Journal of Tropical Biodiversity and Biotechnology
Volume 04, Issue 02 (2019): 82 — 89
DOI: 10.22146/jtbb.45355
Research Article
Distribution Record of Leptophryne borbonica (Tschudi,
1838) (Anura: Bufonidae) from Malang, East Java:
Description, Microhabitat, and Possible Threats
Muhamad Prayogi Erfanda1, Luhur Septiadi1, Sandra Rafika Devi1, Berry Fakhry Hanifa2*
1) Undergraduate Student of Biology Department, Science and Technology Faculty, State Islamic University of Maulana Malik
Ibrahim Malang, East Java, Indonesia, 65146
2) Biology Department, Science and Technology Faculty, State Islamic University of Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang, East Java,
Indonesia, 65146
*Corresponding author, tel.: +6282115517089, email address: berryfhanifa@uin-malang.ac.id
Keywords:
distribution records
Leptophryne borbonica
Hourglass-toad
Malang
East Java
Article history:
Submitted 24/04/2019
Revised 30/05/2019
Accepted 31/05/2019
ABSTRACT
Bromo Tengger Semeru National Park (TNBTS) which partly located in Malang, East
Java, Indonesia holds various kinds of niches that can support the existence of
undiscovered amphibian species. We examine a new distribution of the Leptophryne
borbonica, Hourglass-toad from an area located on the slopes of the Southwest of
Tengger Mountain as well as its ecological implications related to the possibility of
habitat threats. The exploration was carried out on January 1st and March 1st, 2019,
with the description of morphology data and collecting abiotic parameters such as
temperature, humidity, altitude, and habitat preference. The distribution of the species
was marked. Any important notable records of the habitat threats are documented.
The results showed that the amphibians found were Leptophryne borbonica, and set as a
new record on Malang, East Java. We suggested that the isolated distribution is very
susceptible to ecological disturbances, future ecotourism development, and habitat
destruction that prone to local extinction. Further research and conservation efforts
need to be carried out for the sustainability of this species in the observation site.
The amphibians diversity data in East Java are very
important in assessing its distribution, conservation
status and strategies to prevent the threat of
declining population.
Malang as the largest regency in East Java has
an administrative area of 3,534.86 km², was
surrounded by mountain ranges and a lot of
watersheds (Pemkab Malang, 2019). This area has
high potency of biodiversity, but still minimal in
term of exploration and data of herpetofauna. One
area that has high biodiversity potential is Bromo
Tengger Semeru National Park (TNBTS) and its
surroundings. This region keeps various niches such
as high ground, water source, clear water flow, low
to high canopy & dense vegetation, and also plenty
of habitat such as arboreal, terrestrial, fossorial, and
aquatic type that might support the existence of
amphibian species (Septiadi et al, 2018b). This area
has a tourism attraction (ecotourism) which
INTRODUCTION
Amphibians diversity data in East Java is still
recorded on several localities (van Kampen, 1923)
with a lack of further survey afterward. Previous data
shows only 39 species of amphibians (mostly
dominated by amphibian species of Anura, and 3
species of Gymnophiona) (Iskandar & Colijn, 2000)
in the island of Java, with vast majority data
originating from West Java region, especially on the
Mount Halimun-Salak National Park and Gunung
Gede Pangrango National Park (Iskandar, 1998;
Mumpuni, 2001; Kusrini, 2007), and several regions
in the Central Java province especially on the Mount
Slamet region (Riyanto, 2010). Several attempts to
collect amphibian diversity studies have been carried
out in East Java, especially in Batu, Malang, Kediri,
and other regions (Septiadi et al., 2018b; Hanifa et
al., 2016; Indrawati et al., 2018; Hidayah et al., 2018),
although more exploration needs to be carried out.
-82-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
indirectly impacting on the sustainability of
ecosystems, niche and the diversity of species in it.
Leptophryne borbonica (Tschudi, 1838) or
Hourglass-toad is a relatively small body toad that
has specific hourglass pattern on its back. This
species was distributed only in Borneo, Sumatra,
Peninsular Malaysia, and also Java Island with type
locality from West Java (Iskandar, 1998), and also
was recorded in Tengger Mountain, without exact
location (Ardiansyah et al., 2014; Iskandar & Colijn,
2000). Other species found in this genus is
Leptophryne cruentata (Tschudi, 1838) which is
distributed only in West Java and Central Java
(Iskandar and Colijn, 2000; Mumpuni, 2014), and
newly recorded species namely Leptophryne javanica
Hamidy, Munir, Mumpuni, Rahmania & Kholik,
2018 which is endemic, protected, and only
distributed on the conservation area in the slopes of
Mount Slamet and Mount Ciremai in West Java
(Hamidy et al., 2018). Distribution mapping, the
collection of habitat preference data, the population
size of species, and the description related to the
possibility of cryptic species in this genus (Hamidy et
al., 2018) are very important due to the limited
information about this species in East Java. Thus, we
report a new distribution with a description of the
Hourglass-toad from East Java region as well as its
ecological implications related to the possibility of
habitat threats to the sustainability of its population.
and variations on the dorsum side, ventrum side,
lateral side of adult specimens which then compared
to literature, and also webbing diagrams and
formulas (Figure 1) following Glaw and Vences
(1994), and tadpole stages determination following
Gosner (1960) and McDiarmid & Altig (1999).
Distribution and Habitat Data
The survey was conducted using Visual Encounter
Survey (VES) method combined with Time Search
Sampling method (Hill et al., 2005) starting at 6-12
pm, with only 4-5 person involved. The species
distribution mapped out by traversing the water
stream as the specific niche of L. borbonica, then
divided into 3 plots based on stream position
(upstream, middlestream and downstream) which
disembogues at the bank of a larger river with a
length of small watershed approximately ± 45 m (±
15 m each plot). Observed specimen was marked
and the elevation was recorded using Garmin
GPSMAP 64s, then the distribution was projected
(Figure 2) using QGIS Desktop 2.18.12. The habitat
preferences of each individual found in each plot
were documented, air temperature and humidity
(Table 1) were also recorded using a Thermo
hygrometer as a specific habitat reference, and the
possibility of predatory species from L. borbonica was
also noted along with the observation plot.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Specimen Description
Description based on the observation of adult male
of Leptophryne borbonica as follows: A small size toad
(♂ SVL = ± 23.5 mm; ♀ SVL = 26.10 mm), habitus
slender, with long forelimbs and a short hindlimbs;
bony crest absent, snout projects slightly over the
mouth in profile, the tips of finger are rounded (not
dilated), firmisternal pectoral girdle present after
dissection, paratoid glands indistinct, dorsum with
black hour-glass marking, tympanum distinct, a
median subgular vocal sac and vocal slit are present
on males; skin above wrinkled and scattered on all
parts including dorsal surface on the forelimbs and
hindlimbs, supratympanic fold absent; Ventrum
weakly granulated especially on chest, nuptial pads
present on male first finger. Coloration including
brown dorsum mottled with black spots on head,
back, and limbs; groin and ventral surface of
forelimbs and hindlimbs reddish, and webbing are
both dorsally and ventrally reddish; belly with
suffusion of black and white tend to brownish, chest
and throat blackish, limbs with distinct black bars
dorsally, upper lip with black bars; pupil horizontal,
iris golden with netted black pattern (Figure 1 & 2).
The webbing includes hindlimbs with web formulas
Study Locations
The specific location (encrypted) is hidden on the
Southwest of one of the slopes of the Bromo
Tengger Semeru National Park (TNBTS) included in
Malang, East Java, Indonesia (Figure 6). The
location points are buffer zones that are used as
human activities, agroforestry, and nature tourism
sites. The small water stream as the habitat of the
species L. borbonica, disembogues into a large river
bank which is a series of several waterfalls from
upstream to downstream and encountered 24 adult
and 5 tadpole species of L. borbonica. This study
carried out on an expedition of "Malang
Herpetofauna Biodiversity Project", conducted on
January 1st and March 1st, 2019.
Specimens Desctiption Data
Morphological characters were observed as
validation of the species description of L. borbonica.
Eight adult specimens (7 adult males, 1 adult female)
and 5 tadpoles were deposited on the Ecology
Laboratory, Biology Department, State Islamic
University of Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang.
Important characters are observed such as patterns
-83-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Figure 1. Life photograph of adult male of Leptophryne borbonica from the slopes of the Southwest of Tengger Mountain
(Photographed by Luhur Septiadi).
Figure 2. Dorsum and ventrum views (left side), and lateral view of the head, ventral surface of the left hindlimb and
left forelimb (right side) of male Leptophryne borbonica from the slopes of the Southwest of Tengger Mountain. Scale bars
= 5 mm (Photographed by Muhamad Prayogi Erfanda).
as follows: I 0-1 II 0-2 III 1-3 IV 2¾-1 V (Figure 4),
forelimbs webbings are restricted to the base.
The morphological characters observed are
mostly suited to the description of L. borbonica (Inger
& Stuebing, 2005; Hamidy et al., 2018) with similar
web formulas from Hamidy et. al (2018) (I ½-1 II 12 III 1½-3 IV 3-1 V; our direct examination: I 0-1 II
0-2 III 1-3 IV 2¾-1 V), with no black triangular
marking behind the eyes, unlike stated by Iskandar
with black triangular on some specimens from
another localities (Iskandar, 1998)
Microhabitat Preference and Distribution
A total of 24 specimens of L. borbonica were
recorded, often found descend on moist rock
substrates (97-99% humidity) on the banks of the
slow water stream, damp cliff edges with vegetation
of bryophytes mosses (Figure 5), and there none to
be found perched on tall leaves or trees (some
species perched on low leaves, height approximately
0–1.9 meters from the ground). According to
Iskandar (1998), it was found abundant around wet
areas or in clear, slowing-moving waters. According
-84-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Figure 3. Photos of Leptophryne borbonica preserved specimens of tadpole hatchling. Dorsum views (left side), lateral
views (upper right side), ventral views (lower right side) of tadpole at hatchling phase of stage 24 th from the slopes of
the Southwest of Tengger Mountain. Scale bars = 1 mm (Photographed by Muhamad Prayogi Erfanda).
to Inger & Stuebing (2005), this small toad often
found in the leaf litters of seepage areas in forests.
taken to the laboratory to clarification and
identification purpose. The tadpoles were
photographed at the stage 24th-25th (with
development of operculum, oral disc, and
pigmentation) (Figure 3) with only one male
specimen managed to become adult male. We
collected as much as 7, 9, 8 adult individuals
respectively encountered in the upstream,
middlestream, and downstream, and no species to be
found out of the observed plot (> 45 m). The air
temperature recorded in the upstream,
middlestream, and downstream were ± 190C, ±
200C, ± 230C respectively, indicating an increase in
air temperature towards the downstream. Humidity
recorded at the upstream, middlestream, and
downstream were ± 97 %, ± 98 %, ± 99 %
respectively, indicating the higher humidity towards
the downstream (Table 1). These physical
parameters conclude that L. borbonica observed to be
in varying range of air temperature 19-230C and
varying humidity range 97–99 %. The species was
mostly found in the middlestream of the water flow,
and it is difficult to conclude the correlation only by
the physical parameters. According to Ardyansah et.
al (2014), the abundance of L. borbonica has a weak
correlation with physical factors (temperature,
humidity, and salinity) at the study location.
However, the slightly different in the number of
species encounter, indicated that there were other
factors that may responsible for this issue. The
species abundance indicated to be influenced by the
current flow, where this species prefers the calmly
Figure 4. Webbing formula of left hindlimbs of male
Leptophryne borbonica, number I - V indicated the inner to
outer finger, webbing formulas as follows: I 0–1 II 0–2
III 1–3 IV 2¾-1 V (illustrated by Muhamad Prayogi
Erfanda).
Some tadpoles of L. borbonica were managed to
observe on calm flowing ponds. The tadpoles were
obtained at the stage 20th (with no pigmentation,
tends to be white translucent, a presence of gill
circulation, elongation of tail). Some specimens were
-85-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Figure 5. The habitat of Leptophryne borbonica from the slopes of the Southwest of Tengger Mountain: (A) upstream
habitat, (B) a closer look at L. borbonica on upstream habitat, (C) a species of L. borbonica at downstream habitat; red
circle indicated the species-specific location (Photographed by Luhur Septiadi).
flows water for mating purpose, which are mostly
found in the middlestream.
highlands up to 1400 m.a.s.l, while according to
Inger & Stuebing (2005), this toad is most often
found below 400 m.a.s.l. The presence of L. borbonica
is limited by a very steep niche in the upstream area
(Figure 5a) and ends with a stream of water that has
seeped into the rocks on the downstream area,
disembogues into a large river of waterfall stream
(Figure 6).
Table 1. The physical parameters recorded from each
observed plot of L. borbonica niche
Water stream
Upstream
Middlestream
Downstream
Range
Air
temperature
± 19 0C
± 20 0C
± 23 0C
19 – 23 0C
Humidity
Individual
± 97 %
± 98 %
± 99 %
97 - 99 %
7
9
8
±8
Habitat Threats
The L. borbonica habitat is threatened by many
natural factors, such as predators. Other Anurans
species were found, such as Limnonectes microdiscus,
Odorrana hossi, and Megophrys montana which might act
as natural predators for L. borbonica. Bigger size frogs
tend to prey on smaller vertebrate animals (including
frogs) in their dietary performing anurophagy. But,
the circumstance under which frogs eat another frog
are likely to be complex (Measey et al., 2015), further
Distribution mapping shows that the presence
of L. borbonica is very isolated (± 45 m) and currently
recorded on a specific location (Malang) especially in
East Java. The distribution of L. borbonica can only
be found at an elevation of ± 870-850 m.a.s.l. based
on the observed location. According to Hamidy et.
al (2018), L. borbonica occurs in both lowlands and
-86-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Figure 6. The records location for L. borbonica from the slopes of the Southwest of Tengger Mountain (specific location is encrypted), the number indicated the sequence of specimens encounters, the elevation is indicated by contours,
plots is are distinguished by color (projected by QGIS Desktop 2.18.12).
research on dietary (via digestive organ examination)
and the interspecific relationship of each species that
live in the same niche are yet to be studied. Another
habitat threats, include narrow distribution on their
specific habitats niche (found only at ± 45 m) and
might be susceptible by the landscape change.
Massive landscape changes such as volcanic activities
are likely resulting on regional extinctions of this
species in East Java. According to IUCN (2014),
deforestation is a major threat for this species.
Forest clearing for agricultural activities may only
have a small impact on the population because they
leave the subpopulations to re-invade secondary
forest nearly. The species are also threatened by
future volcanoes activity of Bromo Tengger Semeru
mountain, although this species is widely distributed
in Java region (Iskandar, 1998). The nature tourism
development will also contribute to habitat loss and
disease transmission (Septiadi et al., 2018a), exposing
to the infecting chytrid fungus as reported by
Kusrini et. al (2008), and a reduction in population
size due to the development ecotourism that poorly
managed and monitored given its location adjacent
to the location of waterfalls. More research and
conservation efforts need to be carried out to
maintain the existence of the population of L.
borbonica in the East Java region.
CONCLUSIONS
New amphibian distribution recorded on the slopes
of TNBTS that partly located in Malang, East Java
was Leptophryne borbonica (Hourglass-toad) and set as
a new record in the East Java region. Its isolated
distribution is very susceptible to ecological
disturbances, future ecotourism development,
infectious disease, population loss, and prone to
local extinction. Research data and conservation
efforts need to be carried out for the sustainability of
the species. Further molecular, morphological and
vocalization analysis is also needed to confirm this
species of amphibians.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to thank Anandhika M.S.S., M.
Fathoni, M. Zakaria Alwi, and to all ranger of Maliki
Herpetology Society Study Club of State Islamic
University of Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang that
help this research and provides valuable information
and discussion. This research partially supported by
IDEA WILD in providing equipment for
documenting specimens.
-87-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Indrawati, Y., Hanifa, B.F., Septiadi, L., Alwi, M.Z.,
Khatimah, A., & Azizah, I., 2018,
Keanekaragaman
Jenis
Herpetofauna
Nokturnal di Area Coban Jahe, Desa
Pandansari Lor, Kecamatan Tumpang,
Kabupaten Malang, Jawa Timur [Diversity of
Nocturnal Herpetofauna in Coban Jahe Area,
Pandansari Lor Village, Tumpang District,
Malang Regency, East Java], Prosiding Seminar
Nasional VI Hayati Universitas Nusantara PGRI
Kediri, 277-285.
Inger, R.F., & Stuebing, R.B., 2005, Panduan
Lapangan Katak-katak Borneo [Field Guide of
Borneo Frog], Natural History Publications,
Kinabalu.
Iskandar, D.T., & Colijn, E., 2000, Preliminary
Checklist of Southeast Asian and New Guinean
Herpetofauna: Amphibians I, Research and
Development Centre for Biology-LIPI, Bogor.
Iskandar, D.T., 1998, The Amphibians of Java and Bali,
Research and Development Centre for
Biology-LIPI, Bogor.
IUCN SSC Amphibian Specialist Group, 2014,
Leptophryne borbonica, The IUCN Red List of
Threatened Species, e.T54814A62029818.
Kusrini, M.D., 2007, Frogs of Gede Pangrango: A follow
up project for the conservation of frogs in West Java
Indonesia. Book 1: Main report, Institut Pertanian
Bogor, Bogor.
Kusrini, M.D., Skerratt, L.F., Garland, S., Berger, L.,
& Endarwin, W., 2008, Chytridiomycosis in
frogs of Mount Gede Pangrango, Indonesia,
Diseases of aquatic organisms, 82(3), 187-194.
McDiarmid, R.W., Altig, R., 1999, Tadpoles: The
Biology of Anuran Larvae, University of Chicago
Press, Chicago.
Measey, G.J., Vimercati, G., De Villiers, F.,
Mokhatla, M.M., Davies, S.J., Edwards, S., &
Altwegg, R., 2015, Frog eat frog: Exploring
variables influencing Anurophagy, PeerJ 3,
e1204.
Mumpuni, M., 2001, Keanekaragaman Herpetofauna
di Taman Nasional Gunung Halimun, Jawa
Barat [Herpetofauna diversity in Gunung
Halimun National Park, West Java], Berita
Biologi, 5(6), 711-720.
Mumpuni, M., 2014, Keragaman Amfibi dan Catatan
Baru Katak di Kawasan Wisata Guci, Provinsi
Jawa Tengah [Amphibian Diversity and New
Records of Frogs in the Guci Tourist Area,
Central Java Province], Zoo Indonesia, 23(1), 13
–19.
REFERENCES
Ardiansyah, D., Karunia, A., Auliandina, T., Putri,
D.A., & Noer, M.I., 2014, Kelimpahan Kodok
Jam Pasir Leptophryne borbonica di Sepanjang
Aliran Sungai Cisuren, Bodogol, Taman
Nasional Gunung Gede Pangrango [The
abundance of Hourglass-toad Leptophryne
borbonica along the Cisuren River Stream,
Bodogol, Mount Gede Pangrango National
Park], Bioma, 10(2), 11-18.
Glaw, F., & Vences, M., 1994, A Fieldguide to the
Amphibians and Reptiles of Madagascar. 2nd edition,
including mammals and freshwater fish, Vences &
Glaw Verlag GbR Publisher, Frankfurt.
Gosner, K.L., 1960, A simplified table for staging
anuran embryos and larvae with notes on
identification, Herpetologica, 16(3), 183-190.
Hamidy, A., Munir, M., Mumpuni, M., Rahmania, M.
& Kholik, A.A., 2018, Detection of Cryptic
taxa in the genus Leptophryne (Fitzinger, 1843)
(Amphibia; Bufonidae) and the description of
a new species from Java, Indonesia, Zootaxa,
4450(4), 427-44.
Hanifa, B.F., Ismi, N., Setyobudi, W., & Utami, B.,
2016, Komposisi Amfibi Ordo Anura di
Kawasan Wisata Air Terjun Ironggolo Kediri
Sebagai Bio Indikator Alami Pencemaran
Lingkungan [The Composition of Amphibian
from Anura Order in the Ironggolo Kediri
Waterfall Tourism Area as a Natural Bio
Indicator of Environmental Pollution],
Prosiding Seminar Nasional Pendidikan dan
Saintek,
Jurusan
Biologi,
Universitas
Muhammadiyah Surakarta, 363-368.
Hidayah, A., Hanifa, B.F., Devi, S.R., Septiadi, L.,
Alwi, M.Z., & Afifudin, F.A., 2018,
Keanekaragaman Herpetofauna di Kawasan
Wisata Alam Coban Putri Desa Tlekung
Kecamatan Junrejo, Kota Batu, Jawa Timur
[Herpetofauna diversity in Coban Putri Nature
Tourism Area, Tlekung Village, Junrejo
District, Batu City, East Java], Prosiding Seminar
Nasional VI Hayati. Universitas Nusantara PGRI
Kediri, 79-91.
Hill, D., Fasham, M., Tucker, G., Shewry, M., &
Shaw, P., 2005, Handbook of Biodiversity Methods,
Survey, Evaluation and Monitoring, Cambridge
Unversity Press, New York.
-88-
J. Trop. Biodiv. Biotech., vol. 04 (2019), 82 — 89
Pemkab Kabupaten Malang, 2019, ‘Selayang
Pandang’, viewed 27 February 2019, from
http://www.malangkab.go.id/site/read/
detail/79/selayang-pandang.html.
Riyanto, A., 2010, Komunitas Herpetofauna dan
Potensinya bagi Sektor Ekowisata pada
Kawasan Ketenger-Baturraden di Selatan Kaki
Gunung Slamet, Jawa Tengah [Herpetofauna
Community and its Potential for the
Ecotourism Sector in the Ketenger-Baturraden
Area in the South of Mount Slamet, Central
Java], Majalah Ilmiah Biologi, BIOSFERA: A
Scientific Journal, 27(2), 60-67.
Septiadi, L., Wahyudi, D., Rachman, R.S., Syafrudin,
S., & Alfaruqi, N.T.S., 2018a, The Invasive
Plants Species along the Hiking Track of
Mount Panderman Nature Tourism, Batu,
East Java, Journal of Indonesian Tourism and
Development Studies, 6(1), 55-62.
Septiadi, L., Hanifa, B.F., Khatimah, A., Indawati,
Y., Alwi, M.Z., & Erfanda, M.P., 2018b, Study
of Reptile and Amphibian Diversity at Ledok
Amprong Poncokusumo, Malang East Java,
Biotropika: Journal of Tropical Biology, 6(2), 45-53.
van Kampen, P.N., 1923, The Amphibia of the IndoAustralian Archipelago, Creative Media Partners,
California.
-89-