The Apparitions of Mars

Pareidolia — the psychological phenomenon on Earth that causes some people to see or hear a vague or random image or sound as something significant — is intrinsic to human culture. Mars, is no different. Same psychological phenomenon. 225 million kilometers away.

Rich Evans
8 min readNov 2, 2017
Global mosaic of 102 Viking 1 Orbiter images of Mars taken on orbit 1,334, 22 February 1980. The images are projected into point perspective, representing what a viewer would see from a spacecraft at an altitude of 2,500 km. At center is Valles Marineris, over 3000 km long and up to 8 km deep. Note the channels running up (north) from the central and eastern portions of Valles Marineris to the area at upper right, Chryse Planitia. At left are the three Tharsis Montes and to the south is ancient, heavily impacted terrain. Source: Wikipedia; Credit: NASA/JPL/USGS

Sure, we’re all familiar with the childhood tales of the face, female head, rabbit, or boy collecting sticks on the Moon.

However, Mars is quite different.

Since the antiquity of astronomy, the Red Planet has been the focal point for supernatural and extraterrestrial mythos; from Schiaparelli’s “canali” observations and Percival Lowell’s literary works suggesting Mars was an arid world (the cause of its gradual demise due to ancient civilizations purging the planet with their irrigation technology), to H.G. Wells’ radio broadcast which plunged a small New Jersey town into a frenzy of paranoia with claims of a hostile Martian takeover, ‘Mars fever’ has been a thing for well over a century.

Martian canals or “canali” as depicted by astronomer Percival Lowell in 1894. Credit: Percival Lowell Biography, SPACE.com
Mars Attacks! design for Topps trading cards. Credit: Topps
Science fiction authors of today have much more information to wield and integrate into their works than ever before, with data being collected from orbiting spacecraft, robotic landers, mobile rovers, Earth-orbiting space stations, ground-based/space telescopes, simulation research laboratories, and experimental outposts which parallel atmospheric conditions on Mars. Image credit: Andy Weir/Crown Publishing

Humanity’s premiere science fiction writers and filmmakers of the 1930’s through the 1960’s elevated the existing mythologies surrounding Mars to new dimensions. Ray Bradbury introduced The Martian Chronicles; Edgar Rice Burroughs’ took us on harrowing adventures in his Barsoom series; Robert A. Heinlein took us to the Moon, Mars and the spaces between the stars.

In the midst of this bonanza of science-fiction literature, Warner Brothers created the Bugs Bunny antagonist Marvin the Martian; and an onslaught of pulp films rushed to the cinemascape to appease the masses craving more from this enigmatic world shrouded in mystery.

It wouldn’t be long before new residents to the author community would arrive to feed the public appetite. Kim Stanley Robinson’s Mars trilogy beckoned many other artists to the table, such as Greg Bear, Philip K. Dick, Arthur C. Clarke, Isaac Asimov, Wernher Von Braun, all the way up to present science fiction authors such as Andy Weir, Kameron Hurley, and Bob Goddard.

Cover of the New York Times on July 16th, 1965.
Image Credit: New York Times.

When we actually reached Mars — with robotic emissaries of ourselves — the stage of our favorite pop culture obsession was revealed to be a world of desolation, complex terrain, bewildering areology…a world of wonders…to the scientific community. The public at large, however, became instantly underwhelmed, with their fantastical expectations of a welcoming or threatening alien race moved back into the realm of science fiction.

PASADENA, Calif. — America’s Mariner-4 spacecraft has discovered that the Mars atmospheric blanket is a mere whisp of gas eight times thinner than some scientists had predicted. Thus, the inquisitive spacecraft has spotted still another hazard to life, as we recognize it, on the red planet. Among the others: a perennial drought, the probable absence of oxygen, solar flares, cosmic radiation and fierce dust storms blown by winds of hurricane force. While Mariner-4 ‘‘inched’’ its way around the sun, scientists said that the atmospheric pressure on Mars’s surface is between ten and 20 millibars. — 1965: Spacecraft Relays First Images of Mars, New York Herald Tribune, European Edition, July 17, 1965 Credit: Inernational Herald Tribune

Until we surveyed the Martian surface in greater detail, mysteries remained and more questions arose from the data transmitted from above and below Mars’ atmosphere. Although the greater public — especially the niche community of conspiracy theororists, ufologists, and hopefuls betting on the presence of a thriving alien civilization — were generally unimpressed and confronting denial with the returned images of their beloved planet of infamy, little time passed before Mars would once again flood the media with talk of ancient aliens. But this time, spurred by actual data in the form of images of Mars itself.

Imaged on July 25, 1976 by the Viking 1 orbiter, a region of Mars named Cydonia — from Kydonia, a historic polis (or “city-state”) on the island of Crete — attracted scientific and public interest when the below image was returned:

Raw image of Cydonia Mensae. Credit: NSSDCA

If the above image mosaic doesn’t strike you as *gasp*-inducing, here’s the same image, processed:

Processed image of the Cydonia Mensae region on Mars. Credit: NSSDCA

If you’re human, like I know I am, you most likely couldn’t help but recognize the all too familiar “face” making itself obviously visible in three dimensions.

Behold, the original ‘Face on Mars’ image taken by NASA’s Viking 1 orbiter, magnified from the previous raw and processed images. Credit: NASA/JPL

Rest assured, you’re not seeing things. Well, you are, but you simply cannot avoid it when our brains are hardwired with an evolutionary imperative to do just that — see. Pattern recognition is kind of our thing.

The “Face on Mars” drew worldwide attention and speculation by, quite honestly, a small fraction of the population whom were able to illuminate the discovery as an actual discovery, of which it wasn’t.

NASA scientists addressed the public to ensure the face was merely the way shadows were created due to the absence of photons, nothing more; however, those who exploited the idea that it did not form naturally forged a theory that the face was the remnant of an alien civilization, suggesting that other features on the Martian surface were likely a destabilized extraterrestrial city of some sort. Since 1976, “the face” has appeared in numerous pop culture references claiming it as an indication of life on Mars during the planet’s history.

The X-Files “Space” episode where a space shuttle mission is sabotaged. Mulder suspects it may be the work an alien spirit that inhabits the body of a former Gemini astronaut. You know how these things go. Credit: IMDB/FOX

Even the popular sci-fi television show X-Files devoted an episode involving an astronaut suffering from paranoia and an extraterrestrial presence where his face actually starts to turn into the “Mars face.” Spooky, surely, but more a testament to the longevity of Mars fantasy, obsession, and relevance, in human culture.

If humanity only visited Mars in a one-shot opportunity to never come again, perhaps the “face on Mars” would have garnered longer lasting appeal; but this was the proclaimed “golden age” of spaceflight, where there were many missions to follow. So, where there were moments to capture images of the Cydonia region throughout subsequent years, we did so.

The original Viking 1 image of 1976 (left); the same feature captured by NASA’s Mars Orbiter Camera aboard the Mars Global Surveyor in 1998 (middle); and another image from ESA’s Mars Express in 2001 revealed the truth behind “the face” — shadows and light. Credit: NASA/JPL/ESA
Here’s that image again, this time in much higher resolution, courtesy of the HiRISE camera aboard NASA/JPL’s Mars Global Surveyor. Credit: NASA/JPL/MGS

After analysis of the higher resolution Mars Global Surveyor data, NASA stated that “a detailed analysis of multiple images of this feature reveals a natural looking Martian hill whose illusory face-like appearance depends on the viewing angle and angle of illumination”. Similar optical illusions can be found in the geology of Earth; such as the Old Man of the Mountain, the Romanian Sphinx, the Pedra da Gávea, the Old Man of Hoy, Stac Levenish, and the Badlands Guardian.

A second perspective view showing the so-called ‘Face on Mars’ located in Cydonia region on September 21, 2006.. The image shows a remnant massif thought to have formed via landslides and an early form of debris apron formation. The massif is characterized by a western wall that has moved downslope as a coherent mass. Image recorded during orbits 3253 and 1216 by the High Resolution Stereo Camera (HRSC) on board ESA’s Mars Express. Credit: ESA/DLR/FU Berlin (G. Neukum), MOC Malin Space Science Systems

While theories and speculations waxed and waned amidst the public, geologists and planetary scientists at the time were far busier being enamored with Mars’ dynamic range of buttes, hills, valleys, mesas, and knobs located in the Cydonia region, which lies in the Mare Acidalium quadrangle, a transitional zone in the planet’s northern hemisphere with heavily cratered regions to the south and relatively smooth plains to the north. Some planetologists believe that the northern plains may once have been ocean beds and that Cydonia may once have been a coastal zone.

“These images of the Cydonia region on Mars are truly spectacular; they not only provide a completely fresh and detailed view of an area famous to fans of space myths worldwide, but also provide an impressive close-up over an area of great interest for planetary geologists, and show once more the high capability of the Mars Express camera.”

Dr. Agustin Chicarro, ESA Mars Express Project Scientist

Once more; taken by The High Resolution Stereo Camera (HRSC) aboard ESA’s Mars Express at 13.7 meters/pixel, the image above reveals the Cydonia region in superior detail. Credit: ESA/DLR/FU Berlin (G. Neukum), MOC Malin Space Science Systems

Further pareidolia applied to surface features on Mars include:

This photo by NASA’s Curiosity rover shows the raw image of Mars that includes a spoon-shaped rock at the lower center. Curiosity took this photo with its Mastcam camera on Aug. 30, 2015, the rover’s 1,089th day on Mars. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS

The so-called “floating spoon” photographed by the Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) ‘Curiosity’ rover during the rover’s 1,089th day on the Red Planet. Once again, planetary scientists at NASA had to assure the public that “There is no spoon. This weird Mars feature is likely a ventifact — a rock shaped by wind,” NASA officials wrote in an image description.

“That does look like a guy hanging out on Mars, enjoying the 0.01 Earth atmospheric pressure, the 98% CO2 air, the subfreezing cold, and of course, just being four inches tall. Martians are pretty short, it seems. And patient, given its pose.” — Phil Plait for Bad Astronomy Blog

The “Man from Mars” imaged by NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover (MER) ‘Spirit’. British newspapers didn’t hesitate to seize the headlines with such reads as “Crikey! There’s A Little Green Man On Mars!” What was just a craggy little rock formation stood out in the form of what looked like a little walking …Bigfoot? UFO Sightings Daily immediately announced the rock formation was likely a female figure made by aliens, of course. Emily Lakdawalla of The Planetary Society followed up to remind us what optical illusions are, with another fine example of pareidolia.

A rat, iguana, the side profile of Mahatma Gandhi, a bunny rabbit, a *ahem* phallic image in the tracks from the Spirit rover (because, the Internet), trees, a secret Mars “Bio-Base,” evidence of life on Mars asserted by psychics, and a positive — rather than dubious — “smiley” face on Mars seen within Gale Crater have all been the subject of illusive sightings on Mars.

SciShow host Hank Green breaks down the psychological phenomenon of pareidolia. Credit: SciShow

The reality is, pareidolia will continue to influence us as long as there are humans. Or, until the singularity occurs, whereby areological data will be instantaneously accessible to inform us of what our brains actually are seeing; thus, avoiding such illusions.

I hope you’ve enjoyed this exposé on what surely will occur again, especially when we have a physical human presence on the Martian surface to live, explore, and report of leprechauns on Phobos…

#ExploreMars | @ExploreMars

Explore Mars was created to advance the goal of sending humans to Mars within the next two decades. To further that goal, Explore Mars conducts programs and technical challenges to stimulate the development and/or improvement of technologies that will make human Mars missions more efficient and feasible. In addition, to embed the idea of Mars as a habitable planet, Explore Mars challenges educators to use Mars in the classroom as a tool to teach standard STEM curricula.

Register Now For The Humans To Mars Summit 2018

May 8–10, 2018 | George Washington University | Washington, DC

--

--

Rich Evans

Science communicator, father, photographer, passionately curious, advocate for science literacy. Baltimore, MD. #staycurious