation of onboard observer programs in small-scale fishing fleets, which
are thought to have high levels of sea turtle bycatch, is very challenging. This is due mostly to logistical
factors, such as small vessel size, which limits the space available for an extra person (the observer). We
85
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
tested the use of a SPOT Satellite GPS Messenger in parallel with an onboard observer program aboard
small-scale fishing vessels. This device allows communication with up to ten previously programmed
contacts. It operates using satellites and can therefore be used anywhere in the world. The SPOT has five
standard functions that can be used to track the unit’s position (Lat/Lon), send SOS alerts, send emergency
alerts, provide regular check-ins, and, in more advanced versions, even send short text messages. SPOT
trials were conducted from Salaverry port, Peru from May 2011 to August 2012. The function used was
‘Check-in’ which we programmed so that two email addresses received real-time position alerts. It was not
necessary to change the unit’s batteries during the study period. We received a total of 163 signals,
corresponding to the GPS positions of 163 fishing sets conducted by the observed vessels. A comparison of
positions between the SPOT messages and those noted by observers using handheld GPS units indicates
that the two devices typically provided locations within 0.20 ± 0.19 km of each other, with the differences
accounted for due issues such as vessel drift and timing of position. Given the SPOT’s low cost ($120 US,
plus a $99 annual subscription), compact size, and ability to gather and transmit real time position
information, it can serve as option in facilitating the implementation of an observer program where
logistical challenges preclude obtaining more detailed trip or bycatch data. As one of the SPOTs functions
is as an emergency alert, it could be of added value to small-scale vessels which frequently lack safety
devices such as EPIRBs.
COMPARISON OF CIRCLE HOOK AND J-HOOK PERFORMANCE IN SEA TURTLE
REDUCTION RATES IN ARTISANAL LONGLINE FLEETS IN FOUR COUNTRIES OF THE
EASTERN PACIFIC OCEAN
Sandra Andraka1, Maite Pons2, Liliana Rendón3, Lucas Pacheco4, Alvaro Segura5, Samuel Amorós6,
Michael Valqui6, María L. Parga7, Takahisa Mituhasi8, Nick Vogel9, and Martin Hall9
1
WWF, Latin America and the Caribbean Program. San José, Costa Rica
Centro de Investigación y Conservación Marina (CICMAR), Canelones, Uruguay
3
Escuela de Pesca del Pacifico Oriental/WWF, Manta, Ecuador.
4
WWF, Panama Office. Panamá, República de Panamá
5
WWF, Costa Rica Office. San Jose, Costa Rica
6
WWF Perú, Lima, Perú.
7
SUBMON, Barcelona, Spain.
8
Overseas Fishery Cooperation Foundation of Japan; Tokyo, Japan
9
Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (IATTC) La Jolla, CA, USA
2
We analyzed the performance of circle hooks in relation to J-style hooks on the hooking rates of target and
non-target species in the artisanal surface longline fisheries of four of the nine participating countries in the
Eastern Pacific Sea Turtle Bycatch Program, with the largest sample sizes (Peru, Ecuador, Panama and
Costa Rica). These fisheries target mahi-mahi, Coryphaena hippurus, or a combination of tunas, billfishes
and sharks (TBS), and use different techniques and gear configurations to catch their targets. Five different
species of sea turtles are incidentally caught in these fisheries, olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea), green
turtle (Chelonia mydas), loggerhead (Caretta caretta), hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata) and leatherback
(Dermochelys coriacea). We present the results of comparisons between tuna or J-style hooks and 16/0
circle hooks in the TBS fishery from Peru, Ecuador, Panama and Costa Rica, and between tuna hooks and
18/0 circle hooks in Costa Rica. For the mahi-mahi fishery, we analyzed the performance of 14/0 and 15/0
circle hooks in Ecuadorian and Peruvian vessels and 16/0 circle hooks in Costa Rican vessels vs. the
traditional J-style hooks. A total of 1,193,738 hooks were observed, in 4,535 sets. Hooking rates for target
and non-target species were not consistent for all fisheries and countries analyzed. However, circle hooks
reduced sea turtle hooking rates in most of the comparisons analyzed between 25% and over 75%. In some
specific cases, such as mahi mahi fisheries in Ecuador and Peru, results show reduction in target catch rates
with circle hooks, which could affect fishermen acceptation on potential fisheries certification. Thus, a
complete evaluation of the ecological impact of the replacement of J-style or tuna hooks by circle hooks
86
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
requires a holistic approach that considers the changes in selectivity for both fish and sea turtle species, and
the condition of the stocks impacted (threatened and/or overfished). In any case, applying measures to
improve the handling of hooked turtles with the right use of instruments and techniques in regional and
national fisheries longline is essential to increase the survival of these species. Acknowledgements: the
authors would like to thank onboard observers for collecting data and participating fishermen of artisanal
longline fisheries in Peru, Ecuador, Panama and Costa Rica for their trust and cooperation.
ADULT GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN OGASAWARA, JAPAN: A STUDY OF
ANIMALS LIVING WITH INGESTED MARINE DEBRIS
Ayaka Asada1 and Hiroyuki Suganuma2
1
2
Everlasting Nature of Asia , Ogasawara, Japan
Everlasting Nature of Asia, Yokohama, Japan
Populations of green turtles (Chelonia mydas) migrating in Japan’s Pacific coastal region return to the
Ogasawara Islands, Japan for their mating and nesting activities. The Ogasawara Islands are known as the
largest breeding habitat for green turtles in Japan. Their mating season begins in early spring and nesting
activity starts at the end of April and continues through September. This is also the season for sea turtle
fishing. Sea turtle fishing, an important part of the food culture in Ogasawara, is a legal fishery today. This
fishery coincides with a conservation project within the islands, and is highly regulated by Tokyo
Metropolitan. It is imperative for all the fishermen to report their daily catch to the Fishery Union of
Ogasawara upon returning to the harbor. The seasonal harvest limit is 125 individuals of SCL greater than
or equal to 75 cm which considered to be an adult. All harvested individuals are sexually mature since
harvesting action is only applied during their mating activity. Harvesting sea turtles is prohibited from June
to July, which is the peak nesting season throughout the islands. Harvested individuals are mostly healthy,
randomly selected in a biological perspective, and kept in alive in a fish farm pool until the day they are
slaughtered. Sex is visually identified and staff members of Everlasting Nature of Asia (ELNA) take the
measurements of body mass, SCL, and CCL immediately after landing. Along with the slaughtering
process, which is run by a group of local fishermen, ELNA records all the sizes and weights of organs and
collect the contents of digestive organs (including the esophagus, stomach, small and large intestines). Our
sample size from 2010 is 10 individuals and 29 from 2011. For purposes of this study we discuss our
findings regarding marine debris specifically plastics, Styrofoam, and pieces of derelict fishing gear in the
digestive organs as well as findings of sea weed and some type of tunicate (Pyrosoma spp.). We present our
findings on the percentages of harvested individuals containing artificial products in their digestive tract. Of
the turtles sampled, 60% (n=10) and 76% (n=29) of the turtles from 2010 and 2011, respectively, contained
man-made products. These results are highly valuable in terms of the data collected from live full grown
adults of green turtle and significant evidence of individuals that have lived despite consuming marine
debris over time. Moreover, they may provide a considerable indication to other areas where only stranded
individuals are available to study marine debris effects on sea turtle and even some insights into a variety of
studies of sea turtle ecology.
87
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
LEATHERBACK TURTLE MOVEMENTS AND BEHAVIOR IN THE PACIFIC OCEAN: ITS
APPLICATION IN PREDICTING INTERACTIONS WITH FISHERIES
Helen Bailey1, Scott R. Benson2, George L. Shillinger3, Steven J. Bograd4, Peter H. Dutton2, Scott A.
Eckert5, Stephen J. Morreale6, Frank V. Paladino7, Tomoharu Eguchi2, David G. Foley4,8, Barbara A.
Block9, Rotney Piedra10, Creusa Hitipeuw11, Ricardo F. Tapilatu12, John H. Roe13, Evan Howell14,
and James R. Spotila15
1
University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, Chesapeake Biological Laboratory, Solomons,
MD 20688, USA
2
NOAA/NMFS/SWFSC/Protected Resources Division, 3333 N. Torrey Pines Court, La Jolla, CA 92037,
USA
3
The Tag-A-Giant Foundation, P.O. Box 52074, Pacific Grove, CA 93950, USA
4
NOAA/NMFS/SWFSC/Environmental Research Division, 1352 Lighthouse Avenue, Pacific Grove, CA
93950, USA
5
Department of Biology and Natural Resources, Principia College, Elsah, IL 62028, USA
6
Department of Natural Resources, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
7
Department of Biology, Indiana-Purdue University, Fort Wayne, IN 46805, USA
8
Joint Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI 98622, USA
9
Hopkins Marine Station of Stanford University, 120 Oceanview Boulevard, Pacific Grove, CA 93950,
USA
10
Parque Nacional Marino Las Baulas, Ministerio de Ambiente, Energía y Telecomunicaciones Apartado
473-3000, Heredia, Costa Rica
11
World Wildlife Fund for Nature – Indonesia, Jl. Mega Kuningan Lot 8-9/A9, Mega Kuningan Jakarta,
Indonesia
12
Marine Laboratory, The State University of Papua (UNIPA), Manokwari (98314), Papua Barat Province,
Indonesia
13
Department of Biology, University of North Carolina, Pembroke, North Carolina, NC 28372, USA
14
NOAA/NMFS Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, 2570 Dole Street, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA
15
Department of Biology, Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA
Interactions with fisheries are believed to be a major cause of mortality for adult leatherback turtles
(Dermochelys coriacea), which is of particular concern in the Pacific Ocean, where they have been rapidly
declining. In order to identify where these interactions are occurring and how they may be reduced, it is
essential first to understand the movements and behavior of leatherback turtles. There are two regional
nesting populations in the East Pacific (EP) and West Pacific (WP), comprised of multiple nesting sites.
We synthesized tracking data from both populations and compared their movement patterns. A switching
state-space model was applied to 135 Argos satellite tracks to account for observation error, and to
distinguish between migratory and area-restricted search behaviors. Area-restricted search behavior,
indicative of foraging, mainly occurred in the southeast Pacific for the EP leatherbacks, whereas the WP
leatherbacks had several different search areas in the California Current, central North Pacific, South China
Sea, off eastern Indonesia, and off southeastern Australia. We also extracted remotely sensed
oceanographic data and applied a generalized linear mixed model to determine if there were difference
between the two populations in their response to oceanic conditions. For the WP population, the probability
of area-restricted search behavior was positively correlated with chlorophyll-a concentration. This response
was less strong in the EP population, but they had a higher probability of search behavior where there was
greater Ekman upwelling, which may increase the transport of nutrients and consequently prey availability.
The occurrence of leatherback turtles within both coastal and offshore areas means they have a high risk of
exposure to many different fisheries, which may be very distant from their nesting sites. Their movement
patterns were integrated with data on broad-scale longline fishing effort in the Pacific Ocean to estimate
relative bycatch risk over space and time. Areas of relatively high bycatch risk were predicted to occur in
the Western and Central Tropical Pacific, the Central North and Northeast Pacific, Southwest Pacific
88
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
adjacent to Australia, as well as in the Eastern Tropical Pacific and the South Pacific Subtropical Gyre.
Leatherback turtle bycatch has been of particular concern in the Hawaii-based longline fishery, which was
closed in early 2011 in response to the number of leatherbacks in the bycatch. Examination of the timing
and location of this fishery, turtle bycatch and leatherback turtle movements indicated that there had been
an increase in fishery effort in the fourth quarter of the year and to the northeast from 2005 to 2011. This
increased the spatio-temporal overlap between the fishery and leatherback turtles, and hence resulted in
higher bycatch. Based on this analysis, the NOAA TurtleWatch tool is being modified to help reduce
interactions between the Hawaii-based longline fishery and leatherbacks.
GHOST NETS: A NEW HAZARD TO SEA TURTLES IN THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
Hector Barrios-Garrido1,2,3,4, Maria Jose Petit-Rodriguez1,2, Efrain Moreno1, and Natalie
Wildermann1,2,3
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela (GTTM-GV).
Laboratorio de Ecologia General, Departamento de Biologia. La Universidad del Zulia (LUZ).
3
Centro de Modelado Cientifico (CMC-LUZ).
4
MTSG-IUCN
2
There are many natural problems threatening the survival of sea turtles worldwide; however, it is well
known that anthropogenic factors impact the most on reptile populations. The principal threat is ocean
pollution, affecting mainly the migratory pathways and feeding grounds. Until recent years, the Gulf of
Venezuela was considered as an important feeding ground for sea turtles with ideal conditions for their
development during several stages of their life cycles; although these bio-ecological conditions remain
present, we have recently evidenced an increase in problems such as contamination. Impact by
hydrocarbons, plastic intake and ghost nets are the main new hazards that are affecting this important zone
of northwestern Venezuela. During a in-water fieldtrip in the indigenous community of Kazuzain (midGuajira) we observed and recorded the information of a juvenile green turtle (Chelonia mydas) found dead
entangled in a monofilament net (4" mesh size and 15 m long) in advanced decomposition state. Through
this report we account a new anthropic threat within this feeding ground; the low incidence of this kind of
events could be due to the high costs of the fishing nets for the fishermen (Wayúu indigenous communities)
in this area, who tend to reuse the fishing nets, discarding few fishing gears. In addition, we presume that
due to the characteristics of the net, it could proceed from bigger fishing ships of the southern communities
Gulf of Venezuela, a non-indigenous territory. In this sense, it is necessary to develop systematic
assessments in order to evaluate the impact of ghost nets in the study area, extended to all fishing
communities connected by the waters of the Gulf of Venezuela, as the consequences could induce not only
environmental, but also social problems.
89
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
THE SPATIAL OVERLAP BETWEEN NESTING LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES
(DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA) AND NEARSHORE FISHERIES: BYCATCH IN THE TRINIDAD
DRIFT GILLNET FISHERIES
Rhema Bjorkland
Northwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, Seattle, Washington, USA
Integrating information on the distribution of fishing, incidental capture (bycatch) and sea turtle movement
is critical in reducing sea turtle interactions with fisheries. I examined the overlap of nesting leatherbacks
and fishing activity on the north and east coasts of Trinidad, Republic of Trinidad and Tobago. I used
kernel density estimation (KDE) to compare the kernel home ranges (KHR) of turtles, and fishing sets, and
observed bycatch in artisanal gillnets. Data for the analysis came from a satellite tagging study of 9 nesting
females and from experimental gillnet bycatch trials. I applied newer approaches to kernel bandwidth
selection and also examined the home ranges of the telemetered animals based on their principal nesting
location (east coast or north coast). The Caribbean Sea is the primary oceanic influence of Trinidad’s
northern coast, while the Atlantic Ocean is the main influence on the eastern shoreline. Differences in
habitat use between these two groups may impact the spatial overlap with fisheries and create significantly
different bycatch risks. Separating the telemetered animals by primary rookery area (east coast versus north
coast) revealed differences in association with several environmental variables and in the spatial overlap
with the observed gillnet fishery. Furthermore, an overlay of the kernel density estimates of turtle
occurrence and fishing demonstrate that the home range of the north coast turtles overlaps with the fishing
areas to a greater degree than the home ranges of the east coast turtles. However, I identified significantly
higher frequencies in bycatch for east coast nesters in their core habitat. The high rates in the core areas
probably arise from both the behavior of the fishers and the distribution and behavior of the turtles,
suggesting that both spatial measures and fishery practice must be included in the mitigation tool kit.
RISK ASSESSMENT OF HEAVY METALS IN THE OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE
(LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) AT OSTIONAL BEACH, COSTA RICA
Lucrezia C. Bonzi1, Annalisa Zaccaroni2, and Laura Sofia Brenes Chaves3
1
University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy
University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
3
Universidad Estatal a Distancia, San José, Costa Rica
2
Sea turtles are endangered species as a result of centuries of overexploitation for meat, eggs and shells,
incidental capture and habitat destruction. Moreover, several classes of anthropogenic pollutants discharged
into the marine ecosystem could affect their survival. Among the environmental pollutants, heavy metals
have a great relevance in ecotoxicology because of their persistence and their possible role as endocrine
disruptors. In sea turtles, eggs receive their initial burden with maternal transfer during egg formation and
are then exposed to contaminants in the nest environment during incubation. The aim of this study is to
provide a risk assessment of heavy metals in the olive ridley’s (Lepidochelys olivacea) nesting population
in Ostional beach, Costa Rica. From September to November 2012, during and between arribadas events,
we collected blood samples from nesting females during oviposition to measure trace element
concentrations. In order to evaluate the maternal transfer, we also collected 2 eggs per sampled female and
we will determine heavy metal levels in different eggs fractions (eggshell, yolk and albumen). Following
oviposition, exposure to heavy metals in contaminated nest material and soil may also add to chemical
90
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
burdens in eggs. To assess risk for incubation success and estimate the uptake from the environment, we
will also determine the contamination of the nest, by collecting and analyzing sand samples taken from the
nest chamber during oviposition. At the time of hatching, we collected eggshells and dead embryos, in
order to measure heavy metal contamination at the end of incubation, as related to the initial maternal
burden. Following heavy metals determination, a risk assessment will be performed to determine if
contaminant burden could affect embryos survival, starting from available toxic thresholds set for sea
turtles, reptiles or birds. Environmental contaminants can severely affect embryonic development and can
potentially contribute to embryo mortality, representing a very important cause of population declines.
Ostional beach in northwest Costa Rica is the second most important arribada rookery in the world that
supports a large mass-nesting assemblage with persistently low hatching rates. Our study will be the first to
determine the level of heavy metal contamination in this population of Olive Ridleys and to test whether
there is any correlation with hatching success in Ostional beach. The senior author thanks the International
Sea Turtle Symposium for their support with a travel grant that allowed me to attend the conference and
present my research. Support for this grant was made available through generous donations provided by:
International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service,
Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics
and CLS America.
THE UTILIZATION OF A HATCHERY TO MINIMIZE SEA TURTLE IMPACTS DURING A
SEA DEFENSE PROJECT IN ADA FOAH, GHANA.
Audrey Bourgois1 and Phil Allman2
1
2
Dredging International (Cyprus) Ltd, Branch office Ghana
Florida Gulf Coast University, Fort Myers, Florida, USA
Ghana has been exposed to significant coastal soil erosion for over a century, and is responsible for 10
meters of shoreline retreat in some years. Such erosion rates have resulted in the complete loss of coastal
villages and several lives. Loss of coastal habitat is also expected to have negative impacts to sea turtles by
preventing the female from reaching suitable nest sites or by washing out or flooding eggs during
incubation. In 2010, the Republic of Ghana contracted Dredging International Cyprus Ltd to complete a sea
defense project in Ada Foah that would reduce or eliminate coastal erosion. The project includes
construction of seven groins across 5.3 km of beach, with beach nourishment conducted between.
Logistical concerns require this work to be conducted without interruption during a period of 2.5 years. The
PIs developed a sea turtle monitoring program to reduce the project’s impact by monitoring sea turtle
activity, relocating nests located in sites to be impacted by coastal protection work activities, and evaluating
hatching success from relocated and in situ nests. During the nesting season 2011-2012, surveys were
conducted throughout the project site to identify any nesting activity (Dermochelys coriacea, Lepidochelys
olivacea, and Chelonia mydas). Nests deposited in areas that were marked for impact within 70 days were
relocated to a hatchery. Mean hatching success for relocated nests was 80.2 % with the production of 7,231
hatchlings. On the other hand, the hatching success for in situ nests was only 23.8% (3,427 hatchlings
produced) due primarily to predation and beach erosion. Hatchery nest temperatures were significantly
higher than control temperatures at equal depths (F(3)=57.2, p<.0001) and were routinely within the female
producing range (31.7°C for olive ridleys and 31.4°C for leatherbacks). The mean incubation periods of
hatchery and in situ nests did not differ. Therefore, we expect the nest temperatures were not significantly
different between locations. We will also explore the influence of environmental factors and relocation
methods on hatching success of hatchery nests. These data indicate the hatchery served as a successful
mechanism to minimize sea turtle impacts by improving hatching success and not affecting offspring sex
ratios.
91
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
APPLYING LANDSCAPE MODELING APPROACHES TO PREDICT GREEN TURTLE
(CHELONIA MYDAS) MOVEMENT PATTERNS IN THE NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC
Wan-Hwa Cheng1,2, John F. Weishampel1, I-Jiunn Cheng2, and Katsufumi Sato3
1
Department of Biology, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida 32816, USA
Institute of Marine Biology, National Taiwan Ocean University, Keelung, Taiwan, 202-24, ROC
3
Coastal Conservation Section, International Coastal Research Center, Atmosphere and Ocean Research
Institute, University of Tokyo, Japan
2
Unlike most green turtle populations globally, those in the northwestern Pacific are considered to be at high
risk for decline. In order to preserve this Regional Management Unit (RMU), it is vital to understand the
regional biology/ecology of this species to enhance conservation management strategies to reduce potential
threats. This includes understanding their spatio-temporal movement patterns. Studying movement
behaviors provides insight into their habitat use. However, underlying oceanographic features that
influence their migratory behaviors are poorly understood, yet these dynamic features have been linked to
the probability of fisheries interactions with turtles. Here, we use telemetry tracks from 29 post-nesting
female green turtles from Taiwan and Japan over a 19-year (1994-2012) period. GIS was used to overlay
and extract environmental parameters, such as sea surface temperature (SST) and chlorophyll a, that
correspond to these telemetry tracks. Landscape modeling approaches, such as circuitscape theory or leastcost path (LCP) methods, use multivariate techniques to predict potential movement pathways and to
identify important corridors. Circuitscape models were developed for assessing landscape connectivity
using theories that are analogous to electrical circuits; LCP is a technique that uses area weighted distance
functions across a landscape to identify potential corridors between two areas. The geospatial
environmental parameters derived largely from satellite sensors will be used to derive resistances for the
circuitscapes and weightings for the LCP modeling. In this study, we are evaluating these general types of
predictive model to see if they can be applied to the sea turtle migration patterns. These models potentially
have management implications to help minimize interactions with fishing operations.
EU PURSE SEINE FISHERY INTERACTION WITH MARINE TURTLES IN THE ATLANTIC
AND INDIAN OCEANS: A 15 YEAR ANALYSIS
Sandra Clermont1, Pierre Chavance2, Alicia Delgado3, Hilario Murua4, Jon Ruiz3, Stéphane
Ciccione5, and Jérôme Bourjea1
1
IFREMER, DOI
IRD
3
IEO
4
AZTI
5
KELONIA
2
Bycatch of marine turtles, vulnerable or endangered species, is a growing issue of all fisheries, including
oceanic purse-seine fishery. The present paper seeks to assess marine turtle bycatch at a spatial and
temporal level in the European purse seine fishery operating in the Atlantic and Indian Oceans. The study
was based on data collected through French and Spanish observer programs from 1995 to 2011, a period
where more than 230 000 fishing sets were realized by the UE fleets in both oceans. A total of 15,913
fishing sets were observed, including 6,515 drifting Fish Aggregating Devices (FAD) and 9,398 Free
92
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Swimming Schools (FSC), representing a global coverage of 10.3% in the AO and 5.1% in the IO. Over the
study period, 597 turtles were caught during set observations, 86% being released alive at sea. At the same
time, from 2003 to 2011, 14,124 specific observations were carried out on floating objects whether they
ended in a set or not. A total of 354 marine turtles were observed, where 80% escaped or were entangled
alive and, therefore, released alive. At the temporal and spatial level, data were organized and analysed by
ocean, fishing mode (FAD vs. FSC) as well as by year, quarter and statistical square of 1°. In order to
evaluate the impact of this fishery in both oceans, bycatch distribution was compared to the total fishing
effort of the UE fleet, as well as to the known marine turtle post nesting migration routes, nesting
population abundances and known feeding areas. The species composition, the size and sex structure of
bycatch are also discussed here. Finally, an attempt to raise the data to the total fishing effort was carried
out. Based on observations of marine turtle by-catches on sets, we estimated that, globally, 3,500 marine
turtles were accidentally captured by the EU-PS fleet in the Atlantic Ocean from 1995 to 2010, and around
2,000 in the Indian Ocean from 2003 to 2010, with a corresponding annual bycatch rate of 218 (SD=150)
and 250 (SD=157), with 91 and 77% being released alive, respectively in the Atlantic and Indian Ocean.
However, because of important uncertainties mainly due to the low observation coverage and the scarcity
of marine turtle bycatch events, it was impossible to produce solid and reliable global estimates of marine
turtle bycatch and mortality due to PS activity.
SUMMER OF THE KEMP'S RIDLEY: THE IMMS RESPONSE TO HIGH NUMBERS OF
INCIDENTAL CAPTURES AT MISSISSIPPI FISHING PIERS
Andrew Coleman, Delphine Shannon, Heidi Zurawka, Wendy Hatchett, Jamie Klaus, Billie Stevens,
Tim Hoffland, and Moby Solangi
Institute for Marine Mammal Studies, Gulfport, MS, USA
Abnormally high numbers of sea turtles, particularly immature Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys kempii) sea
turtles, were incidentally captured in 2012 by recreational fishermen at coastal fishing piers in Mississippi.
Whereas only 20-30 captures were reported for each year in 2010 and 2011, almost 200 captures were
reported in 2012. The turtles were transported to the Institute for Marine Mammal Studies (Gulfport, MS)
where they received care and rehabilitation. Straight-line carapace lengths ranged from approximately
21cm to 48cm signifying the presence of juveniles and sub-adults in the Mississippi Sound. Turtles were
grouped by capture date and pier to examine temporal and location trends. Additionally, hook sizes and
types were measured and analyzed for any potential influences on incidental captures. Feces were passively
collected from rehabbed turtles for the first ten days, if possible, to examine local dietary preferences.
Several of the turtles were fitted with satellite transmitters, and their movements displayed site fidelity to
the Mississippi Sound often moving towards their original capture site. The waters of the north central Gulf
of Mexico has been previously suggested as being important foraging grounds for Kemp’s ridleys (Ogren,
1989); however, this region has been historically understudied. The observed numbers of captures indicate
that the Mississippi Sound represents a vital developmental habitat for Kemp’s ridleys. The need for better
understanding the regional abundance of these crucial life history stages is emphasized because this
critically endangered species is currently experiencing a population recovery due to conservation efforts on
nesting beaches and foraging grounds. The substantial increase in incidental captures could be due to a
number of factors including increased public awareness and the previously mentioned population recovery.
However, the possibility of their local, natural habitat being degraded thus driving the turtles into close
proximity to fishing piers cannot be discounted and needs further exploration.
93
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
HEAVY METAL ANALYSIS OF MARINE LEECHES (OZOBRANCHUS SPP.) TO ASSESS
EXPOSURE IN SEA TURTLES
Kyle A. Danielson1, Jacqueline M. Roth2, Triet M. Truong1, and Audrey E. McGowin1
1
2
Wright State University, Dayton, OH, USA
Ohio Wesleyan University, Delaware, OH, USA
Knowledge of environmental contaminants to which endangered and threatened sea turtles are exposed is
important for conservation efforts. Currently, contaminant evaluation involves necropsy of turtles found
dead or moribund or sampling blood from captured turtles. The goal of this research was to explore the
potential of the sea turtle leech Ozobranchus spp. for use as a surrogate for heavy metal exposure in their
sea turtle hosts. The leech acts as a mini-sampler of turtle blood and has the potential to accumulate heavy
metals over time providing information on long-term exposure to environmental contaminants. In this
preliminary study, the concentration of ten metals was determined in Ozobranchus branchiatus and
Ozobranchus margoi leeches collected from green turtles, Chelonia mydas, hawksbills, Eretmochelys
imbricata, and olive ridleys, Lepidochelys olivacea, by collaborators in Barbados, Brazil, Florida, Hawaii,
and Mexico. Leeches were received in ethanol, dried, digested with nitric acid and analyzed using
inductively-coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES).Since the leeches are so small,
pooled samples were analyzed from the same turtle to determine Al, As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, and
Zn concentrations. The highest measurements were found in O. branchiatus leeches from green turtles (C.
mydas) in Hawaii that contained Cd levels ranging from 1.85 to 899.7 mg/kg dry wt., Pb levels ranging
from 5.36 to 11870 mg/kg, Zn levels ranging from 257.2 to 753.1 mg/kg, and Cu levels ranging from 19.83
to 104.5 mg/kg. O. branchiatus leeches from olive ridley turtles (L. olivacea) in Mexico had Al levels that
ranged from 490.0 to 1286 mg/kg dry wt. and Cu levels that ranged from 77.20 to 179.2 mg/kg. O. margoi
leeches from hawksbill (E. imbricata) in Barbados had Cd levels that ranged from 1.04 to 134.3 mg/kg dry
wt. and Zn levels that ranged from 121.3 to 526.7 mg/kg. Most of these levels are well above what would
be considered toxic to any organism. Cadmium and lead, in particular, can have serious effects on
organisms and accumulate with age. These levels are much higher than those reported by others for sea
turtle tissues indicating that the leeches have the potential to concentrate heavy metals from their turtle
hosts. Leeches from Brazil had the lowest levels of metals with Florida specimens falling in the mid-ranges.
These preliminary results demonstrate the potential of using sea turtle leeches as surrogates of host turtle
exposure to heavy metal environmental contamination.
INCIDENTAL BY-CATCH OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) BY BOTTOM
TRAWLING IN EASTERN SPAIN
Francesc Domenech1, Sebastian Bitón2, Manuel Merchán2, Gabriela Vélez-Rubio1, Ohiana Revuelta1,
and Jesús Tomás1
1
Cavanilles Institute of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology, University of Valencia. P.O. Box 22085,
E-46071 Valencia, SPAIN.
2
Asociación Chelonia. Aristóteles, 3. 28027 Madrid, SPAIN.
A survey was conducted to assess marine turtle bycatch in bottom trawling fisheries in Valencian
Community waters (Eastern Spain). About 99% of marine turtles in this region are loggerheads (Caretta
caretta) that represent two distinct Regional Management Units (RMUs): the North-Eastern Atlantic RMU,
which makes up the largest population worldwide despite its recent decline, and the Mediterranean RMU,
with a much smaller and highly threatened population. Turtles from both RMUs occur in the Western
94
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Mediterranean, but their distribution in the study area is heterogeneous due to the complex structure of
surface currents and sea conditions. Mediterranean and Atlantic loggerheads are found to the north and
south of La Nao Cape (Alicante province), respectively, although moderate exchange of individuals from
each RMU occurs. Drifting longline fisheries represent the largest threat for loggerhead turtles in Western
Mediterranean over the last few decades. The impact of this fishery has decreased considerably as a
consequence of longline fleet reduction in eastern Spain. However, the bottom trawl fishery could have
significantly impacted local stocks of loggerheads both in the past and at present. Here we replicate
previous surveys in Catalonia (Northeastern Spain) and the Balearic Islands to fill gaps in the assessment of
trawl fishery impacts on loggerhead turtle stocks in the Western Mediterranean. To make the surveys
comparable, we used the same questionnaire and methodology as in previous studies. Between 2010 and
2012, a total of 111 interviews (one per boat) were carried out covering 41.3% of the entire Valencian
Community fleet. According to the information reported by bottom trawl fishermen, the catch per unit
effort (CPUE) was estimated at 0.09, and the total number of turtles captured as bycatch in the Valencian
Community was 238 turtles (95%, CI: 173-304). The fishermen’s perception was that the local stock of
loggerhead turtles is declining and that drifting longline and bottom trawling fisheries are, at least, partially
responsible for this trend. Ivlev’s electivity index revealed that bottom trawl bycatch was higher than
expected in areas with a wide continental shelf (i.e., the north part of the study area). In agreement with
previous surveys, the trawl fishery appeared to mainly affect turtles from the Mediterranean RMU. The
bottom trawl fishery represents a serious threat for the loggerhead turtle population in the Western
Mediterranean and, therefore, urgent conservation measures should be investigated, including possible
reductions in tow time to prevent turtle suffocation, the use of turtle excluder devices (TEDs), and specific
fishery regulation measures. This project was funded by the VOLCAM program of Caja Mediterraneo. JT
is supported by project CGL2011-30413 of the Spanish Ministry of Competitiveness and Economy.
ESTIMATES OF SEA TURTLES BYCATCH IN ARTISANAL FISHING IN SOUTHERN BRAZIL
Camila Domit1, Liana Rosa1, and Maurício de C. Robert2
1
2
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Paraná, Brazil
Associação MarBrasil
The incidental capture is one of the biggest topics of discussion that involve the ecological sustainability of
fisheries on threatened species impact, traditional communities and the local economy. In Paraná, southern
Brazil, the fisheries are predominantly small-scale, distributed in estuarine and coastal environments. The
characterization of the activity and the main fitting equipment that interact with turtles were previously
identified by interviews with local community. Six communities of artisanal fishery are monthly sampled
and 918 interviews were conducted between October 2010 and December 2011. More than 200 sea turtles
was recorded stranded on the beach along this period. Nevertheless, the capture of 52 sea turtles was
recorded to the interview day, identified as Chelonia mydas (30 individuals), followed by Caretta caretta
(10), Eretmochelys imbricata (4) and Dermochelys coriacea and Lepidochelys olivacea (1 individual each).
The frequencies of catches were higher for bottom driftnet mesh 16 to 25cm which occurred in all seasons,
ranging from 2.0 to 3.3% of the fishing landings. Lower frequencies of capture were observed in trawls, in
the gillnet of water column mesh 9 to 12c, in the bottom driftnet mesh 5 to 7cm, bottom gillnet mesh 9 to
12cm and 6 and 7cm, and in the driftnet of water column mesh 9 to 12cm. The frequency of capture in
bottom gillnet mesh 16 to 25cm was significantly higher (2.0%) between the stations and the mortality rate
was observed only for this fishery was 77.8%. Most catches (16 in 17 reports) were related to fisheries
conducted in the open sea between 0.2 and 5.6 km from the coast (56.3%), followed by those held in
nearby islands (31.3%), and made between 27.8 to 39.8 miles from the coast (12.5%). The average values
of Yields Capture (YC=individual / hectare network daily submersion) of turtles was zero in most
communities except in bottom gillnet mesh 16 to 25cm. The IC in this fishery between communities ranged
from 0.1 to 7.7 individuals / (ha.day). The estimated total catch was calculated in 3 ways: based in the
yields of capture, the capture frequencies considering the week fishing and the data only on the day of
95
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
interview. Based on estimates calculated, the total catch (which correlates to capture the different fitting
equipment with frequency of usage) held by the communities studied in different fitting equipment that
interacted with turtles ranged between 412 and 2001 turtles per year. Based on these results, it is evident
the vulnerability of the species caught in traditional systems of fishing, and more studies should be
conducted with fishing and its ecological consequences, economic and social implications for prioritizing
conservation efforts. The problem must be addressed in an interdisciplinary manner to create alternatives to
reduce the mortality of these organisms and simultaneously promote sustainable fishing.
ALARMING POACHING OF SATELLITE TRACKED INDIVIDUALS RAISES REGIONAL
CONSERVATION CONCERNS FOR GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE
WESTERN INDIAN OCEAN.
Stella Dubernet1, Mayeul Dalleau2, Stéphane Ciccione1, Rose Machaku3, Lindsey West4, Bertin
Rakotonirina5, and Jérôme Bourjea6
1
Kélonia, Reunion Island, France
University of Reunion Island, Reunion Island, France
3
Moi University, Eldoret, Kenya
4
Seasense, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
5
Institut Halieutique et des Sciences Marines, Tuléar, Madagascar
6
Ifremer - Délégation de la Réunion, Reunion Island, France
2
A recent satellite tracking study in the Western Indian Ocean reveals several instances of green turtles
(Chelonia mydas) poaching. In 2008, one of 12 tracked nesting green turtles from Glorieuses (French
overseas) was poached in Grande Comores (Comoros). The tag was found and collected from the hut of a
villager. In 2010, 16 satellite tags were deployed on nesting green turtles in Moheli (Comoros), with 3 of
them having an accelerometer. One turtle was found nesting on the same beach some weeks after
deployment, but without its accelerometer. Further observation of the animal showed a piece of net still
attached to the device and evidence of net scars were on the turtle. The satellite track demonstrated that the
turtle had been a prisoner of a fixed costal net in Anjouan (Comoros) for a few days. The same year, further
west in Tanzania, another green turtle nesting track from Europa Island (French overseas, of 10 tracked
individuals) revealed that the individual was captured in Okuza Island (Tanzania) and brought back to
Kieulela village (Tanzania). The villagers were visited but the tag was not recovered. In 2011, 11 juvenile
green turtles were tracked in the marine protected area of Europa Island. One individual later reach the
waters of Madagascar and remained there for 2 months before being poached. The tag was found in Tsifota
village in the south west, and recovered. The same year, from 3 adult green turtles tracked in Kenya, one
was poached only 43 days after deploying the tag. The turtle carcass was found at the nesting beach. The
electronic device was still attached to the carapace, but it had been intentionally broken. These five
incidences of poaching are of high concern when compared to the small number of tracked individuals.
These events occurred in four different countries (Kenya, Tanzania, Madagascar, Comoros) that are known
to host important foraging habitats for green turtles. Furthermore, these individuals were tracked for a very
short period of their lifetime. When considering the amount of time spent in coastal areas by green turtles,
and the level of artisanal fishing activity in those countries, this issue becomes a major concern. While
satellite tracking allows us to raise the alarm, there is still a lack of more precise assessment. Artisanal
fisheries and poaching data are barely accessible and could be a major source of mortality for the green
turtle in this region. We urge future regional conservation actions to address this important issue.
96
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLE INTERACTIONS AT THE BRUNSWICK STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT,
SOUTHPORT, NORTH CAROLINA
Sarah A. Finn
NC Wildlife Resources Commission, Wilmington, North Carolina, USA
The Brunswick Steam Electric Plant (BSEP) is a nuclear power plant located in Southport, North Carolina.
The plant is situated along the Cape Fear Estuary and utilizes water from this system via an intake canal to
cool its reactors. BSEP has developed measures to reduce entrainment of estuarine life into the intake canal,
including threatened and endangered sea turtles, which use the estuary for foraging. Trained employees
monitor the intake canal using both boat and diver patrols. Sea turtle interactions are reported to the
National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), and NC Wildlife
Resources Commission biologists. Though the diversion structure and monitoring measures are effective at
reducing sea turtle interactions and mortality, there has been an average of 9 incidental sea turtle captures
per year at the BSEP since 2001. In 2012, however, there was an increase in incidental captures at the plant,
resulting in 23 sea turtle interactions (15 loggerheads, 4 greens, 4 Kemp’s ridleys). Of these interactions, 14
were retrieved alive and subsequently released. There were 9 mortalities, including 3 green sea turtles,
meeting the allowed take under the NMFS 2000 biological opinion. Factors contributing to this rise in
interactions include high lunar tides in the spring and breaches in the plant’s diversion structure, allowing
turtles to enter the intake canal. Through the efforts of the BSEP employees, monitoring for sea turtles in
the intake canal has increased and modifications to the diversion structure are being considered to limit
future interactions.
TRASHING TURTLES: QUANTIFYING GARBAGE ON THREE SEA TURTLE NESTING
BEACHES IN COSTA RICA
Kari Gehrke1, Emily Kuzmick1, Lauren Piorkowski1, Katherine Comer Santos1, Chris Pincetich2,
Catalina Gonzalez3, Manuel Sanchez4, Lotti Adams5, Emma Harrison3, Randall Arauz6, and Beth
Whitman7
1
The Science Exchange Sea Turtle Internship Program, San Diego, CA, USA
Sea Turtle Restoration Project, Forest Knolls, CA, USA
3
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Tortuguero, Costa Rica
4
Osa Conservation, Puerto Jimenez, Costa Rica
5
PRETOMA, Guanacaste, Costa Rica
6
PRETOMA, San Jose, Costa Rica
7
Florida International University, North Miami, FL, USA
2
The authors tested new methods for investigating the relationship between beach trash and sea turtle
activity in a country-wide study in Costa Rica. Costa Rica contains important nesting beaches for green
turtles, olive ridleys, hawksbills, and leatherbacks. Beach trash is among the many threats to these
endangered species; it can be an obstacle to nesting female turtles and hatchlings traversing the beach, and
in near shore waters turtles can ingest or become entangled in floating trash. Our research goal was to
determine if beach trash and turtles are spatially and temporally correlated. The study sites were Pejeperro
Beach on the Osa Peninsula, Tortuguero on the Caribbean, and San Miguel Beach in Guanacaste. Trash
density was measured using methods described in the NOAA Marine Debris protocol during July and
August of 2012. The Science Exchange Interns mapped three 100-meter zones on each beach. Each zone
97
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
consisted of 20 five-meter wide transects from the mid-tide line to the back of the beach. Four transects per
zone were randomly chosen for weekly garbage observations using predefined size categories and type
categories such as plastics, glass, fabrics, metals, processed wood, rubber, etc. One of our modifications to
the NOAA protocol is that while collecting trash density data, we simultaneously recorded evidence of
turtle activity within the transect. Crawls and nest pits were tallied as separate activities. Successful nests
were counted the same as false nests. Trash was not collected until the end of the study. Ninety-one percent
of the observed trash items in the 252 transects sampled in Costa Rica fell in the macro category (2.5 to 30
cm), with 36 large debris items recorded ranging in size from 0.3 m to 1.10 m. Our new methods also
added a micro size category (5mm to 2.5 cm) that could affect the nest chamber. The mean macro trash
density from all sites was 0.2436 items/m2 and the mean turtle density was 0.0084 activities/m2. Tortuguero
beach had the highest average macro trash density, with 0.4287 items/m2, and also the highest turtle activity
density at 0.0202 activities/m2. Plastics accounted for 93% of all items recorded at our study sites with
rubber products coming in second. To determine the spatial and temporal relationship between macro trash
(in our case small plastic items) and turtles we used a non-parametric two-tailed Spearman’s rho correlation
test. There was a moderately strong positive significant relationship (r = 0.449; p <= 0.001) indicating that
as plastic densities increased and decreased, turtle activity densities followed. However, we cannot infer
cause and effect from a correlative relationship; many factors influence where turtles choose to crawl onto
the beach and dig nest pits, for example natal homing and the presence of artificial lights. The three
beaches’ trash densities in several notable categories will be compared to each other and to other sites from
the literature. Recommendations to managers of sea turtle nesting beaches are increased beach cleanups,
community awareness campaigns, and more trashcans on the beaches with regular disposal.
INTERACTIONS BETWEEN SEA TURTLES AND FISHERIES IN BRAZIL. AN OVERVIEW
WITHIN THE SCOPE OF PROJETO TAMAR MONITORING AREA (1990 – 2012)
Bruno B. Giffoni1, Maria Ângela Marcovaldi1, Gilberto Sales2, João C. A. Thomé2, Augusto C.C.
Dias da Silva2, Guy Marcovaldi2, Berenice M. G. Gallo1, Eduardo H.S.M. Lima1, Eron P. Lima2,
Cláudio Bellini2, Juçara Wanderlinde1, Gustave Lopez1, Armando J.B. Santos1, Milagros LópezMendilaharsu1, and Alexsandro Santos1
1
2
Fundação Pró-TAMAR. Caixa Postal 2219, Rio Vermelho, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil
Projeto TAMAR/ICMBio. Caixa Postal 2219, Rio Vermelho, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil
Projeto TAMAR/ICMBIO has been involved in sea turtle conservation in Brazil since 1980 and currently
operates a network of 22 research stations distributed along 1100Km of coastline. Researches aimed to
reduce the impact of coastal fisheries on sea turtles which have been prioritized since 1990. At the end of
2001 TAMAR created the Brazilian National Action Plan to Reduce the Incidental Capture of Sea Turtles
in Fisheries and started actions also toward to oceanic fisheries. Under this Plan each fishery has been
understood as the management unit of the problem: “sea turtle and fisheries interaction”. Seeking to better
understand why and how sea turtles interact with fisheries, each fishery has been characterized according to
12 criteria. However, here, all fisheries were joined in major categories of gear: a) trawl nets, b) gillnets, c)
traps, d) hooks and lines, e) seines. The fishing effort is quite different and is not being considered here. We
analyzed almost 22 years of data from TAMAR’s database information system (SITAMAR). Trawl nets
involve trawls for shrimp, squid and fishes. 210 turtles were captured (90.5% alive; 9.5% dead). 173
Chelonia mydas (96% alive, 4% dead), 24 Caretta caretta (66.7% alive, 33.3% dead), 3 Eretmochelys
imbricata (66.7% alive, 33.3% dead) and 10 Lepidochelys olivacea (60% alive, 40% dead). Gillnets include
coastal set gillnets, fixed gillnets, encircling gillnets and pelagic driftnet. 5384 turtles were captured (75%
alive; 24.8% dead; 0.2% in condition not informed - cni); 4891 C. mydas (75.4% alive, 24.5% dead; 0.1%
cni), 130 C. caretta (77.7% alive; 20.8% dead; 1.5% cni); 99 E. imbricata (69.7% alive; 30.3% dead); 27 L.
olivacea (70.4% alive; 29.6% dead); 237 D. coriacea (68.8% alive; 30.8% dead; 0.4% cni). Traps include
corrals, pound nets and pots. A total of 8367 turtles were captured (97.4% alive; 2.6% dead). 8005 C.
mydas (97.3% alive; 2.7% dead); 130 C. caretta (alive); 75 E. imbricata (98.7% alive; 1.3% dead); 155 L.
98
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
olivacea (98.7% alive; 1.3% dead); 2 D. coriacea (alive). Hooks and lines include: longlines and handlines.
A total of 4784 turtles were caught (75.3% alive; 7.8% dead; 16.9 cni). 168 C. mydas (79.8% alive; 8.9%
dead; 11.3% cni); 2935 C. caretta (86.5% alive; 6.8% dead; 6.7% cni); 5 E. imbricata (80% alive; 20%
dead); 615 L. olivacea (47.6% alive; 20.7% dead; 31.7% cni); 1061 D. coriacea (59.6% alive; 2.9% dead;
37.5% cni). Seine nets include only beach seines and captured 72 turtles (94.4% alive and 5.6% dead). 66 C.
mydas (95.5% alive; 4.5% dead); 1 C. caretta (alive); 4 E. imbricata (alive); 1 L. olivacea (dead). The
mortality rate of sea turtles in fisheries as gillnets or longlines is higher when compared with others like
corrals or pound nets, which also capture many turtles. Thus, TAMAR has prioritized to monitor specific
fisheries and has tested and implemented mitigation measures among fishermen, which contribute to reduce
sea turtle capture and mortality.
SEA TURTLE CELL CULTURES AS TOOLS FOR INVESTIGATING TOXICANT EXPOSURE
AND EFFECTS.
Céline A.J. Godard-Codding1, Sarah Webb1, Sandy Wiggins1, Benjamin M. Higgins2, and Joseph P.
Flanagan3
1
Department of Environmental Toxicology, The Institute of Environmental and Human Health (TIEHH),
Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas, USA
2
NOAA/NMFS Galveston, Texas, USA
3
Veterinary Services, Houston Zoo, Houston, Texas, USA
Within the past several decades, sea turtles have seen a major decline in population and all are currently
listed as threatened or endangered. A large body of research has investigated several possible factors in this
decline, including disruption of habitat, boat strikes, entanglement in fishing gear, and diseases such as
fibropapillomatosis. However, the impact of chemical contaminants is not well-studied. Sea turtles come
into contact with a variety of contaminants in the marine environment, such as polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons, organochlorines, polychlorobiphenyls, and heavy metals. It is challenging to conduct
toxicological investigations in these animals due to their threatened status. Cell culture work has potential
to describe exposure-effect scenarios in an in vitro context and may offer insight on risks to whole
organisms. The aim of this study was to develop a method of toxicological testing using primary cell
cultures developed from sea turtle skin biopsies. Here, we report on 1) the characterization of loggerhead
sea turtle (Caretta caretta) primary fibroblast skin cell cultures, 2) the optimization of cytotoxicity assays
such as MTT and growth curve assays, and 3) the optimization of biomarker assays such as gene
expression of cytochrome P450 1A genes. Characterization of primary skin fibroblast cultures included the
determination of optimal growth conditions (temperature, medium, serum concentration, and
coating/substrate), observations of morphology, and immunocytochemistry for vimentin, a cytoskeletal
protein. Data analyses showed that RPMI 1640 medium, 30°C incubation, 10% serum concentration, and a
tissue culture treated growth surface for cell adhesion were optimal growth conditions. Preliminary growth
curve analyses of cells exposed to 10 μM benzo[a]pyrene showed markedly lower growth, and MTT assays
suggest toxicity to cells following 96-hour exposure to benzo[a]pyrene at all tested concentrations.
Benzo[a]pyrene is a prototypical polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon and known marine contaminant.
Following optimization, these toxicological assays will be useful not only in single contaminant exposures
but also in examining interactions between these contaminants and other natural stressors. Primary skin
fibroblast cultures were grown from skin biopsies obtained from six healthy loggerhead turtles. Cells were
dosed with benzo[a]pyrene at concentrations of 10 μM, 1 μM, 100 nM, and 10 nM for 72 hours. The
inducibility of CYP1A following exposure was assessed by quantitative polymerase chain reaction.
CYP1A1 and CYP1A-like induction is commonly used as a biomarker of exposure to polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons and planar halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons in wildlife. The present study confirms that
sea turtle CYP1A is inducible by a xenobiotic known to induce CYP1A in other species. Further
99
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
characterization of sea turtle CYP1A expression and inducibility may provide a valuable biomarker of
exposure to these chemicals in this taxon. This research was conducted under U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service Endangered Species Act Section 10a(1)a Scientific Research Permit# TE 676379 4 and
TE#676379 5 and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, FWC MTP 015 and complied
with all institutional animal care guidelines.
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTION OF LEATHERBACK SEA TURTLES IN THE RIO
DE LA PLATA: INSIGHTS FROM STRANDING AND FISHERIES DATA
Daniel Gonzalez-Paredes1,2, Cecilia Lezama1, Andres Estrades1, Milagros Lopez-Mendilaharsu1,3,
Gabriela Veléz-Rubio1,4, and Alejandro Fallabrino1
1
Karumbé. Av.Rivera 3245. 11600. Montevideo. Uruguay.
Hombre y Territorio Association. C/ Castellar 54-56 #2, 41003. Seville, Andalusia, Spain.
3
Fundação Pró-TAMAR. Rubens Guelli 134 sl. 307, CEP 41815-135, Salvador, BA, Brasil
4
Instituto Cavanilles de Biodiversidad y Biologia Evolutiva, Universidad de Valencia, Aptdo. 22085,
46071 Valencia, Spain
2
The leatherback sea turtle, Dermochelys coriacea, is the most migratory sea turtle species. Its geographic
distribution spans from tropical to sub-polar waters worldwide. Leatherbacks exhibit seasonal migration
patterns and tend to remain for longer times in different areas for specific uses. Understanding the seasonal
movements and habitat use of this critically endangered species is essential for its protection and
conservation. The aim of this study is to analyze the spatial and temporal distribution patterns of the
leatherback turtles in the Rio de la Plata estuary, a high use area for this species in the Southwest Atlantic
Ocean. Rio de la Plata is a tapering intrusion of the Atlantic Ocean between Uruguay and Argentina. It
operates as an estuarine system where the Paraná and Uruguay rivers drain into its waters - producing a
saline and turbidity front. Thus, we can differentiate three zones into the estuary according to a salinity
gradient from low to high concentrations: inner estuary, outer estuary and oceanic zone. In addition, this
estuary is influenced by a subtropical convergence or a junction of two ocean currents (a warm water
current from Brazil and a cold water current from Malvinas). This convergence of water masses, plus the
strong halocline, creates a high biological productivity system and foraging area for many species. Records
of D.coriacea incidentally captured by fisheries and stranding events of this species into Rio de la Plata
estuary may indicate this area supports considerable densities of foraging leatherbacks. In this study,
Karumbé Environmental NGO, collates data (N=101) regarding leatherback occurrence on the Uruguayan
side of the Rio de la Plata estuary in the last two decades. All measured turtles (n=52) were adults or
sexually mature (>120cm CCL) and their survival rate was found to be 56.5% of entangled turtles and only
2.5% of stranded turtles. Most events were concentrated in two peak times. Registered strandings (n=78)
occurred from November to July with a remarkable peak during the austral fall months (n=61).A total of
75.6% stranding events were located in the outer estuarine area. The aggregation of leatherbacks in this
zone might be related to the timing of availability and abundance of preys during this period of the year
(e.g. jellyfishes, salps and other gelatinous organisms). Special mention is made to a massive stranding
event in April-May 2008 with 28 stranded leatherbacks. While almost all the incidental captures occurred
from October to December (n=16) and a few isolated events in March and April (n=6). We estimate that
incidental captures increased with the activity of the artisanal fleet in the inner estuarine area following the
valuable target of the croaker (Micropogonias furnieri) during the austral spring. Some species of
scyphozoan medusae tend to aggregate at the bottom of the estuary, mostly beneath the halocline, where
Uruguayan artisanal fisheries set coastal bottom gillnets. Thus, the relatively large number of strandings in
the outer estuary and incidental captures in the inner zone of the estuary may indicate a higher leatherback
aggregation into the Rio de la Plata. Therefore,we suggest more effort should be directed to the assessment
of the impact of artisanal fishing gear on leatherbacks, and systematic surveys should be maintained in
order to improve our knowledge on the spatial patterns of strandings in this important leatherback foraging
area in the Southwest Atlantic Ocean.
100
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
INCIDENTAL CATCH OF MARINE TURTLES IN BOTTOM TRAWLING IN SOUTHEASTERN
BRAZIL
Suzana M. Guimarães1, Juan Pablo Quimbayo2, and Cassiano Monteiro-Neto1
1
2
Universidade Federal Fluminense, NIteroi, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianopolis, Santa Catarina, Brazil
Brazil has five of the seven species of marine turtles known in the world, all of which are subject to
anthropogenic threats - resulting from the degradation and pollution of terrestrial and marine habitats, and
through accidental bycatch in fisheries. Due to the high mortality of sea turtles recorded in fisheries
worldwide, marine turtle bycatch studies have become the main focus of several conservation projects. The
objectives of these studies are to identify which fisheries have interactions with marine turtles, the impact
of interactions on these populations and the development of bycatch mitigation solutions. The accidental
capture of sea turtles by bottom trawlers is considered one of the biggest threats to sea turtles worldwide. In
Brazil, there is little data to accurately quantify interaction levels or to effectively identify which species
are most vulnerable to interactions with bottom trawl fisheries. This study aims to clarify this situation and
generate an interest in further developing collaborative research in this pressing field of fisheries science.
Between July 2010 and December 2011, 3 shrimp trawlers and 1 fish trawler operating from the city of
Niterói, in the state of Rio de Janeiro (located on the coast of Southeast Brazil) were monitored by captains
that voluntarily collected data for this study. All the captains were trained to collect date, time, depth and
GPS location for all the trawling tows (launching and recovery of nets) on data collection sheets. When
interactions occurred the captains recorded species, size, and whether the turtle was alive or dead. To
confirm species identification, captains used a camera to photograph the caught turtles. An identification
key developed specifically for this project accompanied the data collection sheets. A total of 44 turtles were
captured in 1996 tows totaling 8.313 hours which results in a Catch Per Unit Effort (CPUE) of 0.02 turtles
per tow, or the equivalent of 1 capture for every 99.8 tows which on average last 4.2 hours ± 0.92. The
species caught were: Caretta caretta, Lepidochelys olivacea and Chelonia mydas - totaling 22, 21 and 1,
respectively. There were no reports of deaths in catches cataloged by the captains. The curved carapace
length (CCC) ranged between 56 and 76 cm (64.3 ± 4.8) for L. olivacea, 61 and 150 cm (83.5 ± 22.28) for
C. caretta and 38.5 cm for the single C. mydas captured. There was no significant difference in catches
between day time (6:00 to 18:00) and night time (18:00 to 06:00) (χ ² = 0.36, p = 0.55). When compared to
six studies which were conducted in the U.S.A, Australia and Costa Rica, our data shows the fifth highest
CPUE for marine turtle interactions with bottom trawlers. This work provided the first estimates of the
interaction occurring between bottom trawl operations in the southeastern region of Brazil and marine
turtles. Further collaborative efforts between scientist and fishers could improve these estimates and
provide baseline data for reducing marine turtle bycatch.
101
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PREDICTING THE EFFECTS OF SEA LEVEL RISE ON THREE SEA TURTLE NESTING
BEACHES IN COSTA RICA
Lizette Guzman-Zaragoza1, Alyssa Giffin1, Kristen Zemaitis1, Katherine Comer Santos1, Catalina
Gonzalez2, Manuel Sanchez3, Lotti Adams4, Emma Harrison5, Randall Arauz6, Mariana MPB
Fuentes7, Marianne Fish8, Beth Whitman9, and Rebecca Lewison10
1
The Science Exchange Sea Turtle Internship Program, San Diego, CA, USA
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Tortuguero, Costa Rica
3
Osa Conservation, Puerto Jimenez, Costa Rica
4
PRETOMA, Guanacaste, Costa Rica
5
Sea Turtle Conservancy, San Jose, Costa Rica
6
PRETOMA, San Jose, Costa Rica
7
James Cook University, Townsville, Australia
8
World Wildlife Fund, Vancouver, Canada
9
Florida International University, North Miami, FL, USA
10
San Diego State University, San Diego, CA, USA
2
Sea level rise, which has been brought about by rapid climate change, is predicted to increase by
approximately 0.6 m in the next 90 years according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
This increase could affect the availability and quality of sea turtle nesting habitat. This investigation, a
collaborative effort of Sea Turtle Conservancy, PRETOMA, Osa Conservancy and The Science Exchange
Sea Turtle Internship Program, took place at Pejeperro Beach (Osa Peninsula), San Miguel Beach
(Guanacaste), and Tortuguero Beach (Caribbean) in July and August of 2012. These beaches are monitored
by the collaborating organizations for nesting of five out of seven of the world’s endangered sea turtle
species: greens, olive ridleys, leatherbacks, hawksbills, and loggerheads. Data were collected following the
World Wildlife Fund (WWF) Temperature Monitoring Manual. At each beach, slope data were collected
with an abney level along 60 five-meter transects distributed evenly over three separate 100-m zones that
represent zero, low, and high turtle nest density areas according to the expert opinion of the supervisor from
each organization. Two of these slope surveys were implemented, one at the beginning of the study and one
at the end, in order to capture short-term natural rates of change in topography due to factors such as
erosion and accretion of sand from wind, tides, currents, rivers, storms as well as turtle nest excavations
and loss of sand from human activities such as beach development and sand mining. To predict the possible
beach area loss from sea level rise in the year 2100, we took the average of the first and second survey
elevations of each sample point and subtracted 0.6 m to simulate flooding of the beach. Only a few of our
1279 sample points were flooded resulting in a loss of 6% of the sampled beach area at Tortuguero (3%
from the low nest density zone and 3% from the high nest density zone). The site with the most dramatic
loss was at Pejeperro Beach, with a predicted 14% of the high nest density zone potentially being
underwater by 2100. In this zone, 13 out of 20 transects are predicted to shrink five meters in width starting
at the mid-tide line towards the back of the beach because there is a gradual slope with low elevations. We
will present the natural rate of topographic changes and the actual nest densities observed within these
same transects over the six to eight week study period. Our analysis will also include a comparison between
these three beaches and with other beaches around the world that have implemented the WWF slope
surveys. Conservation recommendations to mitigate for impacts of sea level rise on nesting beaches are
continued slope surveys, promoting and enforcing development set back regulations, and hatchery
programs to protect nests that are threatened with inundation.
102
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DEAD SEA TURTLES FROM DRINI BAY, ALBANIA DURING 2002-2012
Idriz Haxhiu and Vilma Piroli
Center for Research and Developement, VitrinaUniversity, Tirana, Albania
Sea turtles of Drini Bay in Albania have been studied since 2002. There are four rivers that converge at
Drini Bay: Drini, Mati, Droja and Ishmi . These rivers flow through rich, mountainous and open-field
habitats - transporting considerable amounts of organic and inorganic elements into the bay. As a result,
numerous invertebrate and plant species occur in the bay. These items are important food sources for
loggerhead, Caretta caretta, and green turtles, Chelonia mydas. The highest density of potential food
sources for turtles is noted from the Ishmi and Mati river mouths, respectively. During 11 years of intensive
research, we have found 78 dead loggerheads and 2 green turtles. Turtle mortalities were attributed to
incidental by-catch in locally intensive and illegally-performed fishing operations. Nets are generally
soaked for 4-5 hours but will occasionally be placed for 2-3 days. Soak times for either duration typically
lend to turtle by-catch and mortality. Turtles that are caught in nets are often suffocated and those hooked
on long-lines are injured when swallowing hooked bait. Dynamite is also employed as “fishing gear” in the
bay - destroying habitats utilized and occupied by sea turtles, and occasionally causing the direct mortality
of individual turtles. Chemical and plastic-waste pollution from the Ishmi River is also a documented
source of mortality for turtles in the bay. Moreover, turtles are collected from the bay and then stuffed as
curios to decorate some local Albanian establishments.
SEA TURTLE TRADE IN INDONESIA: CURRENT MAGNITUDE AND NEW MODE OF
OPERATION
Creusa Hitipeuw1, I.B. Windia Adnyana2, Dwi Suprapti1, and Rusli Andar1
1
WWF Indonesia, Graha Simatupang Tower 2C, 7th Floor Jl. Letjen TB Simatupang kav. 38 Pasar Minggu,
Jakarta 12540 Indonesia
2
Udayana University, Bali, Indonesia
The illegal trade in sea turtle products has been a long time problem in Indonesia. Despite the legal
protection status of sea turtles since 1999, the illegal trade has continued to take place in various places. An
assessment was conducted to review the extent of consumption and trade of marine turtle and their eggs in
Indonesia. A survey of turtle meat consumption was focused in Bali, the main area for commercial trade of
turtle meats and where local consumption takes place. Market surveys of turtle eggs were focused in West
and East Kalimantan region where consumption of eggs is widespread and sold in local markets. We
provide an overview on the current trade status of turtles and their eggs in Indonesia. The survey on source
and trade routes was conducted via interviews with turtle meat/egg sellers, key informants, government
agencies and through literature reviews. In Bali, field surveys were conducted from November to
December 2009, and in Kalimantan from May-June 2010. The survey findings revealed that despite a
decrease trend of trade volume since 1999 due to the legal protection state of green turtles, the illegal trade
of turtle meat and eggs still existed. In Bali, turtle trade for consumption predicted to reach up to 60 ton per
year (equivalent to approximately 1,000-2,000 individuals). The traded turtle meat involves mainly green
turtles that caught locally and outside Bali. Turtle meat shipped from outside Bali was mostly in form of
meat loafs/pieces. An mt-DNA analysis of the confiscated green turtles (n=32) in Bali indicated that the
captured turtles were from various rookeries in Indonesia and Australasia. Turtle eggs seemed to be in short
supply in East Kalimantan (Samarinda city) where the volume of eggs traded ranged from 981 – 1,846
103
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
eggs/day while in West Kalimantan was 12,679 eggs/day. The price of turtle eggs in East and West
Kalimantan differ. In East Kalimantan, the price of an egg ranged from IDR. 5,000 to 10,000 - depending
on the availability; while in West Kalimantan it ranged from IDR. 2,000 to 5,000. Around 36% of the
traded eggs in West Kalimantan were traded at the Malaysia-Sarawak border. The traded turtle eggs in East
Kalimantan were identified as green and olive ridley turtle eggs and they sourced from major rookeries including the Berau islands (East Kalimantan) and Kota Baru (South Kalimantan). In West Kalimantan, the
eggs were from green and hawksbill turtles and were sourced from Paloh (West Kalimantan) and Riau
islands. The result of this study has shown significant trade volume of turtles and their eggs in Indonesia
that may jeopardize the sustainability of turtle population in Indonesia and the surrounding region. Strategic
interventions are needed including from surveillance activities (patrols) at local markets,
apprehension/detention and lawsuit/judicial process with heavy penalties. On the other hand, alternative
sources of incomes for the local sellers should be promoted as well as a consumer campaign (at major
cities) to reduce the trade demand.
BYCATCH INTENSITY OF SEA TURTLES IN THE MARINE WATERS OF BANGLADESH
Mohammad Z. Islam
Marinelife Alliance, Cox's Bazar 4700, Bangladesh
Bangladesh is located at the north of Bay of Bengal with a coastline of 710 kms approximately. A large
number of people live along the coast and a vast portion of community depend on fishing in offshore and
coastal areas. At least 20,000 artisanal fishing boats operate in our territory. The existing fishing gears
utilized are: gill nets of different types, set bag nets, small long lines, and industrial trawl fisheries. The
current threat level to local turtles and cetaceans is still unknown to us. But, the mortality rate along the
coast of Cox's Bazar is clearly thousands of sea turtle each year and several hundreds of small cetaceans (as
per records from the several years study). During 2008-2012 July we conducted various surveys to explore
the incidences of bycatch through fishermen interviews, inwater on-board observation and data collection
by trained fishermen. A total 1,119 fishermen were interviewed. The highest by-catch instances were
recorded from the Marine Set Bag Net (MSBN) fishery, with 579 olive ridley interactions. Small cetaceans
like Irrawaddy and finless porpoises were also recorded during the bycatch survey.
GREEN TURTLE INTERACTIONS WITH COASTAL GILLNET FISHERY OF THE RIO DE LA
PLATA ESTUARY, URUGUAY
Cecilia Lezama, Florencia Rivas, Natalia Viera, Alejandro Fallabrino, and Andrés Estrades
NGO Karumbé, Av.Rivera 3245, CP: 11600, Montevideo, Uruguay.
Incidental catch of sea turtles in fisheries has been recognized worldwide as one of the main mortality
causes for these endangered species. The Uruguayan coast constitutes a foraging and development area for
juveniles of green turtles (Chelonia mydas) that come from different breeding zones. Thus, mortality due to
fishing activities may be depleting nesting populations elsewhere in the Atlantic. The aim of this research
was to evaluate the impact generated by the coastal gillnet fishery on green turtles in Bajos del Solís fishing
zone (between 34º47S; 55º35’W and 34º54’S; 55º14’W), located inside the Río de la Plata estuary and to
compare the interaction throughout three sampling periods. Trained observers made onboard observations
from artisanal boats totalizing 21 samplings in 2002/03, 193 in 2004/05 and 119 in 2009/10. The existence
104
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of temporal and spatial variation of incidental catches was analyzed. During 2004/05 we used Machine
Learning procedures (CART and GLM) to test the effect of environmental, temporal and operational
variables on these catches. A total of 20 juvenile green turtles were incidentally caught during 2002/03, 21
during 2004/05 and 66 during 2009/10. The mean capture per unit of effort (CPUE) was higher during
2002/03 (0,614 turtles/1000m2/hour), followed by 2009/10 (0,204 turtles/1000m2/hour), and 2004/05
(0,013 turtles/1000m2/hour), showing no clear pattern of increase or decrease of interactions. Seasonal
variation was observed being the summer the most critical season where the highest CPUEs were registered
for the three periods. Also spatial variation was recorded and hot spot areas of high risk of incidental
captures were identified in insular and rocky areas of shallow waters based on the coincidence of captures
observed during the three sampling periods. Gillnet soak time and distance to the coast of the fishing events
were the significant variables that together better explained the variations in C. mydas incidental catches.
The incidental capture probability for this species increased with longer soak time and shorter distance to
the coast of the fishing activity. By means of sample-based estimators it was estimated that 497 green
turtles were caught during 2004/05 (95% CI= 260 – 781) and 1584 during 2009/10 (95% CI= 1056 - 2158)
by the total artisanal fleet that operate within the area. We conclude that the gillnet fishery that takes place
in Bajos del Solís area during the summer in the coastal fringe of less than two kilometres from the coast,
constitutes a threat to green turtle’s juveniles. For the protection of this critical foraging and development
habitat it is necessary to implement a marine protected area in the region with spatial and temporal
restrictions on gillnets use.
LOGGERHEADS AND MEDITERRANEAN MONK SEALS: TWO FLAGSHIP SPECIES CLASH
IN ZAKYNTHOS
Dimitris Margaritoulis and Smaro Touliatou
ARCHELON, the Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Athens, Greece
Laganas Bay in Zakynthos, Greece, holds the largest nesting aggregation of loggerhead turtles in the
Mediterranean. Turtles of both genders typically begin to arrive in April, while nesting occurs from late
May to early August. Zakynthos is also home to a resident population of Mediterranean monk seals
(Monachus monachus). Since 1999 the wider Bay area is included in the National Marine Park of
Zakynthos (NMPZ) which is administered by its Management Agency (MA). ARCHELON, since its
foundation in 1983, conducts in Laganas Bay a sea turtle monitoring project, in the course of which turtle
strandings are also recorded. Both loggerheads and monk seals are recognized broadly in Greece as
flagship species and large national and international effort has been invested to conserve them. It was first
noted in 1994 that monk seals in Zakynthos prey upon adult loggerheads by snapping off plastral scutes and
feeding on the entrails. This unique behavior, not documented anywhere else in the world, was thought to
have been caused by depleted levels of fish resources. Predation incidents were ceased after the death of a
male monk seal. Although in subsequent years some similar predation incidents were noted, it was
considered that these were occasional. Nevertheless, during 2010 a surge of predation incidents was
documented; 21 adult turtles, most of these (85.7%) nesting females, were found predated by monk seals. It
was also noted that the predation technique had been changed; instead of snapping off the plastron now
monk seals opened the body cavity by tearing the skin at the base of flippers or at the throat. Predation
continued unabated during the 2011 nesting season with 16 dead turtles, all nesting females. It should be
noted that most turtle carcasses were found at sea and this, coupled with the intense monitoring work on
beaches, precludes post-mortem predation by terrestrial mammals. Increased adult mortality of sea turtles
can have a serious impact to the population. The most likely non-sustainable loss of nesting females,
estimated respectively at 4% and 4.7% of the annual nesting population, made ARCHELON to pull the
alarm signal. Indeed, the MA of the NMPZ together with ARCHELON, WWF-Greece and the Society for
the Protection of Monk Seals (MOm) drafted a joint plan aiming to investigate the phenomenon and
propose remedies. In spring 2012 fishermen reported a carcass of a male monk seal floating offshore. As no
predation events were observed during the 2012 nesting season it was assumed that the predation incidents
105
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of the previous two seasons were made by this individual. Despite the cease of predation events, probably
temporary, it is apparent that work should be continued to comprehend the interaction between the two
flagship species. Are loggerheads an opportunistic prey of monk seals, especially in years of low food
availability? Does this behaviour involve all or a few monk seals? Only male monk seals show this
behaviour? Further, it is important to manage also the social repercussions affecting the local community,
conservation organizations, and national and supranational authorities.
IMPORTANCE OF THE ISLAND OF MAIO (CAPE VERDE) FOR CURRENT AND FUTURE
LOGGERHEAD CONSERVATION IN THE EASTERN ATLANTIC
Samir Martins1, Fernando Soares1, Eusa Ribeiro2, Elena Abella1, Franziska Koenen2, and Adolfo
Marco1
1
2
Estación Biológica de Doñana, CSIC, Sevilla, Spain.
Fundación Maio Biodiversidade, Vila de Porto Ingles, Maio, Republic of Cape Verde
The Archipelago of Cape Verde hosts the world’s third largest loggerhead population. However, the
available surveys indicate that more than 85 % of nesting happens on the island of Boa Vista. Previous
reports suggest that the island of Maio has many suitable beaches for loggerhead nesting that could host a
relevant number of nests every season. During 2011, a partial survey of the entire island provided an
estimation of around 560 loggerhead nests on the island. During 2012, intensive and more accurate surveys
have provided an estimation of almost 2,000 nests annually. These results indicate that the island of Maio,
together with the island of Sal, are the most important areas for loggerhead nesting (in addition to the main
rookery on Boa Vista island). The most important beaches for nesting are Djam Padja, Flamengo, Ribeira
de Baia, Santo Antonio, Santana, Caletinha and Morro. On the other hand, the survey of 2011 in Maio
indicated a severe harvesting of nesting females on the beaches as well as an intense poaching of fresh
nests. Around 125 adult females (more than 65 % of nesting females) were hunted on the beach and around
380 nests (more than 65 % of total nests) were poached on the beach. The survey of 2012 has confirmed
that the slaughter of females on the beach is very severe and unsustainable, substantially decreasing the
overall number of nests laid on the beaches. Using nest counts at the beginning of the season we have
estimated that around 450 females arrived this season to the beaches for nesting. However, more than 150
were killed. Several interviews with local people also indicate that the number of females caught at sea is
already very significant. Many nests are also poached on the beaches during the first hours after egg laying.
Together with this anthropogenic source of mortality, high tides, storms, beach erosion or ghost crabs
destroy many nests on the most important nesting beaches and reduce the production of hatchlings on the
island. The design and implementation of a nest relocation program to a protected hatchery is strongly
recommended on the island. The camouflage of nests immediately after egg laying is also strongly
recommended on the beaches by guards and the monitoring team, to prevent their poaching. Despite the
intense level of exploitation of sea turtles on Maio, the island has a very important potential for the
recuperation of loggerhead nesting in Cape Verde. The availability of many pristine white sand beaches
together with the implementation of an exigent and ambitious conservation program may favor a quick
increase of the levels of loggerheads nesting here over the following decades. Increasing nesting levels at
this island could be extremely important to reduce the risk of extirpation faced by turtles from other Cape
Verde Islands.
106
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ANALYSIS OF SEA TURTLE SPECIMENS ON THE COAST OF KANTO AREA, JAPAN
Shinji Matsuoka1, Yuto Aoki1, Ai Sakabe1, Hiroyuki Suganuma2, and Mai Takase1
1
Seaturtle Research Collegium, Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology, 4-5-7 Konan,
Minato ward, Tokyo, Japan
2
Everlasting Nature of Asia, 3-17-8 Nishikanagawa, Kanagawa ward, Yokohama city, Kanagawa
prefecture, Japan
We surveyed the stranded sea turtle specimens washed up on the coast of the Kanto region of Japan in
cooperation with NPO Association Everlasting Nature of Asia. The number of specimens from April 2003
to September 2012 was 404. The coast of the Kanto region hosts the largest stranding zone in Japan, where
most of the stranded turtles are loggerheads and greens. Digestive tract contents from stranded loggerheads
were crustaceans, seaweed, algae, and human artifacts. Prey item frequency was calculated by using the
following equation: number of turtles that consumed the contents / total number of turtles from which we
collected the contents x 100. In addition to digestive track contents, carapace size, and tags were analyzed
from stranded specimens.
DEVELOPMENT AND TESTING OF A TOW TIME DATA LOGGER TO MONITOR AND
ENFORCE TOW TIME RESTRICTIONS IN TRAWL FISHERIES
Eric Matzen1 and Henry O. Milliken2
1
2
Integrated Statistics
National Marine Fisheries Service
Tow time restrictions have been discussed as a viable alternative to Turtle Excluder Devices (TEDs) in
fisheries where TEDs are likely to significantly reduce targeted catch. Tow durations less than an hour are
usually expected to result in a negligible number of sea turtle mortalities. The Protected Species Branch of
NOAA’s Northeast Fisheries Science Center (NEFSC) solicited a contractor to develop and construct a
robust, simple, and inexpensive data logger that could be used to enforce tow-time restrictions on
commercial bottom trawl fishing vessels. These loggers, which are attached to the trawl net or the trawl
doors, were tested for their ability to reliably record trawl fishing times and to detect when a tow exceeded
a certain time threshold. The testing occurred on eight vessels operating in six fisheries and has shown that
the logger holds up to the physical abuses of the salt environment and the shock and vibration of
commercial fishing practices. Currently, we are working with the manufacturer to resolve some software
issues, and are close to having a viable tow time logger that works as intended. Because these loggers are
also programmable, they may have applications in other fisheries where there is a need to monitor, record,
or enforce fishing time.
107
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PELAGIC PREDATOR DISTRIBUTIONS AND ANTHROPOGENIC IMPACTS:
IMPLICATIONS FOR EFFECTIVE SPATIAL MANAGEMENT IN THE CALIFORNIA
CURRENT
Sara M. Maxwell1, Elliott L. Hazen2, Steven J. Bograd2, Benjamin S. Halpern3, Barry Nickel4, Greg
Breed4, Nicole M. Teutschel4, Barbara Block1, Scott Benson5, Peter Dutton6, Helen Bailey7, Michelle
A. Kappes4, Michael J. Weise8, Bruce Mate9, Scott A. Shaffer10, Jason Hassrick4, William Henry4,
Carey Kuhn4, Ladd Irvine9, Brigitte McDonald4, Patrick Robinson4, Samantha Simmons4, and
Daniel P. Costa11
1
Stanford University, Hopkins Marine Station, Pacific Grove CA USA
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, Pacific Grove CA USA
3
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Center for Ecological Analysis & Synthesis, Santa Barbara
CA USA
4
University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA USA
5
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, Moss Landing CA USA
6
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, La Jolla CA USA
7
Chesapeake Biological Laboratory, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, Solomons
MD USA
8
Office of Naval Research, Arlington VA USA
9
Oregon State University, Corvallis OR USA
10
San Jose State University, San Jose CA USA
11
University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA USADepartment of Ecology and Evolutionary
Biology, University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA USA
2
Predators, including sea turtles have disproportionate impacts on marine ecosystems, yet we lack a spatially
explicit assessment of cumulative human impacts to their populations that is essential for effective and
comprehensive management of their populations. We created a cumulative utilization impact metric by
combining tracking data of eight protected species of leatherback sea turtles (Dermochelys coriacea), four
species of marine mammals, and three species seabirds (n=685 individuals) in the California Current and
24 species-specific weighted anthropogenic stressors to determine the overlap between relative habitat use
of species and the potential human impact on those species. We found significantly greater impacts in the
US National Marine Sanctuaries and on the continental shelf, with 82.6 and 98.2% of core cumulative
utilization impact areas occurring within these regions, respectively. Species may benefit from increased
spatial management in the Sanctuaries and other regions. Variation in how species and impacts are
distributed emphasizes that using either alone is insufficient for effective spatial management. Results can
be used to concentrate more effective management in areas where efforts will be both ecologically relevant
and economically feasible across species.
108
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MORTALITY AND BYCATCH OF SEA TURTLES ASSOCIATED WITH ANTHROPOGENIC
FACTORS ON THE SOUTHERN COAST OF PERNAMBUCO STATE, BRAZIL
Carina C. de M. Moura1, Milena S. C. Neves2, Arthur P. Barbosa3, Thyara N. Simões3, Vivian C. S.
Neves3, Arley C. Barbosa3, and Geraldo J. B. Moura1
1
University Rural Federal of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
University of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
3
NGO Ecoassociados
2
Sea turtles occuring along the brazilian seashore are registered nesting, foraging, and using this area for
reproduction and rest. At the beaches located on southern coast of Pernambuco State, Brazil, there are
nesting registers of Eretmochelys imbricata in greater frequency, and in less number of Caretta caretta,
Lepidochelys olivacea and Chelonia mydas, also with occurrence of stranded and dead turtles. These
species are currently classified by IUCN within endangered categories, due to human impacts that act on
populations of marine Testudines, causing unnatural decline of these species worldwide. Thus, the need for
studies aiming to assess how these impacts affects the biology of this group are essential to compose
management and conservation plans to mitigate the pressure on these animals. Therefore, this study
intended to relate the occurrence and possible causes of stranding and death of sea turtles. The mortality
records of sea turtles were realized from September 2009 to april 2010, in Cupe, Merepe, Muro Alto, Porto
de Galinhas, Maracaípe and Serrambi beaches, totalizing 16 km of monitored coastline, on the southern
coast of Pernambuco, Brazil. The monitoring of these beaches were performed daily, where reproductive
and non reproductive data such as sea turtle mortality and stranding were registered. The data were
gathered by the technical team of NGO Ecoassociados, which acts on monitoring and conservation of sea
turtles in Pernambuco. A total of 93 dead turtles were registered, from which the highest percentage was
68% for C. mydas, 19% for L. olivacea, 6% for E. imbricata, 1% for C. caretta and 5% could not be
identified. It was noticed that 57% of individuals found dead were females, this may be associated with the
fact that the observations were made in the spawning period, implying a greater number of female turtles
being exposed to several factors that may have been the cause of deaths. Amongst the individuals found
dead, 8% had external tumors, 4% had fishing nets marks; 4% with probable death due to accidents with
boats; 1% was found injured with knives marks and 80% were found in a high stage of decomposition,
being unable to ascertain the cause. The months with the highest number of specimens found dead were
November and December with 50% of death records. Were also found 18 turtles weakened,with C. mydas
(6 females, 1 males and 2 juvenile), E. imbricata (3 females) and non defined (6). The data reported here
show the importance of continuous monitoring of the area for the conservation and management of sea
turtles at this location, and the development of educational activities, being extremely importance to the
effectiveness of risk reduction of the species. Furthermore, they can also be used as a basis to fill gaps in
knowledge and management of environmental issues.
LEATHERBACK AND GILLNET INTERACTIONS OFF PERU, HIGHLIGHTING IN COASTAL
BYCATCH
Evelyn Paredes1 and Javier Quiñones2
1
Instituto del Mar del Perú (IMARPE), Unidad de Investigaciones de Depredadores Superiores, Esquina
Gamarra y General Valle s/n Chucuito, Callao, Perú
2
Laboratorio Costero de Pisco del Instituto del Mar del Perú (IMARPE), Urb. El Golf, Paracas, Pisco, Perú
109
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Fishing gear interactions with sea turtles have been increasing worldwide, generating high numbers of sea
turtle bycatch. Leatherbacks (Dermochelys coriacea) are critically endangered in the Eastern Pacific Ocean.
This species interacts primarily with artisanal fisheries rather than industrial fisheries in Peru. Despite the
fact that all sea turtle species are protected by Peruvian governmental policies, leatherback bycatch persists.
A wide range of artisanal fishing gear is used in Peru, however, coastal gillnets are particularly dangerous
due to their high mortality rates. In this survey, we compared the leatherback bycatch in both coastal and
offshore gillnets. Structured interviews were carried out with local fishermen in three harbors along the
Peruvian central coast from March-November, 2012. Most of these interactions occurred in coastal gillnets
targeting stingrays, guitarfishes, mullets and humpback smooth hounds, however this interaction also arises
in offshore gillnets called “animaleras”, used to capture dolphin fish, shortfin makos, blue sharks and manta
rays. Coastal fishing areas were identified as having the highest number of leatherback interactions, at least
5 times greater than in the offshore areas. This information can be used to asses fishing regulations and
local and regional mitigation measures, in order to enforce conservation efforts by the Peruvian government
on this critically endangered species.
BYCATCH MASS MORTALITY OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES AT NW MEXICO
S. Hoyt Peckham1, David Maldonado2, Jesse Senko3, and Aarón Esliman2
1
Center for Ocean Solutions, Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA, USA
Grupo Tortuguero de las Californias
3
Arizona State University, Arizona, USA
2
The waters of northwest Mexico’s Gulf of Ulloa host an extraordinarily high concentration of the North
Pacific loggerhead turtle. Overlap between this juvenile foraging hotspot and instense artisanal fisheries
can produce among the highest turtle bycatch rates reported worldwide. These high bycatch rates were
mitigated from 2007-2012 by local fisher leaders who voluntarily changed fishing practices, resulting in
thousands of turtles spared each year. During July 2012, 483 loggerhead turtles stranded along the 43km
index shoreline of Playa San Lázaro that borders the hotspot, representing a 600% increase over the
alarming interannual average of 78 loggerheads stranded there each July since 2003. Turtle mortality in
artisanal fleets during July 2012 likely numbered in the 1,000s because a) when mortality occurs at sea only
a small proportion of turtles (~20%) strand due to oceanographic factors and b) surveys were conducted on
less than 25% of the shoreline of the Gulf of Ulloa. This level of mortality likely jeopardizes the recovery
of the North Pacific loggerhead population, which is classified as endangered by Mexico and the USA.
This mass stranding event corresponds to unusually high turtle local bycatch rates. During a July 2012
INAPESCA research cruise mean bycatch rates in excess of 2 turtles/24hr/100m net were observed, which
translate to 8-16 turtles caught/day/skiff. High bycatch was caused initially by a nationwide shark fishing
ban which drove many crews to fish with bottom-set nets for finfish This transfer effect was compounded
by unusually high halibut landings which led to increased fishing effort and also unusually high loggerhead
turtle abundance in nearshore waters. Government action is urgently needed to mitigate turtle bycatch in
the Gulf of Ulloa; enforcement is required to curb illegal fishing by artisanal and industrial vessels.
Artisanal fishers require assistance to implement the bycatch avoidance solutions they have helped devleop
over the past decade. This mass mortality event reveals the vulnerability of voluntary bycatch avoidance
programs. While they can be highly productive, both unrelated government interventions and ecological
variability can affect their effectiveness.
110
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FIRST REPORT OF PLASTIC ITEMS IN STOMACH AND INTESTINAL CONTENTS OF
GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
María José Petit Rodríguez1, Natalie Wildermann1, Flor Vera1, Andrés Pineda1, and Héctor BarriosGarrido1,2
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela (GTTM-GV). Laboratorio de Ecología
General, Departamento de Biología, Facultad Experimental de Ciencias, La Universidad del Zulia (LUZ).
2
IUCN-SSC Marine Turtle Specialist Group (IUCN-SSC MTSG). Centro de Modelado Científico (CMC),
La Universidad del Zulia (LUZ).
Discharge a serious problem of marine pollution in recent years. The incidence of synthetic material intake
for sea turtles has been documented and reported in several locations becoming one of the leading causes of
death and weakening of these species. In order to increase the knowledge about the feeding ecology of the
green turtle (Chelonia mydas) in the Gulf of Venezuela, we necropsied three juvenile turtles from Zapara
Island (10 ° 58 '57 "N, 71° 33' 52.92 "W), and examined the stomach and intestinal contents. Analysis of
prey organisms exhibited common diet items for green juvenile turtles, with the main presence of algae,
followed by mollusks (not identifiable items), Thalassia testudinum and sponges (Chondrilla caribensis).
We report for the first time the presence of plastic elements in the digestive tract of sea turtles in the Gulf of
Venezuela, including hard and soft plastic bags of low and high density polyethylene, PVC (Polyvinyl
Chloride) remains, pipe fragments of containers (HDPE), nylon and baby wipes (made of synthetic fiber
based on polyethylene terephthalate). The plastic items were abundant in the intestinal tract (9,93%),
however we found them also in the stomach content (4.44%). As juvenile sea turtles feed on pelagic
material and are unselective, the consumption of plastic debris can be very probable in polluted waters,
leading to possible serious health problems. When consumed in small amounts, this material can cause
esophageal obstructions, perforations and lacerations in the intestine, leading to starvation and thus the
death of the animal. The Gulf of Venezuela has been widely described as an important feeding area for the
development of juvenile green turtles and this study confirms that it ecosystems, as well as the sea turtles,
do not escape from the consequences of marine pollution that are prevailing worldwide. We consider this
report as an urgent call for increasing the efforts in environmental awareness, developing effective plans for
environmental education, recycling and reprocessing of plastic in surrounding communities and inner-city
beaches, in order to increase the regional knowledge about the impact of plastic debris and mitigate its
impact on sea turtle populations.
SEA TURTLE BYCATCH IN ARTISANAL FISHERIES IN PARANÁ, SOUTHERN BRAZIL
Liana Rosa1, Camila Domit1, Maurício de C. Robert2, and Maria Camila Rosso-Londoño1
1
2
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Paraná, Brazil
Associação MarBrasil
The incidental capture of non-target species is currently considered one of the biggest ecological,
economical and social problems in the world. Sea turtles are directly affected in this way worldwide. In the
state of Paraná, southern Brazil, information on incidental catches are limited and fragmented, making it
impossible to diagnose the local impact of fisheries. From February 2009 to January 2010, 141 interviews
were conducted to characterize the fisheries that interact with sea turtles over 10 artisanal fishing
communities. Nearly 70% fisherman reported the incidental capture of at least one species of sea turtle
once time in their lifetime. The turtles most frequently caught are green turtles (Chelonia mydas - 49),
111
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
loggerheads (Caretta caretta - 14), leatherbacks (Dermochelys coriacea - 6), olive ridleys (Lepidochelys
olivacea - 2) and hawksbills (Eretmochelys imbricata - 1). Incidental capture frequency was recorded from
129 fishery interactions with higher frequency in the bottom nets with 16 to 25 cm mesh (46.5%), followed
by drift nets with 9 to 12 cm mesh (12.4%) and bottom trawl fishery (7.8%). The highest catch rates and
mortality of turtles were from nets with 16 to 25 cm mesh: on average 44.4 individuals caught per boat per
annum (s = 83.7, CI = 37.6, n= 19) and until 90% of turtles die. Although catches of turtles occur at
different locations on the coast, areas of consolidated substrate is the main environment-related (islands and
emerged and submerged rocky shores). Some fisherman reported larger catches of turtles near rivers and
shoals and sandbanks. Regardless of fishing equipment, most incidental capture of turtles occurs in the
winter season (37.8%, n = 90), followed by that there is no particular period or that the capture is equal to
throughout the year (35.6%). For gillnets of water column reports indicated 2 to 60 catches per vessel per
year, usually living, however the mortality rate can reach 60%. Most fisherman reported that there was a
reduction in the catch of turtles over the years (47.3%), followed by no change (39.2%) and an increase in
the catch (13.5%). The reduction likely being from a decrease in the abundance of turtles. Besides reports
of interactions with the equipment used, fishermen highlighted environmental aspects that influence the
probability of capture. The information obtained is essential for understanding the dynamics of local fishing
and for developing a monitoring program to document incidental catches.
MONITORING OF ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES IN JUVENILE CHELONIA MYDAS
(TESTUDINES, CHELONIIDAE) CAUGHT IN BRAZILIAN SOUTHEASTERN COAST
Angélica María Sánchez-Sarmiento1, Silmara Rossi2, Franz Zirena Vilca3, Ralph Eric Thijl
Vanstreels1, Robson Guimarães dos Santos4, Juliana Marigo1,5, Carolina Pacheco Bertozzi5,
Valdemar Luiz Tornisielo3, and Eliana Reiko Matushima1
1
Laboratório de Patologia Comparada de Animais Selvagens, Departamento de Patologia, Faculdade de
Medicina Veterinária e Zootecnia, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil
2
Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz e Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura,
Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil
3
Laboratório de Ecotoxicologia, Escola Superior de Agricultura Luiz de Queiroz e Centro de Energia
Nuclear na Agricultura, Universidade de São Paulo, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil
4
Departamento de Oceanografia e Ecologia, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo, Vitória, ES, Brazil
5
Projeto Biopesca, Praia Grande, SP, Brazil
Many are the threats to sea turtles conservation but a special concern remains in the Fibropapillomatosis
(FP), which has been considered a big threat principally against the survival of Chelonia mydas, on account
of its worldwide distribution and multifactorial etiology. Along the Brazilian coast, the historical economic
expansion and resource use activities have resulted in increased sources of pollution, for example chemical
products such organochlorine pesticides (OCPs), long term use for agriculture purposes resulting in their
ubiquitous presence. Banned in Brazil for agriculture in 1985 and in campaigns against vectors since 1998,
these compounds are commonly referred as persistent organic pollutants (POPs) because they remain in the
environment due to their physical chemical properties and have the potential for bioaccumulation and
biomagnification, being constantly incorporated in the trophic web. The contamination for sea turtles
occurs mainly through food, also chronic exposure and low levels have been associated with
immunological, reproductive and carcinogenic effects. So, due to the potential negative influences to the
marine health, pollutants like organochlorines (OCs) are pointed as having a possible relation with
widespread diseases like FP. In order to monitoring some OCPs in marine chelonians, 64 juvenile green sea
turtles, 24 of them with FP, were necropsied and 51 fat and 64 liver samples were collected. In both tissues,
twelve organochlorine pesticides (α-BHC, β-BHC, Heptachlor, Dicofol, op´-DDD, α-Endosulfan, op´-DDE,
pp´-DDE, β-Endosulfan, pp´-DDD, Endosulfan sulfate and Mirex) were evaluated with a new extraction
method involving 1 g of tissue sample and acetonitrile saturated with n-hexane, two clean up stages
112
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
(magnesium sulfate and PSA up followed by silica gel column) and analyzed by GC–µECD system. All the
51 fat samples analyzed showed contamination of at least one of the twelve OCs pesticides monitored;
highest concentrations (ng g-1) were found for: Dicofol, 2141.0581; α–Endosulfan, 136.3498; Heptachlor,
62.9210; Endosulfan sulfate, 61.7963; α-BHC, 48.0612; op´-DDD, 41.2959; β–Endosulfan, 38.6392; op´DDE, 34.9153; β–BHC, 33.9309; pp´-DDE, 20.9140; Mirex,19.5694 and pp´-DDD, 4.2328. From the 64
liver analyzed samples, fifty nine showed contamination for at least one of the OCs pesticides monitored;
highest concentrations (g ng-1) were found for: Mirex, 597.4578; α–Endosulfan, 111.1567; Dicofol,
93.9027; Endosulfan sulfate, 89.4243; Heptachlor, 54.4362; op´-DDE, 29.2114; β–Endosulfan, 28.0161; β–
BHC, 25.9516; op´-DDD, 13.9483; pp´-DDE, 13.4780; α-BHC,13.3562 and pp´-DDD, 10.7563. These
results demonstrate that sea turtles are getting pollutants from marine environment probably via food and
during displacement, however further studies are required in order to establish baseline contaminant levels
and better comprehension of their possible effects. Underway additional studies will attempt to correlate
these results with the presence and severity of FP and Body Condition Index (BCI) aiming to clarify the
role of these pollutants on the health of green sea turtles providing additional information for environmental
decisions towards conservation efforts. Acknowledgements: Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de
São Paulo (FAPESP): 2011/04565-7 and 2010/01781-8; Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico
e Tecnológico (CNPq): 578051/2008-7; Projeto TAMAR-ICMBio and the International Sea Turtle
Symposium and sponsors.
USING EARTH SYSTEM AND GLOBAL CLIMATE MODELS TO ASSESS THE POTENTIAL
IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON SEA TURTLES
Vincent S. Saba
NOAA NMFS Northeast Fisheries Science Center, c/o Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, Princeton
University, Princeton, NJ, USA
Research examining the potential impacts of climate change on marine organisms, including sea turtles, has
been expanding over the past decade. Many of these studies use output from global climate models that are
assessed by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). The upcoming IPCC assessment
report (AR5) will also include Earth System Models (ESMs) that couple global climate models with
biogeochemical models to resolve terrestrial and marine primary production. Unlike global climate models
that only resolve physical variables, ESMs provide projections of biogeochemical variables including pH,
dissolved oxygen, and macro- and micro-nutrients. The use of IPCC-class model output to project the
impacts of climate change on marine organisms must begin with an understanding and statistical treatment
of each model’s bias and uncertainty. In many cases, this involves downscaling lower resolution global
models to resolve regional climate dynamics and/or bias correcting the magnitude and variability of
specific variables. For sea turtles, climate change projections can be used for both their terrestrial and
oceanic habitat and thus climate model output must be statistically downscaled or bias-corrected before
applied to an assessment of potential impacts. Here I discuss specific examples from the major nesting
populations worldwide by showing output from a suite of IPCC-class ESMs (i.e. primary production) and
global climate models (sea surface temperature) that project the impacts of continued greenhouse gas
emissions on critical marine and nesting beach habitat. I also show the consequences of misuse of climate
model output in sea turtle/climate change impact assessments while discussing some statistical techniques
to bias-correct output. The main goal of this presentation is to inform the sea turtle research community of
the caveats and statistical treatment of ESMs and global climate models, as well as the basic structure of
these models and how they can be used to assess the impacts of climate change on sea turtles.
113
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IS THE SW MEDITERRANEAN SEA A TRAP FOR NORTH ATLANTIC LOGGERHEAD
TURTLES?
Ricardo Sagarminaga1, Yonat Swimmer2, Mariluz Parga3, Ana Tejedor4, and Amanda Southwood5
1
Kai Marine Services, c/ Nalon 16 C.P 28240 Hoyo de Manzanares, Madrid, Spain
NOAA NMFS PIFSC, 501 W. Ocean Blvd, Long Beach, California, 90802
3
DS Consultoria Ambiental Marina, c/ Rabassa, 49-51, local-108024 – Barcelona, Spain
4
Kai Soluciones, c/ Nalon 16 C.P 28240 Hoyo de Manzanares, Madrid, Spain
5
Univ. of North Carolina Wilmington, 601 South College Rd., Wilmington, NC 28403
2
Working alongside fishing vessels in the productive Alboran Sea, we deployed satellite transmitters on sub
adult loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) that had either been caught in longline fishing gear or had been
captured while basking at the surface of the water. Over the course of 4 years, 26 turtles were captured and
tagged. In this analysis, we describe the movements and tracking durations for both turtle groups in the
western Mediterranean Sea, including a westerly movement of loggerhead turtle into the Atlantic Ocean.
We present an understanding of turtles’ habitat use in relation to oceanographic features in the region and
we speculate on potential threats to turtle populations due to both pelagic and fixed fisheries from both
European and North African coastlines. We will also discuss our findings of hematological and
biochemical parameters of longline-caught and control turtles to determine physiological impacts due to
stress of capture.
CONNECTING THE DOTS: THE HIDDEN COSTS OF PLASTIC POLLUTION TO MARINE
TURTLES
Dee Sagawe and Jesse Senko
Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA
Entanglement in plastic debris and ingestion of marine plastics are well known sources of direct mortality
to ocean wildlife. However, the problem may be much larger than what can be inferred from stranding
networks and necropsies. We review the literature and use marine turtles as a case study to suggest that: (1)
non-lethal ingestion may reduce energy budgets and decrease reproductive output; (2) persistent organic
pollutants adsorbed on plastic debris may accumulate in turtles and eggs through direct and indirect
consumption; and (3) micro plastics in beach sand may change thermal profiles and alter sex ratios of
hatchlings. We discuss the potential for population-level consequences and highlight areas in need of future
research.
114
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ARE TURTLES EATING MORE DEBRIS? A GLOBAL ANALYSIS SINCE 1900
Qamar Schuyler1, Britta Denise Hardesty2, Chris Wilcox3, and Kathy Townsend4
1
University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
CSIRO Wealth from Oceans Flagship, Ecosystem Sciences, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
3
CSIRO Wealth from Oceans Flagship, Marine and Atmospheric Research, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
4
Queensland Brain Institute, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia
2
Marine debris ingestion can result in both lethal and sub-lethal impacts to sea turtles and other wildlife.
Although studies have reported on debris ingestion by marine turtles, and implied that this incidence may
have increased over time, there has not been a global synthesis since 1985. To address this, we analyzed 37
studies published from 1985-2012 reporting on data collected since pre-1900 to answer the following
questions: Has ingestion prevalence changed over time? What types of debris are most commonly
ingested? What is the geographic distribution of debris ingestion by marine turtles relative to global debris
distribution, and which species and life history stages are most likely to ingest debris? This study shows
conclusively that the ingestion of debris by sea turtles has increased significantly over time, with plastic
being the most commonly ingested debris type. Turtles in nearly all regions studied were found to ingest
debris, but the probability of ingestion does not relate to modeled debris densities. Comparing turtle species
and foraging strategy, carnivorous species are less likely to ingest debris than are herbivores or
gelatinovores. This research indicates that oceanic stage leatherback turtles and green turtles are at the
greatest risk from ingested marine debris. To reduce this risk, anthropogenic debris must be managed at a
global level.
SHADING IN SITU MARINE TURTLE NESTS: A POTENTIAL PRACTICE TO MITIGATE
NEST TEMPERATURES IN RESPONSE TO CLIMATE CHANGE
Monette Virginia Schwoerer1, Betsy Von Holle1, and John C. Stiner2
1
2
University of Central Florida, Department of Biology, Orlando, Florida, USA
National Park Service, Canaveral National Seashore, Titusville, Florida, USA
Although species have shown the ability to adapt to historical changes in climate, it is predicted that
population adaptation will not be able to keep up with the accelerated rate of human-driven climate change.
Climate warming is expected to result in marine turtle sex ratio bias towards females, because the sex of a
marine turtle is determined by incubation temperature, with female hatchlings produced at higher
temperatures. Likewise, nest temperatures beyond the thermal tolerance range can result in nest failure.
Loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) nest temperatures throughout Florida have resulted in a bias toward
the production of female hatchlings; this female bias is expected to become greater due to climate change.
Also, an increase in nest temperatures beyond the thermal tolerance range will increase embryo mortality.
One option for mitigating the impacts of climate change on hatchling sex ratios and embryo mortality is the
use of shading to reduce nest temperatures. In this study, we tested the thermal effects and effects on
hatching success of a cotton shade cloth maintained over 21 in situ loggerhead nests for the duration of
incubation. The study was completed during the 2012 nesting season, with nests laid during the months of
June and July, at Canaveral National Seashore, an important rookery for loggerhead sea turtles on the
Atlantic coast of central Florida. We compared two treatments: un-shaded loggerhead nest (n=21) and
shaded loggerhead nest (n=21), using a matched-pairs layout. Nest temperatures were recorded using
temperature data loggers, with a data logger deployed opportunistically during egg deposition in the center
115
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of each loggerhead clutch in the study. We used mean daily nest temperatures for the middle third of
incubation to predict sex ratios for each nest. Hatching success evaluations were completed for all nests in
the study to compare embryo mortality between shaded and un-shaded treatments. With this study, we are
able to inform the degree to which the application of shade to a loggerhead nest will affect the nesting
environment.
CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT OF OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT INTENSIVE SPORADIC NESTING HABITATS OF ANDHRA COAST, BAY OF
BENGAL, INDIA
P. S. Raja Sekhar
Dept. of Environmental Sciences, Andhra University, Visakhapatnam -530 003, A.P., India
The olive ridley sea turtle is distributed in the tropics of Indo-Pacific and East Atlantic Oceans. In India it is
found all along the east and west coasts and has been placed in Schedule I of the Indian Wildlife Protection
Act (1972). It is listed in Appendix -I of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species
(CITES) which prohibits trade in turtle products. All five species nest on the coasts of the Indian Ocean and
its bay islands, where olive ridleys mass (Arribada) nest on the Gahirmatha beaches of Orissa State in the
Northern Indian Ocean. Nesting olive ridleys migrate from the oceanic Indian Ocean to mass nesting sites
of Orissa, during winter months (November to February), through the coastal waters of Tamilnadu and
Andhra Pradesh. Before reaching the mass nesting sites of Orissa some of the turtles utilize the North
Andhra coast for their sporadic nesting activity. After mass nesting sites of Orissa, the Northern Andhra
Pradesh Coast (NAC) is an important sporadic nesting habitat to olive ridley sea turtles with diversified
nesting beach environments. Nesting densities of olive ridley turtles is varied from riverine sandy spits (<
20 nests/km), mainland beaches (>5nests/km) to calcareous shoals (< 2 nests/km). As part of conservation
measures in situ management of nests and protection of newly born hatchlings were done at Godavari and
Vamsadhara river mouth beaches. Awareness campaigns for the fishermen community were conducted at
major fishing harbors for the implementation of Turtle Excluder Devices (TEDs) to reduce incidental
mortality. The vulnerable nesting sites of the olive ridleys were frequently monitored to reduce the natural
predation and human depredation of eggs.
EFFECTS OF LED ILLUMINATED GILLNETS ON BYCATCH OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
IN COASTAL MESH NET FISHERIES AT BAJA CALIFORNIA SUR, MEXICO
Jesse Senko1, John Wang2, Jesus Lucero-Romero3, David Maldonado Diaz3, Daniel Aguilar-Ramirez4,
Antonio Figueroa5, and S. Hoyt Peckham3
1
Ecology, Evolution, and Environmental Sciences, School of Life Sciences, Arizona State University,
Tempe, AZ 85287-4501, USA
2
Joint Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research, University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, Hawaii
96814, USA
3
Grupo Tortuguero de las Californias, A.C. La Paz, Baja California Sur, México
4
National Fisheries Institute of Mexico (INAPESCA), Baja California Sur, México
5
University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, 90024, USA
Mesh net fisheries are globally ubiquitous and have been identified as one of the leading sources of marine
turtle bycatch. Unlike other fisheries with high rates of bycatch, there are few solutions to reduce marine
116
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
turtle bycatch in mesh nets. The overlap of intense bottom-set gillnet fisheries with a loggerhead foraging
hotspot at Baja California Sur produces among the highest marine turtle bycatch rates documented
worldwide. The resulting mortality is of international concern because of the status of the North Pacific
loggerhead population, which was recently uplisted to endangered under the US ESA in 2011 and
identified as one of the worlds 11 most endangered marine turtle RMUs. Thus, there is a pressing need to
develop novel bycatch reduction solutions without significantly decreasing catch rates of target species. We
conducted controlled experiments at Baja California Sur, Mexico to compare loggerhead bycatch rates,
non-turtle bycatch rates, and target catch rates between illuminated nets (nets with green LED lights) and
conventional (control) nets. The experiment consisted of a fully crossed design partitioned into four
treatments: day control (conventional nets), day experiment (illuminated nets), night control (conventional
nets), and night experimental (illuminated nets). In 28 sets of gillnet pairs, 89 loggerhead turtles were
caught at an average rate of 0.96 ± 0.97 and 0.84 ± 0.92 turtles per 24 h per 100 m of control and
illuminated net, respectively. Loggerhead bycatch rates were lower by 75% in illuminated nets during night
versus control nets during day, and 46% lower in illuminated nets during night versus control nets during
night. However, there was only a 13% decrease in loggerhead bycatch rates in illuminated versus control
nets across 24 h periods. Non-turtle bycatch rates of fish, crab, and squid were lower in both day and night
illuminated nets. Target catch rates were higher for both day treatments versus both night treatments,
although market values (USD) remained consistent between all four treatments. Elasmobranch and halibut
target catch rates were higher in both day treatments versus both night treatments, with higher catch rates in
day and night control nets for elasmobranch and higher catch rates in day and night illuminated nets for
halibut. Our results suggest that illuminated gillnets may be promising for mitigating marine turtle bycatch
in fisheries that operate solely at night.
SYNOPSIS OF THREATS TO SEA TURTLES IN THE GULF OF GUINEA: CONSERVATION
IMPLICATIONS OF ILLEGAL, UNREPORTED AND UNREGULATED (IUU) FISHING
Boluwaji Solarin, O. Adeogun, D. A. Bolaji, C O. M. Adegbile, A. A. Ajulo, R. O. Akinnigbagbe, and
O. S. Fakayode
Nigerian Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research , Victoria Island, Lagos, Nigeria
Sea turtle conservation and the maintenance of biodiversity are integral parts of the Ecosystem Approach to
Fisheries (EAF), which is one of the most current global environmental management instruments. A wide
array of major threats to sea turtle conservation - including the impacts of fisheries - are highlighted.
Harvesting by fishermen during nesting at the beach, beach erosion (escalated in some places by ship
wrecks), environmental pollution from accidental oil discharge and indiscriminate dumping of solid non
biodegradable wastes impact sea turtles. Direct and indirect impacts of fisheries like shark driftnets, seine
nets and long lines also impact turtles negatively. Large scale habitat degradation is caused by incessant
demersal shrimp trawling (due to overcapitalization of the industry and overexploitation of the resources)
despite the installation of turtle excluder devices (TED) in most of the trawl nets in Nigeria and Cameroon.
Illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing, which takes place both on the high seas and within
national zones, by foreign or national vessels, constitutes a major problem with adverse biological,
environmental, social and economic effects and implications on sea turtle conservation in the sub region. A
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) promoted International Plan of Action on IUU fishing (IPOAIUU), a voluntary instrument to prevent, deter and eliminate IUU fishing is highlighted. Recommendations
are also proffered to mitigate the threats to sea turtle conservation and promote responsible, stakeholdersbased fisheries management to ensure sustainable development.
117
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
OVERVIEW OF SOUTHEAST FISHERIES SCIENCE CENTER FISHERY OBSERVER
PROGRAMS AND BYCATCH ANALYSIS
Lesley W. Stokes, Paul M. Richards, and Sheryan P. Epperly
National Marine Fisheries Service Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Miami, Florida, USA
Sea turtles are incidentally captured in commercial fisheries, and these interactions must be documented
and quantified to understand the extent of the problem. The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)
Southeast Fisheries Science Center (SEFSC) operates Fisheries Observer Programs to collect vital catch
and bycatch data from commercial fisheries in the southeast United States. Those fisheries currently
observed by NMFS in the southeast include the pelagic longline, reef fish, shrimp trawl, purse seine
(menhaden), shark gillnet, and shark bottom longline fisheries. Fisheries observers undergo extensive
training to accurately characterize fishing gear, and to identify and quantify target and bycatch species for
stock assessment and biological studies. NMFS observers document protected species interactions in
careful detail. When a sea turtle is captured by a fishing vessel, the observer records the species,
identification criteria, condition at capture and release, fishing gear details, specific hooking location or tow
times where applicable, entanglement status, amount and type of gear remaining at release, morphometrics,
and resuscitation efforts and condition evaluation for comatose or unresponsive turtles. Interaction data are
used to generate estimates of sea turtle bycatch rates and to investigate patterns in injury and mortality.
Observers in the pelagic longline fishery also document the presence of required careful release tools on the
vessel. Turtles are tagged, measured, and biopsied so that demographic and life history parameters can be
used to enhance recovery efforts of these endangered and threatened species.
SEA TURTLE RESEARCH, RESCUE AND REHABILITATION CENTRE (DEKAMER),
DALYAN, MUGLA-TURKEY; RESULTS OF THE FIRST FOUR YEARS
Meryem Tekin1, Barbaros Şahin2, Erdi Can2, Cigdem Fak2, Mucahit Secme2, Çisem Sezgin2, Eyup
Baskale2, and Yakup Kaska2
1
DEKAMER, Sea Turtle Research, Rescue and Rehabilitation Centre, Dalyan, Mugla, Turkey
Pamukkale University, DEKAMER, Sea Turtle Research, Rescue and Rehabilitation Centre, Dalyan,
Mugla, Turkey
2
The first sea turtle rescue centre (DEKAMER) in Turkey was established in 2008 and its activities during
the first four years are shown in these results. A total of 61 injured, sick or problem turtles were admitted to
the centre, 56 Caretta caretta, 12 Chelonia mydas and 2 fresh water turtles Trionyx triunguis were admitted
to the centre during the first four years 2008-2012. With 2 of the 70 sea turtles having been readmitted after
previous treatment and release. Thirty-nine in total were treated, recovered and released back to the sea as
healthy individuals. There are currently 6 sea turtles still undergoing treatment and rehabilitation at the
centre. Injured turtles were mainly found and collected from within the Muğla province. In order to
determine the true cause of mortality, autopsies were conducted on all dead turtles. The main causes of
injuries and deaths were found to be related to fishery and boat activities, such as fishing line and hook
ingestion (16%), fishing line entanglement (33%), propeller cuts (14%) and speed boat crashes and impacts
(7%). Mean treatments take two and half months (77 days). This varies depending upon the type of injury,
and size and depth of wounds being treated.
118
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MORTALITY AND SERIOUS INJURY DETERMINATIONS FOR SEA TURTLES IN THE
NMFS NORTHEAST REGION, 2006-2010
Carrie M. Upite1, Kimberly T. Murray2, Brian A. Stacy3, Sara E. Weeks2, and C. Rogers Williams4
1
National Marine Fisheries Service, Gloucester, MA, USA
National Marine Fisheries Service, Woods Hole, MA, USA
3
National Marine Fisheries Service/University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA
4
National Marine Life Center, Buzzards Bay, MA, USA
2
The National Marine Fisheries Service Northeast Sea Turtle Serious Injury Workgroup reviewed all sea
turtle interactions recorded by the Northeast Fisheries Observer Program from 2006 to 2010 (n=145). The
workgroup determined the condition of individual turtle interactions using guidelines established by the
publication 'Technical Working Guidelines for Assessing Injuries of Sea Turtles Observed in Northeast
Region Fishing Gear.' Turtles were placed into categories using identified post-release mortality rates, or by
100% mortality determination. Sea turtle records were subsequently delineated by major gear type,
resulting in 97 trawl records, 29 gillnet records, and 11 scallop dredge records for which injury
determinations were made. In addition, there were three cases with insufficient information to make a
determination, two records that described moderately to severely decomposed animals not attributable to
the observed fishery, and three records that had injury determinations but were excluded due to
confidentiality issues. Considering the 137 records with injury determinations, the resulting mortality rate
for trawl gear is 47%, the mortality rate for gillnet gear is 58%, and dredge gear is 80%. Additional factors
that may influence sea turtle serious injury and mortality were considered, such as specific fishery (within
an encompassing gear type), geographical area, sea turtle species, and life stage.
UNUSUAL COLD-STUNNING EVENT OF GREEN TURTLES IN URUGUAY
Gabriela M. Vélez-Rubio1,2, Andrés Estrades1, Virginia Ferrando1,3, and Jesús Tomás4
1
Karumbé. Av.Rivera 3245. 11600. Montevideo. Uruguay/
Instituto Cavanilles de Biodiversidad y Biologia Evolutiva, Universidad de Valencia, Aptdo. 22085,
46071 Valencia, Spain
3
Museo Nacional de Historia Natural, CC 399, CP 11000, Montevideo, Uruguay
4
Instituto Cavanilles de Biodiversidad y Biologia Evolutiva, Universidad de Valencia, Aptdo. 22085,
46071 Valencia, Spain
2
Hypothermic, or cold-stunning, occurs when a sea turtle is abruptly exposed to cold water, normally as a
result of unusually cold weather or sudden cold fronts, and it cannot compensate fast enough to avoid a
sudden drop in body temperature. When sea turtles are trapped in cold waters they may become lethargic
and buoyant, floating at the surface, and the effect of the winds and currents on the sea surface could cause
a massive sea turtle stranding. In Uruguayan waters, the hibernation strategy has been described as a
survival strategy of juvenile green turtles (Chelonia mydas) to tolerate low temperatures during the austral
winter. It has been recorded that some green turtles remain in these waters during the coldest months, as
reflected by stranding events, radio telemetry studies, in water surveys and satellite telemetry. Hence some
juveniles of this species may tolerate low temperatures recorded in the area in winter. During July 2012
record-breaking cold weather occurred throughout Uruguay. The seawater surface temperatures went down
under 10 degrees Celsius (°C), normally the seawater mean temperature in Uruguayan coast varies between
11 to 12 °C. From 12th to 19thof July in the Rio de la Plata estuarine influence zone of the Uruguayan
119
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
coast; specifically in Punta del Este (department of Maldonado, South-East Uruguay) and in Montevideo
where the temperature dropped as low as 9 and 8.5°C, respectively. Prevailing winds those days are from
the South and Southwest on the 15th of July there were 25-30 nuts southwestern winds. Ninety juvenile
green turtle strandings were registered in the Uruguayan coast from the 13th to 25th of July, being the 15th,
16th and 17th the days with the highest number of strandings. Most of them were recorded in the external
estuarine zone (departments of Canelones and Maldonado). Twenty of them were found dead. The others
were sent to Karumbé Rehabilitation Center in Montevideo and other civil organizations centers in the
department of Maldonado for recovery. Most of the 35 turtles at the Karumbé center appeared to be in good
physical condition but half of them presented floating problems, pneumonia, skin infection diseases and
septicemia. All the individuals were juveniles (mean± SD curved carapace length, notch to tip [CCLn-t]=
39.9± 3.96 cm). Eighteen of them continue in rehab. Karumbé recorded previous cold-stunned sea turtles in
the period of the last 12 years but the 2012 event has been the one with the highest number of turtles
stranded recorded. No other species stranded during those days, since density of loggerhead and
leatherback turtles seem to decrease in the area during the austral winter. Monitoring these mass stranding
events provides a unique opportunity to obtain information about this phenomenon, and the consequent
impact on sea turtle populations that spent the whole year in this temperate region of the South Western
Atlantic ocean.
INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECTS OF SEA LEVEL RISE ON SEA TURTLE NESTING
DISTRIBUTIONS WITHIN THE SOUTH ATLANTIC BIGHT
Betsy Von Holle1, John Weishampel1, Jennifer Irish2, Scott Hagen1, Monette Auman1, Annette Spivy1,
Mark Dodd3, Matthew Godfrey4, DuBose Griffin5, Anne Meylan6, Llewellyn Ehrhart1, and John
Stiner7
1
University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL , USA
Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA
3
Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Brunswick, GA, USA
4
North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission, Beaufort, NC, USA
5
South Carolina Department of Natural Resources, Charleston, SC, USA
6
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, St. Petersburg, FL, USA
7
Canaveral National Seashore, Titusville, FL, USA
2
Sea level rise (SLR) and disturbances from increased storm activity are expected to diminish coastal
habitats available for sea turtle, seabird, shorebird, and beach mouse nesting by removing habitat as well as
inundating nests during critical incubation periods. Our study links long-term survey data for three species
of sea turtle to maps of coastal vulnerability to sea level rise (SLR) in order to understand the effects of sea
level rise on population viability. We have integrated GIS and location-specific data for sea turtle nests
collected across the South Atlantic Bight coastline into a data layer for this study. We are using 2005-2010
annual surveys for sea turtle nests to map the extent of nesting locations for each species along our study
region. Coastal habitat will be ranked based on relative density of nests, which will determine its relative
importance, or habitat suitability, for each species. We will create GIS map layers of coastal nesting habitat
likely to be lost due to SLR as informed by the U.S. Geological Survey’s Coastal Vulnerability Index (CVI),
created for the Atlantic coast of the U.S. which provides an overall assessment of a coastal area’s
vulnerability to erosion and inundation as a function of SLR. The published CVI is based on historical
trends of SLR, and does not consider future SLR projections with global warming. However, we will use
the CVI framework to develop CVI for selected future Intergovernmental Panel on Climate change (IPCC)
SLR scenarios to assess changes in CVI with changes in SLR rates. The modified CVI will be combined
with coastal nesting density maps of our focal species to create habitat vulnerability maps for selected
future SLR scenarios. Our first objective is to present habitat suitability maps for nesting sea turtle species
along the South Atlantic Bight. Our second objective is to integrate a model of SLR along with long term
field biological observations in order to predict vulnerability to nesting habitat loss for sea turtle species
120
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
within our study region. In sum, we will present preliminary data analyses and maps for objective one and
two. With the results from our study, planners and decision makers will be able to choose from a portfolio
of mitigation techniques for policies relevant to coastal nesting species. There is an urgent need to
determine long-term plans so that the most cost-effective strategies of reducing the effects of sea level rise
on coastal species can be determined.
UV ILLUMINATION OF GILLNETS REDUCES SEA TURTLE AND ELASMOBRANCH
BYCATCH
John H. Wang1, Shara Fisler2, Joel Barkan2, and Yonat Swimmer3
1
University of Hawaii - JIMAR, Honolulu, HI, USA
Ocean Discovery Institute, San Diego, CA, USA
3
NOAA - Pacific Island Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, HI, USA
2
Visual cues play important roles in sea turtle foraging behavior. As such, and altering these cues can be a
useful strategy to reduce the incidental catch of sea turtles in fisheries. We examined the potential
effectiveness of illuminating gillnets with ultraviolet (UV) LEDs in an effort to reduce bycatch of green sea
turtles (Chelonia mydas) in coastal fisheries. Net illumination was also tested in a commercial bottom
gillnet fishery to quantify its effects on target fish catch rates and catch value. When we compared catch
rates in nets illuminated by UV LEDs with catch rates in control nets, we found that the UV illuminated
nets: 1) significantly reduced mean sea turtle catch rates (by ~40%), 2) had similar rates of target fish catch
and catch value, 3) increased the catch of California halibut (Paralichthys californicus), the most valuable
species in the fishery, by ~ 32%, 4) decreased the bycatch of elasmobranch species by 29% and 5)
decreased the bycatch of scalloped hammerhead sharks (Sphyrna lewini) by 57%. Taken together, our
findings indicate that UV illumination may have application in global fisheries to both reduce sea turtle and
elasmobranch bycatch. These results illustrate the potential for modifying fishing gear with visual
deterrents to effectively reduce bycatch species rates without affecting fishers’ revenues.
FEEDING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD (CARETTA CARETTA) AND LEATHERBACK
(DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA) SEA TURTLES: A MODEL TO UNDERSTAND BYCATCH
Natasha Warraich and Jeanette Wyneken
Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Loggerhead (Caretta caretta) and leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) turtles are two sea turtle species
caught commonly as bycatch in longline fishing. The leatherback feeds primarily on gelatinous
zooplankton while the loggerhead is a carnivore feeding on mollusks, echinoderms and crustaceans. Hence,
the attraction and capture of loggerheads to baited longline hooks is not surprising but the attraction and
capture of leatherbacks is somewhat unexpected. We measured and compared the responses to olfactory
cues and investigated the responses of these two species to bait odors in controlled laboratory experiments
to better understand releasers of feeding behavior. Previous studies quantified and compared feeding
responses including increased diving, biting, gaping, and altered swimming behavior including abrupt shifts
in swimming speed. The two species share some behavioral components in response to bait odors such as
changes in swimming behavior and snapping but others were species specific. Our comparative study
121
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
highlights the differences in the two species, unexpected similarities, and suggests aspects of their behavior
that may predispose these species to incidental capture in fisheries.
IN VITRO TOXICITY OF PERFLUORINATED COMPOUNDS IN LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLE (CARETTA CARETTA) PRIMARY SKIN CELL CULTURES
Sarah Webb1, Benjamin M. Higgins2, Joseph P. Flanagan3, and Céline A.J. Godard-Codding1
1
Department of Environmental Toxicology, The Institute of Environmental and Human Health (TIEHH),
Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas, USA
2
NOAA/NMFS Galveston, Texas, USA
3
Veterinary Services, Houston Zoo, Houston, Texas, USA
Perfluorinated compounds (PFCs) are globally distributed contaminants which have been measured in both
human and wildlife blood and serum. Sources of PFCs include polymerization aids, stain repellents,
surfactants, and medical devices. These compounds have been shown to cause a variety of adverse health
effects in mammals, including the development of tumors in the liver and thyroid, hepatotoxicity,
developmental delays, interruption in lipid metabolism and adipogenesis leading to decreased body weight,
and a significant increase in both internal and external morphological abnormalities. These compounds are
extremely persistent in the environment, and the global concentration of PFCs is expected to continue to
rise even if the chemical is regulated as consumer products continue to break down. There is currently no
PFC toxicity data available in any reptile species. PFCs have been found in both juvenile and adult
loggerhead sea turtle tissues with variation depending on geographical location. Body burden of PFCs in
sea turtles seems to be dependent upon body size, species, age, and habitat, as PFCs bioaccumulate and
occur in higher amounts in older, larger turtles, and in species which are more carnivorous. Blood serum
levels of PFCs found in loggerhead sea turtles are at concentrations which are known to cause significant
toxicity in mammals. However the possible adverse health effects of PFCs in turtles are currently unknown.
Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) are the dominant PFC compounds
found in sea turtle blood. This is consistent with global distributions of PFCs, as PFOS and PFOA represent
the largest portion of PFCs globally both in production and in environmental measurements. Here, we
report on the use of cytotoxicity assays to assess effects of PFOA on sea turtle cells, using loggerhead sea
turtle primary skin cell cultures which were established and characterized in our laboratory. Because PFCs
are known to affect mitochondrial activity and lipid production in mammalian toxicity studies, (3-(4,5Dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) were
selected as initial cytotoxicity assays due to their measurements of mitochondrial activity and cell
membrane integrity, respectively. Initial testing used PFOA, with a variety of test concentrations of (0.05
μM, 0.5 μM, 5.0 μM, 50 μM, 500 μM) which encompass chemical concentrations found in the environment,
in sea turtle serum, and in prey animals. Significant toxicity occurs at the highest dose (500 μM) with cells
from n=6 turtles for MTT and n=5 turtles for LDH, a large sample size when working with endangered
species. Following initial testing, dose range was narrowed between the highest dose (500 μM) and the
highest dose showing no significant toxicity (50 μM). Both MTT and LDH assays were performed on this
second dose range (50 μM, 140 μM, 230 μM, 320 μM, 410 μM, 500 μM). Significant toxicity occurs at 410
μM and 500 μM with cells from n=2 animals in initial testing, with further testing to follow using both
PFOA and PFOS.
122
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
REDUCING ENTRAPMENT OF MARINE TURTLES IN WASTE FISHING GEAR AROUND
THE COASTAL WATERS OF BONAIRE, DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Sue Willis and Mabel Nava
Sea Turtle Conservation Bonaire
Entangled and loose lines in the waters around Bonaire are a major concern. There is a considerable
amount of fishing line, sometimes with fish hooks attached, in the water and tangled amongst the corals and
sponges on the reef. Non-biodegradable monofilament lines last for several hundred years before they fully
decompose. During this time, the lines can become a major problem as they are known to trap marine life.
Every year Sea Turtle Conservation Bonaire (STCB) encounters resident green and hawksbill sea turtles
that have been accidentally trapped and killed by fishing debris. In January 2012, STCB launched a new
project to clean up the discarded fishing gear from Bonaire's reefs. The ‘Fishing Line Project’ aims to
reduce the amount of fishing line, hooks, nets and other debris found on Bonaire’s coral reefs. In
partnership with the Dutch Caribbean Nature Alliance, the project will also serve as a model for other
Caribbean islands, so that they may better find solutions to this common and widespread issue. The Fishing
Line Project aims to recruit volunteer experienced recreational SCUBA divers, snorkelers and walkers to
remove the fishing lines that have become snagged on our reefs and shores. When they sign up for the
project, volunteers are given special instruction in safely removing the lines including an easy-tounderstand poster which has been made to instruct diving, snorkeling and non-diving volunteers. In
addition to individuals collecting lines during their regular recreational dives or snorkels STCB is working
in partnership with the dive operators on Bonaire and a number of “clean-up dives” have been organized to
clean the areas where most of the fishing debris occurs, notably around Bonaire’s piers. In the first nine
months of the project 131 volunteer SCUBA divers have registered and over 1000L/265 gallons of waste
fishing gear have been removed from the reefs around Bonaire. “TAngler Bins”, pvc-pipes specially
constructed to be used as bins for fishing lines, have been positioned at several polluted beaches, popular
fishing spots and dive sites around Bonaire with instructions in Papiamentu and English. These are for the
collection of waste fishing line, hooks, lures and nets. STCB is also working with our local fishermen to
inform them about the dangers that some of the fishing methods they may use have for both marine wildlife
and humans, whilst also introducing our fishermen to environmentally-friendly fishing methods. Fishing
lines cannot be recycled on Bonaire yet, so at the end of the first year of the project all the collected lines
will be made into a special piece of art by a local artist and this will be displayed to mark the project’s
success.
123
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FIRST RECORD OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) IN SINALOA,
GULF OF CALIFORNIA, MEXICO
Alan Zavala-Norzagaray1,2, Catherine E. Hart3, Adrian Canizalez-Roman2, Paula Aguilar-Claussell1,
César Paul Ley-Quiñonez2, and Alonso Aguirre4
1
CIIDIR-IPN Unidad Sinaloa, Juan de Dios Bátiz Paredes No. 250, Col. San Joachin, C.P. 81101, Guasave,
Sinaloa, México
2
Doctorado Regional en Biotecnología, Universidad Autonoma de Sinaloa, Culiacan, Sinaloa, Mexico.
3
Doctorado en Ciencias en Biosistemática, Ecología y Manejo de Recursos Naturales y Agrícolas
(BEMARENA), Centro Universitario de la Costa, Universidad de Guadalajara, Puerto Vallarta, Jalisco,
Mexico.
4
Smithsonian-Mason School of Conservation , Front Royal, Virginia, USA; Department of Environmental
Science and Policy, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, USA
The Gulf of California Region is recognized as an important developmental and foraging habitat for three
of the five species of sea turtles known to occur in the Eastern Pacific. To date, monitoring and
conservation programs in this region have focused primarily on the Baja California Peninsula and northern
Mexican Pacific (both coasts being represented by the States of Baja California Sur and Sonora). We began
prospective sea turtle surveys in bays and lagoons located in northern Sinaloa during 2006 and initiated offshore sea turtle surveys in 2012. From May to June 2012, a group of fishermen from "La Reforma"
community, reported the sighting and bycatch of sea turtles while fishing in the off-shore area of the
municipalities of Guasave-Angostura (24º 57 ', 25° 09', 108° 23 ', 108° 01'), they reported the capture of 3
different species: Lepidochelys olivacea, Chelonia mydas and Caretta caretta. These fishermen agreed to
participate with the sea turtle monitoring and were trained to record basic sea turtle data. We present the
first data which demonstrates the presence of loggerhead sea turtles in the Gulf of California. Turtles were
captured alive with surface gillnets designed for shark fishing. Fishermen reported the sighting ≥100
loggerhead turtles during 15 days of fishing using 3 boats. 19 turtles were captured to collect data including
the mean CCL (61.81±6.76 cm) and CCW (57.81±6.27 cm). Each turtle was then tagged with Inconel tags,
the capture site was georeferenced (GPS), and the turtle released. Our data reveals the presence of juvenile
loggerhead sea turtles in the Gulf of California. However the sightings and captures occurred in an area of
high fishing activity, which in previous studies and surveys in fishing communities we identified as at high
risk for bycatch and direct sea turtle capture. We propose a detailed study of the area to assess the
abundance of loggerhead turtles and the bycatch affecting this population.
124
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
In-Water Biology
A FAIR “EGGS” CHANGE: COMPARING STABLE ISOTOPE RATIOS OF FRESH-LAID VS.
ADDLED EGGS*
Ciro M. Amato, Fernanda B. Gusmão, Ryan M. Chabot, Simona A. Ceriani, and Llewellyn M.
Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) are a highly migratory species of marine turtle, often traveling great
distances between their foraging grounds and the beaches on which they lay their eggs. In recent years,
stable isotope analysis has become a valuable technique for assessing migratory connectivity and foraging
ecology, with a significantly lower cost than traditional satellite telemetry, allowing for a greatly increased
sample size. Many tissue types may be used to test questions on migratory connectivity and foraging
ecology, including blood, skin, and in the case of marine turtles, eggs. However, fresh eggs are potentially
viable and sacrificing them for stable isotope analysis must be considered when permitting for study of this
threatened species. Moreover, some research groups do not survey their study area daily, thereby
preventing them from acquiring freshly laid eggs or within 12 hours of deposition. Collecting a fresh egg
more than 12 hours after deposition can have deleterious effects on other eggs within the clutch. Another
option available to researchers is to collect addled, or “rotten” eggs at the time that nests are excavated for
hatchling productivity evaluation. These un-hatched, non-viable eggs are readily available to researchers,
providing an opportunity to increase sample size dramatically without sacrificing potentially viable eggs
and removing the need to encounter the nesting female or discover recent nests within a restricted time
window. However, fresh and un-hatched addled eggs may not be interchangeable isotopically if
decomposition and variations in the microenvironments of the nest cause isotopic differences. We
compared carbon and nitrogen isotopic values of a fresh egg (collected at the time of deposition) and an
addled egg (collected post-hatch) from the same loggerhead clutch from the Archie Carr National Wildlife
Refuge, Melbourne Beach, Florida (USA) from 2009-2012. Fresh and addled eggs from the same clutch
did not differ in carbon or nitrogen stable isotope ratios, suggesting that addled eggs and fresh eggs provide
the same information on foraging history. These results could have far reaching ramifications by markedly
increasing sample sizes for stable isotope research, thereby improving our understanding of migratory
connectivity at the population level. Acknowledgements: Special thanks to the following organizations,
International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service,
Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics
and CLS America for their continued, generous support.
DEPTH AND WATER TEMPERATURE PREFERENCES OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE
DURING INTER-NESTING PERIOD ON DALYAN-IZTUZU BEACHES, TURKEY
Eyup Baskale1, Yusuf Katılmıs1, Mücahit Seçme2, Çisem Sezgin2, and Yakup Kaska1
1
2
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli-Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli-Turkey
Innovations in the science and technology provide advantages in uncovering unknown issues of positive
science. One of this innovations is Time Depth Recorders (TDRs), have allowed researchers to study the
125
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
dive behavior of sea turtles in their natural habitats. Female sea turtles typically lay several clutches during
each nesting season and rest in the time between laying clutches (the inter-nesting period) in the waters off
the nesting beach. The available information about diving behavior of inter-nesting turtles has provided
significant evidence on how to protect nesting turtles from human interactions. This study was conducted
on Dalyan-Iztuzu nesting beach during 2012 nesting season, and aimed to determine depth preference of
loggerhead turtle between the inter-nesting period and temperatures at that depth. Therefore each TDR
device is programmed to record data at 2 minute intervals according to the user manual (CEFAS G5, 2007).
TDR device is mounted to 10 loggerhead sea turtle using fishing line and chrome wire; however data have
been obtained from seven of them. According to the results of the average temperature was measured as
28±1.77°C, (range=16-34°C), and the average depth was calculated as 1.7±1.64 m below the sea level. In
addition, the maximum depth was found as 78 m below the sea level. During the interesting period, we
found significantly important relationships between depth and water temperature preferences of
Loggerhead turtle. These results were discussed in term of habitat usage and preparation of egg shell
formation in the time between the two nesting in a season.
CHARACTERIZATION AND SATELLITE TRACKS OF THE MIGRATORY ROUTES OF TWO
HEAD-STARTED HAWKSBILL TURTLES 13 FROM SANTA MARTA, COLOMBIA*
Jorge E. Bernal-Gutiérrez, Guiomar A. Jauregui, and Carmen L. Noriega
Sea Turtle Conservation Program, Jorge Tadeo Lozano University, Santa Marta, Colombia
Due to the ecological role of Eretmochelys imbricata promoting the matter and energy flow between
trophic levels above and below during its life cycle and high human pressure (capture to obtain carapaces,
bycatch), this species is listed by the IUCN as Critically Endangered. In order to verify the success of the
head - start process, two young hawksbill turtles (named Colombianita and Tuggy), both 13 months old,
were introduced back into the wild at Casa Grande Beach, Mendihuaca, Santa Marta D.T.C.H. The turtles
were tagged and monitored for 6 months with Wildlife Computers SPOT 5 AM – S 206 D satellite devices,
and their movements were related with ocean currents. During the study, Colombianita traveled 4240 km
(mostly in oceanic areas) passing through the continental shelves of Colombia, Panama, Costa Rica and
Belize. Colombianita stayed in coastal waters only in the Rosario Islands and San Bernardo National Park
for about 55 days. While overlapping this turtle’s route with the paths described by oceanographic drifters
in the Caribbean (National Oceanographic Partnership Program - NOPP) it was clear that surface currents
played an important role in the direction of the route. However currents were not entirely responsible for
the path of the turtle because it had the ability to enter and leave the currents. Tuggy made a short trip (90
km), compared to Colombianita's journey, passing Cinto, Gayraca and Concha Bay in Tayrona National
Park. After two months, Tuggy was found entangled in a gillnet by a fisherman in Gairaca Bay and so
bycatch remains a major source of mortality of these turtles. The results obtained indicated that turtles from
the head - start process have a positive coupling to the natural environment and behave in a similar way to
that reported for wild specimens. This confirms that head-starting procedures are a viable alternative for the
conservation of sea turtles.
126
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEASONAL VARIABILITY OF MIGRATING CORRIDORS AND FORAGING AREAS OF
ADULTS GREEN TURTLES REVEALED BY SATELLITE TRACKING AT THE REGIONAL
SCALE
Jérôme Bourjea1, Mayeul Dalleau2, and Stéphane Ciccione3
1
IFREMER, DOI
Université de La Réunion
3
KELONIA
2
Marine turtles do not recognize political boundaries, nor do they have regard for Exclusive Economic
Zones (EEZ s), cooperative agreements, international conventions, or memoranda of understanding
between countries. So is it in the Southwest Indian Ocean (SWIO), a region that hosts some of the most
important green turtle nesting sites in the world, most of which are isolated on remote islands (e.g. Europa
and Glorieuses, Aldabra and Cosmoledo, Moheli and Mayotte). This region of the world is known to have
year round nesting of green turtles but all sites display a marked nesting season. However, very little is
known about migratory pathways that sea turtles ply between their nesting and feeding grounds in this
region where this species faces numerous threats such as fisheries interaction at both open sea and coastal
waters. From 2009 to 2011, we deployed 90 satellite transmitters on nesting green turtle females during (d)
and opposite (o) to the nesting peak in 5 important rookeries of the South West Indian Ocean (SWIO):
Europa (Nd=10; No=10), Glorieuses (Nd= 10; No=10), Tromelin (Nd= 10; No=10), Mayotte (Nd=10;
No=10) and Mohéli (Nd=7; No=3). First results showed that 20% of the tracked turtles used Madagascar
costal foraging ground while more than 80% used the east African ones. It is worthwhile noting that the
North Mozambique and South Tanzania remain the most important foraging ground for the tracked turtle
(45% of the tracked turtles), but that they are mainly used by turtles tagged during the nesting season. On
the other hand, we highlight here that green turtles also use a large range of foraging ground in the area
(55% of the tagged turtles), some of them being hot spots (e.g. south of Maputo – Mozambique, Tulear
lagoon – Madagascar) and being used mainly by turtle nesting opposite to the nesting peak. Spatial
distribution estimation allowed identifying an important year round migrating corridor centered along the
latitude 12°S and that extends westward from Tromelin until the east African coast. The corridor covers 5°
in latitude (10 to 15°S) in open waters, while it covers a larger area in coastal area (from 18°S to 7°S). The
90 tracked green turtles also crossed as many as nine different EEZs in the region before reaching their
foraging grounds, which themselves are shared by six countries. Such spatial migrating pattern of adult
green turtle, the temporal corridors and the regional feeding hot spots identified are of high importance to
implement targeted mitigating measures for artisanal and industrial fisheries and encourage conservation on
key foraging grounds.
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTIONS OF SEA TURTLES WITHIN THE FLORIDA
CURRENT AND SURROUNDING WATERS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR OCEANIC
ENERGY DEVELOPMENT
Caitlin M. Bovery and Jeanette Wyneken
Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
The spatial and temporal distributions of a species are essential to identifying its basic habitats, including
areas used during large-scale movements and seasonal changes in behavior. For marine turtles, such basic
information is often limited to satellite tag data, which can be heavily biased to adult females, or to coastal
127
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
observation. In species that undergo oceanic habitat shifts through various life stages, such information is
often incomplete. We conducted aerial surveys of the Florida Current between the southeast coast of
Florida and the Bahamas banks to establish when and where sea turtles occur in this fast-moving
component of the Gulfstream. Twelve line transects were flown approximately monthly during 2011-12
from a northern boundary near West Palm Beach, Florida to a southern boundary near Miami, Florida.
Surveys were conducted at an altitude of 150 m and ground speed of 185 km hr-1. Loggerhead (Caretta
caretta) and green (Chelonia mydas) turtles were the most frequently detected species. Leatherback
(Dermochelys coriacea), Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys kempii) and other sea turtles not identified to species
were also observed. Percent of turtles not identified to species decreased from 38.0% (2011) to 10.8%
(2012) of total observations. The total number of sea turtle sightings increased from 79 observations (2011)
to 120 (to date, 2012), with consistent survey effort between years. Locations of sea turtle sightings suggest
increased presence of turtles along the western edge of the Florida Current in the spring and early summer
during breeding season. Increased sightings in 2012 were coincident with very high nesting numbers in this
region. Additionally, few to no sightings in offshore regions (20-60nm from shore) suggest turtles seldom
use these waters or are ephemeral in the survey area. Our data expand both our understanding of current use
by migratory turtles and characteristics of their spatial distributions in a central area of interest. The area of
this study encompasses one of many regions under consideration for ocean energy development, including
current-capture technologies which have the theoretical potential to interact with migratory turtles. The
value of collecting robust assessments of sea turtle distributions cannot be overstated as they provide the
foundation on which conservation strategies will be based. Such data provide the necessary perspectives for
assessing possible threats as development and utilization of oceanic energy resources continue to grow.
A PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE SPATIAL DYNAMICS OF IMMATURE GREEN
TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) WITHIN A FORAGING GROUND ON THE ATLANTIC
COAST OF ELEUTHERA, THE BAHAMAS
Annabelle M. Brooks1, Marie E. Tarnowski1, Alan B. Bolten2, and Karen A. Bjorndal2
1
2
Cape Eleuthera Institute, Eleuthera, Bahamas
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research, Florida, USA
Shallow water, neritic habitats such as mangrove creeks and sea grass beds, serve as critical developmental
and foraging habitat for juvenile and sub-adult sea turtles. Tagging studies have elucidated long term use of
foraging areas and site fidelity, but very little research has been conducted on the short term movements
and habitat partitioning of turtles within foraging habitats. This information is vital for effective
management of sea turtle populations throughout their early life stages as harvest or other anthropogenic
disturbances could reduce the reproductive potential of the entire population. This study investigated the
spatial dynamics of immature green turtles (Chelonia mydas) at foraging grounds on the east coast of the
island of Eleuthera, The Bahamas. Half Sound is a large (~3 km2) previously un-studied, semi-enclosed
embayment which encompasses mangroves, rocky shoreline, seagrass beds, and sand flats in depths
ranging from 0 – 3m. A narrow channel (~175m wide) connects this diverse mosaic of habitats to the
Atlantic ocean. Mangrove and reef-associated fish and sharks are also known to utilise the sound.
Standardised, boat-based, visual surveys were conducted to determine estimates of abundance throughout
the sound. Turtles were captured, measured, weighed and tagged to determine movements and habitat use
within the sound, in addition to facilitating population size, growth and survivorship estimates. Data
collection is ongoing through December 2012 and additional surveys will elucidate movements, habitat
association, and size-based dispersal of individuals within the sound. Identifying these fine-scale patterns
within foraging grounds will contribute to a better understanding of habitat and resource use within discrete
populations of foraging sea turtles.
128
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
POWER ANALYSIS USING PROGRAM SOFTWARE MONITOR GREATLY INFORMS
EFFECTIVENESS OF MONITORING MARINE TURTLES IN NERITIC HABITATS
Lucie S. Brown1, Annabelle Brooks2, Dave Hodgson1, Marie Tarnowski2, and Brendan J. Godley1
1
University of Exeter, Centre for Ecology & Conservation, School of Life and Environmental Sciences,
Cornwall Campus
2
The Cape Eleuthera Institute, Eleuthera, Bahamas
The establishment of a sea turtle research and monitoring program at The Cape Eleuthera Institute (CEI),
south Eleuthera, the Bahamas, facilitated preliminary research into the distribution and abundance of sea
turtles in the coastal waters of Eleuthera. In-water surveys and turtle captures were conducted to determine
relative abundance and size distribution of green turtles in eight survey sites distributed across the three
sides of south Eleuthera; the Great Bahama Banks (west), the Exuma Sound (south), and the Atlantic side
(east). Size distribution of green turtles indicated juvenile to sub-adult life stages, which is in keeping with
aggregations reported in the wider Caribbean region. Abundance was significantly higher on the Atlantic
side of the island, and tidal mangrove creeks on the south and west side also provided key foraging and
developmental habitats for juvenile greens. Future survey effort required to accurately detect population
trends was calculated using the abundance data from in-water surveys and the simulation software
MONITOR. Simulations revealed that detection of trends at individual survey sites requires impractical
survey effort; however when survey sites were combined into one network, a 10% trend could be detected
with monthly surveys over a four year period. Recommendations for a future monitoring program are made
with consideration of the accurate detectability of population trends.
TOP-DOWN CONTROL IN A RELATIVELY PRISTINE SEAGRASS ECOSYSTEM
Derek Burkholder1, Michael Heithaus1, James Fourqurean1, Aaron Wirsing2, and Larry Dill3
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Marine Sciences Program, Florida International University, North
Miami, FL, USA
2
School of Environmental and Forest Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
3
Evolutionary and Behavioural Ecology Research Group, Department of Biological Sciences, Simon
Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada
Coastal marine ecosystems have degraded dramatically worldwide and continue to be threatened. Seagrass
ecosystems that provide critical habitat for juveniles of many species, including commercially important
ones, have been particularly hard-hit. Of particular interest is the loss of large herbivores (e.g. sea turtles
and sirenians) and top predators (e.g. sharks), which may have disrupted top-down processes that were
historically important. We used exclusion cages to elucidate the effects of large herbivores (green sea
turtles (Chelonia mydas) and dugongs (Dugong dugon) on seagrass community structure, nutrient dynamics,
and ecosystem dynamics in the relatively pristine seagrass ecosystem of Shark Bay, Western Australia. We
also investigated the possible indirect effect of top predators (tiger sharks (Galeocerdo cuvier) on seagrass
beds) mediated by spatiotemporal shifts in grazing by green turtles and dugongs. Excluding large grazers
from mixed beds of Halodule uninervis, Cymodocea angustata, and Halophila ovalis for thirty-two months
resulted in a shift in seagrass community composition, increased shoot lengths in all species and increased
total seagrass biomass. However, seagrass responses to exclusion were species-specific. There were
increases in percent cover and shoot density for Cymodocea angustata but a decrease in cover and density
for both Halodule uninervis and Halophila ovalis. Overall, our findings suggest that spatiotemporal shifts
129
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
in foraging habitat use by megagrazers may mediate indirect effects of tiger sharks on the seagrass
communities of Shark Bay and that declines in these taxa in other parts of their range are likely to result in
changes to seagrass communities.
ROTTEN LUCK: USING NON-VIABLE LOGGERHEAD EGGS TO INFER FEEDING
GROUNDS ALONG FLORIDA’S EAST COAST*
Simona A. Ceriani1, James D. Roth2, John F. Weishampel1, Daniel R. Evans3, and Llewellyn M.
Ehrhart1
1
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada
3
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Gainesville, Florida, USA
2
In recent years, there has been growing interest in using stable isotopes as a tool to study migratory
connectivity and identify foraging areas of marine turtles. Sampling on the nesting beach is relatively easy
as the turtles are accessible to researchers. Recently, using a combination of satellite telemetry and stable
isotope analysis, we demonstrated that red blood cells (RBC) can be used to assign foraging areas of
loggerhead nesting at the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge (ACNWR), Florida. Florida hosts ~90% of
all the loggerhead nesting activity in the SE USA, yet few research groups encounter nesting females at
night. In contrast, thousands of nests are marked to assess hatchling production through an extensive
nesting survey program in Florida. Although precise turnover rates are unknown for adult sea turtle tissues,
skin, RBC and egg-yolk isotopic values from nesting turtles appear to represent an integration of diet and
geographic location over the 4-7 months prior to migrating to the nesting area. Thus, these tissue types have
been used to unravel migratory connectivity. Collecting blood or skin samples requires intensive night
patrolling and trained personnel, while collecting a fresh-laid egg poses ethical questions related to
sacrificing a potentially viable egg. However, a non-viable (addled) egg retrieved at post-hatching
excavation might be used as a proxy to infer foraging grounds of loggerheads. To test the usefulness of
addled eggs, we collected one fresh laid egg and one unhatched egg at inventory from each nest laid by
loggerheads equipped with satellite tags (n=26) and un-hatched eggs from additional females sampled
(n=150) at the ACNWR between 2008 and 2012. We used telemetry to validate the use of both tissues to
infer non-breeding ground locations. Fresh-yolk isotopic signatures and telemetry-derived foraging
locations yielded similar patterns, with no isotopic differences between fresh-yolk and addled eggs
collected from the same nest at inventory. Isotopic relationships for both δ13C and δ15N among RBC,
fresh-yolk and addled eggs reflect similar resource use at similar timescales. As seen with RBC, females
from the three foraging areas (identified by telemetry) segregated by the isotopic signatures of their eggs.
Our results suggest that it should be possible to use addled eggs to assign females to foraging grounds,
providing an opportunity to (1) sample at a much larger scale, fostering collaborations among research
groups, (2) obtain information that is more representative at the population level and (3) begin
understanding the relative importance of foraging areas. Acknowledgments: Thank you to the International
Sea Turtle Symposium and the following organizations, International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle
Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America for supporting the
attendance of SA Ceriani to the Symposium.
130
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
WHAT’S THE SKINNY? TESTING WHETHER SHOULDER AND REAR FLIPPER SKIN
PROVIDE THE SAME ISOTOPIC INFORMATION
Simona A. Ceriani, Ryan M. Chabot, Fernanda B. Gusmão, Ciro M. Amato, and Llewellyn M.
Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Innovations in genetics and stable isotope analysis (SIA) have helped unravel migratory connectivity in
marine turtles. The collection of tissue samples for genetic analysis is commonplace and has become
routine in several research programs. Since both techniques require very small amounts of tissue, splitting
samples between genetic and isotopic applications may allow researchers to address multiple questions or
similar questions using complementary techniques, thereby maximizing the information obtained from each
sample collected. Currently the protocols used for genetics studies and SIA differ slightly; thus, there is a
need to investigate whether samples collected can be shared. Standardized protocols for stable isotope
sampling include collecting skin from the shoulder area, while tissue for genetics is usually collected either
from the trailing edge of the rear flipper or the shoulder area. Though genetic information is maintained
regardless of anatomical sampling location, to our knowledge, no researcher has tested whether epidermis
isotopic values are consistent between anatomical positions. In 2012, we collected shoulder and rear flipper
skin samples from 25 loggerheads (Caretta caretta) with SCL>65 cm and compared epidermis isotopic
values collected at these two sites. Whereas the δ15N values did not differ between sampling locations, the
δ13C values were significantly higher in samples from the shoulder than from the flipper, contrary to our
predictions. To test whether consistency in sampling procedure affected this result, as rear flipper samples
could contain both scale and epidermis tissues, we sampled an additional 30 nesting loggerheads. Rear
flipper sampling locations were chosen with care, insuring that collected skin samples were from the fleshy
part of the trailing edge. As seen before, the δ15N values did not differ, but our δ13C results were
equivocal. We suggest caution when combining skin samples collected from these two sites for SIA, as
care needs to be taken when sampling from the rear flipper to obtain isotopic results that are comparable to
shoulder skin samples. However, our results suggest it may be possible to foster collaboration between
geneticists and isotope biologists and dramatically increase the sample size of turtles included in stable
isotope studies. Special thanks to the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of
Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America, and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for their
continued, generous support.
GOLFO DULCE TROPICAL FJORD A SPECIAL SITE FOR GREEN AND HAWKSBILL
FEEDING GROUND
Didiher Chacón-Chaverri, Didiher A. Chacón-Vargas, and David Rojas-Morales
WIDECAST -Costa Rica
The project was developed since 2010 in the inner zone of the Golfo Dulce, Costa Rica South Pacific. In
this area was established by the National Fisheries Institute (INCOPESCA) as a responsible fishing area,
given the interaction of baitfish fishery and sea turtles, as well as the destruction of mangrove forests and
the deteriorating physicochemical water by agriculture and coastal development. The objective of the
research was to document the population structure of the green turtle (Chelonia mydas agassizii) and
hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata), and the magnitude and significance of environmental impacts.
131
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Information was collected biometric and-blood tissue samples of each organism captured, documented the
abundance determination with CPUE and developed habitat restoration activities in the mangrove forest.
More than 150 green turtles and 50 hawksbill turtles were sampled and tagged, including two satellite tags
were deployed in two years of activities, biometrics and sex ratio was determined as well as more than
5000 plants were planted mangroves.
PLASTICITY OF THE DIVING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES IN
DIFFERENT HABITATS
I-Jiunn Cheng1 and Wan-hwa Cheng2
1
2
Institute of Marine Biology, National Taiwan Ocean University, Keelung, Taiwan, ROC
Department of Biology, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Animals change their behaviors in different habitats in order to maximize fitness and increase survivorship.
Sea turtles have been known to change their depth utilization in different water mass. It has been suggested
that this relates to prey distribution. However, little is known about the differences in dive patterns between
two distinct habitats, such as the coast and open ocean. Two immature loggerhead sea turtles, one caught in
a pound net and one cold-stunned and rehabilitated) were satellite tracked with SRDLs to determine their
preferred marine habitats and dive behaviors. The turtle that was caught in a pound net was tagged on
December 31, 2011, and the rehabilitated turtle was tagged on June 28, 2012. Results showed that the netcaught turtle forged mainly on the continental shelf east of mainland China, while the rehabilitated turtle
resided in the nearshore waters north and northeast of Taiwan. Dive analyses showed that the net-caught
turtle performed mainly S dives and other types of dives on the continental shelf. The rehabilitated turtle
performed mainly U and S dives in the coastal waters. This suggested that both turtles used energyconserved S dives to move in both waters. However, they performed different dive patterns to explore
different habitats. The turtle on the continental shelf conducted more than one dive type. This included
exploring new foraging areas and opportunistic feeding behaviors. The turtle in the coastal waters
conducted the lengthened bottom residential U dive. This suggests that the loggerhead turtles either forage
or rest along the rocky coasts of north and northeastern Taiwan. This is the first study ever done to
determine the diving behavior of coastal residential loggerhead sea turtles in Taiwan.
LONG-TERM MARINE TURTLE POPULATION AND FIBROPAPILLOMATOSIS TRENDS IN
THE INDIAN RIVER LAGOON SYSTEM, FLORIDA
Kendra Cope, William Redfoot, Dean Bagley, and Llewellyn Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
The Indian River Lagoon system serves as an important developmental habitat for immature green turtles
(Chelonia mydas) and loggerheads (Caretta caretta). For the past 30 years the University of Central Florida
Marine Turtle Research Group has been documenting population trends in this habitat. This is
accomplished by deploying a 430 m large-mesh tangle net and removing the turtles almost immediately
after they become entangled in the net. Each individual is then measured, tagged, photographed, and
examined for Fibropapillomatosis (FP). Since 1982 this in-water population sampling process has been
done a minimum of twice per month, with greater sampling intensity in the summer months. The number of
turtles caught during the entire period of net soak allows us to calculate the catch per unit effort (CPUE).
132
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Using these long-term data we have found significant seasonal variation in green turtle abundance and
population structure, with capture rates being higher in the winter months and lower in the summer months.
However, loggerheads do not share this seasonal variation characteristic in capture rates. Mean straight
carapace length (SCL) of green turtles is 43.95 cm with a range of 22.0-106.1 cm while loggerhead mean
SCL is 65.62 cm with a range of 41.5-106.0 cm. The size distribution confirms this aggregation is
composed mostly of immature individuals. This means the turtles are not permanent residents in the lagoon,
but instead are occupants during an important life history stage. Frequency of captures with FP has
remained relatively constant throughout the study period, remaining at approximately 52.2% prevalence in
green turtles. It is rarely presented in loggerheads (approximately 5.1%). This long-term FP data set can be
useful for current and future research regarding the causes and prevalence of FP in marine turtles in the
lagoon, and even in other locations such as Hawaii, USA. Long-term population monitoring of in-water
populations, like this one, is important for obtaining a better understanding of how the population is
functioning. Many researchers spend about 99% of their time collecting data on nesting beaches, but only
1% of their time collecting data in-water. Population trends found in the in-water data set can be compared
to disasters, pollution changes, in-water policy enforcement, and even large-scale events like climate
change. The increasing trend in lagoon green turtle captures, in conjunction with the observed exponential
increase in green turtle nest production on the adjacent nesting beach (Archie Carr National Wildlife
Refuge), suggests that the species is on the road to recovery. Unlike the green turtle, immature loggerheads
have not seen any significant change in CPUE during the 30-year study period. These data suggest that the
Florida loggerhead population is more stable than previously believed. Acknowledgments: I want to thank
everyone who donated funds for the travel grants that were awarded. Receiving this travel grant allowed me
to attend and present at my first conference. I am very excited to meet other members of the sea turtle
community as well as gain important knowledge for future presentations and my career.
CATCHING MALE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) NEAR ISLA DE AVES,
VENEZUELA
Marco G. Cruz1, Javier Medina1, Verónica de los Llanos1, Robert P. van Dam2, Margarita Lampo1,
Jesús Mavárez1, and Kathryn Rodríguez-Clark1
1
2
Centro de Ecología, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Científicas, Caracas, Venezuela
Chelonia Inc, San Juan, PR
Understanding the reproductive patterns of male green turtles (Chelonia mydas) is of interest for clarifying
population structure in this endangered species, but studying adult males in mating areas has proven
difficult because they are not easy to observe and capture. Isla de Aves (Venezuela) is unusual among C.
mydas nesting populations in the Caribbean because of the large concentration of adult males that
congregate in shallow waters just offshore to court and mate with adult females. Our goal was to develop a
reliable and minimally stressful technique for capturing these males, and to compare their sizes with males
from other areas since females from Isla de Aves are larger than females from many other nesting
populations. We conducted four field sessions to capture, measure and mark males: June and July 2008,
September and October 2009, July and August 2010 and June and July 2012. The first and last of these
sessions occurred during peak reproductive activity. We tested three capture methods: 1) using nets set
from shore and from a buoy anchored in 4-5 m deep waters; 2) by hand, in a nearshore area less than 1m
deep; and 3) by hand, with free diving to 5-20 m. Recorded measurements included curved carapace length
(CCL), curved carapace width (CCW), and tail length (TLC). We captured 93 males and recaptured six of
these in subsequent years. Estimates of capture per unit effort (CPUE) indicated that hand capture at greater
depths was the most efficient (CPUE = 1.5 turtles/person-hours), followed by hand capture in nearshore
waters (0.53 t/p-h), with net capture the least efficient (0.10 t/p-h). These results are probably due to the
high concentration of turtles in intermediate depths during the reproductive season. Isla de Aves males
were larger than males from other regions, with an average CCL of 105.2 cm (SD: 4.8; range 92-116.7), a
CCW of 96.3 cm (95% CI 86-106.1), and tail length of 53.0 cm (95% CI 44.1-63.9). The larger size of
133
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
these animals may be due to the high quality of their feeding grounds (the location of which remain
unknown) and/or because the adult males here are older than in other areas where males have been caught.
TRANS-EQUATORIAL MOVEMENTS OF LATE JUVENILE INDIVIDUALS CHALLENGE
THE UNDERSTANDING OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE (CARETTA CARETTA) LIFE HISTORY
IN THE INDIAN OCEAN*
Mayeul Dalleau1, Stéphane Ciccione2, Marie Lauret-Stepler2, and Jérôme Bourjea3
1
University of Reunion Island, Reunion Island, France
Kélonia, Reunion Island, France
3
Ifremer - Délégation de la Réunion, Reunion Island, France
2
The loggerhead turtle, Caretta caretta, is the main species of marine turtle accidentally caught by drifting
longline vessels operating in the South West Indian Ocean. Since 2006, in collaboration with longline
vessels from Reunion island (-21°09’S; 55°30’E), captured individuals are brought to the Kélonia sea turtle
care center to be treated and released. Between 2008 and 2011, we conducted a satellite tracking study on
these by-caught turtles to improve knowledge on open sea spatial and diving behaviors of this species in the
region in order to mitigate the risks of interaction with fisheries. Eighteen late juvenile individuals (mean
CCL: 67.7 cm; SD = 5.4 cm) were equipped with satellite transmitters and released in Reunion island
coastal waters. Fourteen of these transmitters also permitted us to compute animal diving profiles. The
deployment period lasted between 20 and 310 days. Turtles exhibited various spatial behaviors, either
remaining oceanic or heading to coastal waters. They surprisingly covered a large latitudinal range across
both hemispheres from the 40th parallel south to the 20th parallel North, sometimes swimming more than
4,000 km away from the release point. A majority of the tracked turtles (n = 11) swam northward, while
another group of individuals (n = 4) went south. The swimming direction for each group did not
significantly differ from the main northern and the main southern rookery respectively located in Oman
(20°N) and at the border between South-Africa and Mozambique (29°S). The other turtles (n = 3) remained
in the vicinity of Reunion Island. Ultimately, five individuals stopped transmitting less than 1,000 km from
Masirah Island (Omanese rookery), probably the largest nesting population of loggerhead turtles in the
world. This suggests that turtles from the Omanese rookeries may frequent waters from the southern
hemisphere during their developmental cycle. An ongoing regional genetic study should confirm this
surprising result. This constitutes a new advance towards the understanding of loggerhead turtle life history
in the Indian Ocean. Regarding diving behavior, three types of dives have been identified: short subsurface
dives (<30 m, <800 s) accounted for 79% of the total number of dives, long subsurface dives (<30 m, >800
s) for 15% and deep dives (>30 m) for 6%. Maximum diving depth occasionally exceeded 200 m. Data
analysis showed varying patterns between diurnal and nocturnal diving behavior. During the day, a greater
number of dives occurred subsurface (0-10 m) while turtles exhibited slightly deeper dives (10-30 m)
during the night. It is worthwhile noting that diving behavior is also dependent on spatial movement with
turtles in transit diving significantly deeper than turtles in residency. Such behavioral changes may possibly
be explained by the availability of prey according to the spatial movement pattern of individuals. Despite
the great attention given to loggerhead turtles worldwide, our study is one of the first tracking programs on
this species at juvenile stage in this part of the world. In addition to ongoing conservation actions with
fishermen at the local scale, understanding life history of loggerhead turtle in the Indian Ocean is also
required for appropriate regional conservation planning.
134
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TRACKING NESTING HAWKSBILLS “CHEL” AND “GINGER” FROM THE BAY ISLANDS,
HONDURAS
Lindsey E. Damazo1 and Stephen G. Dunbar2
1
Marine Research Group, Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma
Linda, CA, USA
2
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research, Inc. (ProTECTOR), Colton, CA,
USA
The ability to track animal movements can give vital insights into important aspects of life history. Satellite
telemetry has been a key to broadening our understanding of the migration patterns of nesting sea turtles. In
this study, we attached Wildlife Computer Spot 5 satellite tags onto two nesting hawksbill sea turtles on the
Bay Island of Utila, Honduras. One satellite tag was launched August 12, 2012 on a turtle named “Ginger”.
Ginger left Utila the following day and set off in a northwest direction, navigating through the islands off
the coast of Belize and halting her northward migration about 10 km off the coast, just south of Belize City
and approximately 15 km south of the Drowned Cayes. She traveled a straight-line distance of 181 km and
covered a total distance of 325 km over 19 days, maintaining an average speed of 17 km/day. The other
satellite tag was attached to a turtle named “Chel” and was launched on July 12, 2012. Chel spent 10 days
in the waters off Utila and then also moved northwest toward Belize, hugging the coast of the Yucatan
Peninsula, and finally reaching her feeding grounds just south of Cozumel, Mexico. Over a period of 90
days, Chel traveled a straight-line distance of 402 km, with a total distance traveled of 1,060 km. Her
average traveling speed was 15 km/day. This turtle has now spent approximately 65 days in the Bahia de la
Ascension, a large bay that is bordered on several sides by the Reserva de la Biosfera Sian-Ka’an in the
state of Quintana Roo, Mexico. These types of data from hawksbill turtles are particularly lacking for
turtles found in the waters of Honduras. Continued transmittance from these and other satellite tagged
turtles will provide information that will strengthen conservation efforts for the species both locally and
internationally.
DIET ANALYSIS OF STRANDED LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES IN VIRGINIA, 2011
Shannon J. Davis1, Kristen M. Phillips1, Erin E. Seney2, and Susan G. Barco1
1
The Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center Stranding Response Program, Virginia Beach, VA,
USA
2
Erin Seney Consulting, LLC, Woodbridge, VA, USA
The Chesapeake Bay provides important seasonal foraging grounds for juvenile loggerhead sea turtles
(Caretta caretta). Historical analyses of stranded loggerheads in Virginia indicated a diet primarily
composed of horseshoe crab, blue crab, and other decapod crustaceans. Recent studies indicated a diet shift
to include a larger portion of fish. To better understand the foraging ecology of loggerheads in the
Chesapeake Bay and surrounding ocean waters, the Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center Stranding
Response Program (VAQS) analyzed the gastrointestinal (GI) contents of 43 loggerheads that stranded in
Virginia in 2011. The loggerheads ranged in size from 49.8 cm to 97.5 cm straight carapace length (SCL,
mean: 73.1 cm, SD: 13.8 cm). Prey items were identified to the lowest taxonomic level and minimum
counts were estimated for each prey type based on methods previously used to examine Virginia samples
from 1983-2002. Each food item was categorized as crustacean, fish, horseshoe crab, mollusc, plant, or
other invertebrate. The ‘fish’ category included bony fish and elasmobranchs. Three non-prey categories
135
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
were documented but excluded from the analyses: anthropogenic items (n=2), parasites (n=36), and nonprey organic matter (n=30). Percent numbers (%N, number of specific prey type/total number of prey
items) and percent frequency of occurrence (%F, number of GI tracts containing a prey type/total number
of GI tracts examined) were calculated. VAQS documented and analyzed a total of 755 prey items from the
43 GI tracts. These were comprised of 41% (n=308) crustaceans, 38% (n=290) molluscs, 10% (n=73)
horseshoe crabs (Limulus polyphemus), 6% (n=43) other invertebrates, 4% (n=29) fish, and 1% (n=12)
plants. Large whelks and Atlantic moon snails (Neverita duplicata) comprised 63% (n=183) of the mollusc
group. Atlantic blue crabs (Callinectes sapidus) were the most abundant crustacean found in the GI tracts,
comprising 45% (n=137) of the crustaceans. Identified species of fish and elasmobranchs were: Atlantic
croaker (Micropogonias undulatus, n=7), Atlantic menhaden (Brevoortia tyrannus, n=6), bluefish
(Pomatomus saltatrix, n=1), and spotted sea trout (Cynoscion nebulosus, n=1). Eighty-four percent of the
examined GI tracts contained crustaceans, 51% contained horseshoe crabs, and 23% contained fish, which
could indicate that loggerhead diets have shifted again. The frequency of occurrence of the remaining prey
groups were: 63% molluscs, 23% plants, and 54% other invertebrates. VAQS will continue analyses of the
GI contents of loggerheads in Virginia from 2008-2011, including measuring weights of each prey type,
calculating index of relative importance for each group, and examining trends over time. These analyses
will be coupled with stable isotope analyses to further investigate loggerhead diet and with examinations of
sea turtle-human interaction in the Chesapeake Bay. Results of these studies can and should be used by
resource managers to improve conservation management plans for sea turtles in the Chesapeake Bay region.
THE U.S. NAVY MARINE SPECIES DENSITY DATABASE: CURRENT STATUS AND
IMPROVEMENTS OF IN-WATER DENSITY ESTIMATES OF MARINE TURTLES AND
MAMMALS
Andrew DiMatteo1, Anurag Kumar1, Bryan Wallace2, and Patrick Halpin3
1
Naval Facilities Engineering Command Atlantic, Norfolk, VA, USA
Division of Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University
Marine Laboratory, Beaufort, NC, USA and Marine Flagship Species Program, Oceanic Society,
Washington, DC, USA
3
Marine Geospatial Ecology Laboratory, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University Marine
Laboratory, Beaufort, NC, USA
2
The Navy Marine Species Density Database (NMSDD) is a collection of GIS-based, in-water density data
for marine turtles and mammals compiled from numerous peer reviewed and federal agency models and
sources. The result is one master set of season specific density data that covers several of the Navy’s
operating areas globally, and that are used in the Navy Acoustic Effects Model (NAEMO) for acoustic
impact assessment modeling. The combination of NMSDD and NAEMO allows the Navy to use the best
available science to determine how many marine turtles and mammals may be affected by its training and
testing activities that put sound into the water. Currently, marine turtle density data in the Atlantic exists
only within less than 100 nm of the US East Coast and Gulf of Mexico Coast. Unfortunately, some data
gaps occur near shorelines, bays, and ports where the Navy operates, and offshore beyond the coverage of
aerial surveys. The data currently included for estimating sea turtle density within the U.S. EEZ is from
1998-2005, and only provides coverage out to the shelf break, not the entire EEZ. New surveys have been
flown in recent years which have included additional inshore and offshore areas, including the Atlantic
Marine Assessment Program for Protected Species (AMAPPS) project of which the Navy is a co-sponsor.
As new data and methods become available, the use of predictive modeling is becoming worthy of being
revisited to generate new density estimates for future environmental assessments. Effort is underway to
develop predictive models beyond survey coverage, and the groundwork is now being laid for an effort to
update the marine turtle density data and models by ensuring ongoing data collection for sea turtles. The
new model will seek ways to incorporate data beyond ship track and aerial survey data, such as bycatch
records, satellite telemetry, and remote sensing of habitat. In addition, thought is being given to generating
136
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
better estimates of g(0) for sea turtles, which directly affects modeled densities, and to assess the
detectability of different age/size classes as an input into density models. Here, we discuss the current state
and uses of the NMSDD, as well as the efforts underway to improve it.
DO HATCHLING SWIMMING PATTERNS MATTER WHEN IT COMES TO PREDATION?*
Noemi Duran1 and Stephen G. Dunbar1,2
1
Marine Research Group, Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma
Linda, California, USA. Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research, Inc.
(ProTECTOR), Colton, California, USA
2
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research (ProTECTOR) Honduras,
Tegucigalpa, Honduras
We compared diurnal and nocturnal swimming patterns of recently hatched olive ridley (Lepidochelys
olivacea) neonates from Punta Raton, Honduras. We followed individual hatchlings tethered to a modified
Witherington float by 1.5 m of sewing thread during an average time of 25.4 min (SD ± 4.8), and recorded
the time intervals for swimming at the surface (less than 20 cm of depth) and swimming at depth (more
than 20 cm). Hatchlings were released from a small skiff located 200 - 500 m from the shore in the coastal
waters of the Gulf of Fonseca. We tracked 21 hatchlings during the day and 11 at night. To locate the
hatchlings during night observations, we glued a 1.5 inch chemical glowstick on their carapaces. To ensure
that the presence of the glowstick didn’t affect the swimming pattern, we also glued the glowstick to 8 of
the hatchlings observed during the day. We calculated the percent of time spent swimming at the surface
and compared it among the three groups (day without glowstick n = 13, day with glowstick n = 8, and night
n = 11). We log-transformed the data to improve normality, but one group remained non-normal and the
data remained heteroscedastic. Nevertheless, the results were the same whether subjected to a parametric
one-way ANOVA or non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis one-way ANOVA, therefore we report the parametric
results only. There were significant differences in the percent of time swimming on the surface among the
groups (F(2,29) = 37.998, p < 0.001). Post hoc comparisons using the Bonferroni test indicated that the
percent of time swimming on surface at night was significantly greater than during the day (p < 0.001), but
there was no significant difference between the groups observed during the day, with and without
glowsticks. Differences between day and night swimming patterns during the frenzy period have not
previously been described in the literature. We suggest that this is a characteristic behavior of L. olivacea
that has remained undetected since, although several studies have been performed on hatchling movements
during the first hours of their offshore migration, few have included this species, or that this swimming
pattern is an adaptation for enhancing survival under the local conditions of the Gulf of Fonseca not shown
by hatchlings at other locations. Increased swimming at depth during the day may serve to reduce visibility
of the hatchlings to aerial predators, and may also help them avoid high temperatures in surface waters.
Further research is needed to test these hypotheses and assess the adaptive significance of this behavior.
Acknowledgments: This research has been funded by ProTECTOR and Loma Linda University. I am
especially thankful for the Travel Award granted by the International Sea Turtle Symposium to attend the
2013 meeting, supported by generous donations from the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle
Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America.
137
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PREVALENCE OF OCEANIC FORAGERS AMONG ADULT FEMALE LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES CARETTA CARETTA NESTING IN CAPE VERDE (NORTHWESTERN AFRICA)
Elena Eder1, Alba Ceballos1, Samir Martins2, Héctor Pérez-García2, Isabel Marín1, Adolfo Marco2,
and Luis Cardona1
1
Department of Animal Biology and IRBio, Faculty of Biology, University of Barcelona, Avenida Diagona
643, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
2
Estación Biológica de Doñana-CSIC, c/ Americo Vespucio s/n, 41092 Sevilla, Spain.
Neritic foragers prevail in most of the populations of loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) studied to
date, probably because of the much higher food availability in neritic foraging grounds than in oceanic
habitats. However, previous satellite tracking of a few individuals (n = 10) suggested that oceanic foraging
was prevalent among the adult females in Cape Verde, probably because of the very high oceanic
productivity fuelled by upwelling off northwestern Africa. We used stable isotopes in bone to assess the
actual proportion of neritic and oceanic females in this population, using the ratios of stable isotopes of
marine mammals with well known habitat preferences as a benchmark. Carapace length, clutch size and
egg volume were used to assess differences in turtle fitness and skeletochronology to assess age. Stable
isotope ratios confirmed that the adult female population in Cape Verde is dominated by oceanic foragers,
as 63 of the analyzed adult females grouped with oceanic minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) in a
cluster analysis based on stable isotope ratios, whereas the remaining nine adult females grouped with
coastal monk seals (Monachus monachus). The resulting proportion of oceanic (87.5%) and neritic foragers
(12.5%) in the sample did not depart significantly from that expected if turtles settled opportunistically
between the archipelago and mainland Africa at the end of their developmental migration (Chi-square =
0.23, df = 1, p = 0.630), without any preference for the continental shelf. However, settlement on oceanic
feeding grounds had a cost for females, as adult neritic foragers had a higher fitness, as revealed by larger
curved carapace length (neritic range 87 - 100 cm vs. oceanic range 74 - 101.5 cm, U9,59 = 15.0, p <
0.001) and clutch volume (4188.9 ± 475.2 cm3 for neritic turtles vs. 2906.9 ± 502.4 cm3 for oceanic turtles,
U9,59 = 15.5, p < 0.001). Furthermore, neritic turtles were older than adult oceanic foragers, (14 to 62 lines
of arrested growth for neritic turtles vs. 7 to 31 lines of arrested growth for oceanic turtles; U9,38 = 91.5, p
= 0.032), thus indicating that some animals shifted from oceanic to neritic habitats with age, probably
because a higher accumulated probability of detecting the African shelf over time. These results are
consistent with the hypothesis that immature loggerhead sea turtles are probably picking suitable foraging
grounds to settle from the sites they have encountered previously during their developmental migration and
these settlement sites may not be optimal simply because turtles do not have knowledge of other better
areas because they have not encountered them during their developmental migration. In the particular case
of loggerhead sea turtles from Cape Verde this is because juveniles drift westward and the most profitable,
neritic feeding grounds are found 500 km east of the archipelago.
138
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DO GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) NESTING IN PRINCIPE ISLAND, WEST AFRICA,
EXHIBIT SIMILAR ISOTOPIC NICHES?
Rogerio L. Ferreira1, Filipe R. Ceia2, Jaime A. Ramos2, Teresa C. Borges3, and Alan B. Bolten4
1
Sea Turtle Commission, Natural Park of Principe, Sao Tome and Principe
Zoology Department, University of Coimbra, Portugal
3
Faculty of Science and Technology, University of Algarve, Portugal
4
Archie Carr Center for sea Turtle Research, University of Florida, Portugal
2
Recent studies with green turtles (Chelonia mydas) have suggested polymorphic foraging strategies and
habitats but information is scarce and inexistent for West African populations. In this work we used
nitrogen and carbon stable isotope ratios (δ15N and δ13C) to test if green turtles nesting in Principe Island,
a recent UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, exhibit distinct isotopic niches. The epidermis of 60 nesting females,
collected on two Príncipe beaches (‘Grande’ and ‘Infante’), were analyzed for stable isotopes and the
minimum curved carapace length (CCL) was measured in each individual. δ15N varied from 7.9 to 17.3‰
(13.6 ± 1.5) while δ13C from -19.4 to -8.6‰ (-17.3 ± 1.8). CCL ranged from 87.0 to 108.0 cm (100.0 ±
5.1; mean ± SD). Even though the large variation in isotopic ratios detected within the population, their
distributions were uni-modal indicating, according to baseline isotope signatures, that foraging grounds are
distributed by the entire Gulf of Guinea region and, to a lesser extent, the adjacent areas. SIBER results
revealed that smaller size class females (< median, 100.8 cm) occupied a much larger isotopic niche (four
times higher) than larger ones. Those differences were not significant (Mann-Whitney U Test) but Levene’s
test indicated a significant difference in the variances of δ15N among the size classes (F = 8.59, df = 58 P <
0.01). Furthermore, the larger females showed “preference” to nest on the ‘Infante’ beach located on an
area with lower human densities. Those differences suggest that mature green turtles may forage or nest
opportunistically on the resources and habitat available, in each of their foraging or nesting ranges, strongly
connected to a risk avoidance behavior.
TROPHIC ECOLOGY OF CHELONIA MYDAS (LINNAEUS, 1758) IN SOUTH COAST OF
BRAZIL: SEASONAL AND INTER-ANNUAL VARIATION OF THE DIET.
Luciana R. Gama1, Liana Rosa2, and Camila Domit3
1
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, Paraná, Brazil.
Universidade Estadual do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
3
Centro de Estudos do Mar/UFPR, Pontal do Paraná, Paraná, Brazil.
2
The green turtle(Chelonia mydas)is the most frequent species in the South-Western Atlantic Ocean (ASO),
using coastal area for feeding and development. Sea turtle’s diet evaluate its relationship with its’ natural
habitat, and also helps detect anthropogenic impact, such as the ingestion of debris. Other studies focusing
the green turtle’s diet identified the most frequent items and records of seasonal and regional variations.
Parana coast is an important preserved marine area of south Brazil, presents habitat diversity for C. mydas
feeding such as shoals, mangrove, rocky shores, seagrass meadows. Juvenile of green turtle are recorded
the whole year on this area and 80 dead stranded specimens have been collected from 2008 to 2012 in order
to identify their consumed items and to evaluate the animal’s diet changes over eight years. Digestive tracts
of the green turtles have been analyzed and the results were compared with a previous research in the
region with animals collected from 2004 to 2008. Measures of individuals curvature carapace length (CCL)
range from 30 to 62 cm (X=39.69cm±6.61), with no great variation seasonally or yearly. Twelve feeding
139
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
items have been found, including six new genders of marine algae (Enteromorpha sp., Pocockiella
papenfuss, Porphyra sp, Cladophora sp., Rhizoclonium sp., Halimeda sp.). The three items with the highest
occurrence frequencies (OF%) were: the green alga Ulva sp. (OF%=35), the seagrass Halodule wrightii
(OF%= 30) and angiosperms (OF%=27.50). The three highest gravimetric frequency (GF%) and
volumetric frequency (VF%) were: H. wrightii (GF%= 59.73; VF%= 55.23), Ulva sp. (GF%=19.40;
VF%=22.11) and Gracillaria dominguensis (GF%=9.09 ;VF%=12.96). H. wrightii had the highest
occurrence frequencies in the early rainy season (ERS) (January to March) - (OF%= 50). The highest H.
wrightii gravimetric and volumetric frequencies were in the early rainy season(GF%=89.11;VF%=92.38)
and in the late dry season (LDS) (October to December) (GF%=90.06; VF%=84.83). The high frequency
values of H. wrightii in ERS and LDS are the result of the growing biomass of seagrass. Costello’s graphic
analysis supports the conclusion that H. wrightii is the C. mydas’ individuals dominant diet item, and in the
absence of it, the green turtle assumes a generalist role, utilizing other available resources. Therefore, the
conservation of this species depends not only on the conservation of the seagrass, but also on its foraging
areas inside the estuary, as C. mydas diet varies according to seasonal availability of the feeding items.
Debris had not been considered part of the turtle’s diet, in spite of being the most frequent item
(OF%=68,75) in the whole sample (n=80) and in every season.
POSSIBLE HYBRIDIZATION BETWEEN EAST PACIFIC GREEN AND OLIVE RIDLEY SEA
TURTLES IN NORTH WEST MEXICO
Catherine E. Hart1, Alan A. Zavala-Norzagaray2, Cesar P. Ley-Quñonez3, Alonso A. Aguirre4, Paula
Aguilar-Claussell5, and F. Alberto Abreu6
1
Doctorado en Ciencias en Biosistemática, Ecología y Manejo de Recursos Naturales y Agrícolas
(BEMARENA), Centro Universitario de la Costa, Universidad de Guadalajara, Puerto Vallarta, Jalisco,
Mexico.
2
CIIDIR-IPN, Unidad Sinaloa, Juan de Dios Bátiz Paredes No. 250, Col. San Joachin, C.P. 81101,
Guasave, Sinaloa, México.
3
Doctorado Regional en Biotecnología, Universidad Autonoma de Sinaloa, Culiacan, Sinaloa, Mexico.
4
Smithsonian-Mason School of Conservation , Front Royal, Virginia, USA
5
CIIDIR-IPN, Unidad Sinaloa, Juan de Dios Bátiz Paredes No. 250, Col. San Joachin, C.P. 81101,
Guasave, Sinaloa, México
6
Unidad Academica Mazatlan, Instituto de Ciencias del Mar y Limnologia (UNAM), Calz. Joel Montes
Camarena s/n, Mazatlan, Sinaloa 82040 MEXICO
The East Pacific green turtle (Chelonia mydas) and the olive ridley turtle (Lepidochelys olivacea) both nest
throughout the Mexican Pacific. Here we present the photographic record of the mating between a male EP
green turtle and a female olive ridley sea turtle in front of the coast of Sinaloa, Mexico. We also present
photographic records of the presence of sea turtle neonates and embryos from the state of Nayarit which
present characteristics from both EP green and olive ridley turtles which we conclude may represent
hybridization between the two species.
140
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
HABITAT-USE OF BREEDING HAWKSBILL TURTLES ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA
TAGGED AT BUCK ISLAND REEF NATIONAL MONUMENT, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS
Kristen M. Hart1, Zandy Hillis-Starr2, Autumn R. Sartain3, Michael S. Cherkiss1, Clayton Pollock2,
and Ian Lundgren2
1
United States Geological Survey, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Davie, Florida, USA
United States National Park Service, Buck Island Reef National Monument, Christiansted, St. Croix, U.S.
Virgin Islands, USA
3
Cherokee Nations Technology Solutions, contracted to the United States Geological Survey, Davie,
Florida, USA
2
Buck Island Reef National Monument (BIRNM) includes one of the most important nesting areas for
federally endangered hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the U.S. The Recovery Plan for
hawksbills in the U.S. Caribbean Sea, Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico identified Buck Island as an
index beach necessary for the recovery of this species in the eastern Caribbean. Since 1987, numbers of
nesting hawksbills have increased from 12-15 per season in early years up to >85 per season in recent years,
resulting in ~400-600 nests per season. Previous telemetry work in the 1990s and early 2000s revealed
general destinations of tagged adult hawksbills that departed protected BIRNM waters and at-sea behavior
of several additional turtles. However, earlier studies were limited in scope due to small sample sizes and
relatively short tracking periods. In 2011, we initiated an interagency 3-year satellite-tracking project on
BIRNM nesting female hawksbills to determine 1) locations of high-use inter-nesting habitat locations with
respect to BIRNM boundaries, and 2) locations of foraging sites. Thus far we have used satellite
transmitters to track the movements of 20 nesting hawksbills (N=9 in 2011; N=11 in 2012). Inter-nesting
habitat was concentrated on the north side of BIRNM, and foraging sites include locations in Puerto Rico,
the British Virgin Islands, Anguilla, Saint Maarten, Saint Kitts and Nevis, the Netherlands Antilles (Saint
Eustatius), and Guadeloupe. Several other turtles had not yet reached their foraging destinations as of 1
October, 2012. These locations reveal previously unknown connections for BIRNM hawksbills, which
presents opportunities for conservation at both local and regional scales.
INTEGRATION OF GUT CONTENT AND STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSIS TO INVESTIGATE
ONTOGENETIC SHIFTS IN DIET AND HABITAT BY JUVENILE GREEN SEA TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS) ALONG THE TEXAS COAST*
Lyndsey N. Howell1, Kimberly J. Reich1, Donna J. Shaver2, and Andre M. Landry, Jr.1
1
2
Texas A & M University, Galveston, Texas, USA
National Park Service, Padre Island National Seashore, Texas, USA
Effective population management of green sea turtles (Chelonia mydas) necessitates understanding the
temporal variation in foraging grounds used by multiple life history stages. The coastal waters of Texas
provide developmental grounds critical to immature green turtles (18–70 cm) foraging in the northwestern
Gulf of Mexico. Stomach contents and stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope values of
successive layers of carapace scute tissue were determined for 114 juvenile green turtles that stranded
during 2007-2010. Green turtles were grouped into 10-cm size class increments to characterize sequential
shifts in their foraging strategy in Texas waters. Mean SCL of turtles from the middle Texas coast (MTC)
was 31.5 cm (Range = 17.6-65.4 cm, n = 63) while that for greens from the lower Texas coast (LTC) was
37.9 cm (Range = 15.5-69.6 cm, n = 51). Results revealed green turtles exhibit multiple ontogenetic shifts
141
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
in diet and habitat upon recruitment to Texas coastal waters. Relative values of stable isotopes in the
newest scute tissue of turtles 15-25 cm SCL suggests recent recruitment to jetty habitat, while other turtles
exhibited depleted δ13C and enriched δ15N values, indicative of oceanic habitat. A diet dominated by
oceanic items such as Sargassum spp., Scyphozoa spp., and plastic debris reinforced the conclusion that
many of these immature greens were recent residents of the oceanic realm. Enriched values of δ13C and
δ15N in the newest scute layers demonstrate most turtles 25-35 cm SCL had recently inhabited jetty
structures, where macroalgae is a dominant forage material. High % IRI diet ranking of seagrasses in 2534.9 cm SCL turtles from the LTC suggests these greens may transition to bay systems at a smaller size
than do MTC turtles that exhibited a high macroalgae % IRI ranking. A definitive shift by turtles >35 cm
SCL to inshore habitat in both the LTC and MTC was complemented by a seagrass dominated diet and the
newest tissue layer enriched in δ13C and depleted in δ15N. This study is the first to incorporate stomach
contents of multiple size classes of green turtles with stable isotope analysis of 13C and 15N in serial layers
of scute. Our findings indicate that when integrated these techniques are especially effective for
characterizing ontogenetic shifts in habitat use and foraging strategy of immature green turtles.
Furthermore our results provided an assessment of the effectiveness of isotope analyses in documenting
diet and habitat shifts. Size-related variation in sea turtle foraging activities in Texas requires unified
management strategies that minimize impacts to juveniles utilizing nearshore, jetty and seagrass habitats.
POST-NESTING MOVEMENTS AND FORAGING GROUND UTILIZATION BY UPPER TEXAS
COAST NESTERS
Christi L. Hughes1,2 and Andre M. Landry, Jr.1
1
Texas A&M University at Galveston, Sea Turtle and Fisheries Ecology Research Laboratory, Galveston,
Texas, USA;
2
Sea Turtle Rescue Program, South Carolina Aquarium, Charleston, SC, USA
Current satellite telemetry data indicate Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys kempii) females utilizing Texas’
nesting beaches engage in directed post-nesting movements paralleling the coastline to neritic foraging
grounds in northern or eastern Gulf of Mexico waters, with heavier concentrations noted between Louisiana
and the Florida Panhandle. However, a paucity of data exists for the small but increasing number of
Kemp’s ridleys recurrently utilizing upper Texas coast (UTC) nesting habitats. Additional satellite
telemetry research on UTC nesters is needed not only to examine nest site fidelity within and between
seasons, but also in support of a recovery task in the Kemp’s ridley recovery plan that mandates the
protection and management of conspecifics in the marine environment, in part via the determination of
migratory pathways between and among foraging grounds and nesting beaches. Between 2007-2009,
Sirtrack KiwiSat 101 platform terminal transmitters were deployed on eight individuals (mean straight
carapace length (SCL)=62.6 cm, SD=2.4 cm) intercepted following clutch deposition on UTC beaches.
Seven of these individuals were captive-reared for approximately the first year of life, including six
Mexico-imprinted headstarted turtles; one ridley was sourced from the wild stock. All females remained in
continental shelf waters for the duration of monitoring, which averaged 422 d (range 26-710 d, SD=194 d).
Internesting periods for seven females were characterized by restricted nearshore movements coincident
with fidelity to upper Texas coast beaches. However, one ridley monitored for 26 d made directed
movements south to coastal waters adjacent to Corpus Christi before returning north to enter Matagorda
Bay, where transmissions ceased. The seven remaining adults established post-nesting residency at fixed
destinations in waters less than 50 m in depth spanning from the UTC to Key West, Florida. Neritic
foraging grounds utilized by numerous females were concentrated near the Mississippi River Delta (N=7)
and the Florida Panhandle (N=2); four ridleys established residency at multiple sites. No seasonal
delineation was apparent between foraging grounds and overwintering areas. While nesting and telemetry
data indicate the UTC is becoming increasingly important to the Kemp’s ridley population, current
regulations do not afford ridleys using associated habitat protections equivalent to those enforced along the
middle and lower Texas coast. In addition, continued proliferation of the Kemp’s ridley population will
142
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
likely result in heavier concentrations of adult females exploiting identified migration corridors and
foraging zones, thus increasing the risk of negative interactions with various commercial, industrial, and
recreational activities. Sustained recovery of the endangered Kemp’s ridley may be facilitated by increased
emphasis on conservation activities to maintain or improve the health and accessibility of known feeding
grounds and migratory corridors in the northern and eastern Gulf of Mexico, particularly locales deemed
critical for adult conspecifics. Acknowledgements: The NOAA Sea Turtle Facility permitted access to
turtles and site resources for satellite tagging. Telemetry research was funded by grants from the Texas
General Land Office, while the South Carolina Aquarium covered all costs associated with this ISTS.
FIRST REPORT OF CHANGES IN δ13C AND δ15N VALUES IN SCUTE FROM AN ADULT
KEMP’S RIDLEY TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS KEMPII) FOLLOWING A DIET SHIFT
Claire E. Iseton and Kimberly J. Reich
Texas A&M University at Galveston, Galveston, Texas, USA
Analysis of δ13C and δ15N isotope values from successive layers of sea turtle scute have provided insight
into ontogenetic shifts, foraging regimes, and habitat use of multiple sea turtle species of different age
classes. Isotope analyses of scute assist in capturing substantial expanses of a turtles’ foraging history as
scute is an inert tissue, produced continuously throughout the life of a turtle. However, there is a paucity of
knowledge regarding the time required for δ13C and δ15N from the assimilated portion of the turtles diet to
be incorporated into their scute. These data are vital to establishing a timeline that will aid in interpretation
of diet and habitat changes as inferred by stable isotopes of δ13C and δ15N. The objective of this study was
to track the shift in δ13C and δ15N isotope values in scute following a diet change. The study was
conducted using scute collected from a captive adult female Kemp’s ridley sea turtle. Scute samples were
collected when the turtle (SCL 66.6 cm, SCW 64.2 cm; n=1) arrived at the NMFS Galveston sea turtle
facility with blunt force trauma to the left posterior margin of her carapace in May 2011. Additional
samples were collected prior to her release in June of 2012 following successful rehabilitation by NMFS
Galveston and Houston Zoo staff. Stable isotope analysis of δ13C and δ15N values in 5 layers of posterior
scute showed no significant change in isotope values one year after a diet change. Isotope values from the
anterior scute samples changed significantly, reflecting the δ13C and δ15N values of the new diet in four of
five layers of scute. These results indicate that the δ13C and δ15N isotope values from the poster and
anterior portions of scute from an adult turtle may be incorporated into the ventral layer at different rates.
To our knowledge, this study provides the first data tracking the shift in isotopic values of δ13C and δ15N
in scute layers of an adult sea turtle following a change in diet.
NEW INSIGHTS FOR SEA TURTLE DISTRIBUTION IN COASTAL WATERS OF JAPAN
INFERRED FROM FISHERMEN SURVEYS
Takashi Ishihara1, Naoki Kamezaki2, Yoshimasa Matsuzawa2, and Asuka Ishizaki3
1
Sea Turtle Association of Japan, Osaka, Japan/ University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
Sea Turtle Association of Japan, Osaka, Japan/ Suma Aqualife Park, Hyogo, Japan
3
Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management Council, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
2
The coastal waters of Japan is one of the major habitats for loggerhead and green turtles in the North
Pacific. Loggerhead turtle nesting activity is concentrated in southern Japan along the Pacific coast,
143
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
whereas green turtle nesting beaches are located primarily in the Ogasawara Islands and Nansei Islands.
Large juvenile loggerhead turtles are distributed along the southern part of the Pacific coast, although their
distribution extends to northern parts of Japan. Foraging habitat of green turtles overlap with that of
loggerhead turtles. To date, information on sea turtle distribution in Japan has been primarily based on
nesting beach monitoring conducted by hundreds of independent researchers and stranding reports from
researchers and citizens, and studies to systematically assess foraging habitat distribution have been limited.
Since 2009, we have conducted informal interviews with fishermen to assess the state of coastal fisheries in
Japan and determine the extent of sea turtle interactions. This study has also resulted in increased
understanding of sea turtle distribution in the coastal waters of Japan, and we present these preliminary
findings here. From 2009 to 2011, a total of 940 fishermen were interviewed at 150 ports across Japan,
excluding Hokkaido, Tohoku, and Nansei Islands. Consistent with previous studies, Kyushu and Ki-i
Peninsula regions were found to have relatively high sea turtle sightings and interactions compared to the
Sea of Japan. Fishermen appear to interact with sea turtles more frequently in areas that directly face the
Pacific and East China Sea, suggesting that loggerhead and green turtle abundance in southern Japan may
be higher in areas facing the Pacific Ocean and East China Sea, whereas very few turtles enter the inland
sea. The lower sea turtle density along the coast of Sea of Japan compared to the Pacific coast may be
attributed to the geographical characteristics of Sea of Japan, which appears more like an inland sea
surrounded by the Japanese archipelago, continental China and the Korean peninsula. We also found an
interesting characteristic in turtle distribution in the Sea of Japan region, where sea turtles were found more
often inside bays, such as Toyama Bay and Wakasa Bay, rather than coastal areas directly facing Sea of
Japan. This is contrary to the Pacific side of Japan. Another interesting finding regarding sea turtle
distribution in bays is that fishermen reported interacting with a handful of loggerhead turtles in Ise Bay
throughout the year and even during the winter. Ise Bay opens to the Pacific, and previous studies along the
Pacific coast near Ise Bay had shown that sea turtle interactions substantially decrease in winter. Similarly
along the Pacific coast, very small number of loggerhead and green turtles are known to enter Osaka Bay
and Seto Inland Sea only during the summer and exit the bay by late fall when SST declines below
approximately 20 degree centigrade. These new insights to sea turtle distribution in coastal areas of Japan
highlight the value of local knowledge fishermen possess, and will encourage further ecological research to
validate the findings.
DETERMINATION OF SEA TURTLE MIGRATION PATHWAY BY SATELLITE
MONITORING SYSTEMS IN THE EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN COAST OF TURKEY
Yakup Kaska1, Eyup Başkale1, Yusuf Katılmıss1, Meryem Tekin2, Çiğdem Fak2, Mücahit Seçme2,
Çisem Sezgin2, Fulvio Mafucci3, Sandra Hochscheid3, and Flegra Bentivegna3
1
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli, Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli, Turkey
3
Stazione Zoologica, Anthon Dohrn, Napoli, Italy
2
Sea turtles in the eastern Mediterranean are isolated from the Atlantic populations and information about
migration patterns of males and females in this region is sparce. The understanding of migration patterns,
distribution, habitat use and resource requirements is essential for determining the appropriate conservation
methods for sea turtle populations. Satellite tracking has become a widely used tool for sea turtle
researchers over the past decade. We attached satellite tags to nine loggerhead sea turtles between 20102012 to study the migration patterns of sea turtles (nesting or rehabilitated at the Rescue Center
(DEKAMER)) on Dalyan beach, Turkey. We are still receiving data, but our initial results indicate that
most of the male sea turtles from western Anatolia coasts did not migrate to other countries, but remained
near the Turkish coast. Some females showed similar patterns, but a few females migrated to the shores of
Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Israel. Our initial results suggest that collaborative conservation efforts are
necessary for the protection of sea turtles in the Mediterranean.
144
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
LONG-DISTANCE TRAVEL DURING INTER-NESTING: UNIQUE AND DEVIANT
MOVEMENTS OF LOGGERHEAD NESTERS IN THE NORTHER GULF OF MEXICO
Margaret M. Lamont1, Kristen M. Hart2, Ikuko Fujisaki3, Autumn R. Sartain4, Brail Stephens5,
Jackie Isaacs6, and Dianne Ingram7
1
USGS, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Gainesville, FL
USGS, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Davie, FL
3
University of Florida, Department of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation/Ft. Lauderdale Research and
Education Center, Davie, Florida, USA
4
Cherokee Nations Technology Solutions, contracted to the United States Geological Survey, Davie, FL
5
University of Florida, Florida Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Gainesville, Florida, USA
6
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, Bon Secour National Wildlife Refuge, Gulf Shores, Alabama,
USA
7
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, Ecological Services, Alabama Field Office, Daphne, Alabama,
USA
2
Little is known about movements and habitat-use at sea for loggerhead sea turtles, Caretta caretta, in the
Northern Gulf of Mexico. In 2010, we initiated sea turtle tagging and tracking program, focused on
obtaining inter-nesting habitat-use information for N=4 nesting females from the longest-term Northern
Gulf loggerhead nest monitoring site on the St. Joseph State Peninsula, Florida. In 2011, we continued the
tagging and tracking program on SJP (N=5), but expanded it to include loggerheads nesting at Bon Secour
National Wildlife Refuge and adjacent beaches in Gulf Shores, Alabama (N=13). Most recently, in 2012
we deployed 23 tags, 10 from AL and 13 from Florida. In 2011, definitive links emerged for loggerheads
between these two sites (i.e., one turtle that nested in June in Alabama later nested on SJP in July, and
several turtles that nested in Alabama were re-migrants from SJP from as far back as 10 years). In 2012,
additional links to the SJP site became apparent as one turtle that nested in Alabama in June had previously
been tagged at SJP 6 years prior. In addition to documenting turtle exchanges between the two sites, we
also observed remarkable movements by turtles during the inter-nesting period. Of the 45 turtles tracked,
25 made inter-nesting movements greater than 100 km and eight traveled between the two study sites
(straight-line distance of 250 km). Several turtles traveled over 360 km within a 2-week span of time. Other
turtles made looping movements out into deep areas of the Gulf of Mexico, never returning to nest. We also
documented exchanges between the Northern Gulf of Mexico nesting group and the Southwest Florida
nesting group. Such movements have not been documented for other loggerhead populations during internesting intervals, even for others in the southern Gulf of Mexico (i.e., the Dry Tortugas sub-population). It
is often suggested that the majority of loggerhead turtles remain within 5-km of their nesting beach during
the inter-nesting period. The results of this ongoing study demonstrate loggerheads in the northern Gulf of
Mexico frequently and consistently make movements much greater than 5-km during inter-nesting periods.
Only 9 of the 45 turtles remained within 10-km of their original tagging site during inter-nesting. These
findings suggest loggerheads in this region are not restricted to one “nesting beach” but frequently use the
entire region during one nesting season. These findings have implications for protection of this species
from threats in nearshore waters, such as commercial fishing, and for critical habitat designations, as
protection of one nesting beach would not encompass their entire range.
145
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
VARIATION IN REMIGRATION INTERVAL IS LINKED TO FORAGING DESTINATION OF
WESTERN PACIFIC LEATHERBACK TURTLES
Deasy N. Lontoh1, Jeffrey A. Seminoff2, Ricardo F. Tapilatu3, James T. Harvey1, and Scott R.
Benson4
1
Moss Landing Marine Laboratories, Moss Landing, CA, USA
NOAA-National Marine Fisheries Services, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, Protected Resource
Division, La Jolla, CA, USA
3
University of Alabama at Birmingham, AL, USA, and Marine Laboratory, Department of the State
University of Papua, Manokwari, West Papua, Indonesia
4
NOAA-National Marine Fisheries Services, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, Protected Resource
Division, Moss Landing, CA, USA
2
Timing of reproduction and productivity of migratory species reflect ecological conditions of their foraging
regions. Non-breeding habitat quality has been linked to arrival time to breeding areas, reproductive
performance and breeding population abundance. Leatherback turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) obtain
resources for reproduction from distant foraging regions, and they do not typically breed every year. The
number of years separating successive nesting seasons or remigration interval includes the amount of time
to complete migration and to accumulate enough reserve for reproduction in the foraging region. In this
study, we compared remigration intervals of leatherback turtles that foraged in distinct regions of the
Pacific. The largest remaining nesting aggregation of western Pacific leatherback turtles is in the Bird’s
Head peninsula on the northwest coast of Papua, Indonesia. Turtles that nest during April to September
migrate to temperate (Northeast Pacific and North Pacific Transition Zone) and tropical (South China Sea)
foraging regions, which vary in the distance from nesting beach, latitude, biogeochemical process, and
productivity. To infer foraging regions of nesting turtles, we used stable nitrogen and carbon ratios (δ15N
and δ13C) of satellite-tracked turtles as predictors of foraging region in a linear discriminant analysis. The
resulting functions were then used to classify turtles sampled in 2010 and 2011. Remigration intervals of
assigned turtles were calculated from historic tagging data, and compared among the three groups using
analysis of variance. As predicted, turtles that foraged in the Northeast Pacific had greater δ15N. Turtles
that foraged in the North Pacific Transition Zone were distinguished from those that foraged in the South
China Sea by their lesser (more negative) δ13C. Means of δ15N and δ13C were 15.04‰ (95% CI from
14.04 to16.04‰) and -17.14‰ (-17.66 to -16.63‰) for turtles that foraged in the Northeast Pacific,
12.69‰ (11.42 to13.97‰) and -18.21‰ (-18.86 to -17.56‰) for turtles that foraged in the North Pacific
Transition Zone, and 11.03‰ (9.89 to 12.17‰) and -16.82‰ (-17.41 to -16.24‰) for turtles that foraged in
the South China Sea. The discriminant functions correctly classified 74.2% of satellite-tracked turtles.
Turtles that foraged in the Northeast Pacific had a longer remigration interval (>3 years) than turtles that
foraged in the North Pacific Transition Zone and South China Sea (2 and 3 years). Variable remigration
intervals may explain fluctuations in the number of turtles nesting annually and has implications for
estimating population size. We thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy,
Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, and CLS America for providing a generous travel grant
award. Funding and logistical support for this study were provided by the Bird’s Head Leatherback
Program of State University of Papua, U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration – National
Marine Fisheries Service, Dr. Earl H. Myers and Ethel M. Myers Oceanographic and Marine Biology Trust,
PADI Foundation, and Friend’s of Moss Landing Marine Laboratories’ Signe Memorial Scholarship.
146
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FIRST SATELLITE TRACKS OF NEONATE GREEN (CHELONIA MYDAS) TURTLES USING A
NEW TAG ATTACHMENT METHOD
Kate L. Mansfield1 and Jeanette Wyneken2
1
Southeast Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, Miami, Florida, USA; and School
of Environment, Arts and Society, Florida International University, North Miami, FL, USA
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Satellite tracking of neonate turtles is challenging due to limits imposed by turtle size, shell characteristics,
and behavior. The shell of neonate green turtles differs from that of loggerheads in shape and surface
properties. The acrylic-neoprene-silicone tag attachment method described by Mansfield et al. (2012) does
not adhere to small green turtles. We developed and lab-tested a new tag attachment method specific to
neonate green turtles that relies upon a flexible, low temperature adhesive. Using small, solar-powered
satellite tags and this novel tag attachment method, we satellite tracked 11 neonate green sea turtles (15 to
18 cm straight carapace length) in 2012. Sea turtles were lab-reared, weighed between 500-860 g and
ranged in age from 6-9 months post-hatching. All turtles were released in the Gulf Stream off the southeast
Florida (USA) coast proximal to their natal beaches. Turtles traveled 475 to 3,500 km minimum distance.
The average duration of tag transmissions was 67 d (range: 10-102 d). Similar to neonate loggerheads
tracked in our previous study, the green turtles remained in or within close proximity to the Gulf Stream
immediately post-release, traveling north with the current, along the eastern coast of the US. Initially, most
turtles remained east of the Continental Shelf, and were constrained by the western Gulf Stream boundary.
Five turtles traveled in the Gulf Stream to the northwestern Atlantic where they associated with the edges
of mesoscale eddies prior to tag cessation. However, unlike neonate loggerheads, four green turtles returned
to near-shore neritic waters off South and North Carolina for periods of 1-3 weeks prior to re-entering the
Gulf Stream. Five turtles traveled as far as Cape Hatteras, North Carolina or up to 1,000 km beyond before
traveling south again into the region associated with the western Sargasso Sea. One turtle returned to the
same latitude as its release. All turtles remained within average available sea surface temperatures (SST) of
21-25˚ C. Our data represent the first successful satellite tracks of any neonate green sea turtle and provide
the first in situ, empirical evidence of the long-term movements and habitat use of neonate green turtles in
the Atlantic. Acknowledgments: Funding and support for this project was provided by: the Florida Sea
Turtle Grants Program, Save Our Seas Foundation, Disney Worldwide Conservation Fund, National
Marine Fisheries Service Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Ashwanden Family fund, Nelligan Sea Turtle
Fund, J. Abernethy and personal funds.
147
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IDENTIFYING IMPORTANT FEEDING AGGREGATIONS OF GREEN SEA TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS): THE GULF OF VENEZUELA
María G. Montiel-Villalobos1, Héctor A. Barrios-Garrido2, Rodrigo Lazo3, and Kathryn M.
Rodríguez-Clark4
1
Laboratorio de Ecología y Genética de Poblaciones, Centro de Ecología, Instituto Venezolano de
Investigaciones Científicas (IVIC), Caracas, Venezuela; Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo
de Venezuela (GTTM-GV), Maracaibo, Venezuela
2
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela (GTTM-GV), Maracaibo, Venezuela;
Laboratorio de Ecología General, Departamento de Biología, Facultad Experimental de Ciencias, La
Universidad del Zulia, Maracaibo, Venezuela
3
UniSIG: Unidad de Información Geográfica, Centro de Ecología, IVIC, Caracas, Venezuela
4
Laboratorio de Ecología y Genética de Poblaciones, Centro de Ecología, Instituto Venezolano de
Investigaciones Científicas (IVIC), Caracas, Venezuela
Green turtle foraging habitats have been studied less than the nesting habitats in the Caribbean, but are
known to harbor an important anthropogenic threat: the intentional harvest and bycatch of juveniles and
adults. We examined a foraging area with traditional turtle hunting in the Gulf of Venezuela (GV) by
estimating: a) the area of available feeding habitat within the portion of the GV with most intense
extraction, the “high extraction zone” (HEZ); b) relative turtle density, using catch per unit effort (CPUE);
and c) turtle size class structure. We visited fishing ports, markets and beaches between 2002 and 2005, and
interviewed and observed artisanal fishers to define the HEZ. Then between 2005 and 2008, we
characterized the bottom cover at 400 points and set tangle nets to capture turtles at a rate of 15.03 km-hr.
The area of estimated foraging habitat was 226 km2 (including only seagrass areas), which was much
smaller than similar habitat surrounding an HEZ in Nicaragua, which is considered the most important in
the region to date. Nonetheless, the relative density of green turtles was significantly higher in the HEZ-GV
than in Nicaragua (1.21 vs. 0.61 turtles/km-net-hr, p = 0.01). Furthermore, 63% of green turtles observed
were juveniles (avg. CCL 63.9 cm) and the remaining 37% were subadults (avg. 77.0 cm) or adults (97.0
cm), making the GV the only other feeding habitat in the Caribbean identified to date with both large
juveniles and subadults present, and one of just four with adults. The unusual combination of extensive
available foraging habitat, high relative turtle density, presence of larger size classes, and continued turtle
fishing pressures highlights the importance of the GV both as a foraging ground for C. mydas in the
Caribbean, and as a location of interest for future monitoring.
AN APPLICATION OF VIDEO ANALYSIS TO THE COGNITIVE STUDY: THE
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LOOKING-AROUND BEHAVIOR OF GREEN TURTLES AND
THEIR HABITAT ENVIRONMENT
Kana Nakajima1, Junichi Okuyama1, Kenta Matsui2, Kazuaki Kondo3, Takahiro Koizumi2, Yuichi
Nakamura3, Ayana Wada1, Nobuaki Arai1, and Shiro Kagawa4
1
Graduate school of Informatics, Kyoto University
Graduate School of Engineering, Kyoto University
3
Academic Center for Computing and Media Studies, Kyoto University
4
Japan Broadcasting Corporation
2
An animal-borne video recording system has recently been developed to study underwater behavior of
marine animals, which enable us to understand the meaning of their behavior, habitat and prey items.
148
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
However, the way of using the video data is just watching, and almost all of these studies have not
employed a quantitative video analysis for understanding the behavior and ecology of animals. In this study,
we used the computer vision technique which was developed in the human sensing, and applied to the
cognitive study of sea turtles. The objective of this study was to clarify the relationship between lookingaround behavior of green turtles and their habitat environment. We used 17 juveniles in total (one
individual in 2010, 13 individuals in 2011, three individuals in 2012). In 2010, the turtle was attached the
video data logger (modified from HDR-CX180, SONY Ltd.) with time-scheduled release system (Little
Leonard Ltd.) on the carapaces. In 2011and 2012, the turtles were attached the Fast-loc GPS and depth data
logger (Mk10-FB, Wildlife Computers Ltd.) and video data logger (modified from GoProoR Ltd.) with the
time-scheduled release system on their carapaces. The turtles were released at the place where they had
been captured before. At the scheduled time after the releases, the data loggers were automatically detached
from the turtles by the time-scheduled release system, and then popped up to the sea surface. As the result
of this study, we succeeded in retrieving the loggers and consequently obtaining video data from nine
turtles (one individual in 2010, five individuals in 2011, three individuals in 2012). Then, the lookingaround behavior of turtles was detected using the template matching technique. Our result demonstrated
that green turtles made looking-around behavior more time when they were not in their home range than
when they were, and before and after breathing at the sea surface.
COMPLEX HABITAT USE BY HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN LAC BAY, BONAIRE, DUTCH
CARIBBEAN - PRELIMINARY RESULTS
Mabel Nava1 and Robert van Dam2
1
2
Sea Turtle Conservation Bonaire
Chelonia Inc, Puerto Rico
The Lac Bay lagoon covers an area of about 7 km2 and contains a variety of habitat types including
mangrove stands, seagrass beds and coral reefs, all constituting potential hawksbill turtle habitats. Due to
its diversity value and vulnerability, the area has been designated as a legally protected Ramsar site. Turtle
surveys conducted at Lac Bay since 2003 have resulted in the capture, tagging and measurement of 76
individual immature hawksbills (plus 37 recapture events). In addition, hawksbill habitat use is examined in
detail through GPS/depth/temperature dataloggers, measuring diving behavior and movement patterns.
Here we present preliminary data on size range, displacement, diving behavior, somatic growth rate and
body condition index data of hawksbills using Lac Bay. The high growth rates and body condition index
exhibited by the Lac Bay hawksbills indicate that food quality and/or food availability is greater than in
other habitats around Bonaire and the region. Our preliminary results indicate that immature hawksbills are
successfully foraging in the seagrass beds and mangrove stands of Lac Bay, habitats complementary to the
coral reefs with which the species is typically associated
149
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FEEDING ECOLOGY OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA) STRANDED
ALONG THE PORTUGUESE SOUTHERN COAST – ALGARVE
Lídia Nicolau1, Ana Marçalo1, Catarina Eira1, and José Vingada2
1
Centre for Environmental and Marine Studies (CESAM), Department of Biology, University of Aveiro,
Campus Universitário de Santiago, Aveiro, Portugal
2
CBMA/Departamento Biologia, Universidade do Minho, Campus de Gualtar, Braga, Portugal
Up to the last two years, studies on the biology and ecology of marine turtles were non-existant along the
Continental Portuguese coast. The Portuguese southern coast, the Algarve, is an area of high stranding
records for loggerhead turtles, Caretta caretta, where population status is unknown and interactions with
fisheries are the main cause of death. The present study is the first attempt to determine the feeding ecology
of loggerhead turtles occurring off the southern Portuguese coast in order to evaluate possible competition
and interaction with fisheries. We analyzed the contents of the digestive tract of 53 loggerhead sea turtles
(range of curved carapace length, CCL: 33.2 – 71.5 cm) stranded dead along the Portuguese southern coast
(Algarve) between 2010 and 2012. The food items were identified to the lowest taxonomic level possible.
Seasonal differences, animal’s size/maturity (carapace length) and main causes of death were taken into
consideration. Crustaceans were the most important prey group occurring in 73.6% of the examined
stomachs, followed by fish (56.6%) and molluscs (43.4%). The most important crustacean species were
Henslow’s swimming crab, Polybius henslowi (49.1%) and the hermit crab, Pagurus sp. (22.6%). Also,
debris in the gastrointestinal tract occurred in 70% of the analyzed sea turtles. The percentage of occurrence
of pelagic prey is higher in the first semester (January to June), while benthic prey is most frequent in the
second semester (July to December). Unlike other diet studies for the same species worldwide, in our study
loggerhead turtles with the smallest CCL showed a tendency to feed on benthic prey, while turtles with the
highest CCL preferred pelagic prey. However, number and diversity of prey increased with turtle size
indicating an increase of selectivity with age/maturity. Percentage of occurrence of prey with commercial
value was higher in loggerhead turtles whose cause of death was related to interaction with fisheries
(incidental capture) corroborating that fisheries represent an important food source for loggerhead turtles.
Evidence that commercially important fish species are consumed as discarded by-catch or depredation by
loggerheads, may suggest a worrisome interaction with fisheries, that requires monitoring in order to attain
better estimates of its impact.
AN ENERGY STRATEGY OF FEMALE GREEN TURTLES DURING INTER-NESTING
PERIOD IN ISHIGAKI ISLANDS, JAPAN
Yuka Obe1, Junichi Okuyama2, Hideaki Nishizawa1, Tohya Yasuda3, Masato Kobayashi3, and
Nobuaki Arai1
1
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Kyoto, Japan
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
3
Seikai National Fisheries Research Institute, Fisheries Research Agency, Japan
2
In terms of reproductive strategy, animals are assumed to have evolved to maximize reproductive output.
Sea turtles deposit several nests during a single nesting season and spend the next 10-20 days offshore until
the next clutch is ready to deposit. Therefore, it is assumed that the turtles save energy for the next nesting
event during the inter-nesting period, but detailed movement and behavior patterns of females have not yet
been investigated. This study was conducted between June and August of 2008, 2009 and 2010 at Ishigaki
150
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Island, Japan. The objectives of this study were to investigate the 3-D movements and behavioral patterns
of nesting green turtles (Chelonia mydas). We attached the speed, tri-axial acceleration, tri-axial magnetism,
water temperature and depth data loggers (W1000L-3MPD3GT, Little Leonard Ltd.) on 8 turtles after
nesting, with Fast-loc GPS dataloggers (Mk10-FB, Wildlife Computers) on 4 of the turtles. Dataloggers
were retrieved at the next nesting event. We obtained behavioral data for 9-12 day periods for each turtle.
Our results demonstrated that all females stayed along the coast in front of the nesting beach with a small
home range during the inter-nesting period. At night, much time was spent resting in one place, while
during the day they moved around the resting place. These results indicate that the nesting female turtles
save their energy by resting for long periods of time. Additionally, they seem to save their energy
efficiently, not by searching for a resting place each time, but by selecting a fixed place.
FIRST SATELLITE TRACK OF A HEAD-STARTED HAWKSBILL (FOUR YEARS OLD) IN
THE COLOMBIAN CARIBBEAN
Karen A. Pabón-Aldana, Carmen L. Noriega-Hoyos, and Guiomar A. Jaúregui
Sea Turtle Conservation Program, Jorge Tadeo Lozano University, Santa Marta, Colombia.
Due to the absence of information on residential and migratory behavior of hawksbill turtles, Eretmochelys
imbricata, in the Colombian Caribbean, this study monitored the post – release movement of a four year
old head – started turtle named "Cumbiarey" using satellite transmitter SPOT5 AM–S244B during a period
of six months. The turtle was released on 5 December 2009 in Gayraca Bay, Tayrona National Park,
Colombia (11°19’5.98’’ N – 74°6’24.96’’W) where it remained during the first 21 days covering most of
the extension of the Park’s water, after that, Cumbiarey started an oceanic journey in which had the highest
average speed (3.4 ± 0.19 km/h) across the road, showing the possible influence of the Caribbean current
and the southern part of an anticyclonic eddy that led her to the Costa Rica's inland waters, then she might
have been driven by Panama - Colombia countercurrent to finally reach to the Bocas del Toro archipelago
(Panama).The tag transmitted location data for 64 days and showed that the maximum distance traveled by
the turtle was 1463.66 km from the release site, furthermore, we received 69 temperature recordings within
the range of 25.1°C to 30.6°C. The results of the Pearson test indicated a strong correlation (r(69) = 0.70)
between the station data from the Smithsonian and temperature sensor data from the SPOT5; indicating that
temperature is an important variable that may be useful for validating geographic locations. Cumbiarey
demonstrated that juvenile hawksbill turtles from head-started projects are able to migrate and survive in
the wild for a period of at least of 6 months, travelling within surface currents to successfully arrive at
documented areas known for sea turtle nesting and foraging.
IDENTIFYING BEHAVIORAL STATES IN LOGGERHEAD TURTLES USING SATELLITE
TELEMETRY DATA
Samir H. Patel1, Aliki Panagopoulou1, Helen Bailey2, Stephen J. Morreale3, Frank V. Paladino4,
Dimitris Margaritoulis5, and James R. Spotila1
1
Drexel University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
University of Maryland, Somolons, MD, USA
3
Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA
4
Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne, Fort Wayne, IN, USA
5
ARCHELON, The Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Athens, Greece
2
151
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
The purpose of this study was to identify behavioral states of loggerhead turtles from satellite telemetry
data. We also determined how shifts in behavioral states were influenced by environmental conditions.
During the 2010 and 2011 nesting seasons in Rethymno, Crete, Greece, we successfully deployed 15
satellite transmitters on postnesting female turtles to determine their at-sea behaviors. All of these
transmitters lasted until the turtles reached their foraging sites, with some transmitters continuing to
function into overwintering. We used two statistical methods to determine behavioral states of each turtle:
(1) change point analysis and (2) state space modeling. (1) Change point analyses were used to determine
subtle shifts in dive data. We found that for several turtles, changes in dive behavior occurred prior to
arrival at a foraging site and then again as the turtle established residency. This transition period may
represent a type of searching behavior to identify an optimal foraging site. Another common change in dive
behavior occurred if the individual moved to a new site of residency. Finally, we found obvious shifts in
dive behavior as turtles transitioned into overwintering. (2) We applied state-space modeling to the
horizontal location data to identify changes in behavioral states. These location data were then related to
remote sensed environmental data to identify correlations between behavioral shifts and sea surface
temperature or chlorophyll concentrations. The 15 loggerheads all traveled to relatively shallow regions.
Six went north into the Aegean Sea where chlorophyll levels were relatively low, while nine turtles went
south to the coasts of Tunisia and Libya, where levels of chlorophyll were much higher. These two areas
also differed consistently in sea surface temperature by two degrees; however, this did not seem to impact
turtles’ behavioral states. By consolidating these analyses, we can develop an ecological niche for
loggerhead sea turtles in the Mediterranean Sea. This will allow us to predict which areas could have higher
loggerhead abundances and potentially how this species will react to a changing environment.
POST-NESTING BEHAVIOR OF LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA NESTING IN CAMP LA
GLORIA, JALISCO, MEXICO
Theodora Pinou1, Robert DiGiovanni2, Ildefonso E. Padilla3, Jacobo Francisco3, Carlos Barrera3, and
Antonio T. Robles4
1
Western Connecticut State University, Danbury, CT, USA
Riverhead Foundation for Marine Research and Preservation, Riverhead, NY, USA
3
University of Guadalajara (CUCBA), Guadalajara, MX
4
University of Guadalajara (CUCSUR), Melaque, MX
2
This preliminary study examines the post-nesting behavior of L. olivacea nesting in Camp La Gloria.
Empirical data characterize where sea turtles go after nesting and the frequency of post-nesting diving
behaviors to address whether the current boundaries of the Naturally Protected Area are sufficient for the
protection and conservation of L. olivacea. Preliminary data provide information regarding the spatial
distribution of the nesting behaviors of L. olivacea, and document two patterns of movement: A north-south
movement that complements the existing literature on L. olivacea post-migration, and a second south
south-west post-migration pattern that is poorly documented. We demonstrate how all five turtles moved
beyond the boundaries of the Naturally Protected Area, currently shaped as 4 nautical miles, and postmigration data suggest that the turtles move in and out of the Naturally Protected Area more frequently than
expected.
152
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SEA TURTLE STUDY IN ALBANIA DURING 2011
Vilma Piroli and Idriz Haxhiu
Center for Research and Developement, Vitrina University, Tirana- Albania
During 2011, we collected taxonomic and morphometric data on 121 Caretta caretta individuals and 2
Chelonia mydas individuals. All turtles were captured in two stavniks (a kind of fishing trap) in Drini Bay,
except 2 in Orikum and Durres. Recorded measurements included Curved Carapace Length (CCL), Curve
Carapace Width (CCW), Total Tail Length (TTL), distance from posterior margin of plastron to midline of
cloacal opening (Plas – Clo), and distance from tip of the tail to posterior margin of the carapace (+/- cara).
All turtles were then allocated into size classes. We counted the epidermal scales on the head, dividing
them into prefrontal and frontoparietal scales. Sex was determined using morphological characteristics. All
turtles larger then 30 cm CCL were tagged with Albanian titanium tags and were checked for epibionts,
wounds, missing flippers, parasites etc. Loggerhead CCLs ranged from 32-85 cm, but most were in the 60
cm size class. The two Chelonia mydas individuals were very small (28 and 30 cm). The highest numbers
of turtles were captured in June (35 individuals) and August (30 individuals). We found much deviation in
the number of carapace scales. Three of the 121 individuals were dead, 3 had missing flippers and 3 had
hooks in their digestive tracks.
DISTRIBUTION AND RELATIVE ABUNDANCE OF SEA TURTLES IN BUCK ISLAND REEF
NATIONAL MONUMENT, ST. CROIX, US. VIRGIN ISLANDS
Clayton Pollock1, Paul Jobsis2, Kristen M. Hart3, and Zandy Hillis-Starr4
1
University of the Virgin Islands, MMES Program, USVI and National Park Service, Buck Island Reef
NM, St. Croix, USVI
2
University of the Virgin Islands, USVI
3
United States Geological Survey, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Davie, Florida, USA
4
National Park Service, Buck Island Reef NM, St. Croix, USVI
Buck Island Reef National Monument (BIRNM) provides important habitat for green (Chelonia mydas) sea
turtles and is listed as an index site for hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata) sea turtles. In October 2011 and
June 2012 we conducted snorkel surveys to assess the distribution and relative abundance of sea turtles at
our study site within BIRNM. Our study site was divided into 18 approximately 0.15 km2 survey blocks
and timed snorkel surveys were conducted along transects within each survey block to record the
abundance, location, life-stage and species of the sea turtles sighted. We spent a total of 70.3 hours (431.5
surveyor hrs) surveying a distance of 133.7 km within the study site. During the two survey periods we
observed a total of 168 sea turtles, including 122 green and 46 hawksbill sea turtles. We observed sea
turtles in all 18 survey blocks, however, sea turtle sightings within just three survey blocks along the
southeast forereef accounted for 50% of the total sightings. Using the relative abundance data we generated
density estimates and catch per unit effort (CPUE) estimates for sea turtles for each survey block; these
represent the first effort-corrected estimates for BIRNM. We also investigated the effect of benthic
composition within each survey block on sea turtle abundance. Specifically, we investigated the effect of
rugosity, depth, hard coral cover, soft coral cover, hydrocoral cover, sponge cover, algae cover, seagrass
cover and over-all cover on sea turtle abundance. As part of a renewed effort to collect in-water data from
sea turtles at BIRNM, this study is first in almost a decade to document sea turtle distribution and
abundance at this index site.
153
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
USING MULTIPLE METHODS TO LINK THE LOGGERHEAD FORAGING POPULATION IN
AMVRAKIKOS GULF, GREECE, TO SOURCE NESTING POPULATIONS IN THE
MEDITERRANEAN
ALan F. Rees1,2, Annette C. Broderick1, Carlos Carreras1, Dimitris Margaritoulis2, and Brendan J.
Godley1
1
2
MTRG, University of Exeter, UK
ARCHELON, Athens, Greece
A decade-long study in Amvrakikos Gulf, Greece, has identified the area as a hot-spot for loggerheads
within the Mediterranean, with over three hundred large-juvenile to adult turtles (>46 cm SCL) identified in
only 71 days fieldwork. Establishing links between this foraging site and the different nesting areas is
important to identify which source populations which are impacted by turtle survivorship rates in the Gulf
and to highlight the shared responsibility of marine turtles in the region. To validate these links we
employed multiple research methods. Capture-mark-recapture using flipper tags on turtles caught by rodeo
technique from an inflatable dinghy has been the standard method employed to trace turtles in time and
space over the duration of the study. Additionally we have used satellite telemetry to track several
individuals (N = 6 turtles) from their capture locations within the Gulf and mixed stock analysis from short
(380 bp) and long (815 bp) mtDNA sequences (N = 38 turtles) to generate estimates for the relative
contributions of the region’s nesting populations. Flipper tagging results have linked 11 adult female
loggerheads to nesting areas in Greece (1 Mounda Beach, Kefalonia; 6 Laganas Bay, Zakynthos; 4 southern
Kyparissia Bay, Peloponnese; 1 Rethymno, Crete). One of the tagged turtles displayed poor nest site
fidelity and was observed nesting at both Kyparissia and Laganas Bays in a single season. Satellite tracking
revealed one adult-sized female migrated over 3,400 km with its last location placing it near the Fethiye
nesting area in Turkey during the breeding season. Published tracks of three other adult turtles from the
Laganas Bay breeding area (1 male and 2 female) reported the turtles migrated into Amvrakikos Gulf.
Lastly, short-sequence mtDNA analysis revealed negligible potential contribution from Atlantic breeding
stocks and hence these nesting areas were excluded from further analysis. Long sequence analysis, that
provides greater resolution between breeding stocks, indicated the majority of turtles were of Greek origin
including Zakynthos (42.7%), Lakonikos Bay, Peloponnese (27.7%) and the Island of Crete (12.9%). Longsequence haplotypes present in Kyparissia Bay have not yet been analysed, but previous studies with short
sequences suggested that this area is similar to the other Greek nesting beaches and hence its contribution
would be probably included in the contribution from Lakonikos and Zakynthos. This hypothesis should be
tested in the future using long sequences. Using multiple methods we have revealed that the loggerhead
foraging population in Amvrakikos Gulf is inextricably linked with the more proximal major nesting
grounds in Greece and probably to a lesser degree Turkey. The results highlight that, though not
exclusively so, developmental and adult foraging areas may hold individuals from more localised breeding
assemblages, conferring deeper spatial structure to the region than may be expected. Amvrakikos Gulf is
confirmed as a nationally important loggerhead foraging ground where local threats would impact nesting
populations across the country. Acknowledgments: Satellite tracking was undertaken through and partfunded by EU LIFE project LIFE99NAT/006475. We thank all the field assistants for their help over the
ten years of research. AFR thanks International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of
Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for a travel
grant.
154
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
FACTORS AFFECTING NEST AND IN-WATER SURVIVAL OF HAWKSBILL HATCHLING
SEA TURTLES AT JUMBY BAY, ANTIGUA, WEST INDIES*
Megan Reising1, Michael Salmon1, Seth Stapleton2, and Seth Stapleton3
1
Biology Department, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Department of Fisheries, Wildlife and Conservation Biology, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN,
USA
3
Jumby Bay Hawksbill Project, Long Island, Antigua, West Indies
2
A number of studies suggest that the most dangerous time for hatchling sea turtles occurs during the first
hours after nest emergence. Sea turtles produce large clutches consisting of small offspring, presumably in
response to these threats. Hawksbills in particular, produce very large clutches (mean ~150 eggs) of small
(13.5-19.5 g) hatchlings, presumably to offset typically higher rates of hatchling mortality than are
experienced by other marine turtle species. However, few previous studies specifically document hawksbill
hatchling mortality rates. The purpose of our study was (i) to describe presumed morphological adaptations
shown by hawksbill hatchlings to promote their emergence from nests under canopy vegetation and
through plant roots; (ii) to compare and contrast their time of emergence to the temporal pattern shown by
their closest relative, the loggerhead; and (iii) to document predation rates the hatchlings experienced
during offshore migration. We chose a confined beach site (Pasture Beach on Long Island also known as
Jumby Bay, Antigua) where turtles nest at high densities. The primary nesting beach facilitated tracking
hatchlings offshore to estimate predation rates. We conducted this research during late July through
September, 2012, when hatchling emergence was at its seasonal peak. We recorded nest emergence times,
measured a sample of hatchlings, and completed nest excavations. Hatchlings towing small floats,
illuminated from above, were followed by kayak for 25 min as they migrated offshore immediately after an
emergence. A GPS location was taken every 5 minutes, and predation events were recorded. Hatchlings
most often emerged from nests between dusk and 9PM, which is much earlier than loggerheads from
Florida that emerge most often between 10PM and 2AM. An earlier emergence time might allow hawksbill
hatchlings, which are relatively slow swimmers, more time to reach deeper water before sunrise.
Emergence success for the majority of the nests exceeded 70%. When emergence success was lower, it was
often because eggs didn’t hatch or because hatchlings were entangled in plant roots. Morphometric data
revealed that hawksbills hatchlings have a deeper body and proportionally larger rear flippers than
loggerhead hatchlings. These morphological differences might enhance successful burrowing through root
networks that invade many nests. A total of 50 hatchlings were tracked as they swam offshore. The overall
predation rate was 57% but on the west side of Pasture Beach, where females nest at higher densities, 88%
of the hatchlings were predated. On the east side of the bay rates were much lower (18.2 %). Predators may
have learned to forage where hatchlings were most abundant. Over the past 3 years, there has been a
decline in nesting by both experienced females and (first time nesting) recruits. High rates of hatchling
predation over many years might be a factor, but it’s impossible to know if present predation rates represent
a historical norm or are a recent phenomenon. If this decline persists, alternative management procedures
might be required to enhance hatchling survival, and hopefully stem any further reduction in this important
breeding assemblage.
155
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TROPHIC BEHAVIOR DIVERSIFICATION OF GREEN TURTLES FROM MEXICAN PACIFIC
IN RELATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
Juan M. Rguez-Baron1, Jorge M. López-Calderón1, Rafael Riosmena-Rodríguez1, and Jeffrey A.
Seminoff2
1
Universidad Autónoma de Baja California Sur, Apartado postal 23080, km. 5.5 Carretera al Sur La Paz
B.C.S. México
2
NOAA - National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, 8604 La Jolla Shores
Drive, La Jolla, California 92037, USA
The knowledge of diet and foraging ecology can identify important food resources and guide decisions
regarding the management of endangered populations. Changes in trophic behavior of green turtles
(Chelonia mydas) in relation to the benthic community structure in their feeding grounds may affect net
nutritional gain and in turn, reproductive output and demography. It has been reported that the seagrass
Zostera marina is one of main dietary items of C. mydas in northwest Mexico; however, this onceabundant seagrass has decreased substantially due to environmental changes. Elevated sea temperatures
produced by global warming or El Niño Southern Oscillations (ENSO) are responsible for major reductions
of seagrass populations around the world. In these conditions, it is possible that climax seagrass species (Z.
marina) could be partially or completely replaced by opportunistic species like Ruppia maritima, thereby
producing a radical change in the trophic structure of the community. In this study, we conducted an
extensive evaluation of seagrass populations found 29 sites along Baja California Peninsula, Sinaloa and
Sonora based on literature surveys and in situ sampling efforts for more than 20 years. We found noticeable
amounts of R. maritima growing close to Z. marina meadows in areas and in densities unknown for the
region. Moreover, during 2008-2009 we obtained several samples of stomach contents from dead, bycaught
turtles and oesophagic contents for live juvenile green turtles from three coastal lagoon of Pacific of Baja
California Peninsula. According to esophageal and stomach samples, the R. maritima constituted between
0.40 and 24.33% of the diet of green turtles, while Z. marina values were between 3.33 and 44.21%. To our
knowledge, this is the first documentation of R. maritima featuring more prominently than Z. marina in the
diet of green turtles in northwest Mexico. It is also the first study linking the Bottom-Up effect by ENSO
and climate change in trophic relationships on shallow areas, as well as the ability of green turtle to modify
their feeding behavior at foraging areas in northwest Mexico. We thank International Sea Turtle Society,
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife,
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America and the
International Sea Turtle Symposium for their generous donations for attend to 33rd Annual Symposium on
Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation.
USE OF NON-OCEAN HABITAT BY SEA TURTLES AS FORAGING OR RESTING GROUNDS
Todd A. Rimkus, Samantha Grimmer, and Melany Su
Marymount University, Arlington, Virginia, USA
Sea turtles use a variety of foraging and resting grounds near nesting sites. Several nesting beaches in
Belize are in close proximity to the Northern and Southern Lagoons. These nesting beaches have typical
foraging and resting grounds in front of the beaches, but rivers also provide access to the lagoons. The use
of the Southern Lagoon as a sea turtle habitat has been reported by residents of Gales Point Belize, but only
by word of mouth. In July and August of 2011, three female hawksbill sea turtles were satellite tagged
156
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
during nesting attempts at the Manatee Bar. Each of these sea turtles was tracked for over 100 days and
they remained in areas in front of the nesting beaches where they would be expected to be resting and
foraging between nesting events. On one occasion, the satellite transmissions from one of these females
suggest that she traveled up the Bar River and entered the Southern Lagoon. She stayed in the lagoon for
two days before returning to the ocean. As this is the first evidence that places sea turtles in the Southern
Lagoon, the possibility of transmission error is also analyzed.
COASTAL OR PELAGIC: UPDATING THE LEATHERBACK PARADIGM
Nathan J. Robinson1, Ronel Nel2, Stephen J. Morreale3, and Frank V. Paladino4
1
Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA
Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa
3
Cornell Univeristy, Ithaca, New York, USA
4
Indiana University - Purdue University Fort Wayne, Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA
2
The current paradigm is that leatherback turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) are pelagic specialists. Indeed, the
majority of leatherback turtles satellite-tracked to date have occupied pelagic foraging grounds or crossed
vast expanses of open-ocean en route to coastal foraging grounds. However, it is feasible that leatherback
turtles would not travel to open ocean if suitable foraging grounds existed in coastal waters near the nesting
beaches. The coastal waters of Mozambique may represent such a site. While leatherback turtles are often
sighted in the coastal waters of Mozambique, it has yet to be confirmed whether this is a foraging ground.
Nevertheless, approximately 500 km south along the coast in South Africa are known nesting beaches for
leatherback turtles. To test whether the leatherback turtles nesting in the iSimangaliso Wetland Park, South
Africa forage in the coastal waters of Mozambique and thus remain coastal throughout their adult lives, we
deployed satellite transmitters onto post-nesting females in 2011/12. We recorded the post-nesting
migrations of 8 individuals over a combined total of 956 tracking days. Four turtles headed south with the
prevailing Agulhas current before turning westward into the pelagic regions of the South Atlantic Ocean or
eastward into the Indian Ocean. One turtle headed due east from the nesting site until transmissions ended
600 km south of Madagascar. The remaining three turtles headed northwards. During these northward
migrations the turtles rarely ventured beyond 100 km of the coast. Upon reaching 18 to 20 °S, speed of
movement decreased to below 5 km day-1 and all three turtles appeared to have taken up residence.
Subsequently, these turtles remained resident within an area less than 100 km2 and where the sea floor was
less than 200 m deep. At this time, they dove far more frequently than those in pelagic foraging grounds
(coastal 4 dives hour-1; pelagic 2.5 dives hour-1) and mean dive duration was shorter (coastal ~ 8 mins;
pelagic ~ 16 mins). Although coastal turtles mainly dove to depths less than 30 m, dives to the depth of the
sea floor were not uncommon. Three out of the 8 turtles tracked in this study remained in coastal waters
during their post-nesting migrations and later as they became resident in their foraging grounds. Thus, it is
possible that a portion of this population may exhibit completely coastal habitat preferences. Interestingly,
the movement patterns of the three coastal turtles from this study were similar to a single leatherback turtle
(out of 46) tracked from Playa Grande, Costa Rica and that during its post-nesting migration and
subsequent residence remained entirely in coastal waters. Similar patterns have also been observed in the
number of turtles nesting in New Guinea. Contrasting with the common perceptions of leatherback turtles
as pelagic specialists our study indicates a greater level of diversity in the life history of this species.
Finally, as this coastal cohort remained with the Exclusive Economic Zones of South Africa and
Mozambique during the tracking period this could represent a unique chance for an otherwise complex
multinational conservation plan.
157
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DIET, FOOD AVAILABILITY AND SELECTIVITY OF CHELONIA MYDAS JUVENILES AT
GORGONA NATIONAL PARK, COLOMBIAN PACIFIC*
Laura Sampson1, Alan Giraldo1, and Diego Amorocho2
1
2
Universidad del Valle, Cali, Colombia
CIMAD, Cali, Colombia
Gorgona National Park (GNP) is the only known feeding ground for Chelonia mydas juveniles on the
Colombian Pacific. This project was undertaken to determine diet and food selection by C. mydas in coastal
waters of GNP. Four sampling trips were carried out between November 2011 and August 2012, and three
more will be undertaken in October, November and December 2012. Sea turtles were captured by hand at
night at the two main reefs where C. mydas can be found during the day and resting at night; standard
measurements were taken and esophageal lavages performed. Food availability was determined by
recording items in 15 randomly placed 0.0625 cm2 quadrats on each reef, during each sampling trip.
Relative abundance was calculated by dividing percent cover of each item by total percent cover sampled.
The most abundant items were: Pocillopora damicornis (58.42%), rhodoliths (22.22%), Cladophora sp.
(4.61%) and algae mats (3.58%). A total of 43 C. mydas juveniles have been sampled so far, ranging from
48.7 to 71.9 cm curved carapace length, and weighing from 12.0 to 48.0 kg. The volume collected from the
esophageal lavages ranged from 0.2 to 4.0 ml, and weighed from 0.20 to 4.07 g. A total of 23 items have
been identified. Due to advanced digestion and low sample volume, not all sample matter could be
identified. The most frequent items in esophageal lavages were unidentified organic matter (OUM; 100
FO%), sand (100 FO%), vegetable matter, including small leaf pieces and seeds (97.67 FO%), and
Gracilaria algae (27.91 FO%). The N%, W% and index of relative importance (IRI) were also calculated.
According to the IRI, the most important components in the C. mydas diet in GNP are OUM (11 368),
vegetable matter (647.61), Gracilaria spp. (333.95) and Dictyota spp. (109.03). Sand and plastic fibers
were also commonly found. Selectivity was calculated using Ivlev´s index; C. mydas showed preference for
leaves (0.99), sand (0.92), Dictyota adnata (0.76) and Gracilaria sp. (0.62).
TROPHIC ECOLOGY OF KEMP’S RIDLEY TURTLES IN THE CHARLOTTE HARBOR
ESTUARY, FLORIDA
Jeffrey R. Schmid1, Anton D. Tucker2, Bradley D. MacDonald3, and Jeffrey A. Seminoff3
1
Conservancy of Southwest Florida, Naples, Florida, USA
Mote Marine Laboratory, Sarasota, Florida, USA
3
NOAA/NMFS Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, California, USA
2
Analysis of stable isotopes has become an increasingly common tool for investigating the trophic
relationships of marine turtles, but such information is lacking for Kemp’s ridleys in coastal waters.
Ongoing research efforts in southwest Florida have identified a locality in Charlotte Harbor as foraging
grounds for Kemp’s ridleys. The purpose of the present study was to determine the trophic status and
foraging ecology of the turtles inhabiting this estuarine complex. Kemp’s ridleys (n = 80, including 5
recaptures) were captured via strike net and held overnight in a seawater tank for fecal sample collection.
Prior to release turtles were measured, flipper and PIT tagged, and skin biopsy samples were collected for
stable isotope analysis. Samples were also collected from decapod prey and habitat components (seagrass,
macroalgae, and sessile invertebrates) to characterize the food web in the study area. All but the smallest
(24 – 31 cm) Kemp’s ridleys in Pine Island Sound fed upon spider crabs including adult-size (> 60 cm)
158
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
turtles. As such, the aggregation in these nearshore waters appears to be opportunistic foragers utilizing the
most readily available prey. Kemp’s ridleys occupied the highest trophic level in the study area, but
enrichment in δ15N from primary prey to predator was less than expected and more similar to that of
published values for captive juvenile loggerheads. There was no evidence of an ontogenetic shift in stable
isotope values for smaller size classes of Kemp’s ridleys; however, turtles > 50 cm exhibited higher δ34S
and, to a lesser degree, δ15N values. Decapod prey in the Charlotte Harbor estuary demonstrated temporal
and possibly spatial variation in their isotope signatures. The seasonal pattern was less pronounced in
Kemp’s ridleys and warrants investigation using a tissue with a higher isotopic turnover. Future
applications to these data will include isotope mixing models to compare estimates of prey contribution to
that observed in the diet studies.
CALETA CHASCOS IN NORTHERN CHILE: RESEARCH AND CONSERVATION IN THE
MOST AUSTRAL FORAGING SITE FOR BLACK TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS AGASSIZII)
Cristián E. Squella, Marcela A. Mella, Carlos Canales, and Rocío E. Álvarez
Qarapara Sea Turtles, Chile
The most austral congregation of black turtles (Chelonia mydas agassizii) in the Eastern Pacific is located
in Caleta Chascos, Bahía Salado, in northern Chile. Chelonia mydas agassizii occurs here with Zostera
chilensis, an endemic species of seagrass that is located only in two sites in northern Chile. Historically, the
diets of benthic juveniles and adults of Chelonia mydas consist primarily of algae and seagrasses, although
some Eastern Pacific populations have omnivorous diets. Sporadic studies on the black turtle population at
Caleta Chascos have been conducted and the presence of algae has been considered a possible factor in
promoting this congregation. However, to date, there is no information about the importance of Z. chilensis
for this population of C. mydas agassizii. In April 2012, we conducted the first campaign of identification
and monitoring of C. mydas agassizii and Zostera chilensis in Caleta Chascos, together with a description
of the habitat (biotic and abiotic). Bahía Salado was divided into six sectors in which coastal sightings and
water temperatures were recorded daily. Additionally, underwater explorations were conducted to identify
the species of flora and fauna presnt and the distribution patterns of seagrasses. We identified a total of at
least 8 C. mydas agassizii juveniles and adults in Caleta Chascos inside an area of 0.13 km2. Here turtles
remain near the coast and their foraging areas which coincide with the presence of Z. chilensis, suggesting
that this species is part of their diet. Water temperature ranged from 17.5ºC-19ºC and the highest values
were recorded in the congregation area of turtles, where there is also a high abundance of algae. In Bahía
Salado we identified algae belonging to the genera Lessonia, Ulva, Chaetomorpha and Macrocystis. In
addition we observed the presence of several species of cnidarians, sponges, mollusks and crustaceans. All
of these groups have been described as part of the diet of the black turtle. Additionally, we conducted
workshops with the Totoral community, a small town close to the study area, in order to provide
information about this important foraging site for black turtles and educate locals about the ecosystem
dynamics and fragility. Currently we are continuing studies on trophic ecology of C. mydas agassizii and
biological value of Caleta Chascos in order to propose this area as a marine protected area in the future.
159
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ECOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF DIFFERENCES IN ABUNDANCE OF JUVENILE GREEN
TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ON NEARSHORE REEFS IN SOUTHEAST FLORIDA
Melanie Stadler1, Charles Roberts2, and Michael Salmon1
1
2
Department of Biological Sciences, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Department of Geosciences, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Nearshore reefs in southeast Florida function as important developmental habitats for juvenile green sea
turtles (Chelonia mydas). Turtles recruit to these habitats after spending the first years of their lives as
oceanic omnivores. A gradual dietary shift occurs when juveniles return to coastal waters and begin feeding
as herbivores on the reef. Nearshore reefs provide turtles with algae to sustain growth, as well as shelter
from predators. Differences exist in turtle densities from one reef location to the next. However, little is
known about what characteristics turtles use to select nearshore habitats. One important characteristic of the
nearshore reef environment is its lack of stability. Reef habitats fluctuate with sand exposure and changes
in current and wave action associated with storms. The extent of these changes over time and how they
affect green turtle fidelity to reef areas are still unknown. This study had two objectives: to quantify
differences in green turtle abundance on local nearshore reefs and to determine the ecological factors most
closely correlated with those differences. We measured turtle abundance on several reefs over time and
compared the differences in abundance with two ecological variables: (i) algal abundance and distribution
and (ii) nearshore reef stability over time. We hypothesized that green turtles would be more abundant on
reefs exposed for longer time periods, as these should contain a more stable environment for resting sites
and abundant distribution of food (preferred algal species). We conducted quarterly in-water surveys at six
reef locations in Palm Beach and Broward Counties, Florida, USA, and found that the turtles were
consistently more abundant on some reefs than on others. We also found that turtles at some reef sites
disappeared when those sites were covered by shifting sands. We are presently comparing sites showing
density differences with respect to (i) algal species abundance and composition, (ii) substrate type, (iii)
width and length of exposed reef, (iv) water depth, and (v) available light. We are analyzing these data to
determine which variables are most closely correlated with differences in turtle abundance. We are also
analyzing historical aerial images of nearshore reefs in Palm Beach and Broward Counties to determine the
percentage of change in exposed reef area over a 10-year period.
SUMMARIZING IN-WATER SEA TURTLE RESEARCH IN ST. JOSEPH BAY, FLORIDA
Brail S. Stephens1, Caitlin E. Hackett1, Margaret M. Lamont2, and Raymond R. Carthy3
1
Department of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA
U.S. Geological Survey, Southeast Regional Science Center, Gainesville, FL, USA
3
U.S. Geological Survey, Florida Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Department of Wildlife
Ecology and Conservation, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL USA
2
In-water studies of sea turtle populations in near-shore coastal habitats are important for examining trends
in the composition, abundance, distribution, and health of this imperiled marine vertebrate. Little
knowledge exists regarding the biology and ecology of sea turtles in near-shore environments, especially in
temperate developmental habitats. St. Joseph Bay is a coastal lagoon located in the northern Gulf of
Mexico. It is characterized by low current regimes, limited freshwater inflow, and high salinities, and
supports one of the most dense seagrass stocks in Florida. Hypothermic stunning events have highlighted
the heavy use of this coastal habitat by juvenile turtles and in 2001, researchers at the Florida Cooperative
160
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Fish and Wildlife Research Unit at the University of Florida began studying the assemblage of turtles using
St. Joseph Bay. This 4-year study demonstrated the importance of St. Joseph Bay as a developmental
ground for juvenile green, Kemps ridley, and loggerhead turtles; however this study was terminated in 2005.
Because of the demonstrated importance of this habitat to in-water populations of sea turtles and the
vulnerability of these populations to events like the Deepwater Horizon Spill, we began capturing turtles
again in St. Joseph Bay in May 2011 to re-initiate a long-term mark-recapture program. The primary
objective of this presentation is to provide a summary of the first year of these captures from September
2011 through September 2012. During this time, we captured turtles using four methods: set netting, strikenetting, dip netting, and hand capture. After capture, all turtles were taken onboard the boat and metal
Inconel tags were applied to both front flippers and Passive Integrated Transponder (PIT) tags were
injected into the left front shoulder muscle. Body morphometrics including straight and curved carapace
measurements and mass were recorded. Skin biopsies and blood for genetic, stable isotope, and health
analyses were also collected. A total of 46 turtles (19 greens, 24 Kemp’s ridley’s, 2 loggerheads and 1
hawksbill) were caught during this year. In total, 13 turtles were caught by set net, 26 caught by strike-net,
6 caught by dip net, and 1 caught by hand capture. Turtles ranged in size from 25.8 cm to 83.4 cm (mean=
40.9 cm) curved carapace length (CCL min). Turtles in the 30-40 cm and 40-50 cm size classes were the
most frequently captured. The data being collected in this long-term project are contributing to
mark/recapture studies, satellite tracking, population dynamics and structure, and the overall understanding
of the biology of juvenile sea turtles.
MIGRATIONS OF POST NESTING AND MOVEMENTS OF JUVENILE HAWKSBILL
TURTLES (ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) OF AMERICAN SAMOA
Alden P. Tagarino1 and Katerine Schletz Saili2
1
2
Department of Marine and Wildlife Resources American Samoa, Pago Pago, American Samoa
Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon, USA
Migratory behavior of hawksbill turtle populations in American Samoa, a small group of seven islands in
the south Pacific (Tutuila Island: 14°16’S, 170°42’W) was unknown until recently. Five post nesting turtles,
five juveniles and one male turtle were satellite tagged. One post nesting turtle was satellite tagged on Ofu
Island, approximately 110km east of Tutuila, travelled a total distance of 5964 km (straight line distance:
3582 km) with the last transmission located near the Pitcairn Island. Of the other five post nesting turtles,
one travelled to Sava’i Island in Samoa, one travelled to the Cook Islands, and two travelled to the
southwest of Tutuila. Four of the five juvenile turtles exhibited site fidelity staying near Tutuila Island,
while one juvenile (CCL: 51.5cm) travelled southwest to the Cook Islands area. The only male hawksbill
stayed around the island of Tutuila. These data reinforce the recent findings that hawksbills are indeed
migratory, capable of traveling long distances. A regional approach of management efforts is imperative to
ensure effective conservation.
161
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
STABLE NITROGEN ISOTOPES IN THALASSIA TESTUDINUM ON THE FEEDING GROUNDS
OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN AKUMAL, QUINTANA ROO, MEXICO
Ana L. Talavera1, Alberto Sánchez1, Concepción Ortiz2, Sergio Aguíñiga1, and Eduardo Balart3
1
Centro Interdisciplinario de Ciencias Marinas - Instituto Politécnico Nacional. La Paz, B.C.S. Mexico
El Colegio de la Frontera Sur, Chetumal, Quintana Roo, Mexico
3
Centro de Investigaciones Biológicas del Noroeste, La Paz, B.C.S., Mexico
2
Akumal Bay is an important foraging area for juvenile green turtles and is considered to have mediumtouristic impact on the site in comparison with surrounding areas. However, tourism may be affecting
nutrient load in the region. In order to assess changes in the nutrient load, δ15N was analyzed in seagrass
from Akumal Bay. Samples of Thalassia testudinum were collected during dry season (February) of 2011
and 2012. The δ15N values obtained in both years were similar (7.3-7.0 ‰). When compared to previous
studies, T. testudinum has not shown significant change in the isotopic composition of N in the last seven
years. Nevertheless, these values are considered enriched compared to other sites. This enrichment may be
associated with an increase of touristic development, thus continuous monitoring of N in the environment is
suggested. The anthropogenic N input has the potential to environmentally impact the seagrass meadows,
and consequently all species associated with it, including sea turtles. Funding for this project was provided
by CONACYT (SEP-CONACYT 157993), and CICIMAR-IPN (SIP-IPN 20120689 and 20130541). We
thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries
Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack,
Telonics and CLS America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for the grant support.
INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL DIET VARIATION IN A GENERALIST POPULATION? FORAGING
ECOLOGY OF GREEN TURTLES IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA BASED ON TURTLE-BORNE
VIDEO AND STABLE ISOTOPES
Jordan A. Thomson, Derek A. Burkholder, and Michael R. Heithaus
Florida International University, North Miami, Florida, USA
We used turtle-borne video and stable isotope analysis to study the foraging ecology of green turtles
(Chelonia mydas) in Shark Bay, Western Australia. In previous work, wide variation in δ13C signatures in
skin samples, not related to sex or body size, suggested a diverse diet at the population level, and the
potential for long-term dietary variation among individuals. New turtle-borne video data, obtained using
affordable tags fitted with GoPro cameras, confirm that green turtles in Shark Bay have a highly general
population-level diet that includes temperate and tropical seagrasses, benthic macroalgae, sponges and
gelatinous macroplankton. Preliminary analysis supports the potential for among-individual variation in
diet, and confirms a low overall consumption of seagrasses despite ca. 4000 km2 of seagrass coverage in
Shark Bay. For example, in 2011, 12 of 16 turtles that fed frequently during camera deployments consumed
some combination of macroalgae, plankton and sponges despite high availability of seagrasses. Future
work will determine whether short-term dietary preferences from video data align with isotope signatures
for these individuals to more rigorously test the hypothesis that wide δ13C variation reflects long-term,
individual-level dietary variation.
162
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TRACKING HABITAT USE AND LIFE HISTORY PATTERNS OF EAST PACIFIC GREEN
TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) USING STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSIS WITH
SKELETOCHRONOLOGY*
Cali Turner Tomaszewicz1, Carolyn Kurle1, Hoyt Peckham2, Larisa Avens3, Lisa Goshe3, Victor de la
Toba2, Juan M. Rguez-Baron4, Bradley MacDonald5, and Jeffrey Seminoff5
1
University of California, San Diego, Biological Sciences Division- Ecology, Behavior & Evolution
Department, La Jolla, California, USA
2
Grupo Tortuguero, La Paz, Baja California Sur, Mexico
3
NOAA/NMFS Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Beaufort, North Carolina, USA
4
Universidad Autónoma de Baja California Sur, La Paz, Baja California Sur, Mexico
5
NOAA/NMFS Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, California, USA
The green turtle (Chelonia mydas) population in the Eastern Pacific Ocean is listed as endangered on the
IUCN Red List and by the U.S. Endangered Species Act. Once the target of a large fishery that peaked in
the 1970s, this population is gradually recovering, and, despite decades of ongoing research, much of these
turtles’ complex life history remains unknown. Elucidating the duration of time turtles spend in distinct
habitats – particularly in the remote pelagic habitats of the Eastern Pacific – is critical to successful
conservation as threats and management strategies vary greatly between coastal and open ocean habitats.
Here we describe the general patterns of habitat use by Eastern Pacific green turtles among sequential years,
obtained by a novel method combining stable isotope analysis with skeletochronology. Our goal is to
determine the duration of the pelagic juvenile stage (i.e., the “lost years”) of green turtles in the Eastern
Pacific and improve understanding of green turtle ontogeny. We first applied skeletochronology to identify
and measure annual growth marks in cross sections of turtle humeri. Using this technique, we also
estimated the size (curved carapace length, CCL) of the turtle at each incremental growth mark. Sequential
bulk bone samples were then micromilled for stable isotope analysis. We then identified habitat use over
time by comparing stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope values of sequential humerus bone
growth layers. The δ13C and δ15N values reflect a turtle’s geographic location and diet because isotopes
vary between habitats (δ13C varies between neritic vs. oceanic, northern vs. southern latitude, and pelagic
vs. benthic habitats) and trophic levels (δ15N becomes enriched with each trophic step). Analysis of both
δ13C and δ15N gradients in bone layers allows us to predict turtle foraging and movement patterns over time,
including potential habitat shifts. For this turtle population, we identify ontogenetic shifts from the pelagic
juvenile stage to the neritic juvenile and adult stages. Results from 14 green turtles (CCL 51 - 95 cm)
collected from beach strandings along the Pacific coast of Baja California, Mexico from 2004 – 2011 are
included in this analysis and the δ15N values of the bulk bone tissue show trends in trophic level that appear
to correlate with life stages, growth rates and ontogenetic shifts. The mean δ15N values of new recruits and
subadult turtles (estimated CCL < 70cm) were significantly higher than the δ15N values of adult-sized
turtles (estimated CCL > 70cm), 15.9 ± 2.0 ‰, and 13.0 ± 0.9 ‰ (mean ± SD) respectively, p<0.0001.
These results support the hypothesis that juvenile pelagic and newly recruited green turtles forage
omnivorously and at a higher trophic level, which can support more rapid growth, than adult neritic turtles.
This approach grants us insight into patterns of habitat use and ecology of Eastern Pacific green turtles over
time. Acknowledgments: We thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek,
Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and UCSD for providing assistance to attend the 33rd Symposium.
163
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
GREEN TURTLES: CREATURES OF HABIT*
Hannah B. Vander Zanden, Karen A. Bjorndal, and Alan B. Bolten
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research and Department of Biology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
FL, USA
Not all individuals in a population use the same subset of resources. Patterns of individual specialization
have been documented in an increasing number of organisms, but there have been few studies to examine
individual specialization through the ontogeny of an organism. We quantify and compare temporal
consistency in resource use and individual specialization in three life stages of the green turtle (Chelonia
mydas) using stable isotope analysis of carbon and nitrogen in successive subsections of scute tissue from
the carapace. The three life stages include adults, neritic juveniles, and oceanic juveniles. Temporal
consistency was measured through the mean intra-individual variation in stable isotope values through time,
whereas the degree of individual specialization was calculated as a ratio of the individual variation to that
of the whole population. The scute record maintains a chronological history of resource use and was
estimated to represent a minimum 0.8 years in juveniles to a maximum of 6.5 years in adults. Both
temporal consistency and individual specialization varied significantly among life stages. Adults were
highly consistent through time, and individual site specialists formed a generalist population with
individuals maintaining long-term fidelity to foraging location and trophic level. Oceanic and neritic
juvenile life stages trended toward less temporal consistency in resource use with less individual
specialization than adults. These observations are important when considering the ecological roles filled by
green turtles in each life stage; individual differences in resource use may result in differential fitness
consequences.
WINTER DIETS OF IMMATURE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ON A NORTHERN
FEEDING GROUND: INTEGRATING STOMACH CONTENTS AND STABLE ISOTOPE
ANALYSES
Natalie C. Williams1, Karen A. Bjorndal2, Margaret M. Lamont1, and Raymond R. Carthy1
1
Florida Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, U.S. Geological Survey, Department of Wildlife
Ecology and Conservation, University of Florida, Gainesville FL, USA
2
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research University of Florida, Gainesville FL, USA 3 Department of
Biology, University of Florida, Gainesville FL, USA
The foraging ecology and diet of the green turtle, Chelonia mydas, remain understudied, particularly in
peripheral areas of its distribution. We assessed the diet of an aggregation of juvenile green turtles at the
northern edge of its range during winter months using two approaches. Stomach content analyses provide a
single time sample and stable isotope analyses integrate diet over a several-month period. We evaluated
diet consistency by comparing the results of these two approaches. We examined stomach contents from 64
green turtles that died during cold stunning events in St. Joseph Bay, Florida, in 2008 and 2011. Stomach
contents were evaluated for volume, dry mass, percent frequency of occurrence, and index of relative
importance of individual diet items. Juvenile green turtles were omnivorous, feeding primarily on seagrass
and tunicates. Diet characterizations from stomach contents differed from those based on stable isotope
analyses, indicating the turtles are not feeding consistently during winter months.
164
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DOES A TROPICAL STORM AFFECT THE INTERNESTING BEHAVIOR OF A
LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE?
Maria Wilson1, Anton D. Tucker2, and David A. Mann3
1
University of South Florida, St. Petersburg, Florida, USA
Mote Marine Laboratory, Sarasota, Florida, USA
3
Loggerhead Instruments, Sarasota, Florida, USA
2
Newly developed animal motion tags (OpenTag, Loggerhead Instruments) with 3-axis accelerometers, 3axis gyroscopes, 3-axis magnetometers (sample rate 100 Hz), and temperature and pressure sensors (sample
rate 1 Hz) were attached to six female Loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) together with satellite tags
at Casey Key, Florida between May 2012 and July 2012. Two tags were successfully retrieved during renesting. One tag was recovered at the same beach where the turtles were tagged and another one at a distant
beach (Keewaydin Island). Four tags were not recovered because the turtles had moved to nearby islands
north or south of the study site. The two recovered tags contained continuous 15-day and 16-day recordings,
respectively. One tag was deployed when tropical storm Debby passed through the Gulf of Mexico,
whereas the other was deployed during relative benign sea states. We analyzed whether the tropical storm
affected the swimming and diving behavior of the loggerhead sea turtle as a function of time spent at the
surface, dive profiles, and fluke rates. We find that the before the tropical storm the turtle spent 7.4% of the
time at the surface (0-0.5 meters) and 20% of the time in the upper water column (0-5 meters). During the
tropical storm the turtle spent 14% of the time at the surface (0-0.5 meters) and 55% of the time in the
upper water column (0-5 meters).
OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION OF THE BARNACLE STEPHANOLEPAS MURICATA
FISHER,1886, ON SEA TURTLES IN THE GOLFO DULCE, PACIFIC, COSTA RICA
Nadège Zaghdoudi-Allan
Lund University, Lund, Sweden
The Golfo Dulce, in Pacific Costa Rica, is utilized as a foraging habitat by green and hawksbill sea turtles.
Immature and adult turtles are sympatric in this tropical fjord-like embayment throughout the year. And,
seasonal migrations by post-nesting green turtles to and from distant rookeries, such as the Galapagos
Islands, influence the cheloniid population structure observed in the Golfo Dulce. The barnacle,
Stephanolepas muricata, is a commensal of turtles in the Golfo Dulce, and evidence derived from recent inwater captures suggests that post-nesting green turtles are colonized by S. muricata when they enter the
neritic habitats of the eastern Pacific. And, it appears likely that the same turtles carry this embedding,
potentially injurious barnacle species with them when they return to distant courting/mating areas and
nesting beaches. The current presentation introduces and discusses the aforementioned scenarios, and data
on the biology of S. muricata from the Golfo Dulce are also presented.
165
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Nesting Biology
EVALUATION OF HAWKSBILL TURTLE STATUS ALONG THE DARIEN GAP-CHOCÓ
REGION OF PACIFIC PANAMA AND COLOMBIA
Diego F. Amorocho1, Alexander Tobón López2, M. Alejandra Jaramillo2, Marino E. Abrego3, and
Alexander R. Gaos4
1
World Wildlife Foundation (WWF)
Centro de Investigación para el Manejo Ambiental y el Desarrollo (CIMAD)
3
Autoridad de los Recursos Acuáticos de Panamá (ARAP)
4
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative (ICAPO)
2
Hawksbill turtles inhabiting the eastern Pacific Ocean are considered one of the world’s most endangered
sea turtle populations. The Darien Gap-Chocó region constitues an extensive stretch of approximately 300
kilometers along the Pacific coast of Panama and Colombia, which has never been investigated for the
presence of marine turtles. Between March and May of 2012 a total of 16 coastal communities were visited
along the Darien Gap-Chocó region to conduct local interviews and evaluate the potential existence of
hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata) nesting sites and to generate information on the status of the species in
the region. A total of 68 interviews were conducted in both countries, primarily with fishermen. In
Colombia, interviewees reported a total of 14 beaches where hawksbills nest, most of which is considered
sporadic (1-20 nests/season) with the exception of Chaquera, where approximately 21-50 nests are
reportedly deposisted per season. In Panama, interviewees reported a total of 22 beaches where hawksbills
nest, most of which is also sporadic (i.e. 1-20 nests/season). However, four beaches were reported to
receive 21-50 nests per season, while another beach (Sugaran) was reported to receive more than 75 nests
per season. The overwhelming majority of nests were reported to be poached at rates of 95-100% in both
countries and locals reported that hawksbills were much more abundant in the past. Nonetheless, locals also
reported that hawksbills can be frequently seen year-round at in-water habitats along the coasts of both
countries. It is vital to corroborate the reported nesting at the primary beaches to evaluate the potential for
establishing conservation projects for hawksbills. Local stakeholders showed a strong desire and
willingness to collaborate with research and conservation efforts in both countries. We recommend a binational plan to undertake such research that incorporates local community members in monitoring efforts,
thus factilitating the evaluation and promotion of potential conservation and management plans. Such
efforts will be vital to hawksbill recovery efforts in the eastern Pacific.
CHARACTERIZING THE INTER-NESTING BEHAVIOR OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
(CARETTA CARETTA) AT KYPARISSIA BAY, GREECE
Thomas F. Backof1,2, Stephen J. Morreale3, Thomas Riggall2, and Frank V. Paladino1
1
Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne, Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA
ARCHELON, the Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Athens, GREECE
3
Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA.
2
The second most important loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta) rookery in the Mediterranean Sea is found
along Kyparissia Bay, Greece. Recently, the number of nesting females at this site has begun to increase,
concurrent with local human activity (e.g. tourism, and beach development). There is currently no
governmental protection of this rookery’s beaches or bay habitats. Due to these facts, understanding of the
habitat usage of loggerhead turtles will help guide potential conservation efforts. The inter-nesting behavior
166
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of loggerhead turtles was studied with temperature and depth loggers (TDLs, deployed on 13 turtles) along
with GPS satellite transmitters (seven turtles) at Kyparissia Bay. Six TDLs were recovered following a
subsequent nesting attempt. GPS transmitters were removed when the individual returned for a subsequent
nest, and redeployed providing both inter and post nesting data. TDL results show that the turtles
maintained a relatively constant thermal habitat, with combined average temperatures of 25.0 (±2.3 (SD))°
C. Minimum temperatures experienced by the turtles reached as low as 15.6° C, while maximum
temperatures exceeded 31.2 ° C. The turtles cumulatively spent 99.6% of their time in the top 5 m of the
water column (average depth 0.35 m, ±0.99 SD). Maximum dives were likely limited by the bathymetry of
the area; only two TDL points showed depth greater than 25 meters with the deepest point at 46 m. GPS
transmitter data showed inter-nesting locations within the Bay of Kyparissia, with turtles remaining within
5 kilometers of shore until post nesting began. In summary, the loggerhead turtles of Kyparissia Bay spend
the majority of their inter-nesting period close to the primary nesting area in the upper portion of the water
column.
MARINE TURTLE NESTING AT THE ARCHIE CARR NWR: ARE LOGGERHEADS MAKING
A COMEBACK?
Dean A. Bagley, William E. Redfoot, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
Dept. of Biology, University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL, USA
The UCF Marine Turtle Research Group has been studying nesting and reproductive success of
loggerheads, green turtles and leatherbacks in east central Florida since 1982. On this 21-km beach,
loggerhead nest numbers averaged 9,300 during the 1980s. These were the numbers that predicated the
formation of the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge in 1990. After its inception, nesting jumped by 52%
and continued to climb until 1998, culminating in an all time high of 17,629 nests. From 1998 until 2004,
nesting dropped in what has been described as a “steep and serious decline”, reaching an all-time low of
6,405 in 2007. Since then nesting has increased with some fluctuation to reach a high of 15,539 nests in the
most recent season (2012), just 2,090 nests (11.8%) fewer than the all time high in 1998. Florida green
turtles laid fewer than 50 nests annually for the first three years that UCF worked on the Carr Refuge beach.
With a few exceptions, green turtles exhibited a biennial pattern of high and low years through about 2005,
when low years began to increase as rapidly as high years and the pattern became more obscured, reaching
an all time high of 5,505 in 2011. Several tag recoveries from a 1980s Florida head start program confirm
that at least some green turtles are nesting at 15 to 18 years of age. The number of nests laid by Florida
green turtles ended at 3,023. Green turtle nesting continues to rise exponentially at the Carr Refuge.
Leatherback nesting ranged from zero to one throughout the decade of the 1980s and the first half of the
1990s. In 1996, however, there were 10 nests in the Car Refuge. Nesting dropped to 4 in 1997 but bounced
back in 1998, setting up a biennial pattern similar to that of green turtles. Low years remained at about 11
nests while high years continued to increase until 2008, when low years also began to increase. The high
years of 2007 and 2011 each produced 52 nests. The 2012 season was expected to be a low year and
finished with 37 nests. Leatherback nesting also continues to rise exponentially at the Carr Refuge.
167
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
LONG-TERM MONITORING AND CONSERVATION OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
NESTS ON DALYAN BEACH, TURKEY: RESULTS OF THE RECENT CONSERVATION
AFFORDS
Eyup Başkale1, Yusuf Katılmıs1, Mücahit Seçme2, Çisem Sezgin2, and Yakup Kaska1
1
2
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli-Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli-Turkey
Dalyan Beach is one of the most important nesting sites of loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) in Turkey.
Dalyan Beach was designated as a Specially Protected Area by the Turkish Ministry of Environment and
Forestry in 1988. Nesting activity and conservation actions were started from 1988 breeding season and
generally performed between 1 June and 30 September for subsequent years. The mean nest count was
found as 230 nests for each year and the nest density was calculated as 49 nests per kilometer. The
minimum nest number occurred in 1994 nesting season with 86 nests and the maximum nest was observed
in 2010 nesting season with 354 nests. Nesting and non-nesting emergences were distributed 10-25m
distance from the sea during breeding period. The majority of nesting activities by females occurred in June
but started in the second half of May. These results show similarities in all years. The main predator was
red foxes, badgers and ghost crabs. Approximately 60% of nests were screened against predation each year,
with the screens being fixed with long metal hooks from the corners for additional safety. As a result of
protection efforts, the last 5 year period (2008-2012 breeding seasons) the average number of nests was
calculated as 308 nests per year. The mean hatching success was calculated as 51.9% (range from 33.52%
to 69.17%). The recent increase in recorded nesting numbers can be explained by either the result of the
first conservation efforts started nearly 20 years ago or better record of nesting activities especially early in
the nesting season or a combination of both. While the observed predation rate seems to be higher than that
documented in the literature, Dalyan Beach demonstrates a very good example of coexistence of turtles and
tourists.
EXAMINING HERITABILITY IN NEST-SITE SELECTION FOR LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
(CARETTA CARETTA) USING ADVANCED GENETIC AND SPATIAL TECHNIQUES
Bonnie E. Berry1, Brian M. Shamblin1, Mark G. Dodd2, Kristina L. Williams3, Joseph B. Pfaller3,
Gale A. Bishop4, and Campbell J. Nairn1
1
Daniel B. Warnell School of Forestry & Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia, USA
Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Brunswick, Georgia, USA
3
Caretta Research Project, Savannah, Georgia, USA
4
St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, Georgia, USA
2
Deposition of eggs into a suitable environment for embryonic development is the final parental obligation
for many oviparous species and nest-site selection is critical to offspring survival. For marine turtles, the
elevation of a nest relative to the spring tide line is of particular importance as nests laid below the high
water mark are vulnerable to tidal inundation, which can lead to developmental arrest of incubating
embryos. The correlation between incubation environment and offspring viability suggests the potential for
evolutionary pressures to act on marine turtle nest-site preferences. Specifically, if some females
consistently nest at elevations prone to inundation and this trait is passed to their surviving female offspring,
the frequency of females nesting at low elevations should eventually decrease through natural selection.
168
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
There are concerns that management strategies, such as clutch relocation, may impose artificial selection on
marine turtle populations and unwittingly propagate an undesirable trait (i.e. poor nest-site selection) that
would have otherwise been selected against. However, variation between individuals and heritability in
nest-site selection must be established before the potential evolutionary consequences of clutch relocation
on marine turtle populations can be examined. The objective of this study is to investigate evidence for
individual variation and heritability in nest-site selection for loggerheads (Caretta caretta) nesting on the
Georgia coast. Elevational variation in nest-sites among females will indicate the potential for selection to
act on individuals within the nesting population and individual repeatability in nest elevations will suggest
a genetic basis for the behavior. We are estimating intra- and inter-seasonal repeatability and variation in
nest elevations for individual, genetically tagged females from the 2008, 2009, 2011, and 2012 nesting
seasons. Our data includes elevations for over 900 nests laid on Wassaw, Ossabaw, St. Catherines,
Blackbeard, and Sapelo islands. Examining nest elevation data from multiple seasons allows us to test for
inter-annual repeatability in nest-site selection for females that nested in 2008 or 2009 and re-migrated in
2011 or 2012. Each nest is matched to an individual female using multi-locus genotypes (DNA
fingerprinting) as a genetic tag, and a precision RTK GNSS receiver with a vertical accuracy of ± 3 cm is
used to quantify nest and tide-line elevations. The difficulties associated with estimating heritability in
quantitative behavioral traits can hinder the ability to make appropriate management decisions concerning
the protection of threatened species. A comprehensive analysis of variation and heritability in nest-site
selection in terms of inundation risk will provide quantitative data to evaluate the potential evolutionary
consequences of clutch relocation on marine turtle populations.
IMPLICATIONS OF HATCHLING SEX RATIOS AND SURVIVAL IN THE RECOVERY
PROGRAM FOR THE ENDANGERED KEMP’S RIDLEY SEA TURTLE
Elizabeth Bevan1, Amy Bonka2, Tony Torres2, Diana J. Lira-Reyes2, Thane Wibbels1, Marco Antonio
Castro Martínez3, Hector J. Martinez-Ortíz2, Jaime Peña2, Patrick M. Burchfield2, Earl Possardt4,
and Barbara Schroeder5
1
University of Alabama at Birmingham, AL, USA
Gladys Porter Zoo, Brownsville, TX, USA
3
CONANP, Rancho Nuevo, Tamaulipas, Mexico
4
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Carrolton, GA, USA
5
NMFS, NOAA, Silver Springs, MD, USA
2
The Kemp’s ridley sea turtle was on the verge of extinction during the mid 1980’s, but due to intense
conservation efforts, its population is now gradually recovering. As part of that recovery program, we have
been monitoring the production of hatchling sex ratios produced at Rancho Nuevo, Mexico, in an effort to
optimize the recovery rate of this species. In the current study, sand and nest temperatures were evaluated
during the 2010, 2011, and 2012 nesting seasons. Beach and egg corral temperatures were monitored at
nest depth using temperature data loggers. Incubation temperatures were also monitored in a subset of nests
in egg corrals and on the natural nesting beach from each season. General trends in temperature were
evident during all nesting seasons. Temperatures were relatively cool during the start of the nesting seasons
(i.e. below pivotal temperature), but gradually rose and were at, or above, pivotal temperatures by mid May.
Temperatures then remained relatively high for the remainder of the nesting seasons, except during periods
when tropical weather systems moved through the area and lowered incubation temperatures to near or
below the pivotal temperature. Thus, although an overall female bias would be predicted for each nesting
season, some nests early in the nesting season or those subjected to tropical weather systems were predicted
to produce males. The nesting beach was also relatively warm (suggesting a female bias) but it was cooler
than the egg corrals. Collectively, the data suggest that female-biased sex ratios were produced during the
2010, 2011, and 2012 nesting seasons at Rancho Nuevo. Subsets of in situ nests from arribadas during the
2011 and 2012 nesting seasons were monitored for predation throughout their period of incubation. These
data suggest that the predation rate on in situ nests was relatively low. Additionally, survival of hatchlings
169
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
from the nest to the surf is being evaluated for both low and high density in situ nesting areas from the 2012
nesting season. The results have ecological and conservation implications for the Kemp’s ridley. For
example, the production of a female bias in the Kemp’s Ridley Recovery Program may be accelerating the
recovery rate of this endangered sea turtle. Additionally, the evaluation of predation data supports the
concept that arribadas may result in predator satiation, thus enhancing nest and hatching survival. Therefore,
leaving arribada nests in situ, may be an effective conservation strategy. The sex ratio and predation studies
are providing data which are helping to facilitate an effective transition from the use of egg corrals back to
the use of the natural nesting beach as the Kemp’s ridley recovers.
AIR-DAM ENTRAPMENT OF EMERGING LOGGERHEAD HATCHLINGS, ST. CATHERINES
ISLAND, GEORGIA: A CASE OF OBSTRUCTED EMERGENCE
Gale A. Bishop1, Kenneth F. Clark2, Edward J. Davis1, Doris Davis1, Martha L. Schriver2, and R.
Kelly Vance2
1
2
St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, GA, USA
Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, GA, USA
Loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta (Linnaeus, 1758)) nest on the sandy beaches of the Georgia coast,
depositing clutches averaging 113 eggs in the backbeach sand where they incubate for approximately 50 60 days (average of 56 days in 2008 and 54 days in 2009) prior to emergence during the night. Nestlings
mine their way from the top of the egg chamber from a depth of about 30 - 50 cm to the surface by a
process similar to shrinkage stoping, i.e. bumping sand loose above them, which falls onto and through the
mass of nestlings forming a floor on top of the hatched egg shells at the bottom of the egg chamber
(approximately 50 cm deep). The stope thus formed allows the turtles to mine their way to the surface,
where they emerge under the cover of darkness. Rain and wind storms may increase the cohesion of the
surface layer of sand during incubation while trampling compacts the underlying floor, opening an air
chamber above the hatchlings that is higher than their heads will reach, stopping the stoping process by
formation of an "air-dam." This process, first observed in 1996 in Nest 96-108a, was documented by
observations made on two loggerhead sea turtle nests, 07-042a and 08-097a, on St. Catherines Island,
Georgia, investigated by trenching techniques and documented by sketching, photography, and
videography and has been documented in six additional nests and often observed, but not documented in
numerous other nests, both in situ and relocated over 22 years. Clutches of nestlings trapped by airdammed stoping are vulnerable to desiccation, depredation, and drowning. It was found that: 1. airdammed stopes form during every nesting season; 2. air-dammed stopes form in both in insitu and
relocated nests; 3. hatchlings trapped by air-dammed stopes may die due to subsequent flooding,
desiccation, or depredation; 4. air-dammed stopes may be anticipated by identifying “late-nests,” i.e. those
that don’t emerge on time; and 5. nests may be checked by careful excavation straight down into the egg
chamber; checking for a “collapsing domed roof” (an air-dam) when penetrated by one’s finger. The
common development of air-dammed stopes should be anticipated by the conservationist. When indicated
by late emergence, the conservationist should carefully dig vertically using his/her hand excavating as
small a vertical tunnel as possible to ascertain whether or not an air-dammed stope exists. Further treatment
may involve backfilling the excavation tunnel or removal and release of hatchings. Development of airdammed stopes is thought to be encouraged by over-tamping sand backfill in relocated egg chamber necks
at the time of their relocation or by intense, local rainfall or deposition of wind blown sand near the time of
the nest’s anticipated emergence. This phenomenon, documented in modern nesting loggerhead sea turtles,
is represented as a trace fossil in the Cretaceous Fox Hills Sandstone of Colorado.
170
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EFFECTS OF HABITAT VARIABILITY ON ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA INCUBATION
TEMPERATURES: A PILOT STUDY ON LONG ISLAND, ANTIGUA
Charlie Braman1, Jonathan Pahlas2, and Seth Stapleton3
1
Jumby Bay Hawksbill Project, Long Island, Antigua, West Indies
Department of Marine Sciences, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA
3
Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Conservation Biology, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN, USA
2
Incubation temperature strongly affects sea turtle physiological development, especially through
temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD). However, field experiments have demonstrated
significant inter and intra-nest temperature variability across all sea turtle species. Further, previous work
has shown that E. imbricata nest habitats are particularly vulnerable to deforestation, which could result in
sex ratio distortion toward a more female-biased population as average nest temperatures increase. TSD
and natural nest temperature variation, in addition to increased habitat change from vegetation loss, climate
change, and beach stochasticity, make it extremely relevant to better document and understand nest
temperature variation of understudied organisms such as hawksbill sea turtles. During late July through
early November, 2012, we conducted a pilot study on Pasture Bay, Long Island, Antigua to evaluate
temperature variability between nesting habitat types. We placed HOBO Water Temperature Pro v2 data
loggers at various heights within egg chambers and control data loggers 0.5 m from the egg chamber at the
same depth. Egg chamber loggers remained in situ for the entirety of incubation, while controls were
removed and used to determine the temperature gradient with regards to depth within each habitat type. We
obtained soil cores from each nest post-hatch and performed ash free dry mass analysis of the sediment to
investigate differences in soil organic matter between habitats. Using a marked square meter, we also
quantified percentage shade cover at each nest to help classify the habitat gradient. Finally, we measured
nest distance to high tide line and distance to nearest vegetation edge. We used an ANOVA test to
determine if temperatures significantly varied between nesting habitats and regression analysis to evaluate
relationships of other environmental factors to nest chamber temperature. Based on this preliminary work,
soil moisture, distance to high tide, soil organic matter content, nest minimum and maximum depth, nest
egg count, shade/vegetation cover, and major storm activity all appear relevant to consider when looking at
incubation nest temperatures. Future research should focus not just on expanding the number of nests
sampled, but also more intensive study of secondary environmental factors affecting nest temperature.
Where possible, management of these factors could aid in buffering against further sex ratio distortion.
FIFTEEN YEARS OF RESEARCH ON GREEN TURTLES AT GUANAHACABIBES
PENINSULA: A RETROSPECTIVE OF COMMUNITY BASED TURTLE CONSERVATION AND
RESEARCH IN WESTERN CUBA
Fernando Bretos Trelles1, Julia Azanza Ricardo2, and Anton D. Tucker3
1
The Ocean Foundation
Center for Marine Research, University of Havana
3
Mote Marine Laboratory
2
The objective of this presentation is to provide a retrospective of data and experiences obtained over 15
years on an important green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas) population in extreme western Cuba. The Proyecto
Universitario para estudiar y conservar las tortugas marinas de la peninsula de Guanahacabibes is a project
of the Centro de Investigaciones Marinas de la Universidad de la Habana with support from The Ocean
171
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Foundation and WWF-Cuba. Since 1999 scientists and students have collected beach nesting data on a
population of up to 1,000 female green turtles. Female turtles lay their eggs along seven nesting beaches at
Guanahacabibes National Park and UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, a wild, relatively uninhabited coastal
area. The Project has accumulated continuous annual data on nest size, nesting frequency, environmental
impacts such as sand temperature and the impact of hurricanes for almost a decade and a half. Monitoring
data is helping piece together the life history patterns of the broader Western Atlantic green turtle
population and informing policy decisions by Cuban and regional governments to protect sea turtle
populations from poaching, incidental catch in fishing nets and egg collection by coastal communities.
Guanahacabibes National Park and UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, located on the westernmost tip of Cuba,
is located on the eastern flank of the Yucatan Straits, an important marine pathway for Western Atlantic
green turtles. The Project and its partner, The Ocean Foundation began efforts in 2012 to deploy satellite
telemetry to further understand the migratory patterns of this population. That year five tags were released
and another 5-10 will be released in subsequent years. The Project has also engaged local fishing
communities and a historical fishing community of Cocordilo in the Isle of Youth to transition from
poaching turtles and eggs to embracing alternative livelihoods. Two community festivals were held in
Cocodrilo in 2011 and 2012.
PRELIMINARY RESULTS FROM AKAZUL’S SEA TURTLE TAGGING PROGRAM, LA
BARRONA, GUATEMALA
Rachel Brittain, Sarah Lucas, and Scott Handy
Akazul: Community, Conservation & Ecology, Exeter, Devon, UK
Akazul: Community, Conservation & Ecology is a UK registered not-for-profit Community Interest
Company and has been operating its sea turtle conservation project in La Barrona, Guatemala since 2011.
La Barrona is one of Guatemala’s key nesting sites utilized primarily by olive ridley (Lepidochelys
olivacea) sea turtles and infrequently by eastern Pacific green (Chelonia mydas) and leatherback
(Dermochelys coriacea) sea turtles. Besides the general human impacts of coastal development, marine
pollution, and unselective fishing practices, unsustainable levels of egg-harvesting pose the greatest threat
to Guatemala’s sea turtles. Key to Akazul’s long-term goal is conducting monitoring activities on the turtle
nesting beach in order to further our understanding of Guatemala’s sea turtle populations. Akazul
conducted nightly beach patrols from 1st July-31st December 2011 between the hours of 19:30 and 06:00,
across a study area of 7.5 km. All turtles encountered were checked for existing tags and once egg laying
was complete, a monel flipper tag was applied to untagged fore flippers. Curved Carapace Length (CCL),
Curved Carapace Width (CCW) and clutch size were also recorded. Turtles were observed dring 225
(17.9%) of the 1,119 nesting emergences along the study area. A total of 191 olive ridley turtles and 1
eastern Pacific green sea turtle were tagged during the 2011 nesting season. Fourteen turtles were observed
on subsequent occasions returning to the nesting beach and mean interesting interval was 17.2 days (range:
10 days, SD = 3.2). Two of these turtles were observed 18 days later, nesting on beaches 28 and 45km west
of La Barrona. Mean CCL for 172 olive ridleys was 65.5 cm (range: 57-74 cm; SD = 2.5) and mean CCW
for 171 specimens was 70.2 cm (range 62-77 cm; SD = 2.7) respectively. La Barrona is the first site in
Guatemala to implement a standardised tagging program and preliminary results reveal individual variation
with regard to nest site fidelity, however, more intensive tagging efforts are required to fully quantify this
and other parameters such as clutch frequency and internesting intervals. It is highly recommended to
expand tagging studies to other sites across the coast to give a more accurate insight into the nesting
biology of Guatemala’s olive ridley sea turtles.
172
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
A MATHEMATICAL MODEL CONSISTENT WITH THE GEOMAGNETIC IMPRINTING
HYPOTHESIS OF NATAL HOMING
J. Roger Brothers and Kenneth J. Lohmann
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA
Sea turtles around the world are renowned for their migratory behavior and navigational abilities.
Loggerheads hatching in the southeastern United States are a particularly impressive group as they
circumnavigate the entire North Atlantic Ocean basin before returning to lay eggs in the same geographic
areas they left as hatchlings. This behavior, termed natal homing, is illustrated by a wealth of genetic
evidence from many sea turtle species. How turtles are able relocate their natal beach, however, remains
enigmatic. While the mechanism behind natal homing is still unknown, the recently proposed geomagnetic
imprinting hypothesis notes that the earth’s magnetic field varies geographically and that most nesting
beaches have unique geomagnetic signatures. Furthermore, loggerheads are known to detect the two
magnetic parameters that define these signatures: field intensity and inclination angle (the angle at which
magnetic field lines intersect the earth’s surface). The geomagnetic imprinting hypothesis proposes that
hatchling turtles imprint on the magnetic characteristics of their natal beaches and use this information to
return years later. One potential problem for animals using the Earth’s field to return to a specific area
during natal homing is that the field gradually shifts spatially over time. That is to say, a given geographic
location will not carry the same magnetic signature from year to year. Moreover, field intensity and
inclination angle change at different rates in different geographic areas. In principle, if the geomagnetic
imprinting hypothesis is correct, then changes in the earth’s field might cause shifts in nesting distributions.
Specifically, in areas where the magnetic signatures associated with turtle nesting beaches converge over
time we expect to see an increase in nest density; conversely areas characterized by a divergence of
magnetic signatures should experience a decrease in nest density. To investigate this novel hypothesis we
used the International Geomagnetic Reference Field (IGRF) model to calculate the distance magnetic fields
drifted along the eastern coast of Florida. With these data we described a mathematical function relating
position along the coast to spatial changes of the earth’s magnetic field at these positions. From this
function we generated a quantitative measure for the convergence or divergence of magnetic signatures at
various locations along the Florida coastline. We then modeled the relationship between this measure of
convergence or divergence and the corresponding change in loggerhead nest density. Using a linear model
to correlate these two variables, we found a highly significant slope in the appropriate direction, which
implies that areas with a high level of geomagnetic convergence also experienced greater increases in
loggerhead nest density. We do not claim to show that movement of the earth’s magnetic field is sufficient
to predict changes in nesting distribution. Rather, this study provides evidence consistent with the
hypothesis that turtles may be using information from the Earth’s magnetic field to locate nesting beaches.
Thus, we propose that further research into the geomagnetic imprinting hypothesis is greatly warranted.
MODELING INTRAGUILD PREDATION AND PREDATOR FACILITATION ON SHARED
PREY
Joshua Castro
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Interactions between raccoons (Procyon lotor), ghost crabs (Ocypode quadrata), and loggerheads (Caretta
caretta) are complex. Some of these interactions have negative consequences on hatching success of
173
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
loggerhead eggs. To reduce nest depredation by raccoons, managers at Canaveral National Seashore
(Florida, USA) install cages around clutches. Although this has had a positive effect on hatching success,
predation still accounts for a large percentage of pre-hatchling mortalities. Previous studies have shown that
in addition to intraguild predation (IGP) of ghost crabs by raccoons over marine turtle eggs, there is also a
facilitative interaction by ghost crabs to raccoons. When a ghost crab burrows into a sea turtle nest,
chemical cues signal foraging raccoons towards the nest’s location. Although experimental work has been
done on this topic, further research is needed in order to better understand the dynamics of this system and
the net effect on threatened marine turtles. We propose a mathematical model that explores the effects of
intraguild predation and predator facilitation on shared prey. The model attempts to mimic the interactions
among raccoons (intraguild predator), ghost crabs (intraguild prey) and federally threatened loggerhead
eggs (shared prey). The model is an extension of the Holt and Polis IGP model in which we add further
complexity, predator facilitation. Once established, we will assess the sensitivity of parameter values, e.g.,
functional responses and conversion efficiencies, to the general behavior of the model. We predict that
increasing intraguild prey numbers and decreasing intraguild predator numbers will have a negative effect
on shared prey population. This model can help influence predation management techniques by allowing
officials to view several consequences of this particular system. In this way, managers will be better
informed to develop and implement appropriate methods for predator control and marine turtle
conservation.
GREEN TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITIES ON ZABARGAD ISLAND, A MAJOR ROOKERY IN
THE SOUTHERN EGYPTIAN RED SEA
Islam El Sadek1, Agnese Mancini2, Mahmoud Hanafy3, and Marc Girondot4
1
Red Sea Protectorate, Shalateen, Egypt
HEPCA, Hurghada, Egypt
3
University of Suez Canal, Ismalaia, Egypt
4
Université Paris Sud, AgroParisTech and CNRS, Paris, France
2
The Red Sea is known to host nesting sites for the endangered green turtles. Known sites are located on the
northern coast of Saudi Arabia, in Djibuti, in Sudan and in Egypt. Nesting activities along the Egyptian
coast is scattered and low-density with three major concentrations: Tiran Island (Northern Red Sea), Wadi
Gimal National Park (Southern Red Sea, in-shore) and Zabargad Island (Southern Red Sea, off-shore).
Zabargad is considered the most important nesting site for green turtles in the region. Estimates obtained
from irregular surveys from 2001 to 2008 suggested that as many as 610 turtles could nest on the 3.5 km
long beach on the island. In order to collect more data on nesting activity on the island, we conducted two
3-day surveys in 2009 and 2010 and one 10-day survey in 2012 during the suspected peak of the nesting
season (July – August). In all occasions, during day 1 all turtle tracks were counted and marked to avoid
double counting. From day 1 to the last day, night census were conducted on foot along the beach. Only
new nesting activities were counted. Nesting success (NS) was calculated as the number of true nests
divided by the total number of tracks. The total number of nesting activities per season was calculated
using the method published by Girondot et al. In 2009, 50 tracks were counted, 5 of which being true nests
(NS=10%)(mean number of tracks per night=16.7±3.5). In 2010, 34 tracks were counted, 4 of which being
true nests (NS=12%)(mean number of tracks per night=11.3±8.7). In 2012, 127 tracks were counted, 35 of
which being true nests (NS=27%)(mean number of tracks per night=12.7±3.7). Assuming that the green
turtle nesting season on Zabargad island is bell-shaped, we obtained a total number of counts of 2,262.51
±531.27 in 2009; of 1,073.90 ±268.80 in 2010 and of 1887.29 ±388.97 in 2012. Assuming that the nesting
success was constant every year, and assuming that green turtles lay an average of 2.5 nests per season
(based on data from the Arabian Gulf and Oman populations), we obtained the following estimates for the
nesting females population: 91 in 2009, 52 in 2010 and 204 in 2012. These results are very far from the
estimates obtained from previous data. Effort and timing of data collection can have an effect on the
variation from 2009 to 2012 but this could also be related to other factors. As human impact on the island is
174
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
minimal (access forbidden), causes for such a variation could be related to food availability in the feeding
grounds. In 2009 and 2010, floods affected some of the major known feeding grounds along the Egyptian
Red Sea coast. Although the number of nesting females on Zabargad island could be considered of
secondary importance compared with close nesting sites in Oman and Yemen, this population could be
genetically unique and isolated from the other rookeries, thus in need for a total protection. Genetic studies
are actually under-going to verify this hypothesis. We would like to acknowledge the International Sea
Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach,
Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS
America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for providing us with a travel grant to participate in
this meeting.
VEGETATION AND SUBSTRATE CHARACTERIZATION AT ENSENADA MALIMANSIPA,
CASTILLETES: KEY BEACHES FOR NESTING ACTIVITY AT GULF OF VENEZUELA
Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez1,2, Efrain Moreno1, Lisandro Morán1, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido1,2,3
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuel, Maracaibo, Venezuela
Laboratorio de Ecología General, FEC, Universidad del Zulia, Maracaibo, Venezuela
3
IUCN SCC Marine Turtle Specialists Group, Centro de Modelado Científico, Universidad del Zulia
2
The importance of the Gulf of Venezuela (GV) grew after the record of nesting activity at two beaches at
Ensenada Malimansipa at the northernmost region of the GV. These beaches presented the basic and
essential characteristics for the presence of sea turtles and a potential capacity to support nests from three
species of sea turtles: Dermochelys coriacea, Eretmochelys imbricata and Caretta caretta. Five
environmental units were classified through satellite photo-interpretation and “in situ” observations during
March and May 2011 and July 2012: beach, sparse grasslands, mangrove forests, rocky formations and
clay-mud areas. A brief survey of floristic composition was conducted for each unit. Also, beach profiles
were conducted to describe the environment at the southern zone of the study area. This region comprises a
wide range of environments (terrestrial and aquatic habitats). A total of 8 species were clearly identified,
classified into 7 families and 8 genera, and categorized into 3 types of trees and 5 herbs. No species were
found in the beach environment. Sparse grassland environments supported mainly succulents and regular
grassland species, primarily Sarcocornia fruticosa and Sporobolus virginicus. Mangroves were dominated
by Rhizophora mangle but species such as Laguncularia racemosa and Conocarpus erectus were also
present. The southern beach of Ensenada Malimansipa presents a coastal plain and cliffs were observed in
only a portion of the beach. A constant problem in this area is the frequent occurrence of solid
contaminants (plastics and metals) on the shore deposited by ocean currents and winds. Also, natural
erosion due to strong waves and winds might affect the dynamics of the beach, which can result in threats
for sea turtle nesting activities.
175
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ACOUSTIC COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HATCHLINGS OF DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA
Camila R. Ferrara1, Richard C. Vogt1, Martha Harfush2, Renata Souza Lima3, Ernesto Albavera2,
and Alejandro Lopez2
1
Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia, Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil
Centro de la Tortuga Mexica, Manzute, Oaxaca, Mexico
3
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Natal, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil
2
For a long time it was thought that turtles did not have a well developed system of hearing air or water
borne sounds, and that the sounds made during copulation where just a percussion artifact. However, recent
studies have now shown that both tortoises and freshwater turtles are vocalizing, and that acoustic
communication is an important part of turtle social behavior. Among seaturtles, we know little about
acoustic communication and function. There are just a few reports of sounds produced by Dermochelys
coriacea, which appear to be simply noises made during copulation. The objective of our study was to
verify if Dermochelys coriacea emit sounds in other parts of their life cycle and describe the repertoire of
the sounds they produce. We recorded 12 Dermochelys coriacea nests on Barra de la Cruz Beach in
Oaxaca, México, in March 2012. The nests were divided into two categories, nests where the hatchlings
had emerged from the egg and unhatched eggs and nests with only unhatched eggs. After 12 hours of
recording, one hour per nest, we encountered 328 sounds. These sounds had were divided into four groups
of sounds based on their spectral and aural characteristics. The mean peak frequency of the vocalizations of
the hatchlings was 993.71 Hz (187.5- 2437.5; sd = 440.6). The sound being produced inside the eggs had a
mean peak frequency of 1695.37 Hz (187-2343.8) sharper than the nests with hatchlings and unhatched
eggs which had a mean peak frequency of 1108.24 Hz (375-2437.5). We hypothesize that the young begin
to vocalize to organize a greater number of individuals to help dig out of the nest simultaneously. This may
also increase survivorship of hatchlings moving from the nest to the water by swamping potential predators.
A LABORATORY EVALUATION OF HATCHLING LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE (CARETTA
CARETTA) PERFORMANCE IN RESPONSE TO CONTROLLED INCUBATION
TEMPERATURES
Leah Fisher1, David Owens1, and Matthew Godfrey2
1
2
College of Charleston, Charleston, SC, USA
North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission, Beaufort, NC, USA
Incubation temperature has significant developmental effects on oviparous animals, including determining
sex for several species. For the Northwest Atlantic loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta), apparent
population-wide female-biased hatchling sex ratios contrast with observations of juvenile populations,
where sex ratios have remained constant at about 2 to 1 female-biased over the past 30 years. It has been
suggested that some unknown factor is affecting loggerhead survival, resulting in an unexplained
differential loss of ~60% of female hatchlings per year. One theory suggests that incubation temperature
affects traits that influence survival. Furthermore, there may be differential survival between male and
female hatchlings. We conducted laboratory experiments to test for an effect of incubation temperature on
performance of loggerhead hatchlings. Sixty-eight hatchlings were tested in 2011, and 31 in 2012,
produced from eggs incubated at 11 different constant temperatures ranging from ~27ºC to ~32.5ºC.
Following their emergence from the eggs, we tested righting response and crawl speed, and conducted a
24-hour long hatchling swim test. Data indicate an effect of incubation temperature on survivorship,
176
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
righting response time, crawl speed, change in crawl speed, and overall swim activity, with hatchlings
incubated at 27ºC showing decreased locomotor abilities. No hatchlings survived when incubated at 32ºC
and above. Differences in survivorship of hatchlings incubated at high temperatures are important in light
of projected higher sand temperatures due to climate change, and could indicate increased mortality from
incubation temperature effects. Acknowledgements: We would like to thank the PADI Foundation, Lerner
Gray Memorial Fund, Slocum Lunz Foundation, and the Charleston Scientific and Cultural Society for
supporting this research. The help and cooperation of the SC Department of Natural Resources staff and
volunteers is greatly appreciated, including Dubose Griffin and the SC-DNR Sea Turtle program staff,
Jamie Dozier and SC-DNR Yawkey Wildlife Center staff, and the North Island Sea Turtle Project Team.
PRELIMINARY DATA ON THE OLIVE RIDLEY TAGGING PROGRAM AT NANCITE BEACH,
COSTA RICA
Luis G. Fonseca1, Wilberth N. Villachica2, Eduardo R. Matarrita3, Yeudy Argüello4, Carlos M.
Orrego5, Wagner Quirós4, Jeffrey A. Seminoff6, and Roldán A. Valverde7
1
Instituto Internacional en Conservación y Manejo de Vida Silvestre, Universidad Nacional, Heredia,
Costa Rica
2
Área de Conservación Guanacaste, Ministerio de Ambiente, Energía y Telecomunicaciones, San José,
Costa Rica
3
International Student Volunteers, Edificio Plaza Victoria, Heredia, Costa Rica
4
Área de Conservación Tempisque, Ministerio de Ambiente, Energía y Telecomunicaciones, San José,
Costa Rica
5
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, CA, USA
6
Department of Biological Sciences, Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, LA, USA
The olive ridley sea turtle exhibits two nesting strategies at Nancite Beach, Costa Rica: arribada nesting
(mass synchronized nesting) and solitary nesting. Most studies have focused on the phenomenon of
arribada nesting because of the impressive volume of nesting individuals involved, neglecting the less
abundant solitary nesting behavior. During the peak nesting seasons of 2010-2013 we studied the
internesting intervals and the post-nesting movements of olive ridley females utilizing both nesting
strategies. A total of 2,902 turtles were tagged and 445 were recaptured. One hundred and forty one of the
445 recaptures were observed nesting solitarily and during arribadas. The observed overall internesting
interval was 30.02 days (SD= 12.50), similar to previously reported data for this population. Additionally,
we observed only 17 turtles that laid 3 clutches during the same season, which had not been reported for
arribada beaches. We also observed a total of 78 females that nested during two consecutive seasons,
exhibiting a remigration period of 348.26 days (SD= 34.88), which suggests that at least part of the
population nests annually. Finally, we observed a total of 7 turtles that nested on multiple beaches in the
region, including beaches such as Naranjo, Junquillal and Ostional, all of them located south of Nancite
Beach. Our results demonstrate that olive ridley females exhibit both solitary and arribada nesting
behaviors. This strongly suggests that all olive ridleys have the ability to sense the environmental cues that
trigger the phenomenon of arribada. However, our results must be approached with caution given that it is
not possible to verify the nesting of every turtle during the arribadas due to the large number of individuals
involved. Furthermore, we do not know the level of site fidelity for the Nancite turtles, which might bias
our conclusions. Finally, our data demonstrate the importance of including solitary nesting females, as their
lower numbers may help us reveal nesting behaviors that would otherwise be missed by arribada-specific
tagging programs.
177
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
STUDYING BEACH NOURISHMENT TEMPLATES AND MARINE TURTLE NESTING CUES
TO LEARN HOW TO ENGINEER MORE “TURTLE FRIENDLY” BEACHES
Allison W. Hays and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL, USA
Since 1998, ~55% of critically eroded beaches in Florida have been rebuilt through artificial beach
nourishment, which is the most common method of combating coastal erosion in the United States. Studies
have reported negative impacts on marine turtle nesting success (ratio of nests to non nesting emergences)
post-nourishment, indicating that simply the presence of a sandy beach is not enough to guarantee suitable
nesting habitat. The first objective of this study was to determine if some nourishment templates are more
conducive to loggerhead (Caretta caretta) and green turtle (Chelonia mydas) nesting than others. Since
2005, approximately 35 kilometers of shoreline in southern Brevard County, FL, which supports some of
the highest density loggerhead and green turtle nesting worldwide, have undergone 1) full-scale restoration
(typically called nourishment), where sand was added above and below the mean high tide line (2005,
2010) or 2) dune restoration, where sand was placed on the dune (2005, 2006, 2008, 2009). To quantify the
effects of these two types of restoration, we used a Before-After-Control-Impact-Paired Series (BACIPS)
model, which tests for significance between the difference in nesting success rates at the impact
(engineered) and control (natural beach) sites before and after restoration (Δ). After full-scale restoration,
there were significant differences in Δ for loggerheads during the seasons immediately following
restoration (year of construction) and one year post-construction while green turtles were significantly
affected for five years. After dune restoration, loggerheads were significantly impacted each year of
construction and one year post-construction while the significant effect for green turtles occurred during
half of the years of- and one year post-construction seasons. The significant difference in Δ was
consistently the result of a decreased nesting success rate at the engineered sites, although the extent of the
decline varied between species and restoration types. The second objective was to determine which beach
characteristics serve as loggerhead nesting cues. During the 2010 nesting season, we examined beach
elevation, slope, and width and sand moisture content and grain size between loggerhead nesting (n=49)
and non-nesting crawls (n=25) on natural beaches (n=2), beaches with full-scale restoration (n=2), and
beaches with dune restoration (n=2). When we divided each crawl into quarters, we found that in
unsuccessful nesting attempts, the beach slope was flatter in the final quarter of the crawl compared to the
one previous (in all study sites except one). Conversely, in successful nesting emergences, the beach slope
in the final quarter of the crawl was steeper than the slope in the third quarter. These results indicate that
changes in beach slope during the last half of the crawl were important in determining if a turtle nested.
This study provides insight into changes in marine turtle nesting patterns post-nourishment. The first study
shows that varied design templates affect nesting success rates differently and that gravid loggerheads and
green turtles respond differently to altered beaches. The second study illustrates the importance of beach
slope as a loggerhead nesting cue, which provides data necessary to engineer beaches in a more “turtle
friendly” manner.
178
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
TO RELOCATE OR NOT
Ş. Karakaya1, Z. Ün2, C. Yılmaz2, A. Oruç2, and O. Türkozan1
1
Adnan Menderes Üniversites, i Fen Edebiyat Fakültes, i Biyoloji Bölümü, Aydın
Doğal Hayatı Koruma Vakfı (WWF-Türkiye), Büyük Postane Cad. No:19, Kat 5, Bahçekapı, Eminönü,
İstanbul
2
In this study we aimed to compare the original and relocated nests in terms of hatchling sizes (SCL and
SCW), weight, hatching succcess and carapacial scute deviations. With this aim we randomly selected 22
(11 original, 11 relocated) green turtle (Chelonia mydas) nests consisting of 430 hatchlings. From each nest
50 eggs were relocated 1m away from the original nests. During the hatching season, hatchlings coming out
of these nests were measured with a dial caliper with an accuracy range of 0.2 mm and weighted with a
digital scale nearest to 1g. Furthermore, carapacial scute counts were done. In conclusion, the hatchlings
from the original nests were lighter (t = -4.76 p<0.001) and narrower (t = 4.387 p<0.001) than the
hatchlings from relocated nests. There was no difference in terms of hatching success (Mann-Whitney U
test p>0.005). Acknowledgment: This study is supported by a cooperative protocol between WWF-Turkey
and the Ministry of Forestry and Waters. The senior author would like to thank the International Sea Turtle
Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of
Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and the
International Sea Turtle Symposium for their generous support, which supported our participation in the
symposium.
POSSIBLE EFFECT OF RELOCATION ON SEX RATIO OF HATCHLINGS: SPATIAL AND
TEMPORAL DIFFERENCES IN NEST TEMPERATURES AND SEX OF HATCHLINGS AND
EMBRYOS OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES ON DALAMAN AND DALYAN BEACHES, TURKEY
Yakup Kaska1, Eyup Baskale1, Yusuf Katilmis1, Fikret Sari2, Cigdem Fak2, Mucahit Secme2, and
Cisem Sezgin2
1
2
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli, Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli, Turkey
This sex ratio study was conducted on Dalyan and Dalaman Beaches, Turkey. Sex ratios of dead hatchlings
and embryos were determined by gonadal observation. Sex ratios of live hatchlings were estimated by
measuring the temperatures during the middle third of the incubation period. Sex ratios differed between
the two beaches, however ratios were similar temporally. More males were usually produced early (May)
and late (August) in the season when compared to the middle part of the nesting season (June and July).
Sex ratios differed significantly between years and also between the beach zones perpendicular to the sea.
Nests deposited close to the sea are usually relocated further inland, which may also affect hatchling sex
ratios. Relocation guidelines according to the sand and nest temperatures were applied during the relocation
of nests.
179
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DECLINE OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE NESTS ON FETHIYE BEACH, TURKEY
Yusuf Katilmis1, Eyup Baskale1, Fatih Polat2, Musa Azmaz2, and Yakup Kaska1
1
2
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli-Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli-Turkey
Decline and loss of sea turtle populations are increasingly becoming an international concern. In this
respect conservation efforts are carried out on most of the nesting beaches in the world. Fethiye Beach is
one of the most important nesting sites of loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) in Turkey. Previous studies
showed a negative population trend of the loggerhead turtle population at Fethiye Beach based on nesting
data. The nesting biology of loggerhead turtles, Caretta caretta, on Fethiye Beach was studied in this work
during the 2011 and 2012 nesting seasons. In addition, we analyzed nesting trends over 20 consecutive
years, from 1993 to 2012. As a result, we recorded a total of 145 emergences in 2011 and 247 emergences
in 2012, of which 60 (41.4%) and 89 (36 %) resulted in nests respectively. 3854 hatchlings emerged
(76.03%) from 5015 eggs and 3813 hatchlings reached the sea in 2011 nesting season. For the 2012 nesting
season, a total of 7223 eggs were laid, 5238 (72.5%) of them hatched and 4835 (92.4%) hatchlings were
able to reach the sea. On the other hand, we recorded a total of 1978 nests on Fethiye Beach during 20
consecutive years with a mean of 99 nests per year. There were also strong annual fluctuations in the
number of nests, which ranged from a minimum of 58 nests (in 1994) to a maximum of 158 (in 2004).
Linear regression analyses showed that there is a statistically significant negative relationship between
years and nest numbers at the 99% confidence level (r2=0.39; p<0.01). This result has lead to the
interpretation that the number of nesting turtles is still in decline at Fethiye Beach. The main reasons of the
decrease can be excessive use of the beach by the people, lights from the back side of the beach, and boat
traffic on the shore. With such a potential negative trend at a key Turkish nesting beach shows a need for
more sharp effective conservation programs.
INVERTEBRATE INFESTATION IN LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE NESTS ON DALYAN
BEACH, TURKEY
Yusuf Katilmis1, Eyup Baskale1, İlker Kara2, Mücahit Seçme2, Çisem Sezgin2, and Yakup Kaska1
1
2
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli, Turkey
Pamukkale University, Sea Turtle Research Centre (DEKAMER), Denizli, Turkey
Sea turtle nests face many dangers during the two month incubation period. It is not yet clear whether
certain invertebrates found in the nests are predators or parasites to the eggs or hatchlings. The damage
caused by some invertebrates to the eggs of loggerhead turtles, Caretta caretta, was investigated during the
summer of 2010 on Dalyan Beach, Turkey. The specimens were identified to family or species: Pimelia sp.
(Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae), Muscidae (Diptera), Myrmeleonidae (Neuroptera), Isopoda (Crustaceae) and
Enchytridae (Oligochaeta). The specimens of Enchytridae, Pimelia sp. and Muscidae were observed on
empty eggshells and in eggs. Samples of Myrmeleonidae and Isopoda were observed in the sand columns
of nests. The heaviest impacts of these invertebrates on loggerhead turtle nests were Enchytridae
(Oligochaeta). Seventeen (32 %) of the randomly selected 53 loggerhead hatched nests were effected by
this group. The damage of Oligochaeta was recorded in 188 (5.1 %) out of 3,253 eggs. However it was
determined that Oligochaeta individuals were encountered in the sand columns of nests. The damage in one
nest of Muscidae and Pimelia sp. was recorded in 4 and 7 eggs, respectively. Although no statistical
comparison was possible due to the small sample size, the nests containing these invertebrate were also
near the vegetation line.
180
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EXTENSIVE MARINE TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITY REVEALED ON REMOTE BEACHES
OF ANTIGUA & BARBUDA, WEST INDIES
Kathryn Levasseur1, Dominic Tilley2, Seth Stapleton3, and Mykl C. Fuller4
1
University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA
University of Exeter, Cornwall, UK
3
University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN, USA
4
Antigua Sea Turtle Conservation Project, St. John's, Antigua, W.I.
2
Although low levels of marine turtle nesting activity have long been documented across Antigua's and
Barbuda’s 153 km of coastline, establishing accurate levels of current species composition and nesting
activity across the islands proves difficult. Many nesting beaches are remote and difficult to access by road,
particularly on the southern coast of Antigua and most of Barbuda. To better understand the quantity,
composition, and distribution of nesting activity across the entire nation, we conducted beach surveys
between 16 June and 16 August, 2012, on six Antiguan beaches (previously identified as priority beaches
by the Antiguan Sea Turtle Conservation Project) and two Barbudan beaches. Hawksbill turtle nesting
activity was most frequently observed and was recorded at each of these key nesting sites. Leatherback
nesting activity was documented at seven of the eight monitored nesting beaches, and green turtle nesting
activity was observed at four sites. We note that the survey period overlaps the peak hawksbill nesting
season, but lies outside of reported regional leatherback and green nesting peaks. We created satellite
images of these priority sites using Google Earth to illustrate the distribution of nesting activity. We further
summarize nesting activities by species, season, and geographic distribution and discuss the implications of
our findings, including recommendations for future nesting surveys on Antigua and Barbuda.
RUNNING INTO THE FIRE: LOGGERHEAD NESTING DENSITY SHIFTS INTO AREAS OF
INCREASED EROSION OVER A 20-YEAR PERIOD*
Chris A. Long, Joshua S. Reece, John F. Weishampel, Allison W. Hays, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Global climate change is a major long-term threat to marine turtles. Understanding how marine turtles will
respond to climate change is of paramount importance, as it will inform management decisions related to
all aspects of marine turtle conservation. In this study, we sought to understand how sea-level rise, erosion,
and human land-use have affected loggerheads nesting in the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge
(ACNWR) in Florida, USA. The ACNWR is the highest density loggerhead nesting beach in the Western
Hemisphere, with an average of 740 nests per kilometer in 2012. We used nesting survey data collected
from 1986-2006 to quantify how the proportion of annual loggerhead nesting in each half-km in the
ACNWR has changed over time. We then used data from coastal aerial surveys to quantify the effect of
erosion and sea-level rise on the changes in nesting density. In 1986, the southern portion of the ACNWR
was wider; this trend was continued in 2006, as erosion caused the northern portion to decrease in width
more than the southern portion over the 20-year period (although most areas experienced a decrease in
width). However, counter to our expectation that loggerhead nesting density would mirror this trend,
relative nesting density increased significantly in the northern portion of the ACNWR and correspondingly
decreased in the southern portion. It is possible that the loggerheads of the ACNWR are moving north in
response to climate change, but there are likely other contributing factors, including human modifications
to the beach and dune environments (analyses ongoing). Clearly, sea-level rise and other factors have
181
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
substantially altered the location of suitable nesting habitat, and the response by loggerheads so far has
been to run into the fire instead of away from it. The effects of sea-level rise are likely to accelerate in the
future, and this study will provide knowledge necessary for managers to develop a mitigation strategy.
Acknowledgments: Thanks to the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of
Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America, and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for their
generous support.
BAMBOO BAY, MALAKULA ISLAND,VANUATU, AN IMPORTANT NESTING BEACH FOR
WESTERN PACIFIC GREEN (CHELONIA MIDAS) AND HAWKSBILL TURTLES
(ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA).
Kenneth T. MacKay1 and George Petro2
1
2
Vonu Consulting, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
Wan Smolbag Theatre, Port Vila, SHEFA, Vanuatu
Bamboo Bay, on the west coast of Malekula Island, Vanuatu (16.23o S, 167.24o E), a 12 km long group of
black and white sand beaches was identified in 2005 by local Vanua-Tai Turtle Monitors as a potentially
important turtle nesting area. A detailed survey combined with training of local monitors on nesting bleach
survey methods was carried out in 2006/07 by a combination of local and international turtle researchers.
The preliminary results identified about 350 nests of Western Pacific green (Chelonia mydas) and
hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata) and one leatherback turtle (Dermochelys coriacea) nest. Over
60 nesters, equally distributed between greens and hawksbills were tagged and nesting parameters recorded.
The preliminary results indicated that for green turtles the CCL, within season remigration interval and
numbers of eggs per clutch are similar to nearby Australian green turtle populations. In the case of
hawksbill turtles the CCL and number of eggs per clutch are considerably higher than for adjacent
Australian hawksbill populations. In fact the mean CCL was the largest reported for hawksbill turtles in the
Pacific with some nesters over 1 m. Bamboo Bay had a high survival rate of hatchlings and appeared to
have minimal anthropogenic harvesting, although predation by feral dogs was a problem on hawksbill nests.
Since the initial survey the local Vanua-Tai Monitors have followed up with annual nesting beach surveys.
This paper will summarize the results of seven years of nesting beach surveys,including a description of the
community monitoring effort, the results of flipper and satellite tagging, and conservation efforts on the
nesting beach. Additionally descriptions will be given on the geographic distribution of nests, the role and
accuracy of local monitors in carrying out nesting beach surveys and some novel methods of data collection
and recording, and predator control.This work was initially funded by the Australian Regional Natural
Heritage Programme, with follow up funding to Wan SmolBag Theatre Company from Australian and New
Zealand Aid.
THE STATUS AND NESTING ECOLOGY OF SEA TURTLES IN KENYA
Rose Machaku and Boaz Kaunda-Arara
Moi University, Eldoret, Kenya
The green turtle (Chelonia mydas) is the most common sea turtle species to nest in Kenya. Using data
gathered from seven different rookery beaches along the Kenyan coast (between -3.775o, 39.843 o and -
182
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
3.911 o, 39.787 o) in 2012, we investigate the status, spatial distribution and nesting ecology of green turtles.
Samples of sand were analyzed for grain sizes, moisture content, pH and conductivity. The pH ranged
between 9.3 and 9.6 while the percent moisture content ranged between 4.3% and 9.5%. The conductivity
on the sampled sites varied between sites with notably higher values being noted in areas which were
frequently inundated by sea water. The sand was highly variable in its grain structure with the percentage
of large (500µm and 250µm) grains dominating the structure. The nesting success was much lower at all
study sites during the study period compared to previous years but varied across the different beaches
sampled. The hatching success was zero in clutches that were laid too close to the high tide line and which
were inundated by sea water, while in none inundated areas the hatching success was much higher.
Predation of eggs was observed on four nests at two of the study sites while one nest was poached. The
results of this study give a baseline for the much needed knowledge on green turtle nesting population in
Kenya.
EMERGENCE PATTERN OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLE (CARETTA CARETTA) HATCHLINGS
FROM IZTUZU BEACH, DALYAN, TURKEY
Joanne C. Makin1, Yakup Kaska2, and James Reynolds3
1
University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
Pamukkale University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Biology, Denizli, Turkey
3
Centre for Ornithology, School of Biosciences, College of Life & Environmental Sciences, University of
Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
2
The loggerhead turtle (C. caretta) is a globally endangered species but we understand little about hatchling
emergence behaviour. If we are to increase hatchling survivorship then we must understand diurnal
emergence patterns, a period when hatchlings are most prone to mortality as a result of desiccation and
predation. In this study I investigated hatchling emergence in September 2012 within an area of highdensity nesting on Iztuzu beach, Turkey. A total of 573 hatchlings were recorded during the study period,
with hatchling emergence predominantly occurring at night between 00:00-03:00 hrs. Emergence duration
occurred over periods of 1-6 nights, with some nests displaying a synchronous hatching pattern and most
hatchlings emerging on the first night. The number of hatchlings in each emergence group decreased
throughout the emergence period. Hatchling emergence was inhibited by increasing sub-surface sand
temperatures. Hatchlings from nests with larger thermal variation emerged over a longer duration.
Hatchling emergence predominantly occurred at night, perhaps cued by decreasing sub-surface sand
temperature. Within-nest thermal variation due to shallow nest depths and shorter distances from sea
resulted in a range of hatchling developmental rates and incubation periods, and longer emergence
durations. Future studies should focus on within-nest sand temperatures to understand how hatchling
metabolic processes impact emergence. Such work might lead to the development of ecological models
which might allow prediction of nesting success based upon nest site selection.
DO SEA TURTLES PREFER WHITE SAND BEACHES? IMPLICATIONS OF THE RESPONSE
OF ENDANGERED POPULATIONS TO GLOBAL WARMING
Adolfo Marco, Samir Martins, María Martins, and Elena Abella
Estación Biológica de Doñana, CSIC, Sevilla, Spain
Incubation temperature can affect hatching success and hatchling sex determination. Current incubation
temperatures on many important nesting beaches estimate the predominance of female hatchlings, and this
183
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
trend may increase with global warming in the future. Increasing sand temperatures can reduce or even
prevent male production. Higher temperatures can be lethal for turtle embryos. Environmental factors that
can significantly affect incubation temperature include air temperature, sun exposure, vegetation cover and
sand texture and color. Incubation temperatures within nests are lower on white sand beaches than on dark
sand beaches. Nesting beaches that have areas of different sand color can result in a wide variation of
hatchling sex ratios. In extreme cases, the sand color of nesting beaches could influence hatching success.
We have studied the influence of sand color on loggerhead nest site selection on a volcanic island (Island of
Maio, Republic of Cape Verde) with a wide range of sand color on available beaches for nesting. We have
also evaluated the relationships between sand color, hatching success, incubation temperature and
estimated hatchling sex-ratio on different beaches of the island. Finally, we have evaluated the sand
temperature on many different beaches from different islands of the archipelago of Cape Verde, a very
important rookery for loggerheads on the Atlantic. We have also correlated sand color, sand temperature
and nest abundance. By quantifying this interaction, we can predict hatching success and hatchling sex ratio
as a function of the sand color, in order to assess the importance of different islands and beaches for the
conservation of loggerhead nesting in response to future scenarios of global warming. Most loggerhead
turtles on Cape Verde, one of the world's main loggerhead rookeries and the most endangered in the
Atlantic, are already nesting on the coldest beaches of the Archipelago. Some loggerheads are nesting on
the black beaches of islands that have lethal temperatures for embryos. On many other dark beaches, nests
are only producing females. On islands where the sand color is highly variable even among close beaches,
turtles do not seem to be selecting white sand for nesting. These results have very important implications
on loggerhead conservation and nesting dispersal in response to global warming.
CONNECTING RECORD LEVELS OF LOGGERHEAD NESTING IN KYPARISSIA BAY,
GREECE, TO LONG-TERM NEST PROTECTION
Dimitris Margaritoulis, ALan F. Rees, and Thomas E. Riggall
ARCHELON, the Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Athens, Greece
The 44 km beach at Kyparissia Bay, western Peloponnese, Greece, hosts the second largest loggerhead
turtle nesting aggregation in the Mediterranean. About 84% of nests occur along the southernmost 9.5 km
of the Bay, which is considered as the core area. About 7.3 km of the core area (Sectors A, B, C) has been
monitored every year since 1984, with seasonal night-time tagging activity (since 1982) in sections of the
core area. Turtles with old tags or scars attributed to lost tags are considered as remigrants, and turtles with
no tags or scars as neophytes. In-situ nest fencing and relocation to safer sites was applied to a low intensity
in the early years of monitoring, depending on human resources. Protection measures were stepped up from
1990, as nests were subject to high rates of mammal predation (about 50%) and inundation by the sea
(about 30%) and since 1992 the majority of nests were protected in most of the core area. The minimum
age at maturity for Mediterranean loggerheads is calculated to be 15-16 years. Hence, intensive nest
protection starting at the start of the 1990s could therefore result in higher numbers of nesting turtles and
nests in recent years. Is this the case? Over the 29-year period (1984-2012), nesting effort in sectors A
through C ranged from 174 to 741 nests per year. However, in the last seven years (2006-2012) there has
been a considerable increase in nest numbers. The two highest nesting levels were recorded in 2010 and
2012 with other years since 2006 also some of the highest on record. Annual population growth rate
between 1984 and 2005 is estimated at 0.9%. However, when the most recent years are included it
increases to 1.8%. Through the 1980s to 1992 the percentage of neophyte turtles declined from 100% to
50% as existing members of the population were tagged. This level stabilised at about 40% until 2002
when it bottomed-out at just below 30% for two years. Subsequently the levels have increased, and the
percentage of neophytes has been over 60% in three of the last 7 years. Further, the average SCL of all
turtles has decreased almost 2 cm during this time of increased nesting. Decreased size may be indicative of
a younger population and this tallies with the increased proportion of neophytes observed in recent years.
Our data tentatively indicate that recent increases in nest numbers may be connected with long-term nest
184
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
protection efforts. However, a number of other factors may have also led to these results including the
absence of saturation tagging and particular environmental and oceanographic driven conditions. The
indicated positive trend, potentially resulting from ARCHELON’s conservation efforts in Kyparissia Bay,
make us hopeful that similar activities carried out since the early 1990s at Rethymno, Island of Crete, may
reverse the population decline that we have recently recorded there. Acknowledgments: We thank all field
assistants and the many hundred volunteers without whom the above long-term work would not happen.
AFR thanks International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine
Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek,
Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for a travel grant.
EFFECTS OF GRANULAR INCLINE ANGLE ON THE LOCOMOTION OF LOGGERHEAD
SEA TURTLE HATCHLINGS (CARETTA CARETTA) IN THE FIELD
Nicole Mazouchova1 and Daniel I. Goldman2
1
2
Temple University, PA, USA
Georgia Institute of Technology, GA, USA
Natural environments are complex with animals running over difficult substrates to ensure survival.
Animals that traverse on granular substrates can experience slipping, which decreases their performance
since granular media can act as a solid or a fluid when stress is applied. Kinematics of loggerhead sea turtle
hatchlings (Caretta caretta) reveal that limb use varies significantly depending on granular compaction.
These studies were done on level ground. However, hatchlings rarely encounter level ground on sandy
beaches, having to crawl up and down sandy slopes. As sand is tilted it approaches a critical incline value
(angle of repose) at which the material will cease to act as a solid and start to flow. Depending on substrate
particle properties, the angle at which flow is induced varies. Little is known how legged-intruders are
affected by sandy inclines. We investigated the effects of granular inclines on the locomotor performance
of hatchling sea turtles, hypothesizing that as incline angle increased, the animals will adjust limb-ground
interactions to prevent slipping, which negatively affects their performance (speed). We captured 25
hatchlings from 5 different nests on our field site on Jekyll Island, GA and tested them on loose and hard
packed sand, and on inclines of theta = 0°, theta = 10° and theta = 20°. Using a fluidized bed trackway, we
controlled for granular compaction and incline angle, mimicking a natural beach environment. Two
infrared high speed cameras (250 fps) were attached to the trackway to film the detailed mechanics of
hatchling locomotion. Results showed that the total distance traveled and velocity decreased as incline
angle increased, without granular compaction affecting performance. Maximum angular extent of the
flipper at the beginning of stance phase in relation to the body remained the same at theta = 0° and theta =
10°(alpha = 128.17°± 12.12°; alpha = 127.80°± 11.40°; p>0.05), however at theta = 20°, it significantly
increased (alpha = 143.19° ± 12.86°, P<0.0001). The duty factor during stance phase, remained unchanged
among compaction levels, at 0.69, which is similar to terrestrial turtles that have a duty factor of 0.75 or
higher on level ground. On close packed materials the duty factor decreased at the highest incline angle
theta = 20° to 0.66. Taking indications of the step interaction effect due to disturbed ground from a bioinspired sea turtle robot (FBot), the hatchling data was divided into three step distance categories: no
interactions between steps, small step interactions, and large step interactions. Results showed that average
velocity increased with frequency when turtles utilize adequate step distance to avoid interaction effects for
theta = 0° and theta = 10°. However, little effect was seen at theta = 20° suggesting that at higher angular
inclines slip dominates performance.
185
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SPATIO-TEMPORAL VARIABILITY IN REPRODUCTIVE SUCCESS OF THE HAWKSBILL
TURTLE (ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) IN JARDINES DE LA REINA, CUBA
Yosvani Medina Cruz, Félix G. Moncada Gavilán, and Gonzalo Nodarse Andreu
Centro de Investigaciones Pesqueras, Cuba
The study covers a period of 14 years (1996-2010) and discusses nesting of hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys
imbricata) at nine index beaches; El Guincho, Caballones Este, Caballones Oeste, El Dátiri, Los Pinos,
Cachiboca, El Faro, La Ballena and Boca Seca, located in Doce Leguas Labyrinth, Jardines de la Reina
Archipelago, Cuba. Nesting at these beaches was characterized considering various indicators of nest
success (emerging success, eggs with no apparent development, eggs with dead embryos and dead
hatchlings. Only the indicator ‘eggs with dead embryos’ showed a significant difference (p <0.01) between
the study beaches; ‘emerging success’, ‘eggs with no apparent development’ and ‘dead hatchlings’ showed
no significant difference (p> 0.05). Although there were no consistent trends detected during the study
period for the four indicators of nest success, when baseline data were incorporated there was a significant
decrease (p <0.05) in emerging success, and a significant increase (p <0.05) in the number of eggs with no
apparent development; this indicator is important both spatially and temporally for determining nest
success. A possible cause for the increase in the number of eggs with no apparent development could be the
reduction in the population of adult male hawksbill turtles in the area.
EVIDENCE OF SEA TURTLES NESTING IN LAGOS, SOUTHWESTERN NIGERIA
Adegbile O. Mojisola, B.B. Solarin, A.B. Williams, K.I. Oshisanya, F.C. Olakolu, and H.O.
Omogoriola
Nigerian Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research, Victoria-Island, Lagos, Nigeria
Sea turtles are enigmatic, intriguing, marine megafauna. Sea turtles are cosmopolitan in nature, migrating
within ocean basins and utilizing multiple marine habitats. Sea turtles are known to nest on several beaches
all over the world. Sea turtle nesting has not been documented in Nigeria until recently. Sea turtles have
been nesting in Lagos for as long as there has been fishermen, however due to the low awareness of the
status of sea turtles in Nigeria, such occurrences have not been monitored on a regular basis. Also theereis a
low technical capacity for monitoring marine megafauna in Nigeria. This study is a review of sea turtle
nesting data based on historical records, interviews and actual reports of sea turtle nesting at the Nigerian
Institute for Oceanography and Marine Research, Victoria Island from 1978 to the present. Sea turtle
nesting has been reported in most coastal beaches along the Lagos coast since the 70s, however recent
reports related to sea turtle nesting at NIOMR include the collection of 120 green turtle eggs from Marwa
Beach (March, 2010), the capture of a female leatherback at Orimedu (February, 2012) and an olive ridley
at Onijegi (September, 2012), roasted Sea turtle eggs sighted at Akodo in during PLMR survey (2012), a
hatchling emergence at Onijegi Beach (July 2012), and a nest at Ikate Elegushi Beach (September, 2012).
All reported nesting events were on Victoria Island/Lekki axis, Westward of Lagos, Nigeria. Unfortunately
this region is an area undergoing intensive coastal development and also highly vulnerable to storm surge.
Three storm surge and flooding events have been recorded in this area during this year alone. There is a
need for more intensive monitoring of sea turtle nesting activity in Lagos and Nigeria, and to protect vital
nesting areas in the future.
186
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EFFECT OF CLOSED SEASONS ON NESTING POPULATIONS OF GREEN TURTLES
(CHELONIA MYDAS) AND LOGGERHEADS (CARETTA CARETTA) AT GUANAL BEACH,
ISLA DE LA JUVENTUD, CUBA
Félix G. Moncada Gavilán, Dana Tizol, Gonzalo Nodarse Andreu, and Yosvani Medina Cruz
Centro de Investigaciones Pesqueras, Cuba
The effects of a closed season on populations of green (Chelonia mydas) and loggerhead (Caretta caretta)
turtles nesting at Gunal beach, Isla de la Juventud, Cuba were studied. An analysis of the harvest (trend for
the study period, seasonal variation and during the closed season) and nesting (proportion of nests per
species for the entire period and for each species during each period) in four stages: PVI (1982 -1987), PV2
(1988-1994), PV3 (1995-2007) and PV4 (2008-2011), representing different closed season periods.
Additionally, the size range for both species was analyzed. It was found that the annual variation of the
harvest of loggerhead and green turtles for the whole period shows a decrease over time for both species,
associated with closed season in place, while the variation of nesting was observed for both species
according to closed season, where the proportion of green turtle nests is higher for most of the period
indicating that this is the main species nesting at this beach. An analysis of nesting with the monitoring
effort applied to the entire study period, showed a statistically significant relationship for loggerheads (p
<0.05), but not for green turtles (p> 0.05). The analysis of the mean size of individuals of both species over
the study period showed no significant changes over time.
SEASONALITY OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) REPRODUCTION AT ALDABRA
ATOLL, SEYCHELLES
Jeanne A. Mortimer
Seychelles Islands Foundation, Victoria, Mahe, Seychelles and Dept. of Biology, University of Florida,
Gainesville, Florida, USA
Seasonal and temporal-spatial distributions of green turtle (Chelonia mydas) nesting activity were assessed
at Aldabra Atoll Seychelles, the second largest green turtle rookery in the Western Indian Ocean (WIO),
based on morning counts of fresh turtle tracks conducted during 1980-2011. The datasets used in the
analyses are derived from: an average of 3-4 surveys per month at two index sites representing ~30-42% of
total annual nesting during 1980-1989 and ~58% during 1995-2011; and monthly surveys conducted at
another two remote sites which accounted for an additional 20% of annual nesting (total ~78%) during
2002-2011. Turtles engaged in year-round nesting during the season defined as December to November and
characterized by patterns of high intra- and inter-annual variation. In some seasons nesting peaked
primarily during February to May and in others during May to September. However, on average during
1995-2011, a clear uni-modal pattern emerged with nesting activity greatest during February to September,
peaking during April to June, and lowest in November-December. The two Primary Index Sites situated 2.2
km apart on the west coast and separated by a lagoon entrance had mean peak nesting dates that
consistently differed by more than a month. Possible explanations for the differences are discussed. At
Aldabra, the timing of the 1997-98 ENSO event coincided with a disruption in normal nesting cycles
during 1998 through 2002 and the highest levels of nesting recorded at Aldabra to date during the 2000-01
season. Comparison of seasonal median peak nesting dates at five green turtle rookeries in the WIO
suggests an inverse relationship with latitude among four of them, with those in the lower latitudes peaking
during the austral autumn and winter and in the higher latitudes during the austral summer, an indication
that temperature may be moderating nesting seasonality in the WIO.
187
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
LEATHERBACKS, COMMUNITIES, AND COASTAL CHANGE IN GRANDE RIVIERE,
TRINIDAD
Kevin Muhammad, Len Peters, Nicholas Alexander, Marcia Barker, and David Silverthorn
Grande Riviere Nature Tour Guide Association (Ministry of the Environment, WIDECAST, University of
the West Indies), Grande Riviere, Trinidad and Tobago
Grande Riviere is a village of 380 people on the remote mountainous north shore of Trinidad, W.I. The
community resides on a beach described as the ‘Densest Nesting Site Globally’ for the leatherback turtle.
The beach is a Prohibited Sea Turtle Nesting Site from March 1 to August 31 between the hours of 6 pm to
6am. At night the beach is managed by the Grande Riviere Nature Tour Guides Association (GRNTGA), a
community based organization in a co-management agreement with Wildlife Division. The GRNTGA
transforms the dark beach into a classroom during the nesting season. On a busy night of nesting, the turtles
and turtle-watching visitors often outnumber the population of the village. The group is responsible for
protection through beach patrols, beach cleanup, education, leatherback biology tours and lectures, and
research through monitoring and other projects. This poster provides the perspective of the GRNTGA and
the Grande Riviere community during the internationally-publicized events of 7 July 2012 when an
excavator re-directed the Grande Riviere River in an attempt to re-establish a new river mouth and forestall
the increased rates of beach erosion experienced since December 2011. The media highlighted only the
work and its immediate impact on nests: the community would like to describe the erosion impacts as well
as the appeals and conservation efforts made prior to the intervention. We will present data documenting
nesting events in the excavation area and clarify the ecological and social impacts of redirecting the river.
The outcome of the incident and the implications for future management of this globally important beach
that is nested within a small, conservation-oriented community will be discussed.
ASPECTS OF REPRODUCTIVE ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA (LINNAEUS, 1766), FROM
THE SOUTH COAST OF PERNAMBUCO, BRAZIL
Vivian C. S. Neves1, Milena S. C. Neves1, Elisângela S. Guimarães2, and Simone F. Teixeira1
1
2
University of Pernambuco, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil
NGO Ecoassociados, Ipojuca, Pernambuco, Brazil
The State of Pernambuco has reproductive records of sea turtles, especially the species Eretmochelys
imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766), the hawksbill sea turtle, and a lesser number of Caretta caretta (Linnaeus,
1758), the loggerhead sea turtle, and also Lepidochelys olivacea, the olive ridley, (Eschscholtz, 1829). Nest
placement by sea turtles has influence on the embryonic development, impacting on the sex of offspring,
the survival of embryos and the rate of nest predation. This study aimed to analyze reproductive aspects of
E. imbricata including biological variables (clutch size, incubation time and rate of reproductive success).
In order to provide information that could assist in the preparation of conservation plans and more effective
management of sea turtles in the region. The study covered an area of 12.92 km long coastline of Ipojuca,
south of Pernambuco. The data used in the study were from the 2008/2009, 2009/2010 and 2010/2011 sea
turtle nesting seasons, collected by the staff of the NGO Ecoassociados. A total of 335 E. imbricata nests
were recorded between the months of October and April with peak nesting in February, a period that
coincides with the high tourist season. The highest occurrence of nests was on Merepe’s beach, with 55.7%.
Female E. imbricata, which had nested, present a mean and standard deviation of curved carapace length
and curved carapace width, 92.0 ± 6.1 cm and 83.2 ± 6.3 cm, respectively. The mean clutch size was found
to be 142.4 eggs. The average incubation time was found to be 56.6 days on the beaches of the city of
188
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Ipojuca, and appeared similar when compared to other studies in Brazil. Based on the estimated pivotal
incubation time of 62.8 days and considering that the average incubation time recorded in the region was
56.6 days, a female skewed sex ratio for E. imbricata occurs on the southern coast of Pernambuco. The
average reproductive success recorded was 62.9%, was relatively low compared to values shown in studies
conducted elsewhere. It is recommended that environmental education campaigns to educate the local
community and tourists be undertaken, because the period of sea turtle nesting coincides with the huge
influx of tourists. Greater efforts should be allocated to Merepe’s beach that proved to be the main nesting
site. It is recommended to undertake further research on the physical and chemical characteristics of
Ipojuca beaches in order to establish which features are related to the distribution of sea turtle nesting.
FATE AND EMERGENCE SUCCESS OF HAWKSBILL (ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA) NESTS
IN THE COMARCA NGÖBE-BUGLÉ AND BOCAS DEL TORO PROVINCE, PANAMA
Cristina Ordoñez1, Peter Meylan2, Anne Meylan3, and Emma Harrison4
1
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Correo General, Bocas del Toro, Bocas del Toro Province, Republic of Panama
Natural Sciences, Eckerd College, St. Petersburg, Florida, USA, and Smithsonian Tropical Research
Institute, Balboa, Panamá
3
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, St. Petersburg,
Florida, USA and Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Balboa, Panamá
4
Sea Turtle Conservancy, San Pedro, Costa Rica
2
There is a long history of both commercial and subsistence use of hawksbills (Eretmochelys imbricata) in
Bocas del Toro Province and the Comarca Ngöbe-Buglé, Panama. Extraction of hawksbills from beaches in
the area to support the international trade in hawksbills led to a precipitous decline in nesting. In 2003, a
consortium of interested individuals and organizations, including the Wildlife Conservation Society and the
Sea Turtle Conservancy, established a standardized monitoring and protection program at Playa Chiriquí,
Isla Escudo de Veraguas and Cayos Zapatillas in Parque Nacional Marino Isla Bastimentos. Playa Roja and
Playa Larga were subsequently added to the program. During the 2009, 2010 and 2011 nesting seasons,
daily track surveys were conducted at each of the five study sites. At all localities, the presence of eggs was
confirmed and the nest was marked using flagging tapes; triangulation was used to subsequently locate the
nest for evaluation. Nests were evaluated using a standardized protocol three days (72 hrs) after signs of
emergence were observed or after 70 days if no signs of emergence were reported. Data from the
evaluations were used to determine emergence success (hatchlings successfully exiting the nest) using the
following formula: ((# egg shells – # hatchlings encountered in the nest) / total # eggs)) * 100 %. During
the three-year period, over 3,500 hawksbill nests from five study sites were evaluated. Across the five
beaches, the average number of nests that were intact at hatching was 83.8% (68.5 - 92.8%). The lower
value (68.5%) at Playa Chiriquí was mostly due to predation (27.1% of nests), primarily by domestic dogs.
The average emergence success of intact in situ nests at the five study sites was 76.2% (66.0 - 82.1%). Over
the three years, 127 nests at Cayos Zapatillas were relocated because of imminent threat of erosion. These
nests had an average emergence success of 61.5% vs. 80.7% for in situ nests (n = 1047). At Playa Chiriquí,
predation reduced emergence success to 12.5% for in situ predated nests (n = 377). Buried plastic-coated
metal screens (30x30 cm) were used on some nests to reduce predation by dogs. However, the high density
of nests and the fact that the application of the screens is very labor-intensive, meant that only a small
percentage of nests could be protected. Nests that were protected had an increase in emergence success. As
another measure, the communities near the beach were also asked to help control their dogs. Because of the
presence of beach monitors, illegal poaching of nests has been largely eliminated on all the study beaches.
189
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IMPACTS OF WRACK DEPOSITION ON ST. CATHERINES ISLAND, GA
Kathryn M. Ortiz1, R. Kelly Vance2, and Gale A. Bishop3
1
St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, St. Catherines Island, GA, USA
Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, GA and St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, St.
Catherines Island, GA, USA
3
GeoTrec LLC, St. Catherines Island Sea Turtle Program, St. Catherines Island, GA, USA
2
This study addresses the impacts of major beach wrack accumulation events on St. Catherines Island,
Georgia, including: obstruction of nesting; development of cryptic nests; and hatchling loss. The compound
effect of rising sea level and increasing frequency and height of storm surges flushed Spartina alterniflora
debris out of nearby salt marshes and deposited it as wide, thick, wrack mats on the beaches of southeastern
U.S. barrier islands in 2009 and 2012. On St. Catherines Island, GA, these events appeared to negatively
impact loggerhead nesting success. The apparent negative impact observed by similar conditions in 2009
promoted the 2012 effort to document changes in loggerhead nesting behavior, subsequent impacts on
hatching success, and hatchling egress into the sea. Wrack accumulation also forced adaption of monitoring
procedures and protocols to cope with the new challenge. The ratio of non-nesting to nesting crawls is one
proxy for the difficulty of nesting; the normal average is 1:1 on Georgia beaches, and the normal nonnesting/nesting ratio on St. Catherines is 2:1 due to the high proportion of erosional beaches. During the
2012 nesting season, major wrack deposition events on St. Catherines drove this proxy to a 5:1. The
loggerheads that nested successfully modified the typical nesting ethogram with sand crawls that gave way
to subtle, flattened trails of wrack as the female crossed over it and back to the sea. Nests in the wrack
lacked the typical body pit and exhibited little tossed sand to indicate covering activity. These nests within
the wrack mat are described as a new class of obstructed nests designated cryptic nests. The attempted
egress of hatchlings from nests obstructed or buried by the wrack mats has been observed and documented
in several nests. A typical emergence with an unobstructed path to the sea results in a suite of tiny
crawlways that diverge from the nest toward the surf with the crawl “fan” usually being less than 30 m
wide by the time the hatchlings reach the water line, unless the tide is very low. Hatchlings obstructed by
wrack ridges were diverted laterally with some traveling over 200 meters before crossing a low spot in the
wrack ridge. Inventories of nests and counts of hatchling crawls behind the wrack line versus crawls on the
open beach indicate losses of 45 to 60 % of the emerged hatchlings to predators and/or trapping within the
wrack. Negative impacts were also recorded for nests deposited within the wrack, or nests buried by a
subsequent ‘wrack event’ at some point during incubation. Nests that incubated beneath wrack mats
accumulated additional sand, compacting the wrack mat, and “deepening” the egg chamber beyond the
55cm average depth. The number of ‘stragglers’ in emerging nests significantly increased, as well as the
number of corpses found trapped beneath the wrack.
IMPACTS OF A DECLINING BEACH PROFILE ON HAWKSBILL TURTLE NESTING
SUCCESS AND SITE CHOICE
Jonathan M. Pahlas1, Charles A. Braman2, and Seth P. Stapleton3
1
Jumby Bay Hawksbill Project, Long Island, Antigua and Barbuda, West Indies
Department of Marine Science, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA
3
Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Conservation Biology, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN, USA
2
The critically endangered hawksbill sea turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) prefers nesting on beaches with
vegetated areas, but anthropogenic alterations, coupled with extreme weather events, often result in
190
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
massive alterations to beach profiles. Since intensive saturation tagging efforts began at the nesting rookery
on Long Island (Jumby Bay), Antigua in 1987, the Jumby Bay Hawksbill Project (JBHP) has observed
extensive changes to the primary beachfront including estate construction, beach extensions, vegetation bed
planting, and hurricane-induced sand erosion. Using aerial photography collected since the 1980s, we
quantify these changes on a coarse geographic scale. We use transects oriented perpendicularly to the high
tide line and spaced at regular 10 m intervals to estimate vegetative cover and species diversity across
available nesting habitat and categorize beach zones based upon vegetation and embankment height
resultant from storm activity. Observations from 2012 indicate notable increases in unsuccessful nest
attempts and encounters with previous nests compared to recent years; therefore, we evaluate the effects of
beach embankment height and vegetation cover on nesting success by comparing nest locations, incidences
of unsuccessful nesting attempts, and encounters with incubating nests between the 2005 and 2012 nesting
seasons. Finally, we address the hypothesis that nesting events occur a shorter distance inland when turtles
nest atop embankments. Preliminary results suggest that since 2005, rapid growth of planted vegetation
beds of invasive Scaevola sericea and heavy erosion have drastically changed the face of Jumby Bay’s
nesting beach. An undeveloped beach on mainland Antigua provides a benchmark for recommendations for
beach restoration to improve hawksbill nesting habitat on Long Island. With these results, we will evaluate
the impacts of the rapidly changing beach profile and vegetation to inform management actions to preserve
this rich nesting site.
TIDAL AND BEACH CONFIGURATION INFLUENCES ON THE LANDING OF MARINE
TURTLES ON THEIR NESTING BEACH
Christina Péron1, Damien Chevallier2, and Antoine Gardel1
1
2
CNRS GUYANE, USR 3456, Cayenne, French Guiana
Institut pluridisciplinaire Hubert Curien, Strasbourg, France
The estuarine beach of Yalimapo, located in the western French Guiana (South America) is a major nesting
site for Leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) and green (Chelonia mydas) turtles in the region. During the
nesting season (February to August), turtles come to lay during night all over the beach. Most of the
literature papers have been focused on tidal influence, more precisely the temporal repartition of marine
turtles in regard to high tide, in order to adjust the beach patrol survey. On Yalimapo beach, marine turtles
nesting repartition are not homogenous and spatial nesting patterns seem to be dispatched on the beach.
This beach forms part of the highly dynamics shoreline of the Guianas coast due to mudbank migration.
Nevertheless, the estuarine position of the beach , on the Maroni river estuary, had held the sustainability of
the beach through time, and therefore constitute a stable nesting site for marine turtles. The comprehension
of their nesting behavior is a major issue in conservation programs. The hypothesis of these spatial patterns
is the beach configuration which could explained this behavior. In this context, we divided the beach into
three areas corresponded to three different characteristics zones. In this study, we proposed a combined
analysis of the influence of both tidal and the onshore morphological features on the repartition of the
leatherback and green turtles. The more western area, located near the mouth of the Maroni river, has
typical onshore morphological features such as a sandy bank. This bank constitute an obstacle at low tide,
when it is emerge and could be a natural barrier during marine turtle displacement to access the beach. The
middle and eastern side of the beach is less influenced by the onshore shoal. Consequently, they are free of
any obstacle for the access of the beach by marine turtles. Furthermore, the tidal level influence the onshore
configuration which play a role in the marine turtles repartition. The study highlighted a temporal and
spatial variable of the turtle’s repartition, depending on the species and the localization on the beach.
General observation highlighted a more important arrival of the leatherback turtles during the flood
whereas green turtles are more present during the ebb. Then, we denoted a highly pronounced arrival of
leatherback and green turtles in the western part of the beach during the flood and near the high tide (where
the water level is high), when the sand bank is immerged. And then constitute a free area with no obstacle
for the turtles to come to lay in this portion. However the middle and eastern part of the beach studied is
191
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
more frequented by Green turtles during the ebb. The estuarine position of the beach seems intensify the
tidal current during the flood and ebb. Also, during the flood when the level water is high, the turtles could
be transported in the western part of the beach but also on the other side of the beach during the ebb.
TOUCHING BASE – THE STATUS OF MARINE TURTLE NESTING AT THE PATRICK AIR
FORCE INSTALLATION, FLORIDA (USA)
Steffan M. Pierre, Andrew T. Sterner, and Llewellyn M. Ehrhart
University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA
Since 1987, extensive surveys of marine turtle nesting at the Patrick Air Force Base (PAFB) in Brevard
County FL, USA have been conducted by the University of Central Florida Marine Turtle Research Group
(UCFMTRG). These surveys are among the oldest uninterrupted datasets informing the Index Nesting
Beach Survey (INBS) program. This program, developed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, documents temporal and spatial distribution of
nesting, as well as responses to beach nourishment and recreational activity. The PAFB study area extends
seven kilometers north of Pineda Causeway, SR 404, along the beach front parallel to the eastern margin of
the Base. Three marine turtle species listed under the Endangered Species Act are found at PAFB –
loggerheads (Caretta caretta), green turtles (Chelonia mydas) and leatherbacks (Dermochelys coriacea).
The 2012 loggerhead nest total was 1,530, a 44% increase from the 2011 season (1,056) and 22% above the
PAFB long-term average (1987-2011). Six leatherbacks nests were also documented in 2012 (high for
PAFB) with no observed nests in 2011. Green turtles nested 28 times, tripling 2011 nesting (9), but 24%
less than 2010 (37). This represents a moderately-high year for green turtles and confirms the return to a
biannual “high-low” nesting oscillation observed at the Base, after deviating from the pattern during 2004 2008 (all moderately-high years; mean = 31.8 nests). During the 2012 nesting season, the effects of a 2011
nourishment on the southern-most 3km of the beach (pre-season dune face reformation; UCF km 0.0-3.0),
and the long term effects of the 2005 nourishment (UCF km 3.0-7.0) were also evaluated. Nesting success
for loggerheads usually declines in the first season after nourishment, with subsequent recovery. However
at PAFB, the beach-wide 2005 project saw higher nesting success in the first season post-nourishment than
previous projects (46.0%). Subsequently, nesting improved to 53.4% in 2006, and has been basically
increasing over the last six years, with 58% nesting success in 2012. During the 2011 season, nesting
success in the 2011 nourished area (UCF km 0.0-3.0) was 49%, which is higher than post-nourishment
success for the 2005 project (46%), although it represents a 9.9% decrease from 2010 (58.9%). As
predicted, 2012 nesting returned to 2010 levels (59%). Similarly, in the 2011 non-nourished areas, nesting
success rose to 54.5% in 2011 (an increase of 6.1% from 2010) and further improved in 2012 to 58%.
Given that recent nourishment programs did not result in appreciable nesting depression after sand
placement, the overall trend may portend that loggerhead nesting success may be generally increasing at
PAFB in recent years. Long term continuous surveys of this nature are instrumental in identifying long
term nesting trends and informing government policy regarding coastal management and marine turtle
protection. The presentation of this data would not have been possible without the generosity of the
International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service,
Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics
and CLS America.
192
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CONTINUED DECLINE OF NESTING LEATHERBACK TURTLES AT CULEBRA ISLAND,
PUERTO RICO
Cristian Ramírez-Gallego1, Carlos E. Diez2, Karla Barrientos-Muñoz1, Abby White3, and Ana M.
Roman4
1
Universidad de Puerto Rico, Departamento de Biologia, PO Box 23360, San Juan, PR 00931
Programa de Especies Protegidas, Departamento de Recursos Naturales, PO Box 366147, San Juan, PR
00936
3
Proyecto Tinglar-Culebra, PO Box 217, Culebra, PR 00775
4
Culebra National Wildlife Refuge, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, PO Box 190 Culebra, Puerto Rico
2
The nesting activity of leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) in Culebra Island, Puerto Rico occurs from
mid-March to mid-July and it has been studied since 1984. Therefore, was long known as one of the largest
nesting rookeries in the eastern of Puerto Rico, is as well as, in previous seasons were counted of between
200 to 400 nests. Throughout all these years, the data collected on Culebra's beaches indicated the
importance of these nesting areas at local and Caribbean region level. Nevertheless, since 2004 the nesting
trend declined steadily. Surveys conducted during nesting season at Culebra Island, 2012 revealed an
extremely low number of leatherback females (5 females) and of nests laid (32 nests) on the island's
beaches. Although, in several near-by leatherback nesting areas such as NEC (northeastern ecological
corridor), 17 km west off Culebra Island, localized in Fajardo and Luquillo (mainland Puerto Rico) the
number of nests has increased steadily, from more or less the date of nesting on Culebra Island has decrease.
Then, is possible that nesting females are emigrate Culebra Island and are giving use to other near-by
beaches to nest, resulting in a reduction in the number of nests reported during the past eight years in
Culebra Island. Evidence it are two females marked in previous seasons in Culebra Island, reported in the
season 2012 nesting at Rio Grande (adjacent area to Luquillo), and other female nesting at Piñones (near of
San Juan city). Therefore, the leatherback nesting should understand like a dynamic regional, where each
individual of the species recognizes numerous nearby beaches as a wide area for nesting. For that reason, is
necessary develop monitoring effort in the region for ensure the leatherbacks conservation.
PROFILES OF PROTECTED AREA NESTING BEACHES AT PUMPKIN HILL AND CUERO Y
SALADO WILDLIFE REFUGE, HONDURAS
Robyn E. Reeve1, Dustin S. Baumbach2, Lindsey E. Damazo2, Stephen G. Dunbar2, Amy L. Tan1,
Ariana Cunningham3, Angela Randazzo4, and Lidia Salinas5
1
Department of Biology, Walla Walla University, College Place, WA, USA
Marine Research Group, Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma
Linda, CA, USA
3
Department of Biology, Andrews University, Berrien Springs, MI, USA
4
Department of Biology, Regional University Center of the Atlantic Coast (CURLA), Autonomous
University of Honduras (UNAH)
5
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research (ProTECTOR) Honduras,
Tegucigalpa, Honduras
2
Pumpkin Hill Beach is the predominant nesting beach for Hawksbill turtles on the Bay Island of Utila,
Honduras, and thus is extremely important to the regional conservation of the species. We surveyed both
elevation and vegetation profiles for the entirety of Pumpkin Hill Beach (475 m). To measure elevation,
193
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
transit level points were taken every 5 m for the entirety of each beach length. Vegetation coverage was
documented along each section of beach. The beach at the Cuero y Salado Wildlife Refuge, on the north
coast of Honduras, is also a potentially important site for sea turtle conservation. An elevation profile was
also created for a 1,000 m stretch of beach, and vegetation composition was measured every 20 m along a
1,000 m stretch. At Pumpkin Hill, we found 16 species of plants, and the area in which turtles chose to nest
had significantly more tree cover than other beach areas. At Cuero y Salado, 13 species of plants were
recorded during vegetation surveys, and this beach had sufficient vegetation to be considered a potential
nesting site for turtles. Results of these surveys will be used to calculate future beach erosion on both
Pumpkin Hill and Cuero y Salado beaches, as well as monitor changes in beach structure and vegetation
over time that may impact turtle nesting activity and egg development. This study will provide valuable
information for sea turtle conservation efforts by determining what factors contribute to appropriate nesting
beach areas for both Pumpkin Hill Beach and Cuero y Salado Wildlife Refuge.
TEMPORAL VARIATION OF INCUBATION TEMPERATURE OF GREEN TURTLE NESTS IN
THE SOUTHWESTERN CUBAN ARCHIPELAGO
Julia A. Ricardo1, José L. G. Muro2, Fernando Bretos Trelles3, and Adrián G. Abraham1
1
Marine Research Centre, Havana University, Havana, Cuba
WWF, Havana, Cuba
3
The Ocean Foundation, Miami, Florida, USA
2
We analysed five years of incubation temperature data for green turtle (Chelonia mydas) nests at the
westernmost region of the Cuban Archipelago (2004, 2006, 2007, 2011 and 2012). We compared the
temperatures of the entire incubation period as well as during the thermosensitive period when sex is
determined. There was a significant difference in temperature during this period (F(8, 1143)=5, p<0.01)
although the most interesting result was that the median value of the thermosensitive period was above
29.5oC in four of the five years analyzed. This indicates that a higher proportion of females were most
likely produced. However, when the complete incubation period is considered, there was an increase in the
median temperature with a significant difference between the two later years and the previous ones (F(4,
1153)=22.3 p<0.01). We also compared these temperatures (measured in the middle of the nests) with
temperatures recorded from the bottom of the nests. There was a significant difference between
temperatures from the bottom and middle of the nests during incubation (F(1, 3606)= 13,0126; p<0.001).
However, the median temperature remained over 29.5oC indicating that temperatures remained skewed
towards female production for the entire nest. When the nest temperatures were compared with sand
temperatures at the same depth, there was a difference that increases throughout incubation, but if we add
the sand temperatures to the average difference with nest temperatures, we can determine nest temperatures
with 81% certainty (R2=0.81). If the same analysis is performed with air temperatures, this certainty falls to
55% (R2=0.55). Finally, it was also possible to detect the influence of a tropical storm on incubation
temperature. There was a significant difference in the mean nest temperature when considering the
influence of the storm (F(1, 3600)=54, p<0.01). Nevertheless, this difference will depend on the nest position
on the beach since it seems that innundation of the sea has more of an impact than rain and, therefore, nests
closer to the sea showed a higher variation in temperature than those further from the sea.
Acknowledgements: We will like to thank all the persons and institution that made possible our
participation at the Symposium, specially those who helped with the travel grants.
194
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EFFECTS OF INCREASED CONSTRUCTION ON THE DISTRIBUTION OF LOGGERHEAD
NESTS IN SOUTHERN KYPARISSIA BAY, GREECE
Thomas E. Riggall, ALan F. Rees, and Dimitris Margaritoulis
ARCHELON, the Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Athens, Greece
Kyparissia Bay, in the Western Peloponnese in Greece, contains an approximately 44-km long beach, and
hosts the second largest nesting population of loggerhead turtles in the Mediterranean. Within this bay
approximately 84% of the nesting occurs in the southern 9.5 km, stretching from the Arcadikos river in
front of the village of Kalo Nero, to the Neda river near the village of Elaia. The southernmost 2.2 km
section in front of Kalo Nero village (Sector O), is differentiated from the rest of the bay by its much
narrower, steeper and rockier beach, whereas the majority of the rest of the bay has a wide sandy platform
and is backed by dunes, fields and coastal forest. Historically, Sector O has been characterised by little
construction (restaurants, street lights, hotels and bars) behind the beach leaving much of the sector
undisturbed, quiet and dark. However, gradually over the last 15 years development behind and on the
beach has increased. The beach can now be categorised in three ways: undisturbed by artificial light or
noise; affected by artificial light only and affected by both artificial light and noise. Since 1999 the beach
has been divided into 50-m sections, and nest locations have been recorded accurately; this has allowed
changes in nest distribution to be documented. Nest numbers on Sector O have remained fairly constant
over the past 15 years, when the rest of the monitored sectors have shown an increasing trend, therefore the
proportion of nests on Sector O has actually decreased. Additionally, nest distribution within Sector O has
shifted dramatically, with nest numbers negatively correlated to development behind the beach. However,
artificial light alone has not caused this distribution shift, as demonstrated by one 100-m section of beach,
heavily illuminated by a hotel, which has shown a dramatic increase in nests, 1999 and 2000 had 2 and 4
nests respectively; 2011 and 2012 had 29 and 55. A further section of 800 m which now has many bars,
hotels and streetlights (a combination of lights and noise) has seen the biggest decrease in nests from 80
and 61 in 1999 and 2000, to 21 and 16 in 2011 and 2012. Although this shows that the adult females are
moving away from the most disturbed areas they are still nesting where there is significant lighting, leading
to hatchlings from these nests suffering from serious disorientation, and requiring significant intervention
to allow them to safely reach the sea. The changes observed so far indicate what impact further
development along the entire bay could have in the area; further areas of the beach may become unsuitable
for nesting and the distribution could change even more significantly. Worse still, there is the potential for
development to affect overall nest numbers in the bay. Acknowledgments: We thank all field assistants and
the many hundred volunteers without whom the above long-term work would not happen. TER wishes to
thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries
Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack,
Telonics, CLS America and the International Sea Turtle Symposium for a travel grant.
195
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ESTIMATION OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) HATCHING RATES OF
CHACOCENTE AND LA FLOR BEACHES, NICARAGUA DURING THE 2009 AND 2011
NESTING SEASONS
Heydi Salazar1, Perla Torres1, Lidiceth Jarquin1, Danelia Benavides1, Roldán Valverde2, Jose
Urteaga1, Luis Fonseca3, Domingo Cuendis1, Carol Cabrera1, Nancy Barahona1, Marcial Chávez1,
Nelson Guevara1, Wilber Alegría1, Jefer Cruz4, and Faustino Obando4
1
Fauna & Flora International, Nicaragua
Department of Biological Sciences, Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, LA, USA
3
Coordinador del Programa Binacional Costa Rica-Panamá, Widecast, Costa Rica
4
Ministerio del Ambiente y los Recursos Naturales, Nicaragua
2
The olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea) is the most abundant sea turtle species along the Pacific coast of
Nicaragua. This species is known to nest solitarily all year round, and in massive arribadas at Chacocente
and La Flor beaches between July and January. Since the 1980s, studies have been conducted to assess the
number of females participating in the arribadas (using a total count methodology) and hatching rates.
Since 2008, the instantaneous count method based on transect methodology has been implemented along
with a new methodology to study hatching rates based on marking, monitoring and exhumation of nests.
Using these methodologies, we took a sample of 744 arribada nests during the 2009 and 2011 nesting
seasons to estimate hatchling production at both beaches. We observed that 26.88% of the nests were lost to
tidal erosion, other nesting turtles, predation by domestic fauna and poaching. We were able to exhume the
rest of the 544 nests (73.11%) to measure hatching rates and study causes of embryo mortality. Chacocente
exhibited the highest nest loss (24.46% vs 2.41% of La Flor). The greatest nest loss at Chacocente was due
to nests that could not be found (68.13%) followed by poached nests (14.35%). The greatest nests loss at La
Flor was due to destruction by nesting conspecifics (24.32%). These differences are likely due to the higher
number of turtles that nest at La Flor (~57% more than at Chacocente) which promoted destruction of early
nests due to higher nest density. This greater number of nests was also likely responsible for the greater
emersion rate (57%) observed in La Flor during 2011. Total hatchling production in 2009 and 2011 for
both beaches amounted to 4,146,986, with La Flor contributing a greater percentage (70%) than
Chacocente (30%). Analyzing the data by season, 2011 was significantly more productive than 2009, with
86% more hatchlings. This coincides with an increase of 17% more nests reported during 2011 (111,568
nests). It is important to highlight that more than 1,000,000 hatchlings were produced in 2011 for both
beaches combined. Generally, emergence rates for both beaches were very high (Chacocente=24.21%, La
lor=36.71%) relative to emergence rates reported for other arribada beaches. The emergence rate of 54%
for Chacocente and La Flor was slightly higher than the 52% reported for Nancite beach, Costa Rica in
2011. This may be explained by relatively low nesting volume in the Nicaraguan beaches, which does not
exceed 86,000 nests. The dynamics of the nest microenvironment at arribada beaches are complex and
many variables were not measured in this study (i.e. incubation temperature, humidity, number of clutches
per area and substrate) and we recommend including these variables in future studies. However, the present
study demonstrates that both beaches are contributing a large number of hatchlings to the marine ecosystem
and these are beaches that support an adequate number of clutches.
196
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
CONSERVATION OF SEA TURTLES IN PLAYA CEUTA, ELOTA, SINALOA, MEXICO: 20122013 SEASON
Fernando E. Saracho1, Marco A. B. Ortega1, Ingmar S. Cornejo1, Jesús I. Guardado-González2, Juan
L. C. González1, Zuleica B. G. Camacho Gonzalez1, and Saúl Rubio1
1
2
Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa, Mexico
Ayuntamiento de Elota, Sinaloa, México
The Autonomous University of Sinaloa, through the Faculty of Marine Science and School of Biology and
supported by institutions including the Elota City Council, Agricultural Tarriba, Sinaloa Science Center and
CONANP, carries out the conservation activities on the olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea) beach in Ceuta,
Elota, Sinaloa, Mexico (40 km). The camp now considered a "Sea Turtle Sanctuary" and has a rustic
auditorium and museum which can host environmental education presentations for a large number of
visitors, including school groups, professionals, and regional and foreign tourists. Clutches of eggs are
transplanted into incubation pens and boxes. To date, 22,500 eggs were protected and over 5,500 hatchlings
have been released. Some nests are left "in situ" for research purposes. For the first time in 35 years, a
black turtle, Chelonia agassizii, nested on this beach.
EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT LIGHT INTENSITIES ON HATCHLING LEATHERBACK
(DEMOCHELYS CORICEA) SEA TURTLES
Alyssa Scarfo, Eric Koepfler, Taylor Dacal, Destinee Green, Taylor LaChance, and Molly Wainscott
Coastal Carolina University, Conway, SC, USA
Upon emergence from the nest, sea turtle hatchlings are able to direct themselves towards the ocean. There
are two visual cues used in this sea finding behavior; light intensity and horizon elevation. Hatchlings have
a visual cone of acceptance that is 180 degrees wide and 30 degrees vertical. They use this visual cone to
orient themselves towards the brightest horizon, as they are positively attracted to light. Natural light and
artificial light influence a turtle’s orientation. Natural light supplied by celestial bodies helps hatchlings
orient themselves towards the ocean while artificial light disorients and may lead them in the opposite
direction of the ocean. It has been concluded that most sea turtles are attracted to wavelengths below 525
nm. The purpose of this study was to observe the change in speed and directional orientation when testing
different artificial light (red and blue light) and natural light sources on hatchling leatherback turtles. We
collected 5 hatchlings for each of the three experiments conducted each night for three nights (45
hatchlings total). We first assigned numbers to each turtle and then measured their straight carapace length
ad width and their mass. The hatchlings were then transported to the beach where day, time, light source
and weather status were recorded. Three experiments were conducted each night with natural light and
artificial light (red and blue). Natural light experiments were conducted at 1800 h and 1900 h, and the red
and blue lights were tested at 2000 h. We measured the light intensity using a sky quality meter. After
physical characteristics were recorded we placed the turtles in order relative to their number. They were
released at a starting point facing the ocean. After a one minute interval, a flag was placed at the location of
each hatchling to mark their trails, for a total of six minutes. Once all five hatchlings in a single experiment
reached the ocean, the distance and angles of each turtle’s track was measured starting from their specific
starting point. These tests showed that leatherback hatchlings moved more efficiently under natural light
settings. During the natural light tests at 1800 h and 1900 h the hatchlings’ tracks were direct and oriented
towards the brightest horizon, however some wandering did occur. When tested with artificial light, the
197
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
hatchlings either moved much slower and oriented themselves directly towards the light source or moved in
circles around the starting point. Hatchlings were more disoriented when red light was used than under a
natural light setting. This information can help us in future leatherback research because many scientists
use red light when working with leatherback hatchlings. However, based on our study, the use of red lights
significantly disoriented the hatchlings. We found that less light of any source, artificial or natural, will aid
leatherback hatchlings in their orientation and speed towards the ocean.
SPATIAL ANALYSIS OF SEA TURTLE NESTING FREQUENCY ON TWO BARRIER ISLANDS
IN NORTH CAROLINA
Marc B. Sciance and Joanne Halls
University of North Carolina Wilmington, Wilmington, NC, USA
Despite falling in the northern area of the loggerhead (Caretta caretta) nesting range, North Carolina
beaches still receive a large number of sea turtle nests during the summer nesting season. Although the
numbers are significantly fewer than Florida, which can see up to 10,000 nesting females in a single season,
the dedication put forth towards protecting this smaller population nesting in North Carolina is essential
due to their endangered status. This study investigated the effects of environmental and anthropogenic
variables (elevation, beach angle, distance between nests to shoreline, and proximity to piers, houses and
jetties) on the frequency of sea turtle nesting on two North Carolina barrier islands, Masonboro Island and
Topsail Island. Masonboro is uninhabited and managed by the National Estuarine Research Reserve and
Topsail Island contains large residential areas and some commercial development. Topsail has a long
history of land use development that is predominantly single-family residential areas including oceanfront
housing stretched along the entire 20km length of the island. The commercial areas are largely focused in
the towns of Surf City and to a lesser extent in the town of Topsail Beach and include piers with nighttime
fishing. Multiple GIS spatial analysis techniques were used in this study to determine which variables most
influence nesting distribution and to construct an overall predictive model for sea turtle nesting. The
variables that are most correlated with sea turtle nesting distribution, in both study areas, were proximity to
piers and jetties and the angle of the beachfront. The results obtained from this study document how GIS
can provide beneficial spatial analysis techniques when researching sea turtle nesting information. Data
from this project is available as a resource for sea turtle conservation programs already in place in North
Carolina as well as other programs that have an interest in utilizing GIS to study spatial patterns.
MARINE TURTLES NESTS IN DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENTS IMPACTED IN THE NATURAL
RESERVES OF MONA AND CULEBRA ISLANDS, PUERTO RICO
Krystina R. Scott1 and Carlos E. Diez2
1
2
University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez Campus, Puerto Rico
Department of Natural and Environmental Resources of Puerto Rico
The perpetuity and conservation of marine turtles in the Caribbean Islands depends on the dynamic of the
beaches. Two of the most critically endangered marine turtle species nest in Puerto Rico’s shores; these are
the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) and the leatherback turtle (Dermochelys coriacea). With the
goal of understanding the dynamic environments and the impact on marine turtle nests, we selected two
remote islands adjacent to Puerto Rico. The beaches in Mona Island and Culebra Island represent a
198
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
dynamic shore exposed to swells from cold fronts, tropical storms, and flash floods. Recent studies on
beach profiles indicate a dramatic pattern of changes in beach slopes and lengths. The Amny Method for
measuring beach profiles helped to determine vulnerable zones of erosion, accretion, and sand banks
transported and deposited offshore to inshore. The Island of Mona is known for its high number of
hawksbill nests, while Culebra for its high number of leatherback nests. However, in the past years nesting
numbers in Mona Island have increased considerable (>70%), and in Culebra Island the leatherback nests
have decreased significantly (<70%). The factors attributed to these changes in nesting numbers could be a
combinations of biotic and management. Understanding the dynamic of these beaches could have an
important impact on the success and productivity of sea turtles.
NESTING ECOLOGY AND REPRODUCTIVE SUCCESS OF OLIVE RIDLEY (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) SEA TURTLE AT GODAVARI RIVER MOUTH NESTING BEACHES, ANDHRA
COAST, BAY OF BENGAL, INDIA
P. S. Raja Sekhar
Dept. of Environmental Sciences, Andhra University, Visakhapatnam - 530 003, A.P, INDIA
The Godavari river mouth of Bay of Bengal on East Coast of India is situated between 16°17’ and 18°
30’N latitudes and 81°30’ and 82°37’ E longitudes. The nesting beaches of Godavari River mouth were
separated into four distinctive zones (I, II, III and IV) based on their topography and morphological
characteristics. The mainland beaches nearer to river mouth of zone-I was high elevated and flat terraced
type, while the riverine sand spits, shoals and lagoon fringed beaches of zones II, III and IV were fine
sandy beaches. The profile of nesting beaches and grain sizes of Godavari river mouth were analyzed to
correlate nesting activity and reproductive success (hatching of eggs and emergence of hatchlings) of olive
ridley sea turtle (Lepidochelys olivacea). Maximum nesting activity of olive ridley turtles was observed
during March (50.15%) and April (22.36%), while lowest was recorded in January (8.28%), February
(17.24%) and almost negligible in December (1.97%). Nesting density was recorded highest in zone, III,
beaches with 34.0 nests/km-1, followed by zone, I of 4.64 nests/ km-1, zone, IV with 3.14 nests/ km-1 and
lowest in zone, II of 2.16 nests/km-1. The reproductive success rate (hatching of eggs and emergence of
hatchlings) was highest, 52.50 %, in zone, II beaches where as the remaining zones (I, III, &IV) were
recorded with lowest hatching success of 36.20% respectively. Nest survival and hatching success was
highest (62.71%) at 20 to 40 meters beach profile distances and beyond 40 and 60 meters the nest survival
rate was lowest (20.50 %.) due to presence of lowest moisture content in beach sands resulted in poor
hatching success. In view of above findings the Godavari River mouth is considered to be as potential
“reproductive patch” to olive ridley turtle after Gahirmatha and Rishikulya nesting beaches on east coast of
India. Thus the nesting beaches are recommended for protection as a "sea turtle rookery” by the A.P.Forest
Department for conservation of nesting habitats and foraging grounds of olive ridley turtles.
199
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EFFECTS OF INUNDATION ON HATCH SUCCESS OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE
(CARETTA CARETTA) NESTS*
Katherine R. Shaw1 and Dave Addison2
1
2
University of Miami, Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, Miami, Florida, USA
Conservancy of Southwest Florida, Naples, Florida, USA
Inundation of sea turtle nests typically results in decreased hatching success with repeatedly flooded nests
being affected most severely. While nests can tolerate some inundation, it is unclear how the frequency and
water level within the egg chamber influences hatching success as embryonic development progresses.
Piezometers were installed to determine water levels within the egg chambers over periods ranging from
eight to twelve hours. Hatching success was determined by excavating nests and determining the relative
proportion of hatched to unhatched eggs. For unhatched eggs, we reported the embryonic stage at which
development ceased. In 2012, two tropical storms, Debby and Isaac, severely impacted the hatching
success of nearly all the nests on Keewaydin Island. Debby washed away 50.7% of the nests and inundated
98.5% of the remaining nests. Isaac washed away 25.9% of the nests and inundated 79.1% of the remaining
nests. Nests were inundated up to 66 cm, which filled the entire egg chamber with water. Debby inundated
nests for up to four consecutive days while Isaac flooded some nests for up to 24 h. In the nests impacted
by Debby, all the embryos stopped developing at the time the storm hit. These nests had a mean hatching
success of 3.63%, while nests inundated by Isaac had a mean hatching success of 67.6%. Nests not
inundated by either storm had a mean hatching success of 85.8%. Data from several nests provided insight
into how inundation impacts hatching success. Nests 107 and 110 were laid < 5 days before the waves and
high tides caused by Debby became evident. In these nests, 100% of the eggs appeared to be
undifferentiated; however, it is likely that the eggs stopped developing before the embryos were visible.
Nest 53, laid 19 days before Debby arrived, had a hatching success of 16.2%. This nest was completely
inundated for approximately 12 hours two days after being laid and intermittently inundated again for up to
four days during Debby. Half of the eggs (54.7%) survived the initial inundations but stopped developing
later, possibly during Debby. Thirty-three days after it was laid, nest 151 was inundated for approximately
24 h by Isaac. This nest continued to develop and had a hatching success of 92.2%. An additional nest
(142) that was not inundated until Isaac passed by, was flooded for less than 12 h two days later. The dead
embryos found in this nest stopped developing around the time of the second inundation. The hatching
success was 58.1%, which suggested that the second inundation, which filled the bottom 8.3 cm of an egg
chamber with a total depth of 17.8 cm, was responsible for the cessation of development for the bottom half
of this clutch. Nests not over-washed by tides may still be flooded by tidally induced fluctuations in the
water table. Consequently, nests deposited closer to the shore or in swales are more subject to flooding by
interstitial water and may therefore have lower hatching success. Acknowledgments: This research would
not have been possible without the support of the Conservancy of Southwest Florida, countless hours of
piezometer checking by Sarah Moss, Matt Ramirez, and Jamie Fisher, and travel grants from the
International Sea Turtle Symposium and Dr. David Die.
200
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DARKER BEACHES, BRIGHTER FUTURE: REDUCING THE IMPACTS OF ARTIFICIAL
LIGHTING ON SEA TURTLE NESTING BEACHES
Karen Shudes and David Godfrey
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Gainesville, Florida, USA
Each year in Florida tens of thousands of sea turtle hatchlings are disoriented by poorly managed
beachfront lights. To address this problem, Sea Turtle Conservancy (STC) applied for and received grant
funding to implement a program that increased sea turtle hatchling survivorship on Florida’s high-density
nesting beaches by correcting problematic lights on private properties with histories of causing sea turtle
disorientations. Working with state and local agencies and local turtle monitoring groups, STC identified
numerous properties with problematic lights. STC staff, skilled in sea turtle lighting criteria, designed costeffective lighting plans tailored to each site, which met the safety needs of property owners while ensuring
sea turtle lighting compliance. The latest technologies in “sea turtle friendly” lighting were used to
effectively reduce and manage exterior lighting at over 60 multi-family properties and businesses, which
effectively darkened approximately 7 miles of prime sea turtle nesting habitat. Monitoring of nesting at
project sites following lighting retrofits showed significant decreases in sea turtle disorientations, resulting
in the safe emergence of thousands of hatchlings each year that otherwise would have been disoriented by
lights. Furthermore, STC has documented significant energy cost savings for property owners that
converted to using turtle-friendly LED lighting. This project has proven that turtle-friendly lighting can
effectively reduce hatchling disorientations and save thousands of newborn sea turtles each year. These
results, combined with the financial benefits associated with using energy-efficient LEDs, make this project
replicable in other coastal communities where poorly managed artificial lighting degrades nesting habitat.
EVALUATION OF SEX RATIOS OF THE OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS
OLIVACEA) AT AN ARRIBADA NESTING BEACH IN MEXICO: SECOND YEAR FOLLOW-UP
Itzel Sifuentes-Romero1, Annelisse Bárcenas-Ibarra1, Rosina Varela-Valenzuela2, Martha HarfushMeléndez3, and Alejandra García-Gasca1
1
Centro de Investigación en Alimentación y Desarrollo. Mazatlán, Sinaloa, México
Facultad de Ciencias del Mar, Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa. Mazatlán, Sinaloa, México
3
Centro Mexicano de la Tortuga. Mazunte Santa María Tonameca, Oaxaca, Mexico
2
The olive ridley sea turtle (L. olivacea) is the most abundant sea turtle species nesting in Mexico. Although
most populations are in recovery, in Mexico the species is still classified as endangered. Despite having a
protection status, L. olivacea is still potentially exposed to environmental stressors such as climate change.
The olive ridley, like all sea turtles, displays temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), which makes
them particularly sensitive to environmental changes. Taking into account the increase in global
temperature reported during the last decades and the predicted rapid climate change in the next century,
there is an increasing concern about the possible impact of global warming in species with TSD in which
climate change may result in a strong sex ratio bias that could affect population dynamics. However and
despite this concern, there is little empirical evidence of direct temperature effects on sea turtle sex ratios in
nesting beaches in Mexico. La Escobilla is an arribada nesting beach located in the Pacific Coast of Mexico
with more than 200,000 nests per year. In an attempt to assess the impact of climate change in sex ratios,
we have been conducting a study on this nesting beach since 2010, being this our second report. Samples
were obtained from overlapping arribadas during two hatching seasons from 2010 to 2012: summer-fall
201
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
(September-November) and winter (January-March), and processed by histology with hematoxylin-eosin
staining for sex identification. Main sexing criteria were based on the thickness of the surface epithelium
(cortex in females) and development (in males) or fragmentation (in females) of medullar cords. We
estimated sand temperatures from air temperature records from the closest beach of Puerto Ángel located
25 km (15.5 miles) from La Escobilla for every sample period. No bias sex ratio (significantly different
from 50%) was observed during the 2010-2011 season (which presented a Niña event), whereas sex ratios
were female-biased (75% females) during the 2011-2012 season. This trend was observed in all sampled
months except February 2012, in which sex ratios were 29% males. Consistent with sex ratios data, sand
temperature estimations showed an increment of 0.69°C from summer-fall 2010-2011 to summer-fall 20112012, and 0.91°C from winter 2011 to winter 2012. The temperature increment for the whole nesting
season was 0.8°C. This is a second year study, samples for the 2012-2013 nesting season are underway, and
we plan to continue to sample over several years to collect sufficient data to estimate the real impact of
climatic events. So far our results show how subtle temperature changes affect sex ratios in this species,
highlighting the vulnerability of sea turtle populations to the contemporary climate change. I would like to
thank the International Sea Turtle Symposium for the travel Grant awarded and all the sponsors who made
it possible: International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries
Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack,
Telonics and CLS America.
OLIVE RIDLEY SEA TURTLE (LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) EMBRYO DEVELOPMENT AS A
FUNCTION OF BEACH ZONES AND AN ASSESSMENT OF A METHODOLOGY TO
DETERMINE EMBRYO DEVELOPMENT
Sarah R. Steele1, Ariana O. McCarthy2, and Roldán A. Valverde3
1
Department of Biology, Brandeis University, Waltham, Massachusetts, USA
Escuela de Biologia Marina, Universidad Nacional de Costa Rica, Heredia, Costa Rica
3
Department of Biological Sciences, Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, Louisiana, USA
2
Ostional beach in northwestern Costa Rica is an arribada rookery that exhibits mass nesting events
(arribadas) of up to 500,000 nesting females over a period of one week. Despite the large population, there
is concern that the population may not be able to sustain itself due to the low hatching success of ~8%.
Although beach zone (distance from the high tide to vegetation line) as well as the proximity of the nest to
an estuary are hypothesized to affect hatching success rates, these possible effects have not yet been
quantified. The purpose of this study was to compare embryo development across different areas of the
beach and to assess the accuracy of current methods which determine embryo development. We analyzed
embryo development in clutches laid during the June 2012 arribada. All clutches were exhumed after 55
days from oviposition. Clutches were selected for analysis using quadrat sampling within the section of the
beach with the highest concentration of nesting females during the arribada. Ninety 1x1 meter quadrats
were randomly placed within four distinct areas of the beach: the high zone of the beach near an estuary,
the high zone near the vegetation and away from the estuary, the middle zone near the estuary, and the
middle zone away from the estuary. Each quadrat was dug out to a depth of 50cm and the nests laid during
the arribada located within the selected quadrats were counted. Eggs laid during the arribada were counted
and weighed on a digital scale. Unhatched eggs and embryos were weighed. When possible, embryo
development was categorized into four stages: 0= no apparent development; I= embryo occupies 1-25%
egg; II= embryo occupies 26-50% egg; III= embryo occupies 51-75% egg; IV= embryo occupies 76-100%
egg. We analyzed four clutches of eggs, which contained a total of 324 eggs. Forty nine percent of all eggs
exhibited no discernible embryo development. Twenty one percent had a mean embryo mass 0.53g (±0.36),
13% had a mean mass 2.45g (±0.97), and 0.62% had a mean mass of 5.12g (±0.87). Excluded from this
data are 56 eggs that were too degraded to determine embryo development. In the clutches deposited in
close proximity to the estuary, the maximum embryo development was Stage III, whereas the clutches
deposited further from the estuary reached only Stage II development. In clutches deposited away from the
202
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
estuary, those located in the high zone near the vegetation only reached Stage I, while those located in the
middle zone reached Stage II. These preliminary data suggest that studying differential hatchling success
rates among different beach zones is an area that deserves further investigation. Our results also show that
embryos categorized into earlier development stages weigh less than those in later development stages.
Thus, categorizing embryos into development stages could be a useful tool in determining hatchling
success rates and embryo development. However, the high standard deviations in the embryo weights
within the defined development stages indicate that the methodology may need improvement.
BEACH AND NEST TEMPERATURES, AND ESTIMATES OF LEATHERBACK HATCHLING
SEX RATIOS AT BIRD’S HEAD PENINSULA, PAPUA, INDONESIA
Ricardo F. Tapilatu1, Thane Wibbels2, and Manjula Tiwari3
1
Marine Laboratory and Department, The State University of Papua (UNIPA) Manokwari (98314), Papua
Barat Province, Indonesia
2
Department of Biology – University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB), AL, USA
3
Protected Resources Division, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service,
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, La Jolla CA, USA
Sex determination and hatching success in sea turtles is temperature dependent. Warmer sand temperatures
may skew sea turtle population sex ratios towards predominantly females and high sand temperatures may
also decrease hatching success. Therefore, understanding beach and nest temperatures is important for
conservation programs, including the evaluation of the long-term impact of temperature changes. We
recorded sand temperatures during the boreal and austral summer nesting seasons for eight years (2005 to
2012) to estimate sex ratios and evaluate hatching success at the two primary nesting beaches for the
western Pacific leatherback (both located on Bird’s Head Peninsula, Papua, Indonesia). We also measured
rainfall, sand albedo, and sand particle size at both beaches during the main nesting months in 2009-2010.
During the boreal summers (2005-2012), the daily average sand temperatures at nest depth (80cm) ranged
from 26.4 to 34.9oC. During the austral summers, sand temperatures ranged from 27.2 to 33.0oC. Typically,
the average monthly temperatures at nest depth were relatively warm suggesting the production of femalebiased sex ratios. Furthermore, average monthly temperatures were very high during certain months,
potentially lowering hatching success. Location, sand color, and vegetation affected sand temperature
throughout the boreal and austral summer nesting seasons; the lower-open beach sections with dark grey
sand were significantly warmer (0.5-3oC) than the white sandy beach and the upper beach section adjacent
to the vegetation. Rainfall occurs throughout the year at Bird’s Head and had a significant episodic effect
resulting in decreasing sand and nest temperatures. The size distribution of sand particles was similar
among beaches with predominantly small particle size (500um or less). Thermal absorbance varied
between beaches, with the highest absorbance occurring on beaches with darker sand (Wembrak of
Jamursba Medi and Wermon). Nest temperatures were positively correlated with beach temperatures and
increased up to 2.9oC above sand temperatures during the later part of incubation due to metabolic heating.
Histological examination of dead hatchlings from the boreal and austral summer nesting seasons in 20092010 produced a female-biased sex ratio. This finding is consistent with the relatively warm thermal
profiles of the majority of the nesting beaches. This also included some extremely warm sand temperatures
that were associated with lower hatching success. However, certain areas of the nesting beaches (the white
sandy areas and also some vegetated areas in the upper zones of the dark grey beach) were relatively cool,
resulting in high hatching success potentially producing both male and female hatchlings. Information from
this study provides a foundation for developing conservation strategies for enhancing hatchling production
with optimal sex ratios at the most important nesting beaches for the western Pacific leatherbacks. Further,
this information represents the initiation of a long-term database that can be used at a local level to develop
strategies that could potentially offset the impact of long-term climate change on the Pacific leatherback
turtle.
203
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
REPRODUCTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF GREEN TURTLES, CHELONIA MYDAS, IN
TORTUGUERO, COSTA RICA
Luis Valero-Barrios1, Emma Harrison2, Nínive Espinoza1, and Héctor Barrios-Garrido1
1
2
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela (GTTM-GV), Venezuela
Sea Turtle Conservancy (STC), Tortuguero, Costa Rica
Tortuguero, located on the northern Caribbean coast of Costa Rica, has the largest nesting population of
green turtles (Chelonia mydas) in the Western Hemisphere. The Sea Turtle Conservancy (STC) is
responsible for conducting an on-going long-term sea turtle monitoring and conservation program at the
site. This research provides scientific information needed to characterize reproductive aspects of the green
turtle. The goals of this study were to evaluate various characteristics of green turtle reproductive biology,
specifically to determine if female size is correlated to either clutch size or hatching success. The data was
collected during the STC’s annual Green Turtle Program between June-October of 2010–2012. During the
nesting seasons of 2010, 2011 and 2012, 125, 93 and ~70 nests were marked, respectively, with a total of
~288 nests for three seasons. This study showed that 66.4% and 68.3% (2010 & 2011, respectively) of sea
turtles whose nests were marked were newly tagged females, the remaining were previously tagged
individuals. The majority of nests were located in the ‘border’ zone (areas with partial shading), reflecting
the nest site selection preference of green turtles. The average clutch size in 2010 was 110.8 eggs (33-167),
and 116.7 eggs (65-173) in 2011. The 2012 nesting season is still in progress and data are not available yet.
We will present the results from 2010–2012, including female size, hatching success and any significant
differences detected between years.
ON-GOING RECOVERY OF THE HAWKSBILL TURTLE POPULATION BREEDING AT
MONA ISLAND, PUERTO RICO
Robert P. van Dam1, Carlos E. Diez2, Karla G. Barrientos Muñoz3, and Cristian Ramirez Gallego3
1
Chelonia Inc, PO Box 9020708, San Juan, PR 00902-0708
Programa de Especies Protegidas, Departamento de Recursos Naturales, PO Box 366147, San Juan, PR
00936
3
Universidad de Puerto Rico, Departamento de Biologia, PO Box 23360, San Juan, PR 00931
2
Surveys of the nesting beaches at Mona Island, Puerto Rico, show a continued expansion of the hawksbill
population breeding on the island, the largest nesting colony under U.S. jusrisdiction. For 2012, ongoing
beach patrols indicate that a record numbers of hawksbill nests will be deposited by the close of the
monitoring period in early December. Data on total surveyed nest numbers, false crawl activity, nest loss
due to beach erosion, nest density, hatching success and other nest parameters are also presented.
Population recovery trends spanning three decades are presented and placed in the context of local and
international conservation efforts. Mona Island is an uninhabited island managed as a Natural Reserve by
the Puerto Rico Department of Natural and Environmental Resources. Located in the Mona Passage
midway between the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico, this limestone island has approximately 7.2 km
of sandy beaches located along its southern coast. In 2012, daytime beach surveys were conducted on the
island from mid July until early December. As a subset of the beach monitoring, a nesting activity index
was established in 2003, which consists of daily morning surveys of turtle nesting activity on a subset of
beaches along the southwest coast during the months of September and October.
204
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ACOUSTIC COMMUNICATION DURING LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA ARRIBADA
Richard C. Vogt1, Camila R. Ferrara2, Martha Harfush3, Renata Sousa-Lima4, and Ernesto
Albavera3
1
INPA, Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil
AIHA, Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil
3
Centro de Tortuga, Mazunte, Oaxaca, Mexico
4
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil
2
Social behavior has been described for a wide range of animals and can be attributed to a series of
mechanisms which act as a defense from predators to the dilution effect of numbers. There are few
descriptions of social behavior in turtles; gregarious nesting behavior has been noted in a few species such
as Chelonia mydas, Lepidochelys olivacea, Lepidochelys kempi, Podocnemis expansa and Carettochelys
insculpta. However the mechanism that these animals utilize to maintain these groups and to stimulate
simultaneous group behavior during nesting is unknown. There are a number of hypotheses that attempt to
describe the behavior of Lepidochelys olivacea during arribadas, such as moon phase, meteorological
factors, water temperature and olfaction. With the recent discovery that freshwater turtles, in particular
Podocnemis expansa and Chelodina oblonga are vocally communicating both on land and underwater, we
attempted to document the vocalizations of Lepidochelys olivacea emitted during nesting. The study was
conducted at Escobilla Beach, Oaxaca, México, during an arribada of about 600 turtles. We were able to
record one female Lepidochelys olivacea as she covered her nest and returned to the sea. From the
recording we identified 56 sounds, which, based on their aural and spectral characteristics, we classified
into four sound types. The mean peak frequency of the sounds recorded was 6180.42 Hz (281.2- 10593.8).
Even though the data from this study are preliminary, we believe that the use of sound during the nesting
period is highly appropriate for turtles since these animals live in vast places with low visibility and the
propagation of underwater sound is an excellent media for long distance communication. Now that we have
verified that these marine turtles are vocalizing, we hope that this will stimulate more people to learn more
about this behavior and document whether vocalizations underwater are used to stimulate arribada
formation and emergence onto nesting beaches.
GREEN TURTLES NESTING ON ARUBA 2001-2012
Edith van der Wal, Sietske van der Wal, and Richard van der Wal
Turtugaruba Foundation, Aruba
Nesting of Chelonia mydas was thought to be extremely rare or non-existent in Aruba for many years.
However, green turtle nesting activity has been spotted and confirmed since 2001. A monitoring program
was initiated which consists of early morning patrols, in situ nest protection and post-emergence excavation.
Over 10 years of data from this monitoring project are presented. Twenty different beaches were visited at
least once by a green turtle over the last 12 years. One beach, “Dos Playa Grandi”, contributed 61 out of a
total of 340 green turtle emergences. The average number of Chelonia mydas nests on Aruba over the last 5
years (2008-2012) is 35.2 nests/yr (19-45), with an average of 79.5% hatching success. The nesting habitat
of Chelonia mydas is vulnerable to three major threats: remote artificial lights, off road driving and beach
pollution, and obstruction by marine debris. Although Turtugaruba is unable to resolve all of these threats
at their source, they can be mitigated and nests can be protected one nest at a time. Acknowledgements:
205
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
The authors thank the Turtugaruba volunteers for help with the monitoring and nest protection during the
survey period. Participation at this symposium is co-funded by a travel grant from the generous ISTS
sponsors.
GREEN TURTLE NESTING ACTIVITY AT JUANI ISLAND, TANZANIA, DURING THE 2012
PEAK NESTING SEASON
Lindsey West, Boniventure Mchomvu, and Omari Abdallah
Sea Sense, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
Juani Island is a small island (9 km long and 3.5 km wide) located in the south eastern corner of Mafia
Island Marine Park off the coast of Tanzania. There are eight sea turtle nesting beaches on the eastern side
of Juani Island that support the largest green turtle (Chelonia mydas) rookery in Tanzania. In 2012, the first
saturation flipper tagging programme was undertaken during the peak nesting months of April and May.
Foot patrols were conducted every night between 19:00 and 06:00 hours on four beaches where most
nesting is concentrated. Each female turtle encountered was measured (curved carapace length and width)
and examined for the presence of existing tags. If not already tagged, individually numbered titanium tags
(TZ series) were applied. Sixty nesting attempts were recorded, 50 (83%) of which were successful.
Eighteen individual females nested during the survey period. Females were encountered during 46 (92%) of
the nesting events. Six females that did not nest successfully were also encountered. Curved carapace
lenghts ranged from 101–118cm with a mean of 107.2 SD± 4.7 cm (n = 18). Curved carapace widths
ranged from 90–113cm with a mean of 99.7 SD± 4.8 cm. Three of the females had been tagged in previous
years. One was first tagged in 2006 and was observed again in 2009 then again during this survey. The
second female was tagged in 2006 and the third was tagged in 2009. Half of the nesting females
encountered (n = 9) nested at least three times during the survey period; two females nested at least five
times. Inter-nesting intervals ranged from 9 to 20 days (n = 31) with a mean of 13.2 SD± 2.3 days. The
observed clutch frequency (OCF) value was 2.5 SD± 1.2 (calculated for each turtle encountered nesting at
least once within the survey period). Of the nine individuals nesting at least three times, five used the same
beach for each clutch. Three females used two different beaches and one individual used three different
beaches. The mean clutch size was 134 SD± 14 eggs. Hatching success was 71%. Prior to the saturation
flipper tagging programme in 2012, estimates of the number of green turtles nesting in Juani Island had
been calculated using track counts from daily patrols and breeding frequencies quoted in published
literature. While track counts are a very useful method of estimating nesting population size, detailed
observation of nesting behaviour was essential to begin to build a more accurate and nuanced picture. The
survey not only provided accurate information on nest numbers and the number of individual females, but
also the first data on clutch frequencies and inter-nesting intervals for any turtle population nesting in
Tanzania. Funding for a repeat saturation tagging programme in 2013 has already been secured. Efforts will
be made to secure additional funding for future years to build understanding of remigration intervals, which
can provide crucial information on recruitment, longevity and survivorship within the population.
206
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) NESTING ON AKYATAN BEACH: RESULTS OF SIX
YEARS SURVEY
C. Yılmaz1, A. Oruç1, and O. Türkozan2
1
Doğal Hayatı Koruma Vakfı (WWF-Türkiye), Büyük Postane Cad. No:19, Kat 5, Bahçekapı,
Eminönü,İstanbul
2
Adnan Menderes Üniversites, i Fen Edebiyat Fakültes, i Biyoloji Bölümü, Aydın
Akyatan beach, Turkey is the most important green turtle nesting site in the Mediterranean. The beach is 22
km in length and monitored everyday on foot between 1 June to 15 September between 2006-2011. During
these periods, nest and non-nesting emergences were determined and nests were excavated after the
hatchling emergence was complete. The contents of each nest were recorded. The hatching success, the
number of hatchlings reaching the sea and the incubation duration for each nest were calculated. We
recorded a total of 5879 emergences with 2171 (37%) resulting in C. mydas nests during 6 consecutive
years with a mean of 362 nests per year. The mean nesting density was 16 nests km-1. Of the overall C.
mydas nests on Akyatan beach, 1348 (62%) were excavated and 151976 eggs were counted. Of these eggs
116309 (76.5%) hatchlings had come out and 88673 (76%) of them were able to reach the sea. There were
strong annual fluctuations in the number of nests ranging from 170 (in 2007) to 562 (in 2006). Six years of
nest numbers showed a slightly decreasing but statistically insignificant trend (r = -0.34, p>0.05).
Acknowledgments: This study was carried out with a cooperative protocol between WWF-Turkey and the
Ministry of Waters and Forestry. The authors would like to thank the volunteers.
HATCHING AND EMERGENCE SUCCESS OF GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) IN THE
GALAPAGOS ISLANDS*
Patricia M. Zárate1,2, Karen A. Bjorndal1, Macarena Parra2, Peter H. Dutton3, Jeffrey A. Seminoff3,
and Alan B. Bolten1
1
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research and Department of Biology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
FL, USA
2
Marine Research Program, Charles Darwin Foundation, Santa Cruz Island, Galapagos Islands, Ecuador
3
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, CA, USA
In sea turtles, the interaction of numerous abiotic and biotic factors experienced by eggs during incubation
affects embryonic survival. In this study, we determine hatching and emergence success of green turtle
nests and evaluate the effects of site, year, day of oviposition, carapace length and width of female, nest
position and nest habitat, chamber depth and depredation. We compare the relative success of key nesting
beaches on the Galapagos Islands, one of the most important rookeries for the green turtle Chelonia mydas
in the Eastern Pacific Ocean. To evaluate the extent to which parameters affected hatching and emergence
success, a binomial generalized additive model (GAM) with fixed effects was used. We found variation in
hatching and emergence success to be significant among years and beaches, with the day of oviposition and
with nest habitat. Mean hatching and emergence success (S.D.) for the 1039 nests examined was
46.0%(33.4) and 45.6% (33.4), respectively. These values are relatively low compared to other green turtle
populations. Nest predation by feral pigs and beetles and nest destruction by turtle digging were the most
important causes of embryo mortality. Results from our study will be useful for managers in the Galapagos
National Park Service when formulating management strategies to protect green turtle critical habitats.
207
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Other
ARCHELON VOLUNTEERS: AN ARMY OF HOPE
Theodoros Benos-Palmer, Theoni Karkoulia, Aliki Panagopoulou, Anna Kremezi-Margaritoulis, and
Dimitris Margaritoulis
ARCHELON, the Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Solomou 57, GR-10432 Athens, Greece
ARCHELON, a nation-wide non-profit organisation working for the protection of sea turtles and their
habitats in Greece, conducts sea turtle projects since its foundation in 1983. Several nesting areas were
discovered in the course of ARCHELON projects, and the most important of these are now included in its
annual mandate. As years passed by and data were accumulated, the core areas of these sites were well
defined and today ARCHELON concentrates its work in seven high nesting-density areas, totaling 54 km.
Further, ARCHELON operates a Rescue Centre for rehabilitation of injured turtles and for environmental
education activities, as well as an in-water tagging project in Amvrakikos Gulf. Field work differs from
area to area depending on the threats that adult turtles, eggs and hatchlings face. The daily work runs from
end of May until the middle of October and in general it includes the location, protection and post-hatch
excavation of nests, tagging at night, and public awareness activities in the form of information kiosks and
slide shows in local hotels. In some areas, field work is very demanding, e.g., in Kyparissia Bay all nests
(average 709 in the last 6 years) should be fenced against predators, and the fences should be checked and
maintained everyday! Further, there are several data sheets to be filled and entered in databases. In total,
during a nesting season an average of 2,350 nests are protected and monitored until hatching, 345 nesting
turtles are tagged or checked for old tags, and about 170,000 hatchlings enter safely the sea. Volunteers of
diverse skills and backgrounds are welcome in ARCHELON projects; everybody can find his/her position
in a wholehearted team working for a common objective. ARCHELON provides to its volunteers very little
in material things: a campsite with basic facilities, including gas stoves, cooking utensils and makeshift
toilets and showers. The camp is set by the volunteers themselves, who under a well-built team spirit
organize their everyday life depending on the particularities of each project. On the other hand, volunteers
get the opportunity to work in nature, to materialize their environmental ideas and dreams, and to build up
the virtues of responsibility, of endurance, of persistence and of tolerance; all very important for their
future careers. Moreover, these multinational teams create a sensation to local communities. Local people
start to wonder what has brought these enthusiasts from far-away countries to this particular site and as a
result they soon begin to consider sea turtles an important local asset. Volunteers with their dedicated work
and selfless camaraderie help a lot to pass this notion to the local community. With their tangible example
they promote a more humane model of development which gradually influences local attitudes.
208
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
THE PROTECTOR – GHI - SIMS PARTNERSHIP: A MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH;
SAVING TURTLES, HELPING PEOPLE
S.G. Dunbar1, S.S. Dunbar2, C. Chapman3, S. Vodhanel4, S. Plafker5, C.A. Church6, V.L. Leggitt7, J.
Zumwalt8, E. Rosspencer5, L. Bayardo9, M. Friedman9, L. Huey9, R.L. Parker7, G. Delgado2, R.
Cruzado2, L. Salinas10, and N. Zelaya11
1
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research, Inc. (ProTECTOR), Colton, CA
92324 and Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
2
School of Nursing, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
3
Department of Marriage and Family Therapy, School of Behavioral Sciences, Loma Linda University,
Loma Linda, CA 92350
4
School of Pharmacy, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
5
Students for International Mission Services (SIMS), Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
6
Department of Otolaryngology, School of Medicine, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
7
School of Dentistry, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
8
Global Health Institute (GHI), Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
9
Department of Nutrition, School of Public Health, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA 92350
10
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research Honduras, Tegucigalpa,
Honduras
11
Presidente de Comite de Protecion de Tortuga Golfina, El Venado, Punta Condega, Honduras
A secondary goal of sea turtle conservation is the development of programs within communities which will
introduce economic and educational benefits as alternatives to the consumptive use of sea turtle species.
Such programs may introduce ecotourism and handicraft development as means of persistent economic
income for members within the community. While economic stimulation is an important factor in assisting
conservation efforts in developing nations, there is great need for other forms of direct community
assistance. The ProTECTOR – GHI – SIMS partnership is unique in the field of wildlife conservation in
that it approaches sea turtle conservation and community assistance from a multidisciplinary perspective.
The partnership takes into consideration the whole person, the environment, and the rich natural resources
of the local community and region in a manner that develops a stewardship framework. This approach rests
on the concept of holistic care, which is concerned with caring for the integrated health and welfare of both
the environment and the person. Supported by the Global Health Institute at Loma Linda University, the
first ProTECTOR – GHI – SIMS volunteer project took place from August 19 – 29, 2012 in the community
of El Venado, in the Golf of Fonseca, Honduras. The volunteer group accomplished medical, dental, and
nutrition education outreach, as well as health screening and treatment. Furthermore, the partnership has
provided funding and logistical support for the installation of a much-needed water catchment system to
facilitate running water for visitors to the turtle center. These first steps in meeting health, social, and
development needs of the community were accomplished with a unique, multidisciplinary approach, all
within the context of sea turtle research and conservation undertaken by ProTECTOR working together
with the community of El Venado.
209
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
GRASSROOTS VOLUNTEERING OFFERS GREATER OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE
CONSERVATION IMPACT FOR SEA TURTLES IN CHINA
Laura Gross and Frederick Yeh
Sea Turtles 911, Hainan, China
China is rarely the first country prospective volunteers consider during the quest for the ideal sea turtle
volunteer opportunity. However, their contribution to sea turtle conservation is perhaps amplified on
Hainan Island, where nesting populations are extinct and the illegal sea turtle trade is thriving. Volunteers
for the only sea turtle NGO operating in China get experiences unlike any others in the world, and assist in
many aspects of conservation, including rescue, rehabilitation, research, education, and ecotourism. In the
floating fishing village of Xincun, a central waypoint for sea turtles held illegally for the Chinese market,
sea turtle rehabilitation and research is based on the floating sea turtle hospital: a classic Chinese fishing
home and deck, with free-flowing ocean water netted enclosures, floating in Xincun Bay. Volunteers assist
in a unique rehabilitation setting where most green and hawksbill sea turtle patients were raised in captivity
from hatchlings by local poachers, neighbors to the sea turtle hospital. These circumstances result in
illnesses and injuries that generally differ from those seen at traditional sea turtle hospitals, whose main
patient core is composed of stranded or wild caught turtles. Volunteers also maintain good relations with
fishermen and poachers, working hard to encourage an environment of sea turtle respect and camaraderie
through education and community building. Upon release of rehabilitated patients, volunteers contribute to
sea turtle research by assisting in the application of metal flipper and PIT tags, only recently starting to be
used in the waters of southern China, and by collecting tissue samples for DNA testing. Volunteers also
lead children's educational programs at partner resorts, and are an integral part of extending conservation
knowledge to the tourists that visit Hainan, many of which would otherwise readily seek out sea turtle meat
and products. Volunteers are integral to any good conservation program, and those that choose to volunteer
on Hainan Island have become a vital life-force to the survival of sea turtles in China.
VOLUNTEER PROGRAMS OF THE GEORGIA SEA TURTLE CENTER
Jeannie Miller Martin and Caitlin Sampson
Georgia Sea Turtle Center, Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA
The Georgia Sea Turtle Center (GSTC) is a hospital for ill and injured sea turtles located on Jekyll Island,
Georgia. It is the only sea turtle facility in the state of Georgia. The facility is open to the general public
with an interactive Exhibit Gallery and Rehabilitation Pavilion with viewable turtle patients. The center
also focuses on environmental education and research in the fields of ecology and wildlife health.
Volunteers help in every aspect of our conservation organization including our Education, Gift Shop,
Husbandry and Research departments. Education volunteers devote their time to interpretation within our
gallery, pavilion, assist with groups and attend outreach events. Education volunteers also play a large role
in night time Turtle Walks and Nest Walks. Gift Shop volunteers dedicate their time to answering phone
calls and questions, providing customer service and organizing merchandise. Volunteers working in our
Husbandry department assist with food preparation, water changes, patient treatments and all aspects of the
daily maintenance of our rehabilitation pavilion. The GSTC collaborates with the St. Kitts Sea Turtle
Monitoring Network by allowing volunteers to travel to St. Kitts during leatherback nesting season and
help with their monitoring and tagging program. GSTC Volunteer Gary Buckles won the International Sea
Turtle Society’s Ed Drane Award in 2011 for his dedication to the research and rehabilitation departments
210
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
of the GSTC as well as his participation in international opportunities. Gary Buckles has spent two or more
months in St. Kitts collaborating with their program for the last five years on behalf of the GSTC, while
spending the rest of the year volunteering with the center in Georgia. Our citizen science volunteer
endeavors include our Marine Debris Initiative and our endangered shorebird nesting patrol. Research
volunteers help monitor human impacts and lighting on Jekyll Island’s nesting beaches. These volunteers
patrol the beach by foot during the nesting season, monitoring lighting from buildings while educating the
public and handing out red cellophane to cover flashlights that may disturb nesting females. As the nesting
season comes to an end, human impact Volunteers transition into a nest monitoring role so as to prevent sea
turtle hatchlings from becoming misoriented or disoriented due to lighting and to mitigate their interactions
with public beachgoers. Research volunteers also have opportunities to advance towards working with our
sea turtle nesting patrol after dedicating a season to our Human Impacts Team. The GSTC has over 100
active volunteers that have dedicated over 28,000 hours in the five years the center has been open.
DISMANTLING OLD WALLS AND BUILDING NEW BRIDGES: SEA TURTLE ADVOCACY IN
THE COMMONWEALTH OF THE NORTHERN MARIANA ISLANDS, WESTERN PACIFIC
Tammy Mae Summers1, Jessy Hapdei2, Joseph Ruak2, Eileen Escudero3, Dimitri Varmazis3, and
Arielle Buyum3
1
Rainbow Connection Research, P.O. Box 10001, PMB 370, Saipan, MP, 96950, CNMI, USA
Department of Lands and Natural Resources, Division of Fish and Wildlife, Caller Box 10007, Lower
Base Road, Saipan, MP, 96950, CNMI, USA
3
Turtle Advocate and Guardian Society, PO Box 506500, Saipan, MP 96950
2
In these challenging economic times, government agencies are encouraged to pursue creative means by
which to get the job done with limited funds and staff. One of the means that has allowed many sea turtle
programs to survive and thrive throughout the years has been through the assistance of volunteer
organizations. Volunteerism is old concept in many regions; however, in the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI) it is one which has only recently been adopted. In 2009, the CNMI
Department of Lands and Natural Resources (DLNR) Division of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) Sea Turtle
Program (STP) experienced the resignation of two full-time staff members and needed to find a way to
fulfill project goals and objectives with half the staff. Although sea turtles are protected by federal and local
laws in the CNMI, illegal hunting still occurs at unknown levels. In the past, the poaching problem fueled
the hesitation for volunteers to be utilized by the DLNR-DFW STP; staff perceptions were such that to
protect turtle’s lives there must be absolute confidentiality in disclosing nearshore survey and beach nesting
locations. This trepidation also hindered other outreach efforts such as providing sea turtle data in local
media or mentioning research locations in classroom presentations. As a result, little to no information was
shared resulting in feelings of disconnection, lack of ownership, and misconceptions between the
community and their sea turtle natural resources. Our goal was two-fold, to engage the community in
volunteer activities which would allow DLNR-DFW STP to continue their research by filling staffing gaps
and more importantly, to open up the lines of communication to allow community connections with and
informed conversations about their sea turtle population. We solicited volunteer assistance from several
venues including non-profit organizations, college and high school groups, local dive guides, the general
public, and sometimes even family members. Opportunistic volunteer solicitations occur during classroom
presentations, community workshops, conversations with fellow scientists, or beach patrols. While a more
permanent volunteer pool was founded in 2010 by the Turtle Advocate and Guardian Society (TAGS), a
non-profit organization whose mission is to help protect endangered sea turtles and their nesting sites as
well as help educate the public about the current state of sea turtle populations in the CNMI. Since the
inception of TAGS, the DLNR-DFW STP staff has worked closely with the non-profit to coordinate efforts
in projects such as beach clean-ups, volunteer training workshops, and camera monitoring of nests. TAGS
has also provided DLNR-DFW STP permitted staff volunteer assistance during nearshore surveys, morning
nesting beach surveys, night tagging surveys, and nest inventories. Thanks, in part, to the DLNR-DFW
211
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
STP’s many volunteers we have been able to not only continue but enhance our research, monitoring, and
education outreach efforts within the CNMI community.
900 HOURS ON NESTING BEACHES: PROTECTOR VOLUNTEER EFFORTS IN HONDURAS
Amy L. Tan1, S. Dunbar2,3, D. Baumbach3, A. Cunningham4, L. E. Damazo3, R. E. Reeve1, K.
Lindsay5, and L. Salinas2,6
1
Department of Biology, Walla Walla University, College Place, WA, USA
Protective Turtle Ecology Center for Training, Outreach, and Research, Inc. (ProTECTOR), Colton, CA,
USA
3
Marine Research Group, Department of Earth and Biological Sciences, Loma Linda University, Loma
Linda, CA USA
4
Department of Biology, Andrews University, Berrien Springs, MI, USA
5
Ontario Air Service, Inc., Rochester, NY, USA
6
ProTECTOR, Honduras, Tegucigalpa, Honduras
2
The work of volunteers in sea turtle conservation is indispensable, whether their contribution is over the
short or long term. Participants working with ProTECTOR aid in a variety of research projects throughout
the country of Honduras. During July - November 2012, five individuals donated their time to assisting
graduate students and professors through the ProTECTOR Volunteer Program. Three of these worked in
Honduras for only a few weeks, while two served as interns for up to five months. Although some
volunteers were undergraduates or recent graduates in biology, others were individuals with professional
careers in areas outside the realm of science. Volunteers worked at the Cuero y Salado Wildlife Refuge, on
the Bay Island of Utila, and in the communities of Punta Ratón and El Venado, on the Pacific coast of
Honduras. In all, volunteers assisted in patrolling beaches for nesting females, tagging adult turtles,
monitoring nests, and collecting hatchling data. A related project involved profiling the terrain, slope,
vegetation, and pollution cover of nesting beaches in Cuero y Salado and Utila. Altogether, volunteers
spent over 180 man-hours working in Cuero y Salado, over 500 hours in Utila, over 150 hours at Punta
Ratón, and over 40 hours in El Venado for a total effort of over 900 hours. While working alongside
professionals in the field of biology, individuals gained hands-on experience in the roles and duties of sea
turtle biologists. ProTECTOR Volunteers provide assistance to each researcher that might otherwise be
unavailable at a study site in Honduras. Furthermore, citizen scientists like these continue to help educate
people in both the United States and Honduras about the importance of sea turtles, as well as the
conservation and research efforts of ProTECTOR, through both word of mouth and social media platforms.
COMMUNITY-BASED SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN NORTH QUEENSLAND
Julie Traweek
Sea Turtle Foundation, PO Box 1190, Townsville, Queensland, 4810, Australia
North Queensland, has six of the world's seven sea turtle species, with greens, flatbacks, and hawksbills
being most abundant. North Queensland also has one of the fastest-growing populations in Australia and
one of the highest rates of coastal development. Sea turtles are being affected by water quality,
development of nesting beaches, predation by introduced feral pest species, and extreme weather events
like cyclones. In 2011, over 1800 green turtles were reported dead or stranded on Queensland coasts. Sea
212
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Turtle Foundation works in partnership with multiple community groups, government agencies, university
researchers, and individual volunteers to mitigate the effects of these issues on sea turtle populations. Our
volunteers are part of a Sea Turtle Stranding Response Team, which assists state park rangers in responding
to stranding calls when we have high stranding rates. We work collaboratively with conservation groups
such as the Magnetic Island Network for Turtles, James Cook University, Cairns Turtle Rehabilitation
Centre, and Reef HQ's Turtle Hospital to rehabilitate turtles. In Bowen, Queensland, where there is a high
rate of fibropapilloma in the green turtle population, groups including STF, James Cook University,
Gudjuda and Girringun Traditional Owners, Queens Beach Action Group, and WWF are working together
to monitor turtle health and gather data to research the disease. Our volunteers also conduct beach cleanups and send our marine debris data to Tangaroa Blue, who keep a national marine debris database and
work to find solutions with manufacturers and retailers before their products end up in the ocean. In
addition, STF works with Reef Guardian schools to educate students about sea turtles and train them to
know what to do with a stranded turtle. Thanks to the efforts of all these groups working together, we have
seen an increase in the general public's knowledge about sea turtles and the threats facing them. A
particular challenge for north Queensland is that we do have so much remote beach that is difficult to patrol
without expensive flyovers; these collaborations between community groups and efforts from our
volunteers are making a real difference in spreading the word about sea turtles and what we can all do to
protect them.
Population Biology and Monitoring
ASSESSMENT OF SEX RATIO AND REPRODUCTIVE STATUS OF A FORAGING GREEN
TURTLE POPULATION IN SAN DIEGO BAY, CALIFORNIA
Camryn D. Allen1, Michelle N. Robbins1, Jeffrey A. Seminoff1, Dave W. Owens2, Nick M. Kellar1,
and Peter H. Dutton1
1
2
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA, La Jolla, CA, USA
College of Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina, USA
There has been increased interest in demographic modeling of marine turtle populations to provide context
about conservation priorities. Though, such studies are commonly limited by lack of information on key
demographic parameters of most populations. Few research projects have examined the population sex
ratio or reproductive status of adult turtles at foraging grounds, particularly males, as the majority of studies
examining turtle reproduction occur at the nesting beach where females are easy to access. The green sea
turtle (Chelonia mydas) nesting populations in Pacific Mexico are considered Endangered under the U.S.
Endangered Species Act and IUCN Red List. The San Diego Bay (SDB) is home to a foraging population
of adult and juvenile green turtles that are believed to be primarily of Mexican stock origin. However,
population sex ratio and reproductive state of adult turtles have not been examined and this information
could be influential for the management of this local foraging aggregation in a broad regional context. In
the early 90s, Dutton and colleagues used a previously published technique to determine the sex ratio of the
SDB green turtle population through quantifying the testosterone concentration in blood serum and used
adults of known sex (identified through physical characteristics, i.e. tail length) as the controls. A 6:10 male
to female sex ratio was found for the 1990-1993 field seasons. Following up on this research, we utilized a
commercially available enzyme immunoassay to quantify the population sex ratio through analysis of
testosterone concentration of archived serum samples obtained during field seasons since 1993, many of
which have physical confirmations of sex in more recent capture years. In addition, we compared the sex
ratio of the SDB green turtles to those known for other foraging populations in the Pacific. We also
213
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
incorporated information on adult reproductive status through ultrasound of gonads and body fat (body
condition), female cloacal cytology, male plastron softness, and confirmation of spermatozoa presence in
urine (from opportunistic collection). The reproductive assessments provide a more holistic approach to
assessing reproductive ecology of the SDB green turtle foraging aggregation and establishes a convenient
tool for the rapid assessment of sex ratios.
AN EFFECTIVE AND SAFE TECHNIQUE TO PIT TAG HATCHLING GREEN TURTLES
CAPTIVE BRED AT SEA LIFE PARK HAWAII
George H. Balazs1, Robert Morris2, and Jeffrey Pawloski3
1
NOAA Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA
Makai Animal Clinic, Kailua, Hawaii, USA
3
Sea Life Park Hawaii, Waimanalo, Hawaii, USA
2
An effective, safe, and humane technique has been developed, evaluated, approved, and utilized to
microchip hatchling green turtles born and released into the wild by Sea Life Park Hawaii. Since 1976, Sea
Life Park has released over 13,000 hatchling Hawaiian-stock green turtles as a conservation and research
effort secondary to the Park's principal objective of educational outreach focused on their captive breeding
display lagoon and nesting beach. From 2010-2012, 866 hatchlings born at Sea Life Park have been PIT
tagged with the Destron Sterilized TX1460L 11 x 2 mm microchip, using the one-time use applicator
system. Fifteen hatchlings each year have been retained for captive rearing comparative evaluation of
health, growth rates, tag retention, and any movement of the microchip as shown through x-ray imaging.
Turtles have been reared up to 40 cm for 2.5 years with no negative effects. PIT tags are inserted into soft
proximal tissue of the dorsal left hind flipper after injecting 1% Lidocaine HCL USP pain block. The
puncture at the tag injection site is sealed using a drop of Vetbond 3M Tissue Adhesive. The hind flipper
PIT tagging of juvenile through adult wild-captured green turtles in the Hawaiian Islands has been carried
out since 1995 with significant success and safety, extremely low tag loss, and no movement of the tag
within the flipper. Photographic illustrations with step-by-step descriptions of the hatchling PIT tagging
technique are presented in this poster.
GLOBAL PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF HAWKSBILL TURTLES, ERETMOCHELYS IMBRICATA
BASED ON MTDNA
Karla G. Barrientos Munoz and Cristian Ramirez Gallego
University of Puerto Rico, San Juan, Puerto Rico, USA
Of the seven species of sea turtles, the hawksbill is the one presented by the most anthropogenic pressures.
Many studies have determined the genetic structure of populations of Eretmochelys imbricata throughout
the world. However, to date, there has been no study analyzing the abundance of mitochondrial DNA
haplotypes of nesting populations worldwide, to estimate both their genetic interactions and their possible
dispersal patterns over time. This meta-analysis, used fragments of 891 bp of the mitochondrial control
region, for a total of 125 haplotypes represented in 22 publications, which were grouped into 2 regions by
origin. We constructed a tree using Bayesian analysis, which revealed multiple sources of regional
populations, for which we identified two independent clades: Atlantic and Indo-Pacific, with a divergence
time of ca. 4.3 MYA and showing that lifting Isthmus of Panama makes 3.6 MYA is one of the forces that
214
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
have been effective as a barrier to tropical species giving rise to allopatric speciation, and finally, that the
genetic structure of this species as for other marine organisms reflects different historical and contemporary
forces between complex ecological, demographic, genetic, ethological, oceanographic, climatic and
tectonic.
THRESHOLD TO MATURITY IN GREEN TURTLES: INTERACTIONS OF AGE, SIZE AND
GROWTH
Karen A. Bjorndal1, Joe Parsons2, Walter Mustin2, and Alan B. Bolten1
1
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research and Department of Biology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
FL, USA
2
Cayman Turtle Farm, Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands
Age at sexual maturity is a critical demographic parameter that is difficult to determine in long-lived
species with cryptic juvenile stages, such as sea turtles. We analyze data from a 34-year study of a captive
population of green turtles at Cayman Turtle Farm to evaluate relationships among age, length, and mass at
sexual maturity, and pre- and post-maturity growth rates. Although age at maturity is much younger in
captive populations compared to wild populations, evaluating thresholds to maturity in a captive population
of green turtles provided an opportunity to assess variation in age and size at maturity and growth rates
prior to and after maturity in a long-lived species. Maturity is not attained at a given size or age in green
turtles, nor is there the expected trade-off between size and age at maturity. There is considerable variation
in age, length and mass at maturity even when turtles are held under similar conditions. Although there is
no clear threshold for maturity, of the three parameters (age, body length and mass at maturity) length is
most similar to that of wild green turtle populations and thus apparently most closely approximates a
threshold to maturity. The best predictor for age at maturity is average pre-maturity linear growth rate, and
the best predictor for size at sexual maturity (both length and mass) is average pre-maturity mass growth
rate. At sexual maturity, resource allocation shifts almost completely away from somatic growth to
reproductive output in green turtles, regardless of level of nutrition or size at maturity. Incorporating
appropriate levels of variation for age and size at maturity will improve assessments of status of
populations and effectiveness of management programs.
PREDICTING THE IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING ON SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN
VIETNAM
Cuong The Chu and The Duc Nguyen
Institute of Marine Environment and Resources, Vietnam
One of the greatest threats to sea turtles populations in Vietnam is global warming, besides sea-level rise,
loss of nesting and foraging habitats, incidental capture and illegal trading of sea turtles and their products.
Since incubation temperature of clutches determine the sex ratios, performances of hatchlings and hatching
success rates, higher temperature in the future may produce weaker female hatchlings and more egg
failures. In order to understand these influences of temperature and predict the problem of sea turtle
populations in Vietnam, from 2010 to 2012 we use regression analyses to correlate air temperature, sand
temperature and incubation temperature at 8 remained nesting beaches in Vietnam. At the same time, we
studied the hatching success, quality of hatchlings and running performances of 40 clutches, which burred
215
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
in different time and locations. The results from 2010-2012 seasons show that the sex ratios of hatchling at
8 nesting beaches varying from 72.5% to 80%. However, the regression models suggest by 2050, all
nesting beaches of Vietnam will produce a skew towards females (85 to 100%); it is even worse by 2100,
when the sex ratios of hatchlings will be from 96 to 100% females and about 50% of clutches will be
exceed thermal mortality thresholds. The incubation temperature does not impact the quality and running
performances of hatchlings but it clearly impacts the hatching success, the number of un-hatched eggs in
hot clutches is much higher than that in cooler ones. Therefore, it is necessary to implement the
management strategies to reduce the impacts of global warming on sea turtle populations in Vietnam.
MICROSATELLITE ANALYSES SHOW RESTRICTED MALE-MEDIATED GENE FLOW
BETWEEN MEDITERRANEAN ROOKERIES FOR LOGGERHEAD TURTLES
Marcel Clusa1, Carlos Carreras1, Marta Pascual2, Andreas Demetropoulos3, Dimitris Margaritoulis4,
Alan F. Rees4, Abdulmaula A. Hamza5, Mona Khalil6, Monica Aureggi7, Yaniv Levy8, Ogüz
Türkozan9, Alex Aguilar1, and Luis Cardona1
1
Department of Animal Biology, Faculty of Biology, University of Barcelona, Av.Diagonal 645, E-08028
Barcelona, Spain
2
Department of Genetics, Faculty of Biology, University of Barcelona, Av.Diagonal 645, E-08028
Barcelona, Spain
3
Cyprus Wildlife Society, Emmanuel Xanthou 11, P.O. Box 24281, 1703 Nicosia, Cyprus
4
ARCHELON, The Sea Turtle Protection Society of Greece, Solómou 57, GR-10432 Athens, Greece
5
Marinelife Conservation Unit, Environment General Authority, Alfateh University Post, P.O. Box 13793,
Tripoli, Libya
6
MEDASSET, P.O. Box 19, Tyre, Lebanon
7
Naucrates, Via Corbetta 11, 22063 Cantù, CO, Italy
8
The Israel Sea Turtle Rescue Centre, Nature Parks Authority, Mevoot Yam, Mikhmoret 40297, Israel
9
Adnan Menderes University, Faculty of Science and Arts, Department of Biology, Aydin, Turkey
The population structure of loggerhead turtles (Caretta caretta) in the Mediterranean has been widely
studied through the use of genetic analyses. Mitochondrial DNA has been traditionally used to analyse the
genetic structure of populations but this is a maternally inherited marker. We have reanalysed the genetic
structure of Mediterranean loggerheads by amplifying an extended set of 19 microsatellite loci. Tissue
samples of 152 hatchlings from Cyprus, Greece (Crete and western Greece), Israel, Lebanon, Libya and
Turkey were genotyped. Overall, the number of alleles per microsatellite locus ranged from three to 14
with a total mean of 5.58 alleles per locus. Libya was the nesting area with the highest number of alleles
(6.688 ± 2.301). However, the allelic richness did not differ between nesting areas (Kruskal-Wallis, P =
0.423). Independence of loci can be assumed as no linkage disequilibrium was found between loci pairs
(Chi-square, P < 0.05). Three loci presented departure from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (Chi-square, P <
0.05) and thus, these were not included in further analyses to avoid bias. Significant pairwise genetic
differences were found in the majority of comparisons (Fst, FDR P < 0.014) except among Greek nesting
areas and among the easternmost part of the basin (Cyprus, Israel and Lebanon). Isolation by distance is a
likely explanation to the differences seen as indicated by the Mantel test relating geographic and genetic
distances (Mantel test, P = 0.027). Thus, an eastwards genetic gradient with populations partially connected
by male-mediated gene flow along the coastline might exist. A PCA plot revealed four regional units
genetically distinct: Greece, Libya, Turkey and eastern Mediterranean. According to these results, future
management plans should consider the importance of the specific genetic diversity in each rookery to
ensure the conservation of this species in the Mediterranean basin.
216
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PREDICTED SEX RATIO OF IMMATURE KEMP’S RIDLEYS INCIDENTALLY CAPTURED
AT MISSISSIPPI FISHING PIERS
Andrew Coleman1, Thane Wibbels2, Delphine Shannon1, Heidi Zurawka1, Wendy Hatchett1,
Elizabeth Bevan2, Tim Hoffland1, and Moby Solangi1
1
2
Institute for Marine Mammal Studies, Gulfport, MS, USA
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA
The Kemp’s ridley sea turtle (Lepidochelys kempii) was historically the most endangered sea turtle in the
world and came to the brink of extinction in the mid 1980’s. Due to intense conservation efforts, this
species is now gradually recovering. Although the majority of Kemp’s ridley nesting occurs near Rancho
Nuevo, Mexico, they are known to forage throughout the coastal waters of the Gulf of Mexico. It has been
suggested that the north central Gulf of Mexico may be an important foraging ground and developmental
habitat for this species, but few studies have attempted to survey sea turtles in that region. In 2012,
approximately 200 immature Kemp’s ridleys were incidentally captured at fishing piers along the coast of
Mississippi, and the majority of these received care and rehabilitation at the Institute for Marine Mammal
Studies (Gulfport, MS). In the current study, the sex ratio of these immature turtles was examined using a
testosterone radioimmunoassay (RIA) that was validated for use with Kemp’s ridleys. This subject is of
particular interest since this species has temperature-dependent sex determination which can produce
highly biased sex ratios. Other studies have detected a significant female bias in other aggregations of
immature Kemp’s ridleys, and studies at the nesting beach suggest female biased hatchling sex ratios. The
ability to examine a relatively large number of immature Kemp’s ridleys inhabiting the Mississippi Sound
provides an unprecedented opportunity to investigate population sex ratio in the Kemp’s ridley sea turtle.
The results of the current study provide insight on the population sex ratio which will affect the future
reproductive success in this Critically Endangered sea turtle. Further, the sex ratio of these turtles reflects
many years of hatchling sex ratios produced in the Kemp’s Ridley Conservation Program.
GENETIC CHARACTERIZATION OF OLIVE RIDLEY AGGREGATIONS OFF THE MEXICAN
CENTRAL PACIFIC COAST- PRELIMINARY RESULTS
Rodolfo Martín del Campo1, Christian Ortega1, Sonia Quijano1, and Alberto Abreu2
1
2
Universidad de Colima, Manzanillo, Colima, Mexico
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mazatlán, Sinaloa, Mexico
The olive ridley turtle is a pantropical species and the most abundant in the world. Mitochondrial DNA
studies based on nesting habitats suggest four major lineages in the world. This study is one of the first to
analyze marine aggregations from the Mexican Central Pacific to evaluate genetic composition with the
aim of determining possible origins converging on this area of study. Out of a total of 100 turtles caught, 52
have been analyzed so far (16 adult females, 18 adult males and 18 juvenile/sub adults) from skin samples
from right anterior flipper. Genomic DNA was extracted using standard techniques and 880 bp fragments
of the mitochondrial DNA control region were amplified using LTEi9agc/H950 primer pair. Sequencing
was carried out by Macrogen in Korea. From the 52 samples sequenced in our study, a total of 15
haplotypes were observed with 21 variable sites. One haplotype was predominant accounting for 66% of
samples. Haplotypes were trimmed to 384 bp for comparisons with reported haplotypes. Observed
sequences were compared to the reported haplotypes to infer their phylogenetic relationships. Although
individual sources for the studied aggregation cannot be identified from current results, the presence of the
217
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
sequence from M60-PCM which clearly nests within the East Indian clade suggests a surprising, albeit
infrequent, link between East Pacific (EP) olive ridleys in Mexican Central Pacific waters and central or
western Pacific populations. While Shanker et al found EP haplotypes in eastern India reflects low
frequency westward transoceanic transport for the species; the current results are the first to indicate that
the reverse is also possible. Modeling of oceanic currents will be necessary to explain an eastward transport
from the Indian-West Pacific to western Mexico and greater genetic coverage of SE Asian rookeries will be
needed to locate origins for this unusual olive ridley. Thanks to all sponsors: International Sea Turtle
Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of
Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America,
CONACYT, Universidad de Colima, UNAM.
MULTIPLE PATERNITY OF THE GREEN TURTLE POPULATION AT KOSGODA TURTLE
ROOKERY, SRI LANKA ASSESSED USING MICROSATELLITE* MARKERS
E.M. Lalith Ekanayake1,2,3, P. Samaraweera4, K.B. Ranawana3, Thushan Kapurusinghe1, M.M.
Saman1, A.M.D.S. Rathnakumara1, and R.S. Rajakaruna4
1
Turtle Conservation Project, 11, Perera Mawatha, Panadura, Sri Lanka
Post Graduate Institute of Science, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka
3
Department of Zoology, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka
4
Department of Molecular Biology & Biotechnology, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka
2
Adult sea turtles have multiple mates, but the frequency of multiple paternity varies between rookeries and
among species. Multiple mating can influence the strength of sexual selection, the effective population size,
genetic variability and introgression within a population. Paternity in the offspring of 19 female green sea
turtles (Chelonia mydas) nesting at Kosgoda rookery in Sri Lanka was determined using microsatellite
markers at six loci. Tissue samples were collected from the nesting female and ten hatchlings from each
clutch. A total of 24 clutches including single clutches of 17 females and three or four successive clutches
of two females were examined. Clutches of 47% of the females were sired by two (62.5%) or three (37.5%)
fathers. The successive clutch analysis showed that the dominant father sired 50.0% of the total offspring
followed by 33.3% by the second male. The same paternal alleles were observed at all six loci in all the
successive clutches. This suggests that the male or males that sired the first clutch also sired the other
clutches for a given female. This provides evidence for multiple mating with the same male during a
nesting season and/or sperm storage. Although the size of the females that laid clutches with multiple
paternity were typically smaller than the females with single paternity clutches, this difference was not
statistically significant (Student’s t-test; p = 0.24). There was no evidence that the same male had fathered
offspring with multiple females. Although green turtles are highly promiscuous in their mating behavior
and known to store sperm, fewer than half of the females at Kosgoda rookery laid clutches with multiple
paternity. In populations where multiple matings occur, knowledge of its prevalence and effects on
paternity distribution within a natural assemblage is critical to comprehend population structure. This
information can therefore be of great importance to the management and conservation of threatened species
such as sea turtles. Acknowledgments: We would like to acknowledge the International Sea Turtle Society,
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife,
Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America, the International Sea Turtle
Symposium and National Science Foundation, Sri Lanka for their support to attend to the symposium.
218
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MORTALITY RATES OF KEMP'S RIDLEY SEA TURTLES IN THE NERITIC WATERS OF
THE UNITED STATES
Sheryan P. Epperly1, Selina S. Heppell2, Paul M. Richards1, Marco Antonio Castro Martínez3,
Blanca Monica Zapata Najera3, Adriana Laura Sarti Martínez4, Luis Jaime Peña5, and Donna J.
Shaver6
1
NOAA, National Marine Fisheries Service, Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Miami, FL 33149, USA
Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR 97331, USA
3
Secretaría De Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales, Comisión Nacional de Áreas Naturales Protegidas,
Calle 14 y 15 Bravo 335. Zona Centro, Ciudad Victoria, Tamaulipas CP 87000, México
4
Secretaría De Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales, Dirección de Especies Prioritarias Para La
Conservación, Comisión Nacional de Áreas Naturales Protegidas, Tlalpan, México DF 14210, México
5
Gladys Porter Zoo, Brownsville, Texas 78520, USA
6
National Park Service, Padre Island National Seashore, Corpus Christi, TX 78480, USA
2
We conducted a catch curve analysis of Kemp's ridleys strandings in the USA, 1986-2009, to estimate
instantaneous mortality rates. The methods were similar to those used previously to estimate mortality rates
prior to 1990 (Heppell et al. 2005). Carapace length data were used to estimate the age structure of the
strandings using region-specific von-Bertalanffy curves, assuming a July 1 birthdate. While we had size
data from all states, we were unable to obatin permission to use the morphometric data from South Carolina
for this purpose. The size distribution of Kemp's ridleys stranded in Georgia is not significantly different
than those stranding in South Carolina (Kolmogorov-Smirnoff Test, KSa=0.9420, Pr>KSA=0.3774). Thus,
we used the Georgia size data as surrogate for the South Carolina size data, and applied the distribution to
the numbers reported stranding in South Carolina (http://www.sefsc.noaa.gov/species /turtles/
strandings.htm). Our ridley year-based model (July 1-June 30) included several cohorts in a given year; we
assumed that the reduction in strandings-at-age within a year reflected a constant annual mortality rate for
all cohorts within the year. To account for an exponentially growing population, each cohort was weighted
by an index of its cohort's strength: the number of hatchlings released during the birth year in the 3 core
camps in Tamaulipas (Barra del Tordo, Rancho Nuevo, and Tepehuajes) was divided by the size of
smallest cohort represented in the time series (11,100 hatchings in 1975) to form the index. Annual plots of
the ln transformed weighted size-at-age numbers indicated that during most years, Kemp's ridleys were
fully recruited to the neritic waters by age 2. Unlike the previous catch curve analysis, we did not find that
the plots deteriorated until after 10 years. Thus, the rate of decline from age 2 through age 10 was used to
estimate the instantaneous rate of mortality for a given year.
CLIMATE CHANGE POTENTIAL EFFECTS OVER SEA TURTLE POPULATION ON
FORAGING GROUNDS: VENEZUELAN GULF, A CASE STUDY
Nínive Espinoza Rodríguez1 and Héctor Barrios-Garrido1,2
1
Grupo de Trabajo en Tortugas Marinas del Golfo de Venezuela. Maracaibo – Venezuela. Laboratorio de
Ecología General. FEC. Universidad del Zulia. Maracaibo – Venezuela.
2
IUCN SCC Marine Turtle Specialists Group (IUCN SCC-MTSG). Centro de Modelado Científico.
Universidad del Zulia (CMC).
Sea turtle populations are facing several kinds of threats, from single plastic bags to huge climate
catastrophes that swap away entire nesting beaches jeopardizing their survival. From the last 3 decades sea
219
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
turtle biology, ecology and conservation issues have increasingly captured the interest of many researchers,
trying to explain and predict how sea turtle populations will develop worldwide. Climate Change threats
(like sea level rise, sea surface and sand temperature increase, increase in cyclonic activity, among others)
are a growing interest of study due to the potential vulnerability of sea turtles to those pressures. However,
these studies have been focused mainly on sea turtle nesting beaches and how a single climate process will
affect them. Here, we use a vulnerability assessment framework to assess the cumulative impact of various
climate processes on foraging grounds used by sea turtles at the Gulf of Venezuela (GV). This assessment
framework was modified in order to investigate different climate processes presented in the GV. Our
assessment indicates that this foraging ground have a relative large vulnerability to climate change, being
the potential increment of annual precipitation and a thermocline variability the main climate processes that
might affect negatively sea turtle populations at the GV. Temperature and precipitation projections in the
Caribbean for a conservative and medium-high scenario of carbon emissions indicates that this region may
present a warm and dry climate, with high variations among localities. These alterations will negatively
impact habitats, feeding opportunities and migration routes that in long term will considerable decrease sea
turtle populations. Few countries understand and know how to respond to climate change, Venezuela isn’t
one of those. In recent years we have witnessed a potential effect due to climate change, where notable
changes in sea surface temperatures and high runoff impacts have altered the habitats of sea turtles in the
GV. This framework might allow users to investigate how mitigate different climatic processes individually
or simultaneously by manipulating variables from this assessment. Nonetheless, further research and
investigations are needed in order to provide a greater mosaic of possible adaptation responses by sea
turtles and successful mitigation actions, so sea turtle conservation programs, management and decision
makers could help reduce these threats in the long term.
EXPLORING SOUTHERN WATERS: THE PRESENCE OF HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN
URUGUAY
Andres Estrades1, Gabriela Velez-Rubio2, Maria Noel Caraccio3, and Alejandro Fallabrino3
1
Karumbé. Av.Rivera 3245. 11600. Montevideo. Uruguay/ Museo Nacional de Historia Natural, CC 399,
CP 11000, Montevideo, Uruguay
2
Karumbé. Av.Rivera 3245. 11600. Montevideo. Uruguay/ Instituto Cavanilles de Biodiversidad y
Biologia Evolutiva, Universidad de Valencia, Aptdo. 22085, 46071 Valencia, Spain
3
Karumbé. Av. Rivera 3245. 11600. Montevideo. Uruguay
Hawksbill turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata) occur globally in tropical waters, mainly associated with
tropical reefs. Their distribution in the South Western Atlantic ocean is limited mostly to the northern coast
of Brazil and adjacent waters. Regular nesting occurs mostly in the state of Bahia, although its distribution
area ranges from Ceará to São Paulo (Brazil). Hawksbill turtles may travel considerable distances between
their nesting areas and their feeding habitats. Immature individuals tagged in Brazil were recaptured in the
African coast of Senegal and Gabon. In rare cases, juvenile turtles are known to occur as far south as Rio
Grande do Sul (South Brazil).However, in recent years, a total of ten hawksbill turtles have been reported
in Uruguayan coast. This species was previously unrecorded in this region of the South Atlantic Ocean.
Only one hawksbill has been registered in more southern areas, correspond to a juvenile captured in Bahia
de Samborombon (Argentina). Therefore, these records are the southernmost strandings reports in the
Western Atlantic for this species. The stranding network run by Karumbé registered all the stranded
hawksbills in the department of Rocha, in the North-East of Uruguay. All of them are considered as
juveniles (mean curved carapace length, notch to tip [CCLn-t]= 35.01 ± 7.96 cm, range: 27.6-56.5; n=10).
In 2007, 2009 and 2010 were registered just one hawksbill turtle each year, but in 2011 were registered
seven alive hawksbills, but their physical condition was critical. They were moved to the Karumbé
Rehabilitation Center in Montevideo, but all of them died. The cause of dead was associated to digestive
tract obstruction due to marine debris ingestion. To identify the natal origin tissue sample was collected for
ongoing genetic analysis. The presence of the above reported individuals can be correlated with the
220
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
occurrence of a positive sea surface temperature anomaly registered in the area. During the strandings
events high positive anomalies (0.5 - 1.5) were observed along the Uruguayan and southern Brazil
continental shelf and oceanic region. This sustained temperature anomaly is associated with a strong
influence of Tropical and Subtropical waters, advected southward by the Brazil Current. Probably these
turtles reached the Uruguayan coast owing the favorable thermal conditions during the austral summer
where an intrusion of warm oceanic waters is expected. The strandings reported above are of specially
interest, since the hawksbill turtle is not frequently reported for temperate waters. Our records extend the
geographic range of this species almost 250 km southward. The sporadic occurrence of this critically
endangered species in Uruguayan waters implies a fifth species of marine turtle for this zone and reinforces
the importance of continue monitoring the Uruguayan coast. This evidence altogether affords a new
evaluation of the distribution of this species in the South Western Atlantic ocean.
USING CUSTOM-DESIGNED CAPTURE ARRAYS AND NEXT-GENERATION SEQUENCING
FOR SNP DISCOVERY IN LEATHERBACKS (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA)
Amy Frey, Suzanne Roden, and Peter H. Dutton
NOAA-National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, 3333 North Torrey Pines
Court, La Jolla, California 92037, USA.
We describe an approach that combines custom micro-array capture technology and next-generation
sequencing to discover SNPs for use in population structure analyses. The samples were chosen primarily
as part of an ongoing study of fine scale population structure of leatherbacks nesting in the western Pacific,
with a few additional samples representing the global distribution of the species. Nuclear loci sequences
were compiled from a variety of sources, including Genbank, as well as flanking regions from
microsatellites developed for either loggerheads or green turtles. Additionally some fragments were
characterized during SNP discovery for green turtles using AFLP fragments. Genomic library enrichment
was completed using tiled complimentary sequence probes designed specifically for the Agilent custom
micro-array. Probes were designed to cover the entire mitochondrial genome as well as eighty nuclear loci.
In order to multiplex 100 turtles in the array, the individual turtle genomes were fragmented and labeled
with short a unique sequence or index tag. The indexed libraries were then pooled in equal concentrations.
The pooled library was then hybridized to the capture array and subsequently eluted and amplified for
sequencing on an Illumina genome analyzer. This is a streamlined method for collecting large amounts of
nuclear and mitochondrial sequence data for SNP discovery as well as population genetic studies of wild
populations.
CONSERVATION OF SANDY BEACHES: HOW ANTHROPOGENIC AND NATURAL
FACTORS IMPACT SEA TURTLE NESTING ON A REGIONAL SCALE
Ikuko Fujisaki1 and Margaret Lamont2
1
University of Florida, Department of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation/Ft. Lauderdale Research and
Education Center
2
University of Florida, Florida Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit
Coastal areas provide critical habitats for a variety of wildlife species which helps maintain high
biodiversity in this scarce habitat. Although conservation of this habitat is a priority, it is challenging due to
221
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
both anthropogenic and natural forces. Rapidly expanding human populations and intense coastal
development have resulted in heavy modification of coastal areas. Increasing levels of recreational beach
activities have resulted in more human-wildlife encounters, increases in artificial lighting, and pollution.
Management actions aimed at reducing these problems, such as beach nourishment, grooming, and coastal
armoring, often create additional issues by reshaping sandy beaches. Although sea turtles spend most of
their lives at sea, they rely on sandy beaches for one critical stage in their life-history, reproduction.
Therefore, alterations to the sandy beach habitat may greatly affect sea turtle populations. Given that threats
to sandy beaches are predicted to further intensify in the coming decades, beach management policies that
protect biodiversity and maintain ecological processes, including nesting sea turtles, are required.
Understanding how the anthropogenic- and natural-factors impact nesting turtles using the sandy beach is
essential for success of such conservation efforts. We examined temporal trends in nest density and false
crawl rate of loggerhead sea turtles and the association between these parameters and the characteristics of
16 nesting beaches in northwest Florida using log-term nesting and shoreline survey data. We found a
decreasing trend in nest density and an increasing trend in false crawl rate over years. Human population
growth rate and past nourishment operation were inversely associated with nest density, while erosion rate
was positively associated with nest density. Erosion rate and past nourishment operation were positively
associated with false crawl rate. False crawl rate also varied by shoreline morphology of nesting beaches.
Compared to continuously linear beaches, false crawl rate was higher on beaches located on islands and
peninsula tips, which are typically more dynamic. Our study highlights the complexity involved in
conserving coastal habitats. We quantitatively showed that human activities, management actions and
natural forces combine to influence nesting behaviors of sea turtles in one nesting group in the southeastern
U.S. Modifications of coastal systems are accelerating by increasing human footprints and the amplification
of natural forces. The Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is one example of an acute and
potentially long-lasting threat to coastal habitats. Shoreline alterations due to climate change and associated
sea-level rise are also becoming a global concern. These factors could lead to further degradation of
shoreline habitats, therefore there is an urgent need to develop effective conservation policies that address
multiple and broad-scale issues to maintain the coastal ecosystems and allow for continued co-existence of
humans and wildlife in coastal systems.
POPULATION TRENDS AND SURVIVORSHIP OF NESTING GREEN SEA TURTLES ON ISLA
DE AVES, VENEZUELA
Marco García Cruz1, Margarita Lampo1, Claudia Peñaloza2, Genaro Sole3, and Kathryn RodríguezClark1
1
Centro de Ecología, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Científicas, Apdo. 20632, Caracas 1020-A,
Venezuela
2
Colorado Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit. Department of Fish, Wildlife and Conservation
Biology, 1484 Campus Delivery - Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, 80523, USA
3
FUDENA. Fundación para la Defensa de la Naturaleza. Aptdo 70776, Caracas 1071-A, Venezuela.
One of the greatest challenges facing the conservation of threatened species is to understand the life-history
effects of specific threats and to document population trends, in order to reduce threat impacts and evaluate
recovery efforts. Analyses of a species’ demographic parameters are essential for setting such goals and can
also suggest directions for future research. Here we analyze 26 years of capture-recapture data available for
the nesting population of green turtles (Chelonia mydas) on Isla de Aves. This population is numerically
important in the Caribbean, and has been effectively protected from human impacts since 1979. We
analyzed 6,414 encounter histories using an open robust design model with multiple strata (ORDMS),
which allowed unbiased survival estimates in the presence of temporary emigration. Using Akaike
information criteria, we compared 28 models to estimate survival, recruitment, and remigration rates of
adult females, and to test alternative hypotheses about the effects of time, age class and hurricane patterns
on these parameters. We also obtained estimates of the population size of nesting turtles each year on Isla
222
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
de Aves and their average residence time. The best-fitting model indicated that adult survival was lower for
turtles arriving for the first time than for those returning in successive years, probably due to a high rate of
tag loss during the first year. Survival varied considerably among years, with a mean annual probability of
0.83 for returning turtles (95% CI 0.51–0.98). This value is similar to survival estimated in Tortuguero,
Costa Rica (0.85; 95% CI 0.83–0.87), the only other population in the Caribbean that has demographic
estimates based on long-term capture histories, but is much lower than estimates in Australia (0.95; 95% CI
0.92-0.98). Also, Isla de Aves had a remigration interval of 1-3 years, (X: 2.37, SD: 1,10), which was
similar to the interval estimated for Tortuguero, Costa Rica (X: 2.95, SD 0,88), but shorter than estimates
from Australia (5-7 years). Fluctuations in adult annual survival may be due to turtle fishing in Nicaragua,
the Dominican Republic, the Lesser Antilles and the Gulf of Venezuela, where females from Isla de Aves
are known to feed. Such fishing pressures do not exist in Australia. The frequency of hurricanes across the
Caribbean also explained a small but significant proportion of variation in adult survival (F= 4.638;
p=0.04508 R2=0.16). However, although population size varied among years (100-1,453 females), we
observed an apparent increase between 1979 and 2008. Thus, although we were able to document the effect
of threats on adult survivorship, it appears that the Isla de Aves population may be stable at present or even
growing. Management actions to grow this population further will need to be tailored not only to local
nesting trends but also to regional climatic cycles and distributed anthropogenic threats and natural
conditions in foraging grounds.
GENETIC STOCK STRUCTURE OF HAWKSBILL NESTING POPULATIONS IN THE
EASTERN PACIFIC
Alexander R. Gaos1,2,3, Rebecca L. Lewison2, Michael Liles1,4, Andres Baquero1,5, José Urteaga1,6,
Perla Torres1,6, Aarón Esliman1,7, Ingrid L. Yañez1, Amy Frey8, Erin LaCasella8, and Peter H.
Dutton8
1
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative
San Diego State University
3
University of California Davis
4
Texas A&M University
5
Fundaccion Equilibrio Azul; Universidad San Francisco de Quito
6
Fauna & Flora International
7
Grupo Tortuguero de las Californias, AC
8
National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center
2
The use of molecular genetic techniques plays a critical role in the understanding and management of
global sea turtles populations. Due to strong philopatry demonstrated by the taxon, mitochondrial DNA
(mtDNA) continues to provide a useful genetic marker for evaluating population structure and
phylogeography. We used mtDNA to conduct the first-ever genetic survey of hawksbill nesting stocks in
the eastern Pacific Ocean. We analyzed a total of 61 tissue samples collected between 2008 and 2011 from
four rookeries across the region. Despite small sample sizes for some rookeries, our initial findings provide
novel insights into population structuring and the evolutionary origins of hawksbill turtles in the eastern
Pacific. Three previously identified haplotypes and two new ones were found with overall frequencies of
78.7% and 21.3%, respectively, the latter only evident in Central American nesting stocks. Significant
differentiation was found between rookeries in Central and South America, providing evidence for stock
structuring in the eastern Pacific. One haplotype predominated at all four nesting sites. This and the other
two previously identified haplotypes occur in the Indo-Pacific. From a phylogeographic perspective, the
prevalence of Indo-Pacific derived haplotypes in eastern Pacific nesting stocks suggests eastern Pacific
populations radiated out of the western Pacific, an assertion previously postulated, but which has remained
unconfirmed until now. Furthermore, the existence of new haplotypes exclusive to the eastern Pacific
suggests the populations have been separated sufficiently long to accumulate new mutations in the mtDNA
control region at the regional population level. We also found potential evidence for fine scale genetic
223
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
segregation between nesting habitat types, possibly maintained by behavioral differences. Nonetheless,
additional studies are needed to confirm this hypothesis. Our findings have important implications for
hawksbill management strategies on both regional and global scales. Additional research with larger
sample sizes and variable markers will prove crucial to gaining further understanding of hawksbill stock
structuring and genetic diversity in the eastern Pacific.
LAGUNA MADRE RECRUITING CLASS OF 2012
Anthony J. Gillis1, Jeff George1, and Luis Jaime Peña2
1
2
Sea Turtle Inc., South Padre Island, TX, USA
Gladys Porter Zoo, Brownsville, TX, USA
Endangered sea turtle conservation efforts share the common and very vital goal of increasing populations
to self-sustainable numbers. With a large effort being carried out towards all species of sea turtles in the
Gulf of Mexico, a better understanding of nesting grounds, their relationship to juvenile foraging grounds
and population trends can bolster or increase conservation efforts. The Laguna Madre is and has been a
viable and flourishing marine ecosystem for many decades. It is an area that provides great foraging
grounds for Atlantic green sea turtles (Chelonia mydas) of all sizes. Many nearby beaches in Northern
Mexico have reported increases in Atlantic green nesting. Looking at nesting data totals from Mexico and
straight carapace length from stranding reports in the Laguna Madre, collected over the past 6 years, will
allow for the analysis of possible shifts in the average size of the Lower Laguna Madre Population. A shift
to a smaller average size in the Lower Laguna Madre green sea turtles’ population, coupled with an
increase in Northern Mexico nesting, could represent more recruitment in the Lower Laguna Madre
population and may represent a growing population of green sea turtles in the Western Gulf of Mexico.
Results show a noticeable increase in the number of nesting green sea turtles along with a decrease in the
average carapace length of Lower Laguna Madre juvenile green sea turtles. This decrease in the average
carapace length is a great indicator of positive recruitment. This recruitment of juvenile green sea turtles is
a positive step in the recovery of the threatened Atlantic Green population in the Western Gulf of Mexico.
BAYESIAN FRAMEWORK TO INTEGRATE TRADITIONAL ECOLOGICAL KNOWLEDGE
INTO ECOLOGICAL MODELING: A CASE STUDY WITH SEASONALITY OF MARINE
TURTLES IN FRENCH GUIANA
Marc Girondot
Université Paris-Sud et CNRS, Orsay, France
Indigenous groups offer alternative knowledge and perspectives based on their own locally developed
practices of resource use. This Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK) has been acquired from long-term
observations and uses of natural systems. Some promote the use of TEK in scientific research, however the
methodology to integrate such knowledge in ecological models is not straightforward. We advocate the use
of Bayesian framework to integrate TEK as a prior for analysis. We exemplified such a use of TEK to
analyze the seasonality of marine turtles in French Guiana. We show that TEK can resolve some situations
in which the parameter fit was not possible. On the other hand, TEK could be biased and it is safer to have
data with enough information to prevent this bias to influence strongly the posteriors. The construction of
ecological model to be used with TEK will be discussed.
224
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ADVANCES IN SEA TURTLE PHOTO-IDENTIFICATION. A CASE-STUDY CARRIED OUT AT
THE MARINE BIOLOGICAL RESERVE OF ARVOREDO, BRAZIL
Bruno T. Gonçalves and Nuno S. Loureiro
Department of Marine Biology, University of Algarve, Algarve, Portugal
Photo-identification is a non-destructive and non-stressing method which uses photographs of natural
marks of the animal body to ensure their individual recognition within a population. Photo-ID is also used
as a complement to other identification methods such as artificial marks. The present work is focused on
the validation of the Photo-ID method developed by the Kelonia Institute (Saint Leu - Reunion Island,
France) (www.kelonia.org) for sea turtle Photo-ID for the Cheloniidae family. It uses the specific physical
characteristics of animals and procedures are simple and fast. The Program uses simple photographs of the
head, taken without any special requirements, from the right and left sides. The Program establishes a set of
codes obtained from the analysis of the facial plates (as much as possible), which generates a code
sequence of numbers that is the 'ID number' of the individual. The study area is The Marine Biological
Reserve of Arvoredo (Santa Catarina, Brazil), which presents an enormous biodiversity of marine wildlife
and is an important feeding area for juveniles of the sea turtles species that represent great importance for
the local natural heritage. Captures were made by free diving, with a total of 38 individuals of C. mydas
captured during the summer of 2011/2012, resulting from 136.5 hours of diving effort. Photographs of both
sides of the head are needed for photo-identification with the software. A total of 195 turtles were studied
(from the present work and from the previous research in the same area). Only one individual was captured
by both projects, initially on 19/07/2006 and then recaptured during the present work 06/02/2012. Analyses
in the computer program clearly identified that was the same individual, and that there was no observable
change in the distribution and geometry of the plates, either from right or left sides, despite almost six years
time gap between the captures. Another factor revealed with this turtle was both the right and the left side
of the face have the same symmetry and geometry showing the same numbers of codes. This feature occurs
in only 5% of the turtles analyzed in the present work, so turtles with only pictures of one side of the head
should not be subject to initial registration in order to avoid errors in the database. Previous works using
only two post – ocular columns for identification show that may be flaws in their data, for the reason that
sea turtles captured in the present study showed that these two columns very similar or equal different
individuals. Our final method employed a greater number of columns and scutes thus avoiding possible
errors. In conclusion, this work validated the accuracy and reliability of this Photo-ID method. Future work
will provide new evaluation of the method and may lead to new management and protection actions for
these fantastic animals.
HISTORICAL AND SEASONAL TRENDS IN GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS)
CAPTURED AT SOUTH HUTCHINSON ISLAND, FLORIDA, USA
Jeffrey R. Guertin1, Dave R. Clark1, Cody R. Mott1, Steve Weege1, Ryan C. Welsh1, Michael J.
Bresette1, Jonathan C. Gorham1, and Vince Munne2
1
2
Inwater Research Group, Inc., Jensen Beach, Florida, USA
Florida Power and Light, Port St. Lucie, Florida, USA
The Florida Power & Light St. Lucie Power Plant is located on South Hutchinson Island, Florida. Since
1976, when power generation first began, sea turtles have become entrained into the plant’s intake cooling
canal system. A monitoring program was established and sea turtles were routinely removed from the canal.
225
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Morphometric data were taken from each turtle before it was tagged and released, and compiled into a
database that has been maintained since the plant went on-line. From 1988 to present (a span of 25 years),
green turtle (Chelonia mydas) capture data were analyzed to look at historical and seasonal trends in
population structure, recapture rates, and fibropapilloma rates. Analysis shows that the percentage of total
sea turtle captures at the plant represented by green turtles rose markedly in the late 1980’s and early
1990’s before leveling off. The percentage of new recruits encountered at the plant has steadily declined
since the early 1990’s, while the percentage of turtles that have been recaptured at the plant has steadily
risen. Green turtles have also exhibited seasonal trends in which the percentage of new recruits rises during
winter months and falls during summer months. The data have also shown that fibropapilloma rates are
much higher in the winter months than during the remainder of the year. This long-term monitoring project
will continue to provide insight into the population structure of turtles utilizing the near-shore waters
adjacent to the St. Lucie power plant.
PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF OLIVE RIDLEY TURTLES
Anelise Torres Hahn1,2, Eugenia Naro-Maciel2, Michael Jensen3, Brian Bowen4, Jaqueline Comin de
Castilhos5, Alberto Abreu-Grobois6, Nancy FitzSimmons7, Col Limpus8, Scott Whiting9, Benoit de
Thoisy10, and Sandro L. Bonatto11
1
Laboratório de Biologia Genômica e Molecular, PUCRS, Porto Alegre, Brazil
College of Staten Island CUNY, Staten Island, New York, USA
3
NOAA - Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, CA, USA
4
University of Hawaii, USA
5
Fundação Pró-Tamar, Brazil
6
Universidad Nacional Autonoma del Mexico, Mexico
7
Institute for Applied Ecology University of Canberra, Canberra, Australia
8
Department of Environment and Resource Management, Brisbane, Australia
9
Department of Natural Resources, Environment, the Arts and Sport, NT, Australia
10
Institut Pasteur de la Guyane & Kwata NGO, Cayenne, Guiana Francesa
11
Laboratório de Biologia Genômica e Molecular, PUCRS, Porto Alegre, Brazil
2
Phylogeographic studies, which consider the geographic distribution of genetic lineages, provide a
powerful method to understand a species’ colonization history and the interconnectedness among
populations. The olive ridley turtle (Lepidochelys olivacea) has a global distribution across tropical and
sub-tropical oceans, and is one of the most abundant marine turtle species. It is closely related to the
Kemp’s ridley (Lepidochelys kempii) and the origin of both species is believed to be related to the closure
of the Isthmus of Panama during the Pliocene. Subsequently olive ridley would spread from the Pacific
Ocean into the Indian, and colonized the Atlantic Ocean most recently; or a remnant population from
Indian Ocean would colonized both East Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. In this study we expand our previous
work by investigating new aspects of evolutionary processes and demographic history that contributed to
current L. olivacea distribution. Using Bayesian analyses we analyzed mtDNA control region sequences
from 14 rookeries (n =541), as well as fifteen nuclear short tandem repeats (STRs) from 12 rookeries (n =
285). Bayesian analyses with the mtDNA sequences were carried out in Lamarc in two ways: 1) with 9 sets
of populations: Surinam (SU), French Guiana (GF), Brazil (BR), India (IN), Sri Lanka (SL), Tiwi Island
(Tis), Cape York (CY), Costa Rica (CR), Baja California (BC) and continental Mexico (ME); 2) 4 sets of
populations: Indian Ocean (IN and SL), Indo/West Pacific (Australia and Malaysia), Atlantic Ocean (GB,
GF, SU and BR) and East Pacific (CR, BC and ME). The results showed that genetic diversity, and
consequently the Nef (females effective population size) in olive ridleys varies widely, from Nef ~17,000
for IN to Nef ~1,300 in CY (Australia); all sets of population showed sign of population growth. The
unique pairs of populations with Nm values higher than one are those from the East Pacific (ME, CR, and
BC) and Sri Lanka into India. Divergence times were estimated using a Bayesian approach and resulted in
clade K, found only in India Ocean and the most basal lineages for olive ridley, originated around 1.6 Mya,
226
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
the East Pacific clade about 0.61 Mya, and the split between the Indo-Pacific and Atlantic lineages around
0.36 Mya. These results are mostly consistent with the recent colonization of East Pacific and the Atlantic
and suggest a model of recurrent extinction/colonization for most ridley nesting sites that may be explained
by climatic changes, especially during the Pleistocene. Diversification times within all five clades are very
similar, ranging between 221,000 years ago and 342,000. Significant statistics for the STR data and
similarly shaped star trees in each of the four major olive ridley clades suggested a population expansion, a
scenario partially corroborated by the neutrality tests (Fu’s FS and Tajima’s D) and the Bayesian Skyline
Plot (BSP) analysis which indicate a population expansion for L. olivacea after the last glacial maximum.
These results suggest that the most recent demographic events (colonization and population expansion) for
most oceanic regions may have been concurrent.
GENETIC STRUCTURE OF GREEN TURTLES NESTING IN THE NORTHWESTERN
PACIFIC OCEAN*
Tomoko Hamabata1, Naoki Kamezaki2, and Tsutomu Hikida1
1
Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
Sea Turtle Association of Japan, Osaka, Japan; Suma Aqualife Park, Kobe, Japan; University of
Tokyo,Toyko, Japan
2
Japan is located at the northern limit of the Pacific green turtle breeding area. The Ogasawara Islands and
the Ryukyu Archipelago are the two main nesting sites of this species in Japan. Only green turtle nests are
found in the Ogasawara Islands, where the number of annual nesting is estimated at more than 1,000 by
beach surveys. In contrast, in the Ryukyu Archipelago the nests of three species of sea turtles (loggerheads,
green turtles and hawksbills) are found. This archipelago is a long island chain lying more than 1,000 km
between Taiwan and Kyushu, and contains scattered nesting rookeries of green turtles. Hence, the available
data about nesting sites and the size of nesting populations are limited at several islands of the southern and
northern Ryukyus. Although surveys in the central Ryukyus have been started in past years, the genetic
population structure in the whole Ryukyu Archipelago is still unknown. The previous studies suggested that
there were three genetically differentiated stocks nesting in the Ogasawara Islands and Yaeyama Islands, in
the southern Ryukyus. These populations were also differentiated from the two neighboring populations
nesting in Taiwan. In the present study we collected samples of nesting green turtles in the central Ryukyus,
and analyzed them using mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) by sequencing approximately 860 base pairs of the
control region to understand the extent of genetic connectivity among the green turtle nesting populations
in the northwestern Pacific Ocean. Although several haplotypes were shared with other populations, it was
suggested that there were two differentiated populations in the central Ryukyus. The haplotypes detected in
the central Ryukyus also belonged to three divergent clades, as was previously observed in three other
Japanese populations. These clades corresponded to three of five clades detected in the populations through
Australasia. Although in many rookeries the haplotypes from two divergent clades were detected
sympatrically in the northern Pacific rookeries, mixtures of haplotypes from three divergent clades have
been observed only in Japanese populations. Moreover, all regional populations in Japan showed high
genetic diversities. These results suggested that the source of Japanese populations had their origin in the
emigrations from several common populations in lower latitudes, which might have been geographically
distant. Consequently, they could have maintained high genetic diversities even after they were
differentiated into the small populations at the periphery of their distribution. Fifteen of 18 haplotypes,
including their dominant haplotypes, have been only reported from populations in the northwestern Pacific
rookeries. This suggests that the populations in this region have evolved as their own lineages after the
historical immigration. Acknowledgments: This research was financially supported in part by the Global
COE Program A06 to Kyoto University and the Ocean Exposition commemorative Park management
Foundation. We are grateful to the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.
227
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek,
Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America and International Sea Turtle Symposium for their support and for
providing a travel grant.
THE “HUNT” METHOD FOR ASSESSING RELATIVE ABUNDANCE OF SEA TURTLES IN
SHALLOW COASTAL WATERS
Richard Herren, Blair Witherington, Dave Clark, and Cody Mott
Inwater Research Group, Inc. Jensen Beach, FL USA
Aerial surveys are used to estimate relative abundance of sea turtles over broad geographic areas. However,
detectability of turtles from the air is typically low for coastal waters where water clarity is reduced, the
structured bottom conceals turtles, and where juvenile turtles too small to be seen from aircraft are the most
common life stage. As an alternative to visual surveys from high-altitude, fast-moving aircraft, we describe
the results of surveys using small vessels. Between 2002 and 2012, we conducted vessel-based visual
surveys for sea turtles at the Key West National Wildlife Refuge, Florida USA. This area includes an
approximately 500 square km area with bottom types varying between seagrass, hard-bottom (sponge and
octocoral), and stony coral, with water depths mostly less than 3 m. We used a 7.4 m length skiff with two
observers standing atop a 2-m platform and an additional observer viewing the water ahead of the vessel.
Our vessel paths were not along predetermined lines and were meant to provide exploratory coverage. We
describe these search methods as haphazard, unmarked, non-linear transects, or HUNTs. During HUNTs, a
helmsman recorded vessel path and turtle locations with a Garmin Global Positioning System (GPS). The
GPS recorded start and end locations of HUNTs as well as continuous vessel tracks at a 20 m resolution.
Vessel speed during HUNTs was approximately 9 km per hr. HUNTs were near haphazard with respect to
course decisions made during transects and were biased by access opportunity. Access opportunity was
influenced by water depths where our vessel could navigate and where subsurface turtles could be observed
(0.2 to 6.0 m depth). Perpendicular distance between the transect line and each turtle was estimated by
observers on the vessel. We used the program Distance 6.0 to estimate detectability functions, effective
transect widths, and turtle densities. Opportunistically, turtles observed during HUNTs were captured by
hand. We observed 2,900 turtles of three species (Caretta caretta, Chelonia mydas, Eretmochelys
imbricata) and captured 743 turtles with sizes ranging from 21.4 to 108.5 cm straight carapace length. We
imported vessel paths and sea turtle locations recorded with GPS into ESRI’s ArcGIS 10.0 for analysis and
mapping. Using effective transect widths estimated from distance functions and vessel paths across our
study area, we developed effort density plots useful in revealing search bias and underexplored locations.
We used minimum search effort as a masking criterion for estimates of turtle density and we plotted turtle
density against bottom type. Our conclusions are that the HUNT method is a useful way to assess relative
abundance of sea turtles on a geographic scale between aerial surveys and single-site sampling.
228
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ORIGIN OF IMMATURE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) AT TWO FORAGING
GROUNDS IN SABAH, MALAYSIA
Michael P. Jensen1, Nancy N. FitzSimmons2, and Nicolas Pilcher3
1
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, NMFS, NOAA, La Jolla, California, USA
Environmental Futures Centre, Griffith University, Gold Coast Campus, Australia
3
Marine Research Foundation, Sabah, Malaysia
2
Understanding the population dynamics in both breeding and foraging habitats is a vital part of assessing
the long-term viability of any species, particularly those that are highly migratory, such as green turtles,
Chelonia mydas. Monitoring of the populations at the foraging grounds may help detect early signs of
population trends that would otherwise take decades to be seen at the nesting beach. Mixed Stock Analysis
(MSA) using molecular marker techniques provide an effective tool for estimating the origin of turtles
sampled away from their nesting beach. Here we use sequence data from the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
of 96 immature green turtles at two foraging grounds at Mantanani Island and Layang Layang Island
located northwest of Sabah, Malaysia. We used data from eight Australasian green turtle populations as the
baseline data for tracing back the origin of turtles at the two foraging grounds. The origins of the turtles at
the two foraging grounds were not different and the majority of these turtles originated from key rookeries
at Sarawak in north western Borneo and from the Malaysia and Philippine Turtle Islands in SE Sabah.
These same rookeries have a long tradition of using unshaded beach hatcheries that have resulted in mostly
female hatchlings being produced. This may have contributed to the 1:4 female biases seen at the foraging
grounds. We discuss the implications of hatchery practices at nesting beaches and recommend future
research to improve the management of marine turtles in the region.
GREEN TURTLE (CHELONIA MYDAS) GENETIC COMPOSITION AT A FEEDING GROUND
AND ROOKERIES IN THE WEST ATLANTIC: CONNECTIONS BETWEEN POPULATIONS
Juliana C. Jordao1, Ana C. V. Bondioli1, Benoit de Thoisy2, and Lurdes F. Almeida-Toledo1
1
2
University of Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, Brazil
Institut Pasteur de la Guyane, Cayenne, French Guiana
Sea turtles are globally distributed reptiles that exhibit complex life traits, such as long generation time,
oceanic habitat of juveniles, female homing and wide-ranging migrations. The migratory behavior
outcomes in spatial segregation between breeding and nesting sites, resulting in successive stages of the
mixing and isolation of genetic stocks, both spatially and temporally. The green turtle, Chelonia mydas, is
threatened with extinction worldwide and understanding its history is important to assess population
dynamics and make future projections on the population trends. The use of molecular techniques has
enabled progresses in species conservation, such as characterization of population structure, genetic
diversity and natal origins. Thus, the aim of this study is to characterize the genetic composition of C.
mydas in a feeding ground (hereafter FG) (at north coast of Rio de Janeiro state, Brazil, n=175) and two
rookeries (French Guiana, n=46, and Guadeloupe, n=24) in West Atlantic Ocean, as well as the genetic
contribution of rookeries to the FG, based on mitochondrial DNA sequences. The FG is composed so far by
11 haplotypes: CM-A8 (72%), CM-A5 (17%) and the others with a frequency less than 5% (CM-A1, CMA3, CM-A6, CM-A9, CM-A10, CM-A23, CM-A24, CM-A32 and CM-A42). Besides, two previously
undescribed haplotypes were found, CM-A69 and CM-A70. The nesting rookeries are composed so far by
CM-A5 (95%) and CM-A3 (5%) in Guadeloupe, and by CM-A5 (93%), CM-A8 (4%) and CM-A22 (3%)
229
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
in French Guiana. The mixed stock analyses (MSA) revealed a major genetic contribution to the FG from
Ascension Island, an isolated island in South Atlantic; and from French Guiana, in West Atlantic. Given the
genetic composition of feeding grounds, and the worldwide distribution of green sea turtles, it is essential
to understand the dispersion patterns to establish management plans. These preliminary results contribute to
better understand the dynamic of green sea turtle population on West Atlantic Ocean. This study highlights
the importance of connecting nesting and feeding areas that can be widely distributed according to
ecological opportunities or constraints: conservation initiatives have to focus not only on those areas, but
also on corridors between them, where turtles may also be subject to threats. Acknowledgments: University
of São Paulo, CAPES, Fapesp, Kwata NGO, Institut Pasteur de la Guyane, International Sea Turtle Society,
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Sea Turtle Conservancy,
Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America, International Sea Turtle Symposium,
European funds (PO Amazonie) via the CARET2 project.
ESTIMATING ABUNDANCE AND CLUTCH FREQUENCY FROM TAGGING DATA ON
NESTING BEACHES: HOW MUCH EFFORT IS ENOUGH?
William L. Kendall1 and Wendy Lanier2
1
2
USGS Colorado Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA
Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA
Abundance and clutch frequency are important parameters in studies of nesting sea turtle populations.
Interest in these parameters might, for example, stem from the desire to track population status, estimate
annual productivity, or study the relationship between clutch frequency and environmental covariates.
Regardless, these parameters can be estimated, even in the face of imperfect detection, using modern
statistical methods. The question is how much effort is needed to achieve reasonable targets for precision in
estimates of abundance and clutch frequency. This question is complicated by lack of fidelity by
individuals to an individual study area within a nesting season. Conversely, nest censuses combined with
tag recaptures can provide supplemental estimates of detection probability. We use simulated data to
evaluate precision of abundance and various clutch frequency estimators, under various levels of capture
effort, using scenarios relevant to hawksbill, loggerhead, and leatherback tagging studies. We also discuss
how lack of fidelity can be incorporated into estimation models.
ESTIMATING DEMOGRAPHIC PARAMETERS OF LOGGERHEAD TURTLES NESTING IN
THE NORTHERN GULF OF MEXICO
Margaret M. Lamont1, Ikuko Fujisaki2, and Raymond R. Carthy3
1
United States Geological Survey, Southeast Ecological Science Center, Gainesville, Florida
University of Florida, Department of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation/Ft. Lauderdale Research and
Education Center
3
United States Geological Survey, Florida Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, University of
Florida, Gainesville, FL
2
Population dynamics of marine turtles in the Gulf of Mexico are poorly understood. Although loggerhead
turtles (Caretta caretta) nesting in the northern Gulf are part of one of the world’s largest loggerhead
populations, little information exists from this nesting group on basic parameters such as population
230
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
abundance and survival probabilities. In this study, we derive the first estimates of key demographic
parameters for loggerhead turtles using data from a long-term saturation tagging effort conducted along the
St. Joseph Peninsula, Florida from 1998 to 2011. Clutch size, incubation rate, emergence success and turtle
length were compared among remigrants, internesters, and neophytes using a single-factor Analysis of
Variance and followed by multiple mean comparisons. Temporal trend in turtle size was examined using
linear regression with year as an independent variable. Encounter histories were created for each
loggerhead female encountered within our original 5-km study site. Survival, encounterability, probability
of entry, probability of remaining, and transition probabilities between nesting and foraging states were
estimated using a two-state open robust design model, for which females may be in an observable ‘nesting’
state or an unobservable ‘foraging’ state for any given year. This model type uses a combination of primary
and secondary timescales to account for temporary emigration during unobservable foraging years. Each
parameter may be estimated to vary over time or may be held to a constant value for each primary (year) or
secondary (10-day) period. Alternative models were constructed using varying arrangements of timedependent and constant parameters. The second-order Akaike’s Information Criterion was used to select
the most parsimonious model. Parameter estimates were obtained with Program MARK which implements
the robust design tagging model. Throughout the study period, 433 turtles were tagged following
oviposition. We documented an extremely low (<10%) remigration rate within this population. There were
no differences in clutch size, incubation rate or emergence success among remigrants, internesters or single
nesters; however remigrants and internesters were larger than single nesters. There was no temporal trend
in turtle size. Estimates of survival were high and estimates of abundance indicated a declining trend.
Because of the relatively high survival estimates documented in this study for adult loggerheads, we
suggest that high mortality in juvenile loggerheads may be the primary factor contributing to the decline in
nest abundance reported for this area and other beaches in the Southeastern United States. It is important to
continue intensive tagging in the northern Gulf in order to enable detection of changes in demographic
parameters, including estimated annual survival probabilities that might signal changes in the magnitude or
the appearance of new at-sea impacts such as the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
NEW MICROSATELLITE DNA ANALYSES MAY CONFOUND CURRENT POPULATION
MODELS FOR LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES (CARETTA CARETTA)
Jake Lasala1, Scott Harrison2, Mike Frick3, Kristina L. Williams4, and David C. Rostal2
1
Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida, USA
Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, Georgia, USA
3
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research, Gainesville, Florida, USA
4
Caretta Research Project, Savannah, Georgia, USA
2
Mating systems play important roles in shaping life history evolution and population dynamics of a species;
as a consequence they should be considered when planning conservation efforts. Specifically, in small
populations, mating systems can influence effective population size and direct evolutionary change.
Polyandry, a single female mating with multiple males, may result in the multiple paternity of progeny
within or among nests. A literature review suggests that multiple paternity occurs in most species of reptiles.
Within the Testudines, mating systems vary greatly: 0-100% of nests sampled had multiple fathers.
Previous studies on the loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) showed that within large rookeries in Florida,
Australia and Greece the occurrence of multiple paternity within nests ranges from 30% (Florida) to 95%
(Greece). Our study is the first to assess nests for the presence of multiple paternal contributions within the
smaller and more imperiled Northern Management Unit of NW Atlantic loggerheads. On a small beach on
Wassaw Island, Georgia, USA, nesting loggerheads and up to 20 offspring were sampled from 72 nests
(19.5% of nests laid) over three nesting seasons (2008 – 2010). We determined that 75% of nests sampled
had multiple fathers with an average of 2.65 fathers contributing to each nest; the number of fathers per
nest did not change over the three-year loggerhead nesting cycle. There was a positive relationship between
the number of fathers per nest and female size (SCL), but there was no relationship between number of
231
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
fathers and hatching success. Finally, 195 individual paternal genotypes were identified over the three years.
Each individual male contributed to just one nest throughout the three years of nest sampling. Our findings
suggest that there is a large pool of males contributing to the Wassaw nests. The lack of recurrence of
males may reflect a sampling artifact, males may be transient and mate with the Wassaw Island females in
route to other mating sites, or males may not mate each year.
GENETIC ANALYSIS OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLE HATCHLINGS FROM THE
ALABAMA COAST
Jenny E. Layton1, Jessica Delo1, Miranda Goins1, Rivvi Kukkamalla1, and Thane Wibbels2
1
2
Samford University, Birmingham, AL, USA
The Univ. of Alabama at Birmingham, AL, USA
The loggerhead sea turtle is a protected species that inhabits temperate and tropical waters world-wide. One
of the largest concentrations of loggerhead nesting in the world is in the southeastern U.S. including the
northern Gulf of Mexico. The haplotypes of loggerheads in the southeastern U.S. have been examined in
many locations, but have only received scant attention in Alabama. Therefore, it is of importance to
evaluate the genetic haplotype of hatchlings from the beaches of Alabama to understand how they fit into
the overall population structure of the southeastern U.S. Additionally, the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill
resulted in a wide variety of unprecedented responses implemented to address the impact on ecosystems in
the northern Gulf of Mexico. In order to protect the nests, loggerhead sea turtle eggs were relocated from
the beaches in Alabama to Cape Canaveral National Seashore where the eggs hatched and the hatchings
entered the Atlantic Ocean. A better understanding of the haplotype of loggerheads from Alabama could
help facilitate such strategies in the future. The current study seeks to complement previous studies by
determining the haplotypes of loggerheads nesting in Alabama, and thus verify that they share the same
haplotypes and similar haplotype frequencies as the turtles of the northern Gulf of Mexico recovery unit.
Also, this project verifies that the haplotype frequencies occurring Alabama are similar to those in Cape
Canaveral where the relocated turtles were released. Determining the haplotypes of hatchling loggerheads
from Alabama beaches is valuable to understanding the population structure, movements, and life history
of loggerhead sea turtles. Therefore, such information is valuable to an effective management strategy for
this species. Tissue samples from forty-three hatchling loggerheads were collected over two nesting
seasons as part of a collaborative study with UAB and Bon Secour National Wildlife Refuge. DNA
sequence analysis was conducted on a 380bp fragment of the mitochondrial d-loop control region. The
sequences were compared to haplotype sequences in the Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research
genetics database. The results of this study indicate that haplotypes CCA-1 and CCA-2 occur in hatchlings
from Alabama nesting beaches, with CC-A1 occurring in the majority of the hatchlings sampled. Previous
studies have shown these haplotypes to occur with similar frequency on the mid-Atlantic and northern Gulf
coasts of Florida.
232
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PHOTO-ID AND SNORKELING TRANSECTS: COMPARING TWO METHODS TO ESTIMATE
GREEN TURTLE ABUNDANCE IN A MAJOR FEEDING GROUND IN THE SOUTHERN
EGYPTIAN RED SEA
Agnese Mancini1, Islam El-Sadek2, Mahmoud Hanafy3, and Bénédicte Madon4
1
HEPCA, Hurghada, Egypt
Red Sea Protectorate, Shalateen, Egypt
3
University of Suez Canal, Ismalaia, Egypt
4
Boomerang For Earth Conservation, Antony, France
2
Being able to monitor and assess abundance of marine turtles in their feeding grounds is necessary to
understand trends and evaluate the impact of threats on those populations. However in-water monitoring is
usually costly and estimates can vary according to the technique used. We compared two methods (photoidentification and snorkeling transects) to estimate seasonal variation in population abundance at Marsa
Abu Dabbab, a major feeding ground for green turtles in the Southern Egyptian Red Sea. From September
2011 to August 2012 (excluding December 2011), we conducted monthly snorkeling surveys along fixed
transects. While snorkeling, we counted every visible turtle, estimated the visibility and thus the width of
the belt transect and collected other data on turtles as species, approximate size and gender. We also took
pictures of both sides of the head and the carapace of each turtle observed during each transect. To estimate
the abundance of turtles using the belt-transect method, we simply assumed that the density of turtles in the
surveyed area is the same as in the total bay. We recorded 196 sightings, all green turtles (mean daily
sightings=6.3±2.7, range: 0-11, no of days=31). Mean visibility was 13.0±3.6 m (range: 6-18 m, n=31). We
found that there was no significant correlation between the visibility and the number of observed turtles
(r=0.3494, df=30, p=0.0540). Using the belt-transect method we obtained an average monthly population of
29.8±15.5 turtles (CI 95%: 24.1-35.5). We also found that the relative abundance of green turtles during the
nesting season (n=16, mean=23.7±3.6, CI 95%: 16.4-31.0) is significantly lower than during the nonnesting season (n=15, mean=36.3±3.7, CI 95%: 28.7-43.8)(n=31, df=1, F=5.9818, p=0.0208). As for the
photo-identification method, we used the unique design of the lateral scutes as a natural marker to identify
each new and recaptured individual. We then used closed and open-population capture-mark-recapture
models during the non-nesting season because the population was assumed closed between the months of
October and April. Using package Rcapture in R, the best closed-population models based on the AIC
criteria were models Mth (Chao, Darroch, Poisson and Gamma): under those models the population was
estimated to be between 37.6±2.6 with model Mth Poisson and 46.5±12.4. During the nesting season, an
open-population model was used and population size estimates varied between 12.4 ±0.8 in July 2012 and
29.5±4.7 in May. The two methods gave very close results with an increased population during the nonnesting season. This can be explained as 65% of the green turtles in the bay are sexually mature individuals
that possibly migrate to the breeding grounds during the nesting season. The belt-transect method has the
advantage of being relatively inexpensive and can be used in small areas where turtles are not snorkelerfriendly. The photo-ID method on the other end allows researchers to collect also other information as
individual growth and migrations. We are at present using a combination of the two methods on other 11
feeding grounds to estimate the relative abundance of green turtles in the Egyptian Red Sea waters. We
would like to thank the International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National
Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Defenders of Wildlife,
Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America for providing us with a travel grant to participate in these
meeting.
233
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
BODY SIZE MINIATURIZATION OF LOGGERHEAD SEA TURTLES NESTING ON MINABESENRI BEACH, JAPAN
Yoshimasa Matsuzawa and Kiyoshi Goto
Sea Turtle Association of Japan, Hirakata, Osaka, JAPAN
We measured carapace length of loggerhead sea turtles nesting on Minabe-Senri Beach, Wakayama, Japan
since 1990. The standard straight carapace length (SCL) of the 757 females ranged from 700 to 960 mm.
Annual average of SCL was on a declining trend with yearly fluctuations. Considering that the mean SCL
of 890 mm for 118 females nesting on Kamoda Beach, the nearest rookery in 1972, body size of
loggerhead nesting females in this region seems to decrease consistently in last four decades.
PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF ATLANTIC GREEN TURTLES: INSIGHTS FROM MULTIPLE
GENETIC MARKERS
Eugenia Naro-Maciel1, Brendan Reid2, S. Elizabeth Alter3, George Amato4, Karen A. Bjorndal5, Alan
B. Bolten5, Meredith Martin6, Campbell J. Nairn7, Brian Shamblin7, and Oscar Pineda-Catalan8
1
College of Staten Island CUNY, Staten Island, New York, USA
University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
3
York College CUNY, New York, New York, USA
4
American Museum of Natural History, New York, New York, USA
5
University of Florida, Gainsville, Florida, USA
6
Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
7
University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia, USA
8
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York, USA
2
The interacting effects of past and current processes on population distribution over time constitute an
active research area increasingly central to conservation biology. Despite the species’ globally endangered
status, historical processes leading to the current distribution of highly migratory green sea turtles are
insufficiently understood. Genetic analysis is a powerful tool for uncovering population history and
connectivity, and our aim was to address key remaining questions of Atlantic green turtle phylogeography.
Fifteen nuclear microsatellite loci were genotyped from six Western Atlantic rookeries (n = 301) and
analyzed with respect to published mitochondrial data (n = 1,205) using Bayesian methods. Statistical
analyses revealed two Western Atlantic rookery clusters: southern (Brazil) and northern (USA, Costa Rica,
Surinam, and Venezuela). Genetic differentiation among and within clusters was low but generally
significant, although there was substantive migration between them. Analysis of the two divergent
Atlantic/Mediterranean mitochondrial lineages revealed similar clusters except for Aves and Surinam,
which grouped instead with southern and central rookeries. Analyses indicated these lineages split about
one million years ago. The spatial distribution of multiple genetic markers was consistent with the
historical existence of two glacial refugia. Expansion out of the refugia occurred around the time of the
Last Glacial Maximum or earlier, and was followed by mixing around the central Aves and Surinam
rookeries. This study provides a more complete historical context and refined understanding of population
structure, thus enhancing conservation and recovery efforts for this globally endangered species.
234
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
COMBINED GENETIC ANALYSIS AND DISPERSAL MODELLING REVEAL DIVERSE
NATAL ORIGINS OF GREEN TURTLES FORAGING AT THE PALMYRA ATOLL NATIONAL
WILDLIFE REFUGE, CENTRAL PACIFIC
Eugenia Naro-Maciel1, Stephen J. Gaughran2, Nathan F. Putman3, George Amato2, Felicity Arengo2,
Erin Betley2, Peter H. Dutton4, and Eleanor Sterling2
1
College of Staten Island CUNY, Staten Island, New York, USA
American Museum of Natural History, New York, New York, USA
3
Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon, USA
4
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA, La Jolla, California, USA
2
Population connectivity and spatial distribution are fundamentally related to the ecology, evolution, and
behavior of many species including cryptic marine organisms. In the marine realm the life histories of
diverse taxa are shaped by movements that vary among stages, such as dispersal primarily driven by ocean
currents in younger individuals, and directed migration later in life. Highly migratory and globally
endangered green turtles are important elements of diverse and often distant ecosystems that may be
connected in unknown and surprising ways. Genetic analysis is a powerful tool for investigating marine
turtle connectivity and tracing unknown natal origins of feeding ground populations. However limitations
can include high confidence intervals and incomplete sampling. Simulating hatchling dispersal within an
ocean circulation model is a technique that allows us to generate spatially explicit predictions based on
statistically robust sample sizes (i.e., calculating trajectories for thousands of virtual particles). Our
objective was to combine these methods to determine the unknown natal origins of green turtles foraging at
the Palmyra Atoll National Wildlife Refuge (PANWR), Central Pacific. We extracted hindcast output from
the Global Hybrid Coordinate Ocean Model to examine how surface currents might influence the
probability of green turtles from different nesting beaches reaching the PANWR foraging grounds, and
used particle-tracking software to identify possible migratory corridors juvenile turtles might use to reach
the PANWR. In addition, we used regional analyses of mitochondrial control region sequences from turtles
collected at the PANWR during a five-year period (2008-2012). Genetic analysis revealed widespread
origins ranging from the distant eastern Pacific to closer central Pacific islands. Our modeling results also
indicated that turtles could potentially reach the PANWR via surface currents coming from the eastern,
central, and to a lesser extent western Pacific. The emerging story of diverse PANWR origins contrasts
with the more localized, self-contained Hawaiian green turtle stock, contributing to a complex model of
green turtle dispersal in this region.
INTEGRATING DETECTABILITY AND ABUNDANCE IN ASSESSMENTS OF SEA TURTLE
POPULATION TRENDS
Joseph B. Pfaller1,2, Karen A. Bjorndal2, Milani Chaloupka3, Kristina L. Williams1, Michael G.
Frick2, and Alan B. Bolten2
1
Caretta Research Project, Savannah, Georgia, USA
Archie Carr Center for Sea Turtle Research, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
3
Ecological Modeling Service P/L, University of Queensland, St. Lucia, Queensland, Australia
2
Assessments of population trends based on abundance data alone, without accounting for detectability, can
lead to erroneous conclusions. Population trends of threatened and endangered sea turtles worldwide are
often based on counts of nests or nesting females. We analyze 39 years (1973 to 2011) of nest-count,
235
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
female-count, and capture-mark-recapture (CMR) data for nesting loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta)
on Wassaw Island, Georgia, USA. Annual counts of nests and females, not corrected for detectability, yield
significant, positive trends in abundance, suggesting an increasing nesting population of loggerheads.
Multistate open robust design modeling of CMR data that accounts for changes in detectability, however,
reveals that the annual abundance of nesting females has remained essentially constant throughout the
study period. The dichotomy is primarily a result of methodological improvements incorporated over the
study period that increased detectability and thus the probability of encountering nesting females and nests.
This study is the first comparison of sea turtle population trends that do and do not account for detectability
and demonstrates the potential for serious misinterpretations of data. Past assessments of sea turtle
population trends based exclusively on abundance data should be interpreted with caution and re-evaluated
when possible. These concerns apply equally to a wide range of species, many of which are threatened or
endangered, that are currently monitored with count data not corrected for detectability.
DEVELOPING QUANTITATIVE TOOLS TO EVALUATE RECOVERY IN GREEN SEA
TURTLES, CHELONIA MYDAS: A RESEARCH PROSPECTUS*
Susan E. Piacenza1, George H. Balazs2, Stacy Hargrove3, Paul M. Richards3, and Selina S. Heppell1
1
Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, USA
NOAA Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Honolulu, HI, USA
3
NOAA Southeast Fisheries Science Center, Miami, FL, USA
2
Green sea turtles, Chelonia mydas, have increased dramatically in the Hawaiian Islands and Florida. There
is a need to determine the best tools and practices for incorporating vital rate information into population
models to assess population size and status. These populations provide an opportunity to identify changes
in vital rates (survival, growth and reproduction) that are associated with population growth and recovery.
For the Hawaiian and Florida populations, we ask three main questions. Do key life history traits vary over
time? Which population models are most accurate and reliable? Which management options work best to
maintain population recovery? Data from the NOAA Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center Marine
Turtle Research Program and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Research Institute will be used to determine if
and how life history parameters change over time. The time-variant life-history estimates can be
incorporated into the population models to estimate overall population trajectory and status. We will test a
variety of population models, and use model selection metrics, e.g., Akaike's information Criterion, to
determine which models are appropriate for each population according to their fit to available data. These
new models can be compared to regression models of nests over time to determine if there is an increase in
population size. But, model selection will be more powerful if we can compare model output using multiple
data sources. These include detectable shifts in demographic variables that are linked to adult recruitment,
or size distribution changes in the juvenile population. Recovering populations are useful for model
development because they often show shifts in age structure that are related to changes in vital rates, which
can themselves be linked to management actions. This can reduce uncertainty in model parameterization.
The life-history traits will likely show changes over time, yet the direction of the change may depend on the
history of anthropogenic impacts. For example, a population recovering from harvested adults and
subadults will likely show expanded length-frequency distributions, overall more individuals in each size
class and older size classes. This is a pivotal point in the natural history and conservation of C. mydas.
Understanding how a population is changing as it recovers provides useful ecological and conservation
knowledge that can be applied to other populations and species. By using quantitative methods to examine
long-term data sets, we can find answers to questions about how life history traits have changed over time,
and also which vital rates best indicate population change. Furthermore, we can derive robust nester
population estimates, and ultimately confirm the status of C. mydas populations. Finally, we hope to use the
best-fitting models to understand how these populations may respond to a changing environment and to
identify which management actions will best support the species in the future.
236
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MIGRATION OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) BETWEEN NESTING AND
FEEDING GROUNDS ACROSS THE CORAL SEA
Tyffen C. Read1, Colin J. Limpus2, Laurent Wantiez3, and Jonathan Werry4
1
Aquarium des Lagons, 61 promenade Roger Laroque, 98807,New Caledonia
Aquatic Threatened Species Unit, Queensland Department of Environment and Heritage Protection,PO
Box 2454 City, Qld, 4001
3
Université de la Nouvelle-Calédonie,BP R4,98851 Noumea, New Caledonia
4
Griffith Centre for Coastal Management and School of Environment, Griffith University, Gold Coast
Campus Qld 4222, Australia
2
A review of the data collected over the last 50 years by different projects on the migration of Chelonia
mydas to and from New Caledonia (n=94) indicate that 1) females nesting at D’Entrecasteaux atolls (New
Caledonia) are found in feeding grounds all along the Queensland coast up to Papua New Guinea but also
in New Caledonian waters, and 2) females known to nest in the Great Barrier Reef are found in feeding
grounds located in New Caledonia. Most of the tag recoveries belonged to females part of the south Great
Barrier Reef genetic stock. These females showed fidelity to foraging sites located 2000 km away from the
nesting site located in New Caledonia. Most of the recaptures were done by fishermen that hunt turtles for
food. An extended analysis will be presented of the distances and locations travelled by the individuals,
their sizes and the likelihood of recoveries. Genetic sampling at d’Entrecasteaux will occur in November
2012 and thus results will be available.
GENDER IN A MIXED STOCK GENETIC ANALYSIS OF SUBADULT LOGGERHEAD SEA
TURTLES
Mark A. Roberts1, Michael D. Arendt2, David W. Owens3, and Joseph M. Quattro1
1
Department of Biology, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA
South Carolina Department of Natural Resources, Charleston, SC, USA
3
College of Charleston, Charleston, SC, USA
2
Loggerhead sea turtle mtDNA haplotype data have been used in several previous studies to estimate nesting
beach contributions to mixed feeding assemblages. However, given the known life history differences
between male and female sea turtles, there may exist gender specific nesting beach contributions. Here we
analyze both serum testosterone data and mtDNA haplotype data collected during eight summers spanning
a twelve year period (2000, 2001, 2002, 2004, and 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011) to estimate the temporal
stability of nesting beach contributions to a mixed stock feeding aggregation of loggerhead sea turtles
located along the southeastern coast of the United States. In addition, this unique combination of genetic
and serum testosterone data in subadult sea turtles will allow for a gender specific analysis of nesting beach
contributions to subadult foraging grounds. This gender based approach to mixed stock analyses is
especially critical in sea turtles as nesting rookeries have highly variable sex ratios; not utilizing a gender
based approach can mask the importance of rookeries that would be undervalued based on rookery size
alone. We anticipate overall findings congruent with a previous single-year analysis that demonstrated a
disproportionately large contribution from the nearby nesting populations relative to more distant
populations. Further, we anticipate that the uneven nature of nesting beach gender production will increase
this disproportionate contribution when gender is considered in the mixed stock analysis. These findings
will be discussed in the context of a warming climate further changing the relative importance of nesting
237
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
beach contributions to overall reproductive success, particularly as it relates to the smaller loggerhead
nesting beaches of the northwest Atlantic ocean.
GENETIC SIGNATURE OF POPULATION BOTTLENECKS IN THE OLIVE RIDLEY TURTLE
(LEPIDOCHELYS OLIVACEA) AFTER COMMERCIAL EXPLOITATION IN MEXICO:
IMPLICATIONS FOR CONSERVATION
Clara J. Rodríguez-Zárate1, Axayacatl Rocha-Olivares2, and Luciano B. Beheregaray1
1
Molecular Ecology Laboratory, School of Biological Sciences, Flinders University, Adelaide, South
Australia, Australia
2
Laboratorio de Ecología Molecular, Departamento de Oceanografía Biológica, Centro de Investigación
Científica y de Educación Superior de Ensenada (CICESE), Ensenada Baja California, Mexico
Information on the demographic and genetic consequences of overexploitation, such as human-induced
genetic bottlenecks, are often difficult to detect on ecological time scales. Nesting colonies of Lepidochelys
olivacea in Mexico were severely impacted by a commercial fishery between 1960 and 1990. Although
nesting activity has apparently increased in the last decade, multilocus assessment of the genetic
consequences of the commercial fishery on nesting rockeries are needed. Here we analyzed genetic
variation from ten microsatellite loci of 365 samples representing 18 nesting sites across the Mexican
Pacific coast. We detected population bottlenecks for five nesting areas, providing genetic evidence
compatible with the demographic disequilibria produced by their recent over-exploitation. We also report
on nuclear DNA support for a genetically differentiated management unit in Baja California Peninsula
(FST =0.01, P<0.001) and clarify population structure in other areas. The genetic results reported here are
important for management purposes in Mexico and also contribute nuclear DNA data to challenge the
generally accepted panmixia hypothesis for Olive ridley in the Eastern Pacific.
PREDICTED SEX RATIOS OF JUVENILE GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) ALONG
THE EAST COAST OF FLORIDA, USA
Cheryl Sanchez1, Thane Wibbels2, Llewellyn Ehrhart1, and Michael Bresette3
1
University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL, USA
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA
3
Inwater Research Group Inc., Jensen Beach, FL
2
Temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) has been a fascinating topic to researchers for decades.
Substantial time and effort have been spent on beaches, examining sex ratios of sea turtle hatchlings, in
order to understand the effects of TSD and to gain information about baseline sex ratios being produced in
various regions. Recently the field has gained greater attention in light of climate change predictions. In
addition to hatchling sex ratios, effort has been put into collecting information on juvenile sex ratios. There
are several advantages to sampling the juvenile life stage. Since these developmental areas consist of
multiple age cohorts, a snapshot of the juvenile sex ratio represents a condensation of many years of
hatchling production. Sex ratios of juvenile aggregations will not only provide baseline data on ratios being
represented at this life stage, but will also come into conservation importance as the climate changes. The
objectives of this study were to 1) characterize the sex ratios of multiple juvenile green turtle aggregations
along the coast of Florida, and 2) provide a snapshot comparison of how sex ratios have changed using
238
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
historical data from the 1990s. The three juvenile green turtle aggregations used in this study are found on
the east, central coast of Florida, at the Trident Submarine Basin at Port Canaveral, in the Indian River
Lagoon (IRL) near Sebastian Inlet, and at the Saint Lucie Power Plant on Hutchinson Island. Blood
samples were collected over the course of a year at all locations, then were subject to testosterone analysis
through radioimmunoassay (RIA). A previous study done from 1995-1997, using RIA, demonstrated
extremely female-biased populations at the Trident Basin (5.71 females: 1 male) and in the IRL (5.27
females: 1 male). The IRL has a history of sex ratios going even further back, to 1987, where the calculated
ratio was nearly one female to one male. Objective 2 was addressed by comparing the most recent data to
these previous results using a G-test. By continuously studying the same population over a long period, we
will have a much better understanding of how juvenile sex ratios vary temporally and how they respond to
climate change. This information is critical to an effective conservation effort for the green turtle.
Attendance to the symposium for C. Sanchez was made possible through the International Sea Turtle
Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of
Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics, CLS America, and the International Sea Turtle
Symposium through the Travel Grant.
ANNUAL SURVIVAL OF JUVENILE LOGGERHEADS IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC OCEAN
Christopher R. Sasso and Sheryan P. Epperly
SEFSC, NMFS, Miami, FL, USA
Understanding the mortality of the various life history stages of sea turtles is key to developing population
assessments of protected species. This is especially so for the pelagic stage of juvenile turtles, for which
little such information is available. Juvenile loggerhead sea turtles, captured via dip-net in the North
Atlantic Ocean, were satellite-tagged to assess annual survival: 24 pop-off archival transmitting tags
(PATs) were deployed on 45-60 cm turtles and 13 Mini-PATs were deployed on 30-45 cm turtles. Twentyfour pop-off archival transmitting tags were deployed on 45-60 cm loggerhead turtles and 13 Mini-PATs
were deployed on 30-45 cm loggerhead turtles that had been captured via dip-net in the North Atlantic
Ocean to assess annual survival. A known fate model with the transmission data was used to estimate
annual survival rates and determine if there were differences in survival between the two groups. The best
model of the data suggested there was no difference in survival between the groups and time was constant
across month for both groups.
CATCH RATES, SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION, AND DEMOGRAPHICS FOR KEMP’S RIDLEY
SEA TURTLES (LEPIDOCHELYS KEMPII) CAPTURED IN NEARSHORE COASTAL WATERS
BETWEEN WINYAH BAY, SC AND ST. AUGUSTINE, FL (2000-2012)
Jeffrey A. Schwenter1, Michael D. Arendt1, Albert L. Segars1, J. David Whitaker1, Lindsey Parker2,
David W. Owens3, Joseph M. Quattro4, and Mark A. Roberts4
1
South Carolina Department of Natural Resources – Marine Resources Division, USA
University of Georgia – Marine Extension Service, USA
3
College of Charleston – Grice Marine Laboratory, USA
4
University of South Carolina, South Carolina, USA
2
Since 2000, the National Marine Fisheries Service has funded and permitted a regional sea turtle trawl
survey from South Carolina to northern Florida. Key metrics for loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) in
239
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
this survey have recently been reported. Here, we present temporal and spatial catch rate trends for Kemp’s
ridley (Lepidochelys kempii) sea turtles. Between 2000–2003 and 2008–2012, research trawlers sampled
5,151 stations and captured 164 Kemp’s ridley from May-August. A maximum of three Kemp’s ridley
were captured in a single event and most positive catch events consisted of just one Kemp’s ridley. Spatial
analysis revealed that 10% of sampling events were associated with hot spots and captured 53% (n = 87) of
Kemp’s ridley. Three percent of sampling events were associated with cold spots and resulted in no
Kemp’s ridley captures. Temporal catch trends were examined using a generalized linear model for a
subset of sampling events (4,489) with complete environmental data (21 total variables) in which 150
Kemp’s ridley were captured. Kemp’s ridley catch per sampling event was fit to a negative binomial
distribution to examine catch trends. Four model terms accounted for 24% of total data set deviance. Year
explained 9% of data set deviance due to 46% of positive catch events and 52% of captured individuals
having occurred during 2011-2012. Mean water depth during the trawl and distance from shore accounted
for 8% and 3% of data set deviance, respectively. Subregion accounted for 4% of data set deviance.
Kemp’s ridley were captured across the latitudinal sampling range; however positive catches were greatest
south of Savannah, Georgia and decreased northward along the South Carolina coast. Kemp’s ridley sea
turtles captured in this survey ranged in size from 23.1 to 63.4 cm straight carapace length (SCLmin), but
94% were <60 cm SCLmin. Recent catch increases have also favored smaller Kemp’s ridley, with 58% (29
of 50) of individuals ≤35 cm SCLmin captured since 2011, consistent with neritic recruitment following
exponentially increased nesting in the Gulf of Mexico in the past five years. Testosterone
radioimmunoassay suggests that Kemp’s ridley sea turtles captured in this survey are predominantly
female; however, validation through laparoscopy has not been conducted. Genetic analyses have
documented four distinct haplotypes, but are dominated by the haplotype LK-1. Sex and genetic data for
samples collected in 2012 (~one-third of genetic samples collected in this survey to date) are pending, but
will be included in this presentation. The long-term trends reported here represent important missing pieces
for Kemp’s ridley management in the southeast United States. Continued nesting increases at primary
nesting beaches in Mexico foreshadow continued Kemp’s ridley catch increases along the Atlantic coast.
As such, we anticipate further opportunity to monitor catch rates and to develop analytical partnerships for
Kemp’s ridley on par with those that currently exist for loggerhead sea turtles in our survey. Moreover,
concurrent collection of sex ratio and genetic haplotype data will provide crucial insight regarding
demographics in this critical habitat for developing juvenile Kemp’s ridley.
DEMOGRAPHIC ISOLATION AND COLONIZATION OF SOUTHERN GREATER
CARIBBEAN GREEN TURTLE ROOKERIES WITH AN EMPHASIS ON FEMALES NESTING
ON BUCK ISLAND, UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Brian M. Shamblin1, Ian Lundgren2, Zandy M. Hillis-Starr2, Karen A. Bjorndal3, Alan B. Bolten3,
Eugenia Naro-Maciel4, and Campbell J. Nairn5
1
Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA and current:
NOAA-NMFS Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, CA, USA
2
National Park Service, Buck Island Reef National Monument, Christiansted, United States Virgin Islands,
USA
3
Archie Carr Center of Sea Turtle Research and Department of Biology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
FL, USA
4
College of Staten Island, City University of New York, Staten Island, NY, USA
5
Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA
Genetic tools have proven valuable for inferring demographic partitioning among nesting populations as
well as estimating rookery contributions to mixed foraging aggregations. However, extensive genetic
marker sharing can confound inferences of demographic connectivity and colonization pathway hypotheses
as well as introduce uncertainty into rookery contribution estimates for mixed stock analyses when
haplotypes are based on short control region sequences. We tested the utility of mitogenomic variable
240
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
positions combined with mitochondrial microsatellite repeat (mtSTR) sequences to reassess the genetic
structure of four green turtle rookeries in the southern Greater Caribbean region that share common 490
base pair haplotype CM-A5 at high frequency: Tortuguero, Costa Rica; Galibi, Suriname; Aves Island,
Venezuela; and Buck Island, St. Croix, United States Virgin Islands. We further explored potential
colonization scenarios through genotyping nesting females representing the small but increasing Buck
Island rookery at 50 microsatellite loci to determine pairwise relatedness. We previously demonstrated
through sequencing of mitogenomic variable positions that CM-A5 actually represents at least four distinct
lineages partitioned among regional rookeries, with CM-A5.1.2 accounting for nearly all CM-A5 females
nesting at Tortuguero, CM-A5.2 occurring primarily in the Aves Island rookery, and CM-A5.1.3 shared at
high frequency between Buck Island and Aves Island. Haplotype CM-A5.1.1 was inferred as ancestral
based on its central position in the haplotype network incorporating the novel mitogenomic variable
positions. CM-A5.1.1 was the only CM-A5 subhaplotype recovered for the Galibi rookery and occurred in
the other three rookeries as well, supporting the hypothesis that the CM-A5 lineage has colonized
northward and westward from the coast of South America. We revisited the structure of these rookeries
through sequencing of mtSTR loci previously shown to be highly polymorphic in the Mediterranean green
turtle aggregation. The four mitogenomic CM-A5 haplotypes were further subdivided into 20 mtSTR
haplotypes. CM-A5.1.1 was subdivided into 11 mtSTR haplotypes that were strongly partitioned among
rookeries. Two mtSTR haplotypes were shared between Suriname and Buck Island that were not detected
among the sampled Aves Island females, evoking the possibility of colonization from quite distant rather
than proximal rookeries. Over 60% of the CM-A5.1.1 Buck Island nesters carried an mtSTR haplotype
unique to this rookery. CM-A5.1.3 was subdivided into three haplotypes, with 66% of the Buck Island
nesters carrying a haplotype not detected in the Aves Island sample. The mtSTR results reinforce
inferences of pairwise relatedness generated from 50 microsatellite loci for the Buck Island nesting females.
Nearly half of all tagged nesting females were assigned to just two maternal clusters, each of which carried
an STR haplotype unique to Buck Island. These results suggest that colonization of novel nesting habitats
may occur from close and distant source rookeries, and that rookeries can increase rapidly through
recruitment of daughters from a small number of successful nesting females. Although genetic studies
typically focus on large rookeries, deep sampling of recovering and nascent rookeries may yield additional
insights into the colonization process and how marine turtles will adapt in the face of global climate change.
CLUTCH FREQUENCY AND NUMBER OF NESTING LOGGERHEADS (CARETTA CARETTA)
AT THE ARCHIE CARR NATIONAL WILDLIFE SANCTUARY DURING THE 2010, 2011 AND
2012 SEASONS*
Andrew T. Sterner1, Llewellyn M. Ehrhart1, William L. Kendall2, and Dean A. Bagley1
1
University of Central Florida, Orlando, FL, USA
USGS Colorado Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Fort Collins, CO, USA, Colorado State
University Fort Collins, CO, USA
2
Concerns over the status of loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta) populations in the United States have
been raised due to a dramatic decrease in nest production between 1998 and 2004. These concerns
generated renewed interest in vital demographic rates on nesting beaches (clutch frequency, number of
nesting females, annual survival, remigration interval, etc.) that drive nest production but to date have not
been well understood. Many of these values can be generated through the analysis of mark-recapture data
from nesting females on beaches such as the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge using modern markrecapture statistical methods. Data for this presentation were collected during the 2010, 2011 (completed)
and 2012 (ongoing) loggerhead nesting seasons at the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge, Florida, USA.
Analysis of the 2010 and 2011 loggerhead nesting data has been completed using Open Robust Design
(ORD) models in program MARK. Each annual data set was formatted as a single season and run through a
basic set of models created by manipulating three sets of parameters (pent, phi and p). These three elements
are informative in their own right (indicating the structure of arrivals: pent; probability of renesting: phi;
241
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
and detection probability: p) but they can also be used to derive estimates of residence time (number of
clutches per female) and N (number of nesting females) during each of the two seasons in question.
Detection probabilities (p) for both seasons were low (~15-20%), leading to uncertainty as to whether such
analysis would produce viable results. Program Release was run through program MARK for both years
and indicated good fit of the models to the data. The model-averaged estimate of population size (N) for the
2010 season is 2,167 (95% CI: 1,558-2,775) and it is 2,515 for the 2011 season (95% CI: 935-4,097).
Model-averaged residence time (number of nesting attempts per female) is 5.53 for the 2010 (95% CI: 5.25.9) data and 3.69 for 2011(95% CI: 1.85-5.54). Analysis of the 2012 data is forthcoming and will be
included in the presentation. Results of these analyses show that important variation in number of clutches
per female exists between years at the Archie Carr National Wildlife Refuge. Acknowledgments: I would
like to thank all of the sponsors of the travel grant (International Sea Turtle Society, U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service, U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, Ecoteach, Defenders of Wildlife, Sea Turtle Conservancy,
Defenders of Wildlife, Lotek, Sirtrack, Telonics and CLS America) and the International Sea Turtle Society
for their support in providing my lodging while in Baltimore making it possible for me to attend the
meeting.
VARIATIONS IN THE OPERATIONAL SEX RATIO FOR BREEDING LEATHERBACK
TURTLES (DERMOCHELYS CORIACEA) OVER THREE NESTING SEASONS AT ST. CROIX,
USVI.
Kelly R. Stewart and Peter H. Dutton
Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, California, USA
For marine turtles, the adult breeding sex ratio, or the operational sex ratio (OSR) is important to know for
population modeling purposes as well as for monitoring the status of a population. Previously we
demonstrated that for leatherback turtles in St. Croix (USVI), there were as many males as females in a
given year that were actively breeding. In 2010, we found that for 46 females (a subset of the nesting
females that year), there were 47 males that had been actively breeding with those turtles. We expanded
this study to look at OSR over multiple years to A) determine if operational sex ratios changed from year to
year, B) to identify males that may have been breeding yearly and C) to complete a male census for this
nesting population. Since we had already evaluated male turtles for the 2010 nesting season, we looked at
the OSR for 2009 and 2011 at St. Croix. To do so, we genetically fingerprinted nesting females and their
hatchlings using 7 polymorphic microsatellite markers. Then with GERUD1.0, we were able to identify
fathers for each of the hatchlings and infer male genetic fingerprints. In 2009, we evaluated 1051 hatchlings
from 99 females and in 2011 we fingerprinted 755 hatchlings belonging to 65 females. Over the 3 years of
the study we found that the male to female ratio remained fairly stable at nearly 1:1 and changed only
marginally over the time frame. We found that a few males that had mated in all 3 years, some that mated
in 2 years and more commonly, we found that most males had mated in just one year. It should be noted
that just because a male was not identified in the genotypes of the hatchlings, it should not be inferred that
the male was not at the nesting grounds attempting to mate. We have now identified 190 individual males
at this nesting rookery, thus providing a census of the breeding males in this population. It is now possible
to monitor the breeding activity of male turtles at any nesting ground and this work shows the potential for
evaluating male reproductive success or fitness, as well as quantifying the annual nesting population of
males and females.
242
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
ESTIMATES OF LOGGERHEAD CLUTCH FREQUENCY AT MASIRAH, OMAN DERIVED
FROM SATELLITE TRACKING
Anton D. Tucker1, Robert Baldwin2, Andrew Willson2, Ali Al-Kiyumi2, Barbara Schroeder3, Earl
Possardt4, and Blair Witherington5
1
Mote Marine Laboratory, Sarasota, Florida, USA
Environmental Society of Oman , Muscat, Oman
3
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Silver Spring, Maryland, USA
4
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Division of International Conservation, Arlington, Virginia, USA
5
Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Melbourne,
Florida, USA
2
Oman hosts the largest loggerhead nesting aggregations in the Indian Ocean. The historical track-count
surveys for reliable estimates of loggerhead abundance date from 1977-79 and 1991. Based on these
surveys, an estimated 20 to 40 thousand females have nested annually on Masirah Island. An untested but
key assumption to interpret the Masirah track counts was adoption of a clutch frequency value of 4.0 nests
per female a year. Particularly at remote rookeries, for animals with unknown site fidelity, or for high
density nesting sites, it may be impractical to determine clutch frequency from verified observations of all
nesting events such as attempted during saturation tagging projects. Estimates of annual nesting numbers at
Masirah depended upon extrapolations from limited counts of nesting attempts and upon tagging of nesting
turtles, with corrections for partial effort. More recent efforts have developed interagency partnerships to
better quantify the status of the Masirah rookery, recognized as one of two significant loggerhead rookeries
at an international level. With up to 80 nesting attempts per km / night at the peak of the nesting season and
over 60 km of nesting habitat involved, it was not feasible to reliably distinguish remigrants from newly
tagged females at this population, despite a tagging program using flipper tags and PIT tags. We therefore
attempted to derive estimates of site fidelity and clutch frequencies for females sampled by satellite
telemetry at Masirah. Satellite transmitters were applied to females early in the 2010 to 2012 seasons to
catch the first nesting females of the season and account for inter-annual variability in nest production.
Masirah females during the internesting period are often sedentary near the island which complicates the
identification of subsequent nesting emergences from characteristics of the satellite transmissions. Even so,
preliminary estimates derived by satellite telemetry yielded a mean annual clutch frequency of 5.5 (n=4),
5.2 (n=18), and 5.8 (n=12) clutches per female from those seasons. An overall mean was 5.5. nests (SD =
0.87, range of 4-7 nests). Satellite telemetry provided improved measurements of site fidelity and suggests
a need for revised fecundity estimates. A review of track count data from standardized surveys of recent
nesting seasons on Masirah (2008-2012) is currently in progress. It is intended that a combination of new
surveys augmented by satellite telemetry would yield a more accurate interpretation of recent and historical
records to yield crucial population trends. A revised status assessment would be based upon new data from
current nesting activity and recent clutch frequency data. The Masirah loggerhead population will soon be
re-evaluated from comparisons of the early and recent surveys (taking into account differences in
methodological approaches), and whether overall trends are apparent for the nesting population (a temporal
difference).
243
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
IS THE MAJOR FLORIDA LOGGERHEAD ROOKERY IN THE GULF OF MEXICO
EXPERIENCING DECADAL POPULATION OSCILLATIONS?
Anton D. Tucker1, Kristen Mazzarrella1, Sarah Hirsch1, Kathy Klingensmith1, Wilma Katz2, Zoe
Bass2, Carol Leonard2, Jerris Foote3, George Tatge3, Jim Grimes3, Howard Berna3, Matthew
Osterhoudt3, Kim Heuberger3, Kenya Leonard3, Chance Steed3, and Jennifer Rogers3
1
Mote Marine Laboratory, Sarasota, Florida, USA
Coastal Wildlife Club, Englewoood, Florida, USA
3
Sarasota County Community Services, Sarasota, Florida, USA
2
The Southwest Florida rookery is a unique genetic entity within the Northwest Atlantic loggerhead regional
management unit. Six barrier islands of Sarasota County in Southwest Florida collectively host the highest
density (peaks of 100-200 nests/km) of loggerhead nesting within the Gulf of Mexico. Monitoring of these
islands (Longboat Key, Lido Key, Siesta Key, Casey Key, Venice Beach, and Manasota Key) has been
conducted systematically over three decades, revealing strong annual fluctuations in nest counts. The 2012
season concluded with the highest level of recorded activities since systematic monitoring began.
Preliminary totals of 4616 loggerhead nests and 42 green nests are both new records. Each island has its
own unique features and history. Several of the islands have had a series of beach nourishments and the
extent of coastal development varies, with the least developed islands having higher nesting densities.
However, nest count fluctuations appear unrelated to displacement from erosion hotspots or recently
nourished beaches. While green turtle trends have increased steadily from 1994 to 2012, loggerhead nesting
has oscillated on the same nesting beaches. Loggerhead numbers increased from 1991 to 1998, declined
from 1998 to 2007, and increased from 2007 to 2012. Evidence of alternating periods of population
increase, decline, and increase appear at first glance to agree with a hypothesis that North Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillations are influential as drivers of annual loggerhead nesting activity. However, the present
monitoring study found that the most extreme fluctuations had occurred within a five-year time span - less
than the predicted time scale, from a low of 1592 nests in 2007 to a record high of 4616 nests in 2012. It is
tempting to speculate beyond these data, but future years of monitoring are needed to discriminate whether
a predicted decadal period has shortened substantially (a frequency shift), or whether the increasing trend
will continue through the remainder of the predicted decade (an amplitude shift). Among the associated
factors that warrant further study are shifts of immigration among rookeries, generational time lags
associated with fluctuations in hatchling productivity or primary sex ratios, changes in female remigration
periods, variability in female per capita reproductive output, and variable time frames for mortality and
recruitment.
244
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
EVIDENCE OF RECOVERY OF THE ARRIBADA OLIVE RIDLEY POPULATION AT
NANCITE BEACH, COSTA RICA
Roldán A. Valverde1, Luis G. Fonseca2, Carlos M. Orrego3, and Wagner Quirós4
1
Department of Biological Sciences, Southeastern Louisiana University, Hammond, Louisiana 70402 USA
Instituto Internacional en Conservación y Manejo de Vida Silvestre, Universidad Nacional, Apdo. 13503000 Heredia, Costa Rica
3
Área de Conservación Tempisque, Ministerio de Ambiente, Energía y Telecomunicaciones, San José,
Costa Rica
4
International Student Volunteers, Edificio Plaza Victoria. Oficina # 12, Heredia, Costa Rica
2
Nancite beach, located on the northwest Pacific coast of Costa Rica, was one of the first two olive ridley
arribada rookeries to be discovered in 1970. Since then, various studies have monitored the abundance of
ridley turtles in each of the arribada events over the years. Early data showed a robust population with
individual arribadas amounting to an average of 194,250 individuals for the period 1981-84. Since the early
1980s, however, the population has undergone a significant decline with more recent numbers indicating a
collapse in the population. Early speculations suggested that this population decline was due to the very
low hatching rate that this rookery has exhibited since its original discovery, which resulted from the poor
incubation microenvironment from many broken eggs when the population is elevated. This gave rise to the
hypothesis that arribada rookeries undergo natural population cycles in which, during a crash, nest
destruction is significantly reduced thus promoting a healthier incubation microenvironment with a
subsequent increase in hatchling production. Greater hatchling input into the marine ecosystem would then
result in increased recruitment to the adult population, strengthening the nesting population. We report here
preliminary evidence supporting the natural cycles hypothesis based on our long term dataset collected at
Nancite beach. To address the hypothesis we have collected data on arribada abundance at this beach for
the period 1970 to present, including published accounts and our own data. Our data on arribada abundance
was collected mainly using the instantaneous count or transect method, which allows the estimation of the
number of effective females that nest during arribadas. In addition to this, we have nearly continuously
monitored hatching rates at this beach since 2007. To do this, we marked a number of nests each arribada
and tracked the fate of the each after every mass nesting event. We then compared our data with the
historical dataset for this beach. With regard to the trend in the arribada population our numbers indicate
that since 1970 the population has undergone a reduction of 90%, reaching its lowest point in the mid
1990s and then again around the year 2000. Since then, however, the population has remained stable,
exhibiting an average of 23,900 turtles per year since 2007. Along with this, our numbers show that annual
hatching rates average 70% since 2007, compared with 17.04% for the period 1981-84. We do not know
whether the increased hatching rates will actually result in an increase in the population because life stagespecific mortality is unknown for this population. However, assuming that mortality rates are not
significantly detrimental and that these hatching rates will remain elevated for the next 2 or 3 decades, it is
conceivable that the Nancite population may rebound within the next few decades after that. Only the long
term monitoring of this population will help elucidate the power and appropriateness of the arribada life
cycle hypothesis.
245
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MIXED STOCK ANALYSIS OF LEATHERBACK TURTLES FEEDING IN BRAZIL: RECORDS
OVER FOUR YEARS
Sarah Vargas1, Érica Molfetti2, Sibelle Torres Vilaça3, Danielle Monteiro4, Sérgio C. Estima4,
Luciano Soares e Soares5, Antônio P. Almeida5, Benoit de Thoisy6, Eugenia Naro-Maciel7, and
Fabrício R. Santos2
1
Laboratório de Biodiversidade e Evolução Molecular, ICB, UFMG, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.,
Departamento de Ciências Biológicas, CCHN, UFES, Vitória, ES, Brazil
2
Laboratório de Biodiversidade e Evolução Molecular, ICB, UFMG, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil
3
Department of Biology and Evolution, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy
4
Núcleo de Educação e Monitoramento Ambiental, NEMA, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
5
Fundação TAMAR, Praia do Forte, BA, Brazil
6
Association Kwata, French Guiana
7
College of Staten Island, City University of New York, USA
The population of leatherback turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) nesting in Brazil is restricted to very few
individuals, regularly nesting on the coast of the Espírito Santo State. However, a larger feeding
aggregation occurs throughout Brazilian waters, with higher concentration off the south and southeast
coasts. The objectives of this study are to estimate the contribution of source rookeries to a Brazilian
feeding ground using population genetic measures and Mixed Stock Analysis (MSA), to describe the
haplotypes found for two previously genetic undescribed rookeries: Gabon and Guadeloupe/Martinique, to
increase the number of samples from Brazilian and French Guianan rookeries and to compare the data
obtained with previous reports. To compare the sequences between leatherbacks from Brazil and elsewhere,
we analyzed 496 bp of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) control region from leatherbacks stranded on beaches
(n=90) and incidentally caught by fisheries in Brazilian waters (n=9) from January 2004 to December 2007.
We also analyzed samples of nesting females from a rookery in Gabon (n=23) and from two rookeries in
Guadaloupe and Martinica (n=29) and additional samples from rookeries in French Guiana (n=29) and
Brazil (n=14). The MSA was run using haplotypes from the pelagic leatherbacks (n=99) and from 15
rookeries found worldwide from previously reports (overall n=386). Information from the literature
regarding the number of females nesting per year in each population was used as a prior. An overall of 14
different haplotypes were described using the entire database. The most common haplotype, called A was
found in 171 samples (44,30%). This haplotype was spread across all rookeries except for the Pacific coast
of Mexico and Costa Rica. The haplotype A2, found for the first time only at the foraging area in Brazil,
now was also found in samples in rookeries from Brazil and Gabon. Two new haplotypes (A5 e C3) were
found in this study, both in samples from French Guiana. For the MSA, all chains consistently indicated a
major contribution to the Brazilian pelagic aggregate from Gabon (77,7%), the largest populations of
leatherback in the world. Efforts should be done in order to produce longer mtDNA and nuclear sequences
in widespread worldwide samples to improve the confidence of data in phylogeography and MSA.
Furthermore, MSA studies provide relevant data connecting nesting and feeding sites, and it is also
important information for planning management strategies aiming to enhance conservation efforts
worldwide. Acknowledgments: FAPES, Capes, CNPq, Fapemig and ISTS Program Committee
246
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
INDIVIDUAL IDENTIFICATION OF GREEN TURTLES (CHELONIA MYDAS) USING THE
PARIETAL AND INTERPARIETAL SCALE PATTERN
Amanda W. Vidal, Suzana M. Guimarães, and Cassiano Monteiro-Neto
Universidade Federal Fluminense, Niteroi, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Individual identification is an important tool in ecological and behavioral studies. Photo-identification
techniques have been used to estimate population parameters of aquatic mammals, but have seldom been
used in other marine animal groups. In sea turtles, individuals are marked and identified through the use of
metal tags, but recent studies indicated that photo-identification of facial scale patterns may be reliable for
identifying and marking individuals in a population. This study aimed to validate the identification of
individuals of Chelonia mydas, using the parietal and interparietal scale pattern. Data were collected by
monitoring the beach seine fisheries between August 2008 and May 2012 at Itaipu beach, Niteroi, Rio de
Janeiro, Brazil. Green turtles incidentally caught by fishers were measured and photographed in the head,
where the parietal and interparietal scales are located. The number of parietal and interparietal scales
ranged from one to five scales. Scales also differed in form. These characteristics were used as criteria for
assessing whether a photographed individual was a new capture or a recapture. We photographed 163 green
turtles, out of which 68 were tagged with metal tags. We recaptured 49 animals, 20 identified with metal
tags. To validate the photo-identification method, a double-blind test was applied using volunteers for the
study. We selected one capture and one recapture photograph of 12 animals that also received metal tags
adding up to 24 pictures. Each picture was assigned a randomly selected number to avoid biased
identification either by the test applicator or the volunteer. Photos were randomly grouped into pairs and
showed to volunteers to respond whether the photos were of the same individual or not. A total of 56 tests
(one test for each volunteer) were applied, totaling 672 samples (responses). Chi-square tests were
performed, to look at significant differences between right and wrong answers, types of wrong answers
(false positive and false negative) and between right, false positive and false negative answers. In all tests
the null hypothesis of equal frequencies was rejected. Correct answers accounted for 92% of the responses.
Incorrect answers were 100% false positive. Results of the last Chi-Square test were redundant with 92% of
right and 8% of false positive answers. This study indicated that photo-identification of individual Chelonia
mydas using the distribution pattern of parietal and interparietal scales is a very reliable method not
subjected to losses by deterioration, and do not interfere with animal health like artificial marks.
Social, Economic and Cultural Studies
FROM SEA TURTLES TO REEFS: COMMUNITY-BASED MARINE CONSERVATION AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH THE COMMUNITY OF FALALOP, ULITHI ATOLL,
FEDERATED STATES OF MICRONESIA
Nicole L. Crane1, Jennifer A. Cruce2, and John Rulmal3
1
Oceanic Society, San Francisco and Cabrillo College, Aptos California
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Guam National Wildlife Refuge
3
Ulithi Marine Turtle Program, Ulithi, Yap State, FSM
2
Coral reefs around the world are suffering from multiple stressors, affecting the ecological integrity of coral
systems, and the livelihoods of people who rely on them. In the summer of 2012, a reef conservation
247
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
project was initiated at the request of the community of Falalop, Ulithi Atoll to address a need to work with
small autonomously governed communities to strengthen their capacity to manage their coral reefs and
associated resources to enhance sustainability during a time of rapid ecological change. This project
partnered with and followed the successful efforts of an on-going community-based conservation project,
the Ulithi Marine Turtle Program (UMTP), sponsored by The Oceanic Society. As a result of the UMTP,
the community wanted to expand their conservation efforts to include reef and resource conservation. Ulithi
Atoll, located approximately 185 kilometers northeast of Yap Proper, is home to several “Turtle Islands”,
of which five are identified as significant green turtle nesting sites by the local people. Nesting turtle
monitoring fieldwork has been conducted as part of the UMTP on two of these turtle islands: Gielop Island
(1991, 2005 through 2011), and Loosiep Island (2008 through 2011). Community ownership and ongoing
support of the UMTP, as well as direct involvement in project management and data collection has led to
the success of the project. In line with this effort, the reef survey project worked closely with the
community and traditional leaders, and used an approach that included both social science (interview and
numerous community meetings) and quantitative ecological assessments (reef surveys and specimen
analysis) to develop recommendations to the community. Community members were trained to continue
collecting data throughout the year to inform their own management plan. This approach closely followed
the model of the UMTP, where community ‘field technicians’ collect critical sea turtle data. A key part of
this approach was to hold educational meetings and explain the ecology of what the science team learned,
so community members would understand (for example) the impact of herbivorous fishes on reef ecology
and health, and why certain changes to the community’s resource extraction methods and patterns may help.
Recommendations were provided to resource owners and stakeholders to create their own plan based on
what would work best within their cultural and decision making/enforcement framework. The traditional
leaders implemented a locally managed marine area (LMMA) that was larger in scope and more
comprehensive than what was initially recommended. As a result of the work on Falalop, traditional leaders
have requested assistance to develop an atoll-wide plan (fourth largest atoll in the world). In addition, other
islands in the Yap neighboring island chain are requesting assistance to create a similar program on their
islands. This represents a unique and timely opportunity to advance marine conservation across the western
Pacific.
STUDYING SEA TURTLE VOLUNTEERS IN NORTH CAROLINA, USA
Matthew H. Godfrey1, Lisa M. Campbell2, and Nicholas Mallos3
1
NC Wildlife Resources Commission, Beaufort, NC USA
Nicholas School of Environment, Duke University Marine Lab, Beaufort, NC USA
3
Ocean Conservancy, Washington, DC USA
2
Volunteers participate as monitors and data-collectors in many sea turtle conservation projects in the US
and elsewhere. However, there have been few formal studies of sea turtle volunteers, their demographics,
motivations and concerns. In 2009, we conducted a survey of 700 people who volunteer with the North
Carolina Sea Turtle Project, in collaboration with the state’s Wildlife Resources Commission. Volunteer
characteristics and motives are described, as are their attitudes to some elements of program management.
Results show volunteers share similar demographic characteristics (mostly female, retired, over the age of
60, with higher than average levels of education and income) and are highly motivated to conserve sea
turtles and the environment in general. Social goals and contributing to science were less important motives
than other categories. Although volunteers are generally positive about the state agency coordinating the
work, and believe the data they collect are used, the majority is uncertain about how data are used. We
consider what the results imply for volunteer programs in general and for the overall health of the particular
project and ways to improve its management.
248
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
PERCEPTION OF FISHING COMMUNITIES ON SEA TURTLE POPULATIONS IN THREE
NATURAL PROTECTED AREAS SINALOA, MEXICO
Zuleika B. González Camacho1, Ingmar Sosa-Cornejo1, Jorge Guillermo Sanchez-Zazueta1,
Fernando Enciso-Saracho2, Marco A. Barraza-Ortega2, and Jesús Ivan Guardado-González3
1
Escuela de Biología Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa
Facultad de Ciencias del mar Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa
3
H. ayuntamiento de Elota Sinaloa Mexico
2
Since ancient times, sea turtles in Mexico have been utilized by humans as a source of protein (meat and
eggs), medicine, décor, and ceremonial jewelry. To assess the current state of turtle utilization in Sinaloa,
Mexico we surveyed the residents of fishing communities that operate in the waters of three protected
natural areas, particularly because there is evidence of mortality caused by anthropogenic activities on
turtles from these areas. The results show that 75% had utilized sea turtles recently or in the past, and 25%
had never utilized turtles. Turtles are utilized by 41% of consumers because they preferred the meat and by
3% of consumers because they profited from catching turtles.
PERCEPTIONS, PARTICIPATION AND POACHING: IDENTIFYING THE DRIVERS BEHIND
ILLEGAL SEA TURTLE USE IN COMMUNITIES ADJACENT TO CAHUITA NATIONAL
PARK, COSTA RICA
Katharine A. Hart
Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK
The aim of this research was to identify the drivers underpinning illegal harvest of sea turtles and their eggs
by residents of communities adjacent to Cahuita National Park on the Caribbean coast of Costa Rica. In
2009, representatives from three adjacent communities at varying geographical distance from the National
Park: Cahuita town, Hone Creek and Playa Negra were interviewed using semi-structured face-to-face
interviews, designed to obtain information regarding perceptions of sea turtles and management of the
National Park. Questions also elicited responses related to use of sea turtles through consumptive and nonconsumptive use. Factors identified as influencing poaching behaviour were economic drivers, perceived
legitimacy and awareness of regulations, governance, personal morality, and socio-cultural norms. In
communities where income levels are variable and unreliable, such as Hone Creek and Playa Negra,
economic factors were identified as the major drivers of poaching behaviour. This was due to the
consumptive value of illegal trade in sea turtle eggs as a source of income. Conversely, the key driver
behind sea turtle use in Cahuita town was found to be non-consumptive through economic gain from turtleassociated tourism and social influence, resulting in high levels of compliance towards National Park
regulations. Lack of awareness of sea turtle conservation regulations was recognised as a key factor driving
behaviour in all of the communities surveyed, influencing personal morals and perceived legitimacy of
regulations. Future management strategies should strive to involve local communities in sea turtle
conservation practice as a means of enhancing voluntary compliance towards regulations. Awareness
raising campaigns through educational workshops in all communities associated with the National Park is
recommended. These should be interactive, enabling open communication and transparency of information
between all stakeholder groups and institutional levels, to facilitate change and progress towards both
ecological and socio-economic viability of sea turtle conservation within Cahuita National Park.
249
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
U.S. SHRIMP INDUSTRY ADOPTION OF TURTLE EXCLUDER DEVICES (TED)—OVER A
DECADE LATER: CASE STUDIES FROM TED RESEARCH IN GULF OF MEXICO AND U.S.
SOUTH ATLANTIC
Troy W. Hartley and Michel A. Nalovic
Virginia Institute of Marine Science, USA
The adoption of Turtle Excluder Devices (TEDs) in the U.S. shrimp trawl fishery in the late 1980s/early
1990s was marred by litigation, civil disobedience as shrimp fishermen blocked harbors, legislative actions
by states and the U.S. Congress, and public relations campaigns against the “trawler elimination devices”
or TEDs. Sociological studies in the early 1990s identified a suite of socio-economic factors that
contributed to the resistance among U.S. Gulf of Mexico shrimp fishermen to TEDs: forced innovation;
economic hardship of industry from imported shrimp and loss of catch from TEDs; perception of turtle
bycatch problem; perceptions of the TED’s effectiveness; interagency conflicts; and uncertainty in
enforcement. Nonetheless since the 1990s, existing TED designs and regulations have been improved and a
variety of new rigid and soft TEDs introduced. For example, in 1994 a TED modification was approved
enabling leatherbacks to escape from small grid TEDs. A 1998 introduction of a new soft-TED, the Parker
TED preceded the 2003 release of larger TED escape openings to improve the exclusion of leatherback
turtles and adult loggerheads and green turtles. The double-cover escape opening was introduced,
consisting of two mesh flaps covering the escape hole, providing enhanced turtle exclusion as well as
improved shrimp retention. In this study, we report on preliminary findings from the social, economic and
cultural studies component of case studies in collaborative research with U.S. shrimp trawl fishermen in
Georgia (South Atlantic), Texas, Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi (Gulf of Mexico). Interviews were
conducted with a dozen captains, crew, NOAA Fisheries scientists, and fisheries extension staff, from
April—August, 2012. Interviews were conducted in offices, on fishing docks and buildings, over the phone,
and on fishing vessels during collaborative research on new TED designs. Findings are presented in
comparison to fishermen attitudes about TED adoption from the early 1990s—while some factors seem less
important today (e.g., interagency conflict, uncertainty in enforcement, forced innovation), others have
evolved in significant ways. For example, in the summer of 2012 perceptions of TED’s effectiveness still
plague the industry overall, although loss of catch concerns can be associated with a lack of awareness and
capacity in industry of how to install, maintain, and operate TEDs effectively. Additional operational
inefficiencies (e.g., fuel costs, regulatory mandates) and market forces (e.g., imports) continue to demand
greater productivity from fishing operations and lessen available time to experiment with innovative gear
and fishing practices. There have been unintended positive consequences of TED adoption, including
removal of other larger, troublesome bycatch species (e.g., rays, sharks) that can reduce the quality of the
shrimp catch. Further collaborative research with NOAA scientists directly on fishing vessels and improved
visualization and research tools (e.g., underwater video of trawl performance) has increased the credibility
of TEDs and the science to develop new TED designs. Thus, while barriers to TED adoption continue to
exist and have evolved from the challenges of the late 1980s/early 1990s, additional opportunities have
emerged to overcome these barriers.
250
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
KNOWLEDGE OF BEACHGOERS TO THE PRESENCE OF AND THREATS TO SEA
TURTLES IN THE GULF OF MEXICO; RESULTS OF A SURVEY OF VISITORS TO
GALVESTON ISLAND, TEXAS
Sarah E. Horn and Kimberly J. Reich
Texas A&M University at Galveston, Galveston, Texas, USA
Knowledge of Galveston Island residents and visitors regarding the 5 species of sea turtles most commonly
found in the Gulf of Mexico is relatively unknown. Our objective was to quantify, through surveys, the
public’s knowledge of sea turtles on Texas beaches. Specifically, we were interested in: 1) awareness of
threats to sea turtles in various life history stages and habitats; 2) understanding of their own role in
mitigating threats to sea turtles; and 3) willingness to support programs whose foci include: protection and
conservation of sea turtle habitats, outreach and education, and legislation designed to facilitate the
conservation of sea turtles in the Gulf of Mexico. A random survey of visitors to public beaches on
Galveston Island was conducted during Summer and Fall of 2012 (n = 112). Participants were asked to
provide responses to 14 questions. In terms of general demographics, knowledge and interest, results from
several survey questions are given below. Responses reveal that 15% of those surveyed were from out of
the state, 81% were from areas other than Galveston Island (many from the Greater Houston area) and 4%
were residents of Galveston Island. Less than 1% did not have a high school diploma or equivalent, 22%
had a high school diploma, 77% had a college degree or are in the process of obtaining one. Of the 112
people surveyed, 51 (46%) were not aware that sea turtles nest on Texas beaches. That percentage varied
significantly with level of education. In addition, we quantified the percentage of people surveyed who
would support efforts to conserve sea turtles and their habitats; 72% responded in the affirmative.
Interestingly, there was no significant difference based on education level in this category. Identifying the
demographics of visitors is vital as we refine materials used in outreach efforts. Knowing where
participants elect to stay while visiting Galveston Island (hotel or vacation rental home), or if they were day
visitors allowed us to determine how and where to reach the largest number of people. By providing
location-specific outreach materials (beach signs, hotel door hangers, rental house table tents) to specific
lodging destinations we can maximize our outreach “footprint.” More importantly, the survey results
clarified what visitors and residents are unaware of, thus providing a foundation of topics and concepts for
future education and outreach.
CONNECTING INTERNATIONAL CONSERVATION PRIORITIES WITH HUMAN WELFARE
IN LOW-INCOME REGIONS: HAWKSBILL TURTLES IN EL SALVADOR
Michael J. Liles1,2, Markus J. Peterson1, Yvonna S. Lincoln1, Ana V. Henriquez2, Jeffrey A. Seminoff3,
Alexander R. Gaos4, and Tarla R. Peterson1
1
Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative, San Salvador, El Salvador
3
NOAA–National Marine Fisheries Service, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, La Jolla, California,
USA
4
Eastern Pacific Hawksbill Initiative, San Diego, California, USA; San Diego State University, San Diego,
California, USA
2
Hawksbill sea turtles (Eretmochelys imbricata) are critically endangered globally and hawksbills in the
eastern Pacific Ocean are considered among the most endangered sea turtle populations in the world. Less
251
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
than 500 mature female hawksbills remain in the entire eastern Pacific, with nearly 45% of these
individuals nesting in El Salvador. Cooperation among countries located within the geographical range of
hawksbills in the eastern Pacific is essential for maximizing coordinated conservation actions and to
minimize threats. However, management strategies often emerge from international agendas that may
conflict with local priorities, particularly in resource-dependent areas of low-income regions. Priorities of
the international conservation community often center on the biological aspects and needs of hawksbills,
whereas local priorities of coastal residents tend to focus on the socio-economic development and needs of
human communities. To evaluate the implications of these differences between international and local
priorities and strategies for hawksbill conservation and community development in low-income regions, we
reviewed important socio-political developments during the last 130 years in El Salvador and drew from
the historical record to describe how sea turtle conservation, particularly hawksbill conservation, emerged
along the Salvadoran coast. We then analyzed 34 interviews with local egg collectors to help us understand
how they prioritized hawksbills and their perspectives towards hawksbill conservation. Our results
demonstrated that among egg collectors and other local residents, the primary value of hawksbills was the
economic value attached to egg sales; nests not purchased for protection by conservation initiatives were
sold to local markets for consumption. In addition, most respondents desired more involvement in decisionmaking regarding hawksbill conservation, which they considered to be biased towards elite interests. We
concluded that strategies divorced from local realities can discourage stakeholder participation, escalate
latent conflict, and hamper the sustainability of conservation outcomes. Recognition of local realities could
improve future efforts that connect international conservation priorities with community development to
optimize long-term hawksbill recovery efforts in low-income regions of the eastern Pacific. We thank the
respondents, Boone & Crockett Club, Texas A&M University, National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service, International Sea Turtle Society, Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management
Council, and U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service for invaluable support provided.
CAMINHO MARINHO EXPEDITION: CONNECTING RESEARCH AND COMMUNITY IN A
WAY WHICH CONSERVES THE SEA TURTLES WITH AN ECOSYSTEM-BASED APPROACH
Gustavo Martinez-Souza1,2, Jefferson Bortolotto1,2, Karine Steigleder1,2, Pedro Renato Gonçalves
Filho1, and Paul Gerard Kinas3
1
Caminho Marinho. CEP 88780-000, Praia de Itapirubá, Imbituba, SC, Brasil
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Oceanografia Biológica, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande – FURG.
CP 474, CEP 96.201-900, Rio Grande, RS, Brasil
3
Laboratório de Estatística Ambiental, LEA. FURG. CP 474, CEP 96.201-900, Rio Grande, RS, Brasil
2
The South of Santa Catarina (Laguna, Imbituba and Garopaba) is characterized by the presence of juvenile
green turtles, accompanied by biological diversity, artisanal fishing communities, as well as increasing port
services and tourism. The Caminho Marinho Project is an initiative that aims to connect Research and
Environmental Education to conserve sea turtles and study the services provided by the oceans. The
Caminho Marinho Expedition is the tangible realization of this initiative. One week long, the Expedition
connects research in the ecology of marine vertebrates (in-water sea turtle monitoring), with benthical
ecology (of fauna and flora), in a socio-economic context. The sample points were indicated by community
knowledge about green turtle presence. Points include Farol beach, Galheta beach, Ipoã island and
Itapirubá point, located in Laguna and characterized by community fisheries and tourism. Vila beach,
Santana de dentro Island, and Santana de fora Island, in Imbituba, are sites close to port activity. And
Ibiraquera beach, in Imbituba and a garopaba beaches, have many little artisanal fisheries communities and
a growing tourism industry. Two different methods are used to capture the green turtles. For analysis of
population structure, only first captures are used. Curved carapace length (CCL) is measured using a
flexible tape to the nearest 0.1 cm. Seawater temperature (ST) is measured in situ with thermometer, on all
sampling days. The effort units and their Catch per unit efforts (CPUE) are compared with the different
ocean services, biodiversity, use of fisheries communities, tourism or port, ST values and effort per day
252
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
using general linear model analysis. The results will be disseminated not only in the wider community
through social networks and from the base site with photos and videos, but to and through the local
community participants in the expedition, (as part of participatory research to management). With the
support of a boat from Base Cângulo (a tourism company of Garopaba), children of the coastal
communities experience the diversity of services offered by their environment and experience participation
alongside the expedition, in-water. The experience enhances the awareness to a participatory management
under a marine ecosystem-based approach. In addition, graduate students participated in the Expedition
Team, as part of a course of theoretical and practical training. The Expedition is economically viable and
self-sustaining economically due to the connection and supports of multiple stakeholders, for
environmental, socio-cultural and economical motives, because as Joaquin Torres Garcia said, "Our North
is the South” (Nuestro Norte es el Sur).
PRODUCTIVE WORKSHOPS IN COMMUNITIES ASSOCIATED TO SEA TURTLE
CONSERVATION PROJECTS IN THE MEXICAN PACIFIC
Lourdes L. Parra-Lopez and Pablo A. Trujillo-Susunaga
Ayotzintli A.C., Queretaro, México
In coastal communities which have sea turtles conservation projects, women are not usually involved in
activities that are performed, so it is necessary to work to incorporate these activities and unify the
community in active participation in these projects. From July 2011 to date has worked with women from
different coastal communities of Guerrero (Buena Vista and La Union) and Oaxaca (Ventanilla and
Cacalote) that are associated with nesting beaches by developing productive workshops that allow
interested women to join to the sea turtle conservation project through alternative work to generate a source
of income and a steady food source in their families, in addition in order to minimize plunder of eggs and
killing of sea turtles. We developed two productive workshops: (1) sea turtles crochet and (2) backyard
gardens, which were given to groups of five women in each community, which in turn are training more
women involved in these activities. Each workshop consisted of five sessions of two hours, where the main
activities of the training was an introduction to the topic, sharing of materials, preparation of final products
as well as the resolution of questions of the group. After completed workshops, we partitioned material to
all participants, yarn and polyester fibre stuffing in crochet workshop, and seeds in backyard gardens
workshop, in order to start sea turtles and increase their gardens. Weeks after we reviewed the final
products of each family to verify that it is being applied correctly learned activities to have good results that
benefit the families involved. Actually there are 20 families developing their backyard gardens and 30
women performing activities of crochet in the four coastal communities. Within communities we have seen
an increasing interest in learning these activities among women in the communities, and thus greater
participation by them in such conservation projects.
253
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
MARINE CHELONIAN ILLUSTRATION: PART VIII – THE RISE AND FALL OF TURTLE
SOUP
Rick Schaffer1 and Chuck Schaffer2
1
2
University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
Turtle and Tortoise Newsletter, Jacksonville, Florida, USA
Pictures tell a thousand words, providing far more than simply an image. They tell a story, although one
told in pictures, and in this case, with a few accompanying words. Soup, derived from “sop”, meant bread
dipped/soaked before eating and from prehistory also known as pottage - cooked in a communal pot. Green
turtles with their greenish fat, have been consumed for thousands of years. Strabo and Pliny chronicled the
chelonophagi or turtle eaters. Early texts tout the importance of turtle soup in early Europe and later
Colonial America. But most early cookbooks exclude turtle soup recipes due to difficulty of butchering
large turtles at home. It was the height of fashion in 1700s England, particularly when made with “calipee”
meat. The superior West Indian green turtles survived the journey to England when kept in tanks of fresh
water, the same water they were kept in for up to three months to “retain their flavor”. “West Indian”
recipes for dressing/cooking of turtles appeared and turtle merchants thrived in England. London’s Ship
and Turtle Tavern, known for keeping live turtles in their basement, was established in 1377 was even
recommended in Charles Dickens’ correspondence. An 1873 London city guide stated, “A plate of turtle
and a grilled fowl done Indian fashion will repay a stranger for going the distance to The Ship and Turtle in
Leadenhall Street.” The Tavern in Great Queen-street was also famous for its turtle; keeping the largest
stock of living turtles in London. Through the 1800s, it was considered the ultimate luxury, becoming the
centerpiece of official functions with single Royal events said to serve over 250 tureens. Entire courses
were provided by 60-110 pound turtles. Preparations were complex, belly was boiled, back was baked.
Presentations were elaborate, often being served in the shell. Flippers and entrails were strewed in rich
sauces as side dishes, with at least one tureen of turtle soup including the head. The taste followed English
colonists to America. Philadelphia’s 1700s society began a long tradition of turtle soup with the
Philadelphia Gazette advertising a nine-hour turtle soup banquet. French influences in Boston also
established turtle as a staple. John Adams ate it several times during the Continental Congress. Cookbook
turtle recipes increased sixfold in the next hundred years with turtle available in stoneware crocks. Even the
White House had a dinner featuring a 300-pound turtle main course. But preparation was difficult and time
consuming. This delicacy would likely have disappeared without the innovation of canned turtle (and
terrapin) soup from Campbells, Franco American, Heinz, Ancora, Becas, and others as early as 1882 when
it was widely available in grocery stores. Popular in the early 1900s, turtle on menus and in cookbooks
began to decline mid-century. Prohibition, turtle population decreases, domestic help costs, and finally, the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 brought an end to the turtle soup that was once such an integral part of
culinary history and gave a new lease on life to the turtles that made it possible.
254
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Author Index
Abarca, Gena, 84, 85
Abdallah, Omari, 206
Abella, Elena, 106, 183
Abou-Madi, Noha, 21
Abraham, Adrián G., 194
Abrego, Marino E., 166
Abreu, F. Alberto, 140, 217,
226
Adams, Lotti, 97, 102
Addison, Dave, 200
Adegbile, O. M., 117
Adeogun, D.A., 55
Adeogun, O., 117
Adnyana, I.B. Windia, 62,
103
Adornes, Andrea, 23
Aguilar Claussell, Paula, 5,
12, 124, 140
Aguilar, Alex, 216
Aguilar-Ramirez, Daniel,
116
Aguíñiga, Sergio, 162
Aguirre, Alonso A., 5, 12,
124, 140
Aguirre, Ruth, 85
Ajulo, A.A., 55, 117
Akinnigbagbe, R. O., 117
Aku, Hobete, 38
Al Hameli, Maitha A., 40
Al-Amri, Issa S., 1, 2
Alawi, M., 15
Al-Bahry, Saif N., 1, 2, 15
Albavera, Ernesto, 176, 205
Alegría, Wilber, 196
Alexander, Nicholas, 188
Alfaro-Shigueto, Joanna,
31, 85
Al-Farsi, B., 1
Al-Kindi, Abdulaziz Y., 1, 2
Al-Kindi, M.A., 1
Al-Kiyumi, Ali, 243
Allen, Camryn D., 213
Allman, Phil, 91
Almeida, Antônio P., 246
Almeida-Toledo, Lurdes F.,
229
Al-Musharafi, Salma K., 1
Al-Sumri, B., 1, 2
Altamirano, Eduardo, 84
Alter, S. Elizabeth, 234
Alvarenga, Fernando
Siqueira, 65
Álvarez, Rocío E., 35, 159
Al-Yaqoobi, S., 2
Amato, Ciro M., 125, 131
Amato, George, 234, 235
Amorocho, Diego F., 50,
158, 166
Amorós, Samuel, 86
Andar, Rusli, 103
Andraka, Sandra, 86
Ankersen, Thomas, 54
Antonopoulo, Marina, 50
Aoki, Yuto, 107
Arai, Nobuaki, 20, 32, 148,
150
Arauz, Randall, 77, 97, 102
Arendt, Michael D., 237,
239
Arengo, Felicity, 235
Argüello, Yeudy, 177
Arias, Oscar Brene, 21
Aruna, Edward, 35
Asaad, Irawan, 36
Asada, Ayaka, 87
Asmath, Hamish, 25
ATMAR volunteeers, 39
Auman, Monette, 120
Aureggi, Monica, 216
Avens, Larisa, 24, 163
Azmaz, Musa, 180
Azul, Anabela Marisa, 19
Bachet, Laurence, 40
Backof, Thomas F., 166
Bagley, Dean A., 132, 167,
241
Bah, Ibrahim, 35
Bailey, Helen, 88, 108, 151
Baker, Juliana, 68
Balart, Eduardo, 162
Balazs, George H., 11, 13,
36, 214, 236
Baldwin, Robert, 243
Baltodano, Azucena, 85
Baptistotte, Cecília, 53
Baquero, Andres, 223
Barahona, Nancy, 196
Barandian, Mike, 37
Barbosa, Arley C., 109
Barbosa, Arthur P., 109
Barbosa, Guilherme R., 54
Barcellos, Lauro, 23
Bárcenas-Ibarra, Annelisse,
201
Barco, Susan G., 135
Barkan, Joel, 121
Barker, Marcia, 188
Barraza-Ortega, Marco A.,
30, 249
Barrera, Carlos, 152
Barrientos Muñoz, Karla
G., 193, 204, 214
Barrios-Garrido, Héctor,
18, 64, 78, 89, 111, 148,
175, 204, 219
Barrón, José, 30
Baskale, Eyup, 180
Başkale, Eyup, 118, 125,
144, 168, 179, 180
Bass, Zoe, 244
Baumbach, Dustin S., 193,
212
Bayardo, L., 209
Beasley, Jean, 66
Becker, José Henrique, 65
Bédel, Sophie, 49
Beheregaray, Luciano B.,
238
Bellini, Cláudio, 98
Benavides, Danelia, 196
Benos-Palmer, Theodoros,
208
Benson, Scott R., 11, 88,
108, 146
Bentivegna, Flegra, 144
Bermudez, Erick, 37
Bermudez, Mitsuka, 37
Bermudez, Suki, 42
Berna, Howard, 244
Bernal-Gutiérrez, Jorge E.,
126
Bero, Allan, 38
Berry, Bonnie E., 168
Bertozzi, Carolina P., 29
Betley, Erin, 235
Bevan, Elizabeth, 169, 217
Bézy, Vanessa S., 2
Bishop, Gale A., 66, 168,
170, 190
Bitón, Sebastian, 94
Bjorkland, Rhema, 90
Bjorndal, Karen A., 128,
164, 207, 215, 234, 235,
240
Blanco, Gabriela S., 68
Block, Barbara A., 88, 108
Bograd, Steven J., 88, 108
Boima, Ibrahim, 35
Bolaji, D.A., 55, 117
255
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Bolten, Alan B., 128, 139,
164, 207, 215, 234, 235,
240
Bonatto, Sandro L., 226
Bondioli, Ana C. V., 229
Bonka, Amy, 169
Bonzi, Lucrezia C., 90
Boren, Richard, 70
Borges, Teresa C., 139
Borrat, Virginia, 3
Bortolotto, Jefferson, 252
Bourgois, Audrey, 91
Bourjea, Jérôme, 92, 96,
127, 134
Boussamba, Francois, 80
Bovery, Caitlin M., 127
Bowen, Brian, 226
Boys, Elisabeth, 67
Braman, Charles A., 171,
190
Brantwaith, Angelique, 75
Breed, Greg, 108
Bréheret, Nathalie, 8
Brenes Chaves, Laura
Sofia, 90
Bresette, Michael J., 225,
238
Bretos Trelles, Fernando,
171, 194
Brittain, Rachel, 172
Broadhurst, Heather, 66
Broderick, Annette C., 154
Brofft Bailey, J., 5
Brooks, Annabelle M., 128,
129
Brothers, J. Roger, 173
Brown, Lucie S., 129
Bruce, Rachel, 54
Bruno, Pedro, 23
Buehler, James, 81
Buonantony, Danielle M.,
38
Burchfield, Patrick M., 169
Burkholder, Derek A., 129,
162
Burns, Karen P., 67
Buyum, Arielle, 211
Caballero, Edwin, 85
Cabrera, Carol, 196
Campbell, Elizabeth, 85
Campbell, Lisa M., 248
Can, Erdi, 118
Canales, Carlos, 159
Canizalez-Roman, Adrian,
124
Caraccio, Maria Noel, 220
256
Cardona, Luis, 138, 216
Carreras, Carlos, 154, 216
Carruyo-Rincon, Laura, 64,
78
Carthy, Raymond R., 25,
54, 160, 164, 230
Casale, Paolo, 50
Castilhos, Jaqueline Comin
de, 226
Castro Martínez, Marco
Antonio, 169, 219
Castro, Joshua, 173
Castro, Mariana O., 19
Cavin, Julie, 11
Cea, Cleide, 84
Ceballos, Alba, 138
Ceia, Filipe R., 139
Ceriani, Simona A., 125,
130, 131
Chabot, Ryan M., 125, 131
Chacón-Chaverri, Didiher,
39, 131
Chacón-Vargas, Didiher A.,
39, 131
Chaloupka, Milani, 235
Chambers, Ashley, 4
Chamorro, Veronica C., 41
Chapman, C., 209
Chavance, Pierre, 92
Chávez, Alma, 85
Chávez, Marcial, 196
Cheng, I-Jiunn, 33, 92, 132
Cheng, Wan-Hwa, 92, 132
Cherkiss, Michael S., 141
Chevallier, Damien, 191
Chu, Cuong The, 215
Church, C.A., 209
Ciccione, Stéphane, 92, 96,
127, 134
Cicimuri, David, 34
Cisneros, Julia, 7
Clark, Dave R., 225, 228
Clark, Kenneth F., 170
Clermont, Sandra, 92
Clusa, Marcel, 216
Coleman, Andrew, 93, 217
Conde, Brirelys, 64
Cope, Kendra, 132
Cordoba, Jose A., 70
Cornejo, Ingmar S., 197
Costa, Daniel P., 108
Coutou, Johanna, 25
Cox, Sherry, 20
Coyne, Michael, 60
Crane, Nicole L., 247
Craven, K. S., 5
Crescenzo, Giuseppe, 6
Crespo, Luis A., 39, 42
Cruce, Jennifer A., 247
Cruz, Jefer, 196
Cruz, Marco G., 133
Cruzado, R., 209
Cuendis, Domingo, 196
Cunningham, Ariana, 193,
212
da Cunha Bastos, Jayme, 9
da Cunha Bastos, Vera
Lúcia Freire, 9
da Silva Filho, Rodolfo
Pinho, 23
Dacal, Taylor, 197
Dalleau, Mayeul, 96, 127,
134
Damazo, Lindsey E., 135,
193, 212
Danielson, Kyle A., 94
Daoust, Pierre-Yves, 11
Das, Himansu S., 40
D'Auzon, M. Jean Louis, 40
Dávila, Pedrarias, 85
Davis, Doris, 170
Davis, Edward J., 170
Davis, Neil, 68
Davis, Shannon J., 135
Day, Melanie, 81
De Guise, Sylvain, 28
de la Toba, Victor, 163
de los Llanos, Verónica, 133
de Queiroz Hazarbassanov,
Nicolle G. T., 26
de Thoisy, Benoit, 226, 229,
246
Del Angel, Isbel S., 17
del Campo, Rodolfo
Martin, 217
Delcroix, Eric, 49
Delgado, Alicia, 92
Delgado, G., 209
Delo, Jessica, 232
Demetropoulos, Andreas,
216
Devlin, Christopher, 4
Di Bello, Antonio, 6, 8
Diallo, Mamadou, 50
Diard, Marion, 49
Dias da Silva, Augusto C.
C., 53
Dias da Silva, Augusto
C.C., 98
Dick, Belinda M., 41
Diez, Carlos E., 34, 39, 42,
193, 198, 204
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
DiGiovanni, Robert, 152
Dill, Larry, 129
DiMatteo, Andrew, 38, 136
Dodd, Mark G., 60, 120,
168
Domenech, Francesc, 94
Domit, Camila, 95, 111, 139
Dornfeld, Tera C., 68, 69
dos Santos, Alexsandro S.,
53
dos Santos, Edson
Leopoldo, 65
dos Santos, Robson G., 27,
29
Dow Piniak, Wendy, 10
Driscoll, Cindy, 43
Dubernet, Stella, 96
Dunbar, S.S., 209
Dunbar, Stephen G., 43,
135, 137, 193, 209, 212
Duncan, Mary, 70
Duran, Noemi, 43, 137
Dutton, Peter H., 88, 108,
207, 213, 221, 223, 235,
242
Dyc, Christelle, 10
Dziva, Francis, 25
Eckert, Karen, 75
Eckert, Scott A., 10, 88
Eder, Elena, 138
Eguchi, Tomoharu, 88
Ehrhart, Llewellyn M., 120,
125, 130, 131, 132, 167,
178, 181, 192, 238, 241
Eira, Catarina, 150
Ekanayake, E.M. Lalith,
218
El-Sadek, Islam, 174, 233
Enciso, Ildefonso, 7
Enciso-Saracho, Fernando,
30, 249
Endres, Courtney S., 7
Epperly, Sheryan P., 118,
219, 239
Esbach, Michael, 38, 44
Escudero, Eileen, 211
Esliman, Aarón, 110, 223
Espinoza Rodríguez, Nínive
E., 18, 64, 78, 204, 219
Espinoza Rodríguez, Nínive
E., 175
Espinoza, Raimundo, 42
Estima, Sérgio C., 246
Estrades, Andrés, 100, 104,
119, 220
Evans, Daniel R., 71, 130
Fak, Çiğdem, 118, 144, 179
Fakayode, O. S., 117
Fallabrino, Alejandro, 3,
100, 104, 220
Ferrando, Virginia, 119
Ferrara, Camila R., 176,
205
Ferreira, Rogerio L., 139
Figueroa, Antonio, 116
Filho, Pedro Renato
Gonçalves, 252
Finn, Sarah A., 97
Fish, Marianne, 50, 102
Fisher, Leah, 176
Fisler, Shara, 15, 121
FitzSimmons, Nancy N.,
226, 229
Flanagan, Joseph P., 99,
122
Flynn, John, 68
Foley, David G., 88
Fonseca, Luis G., 39, 177,
196, 245
Foote, Jerris, 244
Formia, Angela, 80
Fourqurean, James, 129
Franchini, Delia, 6
Francisco, Jacobo, 152
Freggi, Daniela, 6, 8
Fretey, Jacques, 10
Frey, Amy, 221, 223
Frick, Michael G., 231, 235
Friedman, M., 209
Fuentes, Mariana MMPB,
45, 102
Fujisaki, Ikuko, 46, 145,
221, 230
Fuller, Mykl C., 181
Gaines, Steven D., 56
Galeano, María, 85
Gallo, Berenice M. G., 98
Gama, Luciana R., 139
Gaos, Alexander R., 84,
166, 223, 251
García Cruz, Marco, 222
Garcia, Karledys, 64
García-Gasca, Alejandra,
201
Gardel, Antoine, 191
Gastelum, Fredy C., 7
Gaughran, Stephen J., 235
Gebhard-Cote, Erika, 28
Gehrke, Kari K., 76, 97
Genoy-Puerto, Elmer A., 26
George, Jeffrey, 4, 224
Giffin, Alyssa, 102
Giffoni, Bruno B., 53, 65, 98
Gillis, Anthony J., 224
Giraldo, Alan, 158
Girard, Alexandre, 8
Girondot, Marc, 174, 224
Goby, Gillian, 38
Godard-Codding, Céline
A.J., 28, 99, 122
Godfrey, David, 71, 201
Godfrey, Matthew H., 60,
120, 176, 248
Godinez, Carlos, 15
Godley, Brendan J., 85,
129, 154
Goins, Miranda, 232
Goldberg, Daphne Wrobel,
9
Goldman, Daniel I., 185
Gomes Gallo, Berenice
Maria, 53, 65
Gonçalves, Bruno T., 225
González Camacho, Zuleica
B., 197
González Camacho,
Zuleika B., 249
Gonzalez, Catalina, 97, 102
González, Juan L. C., 197
González, Liza, 85
Gonzalez-Paredes, Daniel,
100
Gorham, Jonathan C., 225
Goshe, Lisa, 163
Goswami, Dinesh, 82
Goto, Kiyoshi, 234
Gottdenker, Nicole L., 22
Greco, Veronica, 66
Green, Destinee, 197
Griffin, DuBose B., 60, 120
Grimes, Jim, 244
Grimmer, Samantha, 156
Groner, Maya, 22
Groom, Rachel, 83
Gross, Laura, 210
Gu, He-Xiang, 36
Guardado-González, Jesús
Ivan, 30, 197, 249
Guertin, Jeffrey R., 225
Guevara, Nelson, 196
Guimarães dos Santos,
Robson, 112
Guimarães, Elisângela S.,
188
Guimarães, Suzana M.,
101, 247
Gulko, David, 75
257
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Gusmão, Fernanda B., 125,
131
Guterres, Laís, 23
Guyot, Stéphane, 49
Guzman-Zaragoza, Lizette,
102
Hackett, Caitlin E., 160
Hagen, Scott, 120
Hahn, Anelise Torres, 226
Hairston, Jerry, 52
Hall, Martin, 86
Halls, Joanne, 198
Halpern, Benjamin S., 108
Halpin, Patrick, 136
Hama, Feitoumatt Lematt,
10
Hamabata, Tomoko, 227
Hamann, Mark, 62
Hamza, Abdulmaula A.,
216
Hanafy, Mahmoud, 174,
233
Hapdei, Jessy, 211
Hardesty, Britta Denise,
115
Harfush-Meléndez,
Martha, 176, 201, 205
Hargrove, Stacy, 236
Harms, Craig A., 10, 66
Harris, Heather, 11, 18
Harrison, Emma, 45, 97,
102, 189, 204
Harrison, Scott, 231
Hart, Catherine E., 5, 12,
124, 140
Hart, Drew, 45
Hart, Katharine A., 249
Hart, Kristen M., 46, 141,
145, 153
Hartley, Troy W., 250
Harvey, James T., 146
Hassrick, Jason, 108
Hatchett, Wendy, 93, 217
Haxhiu, Idriz, 103, 153
Hays, Allison W., 178, 181
Hazen, Elliott L., 108
Heithaus, Michael R., 129,
162
Henriquez, Ana V., 84, 251
Henry, William, 108
Heppell, Selina S., 219, 236
Hernandez, Estela R., 17
Herren, Richard, 228
Heuberger, Kim, 244
Higgins, Benjamin M., 28,
99, 122
258
Hikida, Tsutomu, 227
Hillis-Starr, Zandy M., 141,
153, 240
Hirsch, Sarah, 244
Hitipeuw, Creusa, 50, 62,
88, 103
Hochscheid, Sandra, 144
Hodgson, Dave, 129
Hoffland, Tim, 93, 217
Holder, Ridley, 25
Horn, Sarah E., 251
Howell, Evan, 88
Howell, Lyndsey N., 141
Huey, L., 209
Hughes, Christi L., 142
Hupp, Amy, 20
Ingram, Dianne, 145
Innis, Charles, 11
Irish, Jennifer, 120
Irvine, Ladd, 108
Isaacs, Jackie, 145
Iseton, Claire E., 143
Ishihara, Takashi, 143
Ishizaki, Asuka, 143
Islam, Mohammad Z., 104
J. B., Armando, 53
Jacob, Théa, 40
Jacobo, Francisco J., 7
Jacobson, Susan, 54
James, Michael, 11, 18
Jaramillo, M. Alejandra,
166
Jarquin, Lidiceth, 196
Jaúregui, Guiomar A., 126,
151
Jehu, Adam, 25
Jenkins, Keith A., 38
Jensen, Brenda A., 13
Jensen, Michael P., 226, 229
Jimenez, Cristian, 72
Jobsis, Paul, 153
Johnson, Rocio, 71
Jordao, Juliana C., 229
Juliana Marigo, Robson G.,
29
Kagawa, Shiro, 148
Kamezaki, Naoki, 143, 227
Kappes, Michelle A., 108
Kapurusinghe, Thushan,
47, 71, 218
Kara, İlker, 180
Karakaya, Ş., 179
Karkoulia, Theoni, 208
Kaska, Yakup, 118, 125,
144, 168, 179, 180, 183
Katilmis, Yusuf, 180
Katılmıs, Yusuf, 125, 144,
168, 179, 180
Katz, Wilma, 244
Kaunda-Arara, Boaz, 182
Kaylor, Michelle, 20
Keledjian, Amanda J., 47
Kellar, Nick M., 213
Keller, Jennifer M., 13
Kendall, William L., 230,
241
Khalil, Mona, 216
Kibler, Brenda, 43
Kilduff, Catherine, 48
Kinas, Paul G., 24, 252
Kinoshita, Denise, 26
Klaus, Jamie, 93
Klinge, Luciana, 72
Klingensmith, Kathy, 244
Knight, James L., 34
Kobayashi, Masato, 20, 32,
150
Koenen, Franziska, 106
Koepfler, Eric, 197
Koizumi, Takahiro, 148
Kondo, Kazuaki, 148
Koroma, Aiah P., 35
Korysko, François, 49
Koval, Julianne, 68
Kremezi-Margaritoulis,
Anna, 208
Kuhn, Carey, 108
Kukkamalla, Rivvi, 232
Kumar, Anurag, 38, 136
Kumer, Jack, 43
Kurle, Carolyn, 163
Kuzmick, Emily, 97
LaCasella, Erin, 223
LaChance, Taylor, 197
Lafage, M. Dominique, 40
Lai, Olimpia R., 6
Lamb, M., 5
Lambert, Didier, 49
Lamont, Margaret M., 145,
160, 164, 221, 230
Lampo, Margarita, 133, 222
Landry, Jr., Andre M., 141,
142
Lanier, Wendy, 230
Lasala, Jake, 231
Lauret-Stepler, Marie, 134
Lavretsky, Philip, 32
Layton, Jenny E., 232
Lazo, Rodrigo, 148
Le Berre, Thomas, 51
Lee, Robyn E., 14
Leggitt, V.L., 209
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Leitão, Santiago Alonso
Tobar, 9
Leon, Ana Maria V., 70
Leonard, Carol, 244
Leonard, Kenya, 244
Leslie, Aimée, 50
Levasseur, Kathryn, 181
Levin, Milton, 28
Levy, Liraz, 51
Levy, Yaniv, 216
Lewison, Rebecca L., 102,
223
Ley-Quiñonez, César Paul,
5, 12, 124, 140
Lezama, Cecilia, 100, 104
Lidz, Barbara H., 46
Liles, Michael J., 84, 223,
251
Lima, Eduardo H.S.M., 53,
98
Lima, Eron P., 98
Limpus, Colin J., 226, 237
Lincoln, Yvonna S., 251
Lindsay, K., 212
Lira-Reyes, Diana J., 169
Lizano, Vanessa, 39
Lohmann, Kenneth J., 7,
173
Lombard, Claudia D., 52
Long, Chris A., 181
Lontoh, Deasy N., 146
Lopez, Alejandro, 176
Lopez, Gustave G., 9, 98
López, Gustave G., 53
Lopez, Jaclyn, 48, 59, 63
López-Calderón, Jorge M.,
156
López-Mendilaharsu,
Milagros, 98, 100
Loreiro, João, 19
Loureiro, Nuno S., 225
Lowell, Beth, 47
Lucas, Sarah, 172
Lucero-Romero, Jesus, 116
Lundgren, Ian, 141, 240
Mabert, Brice D. K., 80
MacDonald, Bradley D.,
158, 163
MacDuffee, David T., 38
Machaku, Rose, 96, 182
Mackay, Amy, 52
MacKay, Kenneth T., 182
Madon, Bénédicte, 233
Mafucci, Fulvio, 144
Mahmoud, Ibrahim Y., 1, 2,
15
Maina, Douglas, 52
Maisels, Fiona, 80
Maizel, Alexia, 21
Makin, Joanne C., 183
Maldonado Diaz, David,
110, 116
Mallos, Nicholas J., 73, 248
Mancini, Agnese, 174, 233
Mangel, Jeffrey C., 31, 85
Mangubhai, Sangeeta, 36
Mann, David A., 165
Mansfield, Kate L., 147
Marçalo, Ana, 150
Marco, Adolfo, 106, 138,
183
Marcovaldi, Guy, 98
Marcovaldi, Maria Ângela,
53, 98
Margaritoulis, Dimitris,
105, 151, 154, 184, 195,
208, 216
Marigo, Juliana, 112
Marín, Isabel, 138
Marlow, Suzie, 4
Marsh, Helene, 45
Marshall, Christopher D.,
15
Martin, Jeannie M., 73, 79,
210
Martin, Kelly, 11
Martin, Meredith, 234
Martinez-Ortíz, Hector J.,
169
Martinez-Souza, Gustavo,
3, 74, 252
Martins, Maria S., 54
Martins, María S., 183
Martins, Samir, 106, 138,
183
Matarrita, Eduardo R., 177
Mate, Bruce, 108
Matsui, Kenta, 148
Matsuoka, Shinji, 107
Matsuzawa, Yoshimasa,
143, 234
Matushima, Eliana R., 26,
27, 29
Matzen, Eric, 107
Mavárez, Jesús, 133
Maxwell, Sara M., 108
Mazouchova, Nicole, 185
Mazzarrella, Kristen, 244
Mbungu, Samuel, 75
McCarthy, Ariana O., 202
McCray, Jame, 54
McDonald, Brigitte, 108
McGowin, Audrey E., 32,
94
Mchomvu, Boniventure,
206
Medina Cruz, Yosvani, 186,
187
Medina, Javier, 133
Medina, Victor, 84
Mejía, Carlos, 85
Melero, David, 84
Mella, Marcela A., 35, 159
Mendilaharsu, Milagros L.,
53
Merchán, Manuel, 94
Mettee, Nancy S., 16, 21, 75
Meyer, Brian K., 66
Meylan, Anne, 120, 189
Meylan, Peter, 189
Mijangos, Eleazar A., 17
Milliken, Henry O., 107
Mituhasi, Takahisa, 86
Mojisola, Adegbile O., 55,
186
Molfetti, Érica, 246
Moncada Gavilán, Félix G.,
186, 187
Monteiro, Danielle, 246
Monteiro-Neto, Cassiano,
101, 247
Montes I., David, 31
Montiel-Villalobos, María
G., 64, 148
Morán, Beatriz, 18, 64
Morán, Lisandro, 64, 175
Moreno, Efrain C., 64, 78,
89, 175
Morreale, Stephen J., 88,
151, 157, 166
Morris, Robert, 214
Mortimer, Jeanne A., 187
Moseby, Katherine, 38
Mota, Mario J., 14
Mott, Cody R., 225, 228
Mounguengui, Gil A., 80
Moura, Carina C.M., 19,
109
Moura, Geraldo J. B., 109
Muhammad, Kevin, 188
Munne, Vince, 225
Muro, José L. G., 194
Murray, Kimberly T., 119
Murua, Hilario, 92
Mustin, Walter, 215
Nagoda-Gamage, Ruvani
N., 76
Nahvi, Nina, 4
259
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Nairn, Campbell J., 168,
234, 240
Nakajima, Kana, 32, 148
Nakamura, Yuichi, 148
Nalovic, Michel A., 250
Narazaki, Tomoko, 15
Naro-Maciel, Eugenia, 226,
234, 235, 240, 246
Nason, April, 18
Nava, Mabel, 123, 149
Navarro Barbosa, Jaime, 65
NDembé, Hélène, 8
Nel, Ronel, 157
Nelson, Steven, 20
Neves, Milena S. C., 19,
109, 188
Neves, Vivian C. S., 109,
188
Newman, Gregory, 81
Ng, Ka-yan, 36
Ngouessono, Solange, 80
Nguyen, The Duc, 215
Nickel, Barry, 108
Nicolau, Lídia, 150
Nilsen, Frances, 13
Nishizawa, Hideaki, 20, 150
Nissen, Richard. J., 38
Nodarse Andreu, Gonzalo,
186, 187
Noriega-Hoyos, Carmen L.,
126, 151
Norton, Terry M., 20, 21, 22
Nowlin, Michelle B., 61
Obando, Faustino, 196
Obe, Yuka, 32, 150
Okuyama, Junichi, 20, 32,
148, 150
Olakolu, F.C., 186
Oliveira, Luciana G., 19
Omogoriola, H.O., 186
Oquendo, Martin, 64
Ordoñez, Cristina, 45, 189
Orimogunje, R.O., 55
Orrego, Carlos M., 177, 245
Ortega, Christian, 217
Ortega, Marco A. B., 197
Ortiz, Concepción, 162
Ortiz, Kathryn M., 66, 190
Ortiz, Natalia, 85
Ortiz, Patrícia, 65
Oruç, A., 179, 207
Oshisanya, K.I., 186
Osterhoudt, Matthew, 244
Owens, David W., 176, 213,
237, 239
260
Pabón-Aldana, Karen A.,
151
Pacheco Bertozzi, Carolina,
112
Pacheco, Lucas, 86
Padilla, Ildefonso E., 152
Padron, Dana P., 64, 78
Page-Karjian, Annie, 22
Pahang, Kristina A., 55
Pahlas, Jonathan M., 171,
190
Paladino, Frank V., 68, 69,
88, 151, 157, 166
Palmar, Jordano, 64, 78
Panagopoulou, Aliki, 151,
208
Papafitsoros, Kostas, 68
Paredes, Evelyn, 109
Parga, María, 86, 114
Parker, Lindsey, 239
Parker, R.L., 209
Parnell, Richard, 80
Parra, Macarena, 207
Parra-Lopez, Lourdes L.,
253
Parsons, Joe, 215
Pascual, Marta, 216
Patel, Samir H., 151
Pawloski, Jeffrey, 214
Pearl, Tami, 43
Peavey, Lindsey E., 56
Peckham, S. Hoyt, 110, 116,
163
Pédurthe, Sandra, 49
Peña, Luis Jaime, 169, 219,
224
Peñaloza, Claudia, 222
Pérez-García, Héctor, 138
Péron, Christina, 191
Perrault, Justin R., 22
Peters, Jeffrey L., 32
Peters, Len, 188
Peterson, Markus J., 251
Peterson, Tarla R., 251
Petit Rodríguez, María
José, 64, 89, 111
Petitet, Roberta, 23, 24
Petro, George, 57, 182
Pfaller, Joseph B., 168, 235
Phillips, Ayanna Carla N.,
25
Phillips, Kristen M., 135
Phillott, Andrea D., 76
Piacenza, Susan E., 236
Piedra, Rotney, 88
Pierce, Simon J., 62
Pierre, Steffan M., 192
Pilcher, Nicolas, 229
Pincetich, Christopher A.,
76, 77, 97
Pineda, Andrés, 111
Pineda-Catalan, Oscar, 234
Pinou, Theodora, 152
Piorkowski, Lauren, 97
Piroli, Vilma, 103, 153
Pitman, Robert L., 56
Plafker, S., 209
Plante, Craig J., 2
Plotkin, Pamela T., 68
Polat, Fatih, 180
Pollock, Clayton, 141, 153
Pons, Maite, 86
Ponzo, Alessandro, 55
Possardt, Earl, 169, 243
Pressey, Bob, 45
Pulido, Graciela D.C., 64,
78
Putman, Nathan F., 235
Quattro, Joseph M., 237,
239
Quijano, Sonia, 217
Quimbayo, Juan Pablo, 101
Quiñones, Javier, 109
Quirós, Wagner, 177, 245
Rabon, Alexis, 67
Rajakaruna, R.S., 218
Rajh, Stacy, 25
Rakotonirina, Bertin, 96
Rameriz, Patrica, 75
Ramírez-Gallego, Cristian,
193, 204, 214
Ramos, Jaime A., 139
Ranawana, K.B., 218
Randazzo, Angela, 193
Rathnakumara, A.M.D.S.,
218
Read, John, 38
Read, Tyffen C., 237
Redfoot, William E., 132,
167
Reece, Joshua S., 181
Reed, Kristin M., 69
Rees, ALan F., 154, 184,
195, 216
Reeve, Robyn E., 193, 212
Reich, Kimberly J., 141,
143, 251
Reid, Brendan, 234
Reiko Matushima, Eliana,
112
Reina, Richard D., 68
Reintsma, Nicole, 57
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Reisbeck, Rachel, 67
Reising, Megan, 155
Rendón, Liliana, 86
Revuelta, Ohiana, 94
Reynolds, James, 183
Rguez-Baron, Juan M., 156,
163
Ribeiro, Eusa, 106
Ricardo, Julia A., 171, 194
Rice, Marc R., 13
Richards, Paul M., 118,
219, 236
Rieser, Alison, 58
Riggall, Thomas E., 166,
184, 195
Rimkus, Todd A., 156
Rincón, Luz María, 30
Riosmena-Rodríguez,
Rafael, 156
Rist, Paul, 11
Rivas, Carlos, 84
Rivas, Florencia, 104
Robbins, Michelle N., 213
Robert, Maurício de C., 95,
111
Roberts, Charles, 160
Roberts, Mark A., 237, 239
Robinson, Nathan J., 157
Robinson, Patrick, 108
Robles, Antonio T., 152
Rocha, Axa, 15
Rocha-Olivares, Axayacatl,
238
Roden, Suzanne, 221
Rodriguez, Francisco, 64,
78
Rodriguez, Tibisay, 64
Rodríguez-Clark, Kathryn
M., 133, 148, 222
Rodríguez-Zárate, Clara J.,
238
Roe, John H., 88
Rogers, Jennifer, 244
Rojas-Cañizales, Daniela,
64
Rojas-Morales, David, 131
Roman, Ana M., 193
Rosa, Liana, 95, 111, 139
Rosales, Hortensia M., 17
Rossi, Silmara, 26, 27, 29,
112
Rosso-Londoño, Maria
Camila, 111
Rosspencer, E., 209
Rostal, David C., 231
Roth, Jacqueline M., 94
Roth, James D., 130
Rousselet, Estelle, 28
Ruak, Joseph, 211
Rubin, David N., 59
Rubio, Saúl, 197
Ruiz, Francheska, 37
Ruiz, Jon, 92
Rulmal, John, 247
Saba, Vincent S., 68, 113
Sagarminaga, Ricardo, 114
Sagawe, Dee, 114
Şahin, Barbaros, 118
Sakabe, Ai, 107
Sakashita, Miyoko, 48, 59
Salazar, Heydi, 196
Sales, Gilberto, 53, 98
Salinas, L., 209
Salinas, Lidia, 193, 212
Salmon, Michael, 57, 155,
160
Saman, M.M., 218
Samaraweera, P., 218
Sampson, Caitlin, 79, 210
Sampson, Laura, 158
Sánchez, Alberto, 162
Sanchez, Cheryl, 238
Sanchez, Manuel, 97, 102
Sánchez-Sarmiento,
Angélica María, 26, 112
Sánchez-Sarmiento,
Angélica María, 27
Sánchez-Sarmiento,
Angélica María, 29
Sanchez-Zazueta, Jorge
Guillermo, 249
Sanders, Aimée T., 80
Sanders, Albert, 34
Santelli, Guilhem, 49
Santidrián Tomillo, Bibi, 68
Santos, Alexsandro, 98
Santos, Armando J.B., 9, 98
Santos, Fabrício R., 246
Santos, Katherine Comer,
77, 97, 102
Saracho, Fernando E., 197
Sari, Fikret, 179
Sartain, Autumn R., 141,
145
Sarti Martínez, Adriana
Laura, 219
Sarto, Nicole, 30
Sasso, Christopher R., 239
Sato, Katsufumi, 15, 92
Scarfo, Alyssa, 197
Scarpino, Russell, 81
Schaffer, Chuck, 254
Schaffer, Rick, 254
Schletz Saili, Katerine, 161
Schmid, Jeffrey R., 158
Schriver, Martha L., 170
Schroeder, Barbara, 169,
243
Schutes, Allison, 73
Schuyler, Qamar, 115
Schwartz, S.L., 5
Schwenter, Jeffrey A., 239
Schwoerer, Monette
Virginia, 115
Sciance, Marc B., 198
Scott, Krystina R., 198
Searle, Linda, 81
Secchi, Eduardo R., 24
Secme, Mucahit, 118, 179
Seçme, Mücahit, 125, 144,
168, 180
Segars, Albert L., 239
Segura, Alvaro, 86
Sekhar, P. S. Raja, 116, 199
Sekhar, P.S. Raja, 60
Seminoff, Jeffrey A., 11, 56,
146, 156, 158, 163, 177,
207, 213, 251
Seney, Erin E., 135
Senko, Jesse, 110, 114, 116
Sepulveda, Istvan, 85
Sesay, Augustine, 35
Sezgin, Çisem, 118, 125,
144, 168, 179, 180
Shaffer, Scott A., 108
Shah, Shwetal, 82
Shamblin, Brian M., 60,
168, 234, 240
Shannon, Delphine, 93, 217
Shaughnessy, Michael, 60
Shaver, Donna J., 141, 219
Shaw, Katherine R., 200
Shillinger, George L., 88
Shore, Teri, 61
Shudes, Karen, 201
Sifuentes-Romero, Itzel,
201
Silberg, Joshua N., 55
Silverthorn, David, 188
Simmons, Samantha, 108
Simões, Thyara N., 109
Sirias, Isabel, 85
Skamiotis, Kharla I., 35
Sladky, Kurt K., 20
Smelker, Kimberly, 30
Smith, Ainsley F., 61
Smith, Lauren, 30
261
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Soares e Soares, Luciano,
246
Soares, Fernando, 106
Solangi, Moby, 93, 217
Solarin, Boluwaji, 55, 117,
186
Sole, Genaro, 222
Sosa Cornejo, Ingmar, 30,
249
Sousa-Lima, Renata, 176,
205
Southwood, Amanda, 114
Spivy, Annette, 120
Spotila, James R., 68, 88,
151
Squella, Cristián E., 35, 159
Stacy, Brian A., 11, 21, 119
Stadler, Melanie, 160
Stapleton, Seth, 155
Stapleton, Seth P., 155, 171,
181, 190
Steed, Chance, 244
Steele, Sarah R., 202
Steigleder, Karine, 252
Steiner, Todd, 61
Stephens, Brail S., 145, 160
Sterling, Eleanor, 38, 235
Sterner, Andrew T., 192,
241
Stevens, Billie, 93
Stewart, Kelly R., 242
Stewart, Neville, 25
Stiner, John C., 115, 120
Stokes, Lesley W., 68, 118
Stringer, Elizabeth M., 10
Su, Melany, 156
Suárez Navarro, Flávia
Cysne, 65
Suarez-Yana, Tania, 31
Suganuma, Hiroyuki, 87,
107
Summers, Tammy Mae,
211
Suprapti, Dwi, 62, 103
Svensson, Patrik, 51
Swiggs, Jen, 68
Swimmer, Yonat, 114, 121
Tabata, Runa, 32
Tagarino, Alden P., 161
Takase, Mai, 107
Talavera, Ana L., 162
Tan, Amy L., 193, 212
Tapilatu, Ricardo F., 88,
146, 203
Tarnowski, Marie E., 128,
129
262
Tatge, George, 244
Teixeira, Simone F., 188
Tejedor, Ana, 114
Tekin, Meryem, 118, 144
Testa, Jamie, 43
Teutschel, Nicole M., 108
Thomas, Rachel, 20
Thomé, João C.A., 53, 98
Thomson, Jordan A., 162
Tilley, Dominic, 181
Tiwari, Manjula, 203
Tizol, Dana, 187
Tobón López, Alexander,
166
Tomás, Jesús, 94, 119
Tornisielo, Valdemar Luiz,
112
Torres, Perla, 84, 196, 223
Torres, Tony, 169
Touliatou, Smaro, 105
Townsend, Kathy, 115
Traweek, Julie, 83, 212
Trujillo-Susunaga, Pablo
A., 253
Truong, Triet M., 32, 94
Tseng, Cheng T., 33
Tucker, Anton D., 158, 165,
171, 243, 244
Tucker, Francis J., 35
Türkozan, Ogüz, 207, 216
Türkozan, Ogüz, 179
Turner Tomaszewicz, Cali,
163
Turner, Allison, 43
Ün, Z., 179
Upite, Carrie M., 119
Urteaga, José, 84, 85, 196,
223
Valastro, Carmela, 6
Valencia, Iver, 70
Valero-Barrios, Luis, 64,
204
Valiulis, Jennifer, 52
Valqui, Michael, 86
Valverde, Roldán A., 2, 30,
177, 196, 202, 245
van Dam, Robert P., 34,
133, 149, 204
van der Wal, Edith, 205
van der Wal, Richard, 205
van der Wal, Sietske, 205
Van Houtan, Kyle, 30
Vance, R. Kelly, 66, 170,
190
Vander Zanden, Hannah
B., 164
Vanstreels, Ralph E. T., 27,
29
Vanstreels, Ralph E.T., 112
Varela-Valenzuela, Rosina,
201
Vargas, Sarah, 246
Varmazis, Dimitri, 211
Vaughan, Katie, 67
Vélez-Rubio, Gabriela M.,
94, 100, 119, 220
Vera, Flor, 111
Viaud, Alban, 51
Vidal, Amanda W., 247
Viera, Natalia, 104
Vilaça, Sibelle Torres, 246
Villachica, Wilberth N., 177
Villar, Silvia, 3
Vingada, José, 150
Visconti, Piero, 45
Vodhanel, S., 209
Vogel, Nick, 86
Vogt, Richard C., 176, 205
Von Holle, Betsy, 115, 120
Vuskovic, Tatiana P., 35
Wada, Ayana, 32, 148
Wainscott, Molly, 197
Walker, M., 5
Wallace, Bryan P., 68, 136
Wanderlinde, Juçara, 53,
98
Wang, John H., 15, 116, 121
Wantiez, Laurent, 237
Ward, Marc, 77
Warraich, Natasha, 121
Watson, Antonio, 25
Webb, Sarah, 99, 122
Weed, C., 5
Weege, Steve, 225
Weeks, Sara E., 119
Weise, Michael J., 108
Weishampel, John F., 92,
120, 130, 181
Welsh, Ryan C., 225
Wen, Wen, 36
Werry, Jonathan, 237
West, Lindsey, 96, 206
Whitaker, J. David, 239
White, Abby, 193
Whiting, Scott, 226
Whitman, Beth, 97, 102
Wibbels, Thane, 18, 169,
203, 217, 232, 238
Wiggins, Sandy, 99
Wilcox, Chris, 115
Wildermann, Natalie E., 64,
78, 89, 111
33rd ISTS Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
Williams, A.B., 186
Williams, Jessica L., 62
Williams, Kristina L., 168,
231, 235
Williams, Natalie C., 164
Williams, Rogers, 119
Willis, Sue, 123
Willson, Andrew, 243
Wilson, Maria, 165
Wirsing, Aaron, 129
Witherington, Blair, 228,
243
Wolf, Shaye, 63
Wood, Roger C., 34
Work, Thierry M., 11, 13
Wyneken, Jeanette, 121,
127, 147
Yaish, M.W., 15
Yañez, Ingrid L., 84, 223
Yasuda, Tohya, 20, 150
Yeh, Frederick, 210
Yılmaz, C., 179, 207
Young, Morgan, 57
Youngflesh, Casey, 47
Yunia, Cherryta, 36
Zaccaroni, Annalisa, 90
Zaghdoudi-Allan, Nadège,
165
Zapata Najera, Blanca
Monica, 219
Zárate, Patricia M., 207
Zavala-Norzagaray, Alan
A., 5, 12, 124, 140
Zawada, David G., 46
Zelaya, N., 209
Zemaitis, Kristen, 102
Zhang, Feiyan, 36
Zirena Vilca, Franz, 112
Zumwalt, J., 209
Zuñiga, Renato, 31
Zurawka, Heidi, 93, 217
263